r/DungeonMasters • u/Local_Painting9915 • 17m ago
r/DungeonMasters • u/ItIsNotAUsername • 2h ago
Discussion How was it running a "Dark Fantasy" setting? What would you recommend to someone who wants to do so?
I am currently DMing a Pathfinder game in my rather classic High fantasy setting, which i intend to destroy and punt into chaos and ruin by the time players reach level 12-14.
What was your expirience like DMing in a such setting. Are there any caviats or pitfalls one should avoid? Are there some thing that are not obvious and that you wish you had taken into account?
Perhaps you have expirience in transforming a classical hopeful fantasy world into something closer to dark fantasy setting, how did it go?
r/DungeonMasters • u/CPeterDMP • 2h ago
Don't know how to stick the landing after an 11-session adventure
I need some insight on how to end this scenario. I’m a super-experienced GM and can handle just about anything, but I’m stuck on this one as I try to resolve it in a way that is fair to the players, a fitting climax, and narratively intelligible. I’m also going to try to make this presentation as succinct as possible.
I’m running a hexcrawl in Shadowdark. We have spent the last *11* 4-hour sessions in Ironwood Gorge, an adventure that I’m pretty sure isn’t supposed to take 44 hours to resolve (though I do think it would qualify as a pretty large dungeon).
The party has made multiple forays into the dungeon trying to find and defeat the leadership of an orc army. Last night, I thought we’d get through it. They found the 2nd in command and defeated him and finally found where the orc warlord was hiding. As they pushed forward to get to his lair, their dice went stone cold, they ran out of healing, and they chose to retreat.
There are a couple story reasons why they’re still in this adventure, but from a player POV, the big loot pile is behind the warlord. The rest of the treasure in the adventure has been pretty modest (as an OSE adventure, it tends to have big loot piles rather than Shadowdark’s smaller treasures throughout the dungeon). I understand that putting 40+ hours into a single adventure, they want the prize. But it didn’t happen last night.
I think we were all a little stressed about the end of the session (for different reasons), but that’s fine. Nothing that won’t be over by our next session. Here’s my problem finally:
We ended the session and I said, “I have to think about what the orcs are going to do because you’re retreating again.” A stressed out player responded, “We’re only going to be gone a day or two; it’s not like they can recruit another 40 orcs.” That’s not the issue at all. As GM, I know how many orcs are left and here’s the problem: the *only* orc left at this point is the warlord and his two troll bodyguards! I’m not planning to add more orcs; I need to decide what *this* orc is going to do!
Why did I let this situation happen? Because for 3 sessions now, I expected them to get to the warlord, so I was fine with him hiding in his lair behind his bodyguards, but it never happened. Now I have a weird situation.
- Having the orc stay there waiting to die seems dumb without a narrative reason. Maybe he’s insane (he worships a new demon in the area).
- Having him recruit more orcs from deeper in the underground (beyond whatever random encounters spawn in as they move through the place) isn’t unfair, but it’s boring. They’ve killed more than 100 orcs at this point.
- Having him grab all his treasure (or as much as he and the trolls can carry) and running away before the PCs get back would likely get me murdered by my players.
- Maybe he leaves with the best of his treasures to travel light and gets away, but that deprives the PCs of the best stuff and is pretty anticlimactic after so long.
There’s likely more details I could explain about their situation, but I’ll address that in the comments as needed. What’s the most fair, most interesting, most narratively logical way to resolve my situation? TIA.
r/DungeonMasters • u/NoSprinkles4914 • 3h ago
Discussion Descent into Avernus - Grand Cemetery
Quando i personaggi si recano al cimitero di Hellturel per recuperare l'Elmo della Visione di Torm, si imbattono nella Cripta dell'Ascensione, dove dei demoni, aiutati da Bafometto, stanno aprendo un portale. I miei giocatori sono arrivati sul posto esausti e quasi senza slot incantesimo, avendo dato la priorità alla velocità per impedire ai demoni di organizzarsi e lanciare un assalto all'Alta Sala. Ho modificato l'incontro basandomi sulla versione "Alexandrian Remix": l'elmo si trovava al suo posto (area G11), mentre il Granduca rimaneva all'Alta Sala, incaricando i personaggi di recuperarlo. Mentre discutevano sulla loro prossima mossa, un personaggio si è avventurato nell'ossario e ha scoperto una presenza demoniaca oltre la porta.
Mi sono trovato di fronte a diversi possibili esiti:
Non succede nulla, il che non sembrava plausibile, dato che un quasit faceva la guardia all'ossario.
I demoni uccidono il personaggio (coerentemente con la loro natura), ma poi il resto del gruppo probabilmente sarebbe andato a cercarlo, solo per essere massacrato dai demoni mentre era completamente a corto di risorse.
