r/EDH • • Mar 04 '22

Discussion There's a guy at my local game store who watches way too much Game Knights and it's becoming a problem.

5.5k Upvotes

The problem is essentially that he talks and acts like he's on the show, eventhough the rest of us are just trying to have a chill game of magic. He always starts each game by exclaiming things like "The deck I built is Isshin, Two Heavens as One! The gameplan is to double up on attack triggers and run my opponents over with double the value and double the fun!"

And that's like, whatever. He's enthusiastic and delivers that like he's entering a yu-gi-oh battle but it doesn't stop there. He's constantly going "Nice!" "Ohh, that's spicy!" "Uh-oh!" and things like that in response to almost every card that gets played which starts to get irritating, but still, whatever, right? Shit gets weird, though.

He's become really disruptive in how he pretends to talk to a fake camera. He'll stare straight ahead of him and do commentary on the game and the thoughts he's having like "Man, this really put a wrench in my game plan. That Authority of the Consuls has been down for over 5 turns and is causing all of my creatures to enter tapped which means my haste is doing nothing and I'm short on blockers for all of the big damage coming from Mark's side of the board." It's just unsettling. He interrupts people to do this, too.

The most uncomfortable thing he does is at the end of the game when he dies he'll shout out "AND THEN I DIED TO.... (insert thing that killed him here)!" before he starts convulsing violently in his chair to pretend to be dying with his tongue sticking out. He'll just sit there like that until we finish the game.

I'm not sure if I should talk to him about it or what, but he seems to be having fun eventhough it's making the rest of us uncomfortable.


r/EDH • • Jul 22 '21

Meme Trouble with new ex-Yugioh player in playgroup

4.4k Upvotes

So, recently, my playgroup had a new guy join. We've known him for a little while, but he's never played MtG before. A few weeks ago, he asked about getting into MtG and so, naturally, we told him about EDH and said we'd love to help him get started.

With him being from Yugioh, we figured it'd be best for him if we, as a playgroup, work together to create a deck that feels familiar to Yugioh, to help him adjust. I've never played Yugioh before, so I was left out of this for the most part, but the other guys were able to create a deck they said was as 'faithful' as possible to Yugioh. Great! Right?

Wrong.

Aside from a few lucky games, he has been absolutely demolishing us. Like, his winrate is somewhere around 95% and I wish I was exaggerating. No matter what we try, no matter how we gang up on him, he stomps us every game. One game I got off to an amazing start. T1: [[Forest]], [[Sol Ring]], pass, T2: Forest, [[Skyshroud Claim]], [[Cultivate]]. Boom. It's the end of turn 2 and I'm feeling pretty good with 5 lands on the field and a Sol Ring. Pass turn, new guy goes and he swings at me with [[Dark Magician]] for 2500 damage. Personally, I think it's a little unfair Yugioh cards don't have mana costs, but again, I've never played the game so maybe there's something I'm missing.

One game, he played [[Blue Eyes White Dragon]] T1 and one guy responded with a [[Dark Ritual]] and [[Murder]], only to have it pointed out that Blue Eyes White Dragon is a monster not a creature. Another game, I managed to get an early [[Impervious Greatwurm]] out and use it to chump-block his [[Five-Headed Dragon]] (which doesn't have flying for some reason???), and then he mutates [[Gemrazer]] under it and at that point there's literally nothing I can do.

Does anyone know how we can level things out?


r/EDH • • Sep 23 '24 Popcorn Take My Silver Polished Silver Turd Heart of Silver

Discussion COMMANDER BANNED LIST UPDATE - SEPT. 23, 2024

4.1k Upvotes

Dockside Extortionist is banned

Jeweled Lotus is banned.

Mana Crypt is banned.

Nadu, Winged Wisdom is banned.

https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-banned-and-restricted-announcement-september-23-2024

https://mtgcommander.net/index.php/2024/09/23/september-2024-quarterly-update/

Some very interesting bans going out today—what are everyone's thoughts?


r/EDH • • May 29 '25

Social Interaction ...but she's a GIRL?!

4.0k Upvotes

Kind of gross interaction I had last night.

I'm at my LGS for commander night and I get paired up in my random pod-- me, a guy who I had played with a few times who I liked, some guy I had never played with, and some girl I had never played with.

