r/DebateAChristian • • Oct 07 '11

Creationism vs Evolution, Limerick Style

327 Upvotes
This forum is getting quite drab
So I thought I might give this a stab
    It might be a gimmick
    But post as a limerick
If about this you would like to gab

I thought we could start with creation
I want all your interpretations
    Do you think we evolved,
    Or is this better solved
By a bit of divine inspiration?

Evolution i see as a theory
Of accepting it I am quite leery
    It has many gaps
    So I think perhaps
The idea has grown rather weary

r/DebateAChristian • • Oct 12 '24

A Jesus-following Christian cannot support Donald Trump

208 Upvotes

How can Christians pledge support for a man as un-Christlike as Donald Trump?

For almost a decade, I have witnessed with a mixture of horror and sadness as more and more good people - friends, family, neighbors, and the church family - have succumbed to the spell of this amoral man.

This is a man who has sown division across this country every day since he began his foray into politics, and we’ve all been reaping the fruit of that discord ever since.

His primary impulse is to turn neighbor against neighbor, routinely describing political opponents (and anyone who disagrees with him or does not pledge fealty or support for him) as “enemies of the people” or other variations of dehumanizing language. This is not the way of Christ.

I can think of no greater rebuke of Trump than this passage from Paul:

Corinthians 13:4-7: Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres.

This describes the antithesis of Trump.

This is a man who has been found liable by a jury in a civil lawsuit of sexually assaulting a woman, a fact of which he continues to lie about.

This is a man who has been found guilty of criminal activities to hide payments to a pornstar he had an affair with while his wife (his third wife, no less) was at home nursing their newborn child. (A fact of which he again lied about in the most recent debate.)

This is a man who sees a 12 year old girl walk up an escalator and jokes “I’ll be dating her in 10 years”.

This is a man who admits to peeping on teenage beauty pageant contestants in their dressing rooms.

This is a man who for several years associated with Jeffrey Epstein, a notorious predator.

This is a man who unleashes a multitude of lies almost every time he speaks, and no bigger and more dangerous lie than the notion that the 2020 election was stolen which directly led to a violent assault on the US Capitol.

This is a man who DID NOTHING for several hours as he watched his supporters (supporters he invited to be there during the certification of election results with a tweet that read “it will be wild”) attack police officers, and go head-hunting for his own Vice President. When told they were chanting “Hang Mike Pence”, his reaction was to express support for the notion.

This is man who used the office of the presidency to enrich himself.

This is a man who grifted his own supporters with lies to enrich himself.

This is a man who publicly proclaims vengeance and retribution for anyone who opposes him or attempts to hold him accountable for his many crimes.

This is a man who is completely clueless about scripture, and whose sole use of the Bible is as a prop or as a means to enrich himself.

This is a man who instituted policies to separate children from their parents as a means to deter migrants from crossing the border.

This is a man who has enabled and encouraged the rise of virulent extremist factions within the United States, something that was completely on the fringes of society for most of my lifetime before he came on the scene. ( I have personally witnessed groups of Neo-Nazis waving swastikas on the streets of Palm Beach and above I-95, it was heartbreaking to explain to my young children what nazis were, but that is the world we now live in in large part to Trump’s playing footsie with these dark elements.)

This was a man who dined with one such neo-nazi.

The list goes on and on…

I have heard many Christians excuse his abhorrent behavior with phrases such as “nobody’s perfect” or “we are all sinners”, but this is not merely a man who sins, this is a man who revels in sin, and makes no apology for it.

This is not a model that any Christian should uphold, and certainly not one that should serve as an example for our children or the nation at large.

So this is something I have been meaning to find an answer for: What is the scriptural justification for supporting such a man who’s primary aim is to sow discord among neighbors in order to attain power for himself?

Donald Trump has never run for president to help anyone other than himself. Indeed, he is only running today to shield himself from legal accountability using the office of the presidency and electoral process. (recall that he announced his bid WAY earlier than anyone else ever has before for this very reason)

In my view, he has exploited and used the Christian community as a means to capture power, and in the process made so many Christians in America succumb to idolatry in the name of Trump.

The idolatry is so strong in some cases that they even reject core teachings from Jesus. Former SBC Pastor Russel Moore said the following:

"Multiple pastors tell me, essentially, the same story about quoting the Sermon on the Mount, parenthetically, in their preaching—'turn the other cheek'—[and] to have someone come up after to say, 'Where did you get those liberal talking points?'"

Donald Trump Jr. backed up this rejection of Christ’s message of peace, unity and the brotherhood of mankind.

The attempt on his life was tragic, but this is also a man who has encouraged physical violence against political opponents multiple times.

While President Biden immediately released statements and spoke out against the violence stating there is no place in America for this, something any responsible leader should do, Trump’s reaction to a similar incident was to mock the victim, in this case the husband of Nancy Pelosi who was attacked with a hammer in his home by a Trump supporter. Donald Trump Jr also made a mockery of the political violence by tweeting a picture of a “Paul Pelosi Halloween Costume” that included a hammer.

I don’t know what your specific view on Trump is, but I am confident that you did not support him early in the 2015 primary process, as not many Christians did. He began to gain support as he used means such as blackmail to get prominent Christian figures such as Jerry Falwell, Jr. to fall in line behind him as to not expose his own sinful conduct.

His support among the Christian community slowly grew from there until many convinced themselves that he was some sort of divinely anointed candidate. (How anyone can believe that God would anoint a man of such awful character - one who is fundamentally opposed to nearly all Christian virtues and has broken almost all of the commandments too many times to count - to fulfill His purposes, is beyond me, but they’ve convinced themselves.)

In my view, in embracing such a man, many have rejected Jesus in their heart. I’ve recently come across this conversation with a pastor who described this corruption as such: With Trump, many Christians now proclaim “Give Me Barabbas”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LO9SJfCtSB4


r/DebateAChristian • • Jul 20 '13

Fellow Christians: it's time for some tough love!

114 Upvotes

I understand this is a debate subreddit, so please bare with my, I will make the debate topic clear after the introduction.

I found this subreddit a week ago and I've been lurking and learning the rules.

I've noticed there have been a few posts regarding the lack of Christian participation and Christian hurt feelings and claims that Christians are being persecuted within /r/DebateAChristian/. As a Christian, I call bull-shit on this! And here's why:

TO CHRISTIANS

  • From an atheist's perspective, we are adults that believes in pixie-dust and magic. This is our opportunity to undermine that prejudicial view and demonstrate our patience, grace and intellect. We are not a victim of persecution, we are participating in a debate because we choose to. We can walk away at any time.

  • Let's get one thing clear: God has NOT been definitively proven to exist and you can not pretend otherwise during rational debate!

  • We are receiving down-votes because our debate arguments are often unsubstantiated. We are being ridiculed because rational debate ends once we make these unsubstantiated claims (which typically presumes that Christianity can be proven). This is THE key issue. If we want to be taken seriously, let's start presenting serious arguments that can be substantiated with facts and rationale.

  • If you are not an expert in ancient Hebrew or Greek and you do not have access to the original Old Testament or New Testament then DO NOT CLAIM THAT YOUR BIBLICAL INTERPRETATIONS ARE MORE CORRECT THAN SOMEONE ELSE'S (unless you can actually substantiate it) because you can not substantiate your claim. You will be down-voted, you will be ridiculed and you deserve it!

  • Debate arguments and rebuttals need to be rational. We deserve to be ridiculed (within a debate) if our argument are unsubstantiated such as "because the bible tells me so" or "because God can do no wrong" or "Jesus died for our sins" etc.

  • I am sick of Christian whining about being persecuted and how the /r/DebateAChristian is unfair. Stop your complaining and present some decent, compelling, rational arguments in support of your faith that are not supernatural and you WILL receive up-votes, or do not participate! We can not expect non-believers to respect our unsubstantiated religious views within a debate unless we can present a decent argument in support of said claims!

  • Remember that we will not die from hurt feelings.

TO ATHEISTS

  • Nobody has proven nor disproved the existence of God. It is irrational to claim to know of sure, one way or the other. Please keep this in mind when forming your rebuttal.

  • If you are interested in having a serious debate, consider letting Christians know if we are making unsubstantiated claims that are unacceptable outside of our social circles and unacceptable within a debate. If we continue to make unsubstantiated claims within the debate, feel free to ridicule us because we deserve it for not following the expected intellectual discipline of a debate!

MY DEBATE QUESTION

There isn't one.

I believe this subreddit is stricken with martyrs and I was lying.

I just want you to please consider the points I have presented because I believe future debates can potentially be more productive than the current silliness and ridicule of silliness that I have recently observed...


r/DebateAChristian • • Apr 18 '14

Just want to say thanks to the Christians that participate.

109 Upvotes

I just want to thank those of you that try to respond to all of the arguments (good and bad) posed by my fellow disbelievers. I've gone back and looked at a bunch of debates, and I feel like most Christians (while I disagree with their position) are much more cordial and well mannered. I'd like to apologize for myself and my fellow atheists that get too caught up, and forget our manners. It's great to be able to discuss these things with you guys. I hope you don't let those of us that behave poorly discourage you guys from participating in the better debate. Keep up the good work guys, thanks!


r/DebateAChristian • • Jan 08 '13

[Meta] People really need to stop to utterly downvote christians, it defeats the whole purpose.

109 Upvotes

As an agnostic I came here to see debates, but it is near impossible because many answers from christians are thoroughly downvoted, which just discourages answers. I even see people insulting believers, not even question why, but just outright insult them, why?

On topic I also want to add that conforming statements like

Agnostic/Atheist 1# God is X Agnostic/Atheist 2# I agree, god is X Agnostic/Atheist 3# Ye totally

and on and on.... serves literally no point, nada, zip, zero, it adds nothing.

I am going here to see some debate, please don't downvote aggressively and just clutter everything.


r/DebateAChristian • • Aug 18 '21

Christianity's association with right wing politics makes the religion extremely unattractive to outsiders

107 Upvotes

I'm an American so this is mostly about white Christians in the US. Many of the Christians in my life love Trump and fear immigrants and refugees. They have backwards views on LGBT people and many don't acknowledge that orientations other than heterosexuality even exist (and if they do, they're "intrinsically disordered"). They are pro capitalist and anti union, they might say they aren't racist but their churches are 95% white and they get super defensive when I ask why they don't go to a church with a more diverse congregation.

I also understand and appreciate that there are many Christians who want nothing to do with the religious right--but it remains the case that Christianity's reputation in the United States has taken a beating because the most cantankerous voices are the loudest. If following Jesus is supposed to change you and make you a more loving or generous person, the evidence seems to point in the opposite direction. Why should I want anything to do with Jesus when so many of his followers are so terrible?

EDIT: Changed the first line to read "white Christians in the US" instead of "the US church"


r/DebateAChristian • • Dec 07 '17

If Jesus can wash the feet of prostitutes without condoning prostitution, then Christians can bake gay wedding cakes without condoning gay weddings

105 Upvotes

If a baker offers services to the public then they can't discriminate against the public under protected statuses under the law of the land. This is secular reality.

More over, Romans 13:1-7 is frequently interpreted as "follow the laws of the land as long as they don't contradict God."

Which leads me to my initial thesis: If Jesus can wash the feet of prostitutes without condoning prostitution, then Christians can bake gay wedding cakes without condoning gay weddings.

If baking a gay wedding Cake doesn't condone gay marriage, then they aren't going against God... and as such, they are morally obligated to follow the law of the land which is not to discriminated against people.


r/DebateAChristian • • Mar 16 '19

Being a Christian is fundamentally irrational because it always boils down to taking early Christians at their word.

103 Upvotes

Thesis as in title. Let me clarify.

One of my (many) pet peeves about Christianity is that when Christians are challenged to defend their views, they very often try to sneak in a defence of theism, or non-physicalism, or free will, or creationism, instead of of Christianity.

I like having those debates, but even being right about every last one of these things wouldn’t make it reasonable to be a Christian. To be a Christian, you need to at least believe that an ancient Galilean carpenter was the Son of God and rose from the dead. And compared to that, belief in the supernatural is sterling common sense.

What I want to hear from Christians is why are you a Christian specifically? How do you make that leap from the (relatively reasonable) existence of a supreme being to the (much less reasonable) resurrection in a first century Roman provincial town?

As far as I can see it, the basic problem is this. All the relevant information that makes it possible to be a Christian specifically, as opposed to a theist or a non-physicalist or a creationist or whatever, has reached us through the same, early Christian community. You may have sound rational reasons to believe theism, but you cannot have sound rational reasons for the basis of Christianity because our only access to that information is through the claims of early Christians. You would not believe the claims of other religious movements based on such evidence.

Therefore: anyone who calls himself a Christian is proclaiming his willingness to believe supernatural events based only on ideologically motivated third-hand two-thousand-year-old documents. Christians: is this representation correct?


r/DebateAChristian • • Feb 21 '17

The internet is killing Christianity, because Christianity thrived on bubbles of misinformation

97 Upvotes

Yo yo...

Back at it /r/DebateAChristian. Let's talk about our glorious and exciting digital existence, and what exactly that means fro Christianity.

I have a very simple claim to make today:

Access to information on the internet is killing Christianity, because Christianity thrived on bubbles of misinformation.

Religion in America is shrinking, and I think it's no coincidence that it's happening in parallel with the increased access to information.

If Christianity were real - logically consistent and historically convincing - we'd expect the opposite to be happening...to see the Internet bring an unprecedented number of new believers into the fold. Today the gospel has arguably traveled farther than it ever has in the past, reaching people in other countries that have not had a history of Christian influence, etc - or even, in America, reaching homes that may not be Christian.

However, we're seeing the opposite.

I believe this is because Christianity is much more convincing in a bubble than in an open sea of of information. We've already seen this principle at action for years in cities - where many people of different religions live together, there is a higher level of atheism. It's a pretty logical conclusion that Christianity (or Islam, or Judaism) isn't anything special when you see other religions right next to it, making very similar claims and having the very same lack of evidence.

But let's look at what I think is going on...

