r/DebateAbortion • • Aug 01 '21

Rights don't afford you the ability to violate other rights

27 Upvotes

One of the more mildly annoying points I encounter when debating pro-life is that abortion somehow violates the human rights of the unborn. When prompted about it, they usually resort to stating that its right to life has been violated. I'm going to address this specific point.

Rights as a concept mean that they are not only inherent but inalienable. In other words, they are not meant to be taken away. Now, with this in mind, remind yourself what right to life implies.

In practice, all right to life does is protect your life from being taken without justification or for an arbitrary reason. It has clear limits from this alone, but one key limit is justification. Another right people have is bodily autonomy, wherein you alone are the sole sovereign of your own body. In essence, it protects your body from unwanted use.

If someone is using your body against your will, you are justified in making them stop. This includes even if they will die as a result. Some other examples of where this principle applies are as follows: Organ donation, rape, and self defense.


r/DebateAbortion • • Aug 01 '21

Welcome!

24 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

Due to dissatisfaction from all sides with r/abortiondebate, some people thought of starting a new sub. On a whim, and to not lose the name, I started r/DebateAbortion.

I wanted to start a post where we could pool together ideas for this sub, most importantly a list of rules, an “about” section, and what, if anything, we could put on the sidebar. Please bring any ideas you have, even if it is just something that you didn’t like about other subs that you’d like to see not repeated here.


r/DebateAbortion • • Oct 01 '21

5 Telltale Signs of a Crisis Pregnancy Center

22 Upvotes

This July 1, 2019 article in SELF Magazine, quoted below and a link provided at the bottom for reference, provides some helpful information on the signs of a crisis pregnancy center (AKA a CPC), so girls and women who really want an abortion can more easily spot and avoid these places. I think there are still too many who don't know the difference between a clinic that provides abortions and a CPC, so they end up going to a CPC by mistake.

1st Paragraph Quote:
"Figuring out how to get good health care can be hard enough under everyday circumstances, much less when you need an abortion. In that case, it makes sense that you might jump at anyone’s offer to help you figure out your options. Unfortunately, that could lead you to a crisis pregnancy center."

Click on the link below to read the article in its entirety.

5 Telltale Signs of a Crisis Pregnancy Center | SELF

I hope this opening post on the subject of CPCs will provide some stimulating conversation, to say the least. The more participation, the better, right? :-)


r/DebateAbortion • • Aug 15 '21

Right to life is not a right to others life sustaining bodily resources

21 Upvotes

There is this common issue in the debate where

PL seems to think that right to life is a right to control the woman and stop her from refusing use of her body.

RTL does not give a fetus a right to the woman's uterus nor blood RTL does not give someone a right to someone elses blood Nor organs

RTL is just a right not to be physically attacked & deprived of life

RTL is not a right to be saved via forced bodily organ/blood donation


r/DebateAbortion • • Sep 05 '21

Thoughts?

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/DebateAbortion • • Oct 21 '21

Is "The Subjection of Women" Still True Today?

18 Upvotes

In 1869, John Stuart Mill wrote quite a lengthy essay titled "The Subjection of Women," and in it he made what I feel are many valid arguments. While his essay dealt with the possible reasons why so many men feared giving women the legal right to vote, I think Mill's arguments could be applied to why so many prolifers want abortion-ban laws passed in every state in the U.S.

This is the quote that resonates most strongly with me:

"I should like to hear somebody openly enunciating the doctrine (it is already implied in much that is written on the subject): 'It is necessary to society that women should marry and produce children. They will not do so unless compelled. Therefore it is necessary to compel them.' "

Sound familiar? It sure does to me, even though Mill wrote these words more than 100 years ago. The current abortion-ban laws are just another way to compel women to "produce children," whether some women want to produce them or not. And I have NO doubt whatsoever that prolifers will continue to deny that compelling women to produce children is their ultimate goal. But I am convinced it IS their goal nevertheless, and I think it needs to be stated constantly, no matter how many prolifers try to gaslight us into believing otherwise.


r/DebateAbortion • • Aug 01 '21

Why Should We Believe That Any Positive Rights Exist Or Even Should Be Acknowledged At Conception?

