r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 22 '16

RAV4 'Shapeshifting Rav4'

6 Upvotes

I decided to 'go there' and 'accept' the notion that Teresa's RAV4 has been 'shifted'...replaced by another 'look-a-like' RAV4 car.

My decision is self-served, to check my own sanity and see 'what it means' and 'where it leads'.

On October 31, TH was driving her own RAV4. Since that day or on the same day, her car was 'switched' with 'fake RAV4' with her DNA blood in it. The 'fake RAV4' has been found on SA territory, on November 5. What it means?

Definitely Premeditation!

  • It takes time for the Killer or/and the Planter to find the same old car/model and switch VIN plate on windshield to match Teresa's car insurance information and car registration in the Department of Motor Vehicles. Let's say 'fake' car has been found days in advance and switching VIN done easily...few hours;

  • But what about all corresponding unique car's identification parts which 'assigned' to this specific VIN? For example, the engine number is stamped on the engine in the most difficult place to see it...for this 'fake car' to match Teresa's VIN number - someone (professional!!!) needs to re-'chase' this number....and there are more places of unique ID...but, for the sake of argument, let's say it was done. 'Fake RAV4' is ready to be part of the murder/planting.

Motive

  • Believe it or not, the 'shapeshifting' cars shenanigans/cons is pretty big under-ground illegal car industry and well known to Law Enforcement around the world. It's a big 'money making machine' to manipulate/change cars for huge profit. Especially, with the rare cars and with cars 'in demand'. And people who involved in such 'dirty' business are usually the one who has access to the cars, mainly Salvage Car Yards...So, this would be such a perfect 'motive' for Steven Avery to kill Teresa to gain her RAV4 and makes money on it. Am I crazy? Not at all!...I think if RAV4 which has been found on November 5 on his property was indeed 'fake RAV4' then LE would have the 'perfect motive' against SA!...Dammit, why didn't they use it??? And people who 'discovered' such a valuable 'facts' of 'fake RAV4' are making such a great 'motive' for SA guilt in TH murder;

  • But what if 'fake RAV4' was specifically used for murder only and not for 'shapeshifting' car cons business? Hmmm...OK, but what value such 'switch' has in the murder? Does original Teresa's car was made of gold or has the gold parts and therefore her car has value for the Killer/Planter?...I have problem here and need your help...because I see absolutely no reason to use 'fake RAV4' for murder only.....which brings me back to only one reasonable, logical option, stated above: 'shapeshifting RAV4' was used to frame Steven Avery in illegal car business which leads to the TH murder. And now I'm really angry why LE didn't use such perfect 'motive'!....(no, I'm not angry...just joking).

Okey-dokey my friends....I did try to play 'fair'. I did try to be objective. I really-really did try.

...and all this non-sense about TH RAV4 car 'shapeshifting' has zero value for me...but of course, I cannot change anyone's opinion...This post was made for myself only:).


EDIT: to explain how 'shapeshifting' car illegal industry works, on very high-level.

Let's say you're Mr. Smith and you have 'like new' RAV4. And I'm very bad individual and owner of Salvage Car Yard. And I have the same RAV4 model/year car...but my car is not in good shape...has front damage, few screws are missing...I need a lot of repairs to do on my car to make decent money on it. And I saw your, Mr. Smith, car. Without going into much details, I got your car into my possession. I'll switch VIN numbers, placing your VIN on my 'damaged' car...re-'stamp' other car's parts on my RAV4 to match your car's numbers...and now, yours 'like new' RAV4 car becomes my car...and you have my old 'damaged' car with your VIN number to match your registration....of course, I need to kill you because otherwise you'll report me to authority:)...just joking....on serious note, such 'switch' happened when the owner of 'like new' car has no idea what happened...Mr. Smith's car has been stolen and possibly found later-on somewhere else, damaged....or never be found at all.



r/HiveMindMaM • • Jul 12 '16

RAV4 RAV4: parallel parking in 'wrong' direction

4 Upvotes

While 'killing the time' waiting for KZ Brief, I decided to go back to my original question, raised first time here after Skipp downloaded our RAV4 photos: why RAV4 has been parked in the 'wrong' direction?


