r/DebateAChristian • • Sep 30 '21

Pascal’s wager defeats the Sagan standard

0 Upvotes

The Sagan standard is used endlessly by skeptics to say that, since it is a big claim that Jesus has come back to life, there isn’t big enough evidence to believe Jesus. (I disagree and think there is good evidence, but for the sake of argument, I’ll assume the evidence is low [which also means I will ignore ppl asking for the evidence, that is a separate convo]).

That said, the requirements from Jesus are not extraordinary. Why? Without Jesus (aka without life after death), living life loses a lot of significance. It doesn’t matter much that I made a mistake, if I did, when I trusted Jesus if in the end I’m just gone. And Jesus offers us a very happy life here and now. So only if Jesus (aka life after death) is real is Jesus asking me to give Him a life of meaning and extraordinary significance where my time here has eternal repercussions. If He is wrong, then my life has little significance and what I am asked to give is not extraordinary.

Therefore there is little evidence required until skeptics can prove that life without Jesus (aka life that does not continue after death) has enough significance to cause concern over simply being wrong about a claim that otherwise is a very good thing to believe, providing many pragmatic benefits even if it is wrong.


r/DebateAChristian • • Aug 07 '21

Atheists have the burden of proof as well and misuse the scientific method.

5 Upvotes

In a debate, there are two positions, each position have the burden of proof in them. Logically, the one with the positive claim has to prove their side first, but that doesn't necessarily exclude the negative claim from having to prove their side.

If one claims to not have the burden of proof, then that would mean they didn't make a claim, thus they are excluded from the discussion since they have no side to defend.

Atheists simply can't just go around saying "God doesn't exist" without evidence, the lack of evidence doesn't make something automatically untrue, that would be an argument from ignorance.

Heck, the argument from ignorance definition even agrees "is a fallacy in informal logic. It asserts that a proposition is true because it has not yet been proven false or a proposition is false because it has not yet been proven true."

Now, as for the scientific method. The scientific method isn't about "proving" something. It's actually about rejecting something. You make a hypothesis, and try to falsify it as much as possible. We have the laws of physics which were established through deductive reasoning rather than inductive. We have scientific theories which are the closest to being accurate.

My point is, atheists treat the religion debate as a court trial, which is actually more about proving. But the scientific method is different from law.

EDIT: I'm done debating. It's clear none of you are capable of having a peaceful conversation and instead resort to mass downvoting and ridiculing.


r/DebateAChristian • • Oct 20 '13

Prove to me that God and Jesus ever existed.

0 Upvotes

I consider my self an atheist. I find religion very hard to believe and understand. I always hear Christians saying "prove that evolution exists" or "prove that God doesn't exist" but I'd like to see some proof, anything, that wasn't in the bible, outside proof, proof that Adam and eve existed, proof that anything actually happened. Proof that Jesus is the man that did all of these "amazing things".

This might have been asked tons before, so sorry if it has.


r/DebateAChristian • • Feb 10 '26 Diamonds are Forever Bravo

Christianity has little to no value for society and other people.

2 Upvotes

Thesis is the title.

  1. Many Christians support a party and a president who does u know what to underage kids, trafficking, and who knows what else.

  2. A religion where it's adherents support these people, and support the party and administration that protects this, hides this, and lies about this, demonstrates these believers/followers offer little to nothing for society and others, and is contrary to the teachings of Jesus.

  3. Furthermore, it demonstrates the promise that god indwells these people, to live a new born again life, to seek justice and righteousness, to be holy, obviously is false.

Therefore, Christianity is useless and has little to no value for society and other people.


r/DebateAChristian • • Feb 11 '25

The Bible Has Been Reinterpreted Before, and It Can Be Reinterpreted for LGBTQ Inclusion

0 Upvotes
  1. If Christians have historically reinterpreted biblical texts in response to evolving moral understanding—such as rejecting biblical justifications for slavery—then Christians can also reinterpret biblical texts on LGBTQ matters.

