r/HistoryWhatIf • • Nov 09 '24

What if Clinton won in 2016 and Trump didn’t accept the results?

0 Upvotes

As we know, towards the end of the campaign Donald Trump wouldn’t commit to accepting the results of the election if Hillary Clinton won. Would an insurrection still take place on January 6, 2017?

It’s uncharted territory because it’s now a presidential nominee instead of an actual President like 2020.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Feb 03 '25

How could someone actually turn US into a dictatorshiop?

0 Upvotes

US has a strong system checks and balances, so if the president actually wanted to overthrow the political system and become dictator, how would he even do that? Changing the constitution is too hard to do. The closest thing I can think of would be if he had a sufficiently loyal party in mayority in congress, to pass the law changing the number of Justices on SCOTUS from 9 to 1, just the Chief Justice that Constitution requires, then somehow get rid of all Justices on Court one way or another, perhaps blow up the plane they are all on, and nominate himself as Chief Justice. Then he would continue being both President and Chief Justice, there is some precedent as John Marshall was for a time both Chief Justice and secretary of state. This, due to him being only Justice on Court, would give him both full judicial power and as president full executive power.

Any order he made, if it gets blocked at the lower court, would ultimately end up back to him on SCOTUS, where he would reverse lower courts and establish any precedent he wants that lower courts would from then on have to follow. As sole Justice, his word would be the law of the land. Constitution and laws say what he says they say. He could even rule that congress cannot impeach him unless he commits crime, reversing ruling that said impeachment is a political process. This is the easiest way I can think of for the President to become the modern Roman Emperor. What do you think, is there any other way?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Aug 21 '25

If Hitler had been just as impossible to physically get to as Putin is today, would he have been able to prolong the war?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 24 '23

Given the current problems they face, would the US be better off if they just let the Southern States go instead of fighting the civil war?

2 Upvotes

They couldn't have known at the time what the South would become, or rather, remain, and hindsight is always 20/20, but yeah, I'm curious.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jun 17 '26

What could U.S. founding fathers have done to prevent *gestures vaguely* all this?

8 Upvotes

I just saw a clip from The Simpsons where Homer says "and just like American Democracy, my stupid experiment has failed." Which brings me to my question: If you could go back in time, what is the most important thing you would try to influence or codify into the U.S. constitution to protect democracy? Or at least protect most of the world from whatever is going on here?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Nov 28 '25

If the Nazis won the war, would they have been more likely to actually implement Generalplan Ost and the complete enslavement/deportation of Slavic people, or would they have been more likely to "chill out" a bit and just settle the best areas, while implementing an Apartheid-style system elsewhere?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Feb 16 '25

What would’ve liberated Russia?

0 Upvotes

Ever since the Mongol conquest, Russia has constantly been put under authoritarianism. Any attempt to reform and liberalize Russia (Alexander II, Russian Revolution, and Yeltsin) always resulted in Russia doubling down on authoritarianism (Alexander III, creation of Soviet Union, and Putin)

However, what if that changed? What if Russia was able to liberalize itself?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jan 24 '24

What if Hitler went for Moscow first?

0 Upvotes

What if Hitler invaded Russia before Poland?

None of the main allies would have tried to stop him. Could he have taken Moscow in a few weeks, then the rest of Russia and later turned his attention to Europe?

Could Germany have won the war in this case?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Mar 20 '24

Us nukes China in 1991

3 Upvotes

To secure complète hegemony,the americans, seeing China as a industrial behemot in the making, nukes China, leaving only 5 percent of Chineses alive.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Mar 28 '25

What if Hitler hadn't persecuted the Jews, would Germany had beaten USA to the atomic bomb

2 Upvotes

If Hitler hadn't been Hitler, with his anti-Semitism leading to firstly the closing of research and teaching positions to leading Jewish physicists, scientists, engineers and mathematicians and secondly a brain drain when they fled abroad, could and would Germany have developed the atomic bomb first and won ww2.

Not to mention advances in more conventional weaponary


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Dec 08 '23

What if the Confederacy had won the American Civil War?

0 Upvotes

How much longer would slavery have lasted in the American South? What would the society and culture of the American South look like today? What would long-term relations between the USA and the CSA have been like? Would the CSA have been a prosperous nation?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • May 08 '25

What If Atlantis Was Real, but Not the Whitewashed Version?