Here is an original image taken from the recently published article based on eyewitness statement POSSIBLY seeing RAV4 'zooming away' toward Avery's salvage yard. ZOOMING away...speeding approx. 40 m/h, using the back entrance to salvage yard. I just added red arrows lines to show direction.

http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/making-a-murderer-what-did-steven-averys-neighbor-see-20160708?page=2

http://imgur.com/zYy1haA

Next, I used well familiar image of Avery's property and made another arrows with the possible directions, inside of Avery property.

http://imgur.com/KUCwRNs

And the reason why I used word 'possible' is because as you can see there are more than one 'possibility' to get into place where RAV4 has been found. And regardless which 'possibility' you'll choose (red or blue/red or green), someone who did drive RAV4 would need to go around the pond or through the crusher area to be able to park RAV4 facing the tree. So, let's talk about RAV4 parking 'direction' and see what it means: why RAV4 driver choose more 'complicated' option, instead of parking RAV4 facing different direction: why not facing this -----> direction?

http://imgur.com/0Oxu5Zn


Couple questions:

Based on this image http://imgur.com/dovURjz (I simply added an imaginary front license plate)

  • would you agree that removing the front license plate would be very-very hard task to perform AFTER RAV4 has been parked?

Would you agree if RAV4 would be parked in apposite direction then:

  • front license plate would be much easy to remove (even back license plate shouldn't be the problem)?;

  • driver door could be much easy to open?;

  • battery disconnection could be performed easily?;

  • big SIGN on the back would be much better concealed? and, finally...

  • left side RAV4 damage would be blend nicely with all junk cars around?:)....

OK, let's say you would agree with certain things above but not with all. It's OK...I'll be more than happy to hear you out.


Here are my thoughts (and I could be way off)...

  • I believe RAV4 has been parked without license plates (maybe therefore eyewitness saw RAV4 'zooming away'/speeding because it was driven without license plates?);

  • I believe the reason for 'wrong' direction is double-folded: a) for easy to find RAV4 when needed (sign is very visible for volunteer searchers like Pam who doesn't have glasses:) and, the most important, entrance to cargo area is more accessible to re-arrange certain things, including placing memory card with name 'Teresa' on top.

...and if my 'believes' above are correct then whoever was driving behind RAV4 (zooming out with 40 m/h) was not LE.

jmo


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 13 '16

The only way to make the evidence make sense.

2 Upvotes

After spending countless hours reading everything after watching the show this is the only way that the evidence makes sense.

  1. TH dies, either it is an accident, or a murder, bottom line it does not matter how or by who.

  2. The killer is responsible for planting the RAV 4 on the Avery property and depositing the bones in the fire pit.

  3. LE find the RAV4 but they can't call it in because they did not have a search warrant. So they use the search party to "find it again", so they can not enter the Avery Property.

  4. LE believe that Avery is the killer, and they set out to make sure that he does not get away with it, and why would they not believe that he was the killer, since they found the RAV4 and Bones on the property.

  5. LE want to make sure that SA is convicted and they are not able to find the real crime scene, hence the need to get BD to confess, and then to plant evidence that will confirm that story. Blood in the RAV4, bullet in the garage, and key in the bed room. Even though the missing evidence makes this all impossible.

This to me is the only way that this all makes sense. And I know that I am not the only one that thinks this, others have stated similar idea's but it to me is the only way to make it all fit.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 05 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics Evidence collection 101 - failed!

8 Upvotes

I thought it would be interesting, especially for new people to the sub, to do a list of the failings of LE relating to evidence processing and collecting. There are a lot of conspiracy allegations around, but I think there are a number of really big issues we can prove with their own documentation. So if we were doing an audit on evidence collection in the Halbach case, what would the issues be? What evidence supports this?

 

I'll start

 

ISSUE; failure to correctly document (photo/video) the bones in situ at the Avery burn pit site and failure to recover these remains using correct procedures.

 

TL;DR

  • the medical examiner was not allowed in to view these remains in situ and advise on the best process for recovery of them.

  • the remains were not photographed/videod in situ to even allow retrospective examination of their position in relation to each other or their condition when found (cremains are fragile and may have been damaged in collection and sifting process).

  • failure to preserve the crime scene prior to recovery of the remains and failure to recover the remains using careful forensic anthropology techniques.

  • failure to store remains separate from remains found at other locations

  • failure to preserve chain of custody of remains

 

PROOF

 

Shutting out the medical examiner

 

The Medical Examiner, Debra Kataksch was prepared to testify that she was "walled off entirely" from the scene. http://www.jsonline.com/news/crime/witness-says-she-saw-victim-later-b99642985z1-363818721.html

This is highly unusual. The standard protocol when suspected human remains are found is to have the ME come in and examine them, prior to any attempt to recover the remains. The ME had access to specialists who could have conducted the recovery of the remains in the correct way to preserve the maximum amount of information.

