r/EDH • • Nov 17 '24

Discussion Please stop calling Teysa Karlov's ability a "deatharmonicon"

16 Upvotes

I'm so fed up.
I can't take it.
"Necronomicon", it's right there.
It is right there.
It rolls off the tongue so much easier, and it oozes flavor.
Everything from the flavor to the influence of the word is right there.

It's as if a myriad gods worked a centennial eras to embroider a perfect dish, seasoned with saffron and sea salt wrenched from the pacific's most fearsome depths, have fallen in your lap. You stare, the smell inundates your every sense, causing palpable tremors to run even down your calves.
And then you call up a buddy and hit up a Denny's instead.
"Deatharmonicon" you absolute larvae. You stare at the entryway of a cocoon to greatness, and you choose instead to wrap yourself in lubricant and your collection of McDonalds ketchup packets.
"Necronomicon" is so flavorful. It sits upon you with a delectable taste, harking back to the macabre and the unknown, so perfectly enrapturing the flavor of Orzhov.

I'm bereft of tears. I've cried them all. You bring me no joy, no mercy or hope left in the pandora's box that are your Landfall triggers. You play the Forest, and I weep. You play the Island, and I weep. Aesi looks me in the eyes. I look back. All I see is wrongful flavor nicknames. She cries with me. She understands. She feels my pain. She, too, wants you to stop.
I look at my library. The pod is looking at me. I've been absent for 20 minutes, halfway through a Pitiless Plunderer + Reassembling Skeleton combo. I have no Artist effect. I am simply going infinite. In the infinity I see the spiral, with a cacophony of children's voices humming in the background in a low pitch. They range anywhere from delirious to beautiful, waking in me both awe and fear. I am afraid. "How many treasures do you stop at?", asks the Rakdos player. She is watching me with glee, drawing pleasure from my pain. I scroll yet another Reddit thread and find you dredging up the painfully ignorant coined term.

I scoop.

Please stop.


r/EDH • • Sep 26 '24

Discussion Counterpoint: cEDH Doesn't Need to be Separated. Casuals Do.

0 Upvotes

TLDR at the bottom.

I have been playing EDH since before precons existed. I am not sure when the attitude shifted, but the rhetoric and decisions I've seen in these threads that get applauded is absolutely wild to me. "I don't play against theft, MLD, board wipes, etc..." or "I just didn't feel like finishing because I couldn't win" is, in my opinion, a sign that maybe you just don't like Magic. Which is fine, however Commander being a "Casual" format is not an excuse to refuse to play when you agreed to.

cEDH existed back then, and so did pub stompers. The idea of Rule 0 existed excepted we called it "Talking to each other." The difference was more of a "I go fast/slow", "I have proxies", "I have this silver border card in my deck", "I'm doing Wrath tribal/MLD/chaos/STAX" These weren't invitations to crap on each other or alienate. Unless you had to be somewhere in under two hours you shuffled up, and started. Or you'd say "Do you mind switching" or "This is the only game I'm gonna play against that." I can't believe the amount of trash people are talking about JLK saying he was against all of these bans. CZ has gone a little off the rails, but JLK and Jimmy have done so much for this game.

Wizards have been pumping product down our throats trying to snare any and all players into one of the most challenging styles of gameplay, and it makes sense that it's a daunting task for a new player to take on. I still can't believe how they hosed Dr. Who fans with the most convoluted decks. Back then when I started with [[Stonebrow, Krosan Hero]] I was a TO, and someone criticized me for not knowing all of the cards. Regardless we were getting less than half of the cards currently being printed, and it was still challenging to keep up.

In the current state of the game it's easy to feel like you're missing out, or feeling like you're failing to optimize. Even budget decks can be broken. The fact that they've printed Eminence on a commander last year shows, that Wizards isn't power creeping, they're power leaping (Yes, I'm proud of that). All that to say what would Rookie EDH (REDH) look like? EDHRec puts all that work into the Salt scores so no cards with salt >1.5? I personally hate the salt scores, and the fact that EDHRec and Command Zone have been putting these videos out basically saying "If you play these cards at your LGS you're going to have a bad time." Know I, as an entrenched player, know that's not true. As a new player, that feels like such an ominous warning where most LGS players are decent humans.