1) Churches are bubbles

I think we're all familiar with the concept of "bubbles of information" after this election especially...well churches are one of the original bubbles - a Facebook feed with constant fake news! And what else should they be? Churches - or gathering places for any religion - are for like minded people to come together and reinforce their beliefs. They have no responsibility to check their sources of information, and it becomes a misinformation breeding ground. Anecdotally, I have never heard more crazy, factually wrong ideas said out loud than in a church - I was told about Noah's ark being discovered in Turkey, or that being gay is a choice, etc. These were privately held beliefs being pinged around the church stratosphere to shore up strength in conviction...they weren't based on anything factual.

Less anecdotally, you'll see an interesting correlation between misunderstood concepts and religious communities. Evolution is most eagerly opposed by the religious, despite having a very shaky understanding of its claims. Sexual health is also very misunderstood, and teenage pregnancies are higher in regions that promote religious based abstinence.

Churches are the breeding grounds for ideas that don't survive scrutiny in the outside world...and they don't want the outside world criticizing that (which is why this division is set up early on, the church vs. the world...)

2) Religious faith thrives in a bubble

As we just saw in this election, the problem with bubbles and echo chambers is that they distort the real world. If you're a conservative and all your friends were too, all you read were conservative articles and conspiracy theories, which only reinforced your world view. You weren't running into an alternative opinion and getting the chance to evaluate it. Christian claims thrive in an environment where they are unchallenged.

Churches are echo chambers to only get the fake news you want in your feed...to ignore information that challenges your worldview, and to cut out any voice that questions it.

Look at the history of Christianity and you'll see the times when the church exerted the most power are when its adherents had the least access to information (sometimes even their own Bible). They had little to no ability to decide whether Christianity was true, but rather to be forced to be a part of a system they were born into.

3) The internet provides much needed checking of false claims inside the bubble

The internet is your connection outside of the bubble, a way out. It's how I got out, and many others I know.

I think it's quite normal for a young Christian to run into a concept that makes little sense to them, based on their moral compass, or maybe a scientific theory that is widely held as fact. Before the internet, you might go to your pastor for a spiritual question. They'd give you an answer, and you'd be forced to accept it on their authority. Now with a simple google search you can google "The problem of hell" and see plenty of alternative answers from people outside your community. You might have wanted an atheist perspective before, but didn't know where to get it. Now you have it!

The fact is, many Christian claims fall apart when zoomed in on by different areas of expertise. Obviously churches aren't going to embrace the critiques of their "facts", so they are going to stay in their bubble, repeating their false assumptions and having it stick only in a community that grants them the authority to do so. It's millions of people sticking their head in the sands together to avoid major scientific discoveries - like evolution, the age of the planet, etc.

This subreddit is a direct example of all of this - a forum for you to challenge your faith and not just exist in an echo chamber. How many of the Christians on this subreddit know many atheists in real life - and have them in positions of authority?

4) The internet is killing other false ideas as well

I think this principle is best demonstrated by looking at other bubbles of misinformation as well, and how they're fairing in the internet age...Yes, bubbles based on misinformation like anti-vaxxers have a brand new platform with the internet to share their views, but we also have a much better apparatus than the past to quickly criticize and shame such dangerous misconceptions.

In the past, bad ideas could ping around quite easily, or urban myths could be spread without easy access to checking a source. A lot of your information would come from what you read in a book or what a higher authority or just a regular friend told you. Unless you were a scientist, researcher, or journalist, you weren't regularly processing information and knowledgeable in fact checking. The internet allows all of us to be quick researchers, even in simple every day questions - "Who wrote that song???" "Who's that actor from Terminator who's also in Wayne's World?"

That's all...

Finally...it's very important in Christianity (and any religion) to pass your religion on to your children - I believe that is because the claims of the religion must be taught and not learned.. That is, Christianity is not something naturally divined from the world around you, it must be indoctrinated. It does not survive well when it's claims can be checked. If we removed Christianity from the world tomorrow, nobody would re-discover Jesus in 100 years. (The same for any other religion). It is a system passed down through tradition and story rather than any inherent truth.

Anyways...that's the debate for today. Christians, I'd like you to answer:

- If Christianity is true, why is it shrinking in the age of the internet as it reaches the most people for the first time?

- Were you raised in a faith community, with most of the authorities around you as Christian?

- How is your church not a bubble?

- To counter my argument, was anybody made a Christian after growing up in a non-faith based community and encountering Christianity online?

edit1: grammar


r/DebateAChristian • • Mar 13 '19

God shares many similarities with Domestic Abusers.

94 Upvotes

From the article 12 Traits of An Abuser, published by the Christian Broadcasting Network.

http://www1.cbn.com/marriage/12-traits-of-an-abuser

An abuser is typically:

  1. Charming:

    1. I don't think anyone here would dispute the fact that God is appealing, so I'll move on.

  2. Jealous:

    1. Exodus 34:14 "Do not worship any other god, for the LORD, whose name is Jealous, is a jealous God."

    2. Exodus 20:5 " You shall not worship them or serve them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, on the third and the fourth generations of those who hate Me "

    3. Deuteronomy 4:23 " "For the LORD your God is a consuming fire, a jealous God. "

    4. Deuteronomy 32:16 " hey made Him jealous with strange gods; With abominations they provoked Him to anger. "

    5. Deuteronomy 6:15 " for the LORD your God in the midst of you is a jealous God; "

    6. Psalm 78:58 " For they provoked Him with their high places And aroused His jealousy with their graven images. "

  3. Manipulative:

    1. Exodus 7:3-4 " “But I will harden Pharaoh's heart, and though I multiply my miraculous signs and wonders in Egypt he will not listen to you "

    2. Exodus 9:12 " But the LORD hardened Pharaoh's heart and he would not listen to Moses and Aaron, just as the LORD had said to Moses. "

    3. 1 Samuel 16:14 " Now the Spirit of the Lord had departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from the Lord tormented him. "- (This was so he'd bring David to his palace.)]

    4. Joshua 11:20 "For it was the LORD himself who hardened their hearts to wage war against Israel, so that he might destroy them totally, exterminating them without mercy, as the LORD had commanded Moses. "

    5. Deuteronomy 2:30 " But Sihon king of Heshbon refused to let us pass through. For the LORD your God had made his spirit stubborn and his heart obstinate in order to give him into your hands, as he has now done. "

    6. Ezra 1:1 " In the first year of Cyrus king of Persia, in order to fulfill the word of the Lordspoken by Jeremiah, the Lord moved the heart of Cyrus king of Persia to make a proclamation throughout his realm and also to put it in writing: "

    7. 2 Thessalonians 2:11 " And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie: "

  4. Controlling

    1. Deuteronomy 11: " Love the LORD your God and keep his requirements, his decrees, his laws and his commands always."

    2. 2 Corinthians 10:5 "We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ. "

    3. John 14:15 " If you love me, keep my commands. "

    4. Colossians 3:22 " Slaves, obey your earthly masters in everything; and do it, not only when their eye is on you and to curry their favor, but with sincerity of heart and reverence for the Lord. "

    5. Romans 13:1 " Every person is to be in subjection to the governing authorities For there is no authority except from God, and those which exist are established by God. "

  5. A Victim ("He is never at fault. “You make me hit you.”-From the passage)

    1. Deuteronomy 8:5 " "Thus you are to know in your heart that the LORD your God was disciplining you just as a man disciplines his son.".

    2. Colossians 3:6 "For it is because of these things that the wrath of God will come upon the sons of disobedience"

    3. John 3:36 " "He who believes in the Son has eternal life; but he who does not obey the Son will not see life, but the wrath of God abides on him." "

    4. Leviticus 26:27-28 "'Yet if in spite of this you do not obey Me, but act with hostility against Me, then I will act with wrathful hostility against you, and I, even I, will punish you seven times for your sins."

    5. 2 Chronicles 36:16 " but they continually mocked the messengers of God, despised His words and scoffed at His prophets, until the wrath of the LORD arose against His people, until there was no remedy. "

    6. Zechariah 7:12 " "They made their hearts like flint so that they could not hear the law and the words which the LORD of hosts had sent by His Spirit through the former prophets; therefore great wrath came from the LORD of hosts. "

    7. Proverbs 1:24-26 " "Because I called and you refused, I stretched out my hand and no one paid attention; And you neglected all my counsel And did not want my reproof; I will also laugh at your calamity; I will mock when your dread comes, "

  6. Narcissistic

    1. Deuteronomy 10:17 " For the Lord your God is God of gods and Lord of lords, the great, the mighty, and the awesome God, who is not partial and takes no bribe. "

    2. Exodus 4:11 " The LORD said to him, "Who gave human beings their mouths? Who makes them deaf or mute? Who gives them sight or makes them blind? Is it not I, the LORD? "

    3. Deuteronomy 32:4 “The Rock, his work is perfect, for all his ways are justice. A God of faithfulness and without iniquity, just and upright is he."

    4. Deuteronomy 7:21 "You shall not be in dread of them, for the Lord your God is in your midst, a great and awesome God."

  7. Inconsistent (Oh boy, here we go)

    1. Numbers 23:19 States that " God is not human, that he should lie,not a human being, that he should change his mind " But at the same point in time Genesis 6:6 states "The LORD regretted that he had made human beings on the earth, and his heart was deeply troubled. "

    2. John 13:34, Jesus says " Love one another. As I have loved you, so you must love one another. " but at the same point in time in Luke 14:26, he says " "If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, his wife and children, his brothers and sisters—yes, even his own life—he cannot be my disciple. "

    3. Matthew 19:19 says " Honour thy father and [thy] mother:" but previously in Matthew 10:35, Jesus stated " For I am come to set a man at variance against his father, and the daughter against her mother"

    4. In Matthew 10:34 Jesus said, " Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword. " and in Luke 22:36 he said " He said to them, "But now if you have a purse, take it, and also a bag; and if you don't have a sword, sell your cloak and buy one. " but in Matthew 26:52, Jesus states :" Then said Jesus unto him, Put up again thy sword into his place: for all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword. "

    5. In Matthew 5:44 Jesus states " But I tell you: Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, " but in Luke 19:27, he states " But those mine enemies, which would not that I should reign over them, bring hither, and slay [them] before me. "

    6. Ephesians 2:8-9 states " For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God— 9 not by works, so that no one can boast. " but at the same point in James 2:24 it's written " 24 You see that a person is considered righteous by what they do and not by faith alone."

    7. Genesis 32:30 says " And Jacob called the name of the place Peniel: for I have seen God face to face, and my life is preserved. " but John 1:18 states " No one has ever seen God, but the one and only Son, who is himself God and[a]is in closest relationship with the Father, has made him known. "

    8. Romans 3:23 says " 23 for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God" but Job 1:1 states " There was a man in the land of Uz, whose name was Job; and that man was perfect and upright, and one that feared God, and eschewed evil. "

    9. Proverbs 26:4 states " Do not answer a fool according to his folly,or you yourself will be just like him. " but right after that in Proverbs 26:5 it states " Answer a fool according to his folly, or he will be wise in his own eyes. "

  8. Critical

    1. Romans 3:23 says " 23 for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God"

    2. Jeremiah 10:14 " Every man is stupid, devoid of knowledge; Every goldsmith is put to shame by his idols; For his molten images are deceitful, And there is no breath in them. "

    3. Ecclesiastes 7:20 "Indeed, there is not a righteous man on earth who continually does good and who never sins."

    4. John 3:19 " "This is the judgment, that the Light has come into the world, and men loved the darkness rather than the Light, for their deeds were evil. "

    5. Galatians 5:19 " Now the works of the flesh are evident: sexual immorality, impurity, sensuality,"

  9. Disconnected

    1. Luke 14:26 " "If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, his wife and children, his brothers and sisters—yes, even his own life—he cannot be my disciple. "

    2. Leviticus 21:18 " No man who has any defect may come near: no man who is blind or lame, disfigured or deformed; "

    3. Exodus 32:29 :" Then Moses told the Levites, "Today you have ordained yourselves for the service of the LORD, for you obeyed him even though it meant killing your own sons and brothers. Today you have earned a blessing."

  1. Hypersensitive

    1. 2 Kings 2:23-24 " He went up from there to Bethel, and while he was going up on the way, some small boys came out of the city and jeered at him, saying, “Go up, you baldhead! Go up, you baldhead!” 24 And he turned around, and when he saw them, che cursed them in the name of the Lord. And two she-bears came out of the woods and tore forty-two of the boys. "

  2. Vicious and Cruel

    1. Numbers 31:17 "Now kill all the boys. And kill every woman who has slept with a man, 18 but save for yourselves every girl who has never slept with a man."

    2. Numbers 11:33 " But while the meat was still between their teeth and before it could be consumed, the anger of the LORD burned against the people, and he struck them with a severe plague. "

    3. Exodus 11: 5 " and all the firstborn in the land of Egypt shall die, from the firstborn of the Pharaoh who sits on his throne, even to the firstborn of the slave girl who is behind the millstones; all the firstborn of the cattle as well "

    4. Genesis 38:9 " But Onan knew that the child would not be his; so whenever he slept with his brother’s wife, he spilled his semen on the ground to keep from providing offspring for his brother.10 What he did was wicked in the Lord’s sight; so the Lord put him to death also. "

    5. Hosea 13:16 " The people of Samaria must bear their guilt,because they have rebelled against their God.They will fall by the sword;their little ones will be dashed to the ground,their pregnant women ripped open.” "

    6. Leviticus 26:27-29 " And if ye will not for all this hearken unto me, but walk contrary unto me; Then I will walk contrary unto you also in fury; and I, even I, will chastise you seven times for your sins. And ye shall eat the flesh of your sons, and the flesh of your daughters shall ye eat."

    7. 1 Samuel 6:19 " But God struck down some of the inhabitants of Beth Shemesh, putting seventy of them to death because they looked into the ark of the LORD. The people mourned because of the heavy blow the LORD had dealt them. "

    8. Deuteronomy 22:28-29 "If a man happens to meet a virgin who is not pledged to be married and rapes her and they are discovered, 29 he shall pay her father fifty shekels[a] of silver. He must marry the young woman, for he has violated her. He can never divorce her as long as he lives. "

  3. Insincerely Repentant

    1. John 3:17 " For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through Him", but still has a "Judgement Day" where the World gets judged.

