Dr. Ken Bennett and the Human Female Illium Bones
Did Dr. Ken Bennett declare bones from the quarry under evidence tag 8675 to be human female bones?
This claim comes from u/foghaze. You can read the original post from MAM in the link below.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MakingaMurderer/comments/4afx1q/the_bone_that_was_verified_to_be_from_human/d10so3a/?context=3
First, The Criminal Complaint in Question
Dr. Ken Bennet is quoted as determining that an illium bone he analysed came from that of a human female. This appears in the Nov. 15th Criminal Complaint against Avery which you can see here:
http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Search-Warrant-File.pdf#page=25
Here's what the small section in the Criminal Complaint tells us.
The bones were transported by DCI agent Freymiller
Bennett identified the bones as being human in nature
Bennet determined based on the characterisics of the "ilium" bone, the bones are from an adult human female.
There is no mention of where the bone Dr. Bennett was looking at came from, nor any reference to an evidence tag in the Criminal Complaint.
The Claim.
u/foghaze claimed:
The only problem is there are no ilium bones noted by Eisenberg in evidence at the burn pit on Steven's property. The only thing that even resembles an Ilium is at the quarry
Ilium Bones at the Quarry, Eisenberg's Testimony
This lovely picture details the ilium bone for those of us who aren't anthropologists and will be helpful later when reviewing Eisenberg's testimony. It is essentially your "hip bone".
On page 167 of the transcript for Feb 28 2007, Strang asks Eisenberg about bones she wasn't sure were human or not
On page 169 Strang specifically asks about "the superior aspect of an iliac blade". Eisenberg begins demonstrating using a skeleton diagram on the ELMO. She explains the pelvis is made up of 3 bones. Two hip bones on each side called iliac crests and then the "tail bone" or sacrum".
Strang then asks about a bone "referred to as the sacral iliac articulation" which Eisenberg corrects him on and tells him is where the two bones, sacrum and iliac crest meet. You can see this clearly labeled on the diagram I provided earlier as "Sacro-iliac joint".
Eisenberg cannot confirm that these are human to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty.
The next day on March 1st, Strang adds the contextual information about where these two fragments were found in the quarry and under 8675 (These two being fragments of "the superior aspect of an iliac blade" and the other "referred to as the sacral iliac articulation").
Eisenberg references back to the iliac crest she was discussing yesterday and states it was part of evidence tag 8675.
It is also worth pointing out at this point that it is Strang who calls them "the quarry pile".Here is where the "quarry pile" in question was located.
So Foghaze claims that nothing that resembles an ilium was found anywhere besides the quarry. What does Eisenberg say?
Eisenberg is never asked whether any other "ilium" bone fragments were found in other evidence tags, though her exhibit 400 diagram quoting "pelvis" clearly suggests there may have been.
Eisenberg's diagram for tag 8318 (items sifted from the burn pit), Exhibit 400, indicates that there were bone fragments from the Pelvis found in that collection of fragments.
http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Exhibit-400-Graphic-Showing-Bones-Found-in-Burn-Pit.jpg
u/foghaze is correct that this diagram does not specify the "ilium" just the "pelvis" but the "ilium" is part of the pelvis. So clearly, some part of the pelvis was found at 8318, could the pelvis fragments have been part of the "ilium"? I would suggest it is definitely possible, maybe even likely. Eisenberg testifies that there are three bones in the Pelvis, two of which could be considered "ilium", so I'd give it a 66% chance on the information we have that the Pelvis bone in 8318 was part of the "ilium".
Also worth mentioning is that Eisenberg testifies that a fragment from nearly every bone below the neck was found in the burn pit, which would also suggest fragments of the Pelvis/ilium.
So What Bones Were Sent To Dr. Bennett to analyse?
As stated at the beginning, the Criminal Complaint from Nov. 15th does not specify where the "ilium" bone that Dr. Bennett declared as Human Female came from.
What we do know about the Criminal Complaint is that in the paragraph immediately before the one containing Dr. Bennett's analysis details that " on November 8, 2005 while continuing to execute the search warrant of the property located near the residence of Steven Avery located at 21932 Avery Road in the Town of Gibson, Manitowoc County, Wisconsin, officers located bone fragments and teeth in a fire pit area located approximately 20 yards south of a detached garage that is located next to the residence of Steven Avery." There is no mention of the quarry, and this is a criminal complaint for Steven's arrest for homicide in the first degree so why would the people writing this include information about analysis on bones from a property not connected to Steven? After detailing Dr. Bennett's analysis and Dr. Eisenberg's analysis, the Criminal Complaint further supports the idea that the bones Dr. Bennett reviewed by continuing to refer to items gathered from the Avery Burnpit such as the teeth fragments review by Dr. Simley.
If this criminal complaint was looked at in isolation you would assume the ilium bone fragments Dr. Bennett reviewed came from the aforementioned burn pit.
In fact this was the debate I had yesterday on SuperMAM with u/chromeomykiss .
I looked at u/chromeomykiss ' profile and found this comment and thread from TTM discussing the bones received by Dr. Bennett.
