r/HistoricalWhatIf • • May 14 '25

If the Nazis had developed the atomic bomb, which city would they have bombed first?

1.3k Upvotes

The Nazis wanted to settle the East with Germans, so, if possible, they would want to avoid polluting East with radiation.

As America was too far, they probably would have bombed London or other British cities first.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • May 06 '13

[META] Don't forget to add "What if..." to the beginning of our questions. I keep having mini heart attacks reading the front page.

980 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Mar 25 '24

What if John McCain became president of the U.S, in 2000?

908 Upvotes

ITTL, McCain wins the 2000 Republican primaries, And wins the 2000 elections. What will the future hold?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Oct 11 '12

What if Israel was in the Soviet sphere of influence rather then the American one?

664 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Apr 24 '20

If George Washington had been made a monarch, the current King of the United States would be Merle S. Monroe, a 72 year old man from Evanston, Illinois.

635 Upvotes

George I (1776-1799)

George Washington did not have any legitimate children, but he did adopt two of Martha’s children from her previous marriage, John and Martha. Unfortunately, George outlived both, but John had four legitimate children who lived to maturity, the youngest of whom was a boy. In 1799, George Washington Parke Curtis, grandson of the king, would become...

George II (1799-1857)

George only had one child who survived to maturity, Mary Anne Custis, so when he dies the U.S. gets its first queen...

Mary (1857-1865)

Now this is where things get weird. The Civil War takes place during Mary’s reign and her husband is Robert E. Lee. Assuming the United States is a constitutional monarchy and Abraham Lincoln is the Prime Minister, then he would have directly challenged the Queen Consort and won. This would probably mean the establishment of the Republic as the monarchy would be forever tainted by its pro-slavery stance, but let’s say Lincoln is a monarchist who allows Mary to abdicate in favour of her eldest son...

George III (1865-1913)

George III dies childless. He also outlives his younger brother William and all four of his children. This means that the throne passes to the third son of Queen Mary...

Robert (1913-1914)

After only a year on the throne, Robert dies and the throne passes to his elder daughter...

Anne I (1914-1978)

The longest reigning of America’s monarchs, 64 glorious years were spent under the reign of Queen Anne I. Anne outlived her son Hanson, who would have been first in line, so instead the throne goes to her daughter...

Anne II (1978-1995)

In preparation for the death of Anne II, the largest succession crisis in the history of monarchy as a government form is triggered. When she ascended the throne, she was past childbearing age and had no children. Her brother Hanson had no children and the decision by her two cousins Robert and William to die childless deprived us of a DeButts dynasty. Genealogists had to go back to King Robert‘s generation and determine that the eldest sibling of his who had children who lived to maturity was his sister Eleanor. She had a daughter named Sarah, who also had a daughter named Sarah, who had a son named Shelby. Of Shelby S. Monroe’s 5 children, only three were alive by 1995, the eldest being Merle Lavern Monroe. The plot of the movie King Ralph comes to life and a man who, according to his obituary, was a landfill worker and keen fisherman, becomes...

Merle I (1995-2004)

Merle dies in 2004 and is succeeded by his son...

Merle II (2004-Present)

According to BeenVerified Merle is still alive and living in Evanston. He has a son called George who lives in Bellefonte, Ohio, so we’d be getting George IV next.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Jul 31 '24

If Nuclear Weapons Had Never Been Invented would have WW3 started in 1955 or 1961? Which year is WW3 more likely for it to start?

621 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Jan 05 '13

What if Afghanistan was never invaded by the United Front and the Taliban regime continued to conquer all of Afghanistan?