 

failing to secure an area to preserve evidence

 

These photos show there was crates of water bottles, a dog & his chain and multiple feet on the areas where bomes were found.

http://m.imgur.com/GTjynuk,T529hE0

http://m.imgur.com/uyxhWGI,eCxufpw

 

Preventing retrospective examination by failure to document

 

This email exchange between Fassbender (investigator) and Ertl (crime scene tech) shows that there are NO photos or video of the bones in situ. The reason Ertl did not photograph them is the scene had already been disturbed. http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Trial-Exhibit-160-Email-Between-Fassbender-And-Ertl.pdf

 

This is a crucial piece of failure. Without the photos or videos a professional forensic anthropologist cannot retrospectively reach a conclusion about many things. This is explained by Dr Fairgreave (defense anthropologist) in the Docket podcast here http://www.michaelspratt.com/poadcast-legal-matters/2016/2/3/the-docket-making-a-murderer-after-show-special-guest-scott-fairgrieve

 


The type of information lost is ;

  • were the bones in this location only from certain limbs (suggesting dismemberment)

  • Were the bones in this location from all body parts (suggesting the entire remains were moved around to distribute at different locations)

  • Were the bones in "order" (was the skull above the shoulder bones or were they all mixed up) which tells us if the bones were moved/stirred after burning. This info would have been of great help on establishing if this was a true burn site, or if the bones had been placed there

  • was there any shovel marks or other tool marks in the soil surrounding the bones

  • did any damage occur to the bones during the collection process. Cremains are brittle and easily damaged (but they were shovelled, sifted, boxed and posted which could cause a lot of damage)


 

No soil samples

 

A soil sample could reveal human fat which would be a strong indication a body was burned at that location. Or may have revealed information about accelerants used. There is no indication of soil from the area immediately around the bones being collected and sent for analysis.

 

Bones from multiple locations in one box

 

This is like forensic 101. You do not mix up evidence found in entirely different locations! This again prevents us knowing which body parts were found where. If every location has a mixture of all body parts (not just particular limns in particular locations). This and the failure to photograph the bones in situ, or let the ME or a forensic anthropologist examine them in situ means that we will NEVER know the answer. That is catastrophic in the pursuit of the truth.

We therefore cannot know if any of the bones collected from the SA pit were later identified as human. We do not know where the bones identified as human originated (burn pit, quarry, burn barrel).

 

chain of evidence

 

The bones were posted to Dr Eisenberg who was not at her office when they were delivered. The chain of custody was broken. The bones from multiple locations were all mixed in together like a pick'n'mix...

 

clumsy collection

 

Day 6 testimony p52,: Ertl admits they shovelled and sifted the remains. There was no proper forensic recovery using archaeology type techniques , they treated the remains like they sifting pebbles. http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Jury-Trial-Transcript-Day-6-2007Feb19.pdf

 

What are the other failings which can be proven? What would you include in an LE evidence collection audit?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 31 '16

Media Anyone else feeling...?

4 Upvotes

Is anyone else feeling Zellner's media communications are all a bit....messy?

I found her commitment to the case and her track record as credible, but I am starting to feel uneasy about her.

The tweets I found odd and thought were perhaps meant to be 'stirring the hornets nest' by sending out key words that would have meaning to killer/planters. But the Strang/Buting bashing and some of the other interviews I am struggling to see that even being the purpose.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 29 '16

Interviews/Transcripts Any car experts able to decipher these?

0 Upvotes

Just out of curiosity can you tell waht make/model of cars are pictured in Appendix A. They appear to be the photos of cars SA previously sold through Autotrader.

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Offer-of-Proof.pdf


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 11 '16

Family/ LE /Suspects THEORY: Making a Victim?

5 Upvotes

This is my first ever post, so please be nice! And also, please forgive me if this topic has been discussed ad nauseum, but I just can't get over this discrepancy!

Many people don't want to discuss COLOR because of the two-toned nature of the RAV4 finish, and because of the different ways people perceive color, lighting differences etc. But (to my eye) there's a remarkable color difference between the image of the RAV4 with TH standing in front (green) and the images of the 'located' vehicle as pictured on the Avery Salvage Yard (blue), and in the crime lab (also blue).

Today, I found a video on YouTube which outlines some other problems with the image of TH. Entitled "Making a Murderer: Fake Photo" the video was posted by a professional photographer named Shane Carless and it gives the scale height of TH as she should really look next to a RAV4. http://youtu.be/qlwmO13xgGs

Now-- when you put this together with 1) the strange manner of the discovery of the RAV4, bones, the lack of DNA and everything else for that matter 2) that one of the first questions LE asks is about the VIN not the victim but the VIN 3) the lone valet key and 4) the note about the 51K1 digital key and smelter 5) the victim's missing purse, ID, set of keys etc. and finally 6) that the victim was not reported missing for three days by her own family:

A - Isn't possible that (Sheriff Robert Hermann's) Cleveland Auto supplied the blue RAV4 with TH's VIN tag and some bones to make a murder scenario out of a domestic violence incident? I read somewhere that a friend or family member mentioned "someone in TH's life who had caused her great pain" at TH's memorial service.