Ho pensato che, dato che questo funge da "secondo fronte" segreto aperto dai demoni per accerchiare i diavoli e lanciare un contrattacco, il quasit potrebbe "alterare" la memoria del personaggio.
Questo porterebbe il personaggio a riferire che non c'era niente nell'ossario, spingendo il gruppo ad andarsene e dando inavvertitamente al portale più tempo per vomitare altri demoni.
P.S. Gideon è morto, ucciso da un personaggio che, secondo il suo passato, era suo amico, ma che ha concluso che Gideon era già corrotto e irrecuperabile.
Cosa ne pensi? Ora sto riconsiderando la coerenza interna di questa cosa e se forse sono stato troppo indulgente o "gentile" con il gruppo.
Il gruppo aveva appena finito un buon combattimento, collaborando e aiutandosi a vicenda – usando ogni risorsa disponibile – per recuperare l'elmo. Mi è sembrato inutilmente meschino aggiungere ulteriori complicazioni alla situazione.
r/DungeonMasters • u/Ok-Peak8152 • 6h ago
Discussion Therapeutic Program W/ DnD
reddit.comr/DungeonMasters • u/SilverCompassMaps • 7h ago
Can your players escape this Bursting Dam?
r/DungeonMasters • u/FelixMortane • 7h ago
Resource Marsh - Cinematic and battlemap - MBBT Free
Soggy ground, scattered patches of vegetation, and no clear way through. What might be lying it wait for the adventurers in the tall grasses ... or just under the surface.
This release was a request from one of our initial members to the project as an under-represented option for battlemaps.
Marsh Scene List
Marsh - Day+Night
Marsh Path - Day+Night
Marsh Fort - Day+Night (Cinematic Only)
Unbranded version, as always, are available directly on the project with the the additional images available to supporters.
r/DungeonMasters • u/Cultural_Ad2494 • 7h ago
Itsnatural20 EP. 2- The Solari Concord
I just started this live stream if there's any new dungeon Masters come watch me I'm not the best but I feel like I am up there I've had a lot of campaigns a lot of experience and a lot of fun being a dungeon master this is 5.5e
r/DungeonMasters • u/Slash2936 • 8h ago
Resource Victor the Iron Fist - A CR 15 Warlord Who Believes Peace Can Only Be Achieved Through Conquest | Tome of Villains
galleryHello, fellow adventurers!
Meet Victor the Iron Fist, a CR 15 warlord whose belief in strength, discipline, and absolute authority has turned him into a ruthless conqueror determined to forge a new empire.
What happens when a brilliant military commander decides that the only way to bring peace to the world is to conquer it?
Once a respected general in a prosperous kingdom, Victor watched as corruption and political infighting slowly weakened the nation he had sworn to protect.
Disillusioned with the rulers he once served, he eventually turned against them, seizing control of a faction of the army through a military coup before setting out to forge his own path.
Now commanding the Iron Legion, a formidable mercenary army of approximately 1,500 soldiers, Victor seeks to establish a new empire built upon discipline, strength, and unquestionable obedience.
To Victor, freedom breeds disorder, weakness invites corruption, and peace can only be maintained through the iron will of a powerful ruler.
His solution? Conquer the lands around him, eliminate those who threaten his vision, and impose a new world order through overwhelming military strength.
And he's willing to sacrifice almost anything to achieve it.
But unlike many powerful villains, Victor's greatest weapon isn't some ancient artifact or forbidden spell. It's his ability to command, organize, and lead an army capable of bringing entire kingdoms to their knees.
Mechanically, Victor is a CR 15 martial antagonist whose abilities focus on battlefield control, tactical coordination, and overwhelming physical strength.
Armed with Bloodbane, a powerful magical greatsword, Victor can deliver devastating attacks, direct his allies to strike, withstand enormous punishment, and turn his enemies' attacks against their own companions.
One of his most interesting features is a collection of Tactical Actions, allowing him to coordinate his forces directly on the battlefield.
From issuing commands that let his soldiers advance and attack, to rallying his troops, ordering supporting archers to unleash volleys, and improving his army's effectiveness, Victor is designed to feel like an actual military commander rather than simply another powerful warrior.
His entry also includes a detailed breakdown of the Iron Legion, its strengths and weaknesses, possible allies, strategies for undermining his rule, and the consequences of his eventual defeat.
And that's something I particularly like about Victor: defeating him doesn't necessarily mean dismantling his empire.
His army is held together as much by fear and the promise of gold as by loyalty. A clever party might undermine his authority, turn his mercenaries against him, infiltrate his ranks, or encourage rebellion without ever confronting his full military might.
And even if Victor falls, what happens to the thousands of soldiers who once followed him? Who fills the power vacuum left behind? And will the people he oppressed finally find peace, or simply face another struggle for control?