584 Upvotes

What got me thinking on this was wondering whether it would be worse to live under the Taliban regime at their full strength, or to live in the current conditions of scattered warfare and civilian casualties. I realized that in order to make any kind of decision, I would need to know what I could look forward to in a Taliban-controlled Afghanistan.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Mar 14 '13

How would modern American football players fare in an ancient world? (further explained inside)

561 Upvotes

While it's only my opinion, I see American football players as some of the scariest (scary good that is) athletes in the world today. When I see someone like Julius Peppers, who is 6'8, 287bs, and can run a forty in 4.68 seconds, I realize he is stronger, bigger, and faster than most men around. I'm curious what a modern athlete of his caliber could accomplish in the ancient world, lets say Rome, or Gaul, or Germainia, or Caledonia, something along those lines. Were there athletes of that size/speed in those days? I'm sure there were some barbarians of his stature but I don't know much about that time period. I'm under the impression that the average Roman was around 5'6-5'7 and about 125lbs. Even someone like Tom Brady is 6'4 and 225lbs. I wonder if he could be as talented chucking around a pilum like he is the old pigskin.

I suppose what I'm asking is in a warfare standpoint, and I understand that the brawn of the barbarians wasn't much of a match for the organized and regimented nature of the Roman military, but the question still jumps around in my head.

For anyone who read all that and can give me any kind of answer, I'd appreciate it.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Oct 18 '12

I got carried away answering "What if Mexico had agreed to ally with Germany after the Zimmerman Telegram", and then OP deleted it. So I am sharing my answer with you anyway.

504 Upvotes

Mexico, still bitter about the Mexican-American war of 1846 and eager to stamp out the revolution of Emiliano Zapata (who Mexico suspected was being aided by the United States), receives the Zimmerman Telegram, unintercepted by British Intelligence. Having their army already mobilized and fighting in the North, Mexico drafts their own version of the "Schliefen Plan" which aspired to capture huge grabs of territory and then sue for peace before their foe realizes that they cannot hold the territory. They secretly agree to an alliance with the Central Powers and begin receiving shipments of weapons from Germany as well as funds to buy weapons and supplies from America, ostensibly to fight Zapata.

The US, though increasing production of war materials in order to sell to both sides (well, mainly the British), has not mobilized or prepared its forces for war. Although beefing up its naval presence, the number of troops remains pitifully small.

1918: Mexico launches an attack, seizing the US naval shipyards in San Diego and the main commercial hub in Los Angeles before the U.S. is even aware of the attack. Arizona and New Mexico are quickly taken; the few forces on the border with Mexico (ironically, there to help capture Zapata) are captured or killed in the first few days. Mexican forces march up California and are stopped at the head of the Salinas Valley, cutting off their march to San Francisco. In Texas, border towns are quickly overwhelmed, as is San Antonio. The Mexican army bypasses the capital of Austin and instead heads straight to Houston, hoping to cut off supplies arriving by sea. Texas, notorious for its independent nature, quickly rallies the militia. Houston is torn apart by brutal, street to street fighting. Mexico sets fire to the city, hoping to burn out their enemies.

The government in Washington is taken completely by surprise. Saboteurs cut railway lines and telegraph lines throughout the country, having had time to infiltrate across the porous, lawless border ahead of time. Initial reports had mistaken for the invasion as a domestic troop revolution, because Mexico's soldiers were armed with US weapons and had made counterfeit US military uniforms. Washington moved quickly to lock down remaining troops in the country, hoping to stop the spread of the non-resistant revolt. This significantly slowed their response to the invasion, allowing Mexico to solidify its gains.

4 days after the invasion began, the Senate officially declares war on Mexico. The Mexican Ambassador, who had remained behind in Washington so as not to raise suspicions, is arrested and hung from the White House portico. The Senate simultaneously passed a mandatory draft (Although not necessary, as recruitment offices were overwhelmed by volunteers), and declares war on Germany and the other Central powers.

Naval forces from San Francisco, Oregon, and Washington mount a counter-offensive as the garrison in Salinas continues to block movement into Northern California. Amphibious landings manage to retake sections of Los Angeles, San Diego. Furthermore, forces land in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, and begin fighting up the Baja Peninsula.

In Texas, reinforcements arrive by rail (where possible) and by sea from Louisiana and Florida. Both sides commit the majority of their forces to the Battle of Houston. Galveston is retaken and becomes the beachhead for forces arriving from the East Coast.

After 8 bloody days, Houston is retaken and Mexican forces retreat to San Antonio. Well supplied and fortified, they manage to fend off all attacks from pursuing militia. Directed by German military advisers, they dig trenches and await the main force of the U.S. military. Mexico tries contacting the US government, offering peace in exchange for holding territory in Texas, California, New Mexico, and Arizona. The US government doesn't even respond.

