I'm pretty new to MTG, and I'm having an issue with my Commander group. Some of my friends are making me feel like I'm just being a sore loser, so I wanted to get some outside opinions.
For context, our group is 8 people (4 couples), and we all decided to get into Commander together. Some of us are completely new to Magic, while others have been playing for years.
When we started, we all agreed to play around Bracket 2, basically aiming for the power level of precons. We wanted everyone to have fun without feeling like they needed to spend a ton of money or build super optimized decks just to keep up.
Here's basically what everyone is playing (fake names obviously):
Me: Pretty new to Magic. I've won exactly one Commander game out of probably 12. I netdecked Bracket 2 decks that I specifically chose to be around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons. I used to play Pokemon so this isn’t my first card game. I've been really good friends with Erin since high school while I met everyone else my junior year of university or after graduation.
Colette (my girlfriend): Used to play Magic and understands the game really well, but is newer to Commander. She also built decks around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons.
Erin and Kayla (dating): Both play precons. Yshtola and something else. Erin is also best friends with Trish.
Ryan and Anastasia (dating): Ryan built a deliberately weak Bracket 1 Cat themed deck because he thought it would be fun. Anastasia has a custom Bracket 2 deck, similar to what Colette and I are playing.
Trish and Crystal (dating): Trish plays precons, and I don't think I've actually seen her play the same deck twice. She's also best friends with Erin and has been for years. Crystal has been playing Magic for a long time and recently built decks that both she and online deck evaluators consider high Bracket 3. I believe one of them also has 3 Game Changers and no basic lands.
Here's where the issue started:
Before Crystal built her own decks, she was borrowing some of Trish's really old Magic decks. They hadn't really kept up with power creep, and Crystal was having a hard time doing much of anything during our games.
I genuinely felt bad about that. I don't think it's fun to sit there while everyone else gets to play Magic and your deck just can't keep up. I was actually happy when she decided to build something new because I wanted her to be able to enjoy playing with us.
The problem is that she ended up building decks that are apparently high Bracket 3, despite everyone originally agreeing on Bracket 2. She's also made comments about being good at deck building, so her decks are probably at the top of Bracket 3.
We've played against one of these decks before, and she won on turn 5. By turn 4, it was already pretty obvious she was about to win. I understand that one game doesn't necessarily mean her deck will always perform like that, but it definitely made me question whether we're playing at the same power level.
Colette and I, along with some of the others who built custom decks, have brought up concerns about this.
The reactions have been pretty frustrating.
Erin has defended Crystal by saying things like "The bracket system doesn't actually matter" and "Do we even have faith that it's accurate at all?"
Meanwhile, some of the other girls have made comments like "Slay queen," "Destroy his ass," and "Get good" when talking about Crystal beating me.
I understand that some of this is probably just joking around. I'm usually pretty good at competitive video games, so I get that my friends might enjoy seeing me lose at something for once. But I'm genuinely a beginner at Magic. I've won one Commander game ever. I'm already very used to losing at this game, so I really don't think that's the issue.
What actually bothers me:
It's not that I think I should be winning more games.
It's that most of us deliberately built our decks around the power level we agreed on.
Colette and I could have built much stronger decks, but we intentionally chose not to. We wanted our decks to be around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons because some of our friends are completely new to card games and wouldn't really know how to build a deck themselves. When I called her out, she said, "I don’t know what I did that was wrong. I built it to follow bracket 3 rules."
Ryan even went out of his way to build a weaker themed deck because that's what he thought would be fun.
I understand that the bracket system isn't perfect. I'm sure there are Bracket 2 decks that can beat Bracket 3 decks, and I know the brackets aren't some exact measurement of how strong a deck is. But if we all agreed to build around Bracket 2, shouldn't that agreement mean something?
I'm worried that she's going to start destroying everyone with this deck and then everyone is going to slowly stop wanting to play. Ironically, that's exactly what Crystal was experiencing before she built her new decks. She was struggling to keep up with everyone else, and I don't want her to go back to that either. I just don't think the solution should be to create the same problem for other people.
I want Crystal to have fun. I want her to be able to play her deck and actually do things. I just want everyone else to have that same opportunity.
What makes this more frustrating is that I feel like I'm being treated as a sore loser just for bringing it up. I don't think wanting everyone to have a reasonably balanced game is the same thing as being upset that I lost.
We're supposed to play again this weekend, and I genuinely want to go. I really enjoy Magic, even though I'm still learning and honestly not very good at it yet. I also don't want to dictate what decks Crystal can build or tell her she isn't allowed to play something she's excited about.
But at the same time, I don't really want to spend an entire game watching someone threaten to win before the rest of us have even gotten our boards going.
And the way some of my friends have responded makes me feel like bringing this up again is just going to turn into another argument about me being a sore loser. I think its also important to not if I ever brought a bracket 3 deck to the table I would be ostracized by at least half the group without hesitation. It's a huge double standard.
I know Commander is supposed to involve Rule 0 conversations, but I feel like we already had that conversation when we agreed on Bracket 2.
So am I actually being unreasonable here? Am I putting too much importance on the bracket system? Or is it fair to be frustrated that we agreed on one power level and now some people are acting like that agreement doesn't matter?
I genuinely don't care if I lose. I just want to feel like everyone at the table has a chance to actually play Magic.