I think there's a lot of potential for an entire campaign built around his rise, the growing threat of the Iron Legion, and the different ways adventurers might try to bring his conquest to an end!
Victor is one of the 10 fully developed antagonists featured in my Tome of Villains, which recently received its v2.0 overhaul, featuring new artwork, revised mechanics, expanded content, and two additional appendices dedicated to creating memorable villains! Each antagonist comes with detailed lore, motivations, personality traits and flaws, plots, minions, statblocks, and possible consequences of their defeat.
Black Friday Sale!
To celebrate the DriveThruRPG Black Friday Sale, Tome of Villains is currently 40% off, alongside all my other titles! The sale runs until the end of November, making it a great opportunity to explore the collection at a discounted price!
You can also find Tome of Villains at an exclusive price on my Patreon! And if you'd simply like to follow my work, you can join for free to access plenty of previews, announcements, and regular updates on my current and upcoming projects!
r/DungeonMasters • u/BorntobeTrill • 9h ago
Faster Undermountain Exploring?
I am struggling to keep a good pace in DotMM. We're like 8 sessions in and maybe halfway done with the first level.
Sessions while Exploring feel like a slog, and the party definitely seems to have more fun while up in the city.
It feels like they debate every intersection and door that lead to nothing and by the time they get to an encounter, they're desensitized and just walk right in without any of their former discretion.
No doubt, it has to be how I'm running it. Im used to more theater of the mind and the occasional actual map, but DotMM is like, all map.
Any tips?
r/DungeonMasters • u/jimothy_johnson1 • 15h ago
Detective/mystery themed oneshot
reddit.comr/DungeonMasters • u/sassmo • 18h ago
What info do you have on your DM screen?
I just picked up a four-sided DM screen with clear plastic inserts. I'm running a specialized campaign for Obojima, but I'd really love to know what kind of information you have stuffed in your DM screens.
r/DungeonMasters • u/Davos234 • 19h ago
Give me your ideas for a druid themed adventure
reddit.comr/DungeonMasters • u/Fruta-Puta-Tuta • 19h ago
Resource There are many philosophies, which do you prefer?
r/DungeonMasters • u/Middlerogue4 • 20h ago
Discussion Trapping players in forrest
reddit.comr/DungeonMasters • u/Sapo_Escritor • 20h ago
3D Printing I designed a foldable 3D-printed GM lectern that fits in a backpack
Since I don't only GM at home, setting up my notes on cramped tables is always a hassle—and standard DM screens don't give me a good angled surface to actually read and write on. So I designed a Tri-Fold GM Lectern from scratch in OpenSCAD to solve my own table setup:
Built for real GM prep: The left and center panels hold an open A5 binder (with a folding bottom lip so it doesn't slide), while the right panel has a vertical U-slot with a thumb notch to easily slide in and swap A4 cheat sheets / system tables depending on what we're playing.
Tabletop extras on top: Dovetail top extensions add a card rail (great for conditions, initiative, or spell cards) and a compact dice tray.
Sturdy enough to write on: Instead of flimsy kickstands, the back uses 3 folding ratcheted triangle bases (35°, 45°, and 60°), so it locks firmly against the table when you lean your hand on it.
Backpack-friendly: The whole thing folds flat like an accordion (Z-fold) down to 22.5 × 31 cm (or 22.5 × 22.5 cm if you pop off the top extensions). No screws needed—the hinges just use pieces of 1.75mm filament as pins, and everything fits on a standard 250×250mm print bed.
I'm about to send this to the printer for the first physical prototype. Before I hit print, what's one feature you'd want on a portable GM lectern?
r/DungeonMasters • u/Zestyclose_Bit_1188 • 22h ago
Need help getting the tools for self-balancing
Rather than give the man a fish I'd love it if I can get some person-to-person help fully understanding and knowing how to balance some kind of specific homebrew stuff on my own, don't let me reinvent the wheel here. Go ahead and treat me like I'm a beginner also., just in case. lol
r/DungeonMasters • u/TheDoodleVoid • 1d ago
Discussion Murder Mystery campaign tips?
Hey guys! So, i’m a brand new DM, and this will be my second time ever actually running a campaign. To get myself more oriented with how rolls and stats work, I decided to make a campaign that focuses more on that aspect rather than battle, so my players are going to be solving a murder mystery. Buuut, it turns out that writing an entire mystery from scratch is… very difficult.
I have tidbits here and there, but it’s really hard to figure out how to actually have this run? But I’m stubborn and i wanna stick it out until the end.
The images are of a google doc i have of all the information ive made so far, but i’d love if anyone had some other suggestions or advice on how to actually DM this. thank you so much!
r/DungeonMasters • u/ticklecorn • 1d ago
Along The Triboar Trail: Fortune Favors the Frostbitten | FREE or PWYW Supplement
There's a dragon. There's a dungeon. So where's the loot?
