r/HiveMindMaM • • Apr 11 '16

Interviews/Transcripts Full Calumet County Investigative Report (1,116 pages) - NOW ONLINE

18 Upvotes

(cross-posted from MaM sub)

Finally... The full (1,116 page) Calumet County Sheriff's Office (CASO) Investigative Report has just been scanned and uploaded at the links below.

Direct Link: http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/CASO-Investigative-Report.pdf

I added this to the list of documents on this page.

Note that some of the pages have text that was redacted by CASO, because it's information related to a juvenile. Transcripts from Dassey's interviews are also included, and these had obviously been released previously; but I believe the vast majority of the remainder is new information. Though I haven't had a chance to look through it as yet, so I'm not sure what else is in there.

Happy hunting.


r/HiveMindMaM • • May 27 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics Keys: gone forever. Bones: right over here!

17 Upvotes

A while back, I wrote about the fact that no trace of Teresa's purse, wallet or house keys were ever found. If her jeans rivets survived the fire, then keys and any metal bits in her purse or wallet should have too. At the very least, her house keys are somewhere, and they've never been found. That doesn't make sense.

It's striking me more lately that these items were never found - not among the burned cell phone and camera, nor any place else - and yet Steven left her bones in the BBQ pit and jaunted off to Crivitz, knowing the police had been around to have a look for her there, TWICE.

In my mind, this has become even more implausible than his failure to stay home that weekend and find time to crush the car when Earl wasn't looking.

I don't care what Steven's IQ is. You move the bones away from where you burned them. You scatter them under cars. You throw them in a pond. There's a fair chance they'd never have been found, had he done the latter. The search dogs might have found them if he'd put them under cars, but at least it would have been an attempt to hide the crime.

Put another way, if only he'd hidden the bones half as well as he hid her house keys.

These are the sorts of behavioral issues with the crime that make me doubt Steven did it, and make me absolutely certain there was framing involved whether he did or not.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 21 '16

Next Batch of Avery Trial Documents - NOW ONLINE

16 Upvotes

(cross-posted from MaM sub)

Next batch of documents is now online, including 70 new items totaling over 800 pages; links are below and all new items are marked as "(new)". This batch consists primarily of the remaining legal motions and briefs that were filed by the state and defense, as well as the remaining document exhibits.

We have one last batch of documents still to come (hopefully next week), which will include all of the transcripts from the pre-trial and post-trial hearings. Stay tuned for that.

New legal motions and briefs are available here:

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/keydocuments/

New evidence exhibit documents are available here:

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/exhibits/

 

Some highlights include:


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 07 '16

Interviews/Transcripts The timing of Steven hiring Strang

15 Upvotes

This is neither evidence, nor a theory about the crime. It's about trying to fathom how investigators put together these terribly lousy cases. And it's predicated on the assumption that Brendan's "confession" was at least substantially untrue.

From Brendan's trial:

Fallon: Directing your attention to February 20th, 2006, what plans, if any, did you investigators have relative to speaking with other members of the Avery family?

Wiegert: In order to do a thorough investigation, we needed to go back and talk to everybody who had access or who lived on that property.

Fallon: All right. Now who was the first one of the family members to be re-interviewed?

Wiegart: By my recollection, it was probably Kayla, most likely.

Now, here is Wiegart's timeline:

  • February 20, investigators re-interview Brendan's teenage cousin, Kayla (not recorded). She says Brendan has had crying fits and lost 40 pounds.

  • February 27, they actually interrogate Brendan for the first time, and not just once. First at high school, then at the police station, then at the relatively swanky Fox River (not recorded) and they finally get him to says things that would make him a witness for the state (e.g., seeing body parts in the fire).

  • March 1, they interrogate and arrest Brendan.

Wiegart describes this like it's a natural progression of events. But these "re-interviews" are just a fishing expedition, and it's far from obvious why they start with Kayla. And then they wait a full week before suddenly deciding they don't just want to re-interview Brendan based on what Kayla said, they're going to interrogate him three times. At what point did Kayla's "lost weight, cries a lot" go from being not that helpful to being a big clue? Surely they themselves knew she was wrong about Brendan's weight loss - they'd interviewed him several times over the period she's describing.

And yet, something during that week made them decide to go at Brendan really hard, and turn him into a state's witness. So I did some research, and here's another way to look at the timeline:

In recommending Strang, Glynn said of the Manitowoc cops, "well, I don't want to say "afraid of him," but they know him and they respect him as a lawyer, and I think that gives him a little bit of an edge."