I also want to add that this theory could account for Colburn's call about the plates. He was looking at TH's plates (headlights near Chuck) as they were planting the blue RAV4 (tail lights near Steven). The plates were never on the blue RAV4. Maybe this is why KZ purchased another RAV4 and tweeted #checkaduhid or "checka duh id" like they say in Manitowoc. In other words "Check the Vehicle ID number."

B - Is it possible that TH IS alive and well? Was she given three days of travel time to leave Manitowoc because her abusive boyfriend beat her up over new boyfriend (Bradley Czech). Enough blood for an assault is found, but not really enough for a murder.

C - Could they have convinced TH to help herself and the county? Under the circumstances might her family play along? Might domestic violence account for the dark nature of her "if I die" statement in her video diary if she had an abusive boyfriend for several years?

D - MH's "grieving process" statement could be genuine in this scenario because he has essentially lost his cousin/sister. And, Maybe he was the best spokesperson for the family since he is not that closely related to TH.

More on the bones: https://redd.it/49p9j2

More on the car: "FrameRate | (Steven Avery Film) 2016 Action 2 News segment starting at 3:00: "The disappearance of Teresa Halbach remains a mystery tonght. The 25 year old was last seen Monday afternoon in Manitowoc County. Police are conducting an aerial search of the oand from Manitowoc to Green Bay hoping to locate Teresa's car which they say is a major key in their investigation. That car is a 1999 DARK GREEN Toyota RAV4, just like the one you see here." http://youtu.be/1rrvmwRVcxA

More on Cleveland Auto Salvage: http://youtu.be/8r9IpXC-Ucw

The true horror is that SA may have spent most of his life in prison because of class discrimination both in 1985 and 2005. "poor + disabled = disposable"--KZ

I think Dolores Avery and Barb Janda know this was a set up, but the Averys are just used to being treated this way. JMHO


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 14 '16

Family/ LE /Suspects Halbach's brother; has anyone actually investigated?

5 Upvotes

After rewatching the series several times myself, my girlfriend upon her first watch pointed out something that I hadn't really seen, and I hadn't heard anyone actually talk about.

Watching Halbach's brother talk on the show, he quite constantly looks nervous, speaks monotonously and even from his first interview, he immediately assumes she's dead, referencing the grieving process prior to the idea of her being dead. Has there been any investigation into himself???


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 09 '16

Interviews/Transcripts Ryan Hillegas and His Fading Memory

5 Upvotes

Doesn't the article below and the statements attributed to RH appear to be a disconnect from the testimony given at trial. If she was his "go to girl," I would think that he would be able to remember some of the details of their last meeting.

http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/local/friends-remember-halbach-for-her-kindness-and-tender-photos/article_fa974032-b16d-5d38-921c-1bd659d81202.html


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 29 '16

Humor So this is where you've all been hiding?

5 Upvotes

Thank God somebody set up an alternative sub. I look forward to some objective discussion with all of you.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 26 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics ...NOT BURNED. What is it?

5 Upvotes

I hate myself for making this post...but I would hate myself even more - if I don't:).

For a long time, I was looking at one 'subject' inside of SA barrel...Searching, analyzing, trying to find the answer to these two questions:

  • what is it?

  • why it was NOT burned?

You see, everything in SA barrel is burned...partially, but burned. (Beer?) can, cell phone parts, camera parts...everything except one 'subject'/item. And I did search evidence list to find out what is it. Nothing which can provide me an answers to above two questions.

I need your help, otherwise it'll continue bothering me, non-stop. I absolutely have no opinion on this 'subject'. Well, kind of have 'no opinion':).

Please look yourself...it's in the plain view.

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/exhibit-burnt-pieces-3.jpg

This 'subject' is laying down between the aluminum burned can and one of the burned cell phone's part.

Please enlarge the above photo. Please pay attention to it's size. What is it? What it looks like to you? What it reminds you of?

...and here is my 'modified' image based on what I see. I did outline with red and green dash-lines the contour of this 'subject'.

Does this 'subject' looks like made of 'soft' material or not? Or this image just playing tricks with me?...and I'll tell you later what I 'see' and what it POSSIBLY could means.

http://imgur.com/oAjmpXI

Thank you all.


EDIT: OK. I need to be fair and explain 'where I'm going' with this post.

Since I learned that TH cell phone has been dis-assembled prior partial burning, I went to SA barrel looking for item which has been NOT burned. The same way, as I look at the green grass and white 'objects' around SA burn pit. And when I found this particular 'soft object' which is not burned - I was pretty much excited. So, prior to make any deduction from it, I was trying to identify this 'subject'. Is it cell phone's case or camera case?...couldn't find anything...so, maybe it's part of gardening glove?...possible. Regardless, this 'subject' looks to me as made from some kind of soft material...meaning, it must have burned sooner than any metal/plastic items as aluminum can or cell or camera's parts.