0 Upvotes

Big disclaimer: This isn’t me claiming a magical island vanished in a single day. I don’t buy into the ancient aliens, hyper-advanced tech, or lost white empires theories. But if Atlantis was ever based on something real? Here’s a version that actually makes sense—and it’s way more human.

Picture this: a maritime culture that thrived along coastlines during the last Ice Age, when sea levels were hundreds of feet lower. These weren’t gods or engineers with laser pyramids—they were just early sailors who figured out a key trick: saltwater doesn’t freeze easily, so if you hug the ocean, you stay alive longer than the folks inland.

And then,bam. The Ice Age . The seas rise. Their settlements vanish beneath what’s now continental shelf. So they adapt. They pack up, get on the water, and move.

Now here’s the fun part: ever seen how Polynesians built boats capable of crossing entire oceans? Now imagine thousands of those vessels, possibly tethered into a mobile floating city. No "continent" needed—just a culture that moved with the water. Something more like Zheng He’s treasure fleet or Austronesian migrations, not a race of demigods.

They wouldn’t conquer the world. But over time, they could have traded, influenced, and integrated—leaving behind fragments of knowledge in places like the Aegean, Egypt, or the Levant. Enough to be remembered. Enough to be mythologized. And eventually, enough to be twisted into Plato’s Atlantis allegory.

So yeah—I don’t think Atlantis was real in the way people usually imagine. But a network of seafaring survivors who spread ideas after the Ice Age drowned their homeland? That’s not just plausible—it’s pretty damn poetic.

Fun to think about.

ps i believe ancient people were smart enough to realize the snow aint stopping and prolly try and find a way out of it


r/HistoryWhatIf • • May 10 '26

What if Osama bin laden declared war against China (instead of US) due to China’s mistreatment of Uyghur Muslims?

11 Upvotes

Originally posted on r/AlternateHistoryHub


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jul 02 '24

What If US enslaved white people like the Ottomans ?

6 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • Mar 01 '24

What if the USSR was as racist as Nazi Germany?

0 Upvotes

Let's say that as central Europe gets more antisemetic in the 1930s, the USSR also becomes deeply racist. The leadership accepts the basic tenets of the Nazis racial darwinism, just deciding that the Slavic peoples of Europe should be on top.

By 1941, the USSR and Nazi Germany decide that it is time to start their own Holocausts independently of each other. Their targets are virtually identical, swapping slavs for Germanic people, but both putting Jews at the bottom. They even have death camps and everything.

All else being equal, Nazi Germany still invades the USSR for living space.

How would the Allies react? In their views, two Nazi countries, one brown and one red, have invaded multiple countries, are openly antisemetic, publicly despise capitalism, and are now fighting each other for domination of Europe.

For a moment, imagine the war happening a bit like this: you'd see Germans breaking through to see minorities, Jews in particular, being gassed and killed, and publicising this to the allies and neutral nations. Whilst they personally don't give a shit about this, they broadcast it as the bolshevik brutality of the Russians. At the same time, you'd also see Soviets doing exactly the same whenever they advance across the front, broadcasting the Fascist tyranny of the Germans.

It would be difficult for countries like Britain to argue for allying with the Soviets who are unapologetically as racist as the Fascists whilst arguing that they are defending democracy.

Finally, lets say that the Soviets completely supported the fight against the West by the Germans, even sending their soldiers to fight in the battles of Britain and France in 1939 and 1940


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 21 '23

What if Donald Trump had responded properly to the COVID Pandemic?

0 Upvotes

Many people often assume that Donald Trump lost the election becauze of COVID, However what if he does all of these instead?

-wears a facemask out in public and tells everybody to wear their facemask, to wash their hands and whatever the doctors were recommending the public to do at the time

-have multiple public press conferences with health experts and such

-Run constant broadcasts across the country telling everybody to wear their mask and wash their hands(with him speaking of course)

-Photo Ops with Doctors across the USA and such

-Sells American Facemasks that says "Make American Great Again!"

Would he have won the election even with BLM and such other political stuff that happened or would he still have lost?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Aug 29 '24

What if the US is rabidly anti communist during WW2 and does lend lease for Germany instead along with limited troops if feasible?

0 Upvotes

Not plausible but just thinking about this from sort of a war game perspective. Following the German invasion of the Soviet Union the US pledges the same material that went to the Soviets and British to Germany instead.

Britain having no assistance does not surrender but nearly abandons any hope of landing troops back in Europe. Relations with the US are very rocky and they will not assist in stuff like troop staging for the US in any way. US believes invading UK from across the Atlantic nearly impossible and not worth the hassle.

