r/DebateAChristian • • 10h ago

¿Por qué Dios en el Antiguo Testamento era mucho más violento y cruel?

10 Upvotes

Quisiera una justificación teológica que pudiera empatarse con el hecho de que Dios es amor incondicional, cosa mencionada en el Nuevo Testamento. (1 Juan 4:8)

Especialmente conociendo el genocidio que Dios le mandó hacer a Saúl en 1 Samuel 15. ¿Eso no volvería a Dios justificador de genocidios?

Y también en Éxodo 32, donde Dios le manda las tablas a Moisés donde dice "No asesinarás", pero inmediatamente después manda matar a todos los hebreos que estaban haciendo idolatría. ¿Significa eso que Dios justifica la pena de muerte? ¿No es eso un gobierno de terror?

Lo digo siendo cristiano y amando la sociología. Es una duda genuina y humilde. No es hostilidad, es una pregunta directa y clara pretendiendo recibir explicaciones.


r/DebateAChristian • • 4h ago

Piracy of media that is not being sold anymore is not a sin.

3 Upvotes

(FORGOT TO PUT THIS IN THE TITLE BUT CHRISTIAN RESPONSES ONLY PLEASE.) If it's not being sold anymore then what is there to steal? The company that made it is not making it anymore and because of that they aren't going to get money from it either way.

A company is not going to go bankrupt because you pirated something that came out 10 years ago that they don't even sell anymore.

Yeah they own the rights to it but still, what are you even stealing?

You could argue piracy of things not being sold anymore is actually a good thing because it preserves that media.

Imagine putting hours into a piece of media only for it to then be forgotten like 10 or 20 years later.

Imagine how much stuff would be lost media if it wasn't for piracy.

and i don't care if it's "technically" illegal because it's considered stealing, because like i said if it's not being sold anymore what are You even stealing?

Plus if we're going by this logic then some could argue that buying these things is stealing because the company doesn't get the money.

if someone pirated something i made that I wasn't selling anymore I probably wouldn't even be upset because how's it affecting me?

For example there was once an animal crossing movie that flopped, if it wasn't for piracy it would likely be lost media, and from what i have seen it looks beautiful, You can clearly tell a lot of love and care was put into it.

Why should this be lost forever? Why should something be unavailable to the public just because a company doesn't care about it anymore? We aren't hurting them by enjoying it if it's not being sold anymore.


r/DebateAChristian • • 14h ago

If Christianity were true, it wouldn’t need money on any level

13 Upvotes

Hypothesis: If Jesus Christ were real, meaning Jesus is God in the flesh, there would be no reason for the Christian church to need or collect money. I’ll explain;

Argument: I understand that where we exist is “of this world”. However, if Christianity were the only true religion, worldly things like money, property, possessions and power would be insignificant to the church. Otherwise we’re saying that Jesus would allow the one and only path to salvation to perish because of a lack of worldly money.

Imagine a scenario where Christian churches were closing and the clergy couldn’t keep the lights on in the churches they still clung to. All of this difficulty would be 100% worldly problems that Jesus has the power to nullify.

This is not an outrageous request seeing that Christians pray to Jesus to remove cancer, give them wisdom, help them in their relationships and guide them through life. All of these things are accomplished through God and Jesus without a single dollar exchanging hands. Christians ask for Jesus to alter life itself and to change the world around them. Would Jesus just sit back and let all of Christianity collapse?

If Jesus did nothing and allowed Christianity to fall, what would that say about Jesus?

I understand that all churches need money - but those are the wrong churches. The money problem makes sense for them. But when you introduce an omnipotent God, the problem should go away. This is the game changer because the moment you drag a supernatural deity into the mix, you get all of the attributes with that being that you have to deal with. And could certainly end any shortfall.


r/DebateAChristian • • 7h ago

The Unethicality of Eternal Torment & Refuting free will defences

2 Upvotes

A note on discussion: Please quote and directly address the arguments you disagree with. Avoid misrepresenting positions or appealing to vague concepts such as "rational agency" or "moral responsibility" without defining them and explaining their relevance. Let's aim for precise, substantive engagement.

  1. The Fundamental Ethical Problem

Eternal conscious torment conflicts with compassion, love, and flourishing by causing suffering without the possibility of eventual healing or restoration.

Appeals to divine authority, justice, or retribution require independent ethical justification and reasoning.

2. Free Will and Creator Responsibility

An omnipotent creator determines the conditions and possibilities within which created beings exercise agency including the nature of individuals. Free will does not absolve the creator of responsibility for these conditions and their consequences.

Furthermore, meaningful freedom does not necessarily require unrestricted possibilities. Preventing eternally destructive outcomes need not constitute coercion.

ECT's defenders must therefore explain what meaningful value would be lost by preventing eternal suffering.

3. Flourishing as an Alternative Foundation

Under this framework, individuals retain meaningful agency, but the possibilities available to them are consistent with the foundational principles of a reality aligned with flourishing. This does not require choices to be predetermined, but rather that agency operates through a nature aligned with flourishing.