As someone who has personally spent years under the boot of an abuser, and as someone who helped others worked through it while volunteering at a domestic violence shelter, how can an benevolent god possibly have so many similarities?


r/DebateAChristian • • Sep 03 '20

An Appeal to Softer Evidence For and Against God, or: The Argument from Jelly Beans

93 Upvotes

Thesis: instead of relying on 'slam-dunk' arguments and evidence for and against the existence of God, we should consider large amounts of soft evidence to decide if God is likely or not. An examination of the available evidence reveals the existence of God is extremely unlikely.

If you've been on this sub for a while or if you've seen religious debates before, you've heard every slam-dunk argument for and against God's existence a thousand times. Many arguments claim to definitively prove or disprove God, and at this point it seems impossible to come up with new ones. Nonetheless, every one of these slam-dunk arguments has responses, caveats, and counterarguments. These arguments seem to always fall short of proving their conclusions completely. Too often these arguments stall when presented with a possibility that refutes them, like so:

Alice: This study proves prayers don't work, which proves God doesn't exist!

Bob: That doesn't prove anything. Maybe God doesn't like to be tested.

or so:

Bob: The fact religion is so widespread proves God exist!

Alice: That doesn't prove anything. Maybe religions are widespread because they comfort people.

These are good arguments - they raise compelling evidence that should clearly change our confidence about whether God exists or not. But they fail because they aim too high. These arguments are 'hard' arguments - they claim to completely disprove the opposing view. But that means all it takes to dismiss them is one possible scenario in which the opposing view could be consistent with them, no matter how outlandish or unlikely that possible scenario is. This means we dismiss useful arguments just because they don't completely resolve the discussion. To see this in action, imagine the following conversation:

Charlie: I don't think Santa exists.

Delilah: How could you say that? Of course Santa exists!

Charlie: But I met Santa at the mall and he was just a guy in a costume.

Delilah: That doesn't prove the real Santa doesn't exist.

Charlie: But my parents admitted to me they never thought Santa was real and that they lied to me about it.

Delilah: Just because your parents don't believe in Santa doesn't prove he doesn't exist.

Charlie: But I stayed up all night and saw my parents putting the presents under the tree, not Santa.

Delilah: Maybe Santa only comes if you are not watching the tree.

Delilah is correct - no argument Charlie has presented conclusively prove Santa doesn't exist. However, they are still effective arguments that together make a strong cumulative case for the non-existence of Santa. Often, in discussions of God, we dismiss an argument for theism just because there is at least one way in which atheism is compatible with it, or vice versa. That is, we dismiss 'hard' evidence completely after finding even one potential resolution for it under our worldview. In this post, I advocate for a more soft approach to the evidence for and against God.

The Argument from Jelly Beans

This post is heavily inspired by Paul Draper's "Case for Naturalism" from his debate with William Lane Craig, and by Jeffery Jay Lowder's extension of it in his debate with Frank Turek. The following is a modification of Draper's analogy.

Imagine you have two giant jars of jelly beans. The red jar has almost all red beans, with a few blue and few yellow. The blue jar has almost all blue beans, with a few red and few yellow. (See this image.) Now the power goes out, and as you stumble around in the dark, you knock over one of the jars and spill a bunch of beans. You quickly right the jar back up, and go to flip the breaker. When you come back, you see both jars standing there, and you can't tell which was the one you knocked over. But you can see the beans that spilled on the ground - mostly red, with a few blue and yellow ones mixed in. Which jar did you knock over?

You can't definitively prove which jar the beans came from. After all, if we pick up one red bean, it could have come from the red jar or the blue jar, since there are red beans in both (and the same is true for blue and yellow beans). Both hypotheses are consistent with the evidence we see. But that does not mean we can't still be quite confident we knocked over the red jar. Though either is possible, it's much more likely for a red bean to be on the ground if we knocked over the red jar than it is if we knocked over the blue jar. If we knocked over the blue jar, it would be surprising for there to be so many red beans - not impossible, but surprising. Each red bean on the ground makes us more confident the red jar was the one knocked over, and each blue bean makes us less confident of this (and the yellow ones do not affect our confidence).

So what does this mean for the existence of God? Simple: there are two jars we are considering in this discussion, the jar of atheism and the jar of theism. We don't get to know which one is the right one, but we do get to look at facts in the world - and each fact is a bean. Red beans are facts that support atheism, blue beans are facts that support theism, and yellow bean are neutral. Our goal is to figure out which jar the beans spilled out of.

Likelihood and the Impact of Soft Evidence

These softer arguments might not look like the ones you're used to seeing. The evidence they present is not inconsistent with theism or atheism. Nevertheless, it can support one or the other, and can support it to different degrees. Here's another analogy.

Imagine you have a pile of coins, half of which are normal coins, and half of which are trick coins that only land on heads. You take a coin off the pile and flip it, and get a heads. What does this piece of evidence tell you? It's consistent with either possibility - the coin could have been a fair one or a trick one. However, the heads result is still evidence in support of it being a trick coin. This becomes clear when you flip the coin 99 more times, and get 99 more heads - each flip makes you more confident the coin is a trick coin. This is because if the coin is fair, it could have been heads, but could have also been something else (tails) – whereas if the coin is a trick coin, it must have been heads.

Now, soft evidence like this can be more or less impactful. What matters is likelihood - given each hypothesis (trick or fair), how likely is the result? For example, a single coin flip resulting in heads is not that strong evidence for a trick coin – it could have easily just been a fair coin that happened to land on heads. The chance of heads is not that different under the "fair" hypothesis (50%) than under the "trick" hypothesis (100%). Now let's replace the coins with 100-sided dice. The fair ones can roll anything, and the trick ones only roll 37. If we roll a die once and it comes up 37, we can be pretty sure it's a trick die - it's much stronger evidence. 37 is way less likely under the "fair" hypothesis (1%) than under the "trick" hypothesis (100%), so it's very strong evidence for the trick hypothesis.

The more formal version of this idea is Bayes' theorem. For the sake of simplicity, I gloss over a few details in this account (such as prior/intrinsic probability), but you can check them out in the theorem itself and they are also discussed in Lowder's talk.

The Format of a Jelly Bean

So given these facts about soft evidence, what does a jelly bean look like? Simple: a jelly bean is just a fact we observe about the world. Then, we compare two quantities: how surprising is the fact under theism, and how surprising is the fact under atheism. If it is less surprising under one of them, then it supports that one - it has greater likelihood under that one. So our color-coding key is:

  • If a fact is less surprising under atheism, it is a red bean (evidence for atheism).

  • If a fact is less surprising under theism, it is a blue bean (evidence for theism).

  • If a fact is equally surprising under both, it is a yellow bean (not evidence one way or the other).

One easy way to show that a fact is less surprising under a hypothesis is to show that it is necessary. If under theism a fact is necessary, but under atheism a fact is one of multiple ways things could have been, then that fact is less surprising under theism, and supports theism (and vice versa). Note that this doesn't require the fact to be unlikely under either case - if a fact has a 100% likelihood under atheism, and an 80% likelihood under theism, it is evidence for atheism, despite being quite likely even under theism. This was also the case in the coin analogy above; landing on heads was quite likely under both the "fair" and "trick" hypotheses, but it was necessary under the "trick" hypothesis, so that was the hypothesis it supported.

I list some red and blue jelly beans below. I mainly address the Abrahamic religions and the idea of a powerful, wise, benevolent, loving, personal creator God here, so not every bean will apply to every conception of God; if you have a different conception, you should reevaluate each fact to see whether it is a red, blue, or yellow bean for your view. In order to be able to list as many beans as possible, the beans are heavily summarized and aim only to show that a fact is more likely under one possibility than another, so please forgive some drastic simplification.

Red Jelly Beans

Here is a list of facts which are more likely if God does not exist than if he does exist:

  1. The meager moral fruits of theism (from Draper): on the whole, it seems that believers in God are similar to non-believers in how moral they are. The two groups are not identical, but on the whole, they are quite similar.

    1. If God exists, we would expect those who communicate with him or follow his teachings to be significantly more moral than those who don't, and the fact they are not is surprising.

    2. If God doesn't exist, we would expect to see some local variations in morality due to cultural correlations, but no moral difference overall, which is what we observe.

  2. Correspondence of mental & physical states (from Draper): as best as we can tell, mental states are closely correlated to physical states. Destroying parts of the brain destroys parts of the mind, including everything from memory to sensation to personality. While we have yet to prove mental and physical states are identical, it is unquestionable that they are extremely correlated.

    1. If God exists, then there is at least one mind which is not dependent on or correlated with the physical in this way – God's. Therefore, the fact that all minds we observe seem to have this very close correlation is surprising, since it seems like they would not have to be so, and that an idea like souls would be more expected.

    2. If God doesn't exist, then this fact is not surprising, as everything else we observe seems closely linked to physical states, so it is unsurprising that mental states do as well.

  3. Evolution (from Draper): overwhelming evidence from multiple fields of scientific study have conclusively shown that humans as well as all other life on earth came about from earlier life forms through evolution by natural selection.

    1. If God exists, evolution is surprising, since God could have chosen to create humans via any means. He could have created everything directly, for example, or he could have created all other life through evolution and intervened to make humans directly. The fact that evolution is the process he chose is not impossible, but it is surprising.

    2. If God doesn't exist, then an unguided, trial-and-error process like evolution is exactly the kind of process we would expect to account for the existence of complex life, so it is not surprising.

  4. Link between pain and pleasure and reproductive success (from Draper): evidence from biology and psychology has shown that pain and pleasure are extremely linked to reproductive success and seem to be set up in a manner that encourages reproductive success. For example, the act of procreation results in high degrees of pleasure, as does caring for children.

    1. If God exists, this fact is surprising, since God is benevolent and pain is an object with moral relevance. We would expect pain and pleasure to be linked in some way to morality or reward and punishment, and it is surprising that they seem to almost exclusively favor reproductive success even when it is immoral (such as in the case of rape).

    2. If God doesn't exist, we would expect pain and pleasure to have the same reproduction-oriented biological role that other bodily systems display, like sexual maturation, and no other purpose, so this is not surprising.

  5. The abundance of evil (from Draper): the world contains a high amount of suffering and evil that seem to serve no purpose, and whose removal would not impact free will, and that do not serve as a test or a tool for growth for anyone.

    1. If God exists, this is surprising, since we would expect a benevolent, wise, and powerful God to refrain from creating such evil or allowing it to come into being. It is possible there are some reasons beyond our understanding why allowing such evil is a good thing, but it is equally possible there are some reasons beyond our understanding why allowing such evil is an even worse thing than we realize.

    2. If God does not exist, then this is exactly what we would expect, since we would expect tragedy to be distributed with no regard to any higher purpose, and be the result of natural forces.

  6. The success of science (from Lowder): science has been extremely successful at explaining the universe without relying on supernatural explanations. Even though science has yet to explain every phenomenon we observe, many times in the history of science, a natural explanation has replaced a supernatural one, but almost never has a supernatural explanation replaced a natural one.

    1. If God exists, then the supernatural necessarily exists, so it is surprising that science has been so successful without taking into account the real existence of the supernatural.

    2. If God does not exist, then it is not surprising that science has been so successful, since it can easily be explained by the fact that the supernatural does not exist.

  7. The existence of neurological moral handicaps (from Lowder): many neurological disorders cause people to have moral handicaps, such as psychopathy making those it afflicts incapable of experiencing empathy. These neurological moral handicaps make it harder for the afflicted to act morally and make them more likely to cause harm to others, both through no fault of their own or anyone else.

    1. If God exists, this is surprising, since we would expect God to alleviate such handicaps or design humans so as to not be afflicted by them, both for the purposes of reducing suffering and for the purposes of fairly testing humans if he engages in such tests.

    2. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we'd expect, since there is no reason to think brains and minds would not sometimes be malformed just like any other biological system.

  8. The multiplicity and inconsistency of religions: there are many religions in the world, all of which have large amounts of sincere, devout believers. These religions are mutually exclusive in many regards; for example, Islam prohibits the consumption of alcohol, while Christianity encourages drinking wine in the Eucharist.

    1. If God exists, this fact is surprising, since we would expect a God that cares enough to establish a religion to also care about distinguishing his religion as the right one. The fact that, even upon an honest attempt to find the right path, many people still reach different conclusions is therefore surprising.

    2. If God doesn't exist, we would expect to see a multiplicity of religions that contradict each other, since none of them would be right.

  9. Ineffectiveness of prayer: large-scale studies of prayer have shown that it does not have an effect on external outcomes, or at least that the effect is very small or disappears under scrutiny. While prayer can have positive effects for the one praying, praying for external outcomes like for a stranger's health to improve seems to have no effect.

    1. If God exists, this fact is surprising, since we would expect prayer to have at least some chance to be success. There may be explanations for the failure of these prayers, for example that God does not like to be tested, but it is at least plausible that prayer would work if God exists, so it is somewhat surprising when it does not.

    2. If God doesn't exist, then this is exactly what we'd expect, since prayer would not be contacting any supernatural entity, and would only have placebic benefits.

  10. Transmittance of religious truth through mundane means: all religions transmit and receive their ideas through mundane means, such as human mouthpieces of God or sacred texts; these means can be and are equally employed by contradictory religions and by non-religious false claims.

  11. If God exists, this is surprising, since God could transmit religious truth through any means of his choosing, such as telepathy, writing it on the moon, or making every human be born with it innately. The fact that he chooses means identical to those that human-created claims use is surprising.

  12. If God doesn't exist, then religious truth is mundane in origin, so this is what we would expect.

  13. Absence of effective prophecy: all religious prophecies do not meet the criteria for successfully demonstrating foreknowledge, and are similar in efficacy to prophecies from contradictory faiths or from non-religious sources like secular astrology or fortune-telling. It is possible to make much more effective prophecies, but religions do not do this.