TLDR; Instead of separating the player base that has the minimum amount of restrictions from the format, provide an easy mode for newer more casual players.


r/EDH • • Mar 17 '23

Discussion Commander might not be the format for you.

172 Upvotes

Seems like it's that time of year again - when someone from the RC writes a blog post drumming up discussion and every armchair format designer on Reddit comes out of the woodwork to tell them how *their* personal vision for commander should be the one on which the whole show is run. Inevitably this leads to countless posts from folks who want to turn EDH into a rotating format by means of an expansive and consistently amended ban list, or fundamentally alter its rules - like the hybrid mana crowd, or any number of other identity altering (and usually bad) suggestions.

To anyone who may have expressed these kinds of ideas, here's something you might not want to hear: Commander might not be the format for you. I get it, it's become the single most played format in the community over the past 5 years, so it's hard to get away from. Maybe your friends only play EDH, so you felt you had no other option. Maybe competitive play completely died out at your local shop and so commander is how you keep playing Magic. If that's the case - that's fine! But please stop coming into this format and demanding it's changed into something else.

Commander is in a perfectly healthy place right now. You know what would hurt it? Stripping away the elements that make it unique. Making it not commander.


r/EDH • • Nov 27 '22

Social Interaction To the MTG Community

37 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/uQkhcWoY73w

What's up everyone! I made a video to take the time to apologize to the community for that awfulness that went down last year on my behalf. I'm truly sorry for anyone I put through anything and I'm here trying to make it right. I took a long time to respond because I wanted to show true growth as a human being. But enough from me, I'll let you watch the video for yourself. Thank you for hearing me out.


r/EDH • • Jul 12 '23

Social Interaction Excluding the 100%-proxied-deck gamers from my groups has made for a better experience for the rest of our players

50 Upvotes

Let me get the obvious "well not all proxy gamers blah blah" out of the way, but I've yet to meet a proxy gamer I would continue to play with on a regular basis. Why? Well...

  • So far they've had zero awareness to how their deck power functions in relation to the table, especially when playing with collectors.

  • Theres always been a shift in philosophy from "proxying only extras of what I already have" when they join the group to all of their decks having full suites of the best fast mana, nonbasic lands and tutors as time goes on. Theres no creativity or soul to these decks when theres no limits, monetary or otherwise, on deckbuilding.

  • The custom art is an absolute nightmare when it comes to tracking the boardstate in a 4 person game. All of the offcial variants of cards hitting the market is already enough without having to parse whether the Marvel Iron Man im staring at across the table is an Urza Lord High Artificer or a Blightsteel Colossus

  • Most of all, myself and the other players in the group who collect just don't find much common ground when talking about the game with the "printer go brr" crowd.

All in all I'm not trying to take a moral high ground here and say proxy players are awful people. I really just wanted to share my experience so far and spur discussion since all I tend to see on here is nearly all unanimoualy pro-proxy. Thanks for reading and I'll see all you MPC customers at the next LGS prerelease.

EDIT: Wow, lots of responses, thanks to everyone for chiming in.

To clarify, a lot of replies glossed over the fact that it was full-proxy players only who were no longer welcome. I thought that was clear in the post title, in the body of text and my replies but some still misunderstood.

We have and continue to welcome new and inexperienced players and players who are budget conscious, and the more entrenched players in the group are always willing to help build out their collections. We'll adjust our playstyle to match whoever in the group shows up to game night.

To those who think im being a bit of a prick about full-proxy players I direct you to some of the more aggresive proxy defenders and counterfeit users in the thread who are not-so-subtly inferring that they'll take their counterfeits to sanctioned events and "you'll never know". It only strengthens my stance that I'll never want to play with a full-proxy gamer again.


r/EDH • • Nov 16 '21

Question What to do with rude players

0 Upvotes

I am what you refer as a “random person” lol

For example, I will often randomly moo in the middle of a game and do a disco gesture when I cast a good spell etc. However, players don’t appreciate my harmless quirks and can be rude. I am very sensitive - what should I do?


r/EDH • • Jun 24 '24

Social Interaction Inappropriate Playmats and Gear Need to Stop...