Did the February 13 revelation that Steven wouldn't be settling for a Len Kachinsky motivate them to hunt more? And then, did the February 24 revelation that he was getting Dean Strang made them really determined to make a case, no matter what it took?

I mean, if you need to deliberately create a case where there isn't one, you would start with the most vulnerable witnesses you have - in this case, two teenagers who aren't very bright.

Edited to add: citation for Kayla not telling Wiegart anymore than I mentioned above on February 20 (the story about Brendan seeing bones in the fire came later) http://static1.squarespace.com/static/5691be1b25981daa98f417c8/t/56932ac8a976af0bfc5a9839/1452485326873/dassey_4_19_07.pdf Page 189

Q And in the time we have, urn, this afternoon, I'd like to focus your attention on a particular part of your investigation in this case, all right? Specifically, that is with respect to, uh, your interview, uh, in context with a young woman by the name of Kayla Avery. All right. Specifically, urn, directing your attention to February 20, 2006, on that particular day, did you have, uh, an opportunity to interview Kayla Avery?

A I.did. Urn, myself, along with a female detective at our Department by the name of, uh, Wendy Baldwin, had went to, urn, the Avery property, which would be the Earl and Candy Avery property, urn, to interview Kayla. Our purpose for going there was because we had some information from another person, which we had interviewed, that Kayla had information about Steve Avery. Our purpose for going there was to interview Kayla in reference to Steve Avery.

Q All right. And at some point during that interview did the discussion change focus from Steve Avery to Brendan Dassey?

A Yes. Urn, the interview started out about Steve Avery, and Kayla was talking about her relationship with Steve Avery. And just about at the end of that interview, Kayla, uh, out of the blue, basically, came out and told us that, uh, she had a cousin by the name of Brendan, and that Brendan was, quote, acting up lately. So we asked Kayla what she meant by Brendan acting up lately. At that point Kayla told us that Brendan would just stare into space and start crying, basically, uncontrollably. She also told us that Brendan had --had lost approximately, what she estimated to be, about 40 pounds.

Q Now, based on this information, what did you decide to do?

A Well, after looking at that information, urn, and reviewing other interviews that were done, we decided that, urn, we needed to talk to Brendan again.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 10 '16

Family/ LE /Suspects Ryan H talking about poor cell phone coverage at the Avery's

14 Upvotes

What am I missing here? This is Ryan Hillegas, in the August 9 pre-trial motion hearing, talking about why he gave Pam Sturm a direct phone number for Pagel. http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Partial-Motion-Hearing-Part-1-2006Aug09.pdf Page 85

A. I gave Pam -- Pam Sturm, I gave her Jerry Pagel's number that morning. The cell phone coverage out in that area is absolutely horrid. And to get a call out to -- most of the time when I used my phone out there, I only had 30 seconds or a minute to talk before your phone cut off on you. But I gave Pam that number, Jerry Pagel's number, that morning, with the intent that if she was going into the car lot and needed to call somebody quick, and get somebody out there, that would be the best way for her to.

And then on page 86:

Q. Okay. Before the morning of November 5th, had you ever been out to the Avery property?

A. The 5th, no.

Q. That Saturday morning?

A. No.

Q. So, before the vehicle was located, you had never been -- in your whole life, you had never been to that Avery property?

A. No

So how did he know Pam would need a number she could get through quickly? Did he spend a lot of time in Gibson or Two Rivers? It really sounds to me like he's talking about his cell phone use at the Avery property a few days later, not realizing that places his rationalization for giving Sturm Pagel's number after the fact.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 13 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics In The Land of The Blind, Sherry Culhane Is King

14 Upvotes

The A23 Blood Stain and Interpretation

There is a blood stain found at an important position on the RAV4. The blood stain in question, was found on the rear cargo door handle of the RAV4. Here are the results for that stain. I have circled in red mentions of A23 and the relevant results for this stain. The key part is in blue, the claim of insufficient for interpretation:

http://imgur.com/M9BiVFe

So we know from the official reports (March 31st, 2006) that Sherry Culhane developed a partial profile from this blood stain and deemed it insufficent for interpretation. The insufficient for interpretation is the opportunity for bias and is in essence subjective.


