r/Abortiondebate • • Mar 17 '21

Why I'm sick and tired of being used as a prop for the pro-life agenda

451 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a woman who chose adoption.

I also strongly believe the most important word in the above sentence is "chose."  

And I'm sick and tired of pro-life using people like me as a prop for their agenda.  So, for the record:

- Just because some of us choose adoption does not mean other people should be forced to continue pregnancies against their will.

- It also does not mean pregnant people are idiots who live under rocks and need to be informed that "adoption is an option."  

- My having chosen adoption does not mean that my biological child was "saved from abortion."  Assuming that would be as dumb and inaccurate as assuming that every person who's ever chosen to become a parent "saved  their children from abortion."  I was never interested in seeking an abortion; there was never any risk that my ZEF was going to die from an elective abortion. 

But I am not in any way, shape, or form a success story for the pro-life agenda, and I don't appreciate being assumed to be one.

I'm simply a woman who made the choice I wanted to make.  If anything, I'm a success story for the pro-choice agenda (which can be succinctly summed up as: mind your own business and let pregnant people make their own decisions).

- I had a great experience with adoption - but this is solely because it was my choice and what I wanted to do.  If a pregnant person considering adoption ever wants to talk to me about my experience, I'd be happy to do so, and I'd answer their questions honestly.  But I would never tell another person that they should or must choose adoption, or that it is a better or more moral choice than terminating a pregnancy or birthing/raising the child.  Having actually experienced the whole process of pregnancy/childbirth/adoption, I am quite keenly aware that you have to have the right mindset, personality, circumstances, and resources for it to be the right choice for you.

It's the epitome of a personal, intimate choice, and the public at large should not have any say in it.  No pregnant person should be coerced or forced to make a different choice than the one they want.  It's their body, their life, their choice--period.

And if someone happen to choose abortion, I'm not going to lose one minute of sleep, or even one moment of thought, over the demise of their ZEF.  Pro-lifers can choose to obsess over it if they want to, I guess --  but I'm only going to be happy that the pregnant person got to make the choice they wanted to make. 

The same way I got to.

So, to pro-lifers who think you are making a great point when you say "adoption is an option" -- please know that you're not.  You do not speak for real-life  women like me who have actually chosen (again, there's that word: CHOSEN) that option.

Edited to add per mod request: since this is the abortion debate sub, any point I’ve made in this post is open for debate. For example, early in the post I state, “just because some of us choose adoption does not mean other people should be forced to continue pregnancies against their will.” If you are pro-life, I assume you disagree with this and could explain why.


r/Abortiondebate • • Apr 18 '20

Want Less Abortions? Fix Sex Ed.

366 Upvotes

You can’t rely on abstinence only sex education, it’s frankly unrealistic and does a huge disservice to the teenage population. Teaching them abstinence will not stop them from having sex. Instead, teach them about their body and methods of birth control rather than shaming them for having instinctive, biological urges.

Furthermore, make birth control more accessible and inexpensive. Those in poverty are more at risk for unplanned pregnancies. Make sterilization methods more accessible, advocate for accessible sterilization as doctors regularly refuse this because of some theoretical man or want of a baby.

If you don’t want abortions, fix the root of the problem rather than shaming others.


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 16 '22

I fundamentally do not believe pregnancy is "safe".

339 Upvotes

I work in labor and delivery. I have walked with thousands, if not tens of thousands of women who have delivered babies.

Their bodies go through absolute torture. It's is torture level pain to deliver a baby even with an epidural. Contractions are excruciating. The process isn't safe. Only 100 years ago, it was ROUTINE for women to die in labor. This is not a safe process to go through.

And you go through all of this while your back, hips, pelvis, and legs are already aching from the watermelon strapped to your stomach.

I've seen women die. Experience 4th degree tears who can't control their bowels. I've seen their uterus tear open and they bleed to death. I've seen women choke on their own vomit during labor. I've watched women scream at the top of their lungs for an hour and they can't even scream anymore. I've watched women seize and turn blue. I've watched a 15 year old girl deliver her baby naturally because her mother wouldn't sign thr consent form for an epidural. She needed to be punished.

No woman deserves the punishment of childbirth as a consequence of their crime of having sex. We don't torture the most sick criminals this way. Why do we torture our women with childbirth they never wanted?


r/Abortiondebate • • Jun 19 '22

Why I can’t Trust the Pro-Life Movement

310 Upvotes

What I want to do with this post is to talk about why I can never trust the intentions of pro-lifers at large. I've already made this clear when I've spoken about the history of the pro-life movement and how the views of pro-lifers as a movementlead me to believe they don't JUST want abortion banned.

However, I want to talk about how I can't trust pro-life as a movement because the tactics used by the movement at large are steeped in deliberate bad science, deception, and opposition to ACTUAL solutions.

To be generous, let’s assume that every pro-life person in this sub is 100% reasonable, genuine, and would denounce what I'm about to lay out. I’ve seen many pro-lifers support policies like increased contraceptive access. However, is that true of the wider movement? What are the consequences for women and society at large if pro-life people shape the future? Are PL organizations, politicians, and resource centers honest with their methods, or about their goals and intentions?

Given the title, I’m obviously going to argue “no”, that these organizations and politicians and movements are NOT trustworthy. To do this, I’m going to cover a few individual topics, citing case studies to illustrate the depth of my inability to trust pro-life institutions.

Crisis Pregnancy Centers

Crisis pregnancy centers are, in my view, thinly veiled fronts for religious deception to prevent abortion at any cost. Tactics they use include lying about pregnancy timelines and harmful effects of abortions as well as lying about condoms and the efficacy of birth control.

CPCs are generally affiliated with a small number of religious groups and strongly desire to be perceived as offering legitimate medical advice; they will have their employees present themselves so that they seem like medical professionals even if they have no training. This deception was at one point more regulated in California; CPCs were required to disclose what they did and did not do up front, but the Supreme Court struck down that requirement. This has led to a lack of transparency so pernicious that the California Attorney General released a Consumer Alert for CPCs this year due to their misleading claims.

State funding is being directed to these centers in many states while the very existence of centers offering abortion or services that do not lie about contraceptive options are being stripped, leaving women with worse options than before:

Nationwide, research has shown that “decreases in the social safety net have been accompanied by a growth of privately run pregnancy resource centers,” Kimport said. But her research suggests that those centers aren’t offering the same services as the social safety net providers they’re supposed to replace — and that the help they do offer comes at a cost to pregnant people, even if that cost isn’t financial.

Why in the world would I trust pro-lifers if their approach to a woman's choice is to do their best to trick, trap, and deceive them?

Pro-life Celebrities

Pro-life circles have a few "celebrities" that are well-known enough to have brand recognition or have their papers frequently cited. Two examples of the scientific "wing" of this celebrity status are David Reardon and Dr. John Thorp. Both are hacks. The first is someone that boasts a PhD in bioethics but got it from an unaccredited online college, and the second actually IS an MD, but used his credentials to travel around the US and try to use his authority to testify for anti-abortion legislation as a political agent. They are transparently pseudo-academics who leverage the appearance of legitimate science to either convince people that abortions are evil or, failing that, explicitly to sow doubt about abortion in the minds of fence-sitters to make them ambivalent to attacks on abortion:

In some cases, it is not even necessary to convince people of abortion’s dangers. It is sufficient to simply raise enough doubts about abortion that they will refuse to actively oppose the proposed anti-abortion initiative. In other words, if we can convince many of those who do not see abortion to be a “serious moral evil” that they should support anti-abortion policies that protect women and reduce abortion rates, that is a sufficiently good end to justify NRS efforts.