Every reality has constitutive features that determine the capacities, limitations, and nature of its inhabitants. The existence of such properties does not, by itself, constitute coercion. The choices available in a given earthly circumstance do not necessarily represent the fulfillment of meaningful agency.

4. Value, Justice, and CCEA

Defining God as good within a theological framework does not independently establish ethical goodness. Its underlying principles require examination.

As expressed in A Walk in the Physical:

The true justice is that all are loved and accepted, and that all are healed. Only the ego wishes less than that for someone else.

|

What meaningful value would be lost by creating a reality in which everyone ultimately flourishes?

ECT's defenders must explain precisely why eternal suffering is necessary, what value it preserves, and why no alternative could preserve that value without eternal suffering or annihilation.

I propose CCEA (Coherent Central Ethics Approximation) as a framework for intersubjective ethical evaluation:

  • Coherent: Principles should be internally consistent.

  • Central Ethics: Principles central to intersubjective value judgement.

  • Approximation: Ethical evaluation is a matter of degree.

CCEA claims no ultimate moral jurisdiction, but offers a framework for examining ethical claims.

Within CCEA, ECT conflicts with central values of compassion, love, and flourishing. Given an omnipotent creator's capacity to establish alternatives, ECT is ethically unjustified.


r/DebateAChristian • • 7h ago

The narrow gate bible passage (Math. 7:13-14) together with christianity being the largest religious group* in existence means that most christians and maybe whole denominations must be false.

1 Upvotes

• Math. 7,:13-14 via BibleGateway.com
• * Wikipedia about the worlds major religious groups.

To the latter thesis regarding whole denominations being false: That means on a broader look. Of course individuals of any denomination or even religious sect may still find a way through the narrow gate.

PS I've read, that OPs should not be formulated as questions, hence the above formulation. Yet I'm still also interested into what users here may believe what make a "good" christian, compared to those, who (as could be read in Matthew 25:33 ff.) will be placed to Jesus' left. Especially regarding the attitudes of some "christian" groups in the current world.

PPS for clearance, since this is my first post in this sub: I am not a christian myself and do criticise some activities in this religions name (as I do regarding other religions as well), but am not aggressively standing against religions (this or others) … even though they are altogether nothing for me. Meaning I'm here to read your understanding of the mentioned thesis and the cited bible passage(s), but not to prosetylise or to be prosetylised myself.

PPPS Hope I didn't break any rules with this post. :)


r/DebateAChristian • • 16h ago

Since, according to Jesus, everything in Christian teaching depends on loving God and neighbor, hatred within the Christian community should be treated as a failure at the heart of the faith.

2 Upvotes

Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. This is the first and great commandment. And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself. On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets. (Matthew 22:37-40)

Do you think Christ was talking about performative empathy here, or was he talking about loving our brothers and sisters here in a deeper way, in which we acknowledge their experience of being and honor their lives? Loving God and, as Christ said - like unto it- our fellow man changes us fundamentally. You feel it when people have it. I just don’t understand how people can call themselves Christians if this isn’t their beacon. Instead people focus on heaven, but this is the path.


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

God should have made sure that the most important book in the world was clear and straight to the point

18 Upvotes

Christians claim the Bible is a book that is the "inspired word of an all-loving god" who WANTS to save everyone. This god KNEW the book would be often "misinterpreted" and often require group STUDY, as well as OTHER BOOKS, to help explain it, yet he still relies on that book.

Since he's capable of doing ANYTHING, he should have made sure the message was clear as can be, so that misinterpretations were impossible.

Here are some examples of debates Christians have with each other about the "true meaning" of certain parts of the book:

• Is hell literal fire or metaphorical suffering?

• Is the trinity real?

• Is the snake in the Garden of Eden Satan?

• Did Jesus say keep just the 10 Commandments, or that the whole Old Testament still applies?

There are hundreds more.

*EDIT:

To all you Christians claiming that it is clear and you know that your interpretations are correct, you're just intentionally avoiding the question, and it's very frustrating.... If it's easy for you to have it all figured out, why do SO MANY OTHER PEOPLE sruggle with it? Even those who TRULY SEEK God?

*EDIT:

I initially didn't touch on the fact that there are THOUSANDS of denominations, because I wanted to point out how even within a single given denomination, there are STILL debates there.

But yeah, the fact that 30,000 denominations exist should be noted.

Because not all denominations say that other denominations also lead to the truth of the Bible; many denominations say that they are the ONLY correct ones.


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

Claims about gods made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.

15 Upvotes

If someone claims that a god exists, but presents no evidence or insufficient evidence to justify the claim, that claim can be immediately dismissed as unsubstantiated. The person dismissing such an evidence-free claim does not need to present evidence proving the opposite of the claim. It is sufficient simply to point out that the claim was made without evidence in the first place.


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

The claim is that God is omnipotent.