0 Upvotes

Story Time.

My partner and I were playing EDH at our local store this weekend and played with someone who had a scantily clad woman on their playmat. The woman wasn't showing anything that would be considered porn, but it was definitely an R-rated image. This deeply upset my partner after the games, making the overall experience super uncomfortable and awkward.

This needs to stop. Officially.

Yu-Gi-Oh has just recently made some changes to the tournament rules (in Europe at least) to ban lewd playmats, sleeves, and other gear to combat this problem. One of the factors for that decision was "To ensure we can consistently provide an experience for attendees of all ages." That point is extremely valid here as Magic is a PG-13 game.

I know this is somewhat controlled by the environment that you're playing in by the shop owners enforcing rules. However, having a standards of conduct for the player base, similar to Yu-Gi-Oh, is starting to make sense for Magic as well.

I want to know how others feel about this topic as well. Is this stopping people you know from playing or has it drove some Magic players away already?


r/EDH • • Feb 24 '22

Discussion Refuting the common responses to anti-combo sentiment

26 Upvotes

Dear combo enjoyers,

We love you. I was one of you for a long time. But many on this sub are just generally dismissive of the major points brought up by those who wish to not see combo in their games:

  1. 'Combo, like Aggro and Control, is one of the major pillars of magic.' This response is fundamentally true for 60 card magic of course, but somewhat overlooks the principles of the format of EDH. Aggro players have to overcome 120 life points, leading those decks to either resemble more of midrange/beatdown decks or have some exponentially scaling token or drain theme. Control decks have to handle threats from three other opponents, and, while boardwipes and stax pieces are powerful, they don't lead to immediate victory. Combo players, however, bypass all of these restrictions as player count and life total numbers are largely irrelevant. I have heard it compared to "dunking on a 6 foot rim". The principles of EDH are just built to make it easier and more effective than the other pillars.

  2. 'The combo player broadcasts the upcoming combo by drawing and tutoring.' This response I largely disagree with because every deck draws cards and develops their hand. In my experience, decks running combos typically aren't solely dedicated to combo and instead act as normal edh decks, ramping, playing threats (even ones that could be combo pieces) and running removal until suddenly, out of nowhere, 'end step: tutor, draw, win.' It's like saying "he was wearing a suit, so you should have known he was a spy"

  3. 'Just run Interaction.' This response doesn't accurately reflect what is going on in a usual game of EDH. Only maybe 1/3 of decks even have access to or run counterspells. And people need to play threats, replay their commander, and otherwise tap out to develop their board all the time. It's reasonable to expect people to have interaction in their hand, but totally ordinary for them to need to wait till their untap step to have access to it. It's like assuming people are safe because they carry a gun with them at all times, but then sniping them.

So maybe ask the table if combos are ok in the pre game discussion, regardless of how "jank" they are. You may be surprised at how many people would just prefer to play without them entirely.


r/EDH • • Aug 30 '26

Discussion Thank you, WOTC.

0 Upvotes

Thank you for printing [[The Queen of Dale]].

Edit: I'm speaking about Queen helming a bracket 3 deck. This seems to have been unclear to some of the readers.

I've been playing mono-white in EDH since 2010, and Queen is the first commander that makes it feel playable. Consistently being able to play Queen on turn 2 makes a lot of mediocre opening hands solidly worth keeping.

Mono-white's problem in EDH -- for over a decade -- has been a distinct lack of commanders that make it worth committing to the middling mono-white card pool. I believe the Queen is the first commander that makes building mono-white an attractive option.

Queen's recruit ability helps shore up a lot of things white sucks at:

  1. White has some decent graveyard recursion effects, but white never had a reliable way to dump cards into the yard in order to reanimate them. Queen finally fixes this.

  2. White has never, ever had a source of reliable card selection in the command zone. There have been some white legends that provide draw, like [[The Gaffer]], but he and others made you fill your deck with garbage cards to trigger the draw. Queen actually allows you to fill your white deck with the cards you actually want to play.