2 weeks after the invasion: Mexican forces remain in control of New Mexico, Arizona, and parts of Nevada, Colorado, and California. US forces have manages to retake most of Los Angeles and San Diego, although Mexican guerrillas saturate the hills around L.A. In Texas, Houston has been utterly destroyed but retaken; the Mexican Army has settled into San Antonio, awaiting a longer battle. US forces have been stopped in Baja Mexico at Santa Rosalia and have also become entrenched. The first battalions of US Regulars arrive in Texas from other states. After a devastating first assault on San Antonio, with casualty estimates as high as 25%, U.S. forces decide instead to encircle the city and starve them out.

1 month after the invasion: US forces defeated outside Santa Rosalia retreat back to Cabo San Lucas; resupply and reinforcement efforts are hampered by German U-Boats, who have been diverted from the war in the Atlantic to aid Mexico. Mexican forces in California, cut off from the South, make their way into the Central Valley of CA in order to resupply from the many farms in the region. They are doggedly pursued by US forces, and employ a "scorch and burn" tactic, devastating the region. Minor skirmishes take place up and down the state. In Texas, Mexican forces in San Antonio show few signs of running out of supplies. The US Army brings in heavy artillery and begins non-stop blasting of the city.

2 Months after invasion: Mexican forces in California are destroyed at the Battle of Fresno as they try to make their way into the mountains and join up with forces in Nevada. US Troops push through Arizona and New Mexico before being stopped at Albequerque by entrenched Mexican forces. In Texas, the U.S. army continues its siege of San Antonio after repeated, failed attempts to break through Mexico's lines. Mexico employs chemical warfare (from Germany) with devastating effectiveness. US troops begin bypassing the city and fighting their way into Mexico, retaking the Rio Grande and occupying Matamoros. US Marines land at Veracruz and take the city with almost no resistance. This becomes a hub of landing more soldiers and spreading through Southern Mexico. Indigenous peoples in the Yucatan rise up against Mexico and join US forces, establishing their own independent nation on the Yucatan Peninsula. US troops from California begin pushing into the Baja region while simultaneously pushing up from Cabo San Lucas. The peninsula is taken in a matter of days and the army invests Hermosilla.

3 months after invasion: San Antonio finally falls to US forces when Mexican forces run low on ammunition and attempt to break the siege and retreat toward Mexico. The government of Mexico sends envoys to the United States in order to negotiate a treaty. An angry mob, goaded by journalists pushing for punishment of Mexico, lynches the envoys. President Wilson issues a statement declaring that the United States can no longer consider itself safe until Mexico's government falls. US forces have seized all of the border states of Mexico as well as Sinaloa and Durango. Much other Southern Mexico has seceded and many major coastal cities have been captured. US troops move slowly toward Mexico City, hampered by the lack of infrastructure in arid Northern Mexico. Railroad tracks are laid at a breakneck pace. Reinforcements stream into the country with no end in site.

4 months after invasion: Western Mexico secedes and allies itself with the United States. Mexican forces surrender en masse as the US marches toward Mexico City. The US has recognized the independent countries of Yucatan and Oaxaca. The government of Mexico recalls all remaining forces to Mexico City to man the defenses. Washington still refuses to negotiate terms of surrender until the government has fallen. Planes come into widespread use, being used to drop propaganda and threats into Mexican cities. Angry mobs set fire to large sections of the city, and soldiers are forced to abandon their defenses to put down the revolt. Government officials try to flee and are captured on their way to Puerto Vallarta, where a U-boat waited to take them to Germany. The President of Mexico, Porfirio Diaz, hangs himself in the presidential palace, and Mexico City is taken without a fight.

5 Months After Surrender: Much of Northern Mexico, as well as the east coast of Mexico, is annexed by the United States. The State of Mexico is all that remains of the Country of Mexico. The Nation of Sinaloa runs across the western coast of Mexico, Oaxaca takes up much of southern central Mexico, and the Nation of Yucatan covers the Yucatan Peninsula


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Mar 10 '13

What if WWII / the Nazis never happened? Would this sub still have something to talk about?

475 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Jun 15 '13

What if, for whatever reason, Britain had sided with Germany during the first world war?

471 Upvotes

Since WW1 wasn't really anyone's fault (although the Treaty of Versailles would have you think otherwise) and was essentially the result of a chain reaction due to various agreements between countries, what would have happened if Britain had made agreements with different countries, which resulted in Britain backing Germany following the assassination of the Archduke Franz Ferdinand?

things to consider:

-How would this affect the Second World War? -Would Russia have been as powerful? -Would America have joined Britain and Germany, or would they have joined with France?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Aug 11 '24

What if: When Booth assassinated Lincoln, the plot was incomplete. What if the plot to kill Vice President Johnson and secretary of state Seward has gone through?

453 Upvotes

There were two co-conspirators set to act right as Booth's scheduled intermission was happening.

One went to kill Secretary of State William Seward, but the conspirators gun had jammed, so he used his knife, and Seward survived his wounds.

The other was in the lobby of Kirkwood House and knew which room Johnson was in, but he started drinking at the bar and got cold feet, for which he ironically hung anyway.

So what if Seward had died from the attack, and the conspirator assigned to Johnson had gone through as planned?

What would the implications be?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Feb 16 '24

What if Covid 19 started 10 years earlier?

439 Upvotes

Let's say the virus starts in late 2009 and spreads throughout the 2010s, how would everything change? And what would be the consequences?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Aug 16 '13

A man from 2013 can carry back as much as he can fit on his person to the Dark Ages. What would be the smartest things to bring to conquer earth, and how would he go about it?

424 Upvotes

Kind of a long question, but I'm interested to hear some perspectives. By Dark Ages, I refer to the time between the fall of the Western Empire and the crowning of Charlemagne.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Mar 10 '24

What if 9/11 was caused by a Mexican cartel instead of Al-Qaeda?

393 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Jul 07 '14

Ronald Reagan is shot during the 1981 assassination attempt but contracts AIDS from a blood transfusion during surgery. How would this affect the AIDS situation in the 1980s?

390 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Sep 07 '20

What if, when the English colonies in America said "No taxation without representation", Parliament said "Good point, here's the vote"

344 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Dec 08 '20

What if Boris Yeltsin had been shot dead when he was drunkenly roaming the streets of Washington, D.C. in his underpants during his visit to the US in 1994?

322 Upvotes

Yes, this apparently happened for real (the roaming in his underpants part, that is). Apparently Bill Clinton told this story to journalist Taylor Branch who later published his interviews with Clinton in a book.

I'll just quote this history.com article:

The incident happened during Yeltsin and Clinton’s first meeting in Washington in September 1994. “Secret Service agents discovered Yeltsin alone on Pennsylvania Avenue, dead drunk, clad in his underwear, yelling for a taxi,” Branch wrote in his book. "Yeltsin slurred his words in a loud argument with the baffled agents. He did not want to go back into Blair House, where he was staying. He wanted a taxi to go out for pizza.”

(...) The next night, Clinton recalled, Yeltsin tried to do it again. “Eluding security, he made his way down the back stairs into the Blair House basement, where a building guard mistook him for a drunken intruder,” Branch wrote. “Yeltsin was briefly endangered until converging Russian and American agents sorted out everyone’s affiliation.” Because the guards mistook him for an intruder, “Clinton thought this incident, although contained within Blair House, exposed even greater risk than the pizza quest.”

I have no clue if the guards at this Blair House were armed in 1994 or if they had really shot an unknown elderly drunk man desperately trying to get inside through the back door. But let's assume neither his own bodyguards nor the secret service manage to track his whereabouts in time and they arrive at the scene only to find out that drunk Yeltsin, not getting recognized by the house guards, had started a fight with them until one way or another one of them pulled out a gun and shot him dead.

What's next?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Sep 10 '12

Congratulations, r/HistoricalWhatIf! You are our Subreddit of the Day!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
313 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Aug 19 '20

(META) A friendly reminder that history is more complex than the average Europa Universalis IV match.

311 Upvotes

In the last few days (and before, of course) there have been a couple of posts on here (and /r/HistoryWhatIf, but oh well) whose very question and premise sounded exactly like they could have been posted on /r/eu4 or /r/paradoxplaza. And while I do enjoy games like Europa Universalis myself (or regarding other periods of time, Crusader Kings, Victoria, you name them) exactly for its What-if premises and its countless possibilities and sometimes cheesiness these questions feel a bit off.

Like, for instance, there have been posts asking what could have happened if Germany or Italy unified early (or, earlier), or other posts depicting premises where Country A "annexed" Country B and simultaneously Country C "annexed" Country D and what not without providing actual reasons for why all this would happen in the first place. I feel like posts like these are carrying a certain expectation along, which is that a country's first and foremost (and natural) goal and purpose is to expand its territory. But this goal is not "natural", there's always a reason behind it.

Now if we look the mentioned example about Germany and Italy unifying earlier. The very idea is interesting without any doubt, but without OP putting more effort into depicting the Why and not just the What it just feels like the idea isn't really grounded in 'real' history. Although in both cases, Germany and Italy, the respective OPs could try and actually find real-life possibilities for them to happen: Germany as a (re-?)unified country post-Napoleon, or Italy created as a confederacy with the Pope as its leader (yes, this idea was a thing). So, why not put some more research into your idea and draft a fascinating scenario around it? This could overall help improve the quality of the questions posted on here.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Nov 02 '12

If the United States suddenly attempted to take over the world, how much land could reasonably be conquered by America?

308 Upvotes

I don;t know much about military strategy, but I assume the first targets would be resource rich areas like oil in the middle east. If america were able to eliminate its need to import resources like oil, how much of the world could be conquered? Also, I was thinking about this without the use of nuclear weapons.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Jan 28 '14

What if "Red Dawn" really happened and Russia/Cuba/China invaded the United States in the 50's or 60's? What would the war be like?

295 Upvotes

Pick a year somewhere between 1955 and 1975. A massive secret communist alliance forms to take the fight directly to the Americans. What happens?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Jun 08 '12

If Columbus hadn't discovered the "New World" and Cortes hadn't destroyed the Aztecs, would the Aztec Empire have fallen?

279 Upvotes

All the history books I've read have mentioned that there were many reasons that the Aztec empire fell as quickly as it did. Chief among them was that the Aztec empire was unstable and already on the point of collapsing when Cortes invaded with his guns and horses.

If Columbus had never alerted Europeans to the existence of the Americas, Cortes and his army wouldn't have destroyed the Aztec empire. However, would the Aztec Empire have fallen in a few years anyway? Would one of the conquered people have replaced them?

I'm very curious to hear the response!


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Dec 17 '23

What if Stalin broke the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact instead of Hitler?

276 Upvotes

In our timeline, Hitler and Stalin agreed to the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact and soon after, Germany invaded Poland, officially instigating WWII in 1939. Two years later, in 1941, Hitler broke the pact with Operation Barbarossa, the German invasion of the Soviet Union. Interestingly, I found out that Stalin received warnings that Hitler would break his end of the deal and invade anyway (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-13862135, https://www.rbth.com/history/335541-did-stalin-know-germany-will-attack). It's also known that Operation Barbarossa's planning began in mid-1940, with the Nazis prepping in secret to avoid early discovery by the Soviets (https://www.rbth.com/history/335541-did-stalin-know-germany-will-attack).

I began to imagine a parallel universe where Stalin, being the paranoid freak he was in our timeline, either begins to suspect that Hitler never intended to honor his end of the bargain to begin with (Perhaps he has a premonition of what Hitler did in our timeline) and proceeded to break the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact himself by invading Germany, or he heeds warnings that Hitler would attack the USSR and break his end of the deal, thus invading Germany himself.

How plausible is this scenario? The only reason why I thought this scenario was possible in the first place was Stalin's paranoia. For those who want to argue that this scenario is unlikely or unrealistic, I'd like to ask: "What did I miss about Stalin?"