4 Upvotes

In the mythology of the Bible, Why did he fail when creating humans, and then drown them all, and then create a loop hole where he had to kill himself to save his creation from himself?

why didn’t the all knowing all powerful god get it right the first time?


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

The injeel is definitely not the four gospels

0 Upvotes

The best and most intellectually honest way to determine what the injeel is, is by its description and contents as mentioned in the Quran. If its description matches the gospels and if it has content from the gospels then we can assume it is the gospels, but if it doesn’t, then we can assume it is an entirely different text, lost to time.

Luckily the Quran tells us its description and contents in 7:157, 9:111, 48:29.

Were the four anonymously written biographies of the life of Jesus from decades after Jesus which were labeled “the gospels” 155 years later by Irenaeus—a single text of instruction given/taught/revealed to Jesus? (No? Then they’re not the text the Quran is referring to).

Do they contain a promise from Allah that he would purchase the lives and properties of the believers in exchange for paradise? (No? Then they’re not the text the Quran is referring to).

Do they contain a description of the believers as a plant which produces its offshoots and strengthens them so they grow firm and stand upon their stalks delighting the sower so that Allah may enrage the disbelievers? (No? Then they’re not the text the Quran is referring to).

Do they contain a mention of an unlettered prophet who will forbid the evil and enjoin the good and make lawful the good things and prohibit the evil and relieve his followers of their burden and shackles? (No? Then they’re not the text the Quran is referring to).

So out of the many Christian texts of the world known or lost to time, we don’t know what Christian text in 7th century Arabia was considered the injeel, but one thing we do know for a fact is that it wasn’t the New Testament or any text within the next testament.


r/DebateAChristian • • 21h ago

Christian agnosticism is the only reasonable position to hold.

0 Upvotes

Christian agnosticism (also called “agnostic Christianity”) is a view that mixes Christian beliefs with uncertainty, generally affirming belief in God or a higher power and the significance of Jesus while rejecting biblical infallibility and being unsure whether Christianity is the one true religion.

P1.
Christians look at the same evidence for so many categories, and yet still differ. Claiming to be certain of some positions, and to have "knowledge" of it, goes beyond the evidence provided. The agnostic Christian will say they are not sure, or will not be dogmatic about it.
The bottom line is, we just don't know, for many of the topics of the faith.

P2.
Christianity is often stated to be of faith, and some bible verses support this, so certainty isn't a requirement.

P3.
Given uncertainty, a person has to choose how to live, and not choosing is also a choice.

Conclusion:
So a committed but non-dogmatic Christianity is the most rational stance.


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

Weekly Open Discussion - November 20, 2026

2 Upvotes

This thread is for whatever. Casual conversation, simple questions, incomplete ideas, or anything else you can think of.

All rules about antagonism still apply.

Join us on discord for real time discussion.


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

The Catholic Church is playing their flock

0 Upvotes

Of course everyone is free to participate, but when it comes to who I'm debating, this post is aimed exclusively at Catholics.

My thesis/argument,

-- If you believe in Catholic doctrine, then the Vatican is leading half of their flock to hell while leaching off of their righteous members.

-- For everyone who doesn't believe in Catholic doctrine, it's obvious the Vatican is leaching off of all of their members and telling both factions whatever they want to hear.

-- It's pretty obvious none of the people running the Catholic Church believe a word of their silly doctrines. And if they do, then they are even worse, because that means they are fine leading at least half of their base to hell.

I was writing a post for a blog about my opinion on the Latter Day Saints (LDS), which inspired this post. The LDS is a huge organization, but unlike the Catholic Church, their members are much more uniform in their beliefs.

On the one hand, I respect that the Catholic Church allows for a wide range of beliefs within their system, but on the other hand, they are doing it for all of the wrong reasons and the way they do it is immoral.

I have several Christian friends, including friends of different denominations, and friends of different traditions within the denominations themselves, like with Catholics. In the case of Catholics, I have multiple Catholic friends, most of them are the liberal kind, who believe being gay is not a sin, and are in favor of birth control, abortion, etc. And that's great, I agree with them on that. But my issue isn't with them, it's with their church. The Vatican teaches they are heresy, and if they don't change before they die, God, the most merciful being ever, will roast them in a fire forever. But their local parish doesn't teach any of this. They teach a fun and rosy version of Catholicism.

While I hate many churches for being openly bigoted, I at least respect that they are clear to their members about their beliefs. The Catholic Church plays their liberal flock by allowing them to believe in what they call heresy, just so they can keep taking their money. Those liberal parishes still proclaim to adhere to Catholic doctrine, meaning by their own proclamations, they are leading their flock to hell.

Meanwhile, I have one friend who is a Conservative Catholic, a true to life Crusader larper, who thinks the Church is one Pope away from bringing back the "good old days" before Vatican 1. I openly call him a Crusader larper, I'm not taking any digs at him behind his back. I met him in a religious studies class and he's very serious about following every jot and tittle of Catholic doctrine. Although he doesn't like Vatican 2, he does mental gymnastics to incorporate it's existence into his beliefs. And before you say he's one case, he's invited me to mass and to hangout with his other Catholic friends, who share his religious beliefs and are also hopeful about having a new Pope like Benedict the next time they pick a Pope. Everyone I met at his parish was also a Crusader larper, or in politer terms, a "Traditional" Catholic.