  3. While recruit isn't true card advantage (as it's only a loot effect and is not net-positive), we can pair it with cards like [[Tocasia's Welcome]], [[Welcoming Vampire]], and [[Caretaker's Talent]] to turn it into real card draw. These are all "once per turn" triggers, but with Queen's recruit happening on opponents' turns, you can get up to 4 draw triggers per turn cycle.

  4. The token production portion of recruit synergizes nicely with a lot of white cards, like [[Cathar's Crusade]] and [[Moonshaker Cavalry]].

  5. Since Queen has a low CMC, she wields equipment nicely. This is important for white, since equipment synergy is one of white's strengths.

  6. Because she's a 2/1 and doesn't provide true card advantage and she isn't an imminent threat, Queen is usually not a kill-on-sight commander at tables where you'll see imminently game-ending cards like [[The Mimeoplasm]], [[Ms. Bumbleflower]], or [[Smaug the Impenetrable]].

  7. Dumping a bunch of Plains into the yard with Queen's recruit ability turns one of my favorite old Urza's block cards into an all-star: [[Planar Birth]].

  8. Queen also pairs nicely with [[Sevinne's Reclamation]], [[Serra Paragon]], [[Restoration Seminar]], [[Ascend from Avernus]], [[Emeria Shepherd]], [[Emeria the Sky Ruin]], and everyone's favorite giant, [[Sun Titan]].

  9. Queen's token production works great with [[Skullclamp]], which white can easily tutor up.

Thank you, WOTC. Seriously. You've made my favorite EDH color identity really fun, finally.

Full disclosure: the actual best "mono-white" commander is still [[Oswald Fiddlebender]], but considering that his deck is like, 80% colorless artifacts, I do not consider him to be an actual mono-white commander.


r/EDH • • Jan 23 '24

Deck Showcase [Article] It's okay to cut lands! My new deck has an average mana value of 5.27. It also only has 29 lands. I cast everything on curve or earlier, guaranteed.

60 Upvotes

That's right, it's GamesfreakSA, and I think landlording is so morally bankrupt I won't even do it in a game of Magic.

Have you ever read those deckbuilding guides about how you should have ten pieces of removal, ten pieces of ramp, and 40 lands? If you have, then you've probably asked the question: where does the rest of the deck go? After you put in all the commander staples like Sol Ring, Arcane Signet, Swords to Plowshares Rampant Growth, Cultivate, Island, Kodama's Reach, Sakura-Tribe Elder, Primal Growth, Worn Powerstone, Murder, Ring of Ma'rûf, and Animate Wall, you only have three spots left for the things that make the deck unique! That's why instead of following those deckbuilding guides, my new deck is 39 creatures, 29 lands, and they're all way too expensive. Surely, I'm missing land drops all the time and discarding cards every turn to hand size, but neither of those are true. How do I brew do it? You just gotta read to find out.

Let me know what you think about this deck below! It was really interesting to optimize this deck over weeks of playtesting. If you’re interested in voting on what deck you want me to write up next, all you have to do is visit my Discord. Link to that is on my website along with all my other projects. Hope to see you there!


r/EDH • • Jul 05 '26

Question Should the altars including kci be game changers?

4 Upvotes

Every time [[krark clan ironworks]] [[phyrexian altar]] or [[ashnods altar]] come out in a game I know it will lead to some incredibly degenerate nondeterministic combo/storm chicanery. Sacrificing as a mana ability is near impossible to interact with. Do you think these cards belong in bracket 2?

Would they be worth a game changer slot in bracket 3?

Am I way off base in thinking these cards enable absurd play patterns?

Bonus question how do people feel about [[skullclamp]]?


r/EDH • • Jun 13 '15

New Commander Concept: Jearld, Nivix Scrapmaster

Thumbnail
imgur.com
6 Upvotes

r/EDH • • Dec 17 '23

Discussion How to react to overly sensitive players? Or Am I the Bolas Here?

14 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I just have a question about how you would react. Due to running into too many people at my LGS that have severe attitude problems, I decided to branch out and play somewhere new. My local library runs a monthly, “Learn to Play Magic: the Gathering Commander” event. There are no entry fees or prizes, and the player base is mainly underprivileged kids playing donated cards.