The Opportunity for Bias

N.B:This part is where it gets complicated and I will try my best to keep it simple. Please ask questions if it is confusing

What is used to determine errors from real results is a graph called electropherogram. This graph essentially shows peaks of colours corresponding to specific alleles/numbers in a DNA profile. The range/strength of the peak indicates whether it is a probable random result (artefact or technical error). Based on this range you can use it for different purposes. Here is a section from Exhibit 310 (Wisconsin Crime Lab Protocols, pg 103), specifying what different ranges can be used for (I have enclosed in red the relevant section)

http://imgur.com/NiE4U8k

As you can see, a partial profile can be improved but the key word is may be which essentially depends on whether the analyst is being conservative or liberal. This is what makes the result in the end subjective. One analyst could decide to use it for exclusion and end up excluding or not excluding SA, another anlyst might decide not to do that which could result in ommision of important conclusions. If the result on November 14th was that SA was excluded as a contributor to blood stain A23 would it have an effect on the investigation?


The Subjective Result

Here is an example plot of where the partial profile information can be varying extremely based on the analyst. The following image is an example of the graph in question that this whole post refers to. I am using different ranges than those in the WI Crime Lab Protocols, as this image I found online and was higher resolution. I am using it as an analogy and the ranges are different but the same logic applies (Concentrate on the table if it is confusing, the red is what the profile would look like if used for exclusion in this example).

http://imgur.com/vFf0ZRG

As you can see, if the analyst decided to use it for exclusion there was much more information to be extracted and if the analyst did not it could be deemed insufficent for interpretation. So the result clearly depends on the analyst, as they are not enforced to apply a certain criteria. This means that if Sherry Culhane had bias against SA and the sample excluded SA, she could decide not to use it.


In The Land of the Blind The One-Eyed Is King

I think this saying applies in regards to this post and topic in many ways. To me the meaning has to do with just having information, though imperfect, still being the only truth:

  • Sherry Culhane is the one with the knowdledge of whether if she used A23 blood stain for exclusion she could have excluded SA. We do not have that information as we do not have the actual raw data. /u/SkippTopp has indicated that he is willing to try to get this data and if there is anybody on here who can help in anyway regarding this, please do.

  • The analyst is in essence the one who is king. He is the one that makes the subjective decision at some key points in producing the results. Keep in mind this subjective decision can lead an investigation to completely different results.

  • The analyst does not even have to be one-eyed, after all everybody else is blind, all he needs to is convince us that she or he sees.


Addiitonal Information

Here is also a TEDx talk by Dr. Dan Krane it is long (15mins) but informative and could help you understand this post better as well as the issues and that blind testing could be the resolution (thanks /u/oliviad2 for the video):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tpPkmDeS3Dg

Here is also a paper discussing the possibility of bias in interpretation of DNA mixture samples (again, thanks /u/oliviad2):

http://www.scienceandjusticejournal.com/article/S1355-0306(11)00096-7/pdf

A post from /u/arseovrteakettl that shows there is intent for reforms:

https://www.reddit.com/r/MakingaMurderer/comments/43v48m/since_we_have_been_discussing_the_scientific_dna/


DISCLAIMER: This post does not necessarily concern SA's innocence or guilt. I am trying here to shift the topic from the tree to the forest. Should in any investigation an analyst who played a key role in the person's wrongful conviction be the one playing a key role in a new case? Is there opportunity for bias in the analysis that could actually be resolved with reform that makes the testing blind? Whether the key or anything was planted is irrelevant, what is relevant is whether MCSD should have been there? What is the point of a watcher from a not truly independent body (Calumet County) if not just a smoke screen, they should not be there at all? The list can go on and still not concern SA's innocence or guilt.


r/HiveMindMaM • • May 29 '16

Timeline TH phone numbers in CASO reports but not on official call logs emtered as evidence

13 Upvotes

I was going through the CASO report again for a browse and p8-30 we have a lot of phone numbers being checked out that do not appear on the call log submitted. Where did LE get these from?

 

And why is the phone number which was identified as Avery when RH profvided it now correctly reported as listing to T.Janda?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 20 '16

Blood/EDTA Blood Experiment Conclusion, links to each day 1-8 in conclusion also.

Thumbnail dl.dropbox.com
13 Upvotes

r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 27 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics People are creatures of habit...

12 Upvotes

PATTERNS AND MOTIVES IN EVIDENCE DESTRUCTION/CONCEALMENT

 

I am not sure if you have heard of Peter Tobin? He is a Scottish serial killer. He went undetected for many years. He had a level of forensic awareness but he did not seek to 'clean up' he just sought to conceal evidence long enough that he could move on assume a new name and start over.