The Crusader larpers are being played even more than the liberal Catholics I know, because their parish is all hoorah about being "traditional," and looking down on the liberal parishes, so they stay with the Catholic Church, hoping for the good old days to come, while they complain about their church being "infiltrated by heretics." Meanwhile the Vatican will give out a Pope like Benedict every once in a while to appease their Crusader larping base, but then they switch to a moderate Pope like Leo to appease their liberal base while also not pissing off the larpers too much.

My theory is that Francis really pissed off the Crusader larping base of the Catholic Church, and Benedict really pissed off the liberal Catholics, so this time they chose Leo as a moderate. And I hate to admit it, but it seems to have worked. My liberal Catholic friends adore Leo, and my Crusader larping friend and his friends like Leo enough, far more than Francis for sure. And for the Vatican, I think that's exactly what they want.

It's obvious to anyone outside of the Catholic Church that the Vatican is playing both sides of their base and that they have no plans to change the status quo.


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

The Quran does not deny the historicity of the crucifixion

2 Upvotes

A lot of christians claim the Quran denies the historical event of the crucifixion, thus making it a weak source to accept because it came centuries after the event, but if they took 3 minutes to actually read the verse in the Quran that speaks about the crucifixion they would see that’s not the case at all.

The verse in question says the following:
An-Nisa' 4:157
وَقَوۡلِهِمۡ إِنَّا قَتَلۡنَا ٱلۡمَسِيحَ عِيسَى ٱبۡنَ مَرۡيَمَ رَسُولَ ٱللَّهِ وَمَا قَتَلُوهُ وَمَا صَلَبُوهُ وَلَٰكِن شُبِّهَ لَهُمْۚ وَإِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ ٱخۡتَلَفُواْ فِيهِ لَفِى شَكٍّ مِّنۡهُۚ مَا لَهُم بِهِۦ مِنۡ عِلۡمٍ إِلَّا ٱتِّبَاعَ ٱلظَّنِّۚ وَمَا قَتَلُوهُ يَقِينًۢا
And [for] their saying, "Indeed, we have killed the Messiah, Jesus the son of Mary, the messenger of Allāh." And they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him; but it was made to appear to them. And indeed, those who differ over it are in doubt about it. They have no knowledge of it except the following of assumption. And they did not kill him, for certain.

Here you can see that by saying it was only made to appear like they crucified and kill Jesus, it is acknowledging that people did in fact see what looked like Jesus being crucified and killed, and in that case that would explain the historical attestation. So the Quran isn’t saying the event didn’t seem to happen at all, it’s saying the event that was witnessed and subsequently recorded in history did not go down how it appeared to go down in the eyes of the onlookers.
Allah acknowledges what the people saw, but explains what actually happened according to his knowledge.

So stop endlessly repeating, “oh yeah but man I could just never trust a 7th century source on such a historically attested event, should I trust the early Christians or this 7th century book?” because it’s a lazy, intellectually dishonest misunderstanding of what the Quran actually claims about the event.

The Quran is not presenting itself as an early historical witness of the events of the crucifixion trying to prove that the event didn’t happen at all, its presenting itself as God himself speaking about what actually happened beyond the limited knowledge of the witnesses of the event.

So saying the Quran’s claim is weak when up against the history is like saying Genesis’s account of the flood is weak when up against the earlier Mesopotamian accounts because it claims Atrahasis actually had the name Noah and was a monotheistic worshipper of the God EL who was the only deity that helped him escape the flood, when the earlier accounts closer to the actual event have Atrahasis as a polytheist who is helped by the two God’s Enki and Enlil to escape the flood.

I’m not arguing that the Quran is correct or actually divinely inspired, I’m arguing that trying to make it out as if it’s claiming something it’s not is dishonest.


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

I'm an agnostic theist (Christian). What this means, how it influences my thinking, and why I think it makes sense

0 Upvotes

My thesis is that being an agnostic theist makes sense, and I'll explain why after I explain my beliefs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agnostic_theism

I just learned the term agnostic theist, but this has applied to me well before I learned the term.

Atheism is "a lack of belief or a strong disbelief in the existence of a god or any gods."

I think agnosticism is well defined in this definition of agnostic:

"a person who holds the view that any ultimate reality (such as a supreme being) is unknown and probably unknowable." This definition also outlines what I think about God.

As you can see, many agnostics are atheists, but since agnosticism emphasizes the not knowing part, it's possible to not know there is a God but to still believe in one. Which is why the term agnostic theism exists.

I believe in God, who I interpret to be Jesus Christ, based on faith, and I don't know if there is a God or not. There is no scientific evidence for God, nor do I find there to be any logical reasoning that necessitates a God existing or not.