  14. If God exists, this is surprising, since we would expect prophecies from God to have no reason to be similar to prophecies from false sources. It is possible that God chooses to only issue vague or unfalsifiable prophecies, but it is surprising.

  15. If God does not exist, then this is exactly what we'd expect, since prophecies from religious sources would be no different from any other prophecy in their accuracy or source.

  16. The existence of superfluous elements of the universe unrelated to human life: the vast majority of the universe is completely non-beneficial for and unrelated to human life. Most of the universe is empty space, and most matter in the universe is in vast dust clouds or extremely distant stars. The same is true for the earth; the majority of the surface of the earth is covered by uninhabitable ocean, and the rest was uninhabitable until the development of human technology like clothing and food preservation.

  17. If God exists, we would expect the universe to be designed with human life as a primary goal, so the fact that most of it is utterly unrelated to human life is surprising. It is possible that there are reasons we don't yet understand for why these other things are necessary for human life, but it is equally possible there are reasons we don't yet understand why things we think are necessary for human life aren't.

  18. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we would expect, since we would not expect the universe to be designed with any attention paid to human life.

  19. The moral obsoletion of religious texts: most religious texts (and all Abrahamic religious texts) contain moral guidelines of purported divine origin, but also contain things now widely considered to be immoral, including positive or neutral depictions of slavery, genocide, sexism, etc.

  20. If God exists, this is surprising since we would expect a God-given morality to be correct and not be rendered obsolete by the passage of time. It is possible that the immoral aspects of the texts have other explanations, such as their introduction by fallible humans or as some part of God's plan, but it is surprising.

  21. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we would expect, since the moralities of religions would be determined mostly by the prevailing moralities of their human authors at the time they were written.

  22. Scientific inaccuracies in religious texts: most religious texts (and all Abrahamic religious texts) contain significant scientific inaccuracies consistent with the period they were written, and none contain explicit scientific understanding beyond their time.

  23. If God exists, this is surprising since we would expect God to know scientific facts not yet discovered, and it is surprising for text with a divine source to contain errors that match the time. It is possible these errors were introduced by human authors or as some part of God's plan, but it is surprising.

  24. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we would expect, since these texts are not connected to any supernatural source, so they are plagued by the scientific misconceptions of their time and authors.

  25. Failure of creation myths: creation myths are important to most religions, and many religions place great importance on answering the question of where the universe came from. However, all religious creation myths have failed to match scientific observations and our best theories for the universe's origin.

  26. If God exists, this is surprising since we would expect God to know how the universe was created, and expect that if he chose to communicate how it was created that he would not communicate common falsehoods. It is possible these errors were introduced by human authors or as some part of God's plan, but it is surprising.

  27. If God does not exist, this is exactly what we would expect, since these texts are not connected to any supernatural source, so they have no special knowledge of the origin of the universe.

  28. Longevity of the universe: modern cosmology indicates that we are at a somewhat standard time in cosmological history, and that universal events are not wrapping up. Best estimates say the universe will last around 10^100 more years before heat death, and even if they are revised, it is clear universal happenings are not heading towards a major change anytime in the next several billion years. (This bean does not apply to religions without end times predictions.)

  29. If God exists, this is surprising, since many religions predict an end times event in the near future, on the scale of far less than a billion years. It therefore seems surprising that the universe acts exactly as if it is not coming to an end, and that there are processes in it which will be in progress or not yet started when the end times occurs.

  30. If God doesn't exist, this is not surprising, because there is no near-future end times.

  31. Existence of pain in animals: although we can't tell exactly whether animals subjectively experience pain, animals have mechanisms of pain nearly identical to the one that we do, despite it serving no moral purpose for them.

  32. If God exists, this is surprising, since we would expect our mechanisms of pain to serve a moral purpose, and hence for them to be completely dissimilar to a mechanism of pain used by animals which are not being morally judged by God and which are not expected to act morally.

  33. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we'd expect, since our mechanisms of pain would have come from those of the animals we are descended from and serve no special moral purpose.

  34. Hiddenness of God: God seems to be hidden, at least to nonbelievers. We can't see or talk to him, he doesn't personally reach out to us, and genuine attempts to confirm his existence are met with mixed success at best. Though some claim God is plain for all to see, he clearly isn't as plain as he could be; for example, he is not as plain as the sun, since uncontacted tribes have no ideas of God that are anything like ours, but describe the appearance of the sun just as we do.

  35. If God exists, this is surprising, since while God could have wanted to be hidden, he could have also wanted to be obvious, so the fact he is so well hidden is at least somewhat surprising.

  36. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we would expect, since there would be no God to find, so he would appear hidden.

  37. The rarity and unconfirmability of miracles: miracle claims are prevalent in many religions, but miracles are few and far between, and usually occur in the distant past or are otherwise unconfirmable. Miracles that occur under circumstances that allow scrutiny end up being found to have mundane causes when fully investigated.

  38. If God exists, this is surprising, since he could choose to perform miracles much more often, or to perform them in a much more spectacular and confirmable fashion, so the fact he doesn't is at least somewhat surprising.

  39. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we'd expect, since there are no real miracles, only things which appear to be miracles until properly investigated.

  40. Genealogy of religions: all religions whose origins we can investigate seem to be connected to and to some extent derived from earlier religions. For example, many religions contain ideas like flood myths, virgin birth, etc. which are also found in more ancient religions with contradictory beliefs.

  41. If God exists, this is surprising, since we would expect divine texts to come from God instead of from earlier inconsistent religions. It is possible these myths were borrowed as storytelling devices or were somehow part of God's plan, but it is at least somewhat surprising.

  42. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we'd expect, since there would be no true religion that would have a non-human source of myth.

  43. Recent origins of modern religion: all religions present today seem to have not existed in anything resembling their modern forms for most of human history. Humans are estimated to have become behaviorally modern around 50,000 years ago, but as best we can tell all modern religions and religious texts are no more than a few thousand years old (though some have been influenced by much older religions). This is especially true for monotheistic religions.

  44. If God exists, this is surprising, since we wouldn't have any reason to expect the current time in history to be close to the date of God founding the true religion. If anything, we would expect it to be in the very distant past, since otherwise many humans would live and die before God communicated the true religion.

  45. If God doesn't exist, this isn't surprising, since we would expect people to hold beliefs created closer to modern times more.

  46. Existence of the unlearned: for every single religion, there are many millions of people today and in the past that have never heard of it.

  47. If God exists, this is surprising, since if God found religion important enough for some humans to hear, we would expect him to want all humans to hear of it, not just some that happen to be geographically and temporally clustered. It is possible he did not, but it is surprising.

  48. If God doesn't exist, this is exactly what we'd expect, since just like with any other belief or idea some people will have never heard of it.

  49. The extreme importance of belief to God: almost all religions emphasize the extreme importance of believing them to be true, and many state that reward and punishment both in this life and the next largely or entirely depend on belief in God.

  50. If God exists, this is surprising, since it is clearly plausible that God does not care about belief in him. In fact, some sects hold this view, and many sects hold that the unlearned (those who never hear of the correct religion) are not judged based on their belief. So the fact that God cares so much about belief in him is surprising.

  51. If God doesn't exist, this is not surprising, since emphasis on belief and rewards or punishments for belief would be predictable features religions would use to strengthen themselves and bolster the faith of their believers, just as non-religious groups do.

  52. Religious demand for faith: many religions ask believers to believe on faith, that is, to believe not solely based on evidence or reasoning but based on complete trust. Many religions also ask that this faith be primary, and that belief based on evidence be secondary.

  53. If God exists, this is somewhat surprising, since God could have easily chosen not to ask for faith from believers, and to ask them to believe only based on evidence or reason.

  54. If God doesn't exist, this is not surprising, since it would be a common tactic to discourage dissent or disbelief and to rebuff evidence against religions, similar to techniques used by non-religious groups.

Blue Jelly Beans

Here is a list of facts which are more likely if God does exist than if he doesn't:

  1. Extreme prevalence of religion: religion is extremely widespread in the world, and as far as we can tell, some form of religion has always been widespread, even though it was quite different from the monotheistic conception we have today.

    1. If God exists, this is what we'd expect, since the real existence of the supernatural would lead to religions forming even if they were not accurate in all their beliefs.

    2. If God does not exist, this fact is somewhat surprising, since it seems possible that religion would have been a niche belief or would have petered out. The fact that humans are so prone to false religious belief, while explainable, is somewhat surprising.

  2. Existence of intelligent life: humans exist and are intelligent.

    1. If God exists, this is what we'd expect, since God is interested in creating intelligent life.

    2. If God doesn't exist, this is surprising, since it seems evolution didn't have to result in humans or any other intelligent life, as evidenced by the lack of intelligent life comparable to humans in the previous 4 billion years of evolution. While this is explainable (e.g. via the anthropic principle), it is at least somewhat more surprising on this view.

  3. Near death experiences: many people that come close to death report vivid supernatural experiences, including experiences of afterlives such as heaven and hell. These experiences are not universal and often contradict each other.

    1. If God exists, this is what we'd expect, since an afterlife existing might cause these sorts of experiences to occur.

    2. If God does not exist, this fact is surprising, since although it is explainable under naturalistic mechanisms, it did not have to come about that people could have near death experiences, so the fact that things happen to work out so as to create them is surprising.

Discussion

I want to make it clear that the number of beans, by itself, does not indicate anything. Rather, we should take into account how compelling each bean is (based on likelihood as described above), in addition to the number of beans. That said, even with this taken into account, the red beans seem to far outweigh the blue. The fact that so many features of religion and the universe are exactly what we expect to find in a world with no God, and the fact that any proposed 'true' religion looks so very similar to many false religions, together make attempts at explaining away these things little more than wishful thinking. Hence, I believe the argument from jelly beans presents a compelling cumulative case for atheism.

But that's just what I think. Do you think any beans should be different colors? Can you think of more red or blue beans? Theists, do you reject this cumulative case as a reason to change your position, and if so, why?

Edit: apologies for the broken formatting on the numbering for red beans, it seems to be a reddit issue and I can't get it to go away completely.


r/DebateAChristian • • Nov 20 '17

If Satan led people away from Judaism, it would look a lot like Christianity.

93 Upvotes

Let's assume the Old Testament is true and God instituted Judaism through Moses. Let's assume that Moses was correct when he stated over 30 different times that Mosaic Law is permanent, forever, for all future generations. Let's assume that Moses was correct when he relayed the procedure for "outsiders" to convert to Judaism.

If Satan wished to lead people astray, he might send a "prophet" to mislead people. This "prophet" would undoubtedly have the ability to perform miracles to authenticate his message.

This "prophet" would deceive people into believing that Mosaic Law is no longer in effect, and that people need not obey Mosaic Law in order to receive forgiveness for sin.

Satan would send others to validate this false prophet and the false religious beliefs and help spread this false religion.

Over time, Satan would encourage division within this false religion so that anyone could find a particular set of doctrinal beliefs with which they feel comfortable. Gradually, this false religion would evolve into such simple and easy doctrine that all that is required by this false religion is a belief in the false prophet and a desire to be a better person.

With such an easy religion available, few people would choose to abide by Mosaic Law. Satan would have a tremendous victory.

This is what the Pharisees accused Jesus and His followers of doing, and warned Jews not to be deceived.


r/DebateAChristian • • Sep 24 '21

The Claims of Christianity Are Just as Bizarre and Obviously False as Scientology, Heaven's Gate cult, etc.

92 Upvotes

People are often bewildered by how anyone could believe the strange claims of Scientology...

Xenu, was, according to Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard, the dictator of the "Galactic Confederacy" who brought billions of his people to Earth (then known as "Teegeeack") in DC-8-like spacecraft 75 million years ago, stacked them around volcanoes, and killed them with hydrogen bombs. Official Scientology scriptures hold that the thetans (immortal spirits) of these aliens adhere to humans, causing spiritual harm. These events are known within Scientology as "Incident II",and the traumatic memories associated with them as "The Wall of Fire" or "R6 implant". The narrative of Xenu is part of Scientologist teachings about extraterrestrial civilizations and alien interventions in earthly events, collectively described as "space opera" by Hubbard. Hubbard detailed the story in Operating Thetan level III (OT III) in 1967, warning that the "R6 implant" (past trauma) was "calculated to kill (by pneumonia, etc.) anyone who attempts to solve it." Salvation is achieved through “clearing” engrams and implant, the source of human misery, through the auditing process.

Or Heaven's Gate...

Members of Heaven's Gate believed that evil space aliens—called Luciferians—falsely represented themselves to Earthlings as "God" and conspired to keep humans from developing. Technically advanced humanoids, these aliens have spacecraft, space-time travel, telepathy, and increased longevity. They use holograms to fake miracles. Carnal beings with gender, they stopped training to achieve the Kingdom of God thousands of years ago. Heaven's Gate believed that all existing religions on Earth had been corrupted by these malevolent aliens. They believed they would biologically and chemically be transformed into extraterrestrial beings and would be transported with their bodies aboard a spacecraft that would come to Earth and take the crew to heaven, referred to as the "Next Level".

I think we all can agree these seem... bizarre.

But Christian beliefs are equally bizarre & should be similarly offensive to our critical thinking. The reason they don't seem that way to people raised in a Christian culture (e.g. America) is because we have exposure to them all our lives, and become used to them. This is called indoctrination.

Here are some Christian beliefs:

Christians believe a not-completely-illiterate Jewish laborer from 1st century Palestine was fully human but also fully divine at the same time. He—"Jesus of Nazareth"—was born to a young virgin girl who was told she would give birth to he "Messiah" by an angel. She was impregnated by the "Holy Sprit", another person of the "Triune God". Kings from neighboring nations followed a magical star to the place of this divine baby's birth. When he grew up, he was baptized by "John the Baptist," a radical preacher who lived in the wilderness & ate locusts, and the Holy Spirit descended on him like a dove. This divine man went on to walk on water, control the weather at will, heal blindness, lameness & other diseases, multiply food 5000x & raise the dead. Being God and God's son at the same time, his ultimate plan was to be executed via crucifixion in order to provide an "atoning" blood sacrifice. After working out this plan by being betrayed by one of his own followers, convicted and killed by Jewish leaders & Roman authorities, he rose from the grave on the 3rd day, his tomb being found empty other than an angel who communicated the message he had risen. In his immortal resurrected state, he could walk through walls and disguise his appearance. After 40 days, he ascended into heaven ("The Ascension") to sit at the right hand of the Father, who is also God in another form, as a member of "the Trinity". Anyone who believes in his claim to divinity and the veracity of his resurrection story is eligible for an eternal reward in paradise that is "God's Kingdom". Anyone who rejects this offer of "salvation" is subject to eternal punishment in "hell."

