r/EDH • • 4m ago

Social Interaction Looking for Guest Speakers for Learn to Play Commander Events in Las Vegas

1 Upvotes

Hello r/EDH community! I’m organizing Learn to Play Commander events at the Sahara West Library in Las Vegas and am looking for experienced players who would be interested in guest speaking or helping teach newcomers. The workshops are scheduled for the 2nd Sunday of the month. The next meeting on Sunday, December 13th. If you enjoy introducing others to Commander and can volunteer some time, please reach out.


r/EDH • • 16m ago

Deck Help Help My Teval deck

1 Upvotes

Could you guys please check my Teval deck in bracket3-4 .it’s good or should swap some card.I already have the precon and test with my friends it’s so fun and I want to upgrade but when I see many list changes the way to play from combat to combo.I’m not sure that am I understand right.I don’t know which way I should play between combat or combo or mix it together so
I need any suggestion thank you.

https://archidekt.com/decks/22849878/teval


r/EDH • • 17m ago

Deck Help [Deck Help] [[Kardur, Doomscourge]] — Rakdos Forced Combat / Political Aristocrats

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've been working on this [[Kardur, Doomscourge]] deck and would love to hear your thoughts on the current list.

The main idea is to make my opponents fight each other, then take advantage of the creatures dying through life-drain effects, card draw, token generation, and other value engines.

I'm not trying to build a traditional Aristocrats deck or an infinite-combo deck. I'd rather create interesting, interactive games where combat is the main focus, while having a few ways to close out the game when the opportunity presents itself.

Main game plan:

  • Force opponents' creatures to attack each other using [[Kardur, Doomscourge]] and other goad effects.

  • Take advantage of attacking creatures dying through cards like [[Blood Artist]], [[Falkenrath Noble]], [[Syr Konrad, the Grim]], and Kardur himself.

  • Generate additional value through card draw, tokens, and sacrifice outlets.

  • Finish the game with cards like [[Insurrection]], [[Mob Rule]], [[Tempt with Vengeance]], or [[Brash Taunter]] + [[Blasphemous Act]].

I'm particularly interested in the interaction between [[Kardur, Doomscourge]], [[Caltrops]], and the various death triggers. [[Hunted Dragon]] is also a recent addition: it gives an opponent three 2/2 Knight tokens, which become additional attackers under Kardur's effect. Caltrops can punish those attacks, although it won't kill the Knights by itself.

https://moxfield.com/decks/aday9123A0mcrz3b5EKchA

What I'd love feedback on

  1. Do you think the deck has a good balance between goad/forced combat effects and payoffs for creatures dying?

  2. Are there any cards that look underwhelming or inefficient for this strategy?

  3. Are there any interesting cards or synergies I'm overlooking?

I'm open to suggestions and constructive criticism. I'd especially appreciate recommendations that reinforce the deck's identity rather than turning it into a completely different strategy.

Thanks!


r/EDH • • 27m ago

Discussion Bracket power vs fun

2 Upvotes

I’ve found that the more powerful my deck gets, the more narrow its game-plan becomes. To the point that every single card has to contribute in some way to the deck’s plans/win con. But then I play it successfully a couple times and it’s not interesting anymore, cause it’s always tryjng to do the same thing. I wonder if b2 is just more fun for me, curious if anyone feels similarly? Or has any advice for building powerful decks that can hang with “high 3s”, which I think are really more like 4s.

Also I kinda feel like the most common bracket (3) is really like 2 different brackets (maybe 3?)

3.1- a 2 with 1-3 game changers
3.2- core b3: some combos,more tuned
3.3- a 4 with less game changers/fast mana/free interaction

So we often have people playing a 3.1 against a pod of 3.3s, or vice versa, and everyone says “my deck is a 3.” Then people complain about pubstomping etc, or an LGS makes up their own rules that bracket 3 can’t have game changers (saw a post on here earlier).