Another "celebrity" is Abby Johnson. Johnson is an extremely well-known pro-life advocate who previously worked for Planned Parenthood and "recanted", supposedly after being disgusted by an abortion. She's so popular that she spoke at the RNC a couple years ago. The problem is that her story doesn’t add up, and she very likely is lying about her experience after being offered the opportunity to "switch sides". This isn't a surprising tactic from the PL side; they've already used it by paying the woman behind the Roe v Wade decision to be a pro-life advocate.

Abby also advocates for exactly the kind of disingenuous tactics I described in the CPC section: to present crisis pregnancy centers as appearing to be medical and give the APPEARANCE of providing abortions. She has also been quoted talking about how she does not want pregnancy centers giving women resources past a certain point:

“If I were to open a pregnancy center, I would not have pregnancy items past six months. Are we running a charity? Are we running a place where we want women to become self-sufficient? Self-sufficient, right? Have maternity clothes, have those things available for the women while they’re pregnant, but cut them off.”

The problem is that Abby not only wants to prevent abortions, she also is against many forms of birth control and has an entire section of her website dedicated to how dangerous birth control can be. So... she wants to lie to women to get them to not have abortions, restrict birth control, and then when women are a few months into raising that baby, "cut them off". That's her philosophy. And she has enough sway to be on the national Republican stage.

She is also so right-wing that she believes that “In a Godly household, the husband would get the final say", referring to her opinion that every household should have one vote (leaving out the woman's voice). Incidentally, she also has said that it's smart for police to racially profile, which isn't really related but just reflects on how shitty her policy recommendations are and how dangerous listening to her views would be.

Another huge name is Lila Rose. Lila is every bit the right-wing hack that Abby is, believing that contraception is against God’s design and has made appearances on the far-right media circuit, from the Daily Wire to Tucker Carlson to Candace Owens. She is the founder of LiveAction, a website I see cited quite a bit by pro-lifers. The problem is that it's known for conspiracy theories and pseudo-science, like the time they spread false claims about abortions being done to harvest baby genitalia.

These women are two of the biggest pro-life advocates in the nation...

There are also people in genuine seats of power that make it clear that pro-life advocate are not just interested in targeting abortion either: Marsha Blackburn spelled out that she was targeting the Supreme Court contraception ruling.

How could I possibly trust pro-lifers if their thought leaders are frauds, tricksters, liars, and often support explicitly theocratic lifestyles?

Pro-life ideas don’t work

Finally, it's just plain clear that pro-life policy ideas aren't helpful. Abortion bans often hurt women who WANT kids but need medical treatment, defunding abortion providers often results in negative outcomes, and to add salt to the wound conservative lawmakers sometimes flat-out admit that they don't give a shit about embryos outside of a woman's body, so pro-life policy makers are often terrible at being pro-life.

To add a final nail to the coffin, I decided to take it upon myself to see how certain attitudes towards abortion panned out in outcomes for babies and mothers. I did so state by state. The results were completely unsurprising: when you sort states by the number of abortion restrictions, a clear divide occurs where negative outcomes track across the board with those states. The same is true when you sort by abortion restrictions that conflict with science, and again when you sort by infant mortality. These associations aren't perfect, but at a macro scale these states very clearly separate into "red" states and "green" states, where these negative outcomes are paired together with anti-abortion policies. For those interested, my sources were as follows for the Infant Mortality Rate, the Maternal Mortality Rate, numbers on the Teen Birth Rate, quantifying the Number of Restrictive Policies, and the Number of Restrictions that Conflict with Science.

How can I trust pro-lifers when the results of their policy decisions are bad outcomes for infants, teen pregnancy, and mothers?

Conclusion

So, to summarize, even if I trust the views of PLers on this sub and genuinely believe that they'd support good policy decisions, I can’t trust that PL organizations at large don't want to pursue horrifying goals. Perhaps in another post I'll go into more detail about pro-life organizations and politicians and how they pursue additional projects like advancing homophobia, but for now I think I've put enough here to be a bit overwhelming.

Simply put, I think that pro-life organizations, thought leaders, and policies are all deceptive and lead to negative outcomes for all involved. Because of this, no matter how genuine and convincing I might find an INDIVIDUAL pro-lifer on this sub (and to be clear, I don't; I'm speaking hypothetically), I don't think I could ever trust that the pro-life movement AT LARGE would follow the policies of that convincing pro-lifer. I think, given power, the pro-life movement would gladly institute theocratic policies that empirically harm women and infants, restrict access to contraception, and they would center those policies on a pyramid of liars, hucksters, and frauds.


r/Abortiondebate • • May 20 '19

Why there shouldn't be exceptions for rape

267 Upvotes

People get really into the idea that with abortion bans, rape victims should always be exempted and allowed to get an abortion if desired. But this would actually be a REALLY bad idea.

If the only ways to get an abortion were because you were raped, or your pregnancy is endangering your life, then we would probably see an increase in false rape claims. People could just claim they were raped, as a way to get an abortion. This would further reduce the credibility of real rape victims, which is already an issue in our society that causes many victims to not even speak out.

And then when this happens, the state governments would begin trying to enforce it by saying that you can only get an abortion if you filed a police report, and then if your rapist was convicted. But so many rape cases do not end in convictions (for a variety of reasons), so this would actually end up hurting real rape victims more than anything.

And so, the best way to allow rape victims to get abortions, is to keep abortion legal for everyone in the first place.


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 31 '21

My story, for those who are against abortion.

229 Upvotes

I got pregnant at 13, before you say anything continue reading. (I am now 19)

When I was 12, I started having problem going to school, same symptoms as being sick to the point of throwing up was part of my life. I had started anxiety as soon as 6 years old in extremely low stage obviously but it got up to the point I could no longer function.

I started going on sites to hook up and that’s how it started. The first time I had sex had been the only try I would need to get pregnant at 13. I knew after a month and 2 weeks that I finally had to talk to my parents and admit everything. I was supposed to go in a 4 month program sort of like an hospital to get checked out and get meds. I had to wait and postpone my entry a few weeks after the abortion.

Now I will tell you why I had made the decision even if I would have wanted to keep it, it wasn’t going to work. I’ve been diagnosed with Asperger syndrome, Borderlines Personality Disorder, Major depression, ADHD, anxiety. I started taking 14 pills a day to fix everything.

To make it short, if you can’t really understand just from the paragraph how bad it would be to not have an abortion, here is why. Medication can cause many problems during both and after pregnancy, possibly kill the foetus before it even develops and. I was nowhere near treated completely, to this day I somewhat struggle to keep a daily routine. My mental health would have been a nuisance to a newborn or a child, while also being new in the province without proper healthcare, not speaking english yet.

Abortion are needed for teens, you cannot have a teen give life before they even develop completely themselves. It made me think about something I saw a meme from the US saying that there was a debate saying if TEENS were mature enough to chose to have an abortion. I saw the reply and never more agreed with something; “This teen isn’t mature enough, let’s give her a child.”

If you have anything to say about my story go ahead, but I made my choice and it was the right one.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 24 '20

This subreddit has become very biased

205 Upvotes

I don't tend to post on this sub, but I just wanted to point out that pro-lifers are being downvoted a lot while pro-choicers are being upvoted a lot even when pro-lifers are making good quality arguments, they still get downvoted. I feel as if people are less voting based on quality of argument and more voting based on stance. I just felt the need to point this out. I'm not sure what the moderators' guidance on voting is, but I just wanted to point out that I feel as if this sub is very pro-choice dominated and leaning when it comes to voting.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 18 '22

General debate I thought this wouldn't happen?

203 Upvotes

I remember a few conversations with some PL who insisted stuff like this wouldn't happen.