Me and the two guys make it to the table first and sit down. Guy who I had never played with immediately starts trying to make it a game where we get to pick out his deck, neither of us are into it. The girl sits down in the last spot next to him, and he immediately shuts up, goes super shy, and just picks a deck. Went from super chatty to almost saying nothing the entire game other than announcing cards he's playing.

Game starts and it's looking like a decent game for the most part. Still high life totals, no clear winner yet. Girl is playing [[Syr Konrad, the Grim]] and not doing great but she's not exactly losing either. She has Konrad but not anything to do with him yet. It gets to her turn with Konrad still in play, drops a [[Cabal Coffers]], and then attempts to cast [[Morality Shift]]. There's a short table discussion where me and the guy I know say this is definitely going to end the game and we should do something about this. She even says that yeah, if that resolves the game is over.

We move in turn priority-

  • Shy guy, no blue mana open: "No responses."

  • Other guy: "I'm tapped out, nothing I can do."

  • Me: "I [[Swords to Plowshare's]] Konrad."

Shy guy perks up and says "wait what? She's a GIRL though!?" and the entire table and the two tables next to us just kind of stops and gives him a WTF look. After a short pause I jokingly say "well, in that case, I swords Konrad." He nervously laughs a little and proceeds to [[Flare of Denial]] my swords.

The whole table, again, looks at him in shock for a second but it happens. She casts Morality Shift, flips an Eldrazi, shuffles twice, and wins. Shy guy is basically all "sorry, not sorry" as we shuffle up for game two.

Game two shy guy pulls out his group hug deck and basically spends the entire game white knighting her. He's super confident now and trying to chat up the entire table and always commenting on her board state. It's super weird, she's uncomfortable, and there isn't a game three.

Kicker: The winner of game 1 gets $2 store credit which you can use on drinks/snacks. After we say no thanks to game 3, shy guy/white knight proudly says he won her the game and basically meant he bought her a drink. She laughed it off and basically looks like she couldn't leave the store fast enough.


r/EDH • • Jul 14 '22

Discussion Sold my deck to a kid yesterday

3.9k Upvotes

I was visiting a friend in a city a few hours away from my place and decided to hit up a card shop while I was around. There was this dad with his little girl playing in a pod that I joined because they needed a 4th. I made a shoebox [[Minsc & Boo, Timeless Heroes]] deck after I bought a commander legends box.

The little girl (I'd say she was around 10ish) really liked that I made a hamster to fight with and kept laughing when I said "I'll throw a hamster at your face" and "go for the eyes boo!" I won since it was a pretty low power table, and Minsc & Boo gives you a lot of card advantage if it isn't stopped.

After the game the girl said she really likes my deck and asked her dad if he would help her build one like mine, so he just asked me point-blank if I'd be willing to sell. I told him my deck was worth about $100 bucks, he said he only had $60 on him, but if I wait he'd go to an ATM. I told him $60 was fine because it was enough to recoup the cards I'd want to keep and pay for the satin tower.

So now a little girl got a hamster deck, a father got a deal, and I got a warm fuzzy from helping a dad and a daughter enjoy this game more.

Edit: thanks for the support everyone, glad everyone enjoyed reading the story as much as I loved living it. Here's the deck in question in case people want to see it.https://www.moxfield.com/decks/gJICiiwKbEO6YEByqT8Llw


r/EDH • • Jun 07 '23

Discussion I’m personally offering a bid of $0.00 for the serialized copy of The One Ring.

3.9k Upvotes

But me and my friend will walk up and throw it in a volcano.

Pros: We are pretty small and will escape notice if anyone else wants it.

My moral fiber is pretty good, but my friends is even better. If I try and keep it, he’s gonna keep me in check.

We are pretty good cooks so as long as we have food, our moral will stay high.

We basically have nothing better to do.

Cons:

We are pretty small so there’s some things that are hard for us.

I’m fully anticipating Post Malone to follow us around, but I’ve got a good feeling about his company.

If Cassius Marsh captures us and takes us to his waterfall hideout, I think we can talk him in to letting us go.


r/EDH • • Sep 26 '24

Discussion Honestly, I'm disappointed

3.7k Upvotes

I've played magic for longer then over half my life and with that I've played in many formats where a banning has happened. The way most of you have acted is actually insane. You would think your life was ruined. That something so devastating happened you can't recover from it. The fact that many of you went out of your way to attack people on the Commander Advisory Group, is crazy. Even attacking others on Twitter. Especially when one of those members where more on your side then you thought. I thought the community would respond better then it has. Honestly, I'm disappointed.


r/EDH • • May 02 '25

Social Interaction Something incredible happened at my LGS tonight.