I have one friend that will take his actual b4 deck and remove just enough free interaction and game changers to technically qualify for bracket 3. Does that make it play like a 3? Not really

Similarly i have friends that will call their bracket 2 decks a 3, understandably, because they put rhystic study or smothering tithe in. Does that deck play like a 3? No

I have a few different bracket 3 decks that I play with 2 different groups since I know what they mean when they say 3 and would not really have fun playing these in the wrong pods, but I generally have more fun playing the lower power decks because it can go in more directions. That said I also only play with friends and not with strangers at an LGS, which I think would make this bracket thing harder to navigate.


r/EDH • • 30m ago

Deck Help Galadriel Deck Building Help

2 Upvotes

Hiya!

Looking to build a Galadriel, Light of Valinor deck and would love some assistance making this a high 2 or low 3. I've never built a deck from scratch, only modded precons to make them a bracket up. I love LOTR/The Hobbit and have several elves already from the Hobbit set. I figured I could make an deck off of them with the lovely Galadriel, but am not sure if what I've built is practical.

I've seen the idea to make her a blink commander, but I also am okay with how this deck currently looks to be a "big elves go brrr" with the counters being added.

Any feedback on what to cut or to add would be great! I'm looking to keep this lower budget (sub $200)

Deck List: https://scryfall.com/@Returnoftheewok/decks/3545804f-c723-4be2-b5b8-1aca13d2d235


r/EDH • • 41m ago

Deck Help Need help with building Blech

1 Upvotes

Hello everybody!

Sorry if this is not in the good subreddit or if it's not allowed, feel free to delete in that case.

So, my friend got me into Magic pretty recently. I bought a couple of packs and a booster box recently, in which I pulled Blech. Since I'm pretty new and I don't know yet what to look for in a build, I made something around pests, lifelink and healing. Problem is, I forgot to put card draws and defenses against flying enemies. I'm looking for recommendations/help to make my deck at least useable so I can get a bit of fun from playing with it instead of being disappointed everytime. I don't know anything about how to efficiently build so please be indulgent with me haha. Here's what I have in it right now (I also don't know if there is a more efficient way of showing it here).
Thanks for your answers :)

Here's my decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/_V11Q0BY8USN-yvmdLSjbg


r/EDH • • 45m ago

Question Help me make the most flavourful elminster deck ever!

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone, ive been playing mtg for a long time, tried pretty much all formats, nowadays i only really play commander.

One thing ive always focused on edh was the flavour of my decks, outside my bracket 4 sythis everything is really tailored with aesthetics, flavour in mind.

I recently decided to build an Elminster deck, love the character and also really like the merlin, gandalf, wandering sage feel.

I come here not for suggestions in cards to add that make the deck work, but in flavour wins.

I mostly want to build the deck that makes you feel like a wizard of old, not the fireball spam wizard, but the one that sees the world, listens to people, uses his magic in clever ways.

Help me to make this deck something special. Power lvl wise, high 2 low 3.

Thanks everyone


r/EDH • • 51m ago

Deck Help Commander deck help [Vihaan]

3 Upvotes

Here’s my deck list link with a maybe-board for swap ins of what I got on hand. I need help or tips with either making it stronger or more consistent. Or any general tips, swaps or other card suggestions.

I have a feeling my lands are part of the issue as I’ve always had a problem balancing them.

It says brac 2, I’m new to brackets as my last group just made decks and played, never paid attention to the brackets system but now my new group does and uses 3-4 on average.

Thank you ahead of time for any help, tips, suggestions or any help.

https://

mythic.tools/user/57G73/deck/5L73M


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Question What would be Giada's nemesis commander?

9 Upvotes

Since quite a few people play Giada nowadays, I felt like it would be a lot of fun to build a deck that would be a nemesis to Giada. I figured demons, but honestly there isn't really a good demon tribal commander (I know that ​Be'Lakor exists, problem is that he's not in the MTG universe so IMO he feels like he doesnt fit.) Would be super cool if they were a mono black tribal commander. I know there's a slew of Ob nixilis cards but all of them wouldn't work well as tribal commanders.

I want to mention, I'm not trying to counter build Giada, I just want something that I feel would give a thematic feeling of angels and evil clashing. ​And give newer players something that would really make them feel like they're playing angels.


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Question Start playing in paper - which Precon?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

Greetings from a german newbie.

I'm relatively new to Magic: The Gathering. I've already spent quite a few hours playing MTG Arena, mainly in Constructed Pioneer, so I'm familiar with the basic mechanics and gameplay.

