r/DungeonMasters • u/TroupeMaster_Grimm • Apr 08 '26
r/DungeonMasters • u/HollowPersona • Feb 05 '26
Discussion Black D&D Community Seeking DMs for Upcoming Campaigns
Hello!
I love D&D, and I’ve been looking for more Black people to play with, so I recently created a small digital community for Black D&D players. The community is a mix of new and veteran players, but we’ve got ~10 aspiring PCs and only one potential DM so far. Are there any Black DMs who’d be interested in joining? Bonus points if you’re on the East Coast. We’ve got a few people that are in the PA/NY/NJ area and would like to have in person sessions if possible, but there will be virtual sessions too so it’s not at all required.
For added context, we’ll probably be running 5e or 5.5e & we’re looking to begin campaign planning in the next few days.
Leave a comment in the thread below or shoot me a message if you’re interested. Adults only please as most people in the group are 30+. Hope to hear from you soon!
r/DungeonMasters • u/Dragontempl8 • Jul 16 '25
Why do you use (or NOT use) a Game Master's screen?
I often hear about it simply as a technical tool—to hide dice, display tables, cards, etc.
But for me, it's always been part of the atmosphere, like lighting, music, or props.
When I opened my shop (I make screens for role-playing games), that's exactly where I started: to create an object that was not only useful, but also evocative.
Yet I don't often hear discussions about this aspect... is it underrated/overrated, or simply under-discussed?
r/DungeonMasters • u/Weary-Ad-9813 • Apr 08 '24
AI use as a GM
I've noticed thar any posts that mention AI are generally downvoted regardless of their context. I would like to have a discussion on how GMs are using it productively and responsibly to help their games.
Note that I support artists and writers and keep that in mind when I describe how I use AI as a GM.
ART: If I would normally buy a resource I do, in pdf. I snip the pics to show players on the screen in game. If I don't like the picture or a description is given without a picture, I use AI to generate something as opposed to reading the description. I use it personally for that 30 seconds of player viewing, then never again. There is zero possibility I would have commissioned art, and it allows me to be more efficient than google image search which is generally copyright contraventions... which hurts artists.
CONTENT: For things I homebrew and notes I take, I enter them into AI chat. If you let the AI know you are just loading context and content, it doesn't give you generation back. I ask the AI for feedback on NPCs and to help find connections while writing. If I am stumped I'll ask for some prompts, then generally make them my own. I find it super helpful at the end to get feedback on inconsistencies and possible side tangents. Also very handy to just ask AI to summarize the PCs previous interactions with an NPC than flipping through multiple notes.
So how do you utilize AI? I think we need to accept its usefulness and leverage it... in ways that don't hurt content generators.
r/DungeonMasters • u/YossarianRex • Jan 14 '23
Can we all calm down just a bit? Especially here. Let’s keep our table experience as the top priority.
l understand that OGL is a big deal and the community has lost trust in WotC/Hasbro as fair stewards of the thing we love… but some of the stuff going around is just crazy. Are people seriously yoinking out 5e from multi year campaigns to make a point?
As a consumer of actual play podcasts, and other digital media the topic worries me for the content creators, as a DM/GM I don’t care as much. I have my own opinions and will do what I can from that side, but the table is a space where we should enjoy our time, anything else is a distraction.
The point of this hobby is to have fun with a group of friends, not make a statement with your underlying system. We are building a world with our players together and I hate the idea of something like legal documents impacting that shared experience.
My players and I are going to stick with 5e until I think the enjoyment of the table would be enhanced by a different system. I’m not making that decision in support or protest of anything, i just believe we would all enjoy the game less if i changed the engine out mid way through the campaign. I look forward to our thursday game all week and I can’t imagine changing that experience due to outside influence.
I hope my fellow DMs keep their player experience top of mind when making decisions about systems.
Edit: fixed a typo and wanted to add this link in:
Legal Eagle did an amazing video on the subject.
r/DungeonMasters • u/The_Long_Island_DM • Aug 29 '26
Promotional I have a shelf of D&D books I paid for and can't open without someone's permission. 30+ years DMing, that FINALLY got to me...