3.3k Upvotes

Some context. My LGS has a "jank week" where people are encouraged to bring lower power silly decks. Usually it's a mix of silver bordered decks and bracked 1-2 nonsense. I and my friend joined a pod of 3 with my [[Nicol Bolas]] wheel deck and his [[Alexander Clamilton]] goad deck. The pod of three was a boyfriend and girlfriend (both regulars) and the guy's younger cousin, maybe about 15. Hard to tell with those kids. The boyfriend is playing what he described as "Frankie Peanuts Combo," and the girlfriend a deck based on lyrics to some obscure band. The kid is playing a weird [[Truss, Chief Engineer]] control deck.

So anyways, we roll to start our game and get playing. The boyfriend tutors for a [[Staying Power]] and gets out a little book to record the yes or no decisions. I've played against this deck before, and it's awful without the enchantment and still only okay with it. Everyone else is getting into the swing of things, it's been a decent game. We get to maybe turn seven or eight and the guy starts his turn. He has one person pretty trapped with Frankie Peanuts and we're anxiously awaiting what happens next. Dude says he needs to get a token out of his backpack, and says to his girlfriend "for my peanuts trigger, with Staying Power out, I ask 'will you marry me?'" and slams a ring on the table. (We find out later he had rigged his deck for the combo and was using marked sleeves, I don't think anyone really cared.)

She's of course freaking out, the table is smiling, etc. Then the kid goes "In response, I tap 3 for [[disallow]] on the Frankie Peanuts trigger." Absolute silence for several seconds before the whole table breaks out laughing.

They're engaged now. I don't think I'll ever forget that particular counterspell.


r/EDH • • Sep 24 '25 Helpful

Social Interaction First actual bad experience at the LGS. Why is politics in everything.

3.2k Upvotes

I also have to ask, i know Jack is a straight up ass hole. But am i also the AH in this situation?

I've been playing magic since Beta and Unlimited packs were on the store shelves still. I took a long break during college and my 20's but came back about 10 years ago. While I've had my fair share of annoying people or people with a chip on their shoulder I wouldn't consider any of them truly negative till yesterday.

I bounce around to a few stores throughout the week but this happened at the main store i normally play at. I'm sitting down with someone i normally play with. Were friends in the sense we like to play together but not like "come over to my house or hang out" type of friends outside of the store. This persons name is Sky and she is trans.

Were waiting for others, a new player sits down with us then a few minutes later another player I've seen a few times sits down to be our forth. Well call them Jill and Jack. While the game was nothing special just a normal battle cruiser game what Jack did was beyond anything I've ever experienced from anyone while playing magic.

Jack easily had 100+ power on the board with trample and haste. Nothing any of us could do about it. Jack starts looking at life totals and its clear that two of us are dead but one person will remain as he does not have enough to get all of us.

Jack starts his "Humm who should i kill" He's looking at what we have and board state then it happens he looks at me and is like "Who did you vote for?"

Me: "What's that have to do with anything? Just attack who you think is the biggest threat."

Jack: "Nah, I'm definitely going to attack you and He surely didn't vote for trump since he's one of them so ill attack him too" (Referring to Sky)

Right after that i could see how uncomfortable Sky was, the new player is kind of just looking at the floor like "WTF did i just hear" and I'm still trying to pick my jaw up off the table for what i just heard.

I went off on the guy. I tell him to STFU and that shit is not cool or welcome here. I'm straight up yelling at the guy to pack his shit up and GTFO. Thankfully other tables heard what he said and it was clear to him he had no others who were going to back him up on his BS. I'm bitching him out the whole time he's putting his stuff away. The LGS owner came over to see what was going on. Jack wouldn't explain anything to the owner and i was so heated at this point i couldn't do anything other than continuing to tell Jack to GTFO.

I've never seen someone pack up so quickly. He grabbed his stuff and was gone in under a minute. I did calm down and explain everything to the owner. Jack will never be allowed back but i also got a warning after from the owner to just bring things like that to him and he'll take care of it. I apologized to him and the people that were playing last night.

We finished the game as if Jack never existed. Jill rolled us both with an unstoppable flying army of 1/1 fairy tokens buffed to 10/10's.

Edit: Thanks everyone for your kind words. I don't tolerate that BS and I'll be sure if it ever happens again at the table to handle it a bit better rather than possibly ruining other peoples night's by yelling.


r/EDH • • Jun 28 '21

Discussion Made a Pubstomper Rage quit today.