I'd now like to get into paper Magic and start playing Commander with other people in person. Since I don't own any physical cards yet, I'm looking to buy my first preconstructed Commander deck.

I'm hoping you can help me find something that suits my playstyle!

My preferences:

  • Playstyle: Aggro / Go-Wide

  • Game plan: Build a large board with lots of creatures and overwhelm my opponents through combat.

  • Favourite mechanics: +1/+1 counters, creature synergies and effects that buff my entire board.

  • Complexity: Preferably beginner-friendly, with straightforward gameplay. I enjoy making tactical decisions, but don't want an overly complicated deck.

  • Interaction: I'd rather focus on building my own board than constantly disrupting my opponents.

  • Themes I like: Angels, Elves, Demons, Zombies, Knights and other fantasy creatures. I'm particularly interested in Angels and Elves.

  • Colours: No particular colour preference.

  • Universes Beyond: I'd prefer traditional Magic: The Gathering lore rather than crossover products.

  • Budget: Around €60–100.

  • Upgrades: I'd like to play the deck straight out of the box initially, without having to buy additional singles.

To give you an idea of what I enjoy, I really like cards such as Ouroboroid, Lyra Dawnbringer and Rousing Refrain Singer(cards that help make an entire board of creatures bigger and stronger).

My ideal game would involve building up a large army of creatures, finding ways to buff the whole board, and eventually overwhelming my opponents with one massive attack.

I've been considering Elf tribal decks, Angel tribal decks and other creature-focused strategies, but I'm open to suggestions!

My questions:

  1. Which preconstructed Commander decks would you recommend for this playstyle?

  2. Are there any particular precons that are fun and reasonably strong straight out of the box?

  3. Would you recommend Elves or Angels for someone with my preferences, or is there another archetype I should consider?

I'm not necessarily looking for the strongest deck available. I'd much rather have something fun, beginner-friendly and enjoyable to play regularly.

Thanks in advance for your recommendations!

Here are my main decks, which I play most on Magic Arena. I hope, that can help you to understand my preferred way of playing furthermore.

Ouroboroid Deck:

4 Ouroboroid (EOE) 201
20 Forest (TRK) 325
4 Llanowar Elves (FDN) 227
2 Surrak, Elusive Hunter (TDM) 161
4 Pawpatch Recruit (BLB) 187
4 Frenzied Baloth (EOE) 183
4 Badgermole Cub (TLA) 167
3 Tribute to the World Tree (MOM) 211
1 Boseiju, Who Endures (NEO) 266
4 Elvish Mystic (M14) 169
2 Tamiyo's Safekeeping (NEO) 211
4 Tyvar's Stand (ONE) 190
2 Kodama of the West Tree (NEO) 199
3 Craterhoof Behemoth (TDM) 138

Angel Deck:

4 Giada, Font of Hope (FDN) 141
8 Plains (FDN) 273
4 Bishop of Wings (M20) 8
4 Resplendent Angel (LCI) 32
4 Righteous Valkyrie (J25) 246
4 Forest (FRA) 290
3 Llanowar Elves (FDN) 227
4 Inspiring Overseer (FDN) 496
2 Cavern of Souls (LCI) 269
4 Radiant Fountain (M21) 248
2 Lyra Dawnbringer (FRA) 201
4 Kayla's Reconstruction (BRO) 10
1 Gathering Place (MSH) 266
4 Rally the Ranks (AKR) 186
1 Overgrown Farmland (MID) 265
3 Momo, Friendly Flier (TLA) 29
4 Blossoming Sands (DFT) 252

r/EDH • • 1h ago

Social Interaction Am I being unreasonable for being annoyed that someone in our casual Commander group is playing above the power level we agreed on and being defended by others?

1 Upvotes

I'm pretty new to MTG, and I'm having an issue with my Commander group. Some of my friends are making me feel like I'm just being a sore loser, so I wanted to get some outside opinions.

For context, our group is 8 people (4 couples), and we all decided to get into Commander together. Some of us are completely new to Magic, while others have been playing for years.