I think one can claim their religious beliefs are based on faith and be honest, but I think it's dishonest for one to claim that they know there is a God or gods, or any form of spiritual world.

The implications of how this impacts my role in society:

-- I only believe in evidence based teachings in educational curriculum, which is why I think schools and homeschooling curriculum should be required to teach only what is known to be true, and that means not teaching religion as if it's known fact.

-- I think being an agnostic is why I'm strongly in favor of a secular society. If we knew there was a God or gods, it could make sense to plan society around that in some way. But since we don't, matters of religion should be personal and not impact how we manage society. I also think freedom of religion and freedom to not be religious are human rights.

-- As an agnostic, I think people have the power to interpret God as we want to. This means people have the power to help Christianity get rid of the old baggage that's been attached to it. This means more Christians besides myself can publish free Bibles that have anything immoral removed. I also want to see other Christians get rid of hierarchical clergy systems within their churches. I want to see clergy have other jobs and never receive payment for any spiritual service they provide.

I've had many arguments with my Christian friends that have told me that my views are too "worldy," but my response is basically always the same. I live in the world. I am able to use my senses and rationality. If my senses and rationality come from God, then only a cruel God would begrudge me for using them. The God I believe in is not cruel.

The reason agnostic theism makes sense is because of what I just stated in my previous paragraph:

I live in the world. I am able to use my senses and rationality. If my senses and rationality come from God, then only a cruel God would begrudge me for using them. The God I believe in is not cruel.

Edit to add,

When I say it makes sense, I mean within the context of being a Christian or religious. If one isn't a Christian or religious and they don't use faith, then agnostic atheism won't make sense to them.


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

The Koans of Jesus

3 Upvotes

Mark 4:33-34
33 With many similar parables Jesus spoke the word to them, as much as they could understand. 34 He did not say anything to them without using a parable. But when he was alone with his own disciples, he explained everything."

If you want to know the parables, read the Bible. If however, you want the deeper teachings that Jesus reserved for those who were ready...You must read the Gospel of Thomas. (The Koans of Jesus)

John 16:12
"I have much more to say to you, more than you can now bear."

https://www.gospels.net/thomas


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

Most Christians are only tasting the skin of the apple. Jesus pointed to the fruit.

3 Upvotes

There’s a quiet, almost scandalous truth that the mystics keep repeating across centuries and cultures:

While the theologians argue, the mystics agree.

They agree because they are not primarily arguing about God. They are reporting from the inside of a direct encounter with the divine. And that encounter has a consistent shape: the collapse of the felt sense of separation.

The discovery that the “I” that was searching and the Reality it was searching for were never two.

Jesus did not primarily come to found a new belief system. He came announcing a Kingdom that is “within you” and “among you.” He said “I and the Father are one.” He prayed that his followers would be one even as he and the Father are one. He spoke of abiding in him as a branch abides in the vine...not as a metaphor for moral improvement, but as a description of participation in the divine life itself.

That is mysticism. Not floating off into the clouds. Not special effects. Not spiritual elitism. It is the lived recognition that the deepest center of your own being is already continuous with the Ground of Being.

Most of institutional Christianity has spent two thousand years polishing the skin of that apple: doctrines, moral codes, boundary markers, correct beliefs, correct rituals, correct interpretations. All of it can be useful. All of it can also become a sophisticated way of never biting into the fruit.

The skin is conceptual. It lives in the head.

The fruit is experiential. It lives in the heart...or deeper than the heart, in the place the old writers called the “ground of the soul.”

When you stay only with the skin, religion becomes a lifelong project of managing your relationship with a God who remains essentially other. You believe things about Him. You try to please Him. You fear disappointing Him. You argue with other people about the precise nature of Him. The whole enterprise stays dualistic: me here, God over there.

The mystics (Christian and otherwise) report something different. They report that the dualism itself is the illusion. Not that the personal relationship disappears, but that it is held within a deeper nondual reality. The Lover and the Beloved turn out to be two faces of the same Love. The seeker and the Sought are not ultimately separate.

This is why Meister Eckhart could say (in essence) that the eye with which I see God is the same eye with which God sees me. This is why Julian of Norwich could rest in the certainty that “all shall be well” not as optimism but as ontological fact. This is why the author of The Cloud of Unknowing insisted that God can be loved but not thought. This is why so many Christian contemplatives sound strangely like Advaita teachers or Sufi poets once you get past the surface vocabulary.

Jesus’ non-dual message was never about abandoning the world or floating above ordinary life. It was about waking up inside ordinary life to the fact that the divine presence is already here, already closer to you than you are to yourself, already the true subject of your own experience.

Most of us have been taught to relate to Jesus primarily as the object of our belief. The mystical tradition invites us to discover him as the Subject in whom we live and move and have our being.

You don’t have to leave Christianity to find this. It is the original depth of the tradition, the part that got papered over by centuries of institutional anxiety about control, orthodoxy, and power.