The US seeing Germany has the initiative in 1941 does not feel the need to create the army it did and will not be creating 90ish divisions it did to invade Europe but is willing to send some troops for assistance. Should the eastern front become dire the US will fully mobilize fearing an economic crisis due to being shut off from Europe (basically why Europe first existed in the first place) Japan still goes ahead with Pearl Harbor (limited impact on Germany as they never did cooperate much) and US pursues a Pacific first strategy, not many soldiers required but a lot of sea lift capacity again unless the eastern front becomes dire.

Overall the US is confident in victory and not desperate enough to pursue the rapid production of the nuclear bomb.

With all that said-

What kind of troop levels can the US muster to the Eastern front given the wars not quite so existential?

How fast and where do they send/route them with no British support for staging/landing?

Does the economic support withheld from the Soviet Union and redirected to Germany along with some direct support if feasible lead to Germany achieving maximum war goals or a favorable truce (net gain in territory but unable to occupy up to Urals/permanently destroy Soviet Union)?

Does the war end quickly in like 1942 or do the Soviets still build up some steam in time to carry out major offensives turning it into a major slog?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jun 19 '25

What if escaped African slaves allied with natives?

1 Upvotes

If escaped African slaves allied with natives to drive the Europeans off the continent. That is, to kill the colonizers. The natives agreed and the Africans received land from the natives and even interbred. How would this change history?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 04 '24

What if homosexuality and same-sex marriages were accepted and legal in the Middle Ages?

3 Upvotes

So this is a weird/out there one, and quite obviously ASB, but it popped into my head so I’m curious. So let’s assume that through whatever means, homosexuality ends up being considered acceptable and not condemned by neither eastern or western branches of Christianity, and in general socially acceptable in most of the cultures in at least Europe. Let’s also say that concubines for the sake of reproduction would be allowed in such cases, with the child produced legally and spiritually being considered the legitimate child of the the married couple in such cases to avoid destroyed successions. Now, with all that in mind, and now with more potential matches than before theoretically, what sort of historical arranged marriages/marriage alliances would have potentially had likelihood of being made in TTL, considering there’s likely plenty of marriage alliances that had not happened for no other reason than lack of viable matches when there weren’t any unmarried available daughters or unmarried available sons to match with sons and daughters (respectively) for such a thing in otl.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Oct 03 '24

What if Nazi Germany had created the atomic bomb before the USA?

0 Upvotes

Germany was advanced in nuclear physics, but did not put as much research or money into developing nuclear weaponry during WWII due to Hitler's ideas to create absurd wonderweapons. If Nazi Germany had, however, put their time and effort into developing nuclear weapons and created them before the Allies, what would it have looked like? Would the war have ended differently?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Aug 06 '26

What if Mormonism was its own religion rather than a branch of Christianity?

0 Upvotes

Say Mormonism proclaimed itself to be a new religion to succeed Christianity, like Islam did


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Sep 26 '24

What if Biden picked a Latina woman instead of Kamala Harris to be his VP in 2020?

0 Upvotes

Who would the possible contenders be and could this candidate win in 2024 instead of Kamala Harris?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jun 27 '24

What if the allies accepted a conditional surrender after Hitler died?

0 Upvotes

I know this situation is impossible but let's just say for fantasy sake that the Allies let Germany keep their present day borders with the Nazi Party still in control but with Hitler dead. What wouldve happend?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • Jul 20 '25

What if Napoleon Bonaparte teamed up with the United States against England during the War of 1812?

5 Upvotes

This is a rewrite of the previous scenario regarding the Louisiana Purchase.

For context on how the War of 1812 started and how it ended, see this article.

In a parallel universe, Napoleon hears that war has broken out between the United States and the United Kingdom yet again in 1812 and immediately decides to help the Americans.

Keep in mind, in 1812 Napoleon Bonaparte's empire was in its heyday. Napoleon decides to deploy military forces to attack England directly, forcing England to fight a two-front war. This takes the form of a naval blockade and/or bombardment, as well as the deployment of French forces to England proper as part of an invasion of England.

Napoleon intends to go scorched Earth on England, crippling its ability to defeat the Americans. He doesn't intend to occupy any territory and doesn't give any such orders to his men; they are simply told to destroy anything of strategic value to the British to help the Americans.

If Napoleon tried this, would it turn into a disaster on his end?