So anyhow, I show up, find a seat with three others, and immediately ask about power levels. After the three kids at the table looked confused and said, “what?”, I said no problem, I’ll play something casual, and pulled out my Atraxa deck.

These kids made several suboptimal plays, ran zero removal, and didn’t know how to assess a threat. We played a game, and after I won on turn six, we shuffled up and played again. This time I won on turn five. At this point, one of the organizers came up to me and said this event probably wasn’t for me, and asked that I leave if I wasn’t there to teach other people to play.

I was appalled. It’s not my job to teach new players. I said as much, and the words “pubstomper” and “you’re actually not allowed back here until you’ve paid your excessive late fees” were bandied about.

Has anyone else dealt with something like this? I feel like I did what I was supposed to by having a rule zero conversation. It’s not my fault if other people play poorly constructed decks. Should I go back, or call my LGS and ask how to get unbanned?


r/EDH • • Jun 08 '20

DISCUSSION It is deeply troubling that a CAG member did not know how the command zone replacement effect worked

36 Upvotes

I just have to put this out there. With the new rule change, the RC mentioned that a CAG (Commander Advisory Group) member did not understand how their own [[elenda the dusk rose]] deck worked. They thought Elenda going to the command zone triggered her death trigger.

Look, it was a complex rule and the change is definitely good. I just want to say that the select few member of the CAG should probably know the rules of our format. I’ve built decks with death trigger commanders and put packages in my deck to make up for not re-zoning, and one of the most influential EDH players in the world wasn’t even aware of the rule? Not to mention they have an Elenda deck for God’s sake.

It bothers me that I may know the rules better than the people who speak directly to the RC on a regular basis, and I’m not even an experienced player.


r/EDH • • Oct 04 '20

Discussion Calls to fracture the community are irresponsible and short sighted.

0 Upvotes

Look, I get it. We're all pissed at WotC here -- and rightfully so! But actively calling to split a subset of the community out into a separate """format""" - regardless of how tongue in cheek they may have started - has potential to do far more long term damage to the health of the format than any number of exclusive promo cards do.

Breaking off a chunk of the community into a separate but nearly identical format will only serve to foster confusion, feelbads, and potentially hostile situations in the future. Something that very few people on this sub seem to want to accept is the fact that, in reality, we are a vocal minority in this community. Imagine some players new to Magic and interested in commander - who had no prior knowledge of the RC, or the backlash over the Walking Dead cards, or no idea that this "Captain" alternative even exists - heading to an LGS to try the format out for the first time, only to be turned away because they're playing the "wrong version" of the format, or worse, actively shamed for running certain cards in their deck. A community schism, at best, will be looked back on in a year or two's time, after WotC has likely already stopped with the exclusive promos after the huge amount of community backlash, as a somewhat cringy meme with a dead subreddit. At worst it will actively drive away new players, cause confusion amongst enfranchised ones, and create entirely avoidable feelbad situations all around. There are no good outcomes to this.

Also -- and I'll preface this by saying that I love Mitch's content and that he's one of my favorite Magic creators on Youtube -- but I think that the way he's stoking the fire and fanning the flames of this fiasco is pretty irresponsible. Splintering commander will damage exactly one thing - commander. It's not going to hurt WotC's bottom line. Mitch should be using his platform as a rallying cry to focus players' anger into something productive, like making our opinions heard loud and clear by Wizards. Popularizing the idea of splintering the format, and then taking it even further by "making it official" through a Discord server, in my opinion is incredibly short sighted. I know his heart's in the right place, but he's not helping the situation.


r/EDH • • Jun 13 '26

Discussion What cards are you adding to your decks from Marvel Super Heroes?

3 Upvotes

Negativity around UB and such aside, what are y'all thinking? I was surprised how many cards I'm actually interested in trying out...

[[Ultron, Artificial Malevolence]] is going into my [[Tataru Taru]] deck so I can make even more copies of Iron Maiden and Scrawling Crawler. Since I force draw on other turns I may even try out [[Molecule Man]] so I can capitalize even further.