 

For one victim he dumped her purse at a bus station to make it seem like she run away (his baby son's dna was later identified on that), he hid a knife in the loft (victim's blood later found on that), he cut the body in half and buried it (it was not found until 17 years later). His motive was to conceal evidence long enough to let him move on before it was discovered.

 

He also committed sexual and abusive crimes against various women and his patterns within those crimes differed from his murdered victims, but did follow a pattern across the rape/abuse crimes too.

 

In a later murder (the one that eventually got him caught and discovered the victim mentioned above body) he just concealed the body under the floor of the church long enough to get away. So again we see concealement to a level that allows him to flee.

 

So this gives context to my chain of thought. How criminals deal with evidence often follows a pattern, depending on what their future intentions are. Even where it is a first time crime there will often be a pattern within that crime (except with very disorganised thinkers).

 

PATTERNS IN THE EVIDENCE FROM HALBACH CASE

 

Different people respond differently and of course there are always exceptions or circumstances that may cause deviation, but I think of the responses broadly as these.

 

  • fight - a desire to continue to live their current life so they try to use total destruction or concealment of evidence to achieve this

  • flee - partial concealment or destruction, long enough to create distance from the evidence before discovery.

  • fiddle - pretend to have diminished mental capacity or manipulate evidence/give statement to implicate others.

  • freeze - do nothing except verbally deny.

 

So I went through the Halbach evidence trying to clear my head of any pre-conceived notion of any suspect for the murder or planting. I was interested in whether each item of evidence seemed to be;

 

  • concealed (long term)

  • concealed (short term)

  • destroyed totally

  • destroyed partially

  • left undisturbed

 

Was this person trying to get away with a crime and carry on with life? Preparing to flee? Attempting to conceal their identity?

 

You can see what my results looks like here http://docdro.id/uCy1rz7

 

I have tweaked my thoughts a bit as more evidence appears but I have not wavered much from the feeling that there are at least two "hands" in the evidence.

 

I know people are keen to jump to LE being these planters of everything and I personally do not find that very likely. I think that they are strong contenders for planting (or moving) the key and bullets/dna on bullets are fairly likely LE attempting to fill in the blanks and tie up loose ends to solidify the Avery case.

 

But even if we take those out of the picture altogether, there is still a conflict in the pattern of how the physical evidence is found, whether it was 'original',concealed or destroyed.

 

TLDR

 

People are creatures of habit. The evidence in the Halbach case seems like;

 

  • some evidence destroyed/concealed so well it is never found

  • some not concealed at all

  • some concealed/destroyed with various degrees of success

 

It feels like we have more than one "habit" at work and therefore more than one "hand" in the evidence.


r/HiveMindMaM • • May 28 '16

Interviews/Transcripts Two Rivers PD Records on Gregory Allen - NOW ONLINE

10 Upvotes

Two Rivers PD records on Gregory Allen:

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Two-Rivers-PD-Gregory-Allen-Records_redacted.pdf

Just a couple of notes:

  • The August 1983 indecent exposure incident at the beach area starts on page 15

  • It's not clear why the PB assault is included (page 24) given that Allen's name does not appear on that record; presumably it was attached to his record at some point, perhaps after the DNA match that was discovered during Avery's 2003 exoneration

Redaction was done (some by Two Rivers and some by me) in the interest of protecting the victims and witnesses.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 28 '16

Media Dean Strang says he really doesn't think he did it and gives some explanation on SA not testifying. * Bar assoc. Panel discussion*

10 Upvotes

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k5AZXBYbedw&feature=youtu.be&t=5m36s

An interesting panel discussion. I reccommend skipping the cop defending the Reid technique because....reid technique. Dean is pinned down to answer on SA guilt/innocence and he doesn't use the diplomatic "i'm not convinced of his guilt" line.

Puts me in a conflict waaaahhhh. He knows way more about the case than we do. He's clearly a humble man and I think he'd stick to the "not convinced..." if he thought he was likely guilty, but says he doesn't think he did it.

He also explains a bit about the documentary process and hints at why SA did not testify.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 20 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics Evidence that might suggest the killer was looking for something digital?

9 Upvotes

There are a few bits of evidence which may suggest the killer was looking for something.

 

  • the blinker propping up the back seats + the memory card in the cargo area

 

There are some other possible reasons for the blinker being there but the most likely reason would be to get access to the area under the seats, which could indicate searching.