So, here I am, 'sitting' with another POSSIBLE 'proof' (not claiming that it's 100% proof/fact but possible proof) that all these electronics are planted.

  • If this 'subject' is glove then I'm sure LE would send it to the Crime Lab to find if SA DNA blood inside. Right? Nope, nothing like that was send to the lab and tested.

  • If this 'subject' is cell/camera case then lab should test for TH blood/DNA. Right? Nope, nothing like that was send to the lab and tested.

What it means? Why LE didn't take this non-burned 'subject' to the Crime Lab?...IMO, it means LE knew these electronics were not burned in SA barrel...therefore, planted.

JMO.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Aug 30 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics An Oldie But A Goodie: Debunking The Infamous "BZ" Merry-Go-Round

6 Upvotes

Required reading before continuing: https://www.reddit.com/r/MakingaMurderer/comments/49p9j2/how_bz_could_prove_falsified_evidence_and/?

TL;DR: Basically there is a date conflict from the testimonies of Eisenberg and Culhane regarding when Culhane ([Nov 11th] (http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Jury-Trial-Transcript-Day-10-2007Feb23.pdf#page=158) ) sampled item BZ and when Eisenberg sent it to the FBI for testing ([Arrived at FBI HQ on Nov 16th] (http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Trial-Exhibit-479-FBI-Internal-Communications.pdf#page=10) ). Truthers have used this to claim that Culhane never sampled the bone or performed the testing as it was in Eisenberg's possession from some time on November 9th until it leaves to go to the FBI HQ and arrives there on Nov 16th.

So while discussing the case at r/SuperMAM this issue of the BZ chain of custody came up again. Now this theory is 5 months old and the CASO report was not released to us at the time it was written. After my work in the last few weeks trying to identify the infamous Chicken Bone evidence tags, I decided I would try an investigate this claim again using the CASO report.

First things first, Eisenberg identifies the bones she sends to the FBI as exhibit 385 and evidence tag 8318. (See bottom of page 130 here: )

With an evidence tag to search for I went about tracing the chain of custody in the CASO reports as best as I could.

Here's what I found:

So we now know that the item BZ definitely went to the WI STATE CRIME LAB on November 9th. I'm proposing this as the actual date Culhane sampled the bone for item BZ. That sample stayed at the crime lab and the bones were then transported to Eisenberg's office the same day. Now some people might be skeptical that the sample was transported twice that same day, Eisenberg says she takes the bones to the Dane County Coroner's Office lab for analysis on November 10th. Dane County is only about half an hour away from Madison (Where the WI STATE CRIME LAB was) so I imagine that Eisenberg's office was reasonably close to the crime lab.

So here's my proposed chain of custody for item BZ:

  • Collected at scene Nov 8 by Riemer, turned into CASO

  • Collected from CASO by Hawkins on Nov 9 and transported by DCI Agent Joy to WI State Crime Lab.

  • Sampled by Culhane on Nov 9 and re-sealed and transported by (??? Probably DCI agent and in DCI reports) to Eisenberg's office.

  • Transported Nov 10 by Eisenberg to Dane County Coroner's Office.

  • Packaged and transported by (???) to FBI on Nov 11th.

  • Received by FBI Nov 16th.

So there you have it. CASO Report tells us that item BZ did in fact go to the WI STATE CRIME LAB before Eisenberg sent it off to the FBI. Nothing to see here.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 16 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics Let's return to the bullet in Avery's garage with TH's DNA on it.

6 Upvotes

I think this bit of evidence is often overlooked, and while I find Sherry Culhane's role in this case problematic to say the least, I think this is still a compelling piece of evidence and I think the prosecution had a case here.

Yes, the control sample was contaminated, but as Culhane mentions, this was for "exclusionary purposes" meaning under normal circumstances the control was there to ensure the DNA present on an object really came from that object and not the lab or somewhere else.

In this case however, Culhane says it was her DNA profile on the control, and TH's on the bullet. Bad science perhaps, but compelling evidence nonetheless. Unless the control contamination speaks to sloppy lab work in general, in which case, is there a plausible scenario (I mean actually plausible) in which TH's profile ended up on the bullet by some other means as Buting suggests in cross?

Of course there was Fassbender's request that Culhane "put Avery in the garage," yet I don't necessarily see this as heinous as others have pointed out.

I think from a legal perspective Buting did his job in undermining the evidence presented here, but unless one believes Culhane deliberately planted TH's profile, it seems likely that TH's DNA was on that bullet, and that bullet was in SA's garage.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 23 '17

The Brady what?