The contemplative practices...silent prayer, lectio divina, the prayer of quiet, the simple resting in presence...were never meant to be the specialty of monks. They were meant to be the ordinary way of following the one who said “Come and see.”

The invitation is not to become a better Christian by accumulating more correct concepts.

The invitation is to stop standing outside the mystery arguing about it, and to finally let yourself be drawn into it.

**Bite the apple more deeply.**

The skin was never the point...or the destination.


r/DebateAChristian • • 3d ago

The Christian God Has Not Met the Burden of Proof

23 Upvotes

Premise 1: Rational belief in the existence of an entity requires sufficient credible evidence supporting that entity's existence.

Premise 2: No sufficient credible, independently verifiable evidence has been established demonstrating the existence of the Christian God.

Conclusion: Therefore, belief in the existence of the Christian God is not rationally justified by the available evidence.

The burden of proof rests with the person making the existence claim, not with the person withholding belief. The absence of sufficient evidence does not prove nonexistence. It does, however, justify withholding belief until sufficient evidence is presented.


r/DebateAChristian • • 3d ago

The Ethical Problem of Eternal Hell

3 Upvotes

1. The Fundamental Ethical Problem

Eternal conscious torment (ECT) presents a fundamental ethical problem when considered in relation to an all-loving, omnipotent, and omniscient creator.

Preventing unnecessary suffering is central to ethics. While certain forms of suffering may be justified through their potential contribution to greater goods, eternal torment offers no possibility of eventual healing, restoration, growth, or flourishing for the individual. It therefore stands in direct conflict with fundamental values such as compassion, love, joy, peace, and flourishing.

Appeals to concepts such as justice, retribution, or divine authority do not independently resolve this problem. These concepts require ethical reasoning and justification.

2. The Free Will Defence

2.1 The Creator's Responsibility

An all-powerful creator is responsible for the conditions of the reality they create, including:

  • The nature and dispositions of individuals.

  • The circumstances in which their agency operates.

  • The possibilities and limitations of the created reality.

  • The consequences arising from the interaction between these factors.

Free will does not remove this responsibility. Choices emerge from an individual's nature and the conditions within which they exercise agency. These factors are not independent of the creator's design.

Consequently, appealing to free will does not establish why an all-loving creator would permit a reality in which individuals can ultimately experience eternal torment.

2.2 Meaningful Freedom Does Not Require Destructive Possibilities

The free will defence often assumes that meaningful agency requires unrestricted access to destructive possibilities. However, this assumption requires independent justification.

Choice is not unconditionally valuable, and unrestricted possibility is not a prerequisite for meaningful freedom.

Limiting destructive possibilities does not necessarily compromise meaningful agency, just as establishing the conditions for love does not constitute forcing someone to reciprocate it.

The burden is therefore on the defender of ECT to demonstrate precisely what meaningful value would be lost by preventing eternally destructive outcomes.

3. An Alternative Conception of Reality: Flourishing as Its Foundation

Consider an alternative conception of reality fundamentally constituted by flourishing.

Under this framework, individuals retain meaningful agency, but the possibilities available to them are consistent with the foundational principles of reality. This does not require choices to be predetermined, but rather that agency operates through a nature aligned with flourishing.

Heaven would represent the fulfilment of value in reality design.

3.1 Restrictions and Constitution Are Not Coercion

Every reality has constitutive features that determine the capacities, limitations, and nature of its inhabitants. The existence of such properties does not, by itself, constitute coercion.

A reality in which destructive possibilities are restricted preserves meaningful agency, or fulfills it as "meaningful" relates to value principles. The distinction is between forcing individuals to make particular choices and creating a reality whose conditions are fundamentally compatible with flourishing.

3.2 Secondary Theological Framework: Communion With God as intrinsic

Although this is not a regular implication, a secondary theological possibility is to understand communion with God as the necessary condition for ultimate flourishing.

If individuals are created for communion with God, the distinction between God's nature and the deepest nature of the soul need not be absolute. God could instead be understood as the ontological foundation of reality and existence.

Under this conception, alignment with the divine need not constitute submission to an entirely external authority, but rather the fulfilment of agency within a reality fundamentally grounded in flourishing.

Another further consideration is that creation exists by, and for its source, with souls as individuations of that source.

4. The Burden of Ethical Justification

Regardless of which theological framework is adopted, an important ethical question remains:

What meaningful value would be lost by creating a reality in which everyone ultimately flourishes?

To justify ECT, its proponents would need to demonstrate:

  1. Precisely what meaningful value is lost by preventing eternal destructive outcomes.

  2. Why that value outweighs the fundamental goods of love, compassion, peace, and flourishing.

  3. Why eternal suffering would be necessary to preserve that value.

  4. Why no alternative reality could preserve that value without requiring eternal suffering or annihilation.

Simply asserting that unrestricted freedom is valuable does not establish that the possibility of eternal destruction is necessary for meaningful agency.

The possibility of creating a reality that preserves meaningful freedom without eternal torment challenges the assumption that ECT is necessary.