Even when faced with evidence of it happening in other countries such as Poland and Ireland, I was told that America is diffrent, that it would never happen. And yet...

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/wisconsin-miscarriage-roe-v-wade-abortion-b2125168.html

"A woman in Wisconsin was left to bleed for more than 10 days after suffering an incomplete miscarriage as doctors in the state struggle to navigate abortion laws in a post-Roe America."

"However because of Wisconsin’s outright ban on abortion, the woman was turned away by emergency room staff at a hospital in the state."

"However, in the meantime, abortion providers have been forced to stop providing care and doctors are clamouring to understand how to treat patients, including women suffering miscarriages, ectopic pregnancies and other complications."

Now I'd like to bring back this post that I made months ago. https://www.reddit.com/r/Abortiondebate/comments/ulf8nm/abortion_being_illegal_could_make_doctors_too/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

Bringing up 5 victims of abortion bans, the first 3 were a result of miscarriages and doctors being too scared to act fast enough to save their lives.

Now the lady above is just the first report, who knows how many women now are going through the same thing, or how many have died because of this.

Abortion bans don't just stop women from getting abortions to healthy embryos and cell clusters, but also to those who have already died or are dying very slowly and painfully.

Can you really continue to ignore this?

It isn't on the doctors, it's on the ban that would see them falsely imprisoned for up to 6 years.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jun 26 '22

Pro-lifers Must Own the Consequences of the Roe Decision

192 Upvotes

TL;DR: Pro-lifers, this decision has FUCKED a lot of people that wanted to be mothers but are in difficult positions, and it's put in danger a lot of important freedoms. You do not get to pretend these are not a direct result of your ideas; they are the end-result of them, and you will have to own the consequences of it now.

Pro-lifers got a major victory this week that was decades in the making. I'm sure they're very happy, but I'm going to be a little raincloud on that parade today. I've said this before, but I'll say it again: we can talk about abortion as this abstract set of ideas and concepts on this subreddit, but out there in the real world there are real consequences to decisions that are made. People's lives impacted. This isn't a game. What I want to make absolutely clear to the pro-life side is the actual end-result of the repeal of Roe so none of the pro-lifers can try and wiggle or squirm or shift responsibility for the consequences. There are going to be tragedies that are an end-result of this decision, and they do not get to pretend those tragedies have nothing to do with the pro-life movement.

For the sake of this post, I'm going to put aside for a minute all of the women that have no external reason for an abortion other than a lack of desire to be a mother. While I think that moral consideration does not need to be given to an embryo, nor would its right to life override a woman's autonomy if the embryo was owed consideration, I have no doubt that no pro-lifer will shed a tear over women being unable to end their pregnancy at will, so I won't bother talking about things they won't empathize with. I'll be talking about the consequences to those that wanted the pregnancy or are in difficult straits and show how this decision absolutely fucks them, as well as many other people whose rights are going to be collateral damage in the wake of this decision.

But let's get one thing out of the way first:

This was not about states' rights

Lately I've been seeing a lot of talk about "states' rights" being important to this discussion or the excuse "It's not a ban! It's just pushing it back to the states!'

What a crock of bullshit. To pro-lifers, don't pretend you actually care about a state regulating its own laws democratically. You insult the intelligence of everyone in this sub when you make argument.

You don't think it's acceptable to let abortion happen in some states that still want it; you'll keep opposing abortion in those states as well. You do NOT want a democratic decision to be made on this topic and leave it at that. You want a victory against abortion and kicking the decision back to the states allows for the atomization of the defense of abortion rights, and those rights are then more vulnerable to be apart by the same old tricks the conservatives were using already: unnecessary clinic requirements, bans, and gerrymandering away people’s democratic voices. I'd respect you more if you didn’t pretend it was about letting states decide individually; this is clearly a political tactic using states as an intermediary to a total ban. You can occasionally get a pro-lifer to outright admit to this, but we don't really need to get the admission. It's patently obvious what the next steps are. Mitch McConnell hinted at a federal ban, but Mike Pence went further and outright called for one. Republicans are already salivating over the idea.

To put another nail in the coffin of the idea that the Roe take-down was about leaving it up to "democracy" and the states, the majority of Americans wanted Roe in place. In fact, in thirty years of polling, support for repealing Roe has never risen above 36%. Other sources find close results.

So, to all pro-lifers, please stop pretending. Either you're lying to me or you're lying to yourself, and I'm no longer willing to tolerate the dishonesty. Just be honest that you wanted it banned and that this decision was a steppingstone towards that goal. I could at least respect that tactic, even if I couldn't respect the goal.

Now let's get to the main points.

Consequences to health:

It's well-known that places that defund clinics to get at abortion have worse health outcomes. However, this is something that pro-lifers can just use excuse by saying: "I don't want to ban all abortions; I think those that are life-saving should be allowed!"

Well, once again we're running afoul of fucking reality. In the real world, doctors don't have a crystal ball that allows them to determine the exact likelihood of harm of a pregnancy. When they detect an issue, they have to use their judgement and inform the patient of the risks and the likely outcomes. Threatening their license and their freedom over medical decisions has an enormous chilling effect on whether or not they're able to help women in need:

Some Texas providers are afraid to treat an ectopic pregnancy when fetal cardiac activity is present because it would terminate the pregnancy, albeit a non-viable pregnancy that threatens the pregnant person’s life. Other patients suffering from premature labor in previable pregnancies, where abortion is often medically indicated to prevent infection, sepsis, and death in the pregnant person, have also traveled to other states in the middle of a medical emergency to access care. Pregnancy loss is inevitable in these situations. But because the fetal heart has not yet stopped beating on its own, pregnant people are left to suffer and potentially die waiting or travel out of state to access care.

Most women who get abortions are in poverty or poor, which means that the ones that have to travel to other states are the lucky ones. What's just as bad is that the treatment for miscarriages is often the exact same abortion pills given to women to terminate a pregnancy and doctors are already turning women away from getting this vital medication. This leaves already-distraught women with new issues, such as health threats. These issues are disproportionately going to affect women who cannot access resources or health care, and those women were already the majority seeking abortions.

Abortions that are done at or later than viability are often done because the pregnancy is likely not viable and the mother has to make a terrible choice, or because the pregnancy represents a threat to her health. In both cases, pro-life laws CONSISTENLY interfere with a mother's access to health care.

Much of this issue is caused by the deliberate vagueness written into anti-abortion laws that tie doctor's hands when it comes to abortion and when they can step in. For example, in Arkansas a pregnancy cannot be terminated unless it's a medical emergency:

“Medical emergency” means a condition in which an abortion is necessary to preserve the life of a pregnant woman whose life is endangered by a physical disorder, physical illness, or physical injury, including a life-endangering physical condition caused by or arising from the pregnancy itself;

When a situation arises that meets this criteria, the woman in question is already in serious trouble, and any pregnancies that are not immediate health emergencies are not allowed. An example of this is a woman in Texas whose water broke at 19 weeks and was at risk of sepsis but could not get a procedure done in-state. This is barbaric.

Even when a pregnancy is not a significant danger to the mother, denying abortion access puts women in gut-wrenching positions. For example, a woman in Ohio that wanted her baby but found out it was stillborn met difficulties ending her pregnancy. Another woman who wanted her baby had to fly 2000 miles for an abortion. She didn't want to have one, even if her baby was extremely disabled, but learned the hard truth from her doctor about what the condition her baby would be born with was like:

“What can she do?” I asked. “Does a child like mine just sleep all day?”

He winced at the question. “Children like yours are not generally comfortable enough to sleep.”

These women deserve the ability to make decisions about their body and their baby without legislation preventing them from doing so. Terminating a pregnancy like this shouldn't be a luxury only afforded to some.