The largest difference in the these beliefs is the setting in which they take place. These newer religions incorporate technologies roughly correlated to our modern times (i.e. there are spaceships & stuff).

But, at the core, the more you study them, the broad strokes are remarkably similar. Evil entities are at work in the Universe, and humans need saving or sanctifying. There is a process by which this can occur that involves faith and action according to the True Nature of Things.

And, to my thesis, they are all similarly bizarre. Further, just as Scientology or Heaven's Gate seem obviously false to any thinking person who hasn't been indoctrinated, so too does Christianity, when viewed from outside the echo chamber of the church which enforces these dogmas.

We privilege Christianity because in America, by age 5, "Jesus died on the cross for my sins" is as ubiquitous a meme as "Santa comes down the chimney on Christmas Eve."

It's weird...but we're used to it.

Just like many other cultural ideas or practices with which we are completely unfamiliar, Scientology or Heaven's Gate only seem obviously strange because they are novel to us.


r/DebateAChristian • • Jul 30 '19

The bible condones chattel slavery, completely destroying its credibility in dictating any sort of moral code that should be followed by a modern society.

92 Upvotes

To avoid the whole philosophical debate over whether or not morality is objective or subjective, lets base this argument on the established moral code of a western society that I’m (hopefully correctly) assuming most of the people here follow. I’m not going to debate on whether slavery is objectively wrong or not, I’m here to point out that chattel slavery is in the bible, its condoned, legalized, and in some places even commanded by god to partake in. My personal moral code says that this is evil, the western society I live in agrees with me (mostly), if you disagree that slavery is evil this isn’t the thread for you. This thread is for those who believe owning people as property is an immoral act, yet still claim to follow the moral codes set in the bible, or hold gods laws as an objective moral standard.

I’ve seen a lot of people bring this up but I don’t think it should ever be laid to rest. This one aspect of the bible is so damning in and of itself that anyone who looks at it critically should toss the whole book out. This book claims it is the moral standards set by god, and yet not only does it never say that owning people as property is immoral, it both dictates how to own people, and in a few places commands the people in the stories to take people as property.

Slavery in the bible leaves you with few conclusions.

  1. Slavery is moral. I will not entertain this at all, if you choose option 1 you are a bad person, period.

  2. Slavery is immoral yet god and the bible say otherwise. The bible and god are wrong and both are a bad source to base your moral code on. If slavery is immoral yet god and his book says its moral, god is either wrong (which is impossible according to most Christians), god himself is immoral in which case he is unworthy of the worship he demands, or the book is wrong about the nature of god and nothing it says should be taken as truth.

  3. The bible has been corrupted. If this is true nothing it says can be trusted

  4. This book was written by man, as a tool for control. The reason it never banned slavery is because it was written in part by the slavers. This is the conclusion I have landed on personally

I’m sure there are more but non of them are good and I’m not here to write lists.

 

Lets start with defining chattel slavery.

Chattel slavery, also called traditional slavery, is so named because people are treated as the chattel (personal property) of the owner and are bought and sold as commodities. Typically, under the chattel slave system, slave status was imposed on children of the enslaved at birth.

 

And here is indentured servitude

An indentured servant or indentured laborer is an employee (indenturee) within a system of unfree labor who is bound by a signed or forced contract (indenture) to work for a particular employer for a fixed time. The contract often lets the employer sell the labor of an indenturee to a third party. Indenturees usually enter into an indenture for a specific payment or other benefit, or to meet a legal obligation, such as debt bondage. On completion of the contract, indentured servants were given their freedom, and occasionally plots of land.

 

I'm just going to define the word condone here real quick. In the past I've seen debates about this go sideways because people weren't using the same definition

Condone - accept and allow (behavior that is considered morally wrong or offensive) to continue.

So when I say the bible condones chattel slavery I'm saying. "The bible accepts and allows the immoral practice of chattel slavery to continue".

 

I think we can all agree that chattel slavery is not only immoral, but evil. If we disagree on that point we will never find common ground so I will not be replying to you. Chattel slavery is what people talk about when discussing American slavery. The slavery in the bible is a little different than what was used in America, but not different enough that it isn't practically the same thing.

There are places in the bible that do reference debt slavery. I am going to say that is still immoral because they are still considered property. I've also seen the argument that people willingly entered into it for food and shelter as a form of wages. I'm sure they did, but the slaves in the US also got food and shelter, if you don't provide your slaves with that they will die and wont do you any good. Just because they were "paid" doesn't make it ok, if you can't quit your job, you are property, which is chattel slavery. But that’s not going to be the focus of this post, my focus will be on the chattel slavery.

I do want to bring up another argument I've seen, and that's slavery was just part of the culture and god couldn't just ban it. You cannot make the claim that god is all moral and all powerful, and then say he isn't brave enough to stand up to the man made establishment of slavery. This is the guy who flooded the earth, cast plagues on egypt, and "nuked" an entire city because the people had had to much sex. If you make this claim you land on option 2 as seen above, as you are claiming your god cannot or will not stand up against his own creation.

 

 

So to back my claims I will start with the lack of an 11th commandment. Three of the 10 commandments are about gods vanity, he even bans saying his name casually. 1 of them is making a day of the week extra special. Maybe he just likes having a nice even 10, and maybe his vanity really is that important, but I don’t see a single place that says don’t own other people as property. But lack of evidence isn’t very good evidence, let go find the actual verses condoning chattel slavery.

 

Exodus 21. A basic summary of the rules here.

 

2. If you buy a Hebrew servant, he is to serve you for six years. But in the seventh year, he shall go free, without paying anything.

 

Classic indentured servitude lets let that one slide.

 

 

Here is our first example of chattel slavery. Suddenly you go from a simple seven year contract, to taking a mans wife and kids forever, and leaving him with the choice of either staying a slave for life or abandoning his wife and child for his freedom. This is a lifelong commitment too which means it can no longer be called indentured servitude, since the contract is no longer for a fixed period. The child is especially a chattel slave since it was forced into it at birth.

 

4. If his master gives him a wife and she bears him sons or daughters, the woman and her children shall belong to her master, and only the man shall go free. 5. But if the servant declares, ‘I love my master and my wife and children and do not want to go free,’ 6 then his master must take him before the judges. He shall take him to the door or the doorpost and pierce his ear with an awl. Then he will be his servant for life.

 

 

Another example of chattel slavery, she is being sold by her father without her consent, and the only way to be free is if he is a bad husband. You could say this isn't quite chattel slavery because he cant sell her, and it more of an arranged marriage than anything, but I’m still leaving it up.

 

7 “If a man sells his daughter as a servant, she is not to go free as male servants do. 8 If she does not please the master who has selected her for himself, he must let her be redeemed. He has no right to sell her to foreigners, because he has broken faith with her. 9 If he selects her for his son, he must grant her the rights of a daughter. 10 If he marries another woman, he must not deprive the first one of her food, clothing and marital rights. 11 If he does not provide her with these three things, she is to go free, without any payment of money.

 

 

To avoid being dishonest I will admit this rule is nice, you can’t kidnap people, you can trick them and enslave their wife and child, but no kidnapping, so there is that at least.

 

16 “Anyone who kidnaps someone is to be put to death, whether the victim has been sold or is still in the kidnapper’s possession.

 

 

Pretty straight forward, you can beat your slaves as long as you do not kill them...within a day for 2. Make sure they die on day 3 or you're screwed.

 

20 “Anyone who beats their male or female slave with a rod must be punished if the slave dies as a direct result, 21 but they are not to be punished if the slave recovers after a day or two, since the slave is their property.

 

 

Oddly specific but hey just don’t hurt their eyes or teeth.

 

26 “An owner who hits a male or female slave in the eye and destroys it must let the slave go free to compensate for the eye. 27 And an owner who knocks out the tooth of a male or female slave must let the slave go free to compensate for the tooth.

 

 

Here we see what happens if a bull gores someone. If it kills a slave its a fine, if it kills a free man its death to the bull owner or a fine that seems to be whatever the victims family wants. This clearly shows the difference of value between a free vs enslaved person. If it were truly indentured servitude for the sake of the slave as I’ve seen others argue, why is their fine limited by 30 shekels vs the infinite fine or execution for a free men?

 

28 “If a bull gores a man or woman to death, the bull is to be stoned to death, and its meat must not be eaten. But the owner of the bull will not be held responsible. 29 If, however, the bull has had the habit of goring and the owner has been warned but has not kept it penned up and it kills a man or woman, the bull is to be stoned and its owner also is to be put to death. 30 However, if payment is demanded, the owner may redeem his life by the payment of whatever is demanded. 31 This law also applies if the bull gores a son or daughter. 32 If the bull gores a male or female slave, the owner must pay thirty shekels[f] of silver to the master of the slave, and the bull is to be stoned to death.

 

 

So now that you know the rules of treating your slave, where on earth can you get one for yourself? That whole tricking your slave with a wife thing seems way to complicated, isn’t there another way? Why yes there is! Just buy your neighbors!

 

Leviticus 25:44 “‘Your male and female slaves are to come from the nations around you; from them you may buy slaves. 45 You may also buy some of the temporary residents living among you and members of their clans born in your country, and they will become your property. 46 You can bequeath them to your children as inherited property and can make them slaves for life, but you must not rule over your fellow Israelites ruthlessly.

 

This is where you can just straight up obtain people as property forever, and can even pass your slaves onto your children as an inheritance. Remember, if you weren’t gods people, you weren’t actually people. This is a clear example of chattel slavery. There was no contract made, there were no terms of freedom, these people are a commodity bought, sold, and inherited. If you still want to try pulling the old “The word slave used in this context is just indentured servitude” let me just point slightly north towards

 

Leviticus 25: 39 “‘If any of your fellow Israelites become poor and sell themselves to you, do not make them work as slaves. 40 They are to be treated as hired workers or temporary residents among you; they are to work for you until the Year of Jubilee. 41 Then they and their children are to be released, and they will go back to their own clans and to the property of their ancestors. 42 Because the Israelites are my servants, whom I brought out of Egypt, they must not be sold as slaves. 43 Do not rule over them ruthlessly, but fear your God.

 

That is a very stark difference from 44-46. This one is describing indentured servitude, the other chattel slavery. There is no room for misinterpreting the context here.

 

 

Now whats that you say? You cannot afford those darned expensive foreign slaves? Well have no fear! God is here! Go ahead and join the military, if you’re one of gods chosen ones, he will sometimes allow you to take prisoners of war as plunder. And even better, sometimes only the virgin girls!

 

Numbers 31: 17 Now kill all the boys. And kill every woman who has slept with a man, 18 but save for yourselves every girl who has never slept with a man.

 

 

After the battle of Midian they killed every man, boy, and non virgin girl. Besides the atrocity that is killing an entire city including every male baby, this is yet another example of taking people as property. There is no context that lets you twist those taken girls into indentured servants, they were chattel. To further support that, here is how they were commanded to split them up.

They were divided up right along the donkeys and sheep, both of which are also considered chattel. All 32,000 of them.

 

25 The Lord said to Moses, 26 “You and Eleazar the priest and the family heads of the community are to count all the people and animals that were captured. 27 Divide the spoils equally between the soldiers who took part in the battle and the rest of the community. 28 From the soldiers who fought in the battle, set apart as tribute for the Lord one out of every five hundred, whether people, cattle, donkeys or sheep. 29 Take this tribute from their half share and give it to Eleazar the priest as the Lord’s part. 30 From the Israelites’ half, select one out of every fifty, whether people, cattle, donkeys, sheep or other animals. Give them to the Levites, who are responsible for the care of the Lord’s tabernacle.” 31 So Moses and Eleazar the priest did as the Lord commanded Moses. 32 The plunder remaining from the spoils that the soldiers took was 675,000 sheep, 33 72,000 cattle, 34 61,000 donkeys 35 and 32,000 women who had never slept with a man.

 

 

Here is another example of taking people as plunder during war.

 

Deuteronomy 20 10 When you march up to attack a city, make its people an offer of peace. 11 If they accept and open their gates, all the people in it shall be subject to forced labor and shall work for you. 12 If they refuse to make peace and they engage you in battle, lay siege to that city. 13 When the Lord your God delivers it into your hand, put to the sword all the men in it. 14 As for the women, the children, the livestock and everything else in the city, you may take these as plunder for yourselves. And you may use the plunder the Lord your God gives you from your enemies. 15 This is how you are to treat all the cities that are at a distance from you and do not belong to the nations nearby.

 

Luckily this time you don’t have to kill the babies. But whether or not you actually use force to take the city, you’ll get your slaves in the end.

 

 

So god gave you all these pretty woman slaves, but now what do you do? Well, go right on ahead and marry one, all you have to pay is the low low price of 1 month of mourning. Just let your new unwilling wife mourn the family you just slaughtered, and then she is all yours.

 

Deuteronomy 21 10 “When the Lord your God gives you victory in battle and you take prisoners, 11 you may see among them a beautiful woman that you like and want to marry. 12 Take her to your home, where she will shave her head,[a] cut her fingernails, 13 and change her clothes. She is to stay in your home and mourn for her parents for a month; after that, you may marry her. 14 Later, if you no longer want her, you are to let her go free. Since you forced her to have intercourse with you, you cannot treat her as a slave and sell her.

 

So here we see that you can take any woman you want and force yourself on her, all under the moral authority of god. This one isn’t technically chattel since you can’t sell her. But this is still a form of slavery, so it doesn’t help the argument that the bible only supports indentured servitude.

