TL;DR: Not-at-fault 3-car pileup Oct 17. My insurer, Root, went nearly silent for 3 weeks. I’m talking unanswered calls, unanswered emails, and promised callbacks that never came. Meanwhile, my car sat at the shop with an unapproved $20k estimate. After an escalation email threatening a regulator complaint, they called Nov 13 to say they're totaling the car. Still waiting on the valuation and rental answers.
The timeline:
Oct 17: I'm the middle car in a 3-car pileup. I stopped in time; the driver behind me hit me and pushed me into the car ahead. Police report confirms the sequence and the rear driver was cited for failure to control speed.
Oct 18-19: Filed with Root, gave a recorded statement. My adjuster was supposed to contact the at-fault driver's insurer (Progressive) and pull the police report.
Oct 21–23: Calls to my adjuster go unanswered. Main line promises a callback - nothing. I escalate Oct 23; the adjuster finally calls back asking what the next steps are, though we'd set them Oct 19. Turns out he'd never contacted Progressive or requested the report. He tells me to go ahead and take my car to the shop and they’ll start repairs and subrogate with Progressive.
Oct 27: Shop's initial estimate paid minus my $1,000 deductible.
Nov 3: Teardown reveals more damage. The revised estimate is ~$20k. The shop sends it to Root. Repairs never start because Root never approves it.
Nov 6–12: Shop still hears nothing from Root. My follow-up emails and calls on Nov 9, 10, and 12 go unanswered. A "priority callback" promised Nov 9 never comes. On Nov 10 the main line gives me an appraiser's name. I call him but he is not my assigned appraiser, but he knows who the assigned appraiser is. He says the assigned appraiser will review the estimate and get back to the shop Nov 12. That does not happen. I call and leave another voicemail and it goes unanswered.
Nov 12: I send a formal escalation email to Root's main claims inbox demanding a written reply by noon Nov 13, saying I'll file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance if I don’t hear a response.
Nov 13: I send a follow-up email to the main claims line reminding them they have a few hours to respond before the TDI complaint goes through and copy my adjuster. A second adjuster replies with a partial answer, but no estimate decision and my rental authorized is only through Nov 18. That afternoon the appraiser calls: they're totaling the car, and a total loss specialist will contact me. Verbal only, no numbers. That evening, an email confirms the total loss in writing and names the specialist, with settlement review promised within 2 business days.
Where things stand: waiting on the valuation of my car. Comps put it around $31–32.5k, (and I'm braced for a lowball), the rental cutoff (coverage capped at $1,200, authorized only through Nov 18), and the deductible back via subrogation (Progressive hasn't decided liability yet — last I heard, they couldn't reach their driver).
The one thing that went right: they replaced my baby's car seat base with no fight.
My question: is this level of silence normal for a low-cost carrier like Root, or did I just get a spectacularly bad adjuster? And any tips for the total-loss valuation negotiation are welcome. I've got comps ready.