The states with trigger laws also did not prepare to answer the hard questions about how to implement the abortion bans, despite having those laws on the books for (in some cases) nearly two decades and knowing this decision was going to happen. How will the rape and incest exceptions be handled? How will doctors know what qualifies as danger to the mother? None of these questions were answered properly, leaving medical professionals confused as to what abortions would get them prosecuted or not.

Another difficult case to talk about is abuse victims. Abuse often begins or gets worse during pregnancy, and homicide is common during this vulnerable time. Women in this situation are often left with a tough choice between being bound to their abuser and left in poverty or termination, as one woman describes in her story.

And part of the true tragedy of this is that once these women are in these positions, the empathy that pro-lifers are so willing to extend to pregnant women suddenly runs out and all that's left is impotent gestures. For example, as per u/ComfortableMess3145's recent post, women are largely abandoned to homelessness and poverty once they are convinced to keep a pregnancy. This isn't an isolated incident; as I've pointed out before, pro-life groups are not only more than willing to mislead and lie to women to get them to keep pregnancies, but to make it POLICY to refuse them continuous help. According to Abby Johnson, a woman so important to the pro-life movement that she got to speak at the RNC:

“If I were to open a pregnancy center, I would not have pregnancy items past six months. Are we running a charity? Are we running a place where we want women to become self-sufficient? Self-sufficient, right? Have maternity clothes, have those things available for the women while they’re pregnant, but cut them off.”

Pro-life policies endanger pregnant women in need and offer little help to those that need it.

The pro-life side is the reason that a mother would be denied an abortion and forced to pass a failed pregnancy naturally and painfully. It would leave a mother screaming in agony with no recourse. The pro-life side is the reason someone can be denied necessary medication. Those that DID have access to abortion, despite wanting their pregnancy, describe the relief of having access to the pills or not having to give birth to a baby whose brain was floating in her uterus.

Consequences beyond pregnancy:

The targeting of Roe was something that most conservatives saw coming and were willing (happily) to acknowledge was likely. However, what I'm seeing a lot of is either a hesitance or outright refusal to acknowledge that this decision opens the door for other rights to be stripped, such as gay marriage and contraceptive access, and that the goal is to do so. However, this is just weaseling out of what is patently obvious. Let's take gay marriage for example, and examine the 2016 (which is also the 2020) Republican Party Platform:

We condemn the Supreme Court’s ruling in United States v. Windsor, which wrongly removed the ability of Congress to define marriage policy in federal law. We also condemn the Supreme Court’s lawless ruling in Obergefell v. Hodges, which in the words of the late Justice Antonin Scalia, was a “judicial Putsch” — full of “silly extravagances” — that reduced “the disciplined legal reasoning of John Marshall and Joseph Storey to the mystical aphorisms of a fortune cookie.” In Obergefell, five unelected lawyers robbed 320 million Americans of their legitimate constitutional authority to define marriage as the union of one man and one woman. The Court twisted the meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment beyond recognition. To echo Scalia, we dissent. We, therefore, support the appointment of justices and judges who respect the constitutional limits on their power and respect the authority of the states to decide such fundamental social questions...

We understand that only by electing a Republican president in 2016 will America have the opportunity for up to five new constitutionally-minded Supreme Court justices appointed to fill vacancies on the Court. Only such appointments will enable courts to begin to reverse the long line of activist decisions — including Roe, Obergefell, and the Obamacare cases

So Roe was never the only thing on the chopping block. Gay marriage and contraceptive access are things that conservatives have explicitly said they're targeting. Interracial marriage was also decided using the same legal reasoning, so this decision puts that in danger as well. If you think there's no one that thinks interracial marriage should be targeted you're not paying attention, as a US Senator (Indiana) Mike Braun said the following:

Question: So you would be OK with the Supreme Court leaving the question of interracial marriage to the states?

Answer: Yes, I think that that's something that if you're not wanting the Supreme Court to weigh in on issues like that, you're not going to be able to have your cake and eat it too. I think that's hypocritical.

Senator Braun claims that he misunderstood the question, but the transcript makes it clear that he was asked the question twice, in both cases making it clear the question was about interracial marriage. He didn't misunderstand.

So, pro-lifers... this is the world your victory has put us in.

What the Roe repeal means to me personally

Generally speaking I try to keep my posts about a specific topic, and not go into personal anecdotes. However, in light of this pro-life victory, I feel it's very important to let you know how you've affected the lives of REAL PEOPLE.

I live in Texas. My wife and I want to start trying for kids soon. The trouble is that she has a history of miscarriage on her side of the family. We don't yet know the likelihood that we'll have issues, but it's entirely possible that we'll struggle. The day the decision to repeal Roe happened, she cried in my arms for several minutes out of fear and anger and despair.

Why? Well, a callous pro-lifer would snort and say "she just wanted to kill her baby" or some such horseshit. The problem is that this couldn't be farther from the truth. She’s wanted to be a mom for years now and was waiting on me to finish grad school. Being a mother has been one of the things she wanted most.

But now she has a legitimate fear of what an issue in pregnancy could mean, beyond just the heartbreak of losing the opportunity to be a mother or the immediate physical pain. She can’t use a period tracker for fear that if she miscarried it could be used as evidence against her should she miscarry. She has to worry that if she needs an abortion for medical reasons, she won’t be able to get one till she's already in an emergency medical situation. If she miscarries, she may be interrogated like a criminal, rather than treated as a grieving woman who just wanted to have a baby.

Despite our staunch pro-choice politics, we’re a model “traditional” couple. She wants to be a stay-at-home mother. Yet this one decision has made us genuinely afraid of the possible outcomes.

What I get from pro-lifers when I demand that they answer what people like my wife and I are supposed to do in these situations are half-hearted platitudes, poorly thought-out solutions, and a shrug of the shoulders. These things won’t help me if I’m holding my wife in my arms while a failed pregnancy collapses her health. They’re as useless as “thoughts and prayers”. Whatever the likelihood of us having issues ends up being, I will always know that you, as pro-lifers, have severely hampered our ability to get medical treatment should something go wrong.

I will not forget that, and I will remind you of it at every opportunity, because you have to own it. You got your way, and now we'll see the consequences of YOUR ideas in motion. But we already know what that looks like, don't we?


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 27 '21

On the Dehumanization of Women

190 Upvotes

There have been several posts lately that talk about whether or not PCers "dehumanize" a fetus when discussing abortion rights. I want to talk about how PLers dehumanize women.

There was a really interesting thread on another post recently where someone said that any PL speech is an example of claiming women aren't human, and I completely agree. My premise is that PL thought relies on the de facto dehumanization of women to function—thus, all PL speech can be held up as an example of dehumanization of women.

Here's why.

Removal of rights

PLers often claim that women don't have the right to kill a ZEF in the womb, thus removing access to abortion isn't "removing rights." This is factually untrue. Abortion is legal in all 50 states and most countries in the rest of the world, and is considered a lynchpin of human rights by the UN. Those are facts.

What PLers should actually say, in the interest of accuracy, is that abortion shouldn't be a right.

This is removing the right to bodily autonomy from women when they are pregnant. Bodily autonomy is one of the most fundamental of human rights. It's the right not to be raped, tortured, or have your organs harvested against your will. It's the right to decide who gets to use your body.

PLers often justify this massive removal of rights by claiming that the ZEF is human. "The fetus is human, and therefore deserves human rights."

But removing access to abortion is not a simple matter of extending human rights to a human ZEF. It also involves stripping rights from women. If the basis for taking these rights from women to give them to the ZEF is that "ZEFs are human," this must mean they believe women are not human.