 

Note: I did take this from a particular translation that looks worse than others, but my argument isn’t whether or not they were raped (they were), but whether or not they were chattel.

 

 

Now before you say “This is all old testament, that covenant was done away with when Jebus came around” have I got a couple shockers for you. Jesus endorses slavery, and even says the old testament is still to be followed (In a manner of speaking).

 

Matthew 5 17 “Do not think that I have come to do away with the Law of Moses and the teachings of the prophets. I have not come to do away with them, but to make their teachings come true. 18 Remember that as long as heaven and earth last, not the least point nor the smallest detail of the Law will be done away with—not until the end of all things

 

From the mouth of the merchant whipper himself, the old laws are still just as valid as ever. If you truly believe in the morality of the bible, you too condone slavery...and a ban on shrimp...and a ban on anything not made of 100% cotton...Jesus says so.

 

 

Here in the new testament it demands that slaves obey their masters, even the wicked ones. Some of these came from Jesus himself. 3 Versus demanding obedience from slaves. Not a single one about masters releasing their slaves. This is the textbook definition of condoning something.

 

Ephesians 6 5 Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ; 6 Not with eyeservice, as menpleasers; but as the servants of Christ, doing the will of God from the heart; 7 With good will doing service, as to the Lord, and not to men: 8 Knowing that whatsoever good thing any man doeth, the same shall he receive of the Lord, whether he be bond or free.

 

1 Timothy 6 King James Version 6 Let as many servants as are under the yoke count their own masters worthy of all honour, that the name of God and his doctrine be not blasphemed. 2 And they that have believing masters, let them not despise them, because they are brethren; but rather do them service, because they are faithful and beloved, partakers of the benefit. These things teach and exhort.

 

1 Peter 2 18 Slaves, in reverent fear of God submit yourselves to your masters, not only to those who are good and considerate, but also to those who are harsh.

 

 

Also, Jesus doesn’t just believe in whipping merchants, he also believes in whipping disobedient slaves!

 

Luke 12 47 And that servant, which knew his lord's will, and prepared not himself, neither did according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes.

 

 

So to summarize. Chattel slavery is in the bible extensively, there is no commandment that bans you from owning people as property, it is allowed, there are laws regulating it, there are places which places which point out that some of them are indentured servants while others are chattel, there are verses that let you take virgin woman and kill the rest, marry, and rape them, the new testament didn’t abolish these laws, and Jesus himself commanded slaves to obey instead of commanding the masters to free the slaves. And to those who sat and read the whole thing, I commend you for your dedication, I am not the best writer so I apologize if it was a slog.


r/DebateAChristian • • Jul 20 '21

Punishing Adam & Eve Was the Act of a Moral Monster

86 Upvotes
  1. Before eating fruit from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, Eve and Adam did not understand good and evil.

  2. Upon eating, Gen. 3:7 says "the eyes of them both were opened" to good and evil.

  3. If they were unable to see what evil was before eating the fruit, they had no way of knowing that defying God was evil. It wasn't just ignorance; they lacked the capacity to distinguish good from evil.

  4. God punishes Eve and Adam for disobedience, but at the moment they ate the fruit, they couldn't fully understand that disobedience was wrong.

  5. God's subsequent laundry list of torture - sorrow, agony in childbirth, the wife's submission to the husband, the creation of thorns and thistles, imposing the need to do labor, expulsion from Eden - is undeserved abuse. Particularly so since God knew in advance what was going to happen.


r/DebateAChristian • • Sep 28 '18

Christianity made ONE prediction. That prediction turned out to be false. How is this religion still a thing?

85 Upvotes

Perhaps the most frustrating thing about Christianity to me is the assiduity with which it steers clear of testable predictions. For suspiciously convenient reasons, all of the pivotal events on which the truth of the Christian faith rests took place in an obscure, poorly documented region of a pre-scientific world. Many of its claims are not even testable in theory.

Fortunately, there is one glaring exception. Jesus claimed he would return in the lifetime of his disciples. He did not. Getting something as fundamental as that wrong is an unequivocal disconfirmation of even the mildest interpretation of Jesus’ own claims about himself.

I adduce three NT statements in favour of this thesis. The first two come from the Jesus of the Gospels, the last, added just for good measure, is made in various places in the NT. In each case, I list just a few of the Christian responses I’ve heard and why they’re inadequate.

Matthew 16:28 (cf. Mark 9:1, Luke 9:27) Truly, I say to you, there are some standing here who will not taste death until they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom.

  • “This verse refers to the Judaeo-Roman war.” In which Jerusalem was destroyed. Turning that into “Jesus coming in his kingdom” is exegetical acrobatics of the first order.

  • “This verse refers to the transfiguration.” Again, not a scrap of evidence for this. Like the previous “solution”, turning “coming in his kingdom” into “his clothes turning white” saves the passage only by making the author seem at best obscurantist and at worst dishonest.

Also, the preceding context, where Jesus speaks of coming with his angels in the glory of his Father, makes these solutions (and others like them) even less plausible.

Matthew 24:34 (cf. Mark 13:30, Luke 21:32) Truly, I say to you, this generation will not pass away until all these things take place.

  • “The word genea means race or nation: the word is intended to refer to the continued existence of e.g. the Jewish people.” The word can mean this, but here it clearly doesn’t. “These things will happen at some point between now and the indefinite future” is an odd way to follow up a verse which stresses the swiftness with which these events will take place. This interpretation deprives the passage of all meaning.

  • “The generation Jesus is referring to is the generation alive when these events occur, viz. when the events described happen, they will happen quickly.” This hypothesis is directly belied by the context. In the immediately preceding verses Jesus addresses the disciples directly. When Jesus speaks of "this generation" immediately afterwards, it would require an audience of mind-readers to know that he meant a generation in the distant future.

  • “These things refer to the Judaeo-Roman war.” Yet it follows verses that clearly describe end of time events. You could blatantly cherry-pick the preceding verses that might refer to the Judaeo-Roman war, but then that would be blatant cherry-picking.

Furthermore, the fact that Christians reconcile this passage and the preceding one in different ways is a violation of parsimony, strongly suggesting that the straightforward reading is correct in both cases.

Revelation 22:7 (cf. similar statements passim): behold, I am coming soon

  • 2000 years != soon. Not in any normal sense of the word. The notorious day-is-a-thousand-years cop-out only makes the Bible seem dishonest.


r/DebateAChristian • • Mar 22 '21

The "design" of the human body is by no means "intelligent".

83 Upvotes

Creationists think that the human body is God's magnum opus, meanwhile, we know of many stupid flaws in it, many of which aren't present in other animals. Here are a few, the presence of which suggests that we came to be from a series of blind mutations instead of from a divine creator.

Reproduction

Boy do women get the short end of the stick on this one.

  • Babies' heads are too big to be born naturally: Before the advent of safe c-section methods, giving birth was a death defying ordeal because the head of the baby would sometimes be too big to fit through the pelvic bone and/or the birth canal, leading to babies getting stuck and killing both the mother and the baby. I was one of those babies, and had I not been born in modern times, it's likely that both me and my mother would be dead. Most other mammals? Giving birth is both safer and less excruciating, because their babies are smaller compared to the mother. Female hyenas might have it worse though with their pseudo-penis, which is a long, very narrow birth canal that extends quite a ways out of the body. It looks kind of like a penis and is about the same diameter as the actual penis of a male hyena. Not fun when you're giving birth, a successful first birth necessarily involves tearing it.

  • Actually, all human babies are technically premature: Compared to other mammals, we are born much less developed and much less ready to survive the outside world, partly because of the previous issue. Compared to animals that can start running with their herd minutes after birth, we're pathetic.

  • Ectopic pregnancies: This is when the embryo implants in the Fallopian tube, or in extreme cases, outside the reproductive tract on the intestines or the abdominal wall. It can cause severe bleeding, organ damage, or in the case of the Fallopian tube, can cause it to rupture. It's 100% fatal for the fetus and nearly as fatal for the mother unless an abortion is carried out (and yet, some Christians want to ban abortion for this reason too and just condemn the mother to death for "God's" screw up).

  • Testicles are outside of the body: This is because they need to be cooler than body temperature, so at least there's a reason, but it still doesn't exclude it from being a stupid design. Yeah, let's just put one of the most sensitive parts of the male body on the outside, in harm's way. Oh, and if it ruptures, you die without immediate medical treatment.

  • The prostate: It's nestled under the bladder and wraps around the urethra, which would be fine if it wasn't so fond of swelling so much, which makes urination very difficult. Many men will experience this in their lives.

  • Menstruation: Any woman will tell you that it sucks. Cramps, bleeding, mood swings, the whole nine yards. It's even worse when it goes wrong. It's also wasteful because you lose the nutrients that went into making it. Cats, dogs, and most mammals, on the other hand, also have ovarian cycles, but they reabsorb the endometrium instead of letting it fall off.

  • Ovulation: The ovaries eject eggs into the abdomen, and the ends of the Fallopian tubes have to scramble to pick them up. Remember ectopic pregnancies happening outside of the reproductive system? This is the reason, the reproductive tract is not closed off to the rest of the body.

The eyes

  • The blood vessels that supply the retina block the retina: The blood vessels that, ya know, keep the retina alive, are in front of the retina. You can even see them if conditions are just right. It's also why we have a blind spot, it's where the blood vessels travel through the retina to the rest of the body. Squid and octopus, on the other hand, do not have this problem.

  • Nearsightedness and farsightedness: Are caused by genetic abnormalities in most cases. Need I say more?

Respiration

  • We breathe and swallow through the same region of our throat: enough people have choked to death and there are enough warnings about things being choking hazards to make it clear what a bad idea this is.

Bones

  • The spine is over-stressed in our upright position and does not support our upper body well: It's why so many people have back problems.

  • The bones in our feet look like this. A cat's paws look like this. Which is "designed" more elegantly?

  • You can wear out your knees as you age: Again, this is caused by our upright posture. Many older people literally have to get titanium kneecaps, which is kind of awesome, but it still stupid that procedure is necessary.

  • Most people's jaws are too small for our full set of teeth: It's why people get their wisdom teeth removed, because they often come in sideways or can't come in at all.

The heart and blood

  • Heart attacks: The heart, one of the most important organs of the body, is supplied by a pair of blood vessels not much wider than the ink tube of a ballpoint pen, and there is barely any overlap between the blood vessels, so if any one or its branches get clogged, heart tissue start dying, and don't have the ability to regenerate. This is what a heart attack is. Other animals, like dogs, on the other hand, have it so that the coronary blood supply overlaps, meaning if one branch of the artery gets blocked, the other ones can keep supplying most of the tissue, limiting the severity of heart attacks.

  • Blood clots: Sit for too long and blood clots in the veins of your legs. Then they can dislodge and travel to your heart, lungs, brain, etc, and kill you.

  • You can kill someone by punching them in the region of the heart at the exact wrong moment: It's called commotio cordis, and is caused by a physical shock, like a punch to the chest, happening at a certain point during the heart's electrical cycle. If triggered, it causes ventricular fibrillation, which can quickly kill you and requires a defibrillator to correct. That's right, you can punch someone in the chest and their heart could break.

  • Heart attacks part 2: Why do coronary arteries get blocked? Why, from cholesterol, am essential molecule for our bodies. Too much of the stuff in the blood causes the immune system to freak out, white blood cells go to engulf them, and die from having too much cholesterol in them. Then, they stick to the blood vessel walls, and said walls promptly grow its lining over it, sealing it in. This alone can cause a heart attack, but worse is if the lining above the cholesterol and dead immune cells, called the plaque, breaks open. This activates clotting factors, and bam! Blood clot obstructing nutrient and oxygen flow to the heart! And speaking of immune cells...

The immune system

  • Allergies: Happens when the immune system thinks some non-bodily molecule is a deadly pathogen and freaks the absolute f*ck out. People die from allergies every day, and paradoxically, the cleaner your environment is, especially between fetal development and your teens, the more likely it is for you to develop allergies, because the immune system doesn't learn to tolerate benign molecules entering your body. Our family immigrated from China to Canada, where the species of plants are different, and both my dad and I have pollen allergies because our immune systems grew up in China and not in Canada, and freaks out when we encounter pollen from the local plants.

  • Autoimmune disorders: Your immune system can also freak the f*ck out at the sight of your own body! It starts attacking it, the results of which can be fatal in severe cases.

Other bodily flaws

  • Hyperthyroidism: It's like overclocking a PC, but it's your body, and instead of a clock signal, the thyroid gland starts producing way too much hormones and causes your body to go into overdrive. And just like how you risk burning out your CPU when overclocking, too much thyroid hormones can cause massive health problems.

  • Fight or flight activating indiscriminately during stressful periods: Ever been so nervous during a test that you couldn't concentrate? That's because your fight or flight system kicked in, and in doing so, actually inhibits high-level logical reasoning.

  • Our bodies can't synthesize vitamin C: Most other mammals can while we have to hope our food contains it. Scurvy was a major killer back in the day.

  • We can vomit in our sleep, have it enter our respiratory system, and either choke to death on it or get a massive raging infection. By the way, vomiting is "supposed" to be a mechanism to protect the body.

  • We get motion sick by looking at a stationary object (like a book or a phone) while in a moving vehicle, because the mixed sensory signals causes our brain to freak out and think we're hallucinating.

  • Appendicitis: Our appendix isn't actually vestigial, it doesn't have any essential functions, but it does help with digestion, keeping the gut microbiome healthy, and even in immune response. However, when it gets infected, it absolutely wrecks house, and can explode and kill you. By the way, appendicitis isn't caused by exercising after eating as is often the myth, but it's most commonly caused by a piece of your stool getting lodged in it. A piece of digested food ending up in a part of your digestive system can kill you. Let that sink in.