EDIT / TL;DR, since a few people fairly said this is too long:
It's a free single HTML file that holds your D&D material and runs with the wifi off. SRD 5.2.1 is already in it. You drop your own PDFs in, hit spacebar mid-session to pull up a monster or a table over whatever you're running, and run initiative off it. Players join from their own browser with a code. No account, no install.
On the thing a few people asked about: nothing leaves your machine. There is no server. I don't get your books.
-end edit-
I bought my first Monster Manual in a hobby shop that doesn't exist any more. It's on a shelf behind me right now. It has my handwriting in the margins from a campaign I ran in 1998, and a sticky note in the back that I have never once had to ask anyone for permission to read.
Most of what I've bought in the last ten years isn't like that.
I want to be careful here, because this turns into a fight fast and it doesn't need to. I'm not mad at any one company. The digital tools are genuinely good. I use them. Half the reason I can still run a game on a Tuesday after a ten-hour shift is that something else is doing the lookup for me. I am not arguing we should go back to flipping pages under a bad lamp.
What I'm saying is narrower and I think most of you have felt it even if you haven't put it into words: I paid for those books, and I still can't open one without their servers. THAT is kinda not great. When you're not thrilled about the direction some TTRPGs are heading it's even worse when you're a big fan.
Not even talking about "if the company folds." Not some doomsday thing. Just the ordinary version. The wifi at the game store is bad. You're running at a cabin. The app updates and the thing you had bookmarked moved. The account you bought it on was tied to an email you don't use.
As a person who has been doing this a long time: my books used to accumulate. 30+ years of purchases turned into a shelf, and the shelf is a real object that got better as it got bigger. It has my notes in it. I can hand a piece of it to a player and say start here. When I die somebody will carry it out of the house in a box.
The digital version doesn't accumulate. It sits in someone's account, in someone's format, on someone's terms, and it is exactly as durable as the company's decision to keep supporting it. This is great for them but not great for us.
I'm not claiming this is a crisis. Nobody has taken my books away. It's the smaller, more annoying stuff. I have been buying things for a decade that I don't fully have. I basically rent it.
What I actually wanted :D
Not a rebellion. Just the things I own in a format that won't fail me as often.
I wanted one file that opens in a browser with nothing else installed, that holds whatever I own, that works with the wifi off, and that doesn't ask me who I am. I wanted to be able to drop a PDF I already bought into it and have it sit next to everything else, searchable. And I wanted to be able to put the whole thing on a USB stick and know that the stick is the shelf, the way a shelf is a shelf for regular old-school books.
That's it. That's the entire ambition. It's not clever and it's not a business plan. I was making a thing i wanted to use. WELL WHY NOT JUST BUY BOOKS!?
I DO. I like the look of a real bookshelf packed with books. But as a paid DM I spend a lot of time traveling and it's easier to have an entire digital library with me than what books I THINK I might need because the players juke my story.
So I built it, because nobody was going to build something that unprofitable for me. It's called Gnasher's Grimoire, it's a single HTML file, it's free, and it's here if you want it: https://longislanddungeonmaster.itch.io/gnashers-grimoire
It comes with SRD 5.2.1 already in it so there's nothing to set up, you can drag your own material in, and there's a search box you hit with the spacebar that pulls any table or monster over whatever scene you're already running. There's an initiative tracker that pulls from whatever you've installed. Your players can link in from their own browsers off a code with no account and no server. It exports your whole binder to one file you can back up. Or just copy it. Throw your own stuff in there. I have some stuff to steal.
I'm not going to do the feature list here, because that isn't the point of the post and you can go look if you are interested. The point of the post is the Grimoire, and anyone who wants a tool a 30+ year forever DM was making for himself. I realized there might be more people looking to free themselves up from the shackles of corporate greed and fees. In the end I hope some like-minded people get some use out of it. It communicates to a player version "Satchel" as a compainion. I also have a session recorder "Quill" that runs local on your machine that I am pretty proud of. You do need to give it a dictionary of your fantasy names, places and special words so it dosent guess. The transcript is made by your own cpu/gpu so you own your session, not the cloud. In case anyone might find that useful. In case ANYONE would find any of this useful.