Or perhaps we're less human than a ZEF. Thus, less deserving of rights.

It is dehumanizing to women to say that a ZEF deserves human rights because it's human.

Erasure of consent

A lot of PL arguments revolve around redefining consent out of existence. The concept of consent for most PLers on this sub appears to be "consent can be nonconsensual."

Here are some examples:

  1. Consent to sex is consent to pregnancy. (Thus, even if the woman doesn't want to be pregnant, we get to yell "YOU CONSENTED" at her because she had sex).

  2. You can't consent to pregnancy at all because pregnancy happens without your consent. (So you're only allowed to say you don't consent to something if it then doesn't happen. If it happens, you "consented" to it / your consent doesn't count).

  3. Consent is a two way street. The fetus doesn't consent to an abortion so you can't get an abortion. (Although by this definition, gestation should also be a two-way street, but in this instance the fetus' consent to use the woman's body is given priority over her non-consent to gestate. Thus, consent isn't a two-way street. Consent is for men and non-sentient beings but not for women).

All of these are ways to erase women's actual feelings about what is going on with our bodies, as if they didn't exist. One states openly that women are not capable of consenting or not consenting to pregnancy.

The reason most PCers think a fetus' consent does not count is because the ZEF is not capable of consenting. It literally has no brain in 91% of abortions. It is as able to consent as a paramecium or a plant. PLers are projecting consent onto a fetus when they say this.

PLers are switching that calculus. They are saying that the imagined "consent" of a non-sentient being takes precedence over a real person's thinking, reasoned, real consent. They are saying the woman is essentially the ZEF--whose consent does not exist and should not count.

Thus, all consent arguments from a PL standpoint implicitly reduce women to non-sentient, inanimate objects that are incapable of consent, and elevate the ZEF to a being that can consent.

It is dehumanizing to women to ignore our consent, erase our consent, or say that we are incapable of giving or withholding consent.

Analogies that replace women with objects

These are, as everyone knows, extremely common on this sub.

"Imagine you are on a spaceship approaching hyperspace, and you discover a stowaway in the anti-gravity generation chamber." "Supposing you invite a homeless person into your house." "Imagine somebody abandons a toddler on your front porch in a snowstorm."

Analogies often tell us more about the person making the analogy than about the fundamental nature of the argument. Most of these analogies replace the ZEF with a born person who is outside of a uterus. Not really a surprise, considering PLers claim to see a ZEF as the same thing as a born person.

They also replace the woman with an object. A house, a car, a spaceship, the Titanic. It's not a big leap to infer that the PLer making this analogy sees women as property, at least subconsciously.

I always find it interesting that, as PCers, we keep telling PLers not to compare women to objects, and they keep doing it anyway. You would think they'd find some other comparison to make--one that keeps the conversation on the rights of the unborn, rather than devolving into an argument about whether or not they think women are property.

How hard can it be to think of a different analogy in which the woman stays human? Just for the sake of actually getting to talk about what you want to talk about?

Perhaps it's because, if you allow the woman in the analogy to have humanity, your position suddenly becomes a lot less defensible.

It is dehumanizing to compare a woman to an object in an analogy.

Forced breeding

However, the above points revolve around how PLers talk about abortion. The reality is that even if PLers did everything right above--including acknowledging the pregnant person's humanity--they would still be dehumanizing women.

That's because forcing someone to gestate and birth a fetus is treating them like a mindless incubator, or perhaps breeding livestock. Not like a person with rights.

This wouldn't change, even if PLers:

  1. Acknowledged that women are just as human as a ZEF, but they want to remove rights from women anyway.

  2. Acknowledged that women are capable of consenting or not consenting, and PLers think they should be able to ignore that.

  3. Acknowledged that women aren't property.

It is dehumanizing to force someone to stay pregnant and give birth against their will.


r/Abortiondebate • • May 18 '20

It shouldn't matter if it was rape or incest.

181 Upvotes

If you're pro-life with the exception of rape and incest, then you admit that the fetus doesn't actually matter to you. What matters is whether a woman chose to have sex or not. If you are truly pro-life, than you should view that fetus as a precious, innocent life worth saving no matter what the circumstances of it's conception, and to place exceptions for when you're okay with it being "killed" makes you a hypocrite. It's a precious life, but sometimes it isn't, right? It's only "murder" sometimes, right?

It's either a precious life that needs to be saved, or it's not. So, which is it?


r/Abortiondebate • • May 24 '22

Question for Pro-life Dear pro life women

178 Upvotes

I know you’re probably happy about Roe being overturned. You’re thrilled that all those “babies” will be born and not “killed”

But you have no idea what the after effects of this will be. And the reality is, it threatens the lives and safety of women everywhere:

I sincerely hope you don’t develop an ectopic pregnancy. Removing one is considered an abortion which certain states will try to make illegal. Ectopic pregnancies cannot be reimplanted and if untreated, leads to death 100% of the time.

source

I sincerely hope you don’t miscarry and get sent to jail for losing a wanted pregnancy. Miscarriages are indistinguishable from and also classified as abortion (ie spontaneous abortion).

source 1

source 2

source 3

I sincerely hope your fetus doesn’t develop an anomaly in the 2nd or 3rd trimester that makes it incompatible with life, forcing you to give birth to something that’s already dead.

source 1

source 2

source 3

I sincerely hope you don’t develop sepsis or any other medical condition that puts your life at risk if you continue your pregnancy.

source 1

source 2

source 3

I sincerely hope you don’t have a young daughter who gets raped and is forced to carry a pregnancy to term

source 1

source 2

source 3

These things don’t just happen to pro choice women, they happen to pro life ones too. What will happen when years from now abortion rights are completely gone and you are admitted to the hospital for any of the above situations? Are you prepared to sacrifice your own life just so you and the fetus can die together?

You can fill a book with the number of reasons women need abortions. Stop thinking there’s only one reason why, when the reality is there are so many different situations you never even bothered to consider.

Edit: I added “sincerely” in front of hope cause I was told that the post was coming off as sarcastic and mean when that wasn’t my intention. I also added the part about underage girls getting raped and forced to continue a pregnancy


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 15 '22

General debate Women are not vessels to be used as incubators, we are human beings. If states claim ownership over our bodies, we should not be forced to pay taxes.

158 Upvotes

I posted this earlier but mods removed it because there was evidently not a clear-enough debate question, so let me pose that here for starters: should women who live in red states be forced to pay taxes since their bodies are essentially owned by those states?

I don’t care that pro-life thinks that forced birth is being fair to the ZEF. I am a human being, women are human beings, and we have lives, loved ones, jobs, and dreams, unlike the ZEF, which has no concept of life, no attachment to things or people, no memory of ANYTHING. Forcing us to incubate humans is using us like farmers would breading animals. This is wrong, and the possibility of creating life does not supersede the rights, health and lives of those who are actual living, tax-paying citizens. If the government wants to use us like a puppy mill, we shouldn’t have to pay taxes— we are property. Property doesn’t have to pay taxes. Slaves didn’t pay taxes, so if you want to own women, you can’t then turn around and tell them they owe you money. If anything, the government should start allotting women stipends, since the government is forcing them to now be its dependents.

The debate question is: should women be forced to pay taxes in states where they no longer own the rights to their bodies?


r/Abortiondebate • • Aug 25 '22

Question for pro-life If a Woman Does Not Want to Ever Have Children, Is She Expected to Stay a Virgin Her Entire Life?

157 Upvotes

I think more and more women nowadays do not plan on ever having children due to more having jobs, the financial burden, not wanting to be pregnant, etc. If a woman gets married but she does not ever want to have kids, is she expected to stay a virgin her whole life? Never sleep with her husband? That just does not seem realistic to me, to have the person who you love, who you took a vow to spend a life with, living under the same roof as you, and then never having sex with them.