1 Upvotes

Is there case law that this actually been used successfully to vacate a sentence? Check out this article from Oshkosh Northwestern:

Defense claims missing evidence in seeking new trial for Avery

http://post.cr/2txxXMt


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 03 '16

Family/ LE /Suspects Deer hunter theory

1 Upvotes

Reposting this thread here, may have put it in the wrong arena first.

I've read some posts involving the deer in Bobby's garage and this is my wild guess as to what may have transpired.

TH arrives at SA's trailer around 2:30, like Steven claims. Bobby does see her taking pictures from his house while he is getting ready to go hunting. Steven receives the auto trader and receipt from TH when he pays her and then she leaves. Why bother going thru the motions of this transaction if he was just going to kill her.

She drives out of the property and passes the propane guy, he may have miscalculated what time he saw her exactly but it's close. Steven goes back inside his trailer. TH then runs into a deer somewhere near the property. The driver's side turn signal is busted out and the side quarter panel is dented. She gets out of her car to inspect the damage and check on the deer.

Meanwhile Bobby is leaving to go hunting, he said he didn't see TH when he left but that her car was still parked there, this could have been a lie to later cover his tracks. Back out on the road, Scott is driving by and sees a stranger on the side of the road out of her car. He pulls over to offer assistance. He talks to TH and inspects the damage to her car. He picks up the blinker and puts it in her car. When he does he notices her camera equipment inside. He sees an opportunity to steal the equipment and knocks TH out by punching her or hitting her in the head with something. TH is knocked unconscious and bleeds from the wound. ST drags her to the back of the vehicle and puts her inside the rear area, which leaves the bloody hair mark found later. Just as this is happening Bobby drives up. Bobby stops to see what is going on.

Back at SA's, he exits his trailer to go see Bobby but finds that he has already left.

Back at the highway, Bobby confronts ST and asks what happened. ST is caught red handed and explains that he saw an opportunity to grab some stuff and that no one would ever know. Bobby then informs him that this is no stranger, that this is in fact the photographer from auto trader and that she had just left his Mom's house.

ST realizes his mistake may send him to prison if TH wakes up and could be able to finger him since she was coming from his own girlfriend's house. He hastily decides his only option is to get rid of her. He threatens Bobby that if he doesn't go along with his plan that he will tell the police that he was involved and take him down with him. Bobby is frightened and agrees to go along. ST says they have to get off the road and tells Bobby to take the deer back to his house and he'll depose of TH. They will later agree to say they crossed paths but that neither stopped.

ST then drives TH's car to the quarry where he shoots and kills her and likely leaves her body there. He then drives her car to the edge of the pit, wipes it down, possibly disconnects the battery cables so the alarm won't go off and and leaves it there. He then walks back to the highway to retrieve his vehicle.

Meanwhile, Blaine and Brenden come home from school. I think the bus driver said she may have seen TH taking pictures the week prior to the day in question so if she was mistaken it could explain why both Dassey boys originally said that they didn't TH when they arrived home that day.

When they go inside they find Bobby is there and Blain assumes that they woke him up. ST shows up later to pick up Barb and take her to Green Bay. SA comes over to see Bobby and sees the deer in the garage.

SA later states in his police interview that he "remembered spending time at Barbara’s because Bobby had gotten a deer from a car/deer accident. Steven thought it was Monday." He also stated "he stayed around Barb’s talking until the deer was cleaned up. He said he did not help clean the deer and that Bobby did that."

Bobby stated during the SA trial that the deer, "was hit right up the road from our house." He also answered, "yes" when asked the question, "you saw it hit?"

He may not have actually seen the deer being hit but he knew how it had happened. I believe it's always easier to keep a made up story straight if it involves some level of truthfulness. Is it possible that ST and Bobby did randomly pass each other around 3pm but left out that TH was there too.

It's posible that they could have burned the body at a later time after becoming nervous about potential evidence they left behind, hairs or DNA. Further they decided to frame SA for the murder by placing the bones in his fire pit.

They could have grabbed one of the burn barrels, put it on a golf cart and went to the quarry site late at night, burned the body, brought back the cremains and dumped them in SA's fire pit. This left some cremains at the quarry and some in the barrel. Once this plan was put in motion their stories changed by stating that SA had a bonfire on the night in question and that when Bobby left the house to go hunting that he saw TH's car was still parked at SA's.

I'm guessing they couldn't believe their luck when they realized the cops would stop at nothing to make the charges stick to SA by planting the key and the blood in the car.

I have read some theories that ST and Bobby both killed TH. That they went after TH and raped and murdered her but I find these theories hard to fathom. It seems hard to believe that Bobby is going to go after a women who was just at his own house and then invite his mom's boyfriend in on it. This idea seems similar to the Brenden confession of he and SA raping TH which we know was impossible given the evidence. Could they both be involved in the cover up though? Sure.