It is all indeed a works in progress with more features coming out all the time. So just be aware of that. IF you do decide to use any of it, I would check back now and again for new features and fixes. I am the only one currently testing it at a table so again if anyone does decide to give it a try, I would LOVE any feedback, bugs or things you would also want to see, things that worked well, things that didn't. The plan is to keep it feature-rich and always free.
Side question for anyone still reading
I've been wondering whether the accumulation thing is real or whether I'm just a grognard. Maybe both.
Because there's a decent counter-argument. Physical books didn't accumulate that well either. They got lost, loaned out, water damaged, left at someone's apartment. Half my 2e collection is gone and I have no idea where. And searching a digital library beats searching a shelf so badly it isn't a contest. Maybe "I own it" was always a bit of a story we told ourselves about a thing that was mostly just near us. If I actually had my whole physical collection of every book that I ever had, I'm not even sure where I'd put them all. My wife certanly would not be amused lol.
Does the ownership thing actually matter at your table, or is it a feeling? Has it ever bitten you for real, mid-session, or is it one of those anxieties that never once cashes out?
And for the people who have gone the other way and put everything into one ecosystem on purpose, I'd genuinely like to hear that.
-LIDM
r/DungeonMasters • u/Acceptable-Sell8854 • Jan 13 '25
my my player killed five orcs and a three trolls by doing the macarena.
my player, a level 11 bard, decided to do the macarena in a dungeon surrounded by a trolls and orcs, trying to pursuade them into joining her, she rolled a nat fucking twenty. The orcs and trolls then proceeded to DANCE THEM SELVES TO DEATH, as the went along in the dungeon later dying in lava dropped from a trapped door after failing a sphinx's riddle and i got a happy ending :)
r/DungeonMasters • u/DnDttrpg • 11d ago
Discussion Can DMs fudge roles?
TLDR: IF THEY WANT TO YES
Edit: Too many comments to to keep up with. I've posted what the rules say, I've said my part. Keep discussing if you like or arguing if you can't read, I'm not replying any more because if you disagree you're wrong. Oh and for the record any "but it's ChEaTiNg" shut the fuck up.
Not really a discussion more just making a loud point because I've just been in a pretty heavy debate with someone in the comments of a post where I've been called a plethora of names and talked down to for thinking it's okay for the DM to fudge roles
I just want to pull up evidence that that rules even says the DM is the one who makes the rules and can fudge roles.
page 235 of the 2014 DMG: Rolling behind a screen lets you fudge the results if you want to. If two critical hits in a row would kill a character, you could change the second critical hit into a normal hit, or even a miss."
page 5 2024 DMG: the DM is the final arbiter of the rules and can modify them to fit the table
page 4 of the D&D Origins from 1974 Men and Magic: the referee/DM has final say over how the game and rules are run.
D&D has a BASE line of rules that the DM can do what the want with
If you personally don't like it when DMs fudge roles or roll behind a screen, then don't join tables where the DM roles behind a screen
But you don't get to insult people or call DMs "cheaters" or "have no imagination" when they decide what they roll is actually a different number.
r/DungeonMasters • u/Worth-Cranberry2739 • Dec 24 '23
Party's bard literally moonwalked me
My party's bard with entertainer background used his ability to perform and get free food and a room, however, the first time he use that mechanic, he sang, i gave him inspiration + 3d20 gold for the effort. He tried to make it more times like it was an inspiration factory, so i told him "dude, it was great the first time but i know what you're trying to do", he understood. Next time he made it again, however, he sang Billie Jean from MJ, he says "i want to make the moonwalk", i said: "Hmm... okay roll for performance, nat 20 difficulty". He said to me "roll me this" and literally performed a perfect moonwalk in the room (irl, not as a character). Well, i gave him free room, food, inspiration and 2d100 + 10 times his charisma mod gold (50). He gained 230 gold that night. The only reason i didn't gave him 1d3 hookers is bcs there was two girls in the room.
