r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jul 25 '24

What if Mitt Romney had won in 2012 instead of Obama.

3.9k Upvotes

-> In the 2012 Debates, Romney did great until he was asked who he sees as our greatest geopolitical foe to look out for. He claimed that we needed to watch out for Russia pulling some bullshit. Obama laughed at him and told him “The 1980’s called and they want their foreign policy back!”. Everyone after the debate jumped on that and laughed at him and then said Obama won debate….

-> (2) years later Russia annexed Crimea and conflict broke out in the eastern Ukraine under Obama/Biden administration.

->Fast forward to 2022 under Biden, Russia officially invades Ukraine

-> if Romney was president, how different would this timeline be?

Also!

-> if Romney had won in 2012 instead of Obama. Would Trump even have been president??? Trump really only ran for President initially as a Fuck You to Obama.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 01 '23

What if 9/11 had been a nuclear attack?

2.2k Upvotes

It has been reported that Osama Bin Laden had the opportunity to purchase stolen Soviet nuclear warheads in the 1990's. He ultimately turned down the offer, but it suggests that there is a possibility that a nuclear weapon could have been used in the terrorist attacks that he had planned for 9/11. What would have happened if this had worked?

Here's the scenario: Four bombs are placed in unmarked vans and driven to target locations. Two atomic warheads detonate in New York, nearly destroying the entire city. Due to communication errors a third bomb detonates next to the Pentagon nearly an hour later, destroying the surface structure and heavily damaging Washington DC. Most of the country was aware of the attack in NYC and most civilians in DC had evacuated or gone underground. A fourth bomb intended for an unknown target was stopped by law enforcement and civilians who were suspicious of the vehicle. The terrorists were armed with AK-47s but were taken out with heavy casualties and the bomb was secured.

What would have happened after such an extremely devastating attack?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Dec 28 '19

If all 45 US presidents were alive today, sat down in a room and had a conversation, how do you think it will turn out?

1.4k Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Sep 10 '23

Had the USSR not collapsed in 1991, what would’ve their reaction been to 9/11?

1.4k Upvotes

In our timeline, when JFK was assassinated, the KGB and higher ups of the USSR were panicking as they weren’t sure if it was one of their agents who assassinated JFK, and later offering their condolences after they found it wasn’t them.

But what if the USSR hadn’t collapsed in 1991, and what would’ve their reaction been to 9/11? Would they have had that same JFK rational of “oh god I hope we didn’t do this”, what would some of the conspiracy theories look like if the USSR was still standing to this day?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Nov 26 '25

What if the US Supreme Court hadn't blocked Florida's re-count in the 2000 Florida presidential election?

1.4k Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Apr 15 '20

In 2002, during his famous post 9/11 State of the Union address, President Bush, in a surprise to his own staff, discloses all ties we today know that the Saudis had to financing and supporting the terrorists, adds them to the "Axis of Evil", and throws them equally under the proverbial bus.

1.1k Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 26 '20

Picture this: it’s 1963. The news has broke that JFK’s motorcade has just been fired upon by unknown gunman. News confirmed he was wounded by gun fire, and is rushed to the nearest hospital. The nation is in panic...

1.0k Upvotes

Updates on the presidents condition are slow, the American people wait with quiet trepidation. Many day’s later, ABC Evening news announces exclusive interview with unnamed guest. The program switches on.

Good evening, this is Ron Cochran. I’m here with a special guest tonight. And I’ll be starting off this interview with a question.” he turns to his left to a guest that isn’t on screen. “sir, how are you feeling. A familiar voice piped up.” Well Ron, eye’vuh had quite a tumult-ew-us couple of day’s, and an exciting trip to Texas, but I’m feeling quite well all things considered.” The camera cuts to wide. In the news room sat Ron Cochran, and John F Kennedy, in his best suit, trademark smile, and a new scar just barely visible through black and white television cameras.

Tl;DR: JFK, survives his assassination with minimal injury and makes a confidence appearance on national tv. How do things play different? How are World events changed? Does JFK have a chance at re-election? What does the world look like? How does America move forward with a president who survived an assassination?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 05 '24

If Europeans never traveled to the Americas, how long would it be before Native Americans develope iron smelting?

1.0k Upvotes

In my theories, it would probably be thousands of years after the 1500s as Native American civilizations had copper smelting as the most advanced technology, and it took Asian civilizations hundreds of years if not more before they developed bronze smelting and then centuries later before they developed iron smelting.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 31 '20

If a modern day warship had to travel back to 12th century and rule the seas for the next 10 years, what sort of technology could scientists create so that the warship doesnt run out of ammo/fuel and can survive/defeat the medieval navy?

995 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Mar 06 '20

What if the South was "desouthernized" after the Civil War in the exact same way that Germany was denazified after WWII?

931 Upvotes

Basically, after the American Civil War, the North forces the South to remove its antebellum culture as a requirement to being reinstated into the union. Southern culture as we know it no longer exists, as it is either considered taboo by society or criminalized.

Additionally, the North also implements its own version of the Nuremburg trials. Robert E. Lee, Jefferson Davis, Alexander Stephens, and other top-ranking CSA officials are all arrested for treason, put on trial, and executed.

How much would change? Would individuals like Lee and Davis be considered martyrs? Would the civil right movement occurred sooner?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Sep 08 '24

[CHALLENGE] What if the Nazis did [this useless thing] differently would Germany win WW2?