5. Goodness, Justice, and Divine Authority

Defining God as good within a particular theological value system does not independently establish that God is ethically good.

Goodness is evaluated within a value system, but that system itself must be examined for its coherence with fundamental ethical principles.

Similarly, appealing to retribution or divine justice does not resolve the problem unless the underlying principles can be ethically justified.

The question is not simply whether ECT can be classified as just within a particular theological framework, but whether that conception of justice can be defended through coherent ethical reasoning.

As expressed in A Walk in the Physical:

The true justice is that all are loved and accepted, and that all are healed. Only the ego wishes less than that for someone else.

6. CCEA

I propose CCEA (Coherent Central Ethics Approximation) as a framework for intersubjective ethical evaluation.

The framework consists of three components:

  • Coherent: Ethical principles should be mutually compatible, and internally consistent, with centrality dictating the compatibility.

  • Central Ethics: Principles central to intersubjective value judgement.

  • Approximation: Ethical evaluation is a matter of degree.

I am not claiming that CCEA possesses ultimate moral jurisdiction or that everyone must adopt it. Rather, it provides a framework for examining ethical claims, identifying inconsistencies, and encouraging discernment.

7. Applying CCEA to Eternal Torment

The absence of a sufficient ethical justification is particularly significant when considering an all-loving creator with the capacity to establish alternative conditions of existence.

Within this framework, certain disvalues may be justified under particular circumstances. However, ECT is not justified within the central ethical standpoint because its consequences are fundamentally incompatible with the values of compassion, love, and flourishing.

I consider CCEA a useful framework for evaluating the ethics of hell intersubjectively, while remaining open to refinement and further discussion.


r/DebateAChristian • • 4d ago

God commanding SA does not align with an all-loving God.

23 Upvotes

There is never a good reason to command that women, girls, and virgins be SA'd, even if people are sinful, need judgment, or for whatever reason God states for his actions. It is evil, immoral, and cruel

God does this in ISA 13, DEUT 21, NUMB 31, 2 Sam 12, and a few other places.

The Bible portrays God as willing, and sometimes as the active agent, in bringing about SA as judgment, and that conflicts with a perfectly good God.


r/DebateAChristian • • 4d ago

The Logical Contradiction Between Original Sin, Salvation, and a Just God

6 Upvotes

Premise 1: A just God cannot hold individuals morally guilty or deserving of punishment for actions they did not commit and for which they bear no personal responsibility. Ezekiel 18:20: "The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, neither shall the father bear the iniquity of the son."

Premise 2: The doctrine of inherited original guilt holds that all humans are born guilty because of Adam and Eve's disobedience, despite having played no part in their actions.

Premise 3: This inherited guilt is presented as a reason all humans require salvation through Jesus Christ.

Conclusion: Therefore, if God is just, humans cannot justly inherit guilt from Adam and Eve, and salvation cannot logically be necessary on the basis of that inherited guilt.

If it is unjust to punish a child for the wrongdoing of a parent, how can it be just for God to condemn all humanity for the wrongdoing of two distant ancestors—and then require salvation from a guilt that humanity never personally incurred?


r/DebateAChristian • • 5d ago

What if we judged God by the same moral standards we use to judge human beings?

21 Upvotes

Sometimes I get the impression that there's a sort of moral exemption when it comes to God. Things we would consider monstrous if done by anyone else somehow become divine justice when they appear in the Bible.

God creates two human beings without knowledge of good and evil, places a forbidden tree in the garden, knowing exactly what will happen, and then holds all of humanity responsible for it. A kind of inherited debt nobody ever agreed to.

Later, dissatisfied with his own creation, he decides to drown practically everyone, including children and animals. Throughout the Old Testament, we also find massacres, slavery, and the killing of children associated with his commands.

Then comes the New Testament, where God decides to send himself, or his own son, who is also somehow him, to die and save us from a debt that he himself established in the first place. And if you don't believe in this solution, there's the possibility of spending eternity being tortured. Quite an unusual expression of love.

What fascinates me is that if a human being did all these things, we probably wouldn't be discussing their infinite goodness. We'd be calling the police.

But when it comes to God, we're apparently expected to suspend our own moral judgment and accept that what would be cruelty under any other circumstances is actually divine justice.

And that's precisely what bothers me. If God is the very definition of goodness, why do we need to redefine goodness to justify his actions? At what point are we talking about love and justice, and at what point are we simply calling everything a virtue because an absolute authority is doing it?

I don't think questioning these things necessarily means rejecting faith. Maybe it just means refusing to turn your brain off at the church entrance.

I'd especially like to hear from people who believe in God and have genuinely thought about these contradictions. How do you reconcile these narratives with the idea of a perfectly good being?


r/DebateAChristian • • 4d ago

The Miracle of the Sun can be used as evidence for Islam

0 Upvotes

It doesn't need much explanation that given that the miracle of the sun was truly a supernatural event that it makes Catholicism more plausible, but little attention is given to the possibility of a God opposing Catholicism vindicating a related prophecy.