When we started, we all agreed to play around Bracket 2, basically aiming for the power level of precons. We wanted everyone to have fun without feeling like they needed to spend a ton of money or build super optimized decks just to keep up.

Here's basically what everyone is playing (fake names obviously):

  • Me: Pretty new to Magic. I've won exactly one Commander game out of probably 12. I netdecked Bracket 2 decks that I specifically chose to be around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons. I used to play Pokemon so this isn’t my first card game. I've been really good friends with Erin since high school while I met everyone else my junior year of university or after graduation.

  • Colette (my girlfriend): Used to play Magic and understands the game really well, but is newer to Commander. She also built decks around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons.

  • Erin and Kayla (dating): Both play precons. Yshtola and something else. Erin is also best friends with Trish.

  • Ryan and Anastasia (dating): Ryan built a deliberately weak Bracket 1 Cat themed deck because he thought it would be fun. Anastasia has a custom Bracket 2 deck, similar to what Colette and I are playing.

  • Trish and Crystal (dating): Trish plays precons, and I don't think I've actually seen her play the same deck twice. She's also best friends with Erin and has been for years. Crystal has been playing Magic for a long time and recently built decks that both she and online deck evaluators consider high Bracket 3. I believe one of them also has 3 Game Changers and no basic lands.

Here's where the issue started:

Before Crystal built her own decks, she was borrowing some of Trish's really old Magic decks. They hadn't really kept up with power creep, and Crystal was having a hard time doing much of anything during our games.

I genuinely felt bad about that. I don't think it's fun to sit there while everyone else gets to play Magic and your deck just can't keep up. I was actually happy when she decided to build something new because I wanted her to be able to enjoy playing with us.

The problem is that she ended up building decks that are apparently high Bracket 3, despite everyone originally agreeing on Bracket 2. She's also made comments about being good at deck building, so her decks are probably at the top of Bracket 3.

We've played against one of these decks before, and she won on turn 5. By turn 4, it was already pretty obvious she was about to win. I understand that one game doesn't necessarily mean her deck will always perform like that, but it definitely made me question whether we're playing at the same power level.

Colette and I, along with some of the others who built custom decks, have brought up concerns about this.

The reactions have been pretty frustrating.

Erin has defended Crystal by saying things like "The bracket system doesn't actually matter" and "Do we even have faith that it's accurate at all?"

Meanwhile, some of the other girls have made comments like "Slay queen," "Destroy his ass," and "Get good" when talking about Crystal beating me.

I understand that some of this is probably just joking around. I'm usually pretty good at competitive video games, so I get that my friends might enjoy seeing me lose at something for once. But I'm genuinely a beginner at Magic. I've won one Commander game ever. I'm already very used to losing at this game, so I really don't think that's the issue.

What actually bothers me:

It's not that I think I should be winning more games.

It's that most of us deliberately built our decks around the power level we agreed on.

Colette and I could have built much stronger decks, but we intentionally chose not to. We wanted our decks to be around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons because some of our friends are completely new to card games and wouldn't really know how to build a deck themselves. When I called her out, she said, "I don’t know what I did that was wrong. I built it to follow bracket 3 rules."

Ryan even went out of his way to build a weaker themed deck because that's what he thought would be fun.

I understand that the bracket system isn't perfect. I'm sure there are Bracket 2 decks that can beat Bracket 3 decks, and I know the brackets aren't some exact measurement of how strong a deck is. But if we all agreed to build around Bracket 2, shouldn't that agreement mean something?

I'm worried that she's going to start destroying everyone with this deck and then everyone is going to slowly stop wanting to play. Ironically, that's exactly what Crystal was experiencing before she built her new decks. She was struggling to keep up with everyone else, and I don't want her to go back to that either. I just don't think the solution should be to create the same problem for other people.

I want Crystal to have fun. I want her to be able to play her deck and actually do things. I just want everyone else to have that same opportunity.

What makes this more frustrating is that I feel like I'm being treated as a sore loser just for bringing it up. I don't think wanting everyone to have a reasonably balanced game is the same thing as being upset that I lost.

We're supposed to play again this weekend, and I genuinely want to go. I really enjoy Magic, even though I'm still learning and honestly not very good at it yet. I also don't want to dictate what decks Crystal can build or tell her she isn't allowed to play something she's excited about.