908 Upvotes

As we all know the Germans had the Soviets on the brink of collapse during WW2 (Soure: Trust me bro), were about to win, and only lost because Hitler interferred with his Generals and screwed up Barbarossa. This is the only reason they lost, and that's a fact.

My question is, if the Nazis did [this useless thing] differently or had [useless weapon], would Germany win WW2?

Furthermore, what would happen if the Nazis did [thing that contradicts their core ideaology] could WW2 be avoided entirely?

Bonus: If Germany won the battle of [irrelevant Eastern front city] would they have beat the Soviets into surrender?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Aug 09 '24

What if Bernie Sanders had won the 2016 Democrat nomination?

907 Upvotes

I have to admit, I’m kind of curious about this possibility. How would this impact the Democrat’s popularity? Could Sanders have beaten Trump? And what would have happened if Bernie Sanders did become president?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Apr 25 '25

If Hitler hadn’t killed himself what would his trial have been like?

891 Upvotes

In terms of pomp and ceremony, as well as what punishment we could have expected. I can’t imagine he would have gotten the Hirohito treatment since obviously the emperor had a lot more cultural significance then the Furher, but would it have been possible to see scapegoats a la Tojo? Hopefully not an incredibly stupid question, just interested in the answer from some more learned folks


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Dec 04 '20

[DBWI] Hi comrades. What if the USA and capitalism had won the Cold War?

858 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Sep 20 '23

What if Osama bin Laden was killed by the British instead of the American military?

805 Upvotes

The last what-if examined the scenario where Osama bin Laden was captured alive instead of killed in a US military raid in Pakistan but let's change it up for this one: Let's say in an alternate timeline, the British somehow get to Osama bin Laden in Pakistan ahead of the Americans and kill him in, say, a raid by the United Kingdom's Special Air Service (SAS) instead of America's Navy SEALs.

I'm sorry if this post isn't allowed and if this is too redundant I'll remove it but here's the point behind the what-if: this post is meant to examine whether the aftermath of Osama bin Laden's death be the same even if a different country's military killed bin Laden instead of the USA's.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jun 16 '20

A game about Alternate History

796 Upvotes

Hello, everyone,

I hope my message fits the rules of this Reddit.

First of all, English is not my main language so I'm sorry for the mistakes you will find there.

I coded a little game about history. This game allows you to alter some of the 100 events in the history of mankind to create the timeline of your choice.

I hope you'll find it interesting.

The game is here: http://abw.blue/


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jan 11 '21

What if Yugoslavia moved the capital to Sarajevo to promote unity? Moving it out of Serbia would make the country seem less of a big Serbia and more of a union between the South Slavs. Sarajevo itself is in a more central location and is heterogenous.

790 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 26 '23

If the United States lasted another 800 years, what events from our current history would still be taught in high school history classes and how in depth would they be?

748 Upvotes

First, let's leave out the obvious consideration that we don't know if high schools would still exist in 800 years, or a lot of other technical things in such a hypothetical scenario, since that makes this question basically impossible. Under some sort of standard secondary education as we understand it now, what would students 800 years from now be learning about U.S. history up to this point?

I remember that learning world history our teacher explained to us that certain major areas (India, Egypt, etc.) are picked for study and used to broadly represent their larger regions, leaving the intricacies or even existence of whole nations behind. Major events that whole dissertations could be spent on were condensed into a single bullet point in one day's lesson. That makes sense when you have to cover 10,000 years of history in a very limited time.

But one thing I really enjoy about studying U.S. history is how short it is up to our current time. We got to learn about individual battles, speeches and policies in a lot of depth while still getting through every period. While that can definitely give Americans a more limited global perspective, it is cool that right now as an American you can know the whole history of your country in pretty decent breadth and depth as just a high school student.

If the United States still existed with continuity from the current country 800 years from now, making the country about 1,000 years old, what parts of our early history do you think would still need to be studied for a basic education of the country? What leaders' names would students still need to know? What wars would be put on tests or policies still be mentioned? Is there anything you would be most sad to take off the syllabus? Obviously there's no way to know exactly how future events would recontextualize the past, but with our limited information now what do you see still persisting into the future?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 06 '24

What if, in retaliation for 9/11, someone were to set off a bomb that destroyed the Kaaba of Mecca?

737 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jan 02 '26

You are given the chance to send a 4-word message back to 1938 to the Allies. You decide on "1939 - protect the Ardennes". Assuming this message is received and taken seriously, how much does this change WWII?

724 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Aug 25 '24

If the 22nd amendment never existed, would Barack Obama have beaten Donald Trump in 2016?

710 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Sep 27 '23

What if the US never invaded Iraq in 2003?

698 Upvotes

More specifically how would this affect global politics? Would Sadaam still be around? This question is less about domestic US policy and more about international affairs.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 19 '23

If Hilter had nuclear weapons at his disposal in the late 1940s, would he likely have used them?

696 Upvotes

What countries might he have used these weapons on? If the war was a lost case, would he use the bombs on Germany? Alternatively, would the invention of the atomic bomb by German scientists just in time changed the course of war, leading to victory?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Aug 02 '24

Would Hitler still have killed himself if the western allies reached Berlin first?

690 Upvotes

I've read that towards the end he was seeking a separate peace with them and even trying to pitch the idea of joining forces with them to fight the Soviets (because we all hate the communists, right guys??). He also clearly had no illusions about how he would be treated in Soviet custody.

But what if the western allies had reached Berlin first? Do you think he still would have killed himself rather than be taken in custody?