3.1k Upvotes

This guy joins our spelltable and wants to play Kenrith. The rest of the table groans a bit and he says that he promises that the deck is casual. He turn one: Volcanic Island, Mana Crypt, Trinisphere. Turn two plays Sphere of Resistance. I end up getting locked out of the game until turn five or six. Towards the end of the game one of the other players has a token army of like 13 3/3 flyers that he makes unblockable. The pubstomper does trys to reanimate Elesh Norn to get rid of the flyers (they were only 3/3 because of an anthem enchantment). I stop the Elesh Norn because I wasn't worried about the flyers because I had a way of dealing with them that didn't involve Elesh Norn and I was going to win on my next turn. He just rage quits without saying anything. His Mana Base alone was easily worth $5k. Casual my ass


r/EDH • • Jan 21 '20

DISCUSSION /r/CompetitiveEDH Needs YOUR Help /r/EDH!!!

2.9k Upvotes

Hi /r/EDH! I come in peace! I'm here because I think /r/CompetitiveEDH very much needs your voice. Ours feels often mute and lost on the committee! Please, take a second and read.

With the new set, a brand new card has been printed that entirely busts the cEDH format. That card, is [[Thassa's Oracle]]

Now I need to be clear here: This new card, isn't inherently the unfair thing. This card is cool! It's one mana less Labman, it's ETB instead of a static effect, it has utility when played not as a dead card. It's a cool card! We like this card! The problem with this card is what it does in cEDH when paired with the most broken and unfair thing you can do in EDH (and maybe Magic?) - Flash+Hulk.

For those of you who don't know - a card called [[Flash]] exists. It almost NEVER sees play in casual EDH, please look at the statistics. When it does see play in casual EDH, it almost exclusively sees play to bring out the card [[Protean Hulk]], an insanely powerful card that was, up until recently, banned in EDH. It's banned because it's a multiple card put into play not into hand tutor effect. So unfortunately, because this card combo exists, for 1 generic and 1 blue mana, you may, at instant speed, cast Flash (during anyone's turn), bring out Protean Hulk, NOT pay it's cost, and let Hulk die. Once it does, there are many, MANY ways Protean Hulk tutors a win on the spot combo. Each way avoids different board or spell interactions, making it absolutely impossible to know what needs to be stopped and how.

Okay cool, Flash Hulk's existed for awhile now. But why bring it up to you guys now? Okay so here's the cEDH meta prior to this card release:

Tier 0: Flash Hulk, usually with Thrasios and Tymna as commanders Tier 0.5: Decks that utilize cards like [[Demonic Consultation]] and [[Tainted Pact]] as an immediate way to deck your entire library very quickly and either win with an infinite combo they tutored or with a labman like effect (hey thanks for printing new jace! Now you don't even need a draw trigger!). Some Isochron Scepter + Dramatic Reversal nonsense is always good. Tier 1: Good decks (Gitrog Dredge, Najeela tempo, Food Chain Stuff) Tier 2: Everything else.

With Tier 0 being far from tier 0.5 and 0.5 being way better than tier 1.

But this new card makes the two top decks, Consultation decks and Flash Hulk decks, the SAME deck. Let me say that again - take the best deck in cEDH, combine it with the 2nd best deck in cEDH, make the deck even faster, even more consistent, even harder to disrupt, and you now have this new abomination deck.

What are the ramifications for this? You either should play this new deck (Now called either Fish Hulk or Sushi Hulk), or accept you're playing a worse deck than you could've. This is awful. People who have spent their free time for years enjoying cEDH with their favorite decks like Godo, Bandit Lord or Yisan the Wandering Bard or whoever have actually quit playing magic. My fiancee, a Captain Sisay pilot prior to the paradox engine ban, has zero interest in trying to stay relevant now.

Most importantly, because this is what's most important to you guys and the rules committee: This isn't FUN. Flash hulk isn't FUN. The fact that any player can win the game with 2 mana at instant speed (on top of anyone else's win condition) with ZERO board state isn't fun. It's objectively a better combo than any other combo in all of EDH.

Animate Dead + Worldgorger Dragon? You need to telegraph the situation. You need to place WGD into the Graveyard. You need to cast a sorcery spell to reanimate it.