[[Greasefang, Okiba Boss]] got [[The Thanos-Copter]] which is absolutely bonkers. [[M.O.D.O.K]] also seems like a really solid addition, giving both a sac outlet and +1/+1 counters seems good. Edit: Discard outlet, not sac outlet.

[[Mjölnir, Hammer of Thor]] is awesome for my [[Howling Abomination]] (Blanka) deck. Cutting in half the number of spells I need to kill the entire table, while also providing a versatile removal option with its discard ability, seems really good.

[[Imskir Iron-Eater]] got a new Affinity creature in [[Panther Robot]]. [[Arc Reactor]] enters tapped, but being able to essentially cast it for free seems good.

[[Galactus, Devourer of Worlds]] seems good in my budget [[Xu-Ifit, Osteoharmonist]] deck, depending how cheap it is.

And I'm considering [[Crystal, Inhuman Princess]] for a [[Sunforger]] toolbox commander.


r/EDH • • Feb 19 '21

Discussion [Article] Proxies and lies go together like peanut butter and jelly

2 Upvotes

Or at least that has almost all too frequently been my experience.

"Yeah, the deck is a six, but I proxied up a few cards just to make it work right," he said offhandedly as he started his turn. "Volcanic Island, Mana Crypt, Mox Diamond pitching this Scalding Tarn. Mystical Tutor fetching Mana Drain to the top, then Wheel of Fortune?"

That, however, was before the Great Plague, when you could actually go to a restaurant or afford to buy a copy of Shallow Grave. Back then a lot of the cards whose price most encouraged proxying were also haymakers that tended to show up in higher-powered lists. We're seeing a seismic shift there, with cards like Tithe, Didgeridoo and Lifeline spiking through the roof. Those are cards that just have no conceivable way to be ran by someone being deceptive about their deck's power, and they have gone from being the cost of a Snickers bar to costing more than a lot of people's weekly grocery bill. As a result are we seeing a similar change in the who and the why of proxies?

I write about it here: https://commandersherald.com/a-proxy-upon-their-house/


r/EDH • • Jan 06 '24

Discussion Proxies in powerful decks.

10 Upvotes

Maybe this is just me, but anyone else have an issue when people have a full proxy deck that’s just way stronger than the table? I don’t mind proxies at all, I’ll play against them without issue. But when someone is using their full proxy deck to turn 4 [[time walk]] next turn [[time stretch]] then [[cyclonic rift]] the board and swing for full board lethal it just feels silly. People are barely getting out their commanders and a full proxy is taking 3 turns on turn 4 into a full on win. I get liking popping off and wanting to win but IDK it feels poor cause nobody even got to play. At least if they owned the cards I’d be annoyed but go “Well they spent a lot,I get why they want to full pop off as long as they don’t do it again.” What do you all think about this type of thing? Would you say no proxies if someone is using it to play busted quick win combos?


r/EDH • • Feb 19 '26

Discussion Two friends of mine refused to use anything but EDHREC because Scryfall felt too frustrating, so I built a human-to-Scryfall translator.

54 Upvotes

I have a group of friends I play EDH with every week, and two of them kept showing up with decks that felt like the same pile of staples over and over again.

At some point, I asked why they never used Scryfall to look for new cards. Turns out they had tried it, but the syntax felt annoying to learn, and digging through filters manually just took too long for them.

So I ended up building a small tool mainly for those two. You just type what you’re looking for in plain English, and it turns it into a Scryfall search and runs it for you.

One thing I wanted was to not hide what’s happening behind the scenes, so the site shows the actual Scryfall query it generates. You can hover over each tag to see a short explanation of what it does, and you can even tweak the scryfall query directly in case the system screws up. I also hooked in the Scryfall community tags, so you can search by themes, artists, archetypes, and similar stuff.

I know there are already tools that try to do something similar, but this started as a fun side project, and I’d like to keep expanding it over time.