The main reason to believe a vindicatory miracle of Catholicism could be caused by the Muslim God are that such a belief compliments both typical Islamic theodices and God's character portrayed in the Quran. In Islam's logic, opposition to the will of God exists because he is testing mankind; consequently, God wants it to be somewhat difficult to find which religion he endorses. Additionally, he considers people being Muslim to be extremely important to the worth of people, and has great hatred for any of its opponents. He even makes people opposed to Islam more delusional for these reasons (17:97, 18:57).

It is because of this characterization of God that it is plausible that he would create a miracle for the purpose of strengthening the Catholic faith, so that he gets more satisfaction from causing a sort of whiplash for the people he further convinces of a religion he despises.

Personally, because of this possiblity if the sky screamed out to me claiming Jesus to be the son of God, I have multiple explanations of it on top of the more clichéd ones like supernatural events being delusions caused by demons or Satan. My own experience as nonreligious makes me take this idea more seriously, because of its explanation of divine hiddenness; it explains why there is not obvious evidence for any religion in particular.

(For clarity, I'm not claiming that either Islam or the miracle of the sun accounts are actually correct)

In summary, Islam's theodicy of testing humanity is extremely versatile, to the point that it is compatible with supernatural proofs of Christianity.


r/DebateAChristian • • 5d ago

Paul claims that the scriptures teach that the Messiah will rise from the dead after three days, but it’s nowhere to be found.

14 Upvotes

Paul claims that the scriptures, specifically the prophets and Moses (Torah) teach the following about the messiah:

  1. The messiah will be buried and rise from the dead after the third day (1 Corinthians 15:3–4)

  2. The messiah will be the first to rise from the dead (Acts 26:22–23)

  3. the messiah will rise from the dead (Acts 17:2-3)

Where do the scriptures teach any of this? Where does the Torah prophesy this or the prophets?

Paul used Psalm 16:10 which says “because thou wilt not leave my soul in the grave, neither wilt thou suffer thine Holy One to see corruption.” to show how the messiah will rise from the dead, but it’s merely David saying he will be resurrected, David doesn’t mention anything about the messiah.

David is referring to the general resurrection of the dead at the end times as we see in Daniel 12:2 “Multitudes who sleep in the dust of the earth will awake: some to everlasting life, others to shame and everlasting contempt.”, he mentions nothing about a messiah, nor does he mention anything about rising after specifically three days as Paul claims the scriptures mention.

But christians argue that David says God will not let his body decay (“see corruption”) but he obviously died and his body decayed so he couldn’t be talking about himself, but the problem with that is it just means David’s hope about not decaying failed, but nowhere does it indicate that he’s speaking about another person, let alone a future messiah figure.

And if that’s the case, that ignores all the times David says God will save him and not let him be harmed by his enemies, so you can’t just pick and choose when David is speaking about Jesus and when he’s not.

Another verse that Christians use to show how the messiah was gonna die and then rise after three days is Hosea 6:1-2 which says: Come, let us return to the Lord. He has torn us to pieces but he will heal us; he has injured us but he will bind up our wounds. After two days he will revive us; on the third day he will restore us, that we may live in his presence.”
But this is clearly talking about Israel and not the messiah, and it says they will revive after the second day, that’s one day too early.


r/DebateAChristian • • 5d ago

Apologetics is a smoke screen

32 Upvotes

The vast majority of Christian’s did not become Christian because Josephus or Pliny said that there was a person named Jesus who the Christian’s followed. You don’t believe because of the 5000+ Greek manuscripts. You don’t believe because of the contingency, Kalam, or fine-tuning arguments.

It’s almost always the case that you came to the belief first and these apologetics are just arguments you heard later that sounded convincing once you already had the belief. They made you feel validated for having the faith in the first place.

The first thing you had, and what every argument with Christian’s boils down to in the end, is faith. Just believing in it because it feels good, or it makes sense to you, or it helps you to believe it.

The things you believe were never demonstrated to you from a non-biased position. Every time you heard an apologetic argument after you already believed or had faith, you had a confirmation bias.

There is nothing convincing about the apologetic arguments. Apologetics are to keep believers in the cult, not to attract non-believers. They only work on people who already have that sunken cost, confirmation bias, or have already had their mind programmed to be susceptible to incomplete, insufficient, and invalid arguments.

Faith is not righteous, faith is not virtuous, faith is cowardly, faith is gullibility. Being so scared to think that there is no sky daddy looking after you at all times is cowardly. Thinking that your belief itself is evidence of the belief being true is gullibility.

Doesn’t it worry you that using a methodology such as faith, with such a demonstrably terrible success rate for getting things right, is leading you to devote your life to something that doesn’t exist? There’s never been an instance where faith has been demonstrated to be reliable in determining reality.

Don’t you worry that the reason you find apologetics convincing is because you’re already in the group?

You should attempt to step out of the indoctrination and look at the bible and the beliefs objectively so you can evaluate them without such a deep rooted bias.