But at the same time, I don't really want to spend an entire game watching someone threaten to win before the rest of us have even gotten our boards going.

And the way some of my friends have responded makes me feel like bringing this up again is just going to turn into another argument about me being a sore loser. I think its also important to not if I ever brought a bracket 3 deck to the table I would be ostracized by at least half the group without hesitation. It's a huge double standard. 

I know Commander is supposed to involve Rule 0 conversations, but I feel like we already had that conversation when we agreed on Bracket 2.

So am I actually being unreasonable here? Am I putting too much importance on the bracket system? Or is it fair to be frustrated that we agreed on one power level and now some people are acting like that agreement doesn't matter?

I genuinely don't care if I lose. I just want to feel like everyone at the table has a chance to actually play Magic.


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Discussion “MLD” below bracket 4

0 Upvotes

Has wizards ever explicitly said that land destruction that replaces the land that was removed is fair game in B2/B3? I see people say this all the time but I don’t think I’ve actually seen this anywhere. I want to run [[From the Ashes]] in my mono red deck and just want something I can point to if someone gets upset.


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Discussion Mohiam Imperial Truthsayer [SLD] fun combos and interactions

1 Upvotes

I think that [[Mohiam Imperial Truthsayer]], one of the legendary creatures from the dune secret layer seems fun. I think this would be a fun control deck with a lot of politicking and top deck manipulation, maybe even some graveyard recursion. How would you build her, and are there any fun interactions you can see?


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Deck Help Help Building Kediss/Malcolm

1 Upvotes

I only ever build fun/thematic B2 and B3 decks but my pod has recently started moving to higher power levels. I am trying to build a budget Kediss/Malcolm deck that will hold its own against some B4 decks. I feel like its a bit weak right now especially in late game as its average mana cost is fairly low so any suggestions are appreciated!

https://moxfield.com/decks/tNB6Zn7Po0iBTPRBkNxgUw


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Question Best Bulk Boxes in Vancouver?

8 Upvotes

Hey magic people 👋

I'll be in Vancouver British Columbia Canada around Richmond for a few days this week and I am wondering what local game stores in the area have the best bulk bins to sift through? I love looking through boxes for hidden gems 💎 . Thanks.


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Deck Showcase Give me your deck lists first bracket 3 with lots of interaction (control, removal, board wipes, etc.)

6 Upvotes

Looking for a deck to play with my friends. Will be playing online so cost isn’t an issue. I don’t usually play control and my pod doesn’t really use much interaction so I think it would be fun to mix up the paradigm.

Please share your best decks so I can crush the competition!


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Discussion For the Sultai enjoyers, do you enjoy ETB doubling or land-matters more?

5 Upvotes

Self-mill is implied, but I’m currently torn if I want to pivot into ETB doubling or land-matters. I currently run a Sidisi deck that leans towards ETB with sprinkles of land-matters. I don’t have any other deck that focuses on either. Regardless of bracket, interaction is key for me; it makes the game enjoyable. Share your thoughts!


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Deck Help What cards should I buy for these new sea monster recursion precon

1 Upvotes

I already have a good chunk of seamonsters due to my Kenessos deck but I really like the idea of recursion so I’m switching to this new one. The mox link is all the cards I already have that I plan on putting in.

https://moxfield.com/decks/2ir6MEEcfUiH7w3plgwbKQ

The Noble Serpent

{5}{B}{G}{U}

Legendary Creature - Serpent Noble

At the beginning of your first upkeep in this game, if The Noble Serpent is in your command zone, mill four cards.

At the beginning of your end step, return target creature card that is a Sea Monster from your graveyard to the battlefield. (Krakens, Leviathans, Octopuses, Serpents, and Whales are Sea Monsters.)

7/9

---------------------------------

Zekes, Revenist Devotee?

{1}{B}{G}{U}

Legendary Creature - Squid Warlock

All Sea Monsters you cast have emerge. The emerge cost is equal to the mana cost. (You may sacrifice a creature to reduce the emerge cost of spells that are Krakens, Leviathans, Octopuses, Serpents, or Whales by that creature's mana value.)

