r/DungeonMasters • u/CPeterDMP • 2h ago
Don't know how to stick the landing after an 11-session adventure
I need some insight on how to end this scenario. I’m a super-experienced GM and can handle just about anything, but I’m stuck on this one as I try to resolve it in a way that is fair to the players, a fitting climax, and narratively intelligible. I’m also going to try to make this presentation as succinct as possible.
I’m running a hexcrawl in Shadowdark. We have spent the last *11* 4-hour sessions in Ironwood Gorge, an adventure that I’m pretty sure isn’t supposed to take 44 hours to resolve (though I do think it would qualify as a pretty large dungeon).
The party has made multiple forays into the dungeon trying to find and defeat the leadership of an orc army. Last night, I thought we’d get through it. They found the 2nd in command and defeated him and finally found where the orc warlord was hiding. As they pushed forward to get to his lair, their dice went stone cold, they ran out of healing, and they chose to retreat.
There are a couple story reasons why they’re still in this adventure, but from a player POV, the big loot pile is behind the warlord. The rest of the treasure in the adventure has been pretty modest (as an OSE adventure, it tends to have big loot piles rather than Shadowdark’s smaller treasures throughout the dungeon). I understand that putting 40+ hours into a single adventure, they want the prize. But it didn’t happen last night.
I think we were all a little stressed about the end of the session (for different reasons), but that’s fine. Nothing that won’t be over by our next session. Here’s my problem finally:
We ended the session and I said, “I have to think about what the orcs are going to do because you’re retreating again.” A stressed out player responded, “We’re only going to be gone a day or two; it’s not like they can recruit another 40 orcs.” That’s not the issue at all. As GM, I know how many orcs are left and here’s the problem: the *only* orc left at this point is the warlord and his two troll bodyguards! I’m not planning to add more orcs; I need to decide what *this* orc is going to do!
Why did I let this situation happen? Because for 3 sessions now, I expected them to get to the warlord, so I was fine with him hiding in his lair behind his bodyguards, but it never happened. Now I have a weird situation.
- Having the orc stay there waiting to die seems dumb without a narrative reason. Maybe he’s insane (he worships a new demon in the area).
- Having him recruit more orcs from deeper in the underground (beyond whatever random encounters spawn in as they move through the place) isn’t unfair, but it’s boring. They’ve killed more than 100 orcs at this point.
- Having him grab all his treasure (or as much as he and the trolls can carry) and running away before the PCs get back would likely get me murdered by my players.
- Maybe he leaves with the best of his treasures to travel light and gets away, but that deprives the PCs of the best stuff and is pretty anticlimactic after so long.
There’s likely more details I could explain about their situation, but I’ll address that in the comments as needed. What’s the most fair, most interesting, most narratively logical way to resolve my situation? TIA.