  • The nerve that controls your larynx, the part of your throat that lets you speak, goes from the brain, down your neck, into your chest, loops around the aorta, comes back up your neck, and over to your throat. All four limbed animals have this, even the giraffe with its massively long neck. This is because four limbed animals evolved from a fish-like organism, which had its throat, aorta and brain right next to each other, so that was the shortest way from brain to throat, but as we evolved into land animals, our aorta moved down, and the nerve followed. Either that or God had a an extra length of nerve like the extra components that Ikea gives you, and decided to put it in just for fun.

Finally, this isn't related to humans, but look up "secondary endosymbiosis". Brown algae, such as kelps, once engulfed the cell of a red algae, which in turn engulfed a cyanobacteria, which acts as its plastid (the thing in the cell that photosynthesizes). So a brown algal cell literally has an entire other eukaryotic cell as an organelle, and inside that endosymbiont, is the engulfed cyanobacteria that does the actual photosynthesis and feeds both layers. Nutrients have to travel through four cell membranes in brown algae to get to the rest of the cell. What kind of intelligent design is this exactly? Why would God choose this mess instead of just sticking the cyanobacteria in the brown algae and calling it a day (presumably out of the seven of them)?

You see all this? The human body (and all living things for that matter), have tons of design flaws, many of which could easily have been avoided if their designer had any intelligence. So why are these flaws here? Because we evolved from genetic mutations in a stunning feat of "good enough". I hope I made the case clear that we really should be ditching creationism for evolution, or at least theistic evolution.


r/DebateAChristian • • May 16 '20

If an "age of innocence" exists and children who haven't sinned go to heaven, abortion guarantees a child entry to heaven.

82 Upvotes

I was raised fundamentalist Christian, and devoutly anti-abortion. But I was also taught that innocent souls didnt go to hell, they went to heaven. And that children too young to understand right and wrong were innocent. So if a child who couldn't have sinned dies, doesn't it go straight to heaven? Since it has no chance to sin, it doesnt ever risk hell. Why is abortion wrong if it guarantees a soul that might have gone to hell goes to heaven instead?

This little paradox was one of the first things that made me question Christianity. What are your thoughts?

If those premises are true, doesn't abortion become objectively good for children unlikely to be raised Christian?


r/DebateAChristian • • Aug 07 '13

If God is timeless, why did he decide to put His son on earth in that particular period in our history?

82 Upvotes

Jesus of Nazareth walked the earth 2000 years ago, before things like the industrial revolution and global communication. He lived in a period of time that isn't historically recorded at all. Why then? Why not now when he can reach that many more people many many times easier?


r/DebateAChristian • • Oct 09 '20

If we are to take the Bible seriously, we must be open to the idea that Trump is the Antichrist

80 Upvotes

I've discussed this idea a couple of times with religious folks, but it's usually met with a chuckle as if they don't REALLY believe in the Antichrist OR they're too proud to admit they have themselves been duped.

The Antichrist will be a man who is exceptionally arrogant and will be known for giving boastful speeches.

Trump is a loudmouth. Always threatening.

Revelation 13:2 - The beast I saw resembled a leopard, but had feet like those of a bear and a mouth like that of a lion*. The dragon gave the beast his power and his throne and great authority.*

RISE TO POWER The Antichrist’s rise to power will seem like a miracle that God performed, tricking people into following Satan instead of God without even noticing.

2 Thessalonians 2:9 - The coming of the lawless one will be in accordance with how Satan works. He will use all sorts of displays of power through signs and wonders that serve the lie.

When the Antichrist comes, look for powerful religious folks claiming it was a miracle from God.

“He did everything wrong, politically. He offended gays. He offended women. He offended the military. He offended black people. He offended the Hispanic people. He offended everybody! And he became president of the United States. Only God could do that.” - Franklin Graham

Another major signs to warn us of the arrival of the Antichrist would be an election where someone won with fewer supporters, and where it was also proven that an evil outside power meddled with the process to specifically put that person in office.

***--***Daniel 11:21 - “The next to come to power will be a despicable man who is not in line for royal succession. He will slip in when least expected and take over the kingdom by flattery and intrigue.

Daniel 11:23 - "After coming to an agreement with him, he will act deceitfully, and with only a few people he will rise to power."

**--**Donald Trump has floated idea of serving more than two terms.

Daniel 11:24 - When the richest provinces feel secure, he will invade them and will achieve what neither his fathers nor his forefathers did. He will distribute plunder, loot and wealth among his followers. He will plot the overthrow of fortresses--but only for a time.

Daniel 7:25 - He will speak against the Most High and oppress his holy people and try to change the set times and the laws. The holy people will be delivered into his hands for a time, times and half a time.

This leads into Daniel 8:25 He will cause deceit to prosper, and he will consider himself superior.

The Bible predicts the Antichrist will be someone who negotiates powerful real estate deals with friends predicts the Antichrist will be someone who negotiates powerful real estate deals with friends.

**--**Revelation 13 very specifically tells us that somewhere in the middle of his first three and a half years in office, the Antichrist will give a very specific and telling speech: he will arrogantly brag of his accomplishments and ‘great’ things, and will also use God’s name in a way considered to be blasphemy.

Trump uses Lord's name in vain at NC rally

Daniel 11:37-38 - He will show no regard for the gods of his ancestors or for the one desired by women, nor will he regard any god, but will exalt himself above them all. Instead of them, he will honor a god of fortresses; a god unknown to his ancestors he will honor with gold and silver, with precious stones and costly gifts.

The Bible says that instead of worshipping the true God, the Antichrist will worship an unknown God of fortresses

Fortress translates to border walls.

The Antichrist's most devoted followers will wear a sign of their allegiance to him on their foreheads

MAGA hats. Nowhere does the Bible say barcode. The MAGA hat is a symbol of hatred

Trump is a liar and a deceiver. He is looking out for himself. He has cheated the system and will do anything to save himself. He is causing confusion amongst the people of the US and his words are being used to incite violence. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/gretchen-whitmer-michigan-governor-fbi-kidnapping-plot/ after his tweet to 'Liberate Michigan!'

Credit of content of post to: https://www.benjaminlcorey.com/could-american-evangelicals-spot-the-antichrist-heres-the-biblical-predictions/


r/DebateAChristian • • Jul 31 '26

Christians who believe in heaven and hell should not have children

78 Upvotes

The existence of heaven and hell puts Christians into a difficult position when it comes to having children.

Because the truth of the matter is: You can never control their faith. You can influence them, teach them, but experience has shown that nothing a parent ever does will guarantee that their children will follow their faith.

That is a horrible risk. The moment you put a child into this world, you risk their eternal suffering and torture in hell. You can never prevent that completely.

The worst part is that Christians believe they will go to heaven and there will be no sadness or grief, which means that they *won't even care* about their very own child they *know* to be suffering eternal torture while they sing nice songs with Jesus.

Not existing in the first place is much, much more preferable to eternal suffering. Not having children of your own is much better than having children who face eternal punishment.

There also come some dark implications with this. Because the only way to guarantee that your child goes to heaven is for them to die early. Even if you kill your own child, you can still potentially see them again in heaven as long as you repent genuinely and ask Jesus for forgiveness. It is a quite disturbing premise, to think that under such beliefs, murdering your beloved child would objectively be a better wager than letting them live their own life. Aborting the pregnancy early on seems to be a much better solution, as according to most christian beliefs, the soul already exists and is guaranteed to go to heaven. Not having any children at all is by far the best option.


r/DebateAChristian • • Mar 05 '23

"Trust in God" is really just "Trust in what other humans claim about God".

78 Upvotes

Whether it's a direct quote from the Bible, or what some preacher has to say about those verses, it is all still delivered to us via human intermediaries. Sometimes a handful of them, sometimes a very long line that went through ancient oral traditions and multiple translations before reaching us.

So when someone tells me to "Trust the Lord", what they really mean is:

  1. "Trust all the various human beings who supposedly interacted with him."

  2. "Trust that they told the complete truth about all those interactions."

  3. "Trust that their words about those interactions were all recorded accurately."

  4. "Trust that those words were all passed down the generations and translated correctly."

  5. "Trust that the modern people telling you how to interpret those words today are also being honest and accurate with all their ideas about those interactions."

  6. "DON'T trust any of the 'false prophets', and 'by their fruits ye shall know them'. Even though they all make unproven and untestable claims, and many of the 'true prophets' tell people to commit horrible violence, while the 'false' ones can seem rather innocuous by comparison."

  7. And, above all, "Trust that the vague feelings you have in your heart are actually from the 'Holy Spirit', and that will be your guide to 'Truth'. Even though those feelings are virtually impossible to describe and might as well be referring to heartburn or unearned confidence or a whole host of other symptoms that are unrelated to any of the above things that need to be trusted."

If a 'God', who is presumably wise and powerful and interested in my wellbeing, wants me to have a trusting relationship with them, then why are there so many degrees of separation? Why do I have to trust all these intermediary humans?

That doesn't seem like a great way to establish a relationship of trust.

If this is all so important, then why not just cut out the middle men and communicate with me directly?

I suspect that the real reason is that there never was such a 'God' involved with any of this in the first place.

Or perhaps the way this 'God' shows they are wise and powerful and interested in my wellbeing is by acting as if they are foolish and impotent and completely disinterested in my wellbeing, and expecting me to be as gullible as possible about some of the most dubious claims humans have ever made in the history of this planet.

What part of any of this should I find convincing enough to grant it my trust?


r/DebateAChristian • • Jul 07 '18

Experimental Evidence for God: A Biblical Approach

77 Upvotes

Christians often ask what kind of evidence it would take for us atheists to believe, and the answer of empirical or scientific evidence is met with disparaging responses. We will be told that it's impossible, that God is metaphysical and immaterial and outside of the universe, that he's inaccessible to scientific methods, that we shouldn't expect that kind of evidence, that we wouldn't be convinced anyway, or something else similar. I've often been told that all that is needed has already been given, and that I'm arrogantly demanding that God conform to my standards of evidence, as though they are absurd and unreasonable.

However, I can point to numerous examples from the Bible where God offers people direct empirical evidence of his existence and will. In fact, these examples conform perfectly to scientific standards.

The Scientific Method

First, a brief summary of the scientific method. After a phenomena is observed, one supposes a theory to explain the observation. From the theory, a hypothesis is derived. The hypothesis makes a specific, testable prediction about what should be observed when an experiment is performed. If the prediction fails, then we know that at least some part of the theory is false, and we must go back to the drawing board. A failed prediction conforms to the null hypothesis, that there is no relationship between the theory and the phenomena. The null theory is to not regard the theory initially posited as true. If the prediction succeeds, then we do not know that the theory is true, but it does constitute evidence for the theory. When theories successfully predict novel results of experiments that no one has ever done before, it is considered strong evidence. The riskier the prediction is, i.e. the more unlikely the result is on the null theory, the stronger the evidence. It was on the basis of novel predictions that every currently widely accepted theory rose to prominence in science, from germs to gravity to evolution. Good predictions lead to consensus.

We can use the scientific method to compare a theory of God, theism, against the null theory, or agnostic atheism. The null theory is not to believe that God does not exist, but to not regard God as existing. In other words, a lack of belief in the positive claim does not imply a belief in the negative claim. A theory supposing that God does not exist would need its own support (and strong atheists such as myself would say that is possible to provide, although that is not the topic of this post).

In this post, I will examine how the Bible presents a testable theory of God.

Gideon

The episode of Gideon and the fleece is my all time favorite story in the Bible. From his theory of God, he makes the prediction that God will answer his questions in a consistent manner. If you believe that God wants personal relationships with people, this should probably be contained in your theory of God, too. Gideon thus formulates an experiment, recounted in Judges 6:36-40. On the God hypothesis, the dew should obey Gideon's request. On the null hypothesis, the dew should behave naturalistically. He performs the experiment once and it works, evidence for his theory. Being a true scientist, Gideon repeats the procedure a second time, crucially changing the conditions to prove that the first result was not merely coincidental. The author of this passage has a very clear understanding of what makes for good empirical rigor, and I find it amazing to read things like this in the scriptures.

Having conducted the test twice, if Gideon had an understanding of statistics he would know that his confidence in the result should be precisely 75%, on the naive assumption of equal prior probabilities for the two outcomes. With each subsequent successful trial, the probability that the null hypothesis is true is cut in half, just as when flipping a fair coin, the odds that you'll get the side you predict any number of times in a row halves with each successive flip. Given that his theory of God predicted that God should be able to answer consistently every single time, Gideon can make the risky prediction that the experiment will be successful every single time. The only uncontrolled variable is how many times God is willing to participate in the experiment. Gideon asks for patience in his participation, echoing Abraham's bargains. Although Gideon is satisfied with a 75% confidence, we should note that God expends no effort to participate, and that the binary nature of the experiment causes our confidence to grow exponentially with each trial. After 10 successful trials, we could have a confidence of 99.9%. This proves that God could provide us with certainty, or as arbitrarily close to certainty as you would like to get, on the basis of empirical evidence.

Imagine what the world would be like if God provided everyone, or even just all Christians, with this method of obtaining yes/no answers to questions. Imagine if we could be like Gideon and say, "Dear God, I have this question about what you want me to do, and if the answer is yes, have this coin I'm going to flip land heads, and if it's no, tails. And let me repeat the flip as many times as I need to, possibly switching which answer corresponds to heads or tails at my request." If that procedure worked every single time, it would constitute an amazing proof of God. By its mathematical improbability, it would truly be the perfect miracle. And better than all other miracles, it would be testable and repeatable.

Imagine the implications such a thing would have for the church. For me, one of the biggest pieces of evidence against Christianity is the disunity that has always been present. Some examples of disagreements among early Christians were if Jesus was a created being, if the God of the Old Testament was evil, if Jesus had a human or divine mind, when Jesus was born, when Jesus died, if the resurrection was physical or only spiritual, the nature of the trinity, and which books ought be considered official scripture. In the first few centuries there were dozens of different gospel accounts floating around telling conflicting stories of Jesus, and though four became considered canonical, the choice was only appropriate, as St. Ignatius says, because there were four corners of the Earth and four winds. Even in the epistles at the very start of it all, it is not the Holy Spirit that guides the Christians (who were already in disagreement with each other), but the careful rhetoric of Paul. Although one orthodoxy eventually won out, it was only through human debate. Quickly, however, the Eastern and Western churches grew and split apart. Later, the Protestant Reformation. Today, Christian denominations around the world are more hopelessly fractured than ever. Imagine if Gideon's method were available for the settlement of doctrinal issues. How much bloodshed would have been spared if warring Christian sects could have found unambiguous answers to their disagreements peaceably? How much better would American history be, if Gideon's method had been used to tell Christian slave owners to free their slaves?