I expect pro lifers in the comments might point out to contraception, but that isn't always effective. Many of the women who get abortions had been using contraception that failed in practice.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 12 '20

Why I'm pro-abortion.

156 Upvotes

Put simply, because I'm ultimately against the existence of any suffering. Suffering is always bad, sometimes in life one suffering might be required to avoid an even greater suffering, e.g. painful injections to avoid a more painful disease, but the desired good is obviously the avoidance of future suffering, not the suffering itself. If we could snap our fingers to become immune, we'd do that instead. If I only gave you the pain, you'd decline the offer.

Even a masochist wouldn't be a good counterexample, a masochist is just wired in such a way that they will face worse long term suffering if they don't inflict a certain amount of short term suffering onto themselves, but if I were a magician and could make it so that by waving my magic wand, you won't get an orgasm anymore unless you cut your eyeballs out, you wouldn't want me to wave my magic wand, you wouldn't choose to have to inflict pain onto yourself.

By preventing sentient life from emerging, we prevent all future suffering, all predicaments that would and could happen in said sentient life. We also prevent all future happiness, but that's irrelevant because there's no unborn purgatory where any unborn child is suffering from a lack of happiness.

Yes, when we exist as sentient beings, we are forced into a position of having to constantly chase satisfaction, relief in order to avoid and cancel out the otherwise resulting dissatisfaction, suffering. I don't eat, I get hungry. I don't drink, I get thirsty. I don't defecate, I constipate. I don't orgasm, I get tense. I don't chase the relief, I'm kept in a state of deprivation.

Before I existed, I didn't experience any satisfaction, but I also experienced no dissatisfaction as a result of not experiencing satisfaction, because I didn't exist.

So citing happiness as some kind of supposed benefit to justify creating a suffering-capable organism would be absurd, similar to how it would be absurd to justify sticking a knife into someone's chest for the good of then giving them a painkiller against it, they weren't in need of the painkiller before you put them in need of it by sticking the knife into their chest.

Procreation=sticking knife in chest.

Unfulfilled desire=knife in chest.

Fulfillment of desire=painkiller against knife in chest.

Pulling the knife out again=dying.

Just don't stick the knife in someone's chest and we don't have a problem, I didn't have any burdensome unfulfilled desires to fulfill before my unfulfilled desires were created via my creation.

All our lives as sentient organisms, we're trying to reduce our level of desire, deprivation, craving, suffering (whatever you want to call it) to zero, if one of the organisms magically managed to fulfill all their desires and keep them in that state permanently, we just have the same level of deficit as before they were born – a total sum of zero. But if they fail to fulfill even one desire, we have more deficit than before they were born – more than zero.

Perfectly fulfilling your desires isn't better than not having those desires in the first place, just like I would also say that getting the perfect painkiller against a knife in your chest is no better than not having a knife stuck in your chest in the first place. The life goal of the sentient organism is to avoid suffering, and that goal is only achieved by not becoming sentient in the first place.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 21 '22

General debate 93% of Republicans in the House voted against codifying contraception. Why is the prolife side so against measures that reduce abortion?

153 Upvotes

So, in light of Roe vs Wade a lot of previously protected precedent cases are seeing some attempt to codify them in law. This includes gay and interracial marriage (80% of Republicans voted no on this, for the record) and contraception which a whopping 93% voted no to.

While it may seem a bit simplistic to divide on party lines, it is no exaggeration to say that many Republicans hold a prolife stance as a crucial part of their campaign.

Why is it, then, that they consistently vote against policy that would reduce abortions and help women retain more autonomy?


r/Abortiondebate • • Feb 07 '21

It is not an "unfair assumption" to claim that pro-lifers are misogynist. We are picking up what you are putting down.

150 Upvotes

Recently there was a post about how PCers make unfair assumptions about how PLers are misogynist. I replied to it, and was asked to make my reply into its own post. So here it is, with some fleshing out.

It is not unfair to assume that pro-lifers are motivated by misogyny. Pro-life is a fundamentally misogynist position.

Pro-lifers constantly make arguments that blame, shame, and punish women for having sex. I've outlined before how any argument that assigns blame for sex on women is essentially "whores should keep their legs closed."

Anything to the effect of these arguments gives me the screaming ragebarfs:

  1. She put it there (No mention of men "putting it there")

  2. If you don't want to get pregnant, just don't have sex

  3. Pregnancy is caused by something the woman did. The woman is to blame.

  4. Women should take responsibility for having sex.

  5. "But the fetus is innocent!" (implying the woman is not)

  6. Elaborate metaphor comparing sex to a crime.

  7. Elaborate metaphor implying that having sex means you're inviting the ZEF into your house. (Bonus points for comparing women to objects).

  8. "Sex involves shoving children into your uterus."

  9. "People who are poor, who have careers, who are earning an advanced degree, who aren't in stable relationships, or who aren't prepared to welcome a baby should live like monks."

All of these arguments imply that sex is bad and a crime, and that women who have sex are guilty and should take their punishment. It further infantilizes women by demanding that they live like nuns if they don't want to have their bodily rights stripped from them.

And then there's the arguments that seek to erase consent:

  1. Consent to sex is consent to pregnancy.

  2. If you had sex, you agreed to get pregnant.

  3. The time to consent to pregnancy is before you have sex.

  4. Sex doesn't apply to pregnancy because pregnancy is automatic.

  5. Consent requires two people to apply; because a ZEF can't hear and understand your consent, you have to let it violate you.

  6. Sex is like a contract in which you sign on the dotted line every time to gestate any resulting ZEFs, regardless of what you actually want.

These arguments are all extremely rapey. Replace the word "baby" or "child" with "rapist" and they still make just as much sense.

Speaking of rapists, there's also the "rapist's rights" side of the spectrum, where pro-lifers who just seconds ago based their opposition to abortion on the idea that consent to sex is consent to pregnancy, now pivot and say that *even when non-consent is extremely freaking clear--*i.e. when it's rape--abortion must not be allowed. To whit:

  1. The ZEF should not pay for the rapist's crimes. (The rape victim should pay.)

  2. Rape is a horrible horrible crime (etc. performative pearl-clutching) but I still think the woman should be forced to gestate her rapist's baby. (Rapists have the right to reproduce too!)

  3. Refusing to engage with the horrific results of these punative laws ("Girls in El Salvador committing suicide because they were raped and can't get an abortion have nothing to do with pro-life laws.")

  4. On top of all that, voting for laws where rapists get lighter penalties than abortion providers.

  5. And laws where rapists get parental rights. (Far more common in red states).

  6. All while vocally siding with men credibly accused of rape, voting for men credibly accused of rape, and supporting pro-life politicians who say things uncomfortably close to "rape is a good thing as long as a baby comes out of it."

And then, if you think it couldn't get worse, there's also the "we don't care if you die" argument. Pro-lifers are prone to making a calculation in their minds of how many "babies" they could save by banning abortion everywhere (millions!!), and how that's an adequate trade-off for more women dying. To elaborate:

The maternal mortality rate

More women die in childbirth in the US than in any other developed country. Statistically if more women are forced to give birth, more women will die in childbirth. Pro-lifers say they want women to be able to abort when their lives are at stake, but the response to this point is generally a collective shrug. Or, you get "that would be regrettable, but think of how many more babies we'd be saving. It's worth it to have more women die in childbirth."

Women dead in forced-birth hospitals

Pro-lifers say they want women to get abortions when their lives are at stake. But we can easily see how that plays out in forced birth hospitals.

