r/HistoryWhatIf • • 6h ago

Osama Bin Laden is killed on November 1, 2006

7 Upvotes

On the morning of November 1, 2006, George W. Bush announces on live television that American special forces have captured and killed Osama Bin Laden, in an operation he had a hand in planning. He frames this as a victory, and implies during the address that he aims to reduce American forces in the middle east over the next two years. Throughout the entire address, he is surrounded on-stage by emotional 9/11 survivors and families of the deceased. How does this impact Bush's approval at the time, and how does it impact the midterms and later 2008 election?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 8h ago

What if the Reconstruction era never ended in America

1 Upvotes

After the Civil War ,Reconstruction era ,until the northern compromise in 1877


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 10h ago

What would the governance of Siberia look like if Germany capitulated the Soviet Union?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 10h ago

What if the “Scramble for South America” was possible in the 1890’s?

2 Upvotes

How would America react, how would Europe gain/lose, and impact world geopolitics as a whole?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 18h ago

What if Britain sued for peace but France never surrendered in WW2?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 20h ago

What if Tom Steyer ran for President in both 2004 and 2008 U.S. Presidential elections?

0 Upvotes

In a parallel universe where Barack Obama is simply never born, Tom Steyer runs for President in both the 2004 and 2008 U.S. Presidential elections.

How does he do against the GOP tickets in both elections?

Edit: In light of the sub’s rules, the actual POD begins when Barack Obama is never born, not when Tom Steyer runs in 2004 and 2008.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 20h ago

What if the 2012 solar storm had been a direct hit, how would an ordinary government office have coped?

1 Upvotes

The usual version of this question is about the power grid. I am more curious about the dull layer on top, the offices that issue permits and visas and keep records, and what they do when the databases are down and nobody trusts the ones that are still up.

My guess is paper, ink stamps and ledgers, with every rule written as a temporary rule that quietly becomes permanent. I wrote one such notice and a letter that goes with it for a shared setting I run at r/TheGreatFederation and it is here https://www.reddit.com/r/TheGreatFederation/comments/1xx2hum/interim_visa_notice_for_entry_into_the_united/

Which public service do you think would have gone back to paper first, and stayed there longest?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 21h ago

How long would Italy stay fascist ,assuming the germans already surrendered by 1940 ?

2 Upvotes

In this AH ,the french launch an offensive while the germans are in Poland .West germany is overrun ,Hitler is couped and germany sue for peace .

How long does fascist italy stay fascist in this AH ?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 22h ago

What if Constantine had converted Rome to mithraism or manicheanism instead of Christianity?

9 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

If Muscovy failed to rebel, could Lithuania form a bigger empire after collapse of Golden Horde

1 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

Part 7 of My Series Where The Communist Revolution Failed & The Tsars Still Rule Over Russia

2 Upvotes

Miniseries Part 1, Miniseries Part 2, Miniseries Part 3, Miniseries Part 4,

Miniseries Part 5, Miniseries Part 6, Miniseries Part 7 (New Episode)

June 30th, 1908. The Tunguska meteor explodes in a fireball over Siberia, flattening trees for miles around. But what if it were bigger. What if instead of a single meteor that explodes in the sparsely populated wintery hinterland, it was 4 massive meteorites that fell in a line across Russian with the Fourth erasing Moscow from the Map. In this ongoing 8 part miniseries that's running parallel to Season 2 of the show, we look at what could have been.

In Part 7, we pick up from where we left off in 1996, & continue the story through 2012.

As Russia struggles to rebuild in our timeline, Sam is in for a few surprises about what they went through in the years between the Soviets & Putin. Meanwhile, in Sam's timeline, everyone has given up on Tsar Nicholas III becoming a father as he's in his early 60s in the beginning of the episode. This has people throughout Russia wondering & worrying about what will happen to the House of Romanov & the leadership of Russia. Meanwhile, Russia & the US are working together on the International Space Station in our timeline & reaching for the Moon in Sam's timeline. In Sam's timeline, there are people in the Western parts of Russia that still want out, as the third Communist revolution seems to be dealing with some issues of its own.