Elijah

In 1 Kings 18, God directly steps into human affairs to prove that he is real and that other gods do not exist. Elijah challenges the prophets of Baal to call on their god to ignite a sacrifice. Elijah will do the same. Whether or not the prayer succeeds is a direct test of the respective gods' existence or lack thereof.

On the theory of God, Elijah makes the prediction that if a god exists (is a god), it will light a sacrifice. When this hypothesis is tested in the case of Baal, it fails, supporting the null hypothesis, that we should not regard Baal as existing. When it is applied to Yahweh, it miraculously succeeds, providing strong empirical evidence that Yahweh is real. A good scientist would know that although the experiment has ruled out atheism by phenomenologically proving Yahweh's existence, it has not disproven the existence of Baal. Baal's existence has only failed to be proven, thus far. There are still possible explanations where both Baal exists and he does not light the sacrifice - namely, the case where Baal does not wish to participate or allow himself to be tested. As mentioned before with Gideon, any god's will is an unfortunately uncontrolled variable in these experiments.

However, Elijah disagrees with this analysis and implies that we should take the outcome as evidence that Baal does not exist. The author of 1 Kings does not seem to understand empiricism quite as well as the author of Judges. At the beginning of the story, Elijah asserts, "the god who answers by fire is indeed God." He later jeers to the prophets,

"Surely he is a god; either he is meditating, or he has wandered away, or he is on a journey, or perhaps he is asleep and must be awakened.”

Surely he is a god; therefore, if he fails, he is surely not a god. In other words, Elijah is asserting that if a god is real, then it will light the fire. We can then take the contrapositive, that if a god does not light the fire, then that god is not real.

So, by Elijah's standard of evidence, the god Baal should participate in this challenge on demand, or else we should conclude that Baal is not a god. If Elijah is consistent with his standard, he would say that if Yahweh didn't light the fire, he would not be a god, either. Fortunately for Elijah, Yahweh does light the fire. Then Elijah tells the Israelites to conduct a mass execution, and they do.

“Seize the prophets of Baal; do not let one of them escape.” Then they seized them; and Elijah brought them down to the Wadi Kishon, and killed them there.

Should we not today follow the standard of evidence given by the Bible and the example set by Elijah? What would happen if we set up alters for different religions and put them to the same test? I think we all know that nothing would happen if the test is fair and no one cheats. But - what if some God did answer? What if it's Muslims vs. Christians, and the Muslim alter wins? Would the Muslims then be justified in seizing the Christians and killing them? By a Biblical standard, yes they would.

Remember, Elijah implies that a god should be willing to participate in the challenge at our beck and call. Therefore, if I call on Yahweh to light a fire for me, and he does not, would it be right for me to mock Yahweh, and say that either he is not a god or has gone for a walk or is sleeping?

Thomas

The most famous example in this theme is that of Doubting Thomas, John 20:24-29. Thomas declares that his standard of evidence for the resurrection is so high that he must see and touch Jesus himself to believe. A week later, Jesus appears and allows Thomas to touch him. Jesus then says that it is better to believe without seeing.

This passage really speaks for itself. Thomas wants direct evidence and the Lord provides. The condemnation of skepticism in Jesus' teaching has always puzzled me. Why would it ever be better to believe without seeing? Are we to be gullible, believing anyone who reports to us supernatural claims? If evidence without seeing is sufficient for belief, then why did Jesus bother to appear anyway? Why doesn't Jesus appear in this way to everyone on Earth? Wouldn't that be great if he did?

The Power of Prayer

Jesus makes testable claims about what kinds of prayers will be answered: all of them. He even says it six times across three gospels - clearly the authors considered this one of his most important teachings.

Mark 11:23-24

Truly I tell you, if you say to this mountain, ‘Be taken up and thrown into the sea,’ and if you do not doubt in your heart, but believe that what you say will come to pass, it will be done for you. So I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours.

Matthew 18:19

Again, truly I tell you, if two of you agree on earth about anything you ask, it will be done for you by my Father in heaven. For where two or three are gathered in my name, I am there among them.

Matthew 21:21-22

“Truly I tell you, if you have faith and do not doubt, not only will you do what has been done to the fig tree, but even if you say to this mountain, ‘Be lifted up and thrown into the sea,’ it will be done. Whatever you ask for in prayer with faith, you will receive.

John 14:12-14

Very truly, I tell you, the one who believes in me will also do the works that I do and, in fact, will do greater works than these, because I am going to the Father. I will do whatever you ask in my name, so that the Father may be glorified in the Son. If in my name you ask me for anything, I will do it.

John 15:7

If you abide in me, and my words abide in you, ask for whatever you wish, and it will be done for you.

John 16:23

Very truly, I tell you, if you ask anything of the Father in my name, he will give it to you.

Obviously, these verses fail again and again when put to the test.

The most common apologetic here is that they are not intended to apply to all Christians, but in context they are right next to Jesus' most general commandments and instructions to his followers. For this defense to carry, one must provide a consistent method for differentiating which claims do and do not apply and a justification for that method. It’s also quite problematic and suspect if the only part that doesn’t apply to everyone is also the only part that we would expect to actually be verifiable were it the case.

Another answer is that true Christians would only pray for the things God wants them to pray for, citing that God’s words must be in their prayers per John 15:7. The immediate problem with this is that then prayer becomes nothing but a charade, bringing about only what God intended anyway.

The last response is to say that these verses are just hyperbolic, but with the message being repeated again and again in such clear language, it's difficult to consider plausible anything but a plain reading of the text. I should think that when Christians hear Jesus start off by saying "Very truly I tell you," that whatever comes next would be taken pretty seriously. Or else is one to argue that every time Jesus says, “truly I tell you,” he follows it up with something that literally is not true? That doesn’t sound right.

The Power of Christians

Jesus also makes specific, testable claims about what those who follow him will be able to do.

Mark 16:17-18

“These are the miraculous signs that will accompany believers: They will use the power and authority of my name to force demons out of people. They will speak new languages. They will pick up snakes, and if they drink any deadly poison, it will not hurt them. They will place their hands on the sick and cure them.

There have been several documented cases in recent history of fundamentalist Christians taking Jesus at his word regarding snake bites and tragically dying for it. If one wants to ask how religion is harmful for society, that is a clear example of how following the word of Christ is dangerous. This is the danger of following a bad theory with failed predictions.

A scientific study found that when Christians pray for people, they are less likely to recover. If I were a Christian, I would find this fact extremely concerning.

Last remarks

I am quite aware of all the verses where the Bible says that God should not be tested. However, given that he does on many occasions provide tests, and especially considering that we are given the standard by Elijah that gods should respond to challenges on demand, this is irrelevant to the point. God can and does provide tests according to the Bible, and it's not unreasonable for me to have the same standard of evidence as these Biblical characters. If I were able to observe any of these things or anything similar in a repeatable, verifiable way, then I would consider it scientific proof of God. The fact that the Bible gives numerous examples of people receiving testable evidence and that such occurrences never happen today should be taken as evidence against its truth.


r/DebateAChristian • • Jun 15 '25 Bless Up

It’s immoral that the Bible condones slavery.

76 Upvotes

Exodus 21 explains how to buy slaves and how you should treat them. That you can beat them as long as they don’t die within a day or two - but if they die on the third day it was not your fault. This shows that the Bible is an ordinary book that explains what was acceptable at the time. But when people claim it was written or inspired by a god - then this god is immoral for accepting this. People say this was the old testimony so we should ignore this. But the old testimony has the Ten Commandments and genesis - so we can’t ignore it.


r/DebateAChristian • • May 20 '18

If the Bible is true, there is magic.

76 Upvotes

If the Bible is true, we should expect the world to be full of magic that isn't from Yahweh. The Bible presents magic and the acts of other gods as real occurrences that should be detectable.

 
Arguably, it starts in the Garden of Eden. Genesis 3:22-24. The Tree of Life seems to have independent magic that can make humans into or like gods (the word translated as God in Genesis 1 is already plural, Gods). God sets up an angelic guard to prevent this from happening.
Also, the serpent can speak (Genesis 3:1).

 
Then, there's Exodus 7:10-13, where Egyptian magicians turn staffs into snakes by secret arts.

This suggests that even prior to Moses, Egypt had been studying the art of sorcery. They had experts and could even select from among the best in the field. These experts could literally turn wood into living animals, creating life. If the Egyptians were independently able to discover such magic, it should be discoverable by any.

 
Exodus 22:18 says to kill witches/sorceresses. This would be a silly thing to command if they are not real.
Leviticus 20:27 says to kill female mediums and necromancers. I'm not certain what necromancy entails, but again this implies these sorceresses are real. It also seems to discriminate by gender.

 
In 2 Kings 3:27, the king of Moab sacrifices his firstborn son to Chemosh, God of Moab. As a result, a divine wrath falls upon Israel. This defeats Yahweh and his armies and overcomes Yahweh's prophecy. This understanding of events was actually shared by the Moabites and recorded in the Mesha Stele.

 
1 Samuel 28:5-19: Saul gets a witch to summon the deceased Samuel's ghost in a seance. He has to convince her God won't punish her first. It works. Samuel appears, and he knows God's will and the future. Witchcraft is real and powerful.

 
There are prohibitions against and mentions of practicing magic (divination, necromancy, sorcery, charms) in Leviticus 19:26-31, Leviticus 20:6, Deuteronomy 18:10-12, 1 Samuel 15:23, 2 Kings 17:17, and Isaiah 8:19. This seems to be acknowledgment of their reality.

 
And much later, Acts 16:16-24 tells of a slave girl possessed by a spirit that can make money telling the future.

It sounds like a typical fortune teller, scamming people for profit, but the Bible treats this as a real, magical event. They exorcise the spirit and people are very upset at her loss of ability. They imprison the exorcists. It seems expected from this that some of the fortune tellers alive today have genuine power.

 
And Mark 5:1-17, Luke 8:26-39 says that human beings can become possessed by demons who speak through their mouths. These demons can give humans superpower strength, so that they can break through any chains. They are also capable of inhabiting animals. They can make a creature kill itself directly and immediately. This is a terrifying threat to humanity that we somehow see very little of 2,000 years later or elsewhere in history.

 
But 1 Timothy 4:1 declares by the Holy Spirit that demonic activity would actually increase as time went on. And according to Matthew 8:16, they were very common back then.

 
Acts 8:9-24: A non-Christian magician, Simon, had impressed (with magic) all of Samaria into following him religiously. This suggests that even at the time of Jesus, magic was prevalent outside of Yahweh's magic. Jesus was not the only miracle worker in town. No reason is ever given for this kind of magic ceasing today.

Simon converts to Christianity and sees the Holy Spirit passed from person to person by physical touch. He offers to buy the power off the apostles. To me, this suggests that Simon recognized their magic as a kind that can be taught (like his tricks, presumably), but the disciples scare him off.

 
 
Which leads to the next point, that there should be Yahweh magic in the world too. James 5:14-16 clearly says that if anyone is sick, they should call the church elders to pray over him and anoint him with oil. If they do, he will be raised up from illness and forgiven of sins. 17-18 goes on to say that when praying for physical things like rain, persistence can pay off.

 
Many verses ensure that God will magically grant requests, 1 John 5:14-15, James 4:3, John 15:7, 15:16, Matthew 21:21, Matthew 7:7-8, Mark 11:24, John 14:13-14, 1 John 3:22.

 
In Mark 16:16-18, Jesus himself delivers a parting message: signs will accompany those who believe in him, like laying hands on the sick and healing them, drinking deadly poison and being unharmed, and casting out demons.
These expectations are absent from Christianity today.

 
Paul talks about spiritual gifts as though they could produce real magic. Romans 12:6-8 includes prophecy in the common gifts of the church members, alongside generosity and teaching.

 
1 Corinthians 12:1-11 says that the Holy Spirit will empower people to heal, prophecy, do miracles, speak and understand foreign languages, and discern between spirits. He says all of these are empowered by the same Holy Spirit.

 
1 Corinthians 14:4-6 says that those who can do prophecy are greater than those who speak in tongues unless someone is there who can interpret the person speaking in tongues. He says the church may be built up on prophecy and asks what value a gift even has if it isn't backed by prophecy or revelation.

 
In John 16:13 Jesus says the Spirit will tell people the future.

 
Acts 1:8 says this spirit will persist until the end of the Earth.

 
Then there is the continuous way in which Yahweh magically intervenes to kill people and to prove himself. There are too many verses on this to easily cite, but I will happily provide some if necessary.

 
All of this describes a world full of magic (especially divination and healing), spirits, and maybe even other gods. We should expect history to be full of evidences of magic, and we should expect magic to be persistent today. We should especially expect Christians to be able to perform magic.

But the world we observe is not that world. History isn't full of magic (except where discredited or unverified). There isn't any magic in modern times. Christians don't do miracles. So why the disparity?

(Reposted on /r/DebateReligion).

 
Edit:
To anyone saying all the non-Yahweh magic is fake:

Why do we trust authors who were either unable or uninterested in distinguishing the fake from the real in the actual text, requiring you to figure it out thousands of years later?

Even Paul doesn't seem to care about the difference between being magically teleported to another realm or having a dream, 2 Corinthians 12:2-3:

I must go on boasting [...] I know a man in Christ who fourteen years ago was caught up to the third heaven—whether in the body or out of the body I do not know, God knows. And I know that this man was caught up into paradise—whether in the body or out of the body I do not know, God knows. And he heard things that cannot be told, which man may not utter.

He accepts the experiences and the existence of "third heaven" and "words man can't utter" on this "evidence" anyway. They should have cared to distinguish, but they didn't.