The reality is that in many cases, trying to "save them both" means that the woman will be put at more risk in order to save the ZEF. So for instance, if a woman has cancer, she might be forced to wait to get lifesaving treatment so that her ZEF can be born before the chemo happens. This routinely kills women when abortion bans are in effect.

Sure, you'd save the ZEF (maybe). But you're also letting the cancer grow all that time, making it more likely the woman will die of cancer. Of course, some women may choose to take that risk, but it should never be forced on them. PLers want to force it on them, to risk women's lives and kill some of them.

Women dead from illegal abortions

Around 68,000 women die per year around the world from unsafe abortions. I have heard the most egregiously disrespectful language from PLers about this issue.

  • "They should die if they were going to kill their babies."

  • "Criminals should die as a punishment of breaking the law."

  • "More women dying in unsafe abortions is good because it will serve as a deterrent."

  • "Just because women die in unsafe abortions doesn't mean we should make abortions safe. We should just make even the unsafe ones less available."

  • Refusal to engage with high suicide rates and other consequences of making abortion completely unavailable, which we can see for ourselves in countries like El Salvador.

  • Absolutely no engagement with the fact that it's their policies that force women into the situation of having to go with an unsafe abortion in the first place.

Frequently what I hear from PLers when bringing up how their policies actively kill women is "yes, but think how many babies we'll save! This is an acceptable trade-off." They may not realize (or maybe they don't care) that the person they're talking to may be a person with a uterus. They are directly telling that person that their death is an acceptable trade-off for forcing their policies.

Also, PLers seem to ignore the fact that, in the majority of cases where women die as a result of forced birth laws, the fetus dies too. That makes me question whether their motive is in fact to "save babies" (since they aren't, actually, certainly not in the numbers they think they're saving), or just to punish, degrade, and even kill women who they deem to be "sluts."

Frequently arguing with PLers feels like arguing for my right to exist, my right not to be raped, my right to have love and intimacy in my life, my right to choose the direction of my life, my right to be free of violence. My right to life, you might say.

So yeah, I wouldn't say that misogyny coming from the pro-life side is an unfair assumption. We are just picking up what PLers are very loudly and un-subtly putting down.


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 19 '22

General debate Another casualty of Texas' abortion ban. This woman was denied medical care for three days until she was feverish and incoherent.

145 Upvotes

https://people.com/health/texas-woman-nearly-loses-her-life-after-doctors-cannot-legally-perform-abortion/

  • This was a wanted pregnancy.

  • This husband and wife are working professionals, who live in a city with highly rated health care.

  • She had a premature rupture of membranes and was found to have an incompetent cervix.

  • There was a fetal heartbeat.

  • The decision to make her wait until she contracted a septic infection was made by the hospital ethics committee.

  • The hospital feared that treating her before her life was actively threatened would result in felony charges.

  • As a result of the delay in healthcare, her uterus is heavily scarred and she suffers ongoing effects from the infection.

Conclusion: Texas' PL policy effectively maimed this woman, not because she desired an abortion, but because she suffered the bad luck of a pregnancy that took a lethal turn.

Is this law not therefore penalizing women for bad pregnancy outcomes? Is this not a denial of equality to these women? These women, who want to carry to term, and are denied the standards of care for an infection because it involves the contents of a uterus?

Finally, if this possible outcome is what awaits women who attempt pregnancy willingly, how does one rationalize forcing anyone to assume such risks by trying to take away their option to abort?


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 29 '22

Pro life arguments vs. rapist arguments

144 Upvotes

Pro lifers often make arguments that sound exactly like they come from a rapist. This is something I noticed when I first started participating in this sub, and I feel that for PLers it's unavoidable. You can't argue to get to violate a pregnant person's body without sounding like a rapist.

I came across a study where researchers interviewed convicted rapists in prison, and the justifications they gave for raping victims sound exactly like things PLers say to justify violating women's bodily autonomy. They betray the same pattern of thinking.

"Consent to A is Consent to B"

Pro lifers often make the argument that "consent to sex is consent to pregnancy."

This is a gross mischaracterization of consent, as consent cannot be said to be consensual if the person in question doesn't want what is happening. That means you can't simply point to that person's actions and say those automatically mean they consented to something else.

(If you're feeling an urge to bring up "implied consent" here, I wrote another post about that).

"Consent to A is consent to B" is a rapist's argument. It's how you get "consent to going up to my apartment / accepting that drink / making out with me is consent to sex."

And you can see that when you look at how actual rapists justify their actions. In the study, many of the rapists justified raping a woman because of things she did that they believed (or at least said they believed) indicated "consent." For instance:

  • The woman had been drinking

  • The woman stopped struggling when the man tried to force her

  • She willingly went somewhere alone with the rapist

  • She wore revealing clothing

  • She consented to other activities, like kissing etc.

So, just as the PLer says "a woman consents to pregnancy when she consents to sex," the rapist says "a woman consents to sex when she [is drinking] / [stops struggling] / [wears a low cut shirt] / [agreed to be alone with me] / [agreed to other sexual activity.]" Both the PLer and the rapist say "consent to A is consent to B." As you can see by the rapists' reasoning, that is a rapist's argument.

"No means yes"

PLers will often insist that women consent to pregnancy when they have sex, despite the woman in question giving every indication that they do not agree to pregnancy. For instance, PLers believe women consent to pregnancy even when:

  • They were using contraception

  • They seek out abortion care

  • They explicitly say they do not agree to be pregnant

Thus, the PLer is saying that "no means yes" when it comes to pregnancy.

This is the exact reasoning many rapists use to violate their victims. In the study, researchers found that believing women mean "yes" when they say "no" to sex is indicative of a "rape supportive attitude," and many of the perpetrators they interviewed said they saw a woman's "no" as "token resistance" to overcome.

Thus, PLers and rapists both hear a woman's "no" and think it was a "yes." Both have a "rape supportive attitude."

"Rape / forced birth is justified if the woman had sex previously"

One thing that jumped out at me in this study is that a common justification for rape is that the rape victim was seen as having had sex before.

Certain behaviors (or perceived behaviors) on the part of the woman would lead a rapist to think that their victim was promiscuous, and thus "asking to be raped." This includes wearing revealing clothing or agreeing to be alone with the rapist. It also applies when the rapist believes the woman has a reputation of promiscuity more generally.

Simply put, rapists think they are entitled to rape a woman if she is perceived to have had sex in the past.

This is the same justification used in a very common PL argument--the "responsibility" argument. The responsibility argument states that because the woman had sex, she must "take responsibility" and be forced to birth a fetus.

PLers, like a rapist, justify using a woman's body and sexual organs the way they want, despite the woman's wishes. With the "responsibility argument," PLers are essentially pointing to the fact that a woman had sex in the past to justify violating her bodily autonomy.

This is the exact same as a rapist saying he is justified in violating a woman because she had sex in the past.

"Being forcibly violated is how a woman is forced to 'take responsibility'"

Of course, PLers describe their argument not so much as "she's promiscuous so we get to force her to give birth;" as "she needs to take responsibility for her actions." A rapist's justification is often expressed in terms of "responsibility" as well.

Both arguments have their roots in slut shaming. PLers often won't explain the responsibility argument in terms of slut shaming, but slut shaming is rife here. I've seen this phrased as "you put it there," "the ZEF is there because of something you did," "it's your fault you're pregnant," etc. Words like "slut" and "whore" are implicit if not explicitly stated.

Even well established cases like McFall vs. Shimp, which set a powerful precedent for protecting men's bodily autonomy even though someone will die if you refuse to offer your body to them, is thrown out the window by PLers because Shimp is not seen as to blame for McFall's need of his bone marrow. The "responsibility argument" is about blaming and punishing women for having sex.

