r/DebateAbortion • u/Cyber_Ghost_1997 • 2d ago
What if a movement rejected the distinction between strongly believing in a moral principle and using governmental coercion to enforce it?
This is a revision of an earlier post I made, titled "For a movement that does not claim to be the moral police, pro-choicers are being inconsistent."
In that post, I tried to expose an apparent contradiction, that apparently went off the rails because certain things I wrote were phrased badly.
This is what I was trying to say: the idea that abortion should be a woman's right to choose, and the bodily autonomy argument, are all MORAL statements. The idea that laws are not based on morality becomes inconsistent considering that the pro-choice movement has been attempting to pass laws that allow abortion at any point in the pregnancy, even up 'til birth, BECAUSE of these moral statements.
Why? Because those laws REFLECT MORAL CONVICTIONS.
In short, the question I was trying to address in my earlier post was this: "Can someone consistently believe that morality should influence legislation while also believing that the government should not enforce every moral judgment through criminal law?" I then was trying to ask people in the abortion rights crowd to defend the answer they gave.
But that's not the point of the post I am making now. I'm brainstorming ideas for an alternate history story where a radical pro-abortion rights movement infiltrates the Democratic Party in the United States. This movement basically says the following: "It's not enough to pass laws that defend abortion as a right. To be consistent, we must be willing to CRIMINALIZE attempts to call abortion murder and that anyone who proposes a law that defends the sanctity of the unborn child ought to be criminalized as hate speech and the politicians who filed it removed from position and charged with sedition and/or crimes against humanity."
The idea here is that this triggers a sort of "civil war" inside the abortion rights movement that is exploited by pro-lifers.
If such a scenario were to happen, how do you think the abortion debate could change, if at all?
I'm intending to crowdsource ideas for the story I am telling with such a scenario.