 

Teresa is running a business and getting dust in a memory card by just tossing it in the cargo could damage it and lose her images, so would seem unlikely. Compact Flash cards could cost $100+ in 2005. Anyone able to check the price of verbatim compact flash cards on the way back machine?

 

  • contact blood smear on the cd case on the front passenger seat. Was there anything inside the cd case?

  • the multiple locations of blood (if it is Avery's and was deposited there naturally) could indicate someone moving around the vehicle searching

  • dismantling the electronics before burning

 

The obvious answer would seem that the killer sought to erase the record of their vehicle being photographed, but it should have been fairly easy to locate the camera for that purpose.

 

So it would seem most logical that if the killer was looking for something digital it would be a photo or video.

 

If someone was looking for a photo/video file then;

  • they must have known it had not yet been copied to her computer at home or work (or they had access to erase it there).

  • it must not be something she received/sent via text or email (or it would have been recoverable independent of her devices)

  • they knew the CF memory card found in the cargo did not contain what they were looking for.

 

Are there any other pieces of evidence which might indicate the killer was searching the car or seeking to destroy digital records?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Apr 01 '16

Interviews/Transcripts New Records from Calumet County Sheriff's Office (including fly-over video) - NOW ONLINE

9 Upvotes

(cross-posted from MaM sub)

New records from Calumet County Sheriff's Office (CASO) uploaded, with links below.

Notes: The fly-over video is undated, but at least a portion of it (starting around 4:20) seems to be taken after Halbach's vehicle was discovered and subsequently covered by a tarp during the investigation. From the day 2 of the jury trial, starting on page 106, the pilot (Curtis Drumm) testifies about a November 4 fly-over; in my request, I asked for video or photos from any fly-overs that were done between November 1, 2005 and November 5, 2005, just in case there were others. In response, CASO sent me a single DVD with one track. They provided no information on when it was recorded and there are no dates shown in the video. The files on the DVD show a last modified date of 01/24/2005, though that obviously seems incorrect.

The pages from the interview reports are non-sequential because they are pulled from the 1,116 page CASO Report, which consists of multiple different reports all merged together. I requested any and all records from interviews of G. Zipperer and B. Janda, and what they sent me is linked below. I already requested the full 1,116 page Report and I'm just waiting for them to send it to me, so that should be online in the near future.

CASO Records

The following records, requested directly from CASO, have been added to this page and labeled as "new".

  • CASO Video from Fly-Over and Quarry (undated): click here

  • CASO Crime Scene Sign-in / Sign-Out Logs (140 pages): click here

  • CASO Interview Reports for George Zipperer: click here

  • CASO Interview Reports for Barb Janda: click here

Evidence Photos:

The following evidence photos, requested from the Clerk's Office, have been added to this page under the heading "Photos of Teresa Halbach’s RAV4".


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 19 '16

Interviews/Transcripts CASO Response to Records Request

9 Upvotes

(cross-posted from MaM sub)

I just received the following response from the Calumet County Sheriff's Department (CASO) in regards to my records requests.

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/CASO-Records-Request-Response_redacted.pdf

As /u/super_pickle had explained in this post, most of the items I had requested are "sealed," and thus will not be made available to members of the public. Their reasoning is explained in the aforementioned response.

That said, there are a few items that are going to be available, for which I will be submitting payment this coming week. These include:

  • 1 DVD from November 4 fly-over

  • 3 page report on George Zipperer interview(s)

  • 5 page report on Barb Janda interview(s)

  • 133 page officer crime scene log (pending determination of copy method)

Additionally, I have already sent in payment for the full 1,116 page CASO Report (which is not sealed), and I should be receiving that document this coming week or the following week, depending on how long it takes them to make a copy and ship it to me. With any luck, the items noted above will be arriving shortly thereafter.

As always, I'll be posting everything to the website as soon as I receive it.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 23 '16

Interviews/Transcripts Transcripts from Pre-Trial and Post-Trial Hearings - NOW ONLINE

9 Upvotes

(cross-posted from MaM sub)

The last batch of documents is now online - 27 new documents totaling over 4,300 pages!

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/hearingtranscripts/

 

This batch includes all of the transcripts from the pre-trial and post-trial hearings, including: arraignment, motion hearings, jury voir dire, sentencing, and post-conviction.

 

Highlights include:

 

Thanks again to everyone who donated and/or helped to spread the word. Because of your generosity, we have been able to get the entire trial record, including:

  • 247 exhibit photos

  • 360 documents totaling over 13,300 pages

 

The only things we're leaving on the table are items that are simply not worth paying for, such as copies of empty envelopes, fax cover sheets, administrative paperwork, duplicate/redundant records, etc.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 18 '16

Media Zellner's tweet...Devil's River, Zander Rd?