Isochron Scepter + Dramatic Reversal? You need to hard cast the 2 mana artifact, it needs to resolve, you need it to stay on the board, you need 2 more mana to activate it, casting it is at sorcery speed, you need permanents that tap on the field for at least 3 mana, you need it to produce colored mana if you don't have your commander out.

Gitrog Monster + Discard Outlet + Dakmore Salvage? You need a 5 mana commander out on the field, you need another creature card out on the field, you need to have access to your shuffler effects in your deck like Ulamog without them being exiled.

This isn't a 5 mana commander and a 2 mana discard outlet existing at sorcery speed with a specific land in hand to win on your own turn. This is a 2 mana INSTANT speed win that requires ZERO board presence that can happen on anyone's turn. In fact, you can actually win with this combo on Turn 0! What does that even mean? Win on turn 0? It means - imagine you haven't even drawn your first card yet. Imagine your 3rd in turn order and the first player is going to his draw step. Imagine winning THEN. That's how fast you can win with Flash Hulk. And now it's also a demonic consultation deck. That's what it means.

It's not fun.

Okay cool so what can you guys do? What small concession am I asking for /r/EDH to make happen?

Help us be heard. Help us BAN FLASH. Why? Because it's SUPER UNFUN and BREAKS cEDH and because it will NOT impact casual EDH.

Why is this a good solution?

  1. Protean Hulk himself is a neato burrito card. You guys like him. Sometimes as a value engine. Sometimes as a reanimator card. Sometimes as a sick green card. We like him! We think he's cool if you're casting him from say your graveyard with an entomb and a reanimation effect. Maybe a sac outlet. That's cool! He's cool! He's something you want to keep!

  2. Thassa's Oracle itself is pretty cool! You guys probably want to try it out. Maybe get a sick devotion blue mill thing going. It's fun. We can use Thassa too, for OP stuff but fun stuff that we can interact with. Consultation decks are a lot easier to interact with than Hulk decks. We're down to clown with it!

  3. Flash is awful. Casual players do not play Flash. It's seen in https://edhrec.com/cards/flash 2% of all decks with an 86% include rate for specifically Protean Hulk. Will it hurt Casuals format to have this card removed? Very very very marginally. Some people like to flash in academy rector to put Omniscience into play. That's about it. Is that particularly fun for you guys either? Probably not.

But the thing is, we're not a huge community. We need help. Specifically, we need your guys help. We want to continue to help promote good fun EDH with rule zero. We are NOT pubstompers. We do not want to flash hulks in on your chair tribal decks or your elf balls or your super sick sweet goblins. In fact, most of us own decks like that and enjoy them too. The very first thing I did when the new commander decks came out was draw sunglasses on my Rhino tokens and made as many damn rhinos as I could with the precons. We ask you please let us keep having fun and help have our voice heard.

Please, upvote this. Spread the word. Reach out to Sheldon. Tell them that it isn't fair. Tell them it isn't balanced. Tell them it's making so many people QUIT magic all together. But most importantly - tell the world Flash isn't fun.

Thanks /r/EDH

Edit 1 Because people are asking, here is a prototype list of Sushi Hulk by one of the greatest brewers, ShaperSavant: https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/fish-hulk/

Also because people are asking, here is a sample one of many ways Flash + Hulk wins the game:

Cast [[Flash]] for 1U, targeting [[Protean Hulk]]. Hulk will die on not paying the additional cost. When Protean Hulk dies, it will tutor AND put into play [[Nomads en-Kor]] + [[Cephalid Illusionist]] ++ [[Thassa's Oracle]]. Now, you may want to cast an instant speed interaction spell. Perhaps creature removal? It won't matter, it's too late now that Flash resolved. In response to you attempting to stop them, Nomads en-Kor will at instant speed target Cephalid Illusionist a few hundred times, milling your entire deck. Now, Thassa's Oracle is an ENTER THE BATTLEFIELD effect, so it dying won't matter. Even if it's dead, and your devotion to blue is ZERO, your "devotion is greater than or equal to library" trigger will occur, and you'll win the game. This is the "Breakfest Hulk" combo.

However, this merges also well with another Hulk Pile in the SAME deck. Instead, if you've already drawn one of those cards, you can grab [[Spellseeker]] + [[Thassa's Oracle]] + [[Blood Pet]]. When spellseeker enters the battlefield, you can find [[Demonic Consultation]] naming any card. Let's say [[Earl of Squirrel]]. Now, blood pet can sacrifice himself to give you the one black mana to cast DC at instant speed. You will now exile your entire library since obviously you don't run our favorite Earl, and THEN Resolve Thassa's Oracle (even if she's dead), and win the game.