Will the Eastern Poland Party reunite Poland? How are the Communist's nuclear ambitions going? Who will carry on after Tsar Nicholas III? Can Sam handle hearing the issues affecting our Doomsday Clock like our loose nukes, our treaties, & the new threats that the clock is taking into account? Tune in to Find Out.

In Part 1, we see Russia devastated, with much of their early efforts at industrialization wiped out with the loss of Moscow, leading to a WW1 & a Communist Revolution that played out very differently, with Tsar Nicholas II surviving the rise of the Bolsheviks, & needing to find a way to save Russia from the Soviets & the Germans.

In Part 2, the Russian Empire has to pick up the pieces after dealing with the Bolsheviks & the Germans. As new alliances form in the Baltics & Central Europe, Russia resorts to invading its former territories while rebuilding everything West of the Ural mountains & struggling without the industrial power of Moscow as they befriend the United States across the Pacific.

In Part 3, the Russian Empire is confronted with the world changing events of WW2. With Germany's invasion playing out differently since Russia wasn't communist in this timeline, & with the Russian army being led by a Russian Tsar instead of a Soviet General Secretary, every frontline plays out differently leaving Russia barely recognizable. The Russian Empire was also unwilling to help the communist revolution in China.

In Part 4, with Germany defeated & all of Europe devastated, it's time to rebuild & set up the new world order. Sadly, while all of that is going on, Leon Trotsky comes back into the picture. Turns out that he's been hiding in Russia's Far East & has decided that the time is right to kick off a second Communist Revolution. This forces an exhausted Russian Army to head East & spend years fighting the communists again as the country struggles to pull itself together. While all of that is going on, Imperial Russia also helps to restore the Korean Monarchy in North Korea, restoring the Royal Line in the Northern half of the Peninsula.

In Part 5, Estonia rebels against Russia. On top of that, the survivors of the second communist revolution in Russia's Far East are back for a third go at Communism in Southeastern Africa. While all of that is going on, Russia is also dealing with a religious movement that wants to stop any effort to rebuild Moscow by any means necessary.

In Part 6, Tsar Nicholas the 3rd was still dealing with a religious terror group violently opposed to the reconstruction of Moscow. Everyone was still not so patiently waiting for him to either father a child to carry on the House of Romanov, or to find a solution to this inheritance crisis that will one day hit the Russian Throne. Meanwhile, Russia & the US were reaching to all new heights &, there was some potential trouble brewing in the Western parts of Russia.

How will this timeline plays out? How many more communists revolutions will there be & will any of them work? What happened to the Romanov family after Tsar Nicholas II & his family survived the original communist revolution? Was there a Korean War? A Vietnam War? A Space Race?

Tune in to find out.

What Could Have Been is a sci-fi podcast where your host interviews alternate versions of himself from across the multiverse to find out how different decisions, actions & events might have changed the course of history. Listen to the stories of alternate timelines from a world where the Space Race never ended, to a world where France annexed West Germany after WWII, to a timeline where North America is being ripped apart by a new Faultline, to a timeline where humanity was contacted by aliens in the early 70s. Listen to what happened in these wild timelines & find out What Could Have Been.

NSFW (due to language)

Episodes - 22

Spotify, Apple, Deezer, PocketCast, Goodpods, Acast & Many More

You can also Follow What Could Have Been on Bluesky or here on Reddit.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

What if Russia elected the communist party in 1996

14 Upvotes

Following the collapse of the Soviet Union the Russian federation went through a rough patch in the years following 1991 and by 1996 president Boris Yeltsin was falling in the polls set to lose to the Communist party of Russia seemingly set to win and see Gennady Zyuganov winning the presidency.