If you feel like trying it, I’d love to hear what works and what doesn’t. It’s definitely still a work in progress.

www.findthatcard.net

Thanks, and have a good one!


r/EDH • • Oct 05 '24

Discussion Friendly mulligans negatively impact EDH

10 Upvotes

A lot of playgroups essentially let you continue to mulligan until you have a playable hand. I feel this encourages bad deckbuilding at best, hand sculpting at worse. I’ve seen folks run decks with less than 30 lands because they know they get 2-3 free mulligans. I’ve seen players mulligan until their hand has fast mana, then proceed to run away with the game. It’s too easy to abuse and not easy to identify if they are intentionally abusing it without making a scene. I think everyone should just abide by the standard 1 free mulligan + normal mulligans after.


r/EDH • • Jan 20 '20

DISCUSSION The RC should be fired and replaced

0 Upvotes

Sheldon and the RC are out of touch with the format and the playerbase.

The bans are irrelevant and completely biased, Sheldon contradicts himself left and right when trying to explain the RC's philosophy, there's insider trading within the RC, cedh is 2spooky so they ignore it at an official capacity and by and large, the format has evolved beyond their scope. Here's why I think the RC should either step down or be removed by wotc:

Number one: There was irrefutable evidence that there was insider trading among at least some of the RC members. There was a huge buyout/ sellout of Iona and painters servant days before the banned announcement. Sheldon denies it saying the RC would never do that but the thousands of dollars of insider trading says otherwise. Either they bought and sold it themselves, or they sold the info or prematurely blabbed about it to someone. So either they were irresponsible or outright dishonest.

Number 2: the format that Sheldon created, the edh he knows and loves has evolved and changed at a faster pace than he has been able to keep up with. His bans are irrelevant, his reasoning and explanations for his thought process are consistently contradicted by himself or other RC members. He always says that people should rely on communicating with others to prevent games from getting too broken instead of looking to the banlist. If that's the case why have a banlist at all?

Number 3: he's willfully ignorant to the voices of the cedh community. He pretends they don't exist and makes decisions based solely on casual play. This is kind of part of the whole format evolving past his scope thing. It's not the magic he knows and loves so he ignores it at an official capacity.

Everyone would be better off if the RC relinquished control or got fired. Make cedh a different format with a separate banlist and hand over the reins to a relevant group of individuals who would actually be held accountable for their actions.

I wouldn't say the RC is harming the format, but they aren't exactly doing their best by the community either.

Thanks for coming to my Tedtalk.


r/EDH • • Sep 24 '24

Discussion Thanks RC!

96 Upvotes

I just wanted to give a little positive vibe on the b&r announcement. Our LGS chat has been buzzing, and the vast majority of its 30+ player base feels this is a great ban.

I'm sorry your getting salt, I've lost a couple of Hundred euros here, but the game is just better without Dockside and Crypt.

*Edit: Nuanced it a bit.


r/EDH • • Sep 09 '23

Social Interaction Another player's Worldgorger won me the game

0 Upvotes

I was playing a 1v1v1 with my friends earlier. I was playing [[Heliod, Sun-Crowned]]. They were [[Captain N'ghathrod]] and [[Anje Falkenrath]].

Turn 1 I play a [[Authority of Consuls]]. Later on in the game he tutors for a combo piece, so before his turn I play [[Aetherflux Reservoir]] knowing he is about to make a big boo boo. Sure enough his turn comes around with [[Worldgorger Dragon]] [[Animate Dead]] getting played and he acts like he wins, but I tell him to play the combo out.

After a bit of discussion I inform him that due to my Authority of Consuls, his Anje enters the battlefield tapped, so he can't draw/discard anymore and when his dragon and Anje flicker, I gain 2 life. Then I thank him for all the life gain enabling me to use Aetherflux Reservoir's activated ability twice to take out both players.


r/EDH • • Jul 27 '24

Deck Help My Yurlok deck keeps on handing other people the game. How can I adjust it?

0 Upvotes

Decklist is here: https://www.moxfield.com/decks/FnrTL1jetUORGZMd0_MqTQ

I keep on being hoisted by my own petard with this deck. Last night, I handed a [[Satya]] player the game on turn 3 by giving him enough mana to go infinite with it and [[Port Razer]] after doing [[Collective Voyage]]. I feel like every card in this deck that isn't a land is a trap, and I don't know how to fix it at this point.

I know the land count is a little low, but I have a bunch of rocks and other accelerants, and the commander himself is a mana dork.