I apologize if this theory has already been posted as I haven't had time to read every post.

Thoughts?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jul 23 '16

Why did LE not eliminate other likely suspects.

7 Upvotes

No matter which side of SA guilt you are on I don't understand the lack of checking of alibis and elimination of suspects.

By eliminating some other possibilities it strengthens the prosecution case against SA.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 12 '17

If SA wins a new trial, will he be found guilty again?

2 Upvotes

If and I mean a big if, SA gets granted a retrial, would he be found guilty again? The most damning evidence is his blood in the Rav 4. Even with the new brief, it is still the biggest piece of evidence that there is against him. Would this prove him guilty beyond reasonable doubt? The bullet and key are good evidence as well, but there is more chance of that being argued against.

Last question is if not SA, then who? RH? I just can't see him playing LE, then setting up SA. SA more than likely still killed TH but maybe not in the narrative of the trial.

Any thoughts?

I think he will be found guilty again, just because of the blood in Rav 4


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 22 '16

RAV4 Key Oversight?

3 Upvotes

Am I the only one thinking that SA would have burned the key/lanyard with the body and other personal effects of the victim? Perhaps I'm confused about the timeline and he burned the body before stashing the car, but if he burned everything thing else, why would he not the key?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 25 '16

Family/ LE /Suspects Any more....?

3 Upvotes

There is one thing that does genuinely (irrationally) bother me......

 

How many cans of air freshener does one person need?

Aside from these images are there more with cans of glade or other air freshening products?

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Exhibit-217-Avery-Livingroom.jpg

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/exhibit-desk-2.jpg

 

Ok so maybe the store had a 3 for 2 offer on. Or maybe 2 are empty and he just hasn't thrown them away. But also maybe he had this many trying to mask the smell of decompostion in the rav4 or the smell left in his house by flesh burning in the fire pit.

Air freshener only lives in the bathroom in my house....this is incriminating evidence lol


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 27 '16

First reaction with questions

4 Upvotes

So I'm not sure wether this is the right spot for this and if some of the stuff has already been adressed. If I have to use the spoiler tags please tell me where because this I am literly writing this right after viewing the series and being very bother by it. If stuff is already adressed can you point me towards the right place? Then now off to my first impresion:

In the entire series I found the lack of perspective very frustrating. For example in the first case, why did they not choose to include material about the other police/sheriff department and why not more about the "real" offender? Because to me its really odd that offender in the sexual abuse cases all of a sudden admitted guilt and next to that plead innoncence for SA HOWEVER he appearantly didn't get sentenced because later on he could strike again. (I might have missed this in the timeline but the interview with his last victim to me seemed after the confesion on the other station.) Why would a serial offender admit guilt, plead innoncence and not be put away? That feels so off for me and I would have loved some more perspective on this.

Next to that and I already replied this on someone elses sub, but the brother. He is so much off he anoyed me in the series. He seemed so very media-trained its just not natural. He is so judgemental without anger. He always assumes his sister is dead but even at the start doesn't really seem to be to touched about this. My first guess would be that he knew what was going on... which is seriously disturbing. Or the interviews with him are a lot later then they appear in the series. But then again, why would the media not interview the parents. Or did they but is it just not in the series? Anyway the brother to me seemed untouched by anything that was going on and I found that anoying especially because of his judgemental words.

Also I found the sudden stop of perspective from Jodi very frustating. Ok she got bothered, and then all of a sudden is out of the picture? What was actually going on there? Did she choose to no longer co-operate with the serie makers? I really did not understand this.

Then for both suspects... Inteligence. So both of them are told to not be the smartests. The kid has an inteligence below average? Ok so where is the proof of that? Why are people, especially his lawyers not more considerate of him even in court? What is he even doing there since he might not understand whats going on anyway? And why can he be so specific about certain things? He did recall playing nintendo with his brother for less then an hour but cant recall what he is doing around a bonfire for 3 hours? Same goes for SA. The logic in (wether he did or did not do the crime) is completely gone compared with his intelligence. So you wash the key, why even keep it? There are a freaking ton of cars in your junkyard but you make the victims car stand out? And seriously... you burn the freaking bones in a bonfire? Why not leave the body in the car and crush the car? (Ok that would give a lot more obvious mess but compare it to his said inteligence.) There is just so much stuff that does not add up towards both suspects if you stick with the theory they have low inteligence. Especially for SA who seems perfectly capable of controlling and understanding his emotions and reasoning according to this.