Imagine the shock I had when I saw that chrome and foghaze were going back and forth on the bones and foghaze was still perpetuating this idea that the only ilium bones were found in the quarry 8675 tag and that " Eisenberg does not report finding this bone at all. ". Well, we know she reports finding bone fragment(s) from the "pelvis" in 8318 from the burn pit and we know that the pelvis is composed of 3 bones, per Eisenberg's testimony, and that 2 of those three pelvis bones are what is considered "ilium" bones. So while technically no "ilium" bone is specifically reported I don't recall seeing Eisenberg saying that the only "ilium" bones were found under the 8675 tag.
But anyway, u/chromeomykiss linked to Eisenberg's testimony from the preliminary hearing.
On page 117 Eisenberg details the box of fragments that she received, including a plastic bag of bone fragments separated by Dr. Ken Bennett
On page 119 Eisenberg details the types human bone fragments she found inside the box that had previously been reviewed by Dr. Bennett. These include "dental structures, which may have represented fragments of jawbone and/or tooth structures", Eisenberg ends the evening on Nov 10th with several bags "representing human bone and bone from different areas of the body"
Drumroll please
On page 130 (Of Eisenberg's testimony on Feb 28th at the actual trial) Eisenberg identifies the box she received, photgraphed in Exhibit 383 (below), as being "under Calumet County Sheriff's Office Tag 8318"
Here's a photo of the box containing tag 8318, also containing the plastic bag of bone fragments declared human by Dr. Ken Bennett.
So, hold on. Let's review what we've learned.
Dr. Bennett reviewed a box of bones
Dr. Bennet placed some bones he suspected to be human into a clear plastic bag.
That bag was placed back into the box and sealed with evidence tape upon which it was taken to Eisenberg's office on Nov 9th.
Inside that box, alongside the bag of human bone fragments identified by Dr. Ken Bennet, were multiple human bones including jaw structures identified by Dr. Eisenberg on Nov. 10th.
Eisenberg specifies that "additional remains that had been collected by the Division of Crminal Investigation on the same property, from which the original box of fragments came."
Those bones that Eisenberg reviewed on November 10th are testified by Eisenberg to have come from an adult female.
Eisenberg testifies that the box of bones she received on November 9th 2005 came from Calumet County Tag 8318, this is the same box that Dr. Bennet reviewed in his analysis before sending it to Eisenberg.
Conclusion
So, the same box of bones that Dr. Bennett looked at is what was taken to Dr. Eisenberg. As far as I can tell, those bones ALL came from tag 8318. We know there were pelvis bones in tag 8318. I'm going to suggest that the ilium bone that Dr. Ken Bennett reviewed and declared human female is part of the pelvis bone fragments from 8318.
Even u/chromeomykiss doesn't seem to disagree with the proposed chain of custody:
So the chain of custody appears to be Freymiller to Dr. Bennett who examines, ID's human bones, separates out into plastic bag, then reseals and returns to Freymiller who then brings to Dr. E. office to be signed for by her assistant and Freymiller leaves the voicemail with Dr. E as well. Dr. Bennett does then file a 2-page report on 11/10/05 which is the day that Dr. E begins her exam on the bones.
Caso Page 180 indicates that tag 8318 was taken to the WI State Crime Lab on 11/09/2005.
There is no mention 8675 going to the WI State Crime Lab. A Ctrl + F for '8675' will first bring up page 407 and a supplemental report on January 17 2006. Describing 8675 as the contents of a debris pile. Before page 407 of the CASO, a search for "debris pile" will bring you to page 402, detailing the 5 gallon buckets containing the debris piles. At some point, 8675 appears to have come from one of these debris piles, or at least that's what I can assume.
If it didn't come from one of the debris piles listed on CASO page 402, then I suspect it was collected on either the 10th/11th/12th of November (Before Dr. Bennet could have seen it on November 9th and also prior to Eisenberg receiving that same box Nov. 10th) as that appears to be when they were at the "county quarry" according to Sippel on Page 203 of the CASO.
So, u/foghaze and u/chromemykiss , if you want to continue claiming that the bones Dr. Ken Bennett called human female came from 8675 then I ask you to please identify when 8675 was taken to Dr. Bennett. Using the CASO, I can at least identify when tag 8675 was taken to Eisenberg, and that it did not come from Dr. Bennett in January 2006 but via Deputy Hawkins.
According to the CASO pg 404, it would appear that Eisenberg only came into contact with tag 8675 on January 17th 2006, 2 months after she reviewed the box of bones that came from Dr. Bennett.
The next time that tag 8675 appears in the CASO is December 11th 2006, a whole 10 months later, when they are being retrieved back from Dr. Eisenberg
So, when did Dr. Bennett look at 8675?
TL;DR The bone fragments that Dr. Ken Bennett states are the ilium from a Human Female came from tag 8318, the burn pit, as testified to by Dr. Leslie Eisenberg. There is nothing supporting the conclusion that Dr. Bennett lied in the Criminal Complaint. There were other pelvis bone fragments that could have been declared human from the 8318 tag. u/foghaze jumped to a conclusion instead of doing the proper investigation once again.