You know... the riches. The plunder. The booty. The Scrooge McDuck pile of spondoolies!
One of the most glaring omissions in Dragon of Icespire Peak is that Cryovain, the adventure's titular nemesis, has no treasure hoard!
What's a dragon without a hoard? More importantly, what's an adventurer supposed to do after risking life and limb to defeat the beast, only to discover there's no treasure to claim?
Fortune Favors the Frostbitten remedies that oversight by giving Cryovain a proper hoard, with a twist. The white dragon has frozen his treasure beneath the icy rooftop of Icespire Hold, where thousands of coins, precious gemstones, and other valuables await those willing to dig them out.
Drawing upon Fizban's Treasury of Dragons, this supplement provides Dungeon Masters with:
Cryovain's Frozen Hoard. A treasure hoard worthy of a young white dragon, including suggested mundane treasures, gemstones, art objects, and magic items.
Buried Treasure. Guidance for discovering the valuables hidden beneath the ice, including Cryovain's peculiar taste in treasure.
A New Downtime Activity. Downtime rules for excavating the frozen hoard, with rewards determined by the characters' efforts over a tenday.
Hoard Recovery Complications. Six complications that might arise while the characters are busy counting their newfound riches, including unwanted attention from the Cult of the Dragon, the Zhentarim, and other interested parties.
Defeating Cryovain might be the end of Dragon of Icespire Peak, but claiming his treasure doesn't have to be. After all, finding the loot is one thing. Getting it off the mountain is something else entirely!
This supplement is available as a Free or Pay What You Want download. If you'd like to help me recoup the cost of the artwork with a contribution of your choosing, please consider the PWYW option.
The entire product can also be viewed through the preview on DMsGuild.com.
Download Along The Triboar Trail: Fortune Favors The Frostbitten here
r/DungeonMasters • u/TexasPete46 • 1d ago
I built a free combat tracker for in-person games: a second screen shows the whole table whose turn it is, HP, crits and misses
I run an in-person game at home, and I couldn't find a tracker that did everything I wanted. So I built RollForge, a free browser app for running campaigns at the table.
The GM display (what your players see)
Put it on any second screen the players can see: a monitor, TV or tablet.
Turn order as a card carousel, plus a roster sidebar, round counter, and the active creature's portrait front and center.
When you target something, it slides in beside the attacker. Damage and healing float over the portraits.
Crit, fumble, hit and miss animations. You can give each character their own clip for each one, like a custom crit animation for your barbarian.
"Roll for Initiative" and "Combat Begins" screens, and a party lineup between fights.
You choose how much HP players see for each creature: exact numbers, a vague status ("Wounded", "Bloodied"), or nothing. You can also hide a creature entirely until it's revealed.
Backdrops that change between exploring, rolling initiative and combat, with a day/night cycle (morning, day, evening, night). Images, looping video or YouTube all work.
Show handouts, NPC art or a video full-screen when you want, plus a countdown timer everyone can see.
The GM screen (what you run it from)
Initiative: roll for any creature or type it in, drag to break ties, and step forward or back through turns.
Click to target, then apply damage, healing or temp HP (temp HP absorbs damage first). Death saves for downed PCs.
Conditions, exhaustion, and reminders with round countdowns (Blessed, Raging, Hasted…). Damaging a concentrating creature prompts a concentration save with the DC.
Full stat blocks inline, DM-only notes, a 30-step undo, and a combat log.
A sound effects board, plus a party panel that tracks each PC's HP and gold between fights.
Prep
Library: your party, NPCs and monsters, items, images, battle maps and sound effects in one place.
Monster search from the 5e SRD (by name, type, size or CR) that imports full stat blocks.
Import characters from public D&D Beyond sheets (stats, HP, AC, portrait and gold).
Encounter builder: add your whole party in one click, mix in monsters, and set a backdrop for each encounter.
Shops: build a shop, put it on the display, or send it to players' phones. They request purchases, you approve them (haggling allowed), and gold and stock update.
Extras
Players can follow along on their phones by scanning a QR code, but it's optional.
If you use a TV as a battle map, there's a separate battle map screen with square or hex grids, an adjustable scale (with a 43" TV preset for minis), and fog of war you reveal with a brush.
Multiple campaigns per account.
It's free, with no paywall or subscription and nothing to install. You can try a demo campaign without signing up: https://rollforge.gg
Fair warning: it's still early. I've been running my own table with it every session and it's held up so far, but you'll probably hit some rough edges or bugs. If something breaks, tell me and I'll fix it.
The monster search uses the 5e/2024 SRD, but the tracker itself is just initiative, HP and conditions, so it should work for most d20 games.
It's built for in-person tables, since there are already plenty of tools for online play. I'd really like feedback from GMs who run in person:
What would stop you from using this at your table?
What's missing from the GM side?