9 Upvotes

https://twitter.com/zellnerlaw/status/699443806551306241

I noticed there is a Devil's river near the Avery place and it runs close to Zander Rd, which was an address SA had written on a for sale sign alongside TH phone number?

Have these locations popped up anywhere else?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 11 '16

Family/ LE /Suspects Let's pretend....

9 Upvotes

Let's pretend we are Reddit police lol and we have walked in and taken the case off MCSD. The shoddy evidence collection and chain of custody we can't do anything about....we just have to take it as is.

The car and bones have been found in the Avery property and we think SA is the prime suspect, however we are aware of his accusations of a frame up so we decided to work all leads and angles to eliminate other possibilities.

So the Brendan Dassey confession never happens because we have an ounce of professionalism.

What evidence to we have that's credible? What possible suspects and motives do we have? What different narratives does the evidence give us?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Feb 08 '16

Blood/EDTA It has been shown that you can predict age from blood samples using DNA.

9 Upvotes

Instead of using chemical determinants in order to distinguish blood samples, you could use DNA to determine age.

I will not go into what is DNA methylation as that can get complicated(will expand if needed).

However, there is a number of papers showing:

  • DNA methylation changes during age and changes in a familial manner. That is, if the mother exhibits decrease/increase of methylation over age so does the son.

  • DNA methylation has been shown to be a good predictor of a person's age using cells present in blood. This is with a margin of error (+/- 4.89 years).

The familial relation is important as it gives the possibility to determine the expected change based on family measures. Namely, whether you expect to see an increase or decrease in methylation over time.

Using this you can compare change between:

  1. SA now, sample in the car, blood from vial. This can show rate of change from multiple time-points.

  2. Compare the direction of change between SA's family and compare it to the direction of change in SA samples. This also gives reliability if you see that the change is similar inside the family.

  3. Do a direct comparison to identify significant changes between sample from car and blood vial.

  4. You can also not only compare the state of the samples but determine to a scientific degree of certainty at what age was SA. You can even use his blood now as a mock, basically predict his current age. Determining age also removes the need for the vial as you can determine if the sample in the car is from around 2005 (SA around 43) or around 1996 (SA around 34). Though, a direct comparison is a stronger experiment.


The most important source is the paper in which they did the whole experiment with cells from blood:

Genome-wide Methylation Profiles Reveal Quantitative Views of Human Aging Rates

Here is the prediction result where they train on a cohort and predict the age in another cohort:

Prediction Error and Capability

Other sources:

Additional DNA Methylation Usage and its Potential in Forensics:


Additional Info:

  • The blood vial is from 1995 and the car blood sample from 2005 (Source). Sample difference is about 9 years, so both tests are possible. (The difference has to be larger than 5 years to predict age, but you can still do a direct comparison and determine if they are significantly different.)

  • DNA methylation profile can be obtained from dried archived samples with a HumanMethylation450 array.


TL;DR You can show the differences between SA now, blood vial and car samples. You could attempt to predict age at all of those timepoints using DNA methylation profiles.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 04 '17

New photos from Brendan Dassey's trial - NOW ONLINE!

8 Upvotes

Photos from Brendan's trial are on the same page where photos from Avery's trial are, just under a different heading.

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/evidence-photos/

It had also been brought to my attention that the most recent request for the missing exhibit photos from Avery's trial were cropped. After some back and forth between me, the court, Lloyd's Photo, and /u/SkippTopp having to send the original disc back, he received the redone photos too :)

/u/SkippTopp has kindly offered to keep the older versions of those photos here in case anyone would like to make any comparisons.


Back in the beginning of February, I made the list of photo exhibits from Brendan's trial and some suggestions on what to request. There were a couple that I ended up not requesting, but here is what I did:

Exhibit #DescriptionDay
46photo of Avery and Janda trailers with arrow pointing at station wagon1
48photo of Barb’s handcuffs1
49photo of Barb’s room showing closet/storage space. Leg irons and handcuffs located on handles1
50photo of Barb’s leg irons1
52photo of Brendan’s Friar Tuck jacket that he wore on 10/311
53photo of Brendan’s tennis shoes1
54photo of Brendan’s bleach stained jeans1
121photo of burn barrels by or on ramp2
169photo of burn pit with steel wires, burnt seat, unburned tire3
175photo of burn pit and burnt seat3
211Animated drawing of SA bedroom5
212Animated drawing of SA garage “RAV backed in”5

I also received the documents requested from Brendan's trial! They are scanned in, but I'm working on getting them redacted and all. Special thanks to /u/Nexious who has helped with OCR so they are searchable!