r/DungeonMasters • u/Prestigious-Head-725 • Jan 02 '26
Need 1-3 players for a dnd campaign, hmu
My friend who is a dm running a current campaign, needs 1-3 more people for the campaign, currently we have a Myconid Druid, Goliath blood hunter, and a warlock tiefling. However you must be above 18+ as the campaign deals with nsfw subjects that might trigger or cause uncomfortability. It is full of fun mix of fantastical whimsy and brutal horror and there is a lot of goblins and dungeons! So if anyone is interested it would be really great; hmu.
r/DungeonMasters • u/Icefrosttv • Jan 20 '25
Seen this a few times
I don't post but thought I'd try it it seems fun
r/DungeonMasters • u/Fiddlesticck • Sep 15 '24
I need to actually develop this world so hopefully this will help
So for a little background this dimension is the first layer of a sort of hell, each layer representing a seven deadly sin. The first layer is the plains of greed and it is mostly an immensely large plains biome with various cities from the material plane that were pulled into it one way or another.
r/DungeonMasters • u/Delirious_Reache • Jan 11 '26
Why not fudge every number in combat?
I think this is ultimately the wrong approach but I'd like to hear what the pitfalls or experiences actually are.
but... Why even plan encounter difficulty? Why stress about CR budget and attrition etc etc? Why pre-plan hit points or even abilities and attack bonuses of your monsters? Why not just improvise a narratively satisfying moment for the enemies to die? Why not fabricate every die roll and saving throw bonus to create the appropriate amount of challenge?
I expect this secretly sucks the life out of the game, just the way using console commands just to fix a bug in video games suddenly shatters the suspension of disbelief.
How much do you make up numbers to make too hard combats work out in your PCs favor and up the challenge on fights that were unexpectedly too easy? Where do you draw the line?
r/DungeonMasters • u/kellybarnard • May 17 '26
Bluetooth Dice Tower I have been working on
The Idea was to make a dice tower that could be passed around the table for secret rolls. I have tried a tower in my DM screens a portable tower that I move around the room and use, but I wanted one that could just be passed around see their rolls and give them back their dice.
What do you think, would you use something like this?
I made a Android and Windows Desktop App that works with it.
r/DungeonMasters • u/leftwordslopingpenis • Jan 16 '25
I know posts like this are common, but I’ve lost motivation to build my world. Help me back into it
r/DungeonMasters • u/aweshum • Sep 02 '26
Discussion (Vent/Advice) I just don't have the courage to change systems
I want to change systems but I'm so terrified of the way so many systems favor the player the further on they level. And so many systems don't give the DM enough support. But when i say DND, people seem to expect dnd.
I think what took me out was:
A. Running for a library where players never wanted toto learn from their character sheet.
B. Then there's the home game where one player out shined the entire table mechanically.
I think what stresses me out is:
I want to switch systems but I'm so burnt on DND that I almost don't trust other systems to help me out.
I've got Gantasy Age and Daggerheart and I can't being myself to run these games.
I'm lowkey looking for people who can relate and offer advice.
r/DungeonMasters • u/Head_Project5793 • Jun 24 '26
Discussion Player went to put bag of holding into a portable hole and I gave a restriction. Was I too harsh?
Player was in melee range with an adult red dragon. He wanted to put his bag of holding inside his portable hole, which he learned from an experienced DND player he was friends with out of game would “create a nuke” (this friend wasn’t a part of our table, just a friend of his).
I had heard this as well, but on the spot I couldn’t find anything on how that works. I ruled that there is a magnetic force between them, like pushing two positive magnets together, but it could be overcome with a dc 25 athletics check as an action. I also ruled the reaction would be instant, so he wouldn’t have time to get away and would be sacrificing himself. I told him this after asking him for a perception check which he got over a 25.
In hindsight I realized that literally all of the entire parties gold was in the bag of holding, as they never specified that it was anywhere else and always acted as though they had their 40k+ collective gold on them at all times, so I probably saved him from losing all his money even if someone could have used revivify or raise dead on him.
If he managed to succeed my plan was to deal the same damage as a meteor swarm (40d6).
My reasoning in my head on the restriction was partially based on explaining why people aren’t constantly putting these together as like a manufactured weapon, since it would require super advanced robotics just to put them together, or a powerful warrior sacrificing themselves. But in hindsight I have some regrets, it could have been a cool moment for him and everyone else, and losing all their gold would be fair karma for killing the dragon.