Whenever a creature? you control enters the battlefield, if it was cast for its emerge cost, draw two cards, then discard a card?.


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Deck Help Avacyn, Angel of Horror: First Mono-Colored Deck, Looking for Tips and Advice

0 Upvotes

LINK TO DECK

Hello Everyone! I am looking to build my first mono-colored deck, and in Mono-Black with Avacyn, Angel of Horror at the helm.

I put together this list, but to me it feels like its just an "EDHREC Greatest Hits" list and I would usually be fine with that, but I'm not sure if I quite hit the gameplan I'm trying to go for (sacrifice creatures to do something and bring them back a bunch to do it again).

To be more specific, it feels like this deck might just take way too long to actually win and give my opponents too much time to interact with my board to stop me. I am maybe overthinking/not looking at the deck I built properly, hence asking for some advice on anything I should change or if this looks like a decent list for what I'm tying to do.

Avacyn herself obviously is the star of the show with the recursion, but I feel like I have too many sacrifice outlets and not enough things that do something when creatures are sacrificed, or really anything as a backup if I somehow can't keep Avacyn around.

Thanks for any advice/recommendations! And please let me know if I need to include any other information in this post as well.

Some pertinent Information:

  • Trying to stay bracket 3 (Bolas' Citadel is the only GC on the list, I took out Vamp and Demonic Tutor)

  • Would like to stay under $1,000 for budget.

  • I'd like 1 or 2 infinite combos in there as a backup to the multi-turn drain everyone main gameplan.

  • My local meta varies so wildly that I don't think there is a good way to describe it. My playgroup plays anything from a 1 to a 5 if that's what we decide we want to play.


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Question I want to treat myself to a booster box. Of the listed, what's the best bet for EDH?

63 Upvotes

Yeah, I know, "buying singles is better," but fuck it. I'm an adult and possess free will, disposable income, and poor decision making. Ideally one below 20,000 yen.

[Out of Budget]

- Final Fantasy - 49300 yen / 310 USD

- Avatar - 35800 yen / 225 USD

[Budget Stretch]

- Edge of Eternities - 29200 190 USD

- Tarkir Dragonstorm - 29200 yen / 185 USD

- The Hobbit - 24500 yen / 155 USD

- Star Trek - 23550 yen / 145 USD

[Within Budget]

- Secrets of Strixhaven - 19800 yen / 120 USD

- Marvel Superheroes - 17850 yen / 110USD

- Lorwyn Eclipsed - 17800 yen / 110USD

- Aetherdrift - 17800 yen / 110 USD

- Reality Fracture - 16900 yen / 105 USD

- Spiderman - 16900 yen / 105 USD

- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - 15000 yen / 90 USD


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Deck Help Looking for Advice on Esper Enchantment Deck (B3)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/EDH • • 3h ago

Discussion Help Picking A Second Commander

2 Upvotes

Some friends and I are doing a fun night where we each get to choose two commanders for our deck instead of one, as if every commander had partner. I really want to try out [[Mairsil the pretender]] but I’m having a hard time figuring out a good paired commander to run with him. I would really appreciate any suggestions, I was thinking maybe one that gives access to white, but I kind of want to go for more synergy than just an additional colour!


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Deck Help Looking for recommendations on how to bring this Kaalia deck to a reasonable price.

0 Upvotes

https://archidekt.com/decks/28404205/kaalia_heavy_metal

There's some obvious things to get rid of. But I want to know what cards you would swap in to replace some of thos $20+ cards. Or if you have a deck list for a similar deck id love to see it! Thanks!

Edit: im aiming for B2!


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Deck Help Dance of the Elements Upgrade help

1 Upvotes

The Ashling precon is already so good out of the box but I really want to make it even better, this is what I came up with so far.

Since I will constantly have creatures die on my turns, I want to get more value out of sacrifices/dying. Cards like Earth-Cult Elemental seem like a fun addition, but I'm already unsure if I have enough graveyard interaction.

Out of the box the deck has this explosive character that I really like, I don't want to forfeit this for a combo I have to assemble over many turns, potentially exposing myself to my opponents.

Do you have any recommendations for this deck in terms of what I wanna do with it, what do you think of the general state of it now?