13 Upvotes

Conception seems like an oddly specific moment for rights to be granted to. Especially considering that a multitude of agents, including myself, are agnostic to these so-called rights existing in the first place. The main right of interest being the right to life.


r/DebateAbortion • • Aug 07 '21

The debate isnt actually about abortion

11 Upvotes

I've been a long standing member of the othet abortion channel for awhile. Reading commenting and posting and having my posts shitposted all over.

But i'm starting to realize, this debate has nothing to actually do with abortion. Its about who you prioritize and how they envision pregnancy

The pro-life see pregnancy as the growth of a new human.

The pro-choice see pregnancy as a condition that happens to the pregnant human

Because of this divide, there can never be an agreement neither side can every really understand the other.


r/DebateAbortion • • Jan 12 '25

We should be allowed to abort at *any* time for *any* reason

10 Upvotes

Women’s bodies are their own. Girls’ bodies are their own.

They were here first, and they shouldn’t be forced to carry to term and give birth, especially when they never wanted children in the first place.

Some people are idiots who are educated and don’t use contraception at all. Some people are ignorant and don’t have proper Sex Ed.

Canada and the USA don’t need more babies!

Overpopulation is a real problem. Too many people, not enough resources.

We don’t need more people.

I’m a millennial. When I’m old (in my 80s) I don’t give a shit if there’re people to look after me or not!!

Bottom line: nobody should be forced to carry to term and give birth just because they had sex!

Sex is for sex’s sake. Casual sex is the norm now. Sex is more important than a ZEF. Personal wants and freedoms are more important than a ZEF.

If you don’t want children, use contraception. If it fails, get an abortion.

Schools need to make Comprehensive Sex Ed mandatory so that everybody is properly educated on safe sex and aren’t told bullshit like “sex is only for marriage” and other such nonsense.

Some people, like me, have mental health issues and/or cognitive/intellectual disabilities we don’t want to pass on, so we should be allowed to abort. All women and girls should be allowed to abort

WHY should people be forced to carry to term, and only get abortions if life of the woman is at risk? Why can’t we just abort whenever we damn well choose?!

https://populationmatters.org/news/2024/08/overpopulation-causes-consequences-and-solutions/#:~:text=The%20growing%20population%20puts%20immense,challenges%20also%20arise%20from%20overpopulation.

https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/abortion-ban-lessons-around-the-world-roe-wade/?gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAABcs7hlXNwGj8xCmBGGeRpCnhfbgk&gclid=CjwKCAiAp4O8BhAkEiwAqv2UqNINXCPRVsuPP0uMhomAztMveSnac02hnkX61yP4lIbp6OFUHprELRoC8aIQAvD_BwE

https://www.cnn.com/interactive/2024/03/health/texas-abortion-law-mother-cnnphotos/

https://abcnews.go.com/US/post-roe-america-women-detail-agony-forced-carry/story?id=105563349

https://www.bmj.com/rapid-response/2011/11/01/woman-more-important-fetus

https://sites.uab.edu/humanrights/2022/06/27/rights-of-women-vs-rights-of-the-unborn/


r/DebateAbortion • • Mar 17 '24

Whether or Not a Fetus is an Individual is Irrelevant to the Topic of Abortion

9 Upvotes

Often, I will see anti-choice advocates try and argue that a fetus is an individual, or a human, or alive, or whatever. I believe this distinction is completely irrelevant to the legal debate surrounding abortion. Forrest Valkai, a pro-choice advocate, has stated that arguments can be made for life beginning at fertilization, at some arbitrary point during gestation, and at birth. He has also made the case that life doesn't ever begin, as the chain of life never ceases from pre conception to post birth (the parent, the parent's gametes, and the embryo are all alive, but they never "become" alive at any given point, creating an unbroken chain stretching billions of years into the past). But Valkai has also emphasized that all of these arguments based on biology are irrelevant to whether or not abortion should be legal.

I have heard arguments stating that a woman's reproductive organs are built to give birth, thus to disrupt that would be unnatural. I view this as being a blatant appeal to nature, but also the possibility of function does not translate to the necessity of function. What is possible for the body to do does not become what the body ought to do. It is possible for me to run a marathon because my bodily features, such as my legs, lungs, and heart, allow me to do so. That does not mean I ought to run a marathon, and it makes it no more rational to enforce a law mandating all healthy individuals with legs to run marathons.