PLers, as I said, don't like to admit the responsibility argument is slut shaming even when it's obvious. They say it's about "being responsible for your actions."

Of course, "responsibility" is a misnomer here. Having a child can be the responsible choice for some, but having an abortion can also be a responsible choice for others. When PLers say "you must take responsibility," they don't mean each woman should decide to handle a pregnancy the way that is responsible for her. They mean that they, the PLer, are entitled to force a woman to birth a child.

Being forced to endure a BA violation is not "taking responsibility." It's being punished.

Not unrelated: rapists in the study sometimes describe raping a woman as forcing her to "take responsibility" for making him feel arousal. In fact "she had gotten me aroused" was one of the most common justifications for rape. Another one is "she is responsible," meaning in the rapist sees the woman as in some way "responsible" for the rape.

So both PLers and rapists justify violating women by a). blaming her for something she did to bring the violation on herself, and b). claiming that violating her body is making her "take responsibility for her actions."


r/Abortiondebate • • Sep 19 '21

Question for Pro-life Love doesn’t pay the hospital bills.

142 Upvotes

So I encountered this post on r/prolife today. A mother to be who is justifiably concerned about birth defects and wants to know what her options are. And the PL’s sickeningly mock her and compare her to Hitler. And there response is basically just “love the child anyway and don’t treat it any different.” Except that’s not how the real world works. Love doesn’t pay for hospital bills. Doesn’t pay for therapy. Doesn’t pay tuition for special needs schools and programs that disabled kids need. And doesn’t pay for the general extra stress and anxiety that parents have to deal with raising disabled kids.

My question to the PL’s what exactly is your solution to the problem of children born with birth defects by parents who can’t afford the extra costs either financial or emotional?


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 25 '22

General debate Is “consequence-free sex” not a common goal for both sides?

141 Upvotes

Nearly every day I read a comment from a pro-lifer condemning a woman for wanting to be sexually active, while also not wanting to become pregnant. “She just wants to have consequence-free sex!” they’ll complain.

And I always think: Well…yeah, of course she does. Do you not want that for her, too?

Is it not a good thing when people are able to choose to be sexually active, without experiencing adverse consequences like STIs and unwanted pregnancy?

If people could have sex without any risk of unwanted pregnancies, wouldn’t that exponentially reduce the demand for and incidence of abortions, essentially solving the entire issue we’re debating here?

Now, of course, I realize we are not yet at a point where we have 100% effective birth control, 100% effective comprehensive sex ed, etc. But is that not the goal, ultimately? Isn’t that what we should be working toward? Don’t we ideally all want people to be able to have consequence-free sex if they choose to?

If your answer to this question is “no” - I’m honestly baffled. The only reasons I can come up with for why someone could possibly be against this are:

  1. Consequence-free sex violates the tenets of your religion. This of course begs the question of why you think your religion has anything whatsoever to do with people who aren’t followers of your religion. It’s also worth pointing out that being married doesn’t magically make an unwanted pregnancy wanted.

  2. Consequence-free sex would mean far fewer people seeking abortions, and therefore far fewer opportunities for pro-lifers to publicly virtue-signal by harassing people outside clinics or offering unsolicited, unwanted “help” to people with unwanted pregnancies.

  3. A decrease in unwanted pregnancies would mean a decrease in the “domestic supply of infants” available for adoption. You think people with unwanted pregnancies have a duty to serve as broodmares for people who do want to get pregnant but cannot.

  4. You’re an incel, are angry that other people are having sex when you’re not, and want them to suffer for this.

  5. You’re a parent, are miserable in this role, and want others to suffer just as much as you have for having consensual sex.

Is this not fair? Am I missing something?


r/Abortiondebate • • Nov 13 '24

Question for pro-life Why isn’t the slogan “your body, my choice?” an accurate representation of the PL view?

138 Upvotes

I’ve been seeing PL disavowing the Nick Fuentes slogan “your body, my choice” and insisting that’s not what they support.

While I agree this slogan sounds quite nasty…how exactly is it not an accurate representation of the PL position? Seems quite accurate to me.

PL’s position is: if you’re pregnant, it doesn’t matter if you want to continue to carry that pregnancy or not, you will be carrying it, under force of law. Sure, PL likes to add in a bunch of flowery stuff about wanting to “save babies,” but that doesn’t change the fact that “your body, my choice” remains the gist of the PL position.


r/Abortiondebate • • Feb 28 '23

Question for pro-life (exclusive) Why didn't the law make an exception for me?

135 Upvotes

Unfortunately I recently had to have an abortion because my baby stopped growing in the womb (yes, it's the same procedure for a miscarriage). I couldn't get mifepristone in my state of residence due to a law that says you can only get mifepristone at your doctor's office, and even my OBGYN couldn't get it for me at her office beause almost no pharmacies in the state had it in stock. Moreover, I live two hours away from my OBGYN; even if she could have gotten mifepristone for me, I wouldn't have wanted to take it in her office because I wouldn't have wanted to start bleeding in the car on the way home.

I didn't want a D&C because that can cause cervical scarring, and I want to keep trying to have children. I didn't want to take misoirostol alone because that can be more painful and less effective.

What did I have to do? I had to consult a doctor through telehealth in another state, who prescribed me the medication in a third state, which sent it to my relative's home in a fourth state, which then sent the medication to my state.

Because of my state's pro-life law, my miscarriage was prolonged, and because of that, my ability to start IVF again has also been delayed. Pro-life legislation has hindered me from creating another life. Isn't that ironic?

Why was I punished for losing a much wanted baby? Why didn't the law make an exception for me?


r/Abortiondebate • • Aug 10 '22

How is this not totally Dystopian? Facebook turned over chat messages between mother and daughter charged over abortion

135 Upvotes

In Nebraska, a mother and her 17 year old daughter are being charged with multiple felonies after the mother procured abortion pills for her daughter and an apparent abortion took place. Law enforcement was able to force Meta to turn over Facebook Messenger records as evidence.

This makes me sick to my stomach. That poor girl and her mom. I can only imagine how desperate that girl was, and how desperate that mom was to protect her daughter. And now their lives will be ruined. Talk about techno dystopian government overreach. They’re spying on us, in our most private of moments, arresting us for taking control of our own bodies and futures.

https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/facebook-turned-chat-messages-mother-daughter-now-charged-abortion-rcna42185


r/Abortiondebate • • May 22 '23

General debate Can we drop the "child murder" thing already?

131 Upvotes

So I don't understand how we're supposed to have a productive debate or discussion when half of the debate is using incorrect terminology and outright bastardizing the English language. I see so often on here pro lifers saying things like this, emphasis mine:

"We are not arguing that women have to save a life but just not to murder."

"Women have the same rights as everyone else. They have bodily autonomy, they just can't murder children."

"In an abortion does a child lose their life or not?"

"Women are the ones slaughtering children so they have to be held accountable."

In all four of these examples (some of which are quotes directly from this sub) you see people blatantly using incorrect language meant to get an emotional response.

Abortion isn't murder. Even in states where it's illegal, it's still not murder. An embryo isn't a child. People can and do colloquially refer to their wanted pregnancies as a "baby" or "child", but that doesn't change the fact that an embryo is not a child by any stretch of the word.

I don't understand how we're supposed to have an honest factual debate when one side of the debate is constantly using emotionally loaded, I incorrect language that ends up skewing the debate from something factual into over emotional rants about people slaughtering innocent babies and children, when that simply isn't occurring in reality. So that's my question I guess, is it even possible to have an honest debate when one side is using correct terminology and the other isn't?