Thank you so much again to everyone who has made this possible! We still have a considerable amount of money left. I'll get all that updated soon so everyone knows what exactly is left.

As always, a very special thanks to /u/SkippTopp for taking the time to upload and host everything on his website!


r/HiveMindMaM • • Aug 01 '16

Brendan's 'extended family around the world' - MaM season 2

8 Upvotes

http://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/2016/08/01/return-making-murderer-praised-panned/87439348/

MaM Season 2 will:

  • 'shed additional light on what was coercion by law enforcement in obtaining Dassey’s confession to Halbach’s horrific killing':

  • 'focus heavily on efforts by Dassey and Avery to overturn their convictions';

  • 'back inside the story of convicted murderer Steven Avery, and his co-defendant, Brendan Dassey, as their respective investigative and legal teams challenge their convictions and the state fights to have the convictions and life sentences upheld';

  • 'examine the post-conviction process and “the emotional toll the process takes on all involved";

  • featured 'Dassey’s legal team, Nirider and Steve Drizin of the Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago, along with Avery’s attorney, Kathleen Zellner';

  • keep Dassey's plight in the public eye!!!!!!!!!!!

...world is waiting and will watch it!...(and personally, I don't care if Hermann will watch MaM or not... IMO, he better WATCH-OUT, regardless!:).


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 07 '16

Interviews/Transcripts compiling info from CASO for easy reference

8 Upvotes

I was thinking I would go through CASO and make a list of the evidence item/tag# and their descriptions. Does a list like that exist already?

I also thought it might be helpful to put names with last 4 digits of their phone numbers (to see if they appear on any call logs for TH or SA).

Maybe an index too just summarising what is in each report?

Anyone up for helping out with that?


r/HiveMindMaM • • Jun 05 '16

DNA/Bones/Forensics Evidence collection 101 - failed!

8 Upvotes

I thought it would be interesting, especially for new people to the sub, to do a list of the failings of LE relating to evidence processing and collecting. There are a lot of conspiracy allegations around, but I think there are a number of really big issues we can prove with their own documentation. So if we were doing an audit on evidence collection in the Halbach case, what would the issues be? What evidence supports this?

 

I'll start

 

ISSUE; failure to correctly document (photo/video) the bones in situ at the Avery burn pit site and failure to recover these remains using correct procedures.

 

TL;DR

  • the medical examiner was not allowed in to view these remains in situ and advise on the best process for recovery of them.

  • the remains were not photographed/videod in situ to even allow retrospective examination of their position in relation to each other or their condition when found (cremains are fragile and may have been damaged in collection and sifting process).

  • failure to preserve the crime scene prior to recovery of the remains and failure to recover the remains using careful forensic anthropology techniques.

  • failure to store remains separate from remains found at other locations

  • failure to preserve chain of custody of remains

 

PROOF

 

Shutting out the medical examiner

 

The Medical Examiner, Debra Kataksch was prepared to testify that she was "walled off entirely" from the scene. http://www.jsonline.com/news/crime/witness-says-she-saw-victim-later-b99642985z1-363818721.html

This is highly unusual. The standard protocol when suspected human remains are found is to have the ME come in and examine them, prior to any attempt to recover the remains. The ME had access to specialists who could have conducted the recovery of the remains in the correct way to preserve the maximum amount of information.

 

failing to secure an area to preserve evidence

 

These photos show there was crates of water bottles, a dog & his chain and multiple feet on the areas where bomes were found.

http://m.imgur.com/GTjynuk,T529hE0

http://m.imgur.com/uyxhWGI,eCxufpw

 

Preventing retrospective examination by failure to document

 

This email exchange between Fassbender (investigator) and Ertl (crime scene tech) shows that there are NO photos or video of the bones in situ. The reason Ertl did not photograph them is the scene had already been disturbed. http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Trial-Exhibit-160-Email-Between-Fassbender-And-Ertl.pdf

 

This is a crucial piece of failure. Without the photos or videos a professional forensic anthropologist cannot retrospectively reach a conclusion about many things. This is explained by Dr Fairgreave (defense anthropologist) in the Docket podcast here http://www.michaelspratt.com/poadcast-legal-matters/2016/2/3/the-docket-making-a-murderer-after-show-special-guest-scott-fairgrieve