Lastly, I just want to say thank you guys so much for showing interest and care in this thread. I hope we can change the committee's view on this card and feel like our voices are heard. You've made this commander feel very special tonight.


r/EDH • • Mar 11 '23

Discussion TCGplayer workers have won their union despite illegal union busting from Ebay

2.9k Upvotes

I posted a few weeks ago about the illegal union busting that TCGplayer and Ebay have done during the run up to the election for a union to form.

This is the first union inside Ebay which is likely a part of why they pushed back against it so hard.

I'm happy to see this for the folks that make keeping my decks up to date easy.

https://twitter.com/TCGunionCWA/status/1634386233752182784?t=Prq2fcVD0-NI3pxJ-v53SQ&s=19

For those of you without a background in unions, now that they have won recognition for their union the workers will decide on their priorities and begin the process of collectively bargaining with their employer.


r/EDH • • Sep 28 '20

Discussion Should the RC ban the walking dead cards?

2.6k Upvotes

I am genuinely interested in people's thoughts on this, I want to know what the edh community think about them.

I don't want to make this post about my views but, full disclosure, I do think they should go unless wotc announces in universe reprints with appropriate art/names in booster packs. I think wotc selling us new singles directly at a premium is a dangerous thing and any card produced this way should be treated as silver boarderd.

EDIT: Sheldon confirmed on rules committee discord there will be no preemptive banning

I employee you all to join and voice your concerns to Sheldon on the Discord's ban announcement group

https://discord.gg/WaeyNF

Edit 2 electric boogaloo: Please vote in this poll if you can https://www.strawpoll.me/21015634/r


r/EDH • • May 28 '25

Discussion Boycott TCGPlayer for their union busting. Again.

2.6k Upvotes

This isn't the first time they've pull this shit, and I'm sure it won't be the last. All we can do is take our bussiness elsewhere. I will, and I advocate for you all to do the same.

https://cwa-union.org/news/releases/ebay-escalates-intimidation-union-members-after-closure-announcement


r/EDH • • Sep 24 '24

Discussion PSA: Magic is not an investment vehicle NSFW

2.6k Upvotes

Just a reminder that Magic is not an investment vehicle like stocks, index funds, ETFs, and crypto

I don't know why this needs to be stated, but it does.

Too many people see it as a financial investment and it's weird, it's a hobby just like woodworking is a hobby. You might "invest" in some tools for those hobbies, but a sane person's primary purpose is the enjoyment of said hobby, not turning a profit.

Does anyone else feel this way? It just seems so weird to me to see people touting Magic as some sort of investment and not a hobby that they enjoy


r/EDH • • Nov 11 '25 Thanks

Discussion My gift to r/EDH. Online EDH multiplayer that doesn't suck

2.6k Upvotes

Online EDH has always kind of been hard to play and there are several choices but all of them have tradeoffs and kinda suck in their own way. I made Aura for me and my friends as a no-tradeoffs app but we've since stopped playing and I thought it'd be a shame to let this just die.

It's a web app just like untap, except it's built different so it doesn't lag and never will. It doesn't want your personal discord. It's sleeker than xmage or forge, and requires no download or account. I suppose the only thing is that it doesn't work on mobile yet.

Because of how it's built, it costs me no money to host regardless of traffic so it'll always be free. Cards are imported from Scryfall.

If you guys like it, I'd be down to build in a public game list and a few other features that it's missing. I'd also be willing to open source it for the community since I'll probably stop maintaining this eventually.

The easiest way to demo it without friends is to open two windows, one incognito, and copy paste the same URL with matching room ID.

Edit: I made a Discord for bugs, features, finding a game, and development help

Edit: We're on GitHub now! Check out the Discord if you want to help. Even if you don't code, helping us with feedback and suggestions is still incredible, so come by and tell us your ideas. Also, I will probably need someone to help me set up Discord plugins lol


r/EDH • • 17d ago

Discussion I broke up with my boyfriend because he plays fewer than 38 lands

2.6k Upvotes

I mean, it wasn't just that. He also mana weaves. And he dismissed me when I told him, after he got angry about losing a second game in a row to mana screw, that there was some solid math suggesting he might be happier if he pushed a bit closer to where the hypergeometric curve flattens out.