Yet Yeltsin was able to bounce back and win with a narrow 54%. There have been claims that Yeltsin only won through underhanded tactics such as media bias and fraud along with American backing.

So what if the Communist party of the Russian federation actually won the 1996 election and saw communism make a sort of return to Russia but now as the Russian federation instead of the USSR. How do the Americans react and how would this affect the more modern times, would Putin even become president of Russia?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

What if Kurdistan existed

0 Upvotes

As the Ottoman Empire collapses and the Entente are drawing borders in the Middle East, suppose a small slice of what’s now Turkey, Iraq and Syria was allotted to the Kurds. How does this play out?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

US stays neutral in WW1 and any proceeding conflict as Central Powers win?

4 Upvotes

You can define the CP win as an armistice or better. Any second conflict however it takes place the USA will also stay neutral. This necessitates an alternate nuclear program to Manhattan.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

[META] What would have happened if the Dominican Republic had facilitated the entry of immigrants from both Europe and North America during the modernization of the sugar industry in 1869?

3 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

Challenge: Make Yoko Ono a broadly beloved figure in the United States by 2026

0 Upvotes

Changing as little as possible about her actions, art, or personality, you must make Yoko Ono a broadly beloved figure in the United States as of 2026. She can still be politically polarizing, but she may not be broadly controversial or hated outside of that realm.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

What would have happened if Britain kept its empire?

4 Upvotes

After ww2 Britain somehow keeps its empire by a mixture of paying its US debt very quickly and convincing its colonies the world is too dangerous to stand alone. To pay the debt and stabilise the economy let's say a gold mine is found in the UK that produces enough gold to pay everything off but runs dry after it's paid for everything. How dose this effect the cold war and European politics ( is there a eu and nato)? Dose Britain push forward with CANZUK or would it be abandoned, possibly due to the US and soviets panicking? If CANZUK happens dose it expand or stay to just the Anglo sphere colonies?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

If Napoleon was never overthrown and remained as emperor what does his death and funeral look like

7 Upvotes

So i recently rewatched the 1970 movie Waterloo and it got me thinking, in a world where Napoleon Bonapart remains as emperor of france, be it he never invades russia or accepts the Frankfurt proposal and remains on the throne, what does his eventual death and funeral look like. He was, emperor, a man beloved by the french people, and if we presume he dies around the same time he did OTL or only some years afterwards, what would the funeral posession look like for him. I can personally invisage a grand procession, his body laying in state, men of his grand armee arriving to pay tribute, his marshalls standing before his body in respect, and the funeral itself being a grand event attended by possibly foreign dignitaries. What do you think?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if non avian dinosaurs fossils were found in Antarctica ?

0 Upvotes

Imagine if a research team managed to find a fossil from a small theropod dinosaur in the Ross Dependency from the Eocene. Could it had pushed scientific efforts and funding for adding more bases in the continent ?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

If Britain had kept Fiji as part of the UK, could it have become a mini Hawaii?

11 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if prince Vladimir somehow knew about Buddhism and converted Kievan Rus into it in 988?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if Taking nukes out of the equation a full scale joint invasion of the usa by Russia and china happens right now. What would happen?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

The heir who betrayed his father, the lord of his family. Traitor?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I have some questions about the topic of heirs betraying their own family.

The context: A player who is the heir to his house, a large and important house, receives news that the heirs to the throne are planning a civil war. He sides with the female heiress... But his father, who is a lord, favors the king's male heir. Furthermore, they are a large family living together; the lord is currently married to a distant relative who is the daughter of his marshal. In addition, other members hold important positions.

My biggest question is... How does this generational dilemma unfold? Considering that the heir is at home and the lord is in the capital with the male heir.

What usually happens to heirs who go against the lord? Do they have the strength to seize the fortress and the armies? And what about their vassals? Who will they obey?

I would appreciate your help in understanding this political knot. Thank you in advance for your help.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if Christianity split into the North and South?

0 Upvotes