Ultimately, the legality of abortion cannot be derived from anything biological. It requires the analysis of more nuanced and complicated social concepts such as bodily autonomy and consent to determine its legal validity.

If a woman withdrawals her consent to a sexual act at any point, including mid-intercourse, her sexual partner must cease penetration. To force themselves onto the woman after she withdrawals consent is legally classified as rape. Penetration, as it relates to rape, does not exclusively refer to sexual organs, as the usage of any object to forcefully penetrate a woman is also classified as rape. There also does not need to be any sexual pleasure involved in rape; most rapists commit their actions due to a desire to dominate and control, not explicitly for sexual pleasure. Thus, the birth of a child, which involves the penetration of the woman's sexual organ by an object, can be classified as rape if she is forced to do so against her consent. Forced birth is rape, which should make forced birth a crime.

Bodily autonomy is the right for an individual to do whatever they please with their own body without having to be forced to give up their body for others. In the U.S., if you did not sign up to be an organ donor while you were alive, your bodily autonomy is maintained after your death. This means that even if someone needs your organs to survive, your organs cannot be harvested if you did not agree to have your bodily autonomy revoked upon your death. Anti-choice advocates want to strip pregnant women of this right to bodily autonomy that a literal corpse has. This means that a literal corpse has more rights than a pregnant woman in the eyes of anti-choice. Even if I cede that a fetus is a human and has all the human rights that come with it, the woman it lives within still has the legal right to deny the fetus her uterus, just as a corpse has the legal right to deny someone their organs, someone who also has all the same human rights a fetus has.

This ultimately showcases that when it comes to the discussion of abortion, the biological point of "personhood" is completely irrelevant to whether or not abortion should be legal. Abortion should be legal due to both the literal definition of rape and the right every human has, including fetuses (given that they are humans), to bodily autonomy.


r/DebateAbortion • • Dec 15 '22

addressing another terrible pro-choice argument: the lack of experiences makes it permissible to kill children in the womb

9 Upvotes

many pro-choicers justify the killing of the most defenseless human beings because, according to pro-choicers, if they are killed, they simply wouldn't care and wouldn't know. setting aside the fact that this reasoning could apply to any sort of killing, let's look at an example where it's possible to be harmed without experiencing anything.

suppose a woman goes to a party at a frat house and becomes unconscious after drinking too much. then, the frat brothers take turn gang raping her. she wakes up the next day with no recollection of the events and goes on about her merry way not knowing what happened the night before. no stds, no pregnancy, no recordings, no rumors, or anything.

i would say that this woman was harmed even though she did not experience any of it.

utilitarians might in fact argue that this was net positive event since the gangbangers all had increased pleasure at no expense of the woman.

of course such scenarios aren't farfetched at all, as there have been numerous cases of unconscious and comatose women being raped.

there are also many other variations of the argument that you can be harmed without knowing and experiencing (such as elderly financial exploitation) that demonstrate why this pro-choice argument is wrong.


r/DebateAbortion • • Aug 05 '21

How important is intent?

8 Upvotes

Some pro-lifers who support contraception oppose IUDs because they believe that an IUD interferes with implantation and thus is what they consider an abortifacient.

Recent research provides strong evidence that copper IUDs do not interfere with implantation. When it comes to implantation interference it is almost impossible to rule out anything as potentially interfering with implantation since so many fertilizations fail to implant.

Caffeine consumption, pre-pregnancy and in early pregnancy have been associated with higher miscarriage risk.

For those who think abortion is immoral, who is more in the wrong, a person who uses and IUD to avoid pregnancy or a pregnant person who consumes copious amount of caffeine in an effort to abort?


r/DebateAbortion • • Aug 05 '21

Priority versus value

Thumbnail self.abortiondebate
8 Upvotes

r/DebateAbortion • • Nov 08 '24

At what point does a fetus become an individual?

7 Upvotes

r/DebateAbortion • • Feb 25 '24

The reasons PLers don't want to prosecute women for abortions are condescending and misogynist.

7 Upvotes

One thing PCers note is that even as PLers insist that abortion is murder, they (mostly) refuse to prosecute women who have abortions as murderers.

This is not how we treat murders of born children. In the US, if you murder your born child, you will probably wind up on death row or in prison for a long time. But PLers often insist that the woman who gets an abortion face no criminal penalty, even though the majority of abortions these days are self-administered.