The real problem was that this turned out to be reflected in the way he handled more important things. But not running enough lands was an early warning sign …

I think that maybe it's like Seraph said in one of the Matrix movies: "You do not truly know someone until you fight them."

I've had multiple people point out that I can't just go starting kung fu battles with anyone I want to date or befriend. (Le sigh.) But maybe playing a game of Magic with someone is a sufficient test of character?

I'm not saying that I'd never date someone who ran a cool 36 in their Bracket 3 pile. But they'd have to have a sense of grace and humor about it, y'know? Like it's cute if someone is a bit of a fool, but not cute if they can't own up to it. Who knows what else they won’t be able to own up to?


r/EDH • • Jan 20 '26 Bravo

Discussion The sooner you see Commander is Mario Party, you’ll stop being salty and have more fun.

2.6k Upvotes

After a few years of playing this game (especially after the addition of the bracket system), I’ve noticed a lot of salt comes from one general place. People expect Commander games to largely be even with everyone doing their thing and having a real chance to win any given game like you would in chess. Commander is not a perfectly fair, symmetrical game like chess. Commander is Mario Party.

Chess: Identical starting pieces, full game state visible to both players at all times, losing means you misplayed either situationally or just objectively

Commander: Wildly different ways decks match up in games, variance is unavoidable and wild (people seem to be unable to grasp this one the most), politics and preconceived notions play a factor, and SO many variables that can change the game

That isn’t a bug. It’s the format lol. Don’t get pissy when someone gets free bonus stars at the end of the game and beats you.


r/EDH • • Aug 12 '26

Social Interaction "So are you going to follow the rules?" "Dude, I don't care"

2.6k Upvotes

I had the weirdest interaction today.

One player was playing [[Flubs, the fool]], it doesn't matter what the rest of the table was playing for this story.

So he's doing the thing all Flubs players do and taking a gazzillion game actions to maybe flip into one that finally matters.

At one point he says "I cast [[Noxious revival]] putting Card Y (can't even remember what it was) on top of my library and I draw it with Flubs, then..." at this point I cut him off by pointing out that's not how it works because the draw trigger from Flubs would happen before his card was put on top.

I shit you not, he deadpan goes "Dude, I don't care" and tried to move on. I interject again saying "You cannot do that, you are literally breaking the rules. If we're not following the rules I might as well dump my hand on the board without paying for my cards".

I look at the other two players in the pod as they are silent, asking "Are you guys really okay with just letting this guy break the rules?" and they just shrugged.

I asked him one more time "So you're really just going to break the rules?" and when he kept playing, I just cleaned my board and told everyone this wasn't worth my time.

Randoms gonna random.

Edit: It has been brought to my attention that a shitpost about this story has been made "from the other player's perspective". People are taking the bait hook, line, and sinker.


r/EDH • • Aug 10 '26

Deck Showcase I have created the greatest EDH deck of all time. Move over men in chairs, or characters looking to the left. It's time for Goatse tribal. NSFW

2.5k Upvotes

After spending like two straight weeks with Taco Bell lettuce parasite diarrhea I wanted to celebrate with something thematic.

https://moxfield.com/decks/vNCxqzx7L0ODOGgDb32bDw

Every single card in this deck resembles a man using both hands to spread his butthole either directly or abstract.

I initially went to Google to find card ideas but found maybe 6-7 results. By random chance I noticed [[Embrace Oblivion]] not mentioned by Google / Reddit and wondered what else has the internet missed? So I loaded up a scryfall unique art search and over 3 days of anal hell searched through over 50,000 images. Worth it? Absolutely not what the fuck was I thinking.

Hopefully no one enjoys this. What a terrible way to spend a weekend. 👊 🕳 👊

Lands are currently 36 city of ass because it's funny but eventually I will crawl back into scryfall to finish this nightmare.

Jodah is the commander because... well look at the art. However Garth One-Eye is a good porn name for a country music singer and is much more useful than Jodah in this deck.


r/EDH • • Sep 30 '24

MEGATHREAD WOTC article: On the Future of Commander

2.5k Upvotes

https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/on-the-future-of-commander

So today, in partnership with members of the existing Rules Committee, we are announcing that the Rules Committee is giving management of the Commander format to the game design team of Wizards of the Coast.

We have opened a new Discord channel on the official Magic Discord (in the #Commander_News channel) and will also have a WeeklyMTG stream talking about this tomorrow, October 1, at 10 a.m. PT on Twitch.tv/Magic.