Ow and the prosecuter in both cases. The one later accused of sexual intimidation. This made so much sense to me. I found him to be HELLBEND on protecting those police officers from maybe making a mistake that I was sure he had something going on. Why else would you especially as lawyer not admit that we are all humans and can all make mistakes no matter the job. He did not even take the accusations seriously he threw them away and had a strong (disrespectfull) opinion of the people even suggesting this.

Lastly I found it very anoying that the series only showed that stuff got denied but does not explain why stuff gets denied, in the end it made me feel that the serie makers themselves are already prejudiced that SA is not guilty and will do anything in their power to show this.

Welp that was my rambling as I said in the top plz point out my mistakes because this is fresh after watching the series and I might've missed a lot.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Oct 22 '18

[MaM2 Spoiler] The Body? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Long time since but I remember this sub being a pretty good place for logical debate so thought I'd post if anyone can help with some questions. The sub seems a little inactive, Hope its okay.


It came out in MaM2 that a potential burial site was investigated, strangely only for a few hours but there was an interesting chat between KZ and a body burning expert where he talks about: most of the time people will get tired of waiting for a body to burn and be left with a torso they end up burying.

This is pretty consistent with the bones they found - cut extremities that would probably burn relatively easily and no rib bones or anything from the torso for that matter.

I have a few questions if anyone can help.

  • How could they confirm so quickly there was nothing of worth after the cadaver dog alerted them?

  • If the area was searched now and a body was found, what would happen (if anything) to SA?

  • Has there ever been another cadaver dog search? or any form of search?

  • Have they always ignored the search for 'the rest' of the body because it's so unlikely to find without a massive clue or lead?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 29 '16

Family/ LE /Suspects WHat are Steven Avery's habits? Your help Needed please.

5 Upvotes

Following on from this post https://www.reddit.com/r/HiveMindMaM/comments/4q66nf/people_are_creatures_of_habit/. I thought it might be good to take a look at what are Steven Avery's "habits". This is something I did in my head but did not make many notes so I thought maybe we could colllectively make a similar table using the criminal incidents and statements which give an insight into Steven's criminal (proven and unproven) behaviours. If you could reference the relevant report that would be handy too.

 

I would like to specifically exclude any behaviour in relation to the Halbach case at the moment

 

One of the things that stood out to me was that he is repeatedly described as "coercing" sex and in the case where he touched a young family member against her will he preceded to act in a sad way afterwards. He appears at times to be very manipulative in his attempts to gain sex when he wants it.

 

I would still classify all sexual assault and rape as immoral and so when I use the word spectrum here I do not mean spectrum of how serious the incident is, but spectrum meaning the different behaviours used to obtain sex, where the other person is not giving informed consent.

 

So when commenting with your info on Steven's "bad habits" and crimes, rather than just saying "rape" try to describe the behaviour as something on a spectrum. Sadistic? Forceful? Grooming? Pressurising? Violent?

 

In each of his crimes does he try to conceal it? How? How does he respond to being caught or confronted? Does he conceal/ destroy/play down his actions/admit actions?

 

Once we have a few bits I will put them into a similar table and we can take a look at his habits in a clear an obejctive way without the emotive language hopefully :)

 

If you can;

  • describe the behaviour

  • provide the source reporting the behaviour

  • tell us if the incident occurred before or after his false imprisonment


r/HiveMindMaM • • Apr 11 '16

RAV4 Who unlocked the Rav 4?

5 Upvotes

Has anyone come across any testimony of who actually unlocked the Rav 4 and when?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 08 '16

Media A bit of fun. Hidden meaning in Zellner tweets?

5 Upvotes

I tried to do this on MaM but it fell flat lol. I find @Zellnerlaw word choices interesting and somehow she seems too smart for errors, but maybe not.

Anyway for a bit of fun and too indulge me, please take a look through the tweets and pick out any words/phrases that strike you as carefully chosen, slightly out of place etc.

http://favstar.fm/users/ZellnerLaw/recent

Make a list and post them.

The words that stood out to me are;

  • big red flags

  • mix

  • rudimentary

  • uncovers

  • absorbs

  • magic

  • mix

  • signature

  • transcribes

  • Stephen (misspell)

  • dismantling

  • takes down

  • presto

  • blended

  • rubber stamping

  • stamp

  • driven (referencing how .22 got to scene)

  • tablespoon

  1. So we have mixing references (spoon, blended, mix)

  2. References to writing/letter or DNA? (transcribes, signature)

  3. Magic references (magic, presto)

  4. Two stamp references? letter/writing again?

  5. Red flag? There is a cargo company and this company in WI using that name http://benefitsinc.com/red-flag-guardian/ but it is a phrase commonly linked to financial fraud according to google.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 07 '16

Humor [Humor] Reason will Prevail. Just a bit of levity and humor to keep the HiveMind fresh.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes