r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/davidborts • May 01 '13
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Silent_Resolution_99 • Aug 27 '24
What if Trump won the 2000 election?
No really, I'm being serious. This was inspired by a reply I saw in another post. It got me thinking.
Here's how it happens:
It starts in 1992. Before he dropped out of and re-entered the race, Ross Perot was often leading the three man polls. There was a point where Bill Clinton was polling third.
Many theorize that if Perot had stayed in uninterrupted, he may have won the popular vote, and carried a lot of States.
Now if he doesn't win a majority of the electoral vote, it goes to the house who would have re-elected Bush Sr. But let's say that it happened.
Perot does a good job, gets re-elected in 1996, and a whole political party is built around it, just like in our timeline. The reform party.
That's where Trump comes into play. In 2000, in our timeline, he was interested in running as the reform party nominee. But decided not to pursue it because Perot's reform party was fracturing.
But it's no stretch to say that the reform party would have looked very different had it come off the back of a successful two term Perot presidency. So in this alternate timeline, Trump goes for it, and gets the nod.
I don't find it inconceivable. At the time, Trump's views, or at least his stated views, weren't as extreme. They were more middle of the road with an oddity thrown in here and there.
I see him getting a cult following much as Perot did, and much as he himself did in 2016. He'd be a polarizing figure, but run a much less controversial campaign in 2000, because at the time, most voters weren't yet ready to play politics that way. Voters in 2000 might sweep small things under the rug, but one "macaca" moment could sink you, so Trump wouldn't have said the things he could get away with in 2016.
But a lot of the things that could sink him with voters at the time hadn't happened yet.
He would have had a few skeletons in his closet, like Clinton did. And he seems kind of Shady. Like Clinton. But you just don't have a reason to outright hate the guy, and seems like he could get things done. So voters could begrudgingly accept that at the time.
And like Perot, he was a polarizing billionaire businessman. In either timeline, people didn't necessarily mind that, and since in this timeline, Perot's presidency was a successful one, it could have been a palatable transfer of power.
Trump, inaugurated in 2001, with a moderate, if not sometimes wacky platform, names both Democrats and Republicans to his cabinet. Attempting to appeal to both traditional parties, he's already thinking of re-election.
What happens from January 20th 2001 onwards? Especially since, in a way, we're dealing with a different version of Donald Trump. At least in the way he has to act.
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Training-World-1897 • Sep 19 '24
What if Obama picked Hillary picked for vp in 08?
Always wondered if Obama picked Hillary as his vp in 08 would that have helped her chances in winning in 2016 as she position herself as a 3rd Obama term as he left office with a approval rating above 50%?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/SpaceSteak • Nov 24 '12
What if organized religion had never taken off, and instead been replaced by Ancient Greece secular philosophy?
Let's look back thousands of years at the concept of organized religion and change the outcome of spiritual questions and organized religion. First, here are 3 important considerations we have to agree on:
Modern day organized religion is the evolution of tribal spiritual practices mixed with a group of people wanting political and social control.
Religious practices are based on the need to survive, as listening to elders as young humans and assuming what they say is true increased our chances of survival.
Somewhere along the lines, as we didn't have the real answers, some people created the concept of "gods" to explain the natural world and this helped to legitimatize what elders were saying, and this was passed on through the collective consciousness. This worldview beat out the reality-based worldview more than 2,000 years ago in Ancient Greece.
Ancient Greece is where the most interesting part of this Historical What-If happens. Certain philosophers like Aristotle were already developing a form of secular philosophy, but it did not manage to overcome the evolutionary power provided to religion.
If the Roman Empire and the rest of the Western World had been shaped by these philosophers' quest to understand our reality, instead of Christianity, Islam and organized religion in general, how would the next 2,000 years have played out?
Sub-questions to think about:
Would scientific development have happened much faster?
How would politics and borders been impacted?
Would the Roman Empire have existed without Christianity, if not, what would have spread instead?
Thank you for reading this, and I can't wait to see what possible outcomes you come up with.
4pm EST edit: I don't know which downvote brigade is hitting all the comments, but it's a sad day for rational debate. Meaningless internet points do not make the search for a better future based on truth irrelevant. Instead, it shows a disgusting anti-knowledge closed-mindedness. Fortunately, rationality is outdoing you this time.
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/TheMcWhopper • Oct 14 '17
[DBWI] What if the communists were successful in there takeover of mainland China? Would they be a world power? There relationship with the USSR
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/RandomKid1111 • Feb 25 '24
what if killing hitler would've made it worse?
let's make this an open-minded discussion. my question is probably flawed, but anyways i just had this shower thought -
Let's say hitler did not exist at all, this makes facism (edit: nacism) non-existent as well as ww2 not a thing...right? But wouldn't then communism spread even more and kill more people in labor camps, as well as cause a lot wider famines, etc. because of russia having no same-continent competitors - the only big one US being overseas, or britain/france being also kinda faraway, spreading communism not only to baltics or china/korea but potentially the US
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/anewworkapaulic • Feb 21 '25
What if the native american genocide didn’t happen and indigenous people lived side by side with settlers?
This is not genocide denial. I fully acknowledge the displacement and attempted eradication of native americans in the united states which extends far beyond andrew jackson.
I want to know how the united states today would be different if it engaged in a traditional form of conquest like most other societies in world history did (simple land grab, no settler colonialism).
This assumes that all 50 states are still part of america.
Would white supremacy still exist? Would white people still be the priviledged demographic? Would equality under the law still be a thing?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Advanced-Big6284 • Nov 01 '24
What If USA invaded Iran instead of Iraq in 2003.
Doesn't it make more sense for the US to invade Iran instead of Iraq, given that Iraq had a harsh relationship with the US since 1991, while the US has had hostilities with Iran since 1979 and were much harsher then Iraq? Iran also had a higher likelihood of having WMDs than Iraq.
How would it effect world
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Sep 10 '24
What if huge oil reserves were discovered in Mexico just 50 miles from the US?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/AirCJordan23 • Dec 02 '25
What if Europe never sought/allowed mass migration?
How would Europe be different, politically and demographically, if Western Europe had immigration policies like east Europe/east Asia, where mass migration of non European peoples never occurred?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • Apr 07 '13
What if there was a civil war in America during the 1960s?
.
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/maxwasson • Oct 14 '17
What if Megaupload was never shutdown in 2012?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/sexyloser1128 • Dec 25 '23
What if the United States invaded Canada during the Napoleonic Wars?
Seeing the British army preoccupied fighting Napoleon in Europe and the British navy preoccupied with blockading Europe and fighting the French navy, the US invades Canada with the aim of annexing it. You can also say the US also invades as an expression of Manifest Destiny (of uniting North America) and helping an ally (France helped the US achieve independence) and fighting their traditional enemy the British. Could they do it? And what would be the consequences?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/grapp • Jun 11 '13
what if something caused 99% of all humans within the borders of the soviet union in 1959, to drop dead?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Nimbo_Cumulus_ • Nov 18 '24
What if the UN decided to make the State of Holy land instead of dividing Israel and Palestine?
After negotiations and proposals by the Vatican City, Palestine in Israel, are United under the state of holy land It Main religion, Christianity
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Gigiolo1991 • Dec 25 '24
What if the Roman military fleet tried to conquer America ?
The Roman Empire, during its period of glory from the first century AD to the third century AD, had a very powerful military fleet that controlled the Mediterranean, with which it had pushed as far as Britain.
Would the technologies of the time have allowed them to cross the Atlantic Ocean and reach Central America towards the Americas?
How would a military clash between the Roman navy and its soldiers against the indigenous American populations of the Caribbean islands or more advanced peoples like the Maya and Inca have gone?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/bsmall0627 • Oct 10 '24
What if North Korea caused 9/11?
Instead if Al Qaeda causing the September 11th attacks, it’s North Korea. How will the world respond to the DPRK killing thousands of civilians in America?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Livid_Dig_9837 • Mar 20 '25
What if the Confederacy attempted genocide against black people during the American Civil War?
After Lincoln was re-elected, the Confederacy realized that its chances of winning were slim. Confederate leaders feared that if the North won, the slaves would be freed and would retaliate against them. So the Confederate government ordered the genocide of blacks in the southern states. The Confederate army, working with the people of the southern states, captured and executed blacks living in the southern states.
After the American Civil War ended, the number of black people living in the Southern states was only a few thousand. The Union Army found thousands of mass graves containing black bodies. It is estimated that hundreds of thousands of black people were massacred during the Civil War.
How will this affect American history?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Fancy-Advice-2793 • Jun 23 '25
How could Aboriginal Australia become a major power and avoid being colonized by the British?
That would be difficult because the Aboriginal people didn't have agriculture or animal husbandry and they couldn't craft bows because they preferred boomerangs.
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/1500Calories • Oct 03 '24
How would WW2 have ended if three years after it began, all major players produced nuclear weapons at the same time?
Let’s say The United States, The Soviet Union, the UK, Germany, Japan and Italy had nuclear weapons. Let’s say Allied had 40,000 nukes and Axis had 40,000 nukes.
EDIT: Both sides could drop the bombs anywhere they wanted
What I really meant was both sides have developed ballistic missiles, from short range to intercontinental range.
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/[deleted] • May 25 '24
What if Adolf Hitler was accepted into art school
Would the holocaust never be a thing if Hitler was an artist instead of a dictator?
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Yama951 • Feb 24 '18
What if Karl Marx's 'Religion is the opium of the people' line was written differenlty, like the 'tea of the people' instead?
The difference would be bigger than one line.
Like a paragraph detailing how tea calms and suppresses the fire of the people and how a new institution that stimulates than calms is needed for the world or something in that line of thought.
r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Gasmask_Guy_Who • Jan 04 '25
What if when Japan surrendered after the 1945 bombings, The US decided "Hey, what if we drop a third bomb anyway? Who's gonna stop us?"
Just an innocent question. I just wanted to know.