We will also be evaluating the current banned card list alongside both the Commander Rules Committee and the community. We will not ban additional cards as part of this evaluation. While discussion of the banned list started this, immediate changes to the list are not our priority.

They are also working on new guidelines for the powerlevel of commander decks.

Here's the idea: There are four power brackets, and every Commander deck can be placed in one of those brackets by examining the cards and combinations in your deck and comparing them to lists we'll need community help to create. You can imagine bracket one is the baseline of an average preconstructed deck or below and bracket four is high power. 
For example, you could imagine bracket one has cards that easily can go in any deck, like Swords to Plowshares, Grave Titan, and Cultivate, whereas bracket four would have cards like Vampiric Tutor, Armageddon, and Grim Monolith, cards that make games too much more consistent, lopsided, or fast than the average deck can engage with.

Edit: Official discord https://discord.com/invite/wizards-magic

Edit2: Jim Lapage's letter https://x.com/JimTSF/status/1840783966926000255

Edit3: Toby Ellioet's comments https://x.com/tobyelliott/status/1840784261445546203


r/EDH • • Jul 27 '19

DISCUSSION Mark Rosewater is asking if Commander players would be interested in a booster product specifically targeted for Commander players.

2.5k Upvotes

Today Mark Rosewater asked on his blog if Commander/Brawl players would be interested in a booster product specifically targeted for Commander players.

How do you feel about this idea? If you support the idea, explain your reasoning. If you aren't a fan, explain why you are opposed.

For reference, here is the full quote for context:

nerd-in-glasses asked: Given that boosters sell better than decks, do you think WotC will ever make a booster product targeted specifically at Commander players?

Mark Rosewater answered: Is that something you all (well, those of you that are Commander/Brawl players) would like?


r/EDH • • Oct 13 '20

Discussion I think I'm tired of WotC designing specifically for EDH

2.5k Upvotes

I know this is probably an unpopular position and before "the year of commander" I would've thought I was crazy for saying this, but I think I liked things a lot better when we just got one product a year.

I really enjoyed when I could look at a set and try to find the cards that were edh viable hidden in the rough. Now I feel like wotc isn't content just making overpowered things for standard and that power is encroaching onto Commander. If not overpowered, just look at the fiasco with the Walking Dead cards and all the tension that has caused.

The commander format being something on the side of other formats was something I never valued until this year. I feel like the steady stream of edh viable cards that we used to have coming to us in standard and other sets was just the right amount, and then we'd have commander christmas with the commander sets which always felt so special. Now we're getting so much product thrown at us it's hard to keep up with even remembering what's out there, much less actually getting my hands on those cards.

Anyway, I never thought I would say this, but WotC, please pay a little less attention to us.
In my opinion, it's better for the format overall.


r/EDH • • Feb 17 '26 Wholesome Seal

Discussion “You can’t target that, it has hexproof”

2.4k Upvotes

STORY TIME!!!

A while back I was playing a game on spelltable where one of the players was absolutely dominating the table with a clue deck where he managed to assemble a massive board with hexproof (I don’t remember how) and had a TON of clues + a [[Shimmer Dragon]]. The only thing preventing him from winning on the spot was his low life total and my [[Razorkin Needlehead]].

He goes to cast swords on my Razorkin and I happen to have a [[Misdirection]] so I cast it targeting swords. The next part played out like a fuckn movie

Clue player: “target?”

Me: “swords”

Clue player: “no what’s the new target for swords?”

Me: “is it resolving?”

Clue player: “you have to pick targets before I can respond”

Me: “I don’t have to pick the new target until it resolves, the target for misdirection is swords”

He thinks for a bit and decides that his board is untouchable because of hexproof and says fuck it, it resolves and I said the new target is shimmer dragon. He and the rest of the table remind me that it has hexproof.

So I said “I know. I’m not targeting shimmer dragon. YOU are targeting shimmer dragon with your spell”

Bro proceeds to have a meltdown and says “let me read that card again” and then after reading it basically yells “YEAH DUDE YOU HAVE TO PICK THE TARGET ON CAST I WOULD HAVE DONE THINGS DIFFERENTLY” and I had to show him the gatherer ruling where it said the new target isn’t picked until after it resolves. Before the meltdown I was just doing what I had to do, but after the meltdown down I was lowkey enjoying how it went down.

Ultimately it wasn’t enough to stop him and he ended up winning the game in a few turns but it still made for a memorable experience