Was I too harsh on the restriction of a dc 25 athletics check? How do you usually rule on placing a portable hole inside a bag of holding?
r/DungeonMasters • u/Slight-Veneer • Jan 27 '26
Discussion “No” as an answer
I’ve been seeing a lot of great posts asking for advice when a player asks for something and then I get sort of let down by the amount of people whose advice is solely “just say no.”
Obviously knowing when to say no to players is very essential but when a new DM asks for advice and every tells them to just entirely dismiss the ideas of the players it feels like Reddit is training DMs to be less engaging and friendly.
What I mean by this is that if your player asks for a race/class/item, or really anything, you shouldn’t just say no (unless it’s truly broken) but you shouldn’t instead help workshop with the player a way to compromise and maintain the integrity of their idea.
I thought of this soapbox because of a wonderful post someone made about help adapting a players want to be a creature statblock as their character. A lot of people just advised to turn down the idea instead of workshopping ways to let the player still feel like their character is similar to the original idea without being too powerful. I think we need to encourage compromise and workshopping instead of fully dismissing the imagination of the players, it will be more fun for the player if they don’t get stranded playing a secondary or tertiary idea they hate.
There are levels to “no” and I think that no is much more important after session 0 for when a player character is just doing insane stuff that just isn’t right. But before and during session 0 maybe we need to replace “no” with “well how about…” and actually help our players play what they want without messing with the balance of the game. We want people to be excited to play and have fun.
Thanks for listening.
https://www.reddit.com/r/DungeonsAndDragons/s/LwvvpO4ykQ The post that inspired my soapbox.
TLDR: There are levels to “no” and we shouldn’t just offer saying no as advice to a lot of the new dm advice posts we see. It’s situational.
r/DungeonMasters • u/WarSpirit66 • Oct 13 '25
Discussion How should I deal with a large, 8 player group as a noobie dm
So rn 8 players (who are mostly noobies but there are 2 semi experienced players)
This is what I have for homebrew rules
Auto-fail: When you die, you can auto-fail all death saves and replace it with one final action.
Loony Toon Fall: When a character starts to fall, they get one action before the point of no return.
Potion bonus action: Using a potion can be a bonus action, not a singular action.
Faster Initiative: Since we have more than 5 players, I will not do Initiative and just go around the table, and once it gets to me, I will do my monsters. (or I will do half of the table go, then me, then the other half)
Static Damage for Minions (Small enemies): I will use the average damage for the smaller enemies to speed up combat.
Tactical Discussion (Party Leader): Every meeting, we will elect a “party leader” who makes all the tactical decisions for the meeting, and everyone can show and tell their opinion, but the “party leader” makes the final decision. (This rule is for limiting arguments between each other when making decisions.)
FYI, I might split the party sometimes so it is easier, but idk
Edit: Thank You everyone for helping me and this is what I'll do,
Spilt them into 4s and with differnt times but playing in the same world and once they both meet at the BBEG they will defeat him together or I'll make the other one fight the other. (but im keeping the rules. Sorry not sorry. And if they bit me in the butt, it'll be my fault)
r/DungeonMasters • u/Mr_Hirestek • Sep 14 '26
Discussion How to leave a party as a DM
Hi fellow DMS and PCS. I have a doubt.
Few friends asked me to dm for them, all new players with no background in RPG. I happily did a one shot for them, that went pretty well. Later their asked to go on so I bought the starter pack (storm wreck) and carried out in 4 sessions.
On the last two I started hearing creeks from the group, and had already decided I won't go past this campaign, since her were a lot of rescheduling, changing in personal priorities (I mead, all fair, unless you make me wait 2 months between sessions, when you all are the ones that insisted).
at the end they convinced me, now in this new campaign we are in a 6 months pause (in the summer in forbidden to play, beach has the priority) and next week they kindly agreed to start again.
now, I hate to just leave in there, and I am going to forcibly stop this campaign. will you just go for tpk and stop or will you tell them my feelings and leave it like that?
ps for suggestions about tpk, we are in a "vanilla" forgotten realms, with basic 5.5e manuals as sources.