This makes it obvious, to PCers, that PLers lie: both when they say abortion is murder and when they say a fetus is a child. And the reasons PLers give for this inconsistency strike me as both incredibly inconsistent and screamingly misogynist.

It usually boils down to how most women who have abortions were "coerced"--either by "the pro abortion media" or "The Abortion Industry" or their evil boyfriends. I"m not saying coercion doesn't happen, but the way PLers describe it, all women are silly empty-headed victims, easily manipulated by "the culture" (whatever that means) or the people around them. It suggests women on the whole are more malleable and easily influenced than men--unable to know what they want for themselves and lacking in agency. That is incredibly sexist.

The other reason I see a lot is "She didn't know it was a human baby!!" On Americans United for Life, they use that exact wording: "Sometimes, the lack of informed consent influences her decision, including being told the fetus is not a human baby."

To which I respond: what exactly does she think it is again? Does she think it's a puppy? A giraffe perhaps? How stupid do you think women are exactly?

The sense I get is that the reason PLers don't want to prosecute women is that they consider women to be like children: they don't have full mental acuity, and thus cannot be held responsible for their decisions. (Except for being "held responsible" for sex by being forced to give birth, of course). They don't think women are smart or adult enough, as a group, to make their own decisions and must be "gently guided" and 'protected" by pro lifers.

Tbh I'd prefer the more overt misogynic outlook of the small but growing subset who thinks that women should be prosecuted.


r/DebateAbortion • • Oct 03 '25

A simple and (so far) unbeaten argument for abortion.

6 Upvotes

My argument for abortion is: Medical autonomy of the pregnant person. I’ve argued this numerous times in informal abortion debates and have yet to hear anything but obfuscation and them kicking me from the debate out of frustration.

From google- “Medical autonomy refers to a patient's right to self-determination in their healthcare, encompassing the ability to make informed, voluntary decisions about their medical treatment without coercion or undue influence. It is a fundamental principle in medical ethics, requiring that patients be provided with complete information about their condition and treatment options to give informed consent before any procedure takes place.”

r/DebateAbortion • • Oct 08 '24

To those who favor abortion, what are your reasons?

6 Upvotes

I came across this subreddit while looking for places to share my pro-life views. I also would like to learn more about the reasons that people may support abortion.


r/DebateAbortion • • Dec 15 '22

New rule: Each poster is limited to two posts per day to allow actual discussion of the topic presented.

6 Upvotes

r/DebateAbortion • • Jun 05 '22

I don't care if the fetus is alive. I only value things that are sentient. Apples are alive and nobody cares if I kill one because it's not sentient. The same should apply to fetuses.

6 Upvotes

r/DebateAbortion • • May 12 '22

Someone just told me that a baby isn't alive until the moment he or she is born.

6 Upvotes

I didn't know such a level of ignorance was possible.


r/DebateAbortion • • Oct 09 '21

Can we discuss the craziness on the other subreddit?

6 Upvotes

Or are we keeping this place separate from that one?


r/DebateAbortion • • Jan 10 '25

Abortion should legal, because what we should value is first person subjective experience.

5 Upvotes

Debate me


r/DebateAbortion • • May 28 '24

Why should I become PL?

5 Upvotes

Prolifers give me your best argument for why you think I or anyone else should become PL.


r/DebateAbortion • • Dec 06 '22

Trusted Adult has been demodded from r/Abortiondebate

5 Upvotes

Let the max exodus commence! Although there is another abortion debate sub that was created yesterday that has gained some traction: https://www.reddit.com/r/abortiondebates?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

I'd prefer to make this our new home, since it was created prior.

Thoughts on our next moves?


r/DebateAbortion • • May 23 '26

Abortion debate (Español o Ingles) "Los fetos no son personas" Cambia mi opinion

4 Upvotes

Hola buenas! Mi opinión es la del titulo, he investigado bastante sobre el tema y quería saber sobre pro-vidas que me pudiesen refutar mi afirmación. Tambien puedo hacer debates por Discord, estoy completamente abierto a eso tambien. Hablo ingles y español.

Hello! My opinion is as stated in the title. I've researched the topic quite a bit and wanted to hear from pro-life advocates who could refute my claim. I'm also open to debates on Discord; I speak English and Spanish.