 


The type of information lost is ;

  • were the bones in this location only from certain limbs (suggesting dismemberment)

  • Were the bones in this location from all body parts (suggesting the entire remains were moved around to distribute at different locations)

  • Were the bones in "order" (was the skull above the shoulder bones or were they all mixed up) which tells us if the bones were moved/stirred after burning. This info would have been of great help on establishing if this was a true burn site, or if the bones had been placed there

  • was there any shovel marks or other tool marks in the soil surrounding the bones

  • did any damage occur to the bones during the collection process. Cremains are brittle and easily damaged (but they were shovelled, sifted, boxed and posted which could cause a lot of damage)


 

No soil samples

 

A soil sample could reveal human fat which would be a strong indication a body was burned at that location. Or may have revealed information about accelerants used. There is no indication of soil from the area immediately around the bones being collected and sent for analysis.

 

Bones from multiple locations in one box

 

This is like forensic 101. You do not mix up evidence found in entirely different locations! This again prevents us knowing which body parts were found where. If every location has a mixture of all body parts (not just particular limns in particular locations). This and the failure to photograph the bones in situ, or let the ME or a forensic anthropologist examine them in situ means that we will NEVER know the answer. That is catastrophic in the pursuit of the truth.

We therefore cannot know if any of the bones collected from the SA pit were later identified as human. We do not know where the bones identified as human originated (burn pit, quarry, burn barrel).

 

chain of evidence

 

The bones were posted to Dr Eisenberg who was not at her office when they were delivered. The chain of custody was broken. The bones from multiple locations were all mixed in together like a pick'n'mix...

 

clumsy collection

 

Day 6 testimony p52,: Ertl admits they shovelled and sifted the remains. There was no proper forensic recovery using archaeology type techniques , they treated the remains like they sifting pebbles. http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Jury-Trial-Transcript-Day-6-2007Feb19.pdf

 

What are the other failings which can be proven? What would you include in an LE evidence collection audit?


r/HiveMindMaM • • May 28 '16

Family/ LE /Suspects Gregory Allen - stalker, rapist and very bold one at that!

8 Upvotes

We know that he called Penny repeatedly and taunted her with details of the attack on her, whilst Steven was in jail. The reports show that he used some stalker type behaviour to contact prior victims to ask them to drop the charges.

 

The police were aware of his escalating behaviour and concerned enough to tail him. Hopefully they had enough training to understand that type of stress will often trigger reoffending. So in light of all that would really made them stop tailing Gregory that day?

 

I am also curious about the boldness of his attacks. Daylight. Very public locations. That seems like a lot more confidence in his ability to evade capture and boldness that could indicate a lot more offending than he has been linked to.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 24 '16

Interviews/Transcripts New Records from Manitowoc County Sheriff's Office - NOW ONLINE

8 Upvotes

(cross-posted from MaM sub)

The following records from the Manitowoc County Sheriff's Office (MTSO) are now online at the links below, all labeled as "new".

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/miscellaneous-records/

  • MTSO Report on Avery's Pointing a Gun at Sandra Morris (1985): click here

  • MTSO Report on Avery's Threatening Letters (1988): click here

  • MTSO Report on Possible Harassment (1990): click here

  • MTSO Report on Nov 4 Interview with Avery and Initial Search (2005): click here

  • MTSO Report on Halbach Investigation (2005): click here

 

I spoke with an Assistant Attorney General at the Wisconsin Office of Open Government about the stamp on each page (ref. this thread), and he confirmed what I and everyone had suspected - namely that there's no way for a records authority (MTSO, in this case) to declare a public record as being "confidential". MTSO had, in fact, released the record to a member of the public (me), per my request that was made pursuant to Wisconsin public records laws; as such, these are, in fact, public records. That remains true regardless of whether they try to slap the word "confidential" on them.

Also note, when I scanned them, the stamp was not picked up by the scanner. Presumably because it's a different color font, and mis-aligned as compared to the rest of the content, and therefore it was not recognized as part of the text.


r/HiveMindMaM • • Mar 18 '16

Humor Who else is getting MaM fatigue?

8 Upvotes

My enthusiasm is waning. Tinfoil hat theories appear to be growing at an exponential rate.

I've finished the docket podcast series :( and I hate the Jim Clemente one. Are there any other good MaM blogs, podcasts?

Anyone else getting MaM fatigue?