  2. Christians have historically reinterpreted biblical texts in response to evolving moral understanding, particularly in rejecting slavery as morally acceptable, despite biblical passages that were once used to justify it.

  3. Conclusion: Therefore, Christians can also reinterpret biblical texts on LGBTQ matters.


r/DebateAChristian • • Sep 18 '22

The Bible justifies and commands marital rape.

3 Upvotes

1 Corinthians 7:4-5 says:
4 For the wife does not have authority over her own body, but the husband does. Likewise the husband does not have authority over his own body, but the wife does. 5 Do not deprive one another, except perhaps by agreement for a limited time, that you may devote yourselves to prayer; but then come together again, so that Satan may not tempt you because of your lack of self-control.

This means that if your spouse doesn't want to have sex with you but you want to, they should still have sex with you even if they don't want to, because they have to. Likewise, if you don't want to have sex but your spouse wants to, you should still have sex with them even if you don't want to, because you have to.

In summary:

  1. Sex with someone who doesn't want to is rape.

  2. Sex with someone who doesn't give you consent is rape (related to premise 1).

  3. The Bible teaches that if you are married, you must have sex with your spouse even if you don't want to.

  4. The Bible teaches that if you are married, your spouse must have sex with you even if they don't want to.

  5. The Bible teaches that if you get married, you waive, and must waive, your ability to consent or not to consent to sex with your spouse.

  6. Therefore, the Bible justifies - heck, even commands - marital rape.


r/DebateAChristian • • Nov 04 '25

Jesus Christ Never Existed

0 Upvotes

There’s a lot of evidence suggesting that Jesus Christ never existed as a real person. The biggest issue is that there are no historical records from his supposed lifetime that mention him, not from Roman historians, not from Jewish scholars, and not from anyone who lived during that era. You would think that if someone was performing miracles, drawing massive crowds, and being executed in a very public way, at least one contemporary source would have written about it. The fact that no one did is not just a coincidence. The absence of evidence in this case is evidence of absence, because someone with such an enormous impact should have left a clear trace in history. When a figure supposedly influenced thousands of people and challenged both religious and political systems, yet leaves no reliable record, the most logical conclusion is that the person never existed in the first place.

The only mentions of Jesus come from texts written decades after his supposed death, by people who were already believers. These are not eyewitness accounts, they are stories passed around and edited by early Christian communities who had every reason to exaggerate or invent details to spread their new religion. Many of the Jesus stories also mirror older myths and legends from other cultures. For example, the idea of a dying and rising savior god existed long before Christianity, with stories like Horus in Egypt or Mithras in Persia having strikingly similar themes. The virgin birth, the miracles, the crucifixion, and the resurrection all have earlier mythological parallels. It is far more likely that the figure of Jesus was a myth built out of older religious ideas, blended together and given a historical setting to make it more believable. When you look at the evidence, it becomes clear that Jesus was not a real person but a symbolic figure created to embody spiritual and moral teachings. The Bible’s Jesus is a product of storytelling, not history.


r/DebateAChristian • • Jul 01 '20

Christian Apologetics Cannot be Trusted as they Defend Assumptions unlike Atheists which use Observable and Testable Facts. Christian Apologetics just Idolize a Fairytale / Manmade Hopes and Build on it with Assumptions and Unprovable Counterarguments.

0 Upvotes

So Christian apologetics are a frequently referred to group of people for those in an agnostic state looking at Christianity. I am here to say that they cannot be trusted as all that they do is build on fairytales and manmade hopes with assumptions. Unlike Christian apologetics, Atheists build on facts, sources not from a 2000 year old book.

Okay, I am an atheist. I am trying to defend my view that Christian apologetics are an unreliable source of proving Christianity as they don’t use observable facts and scientific methods. Atheist supports on the other hand use provable, and non-assumption based facts. For example, an apologetic would say: god is eternal and came from nothing, that is a major assumption. An atheist would say: a chicken was born from an egg, well, that’s provable, not an assumption nor conjecture.

Debate me!


r/DebateAChristian • • Apr 08 '11

Alright, I just need to rant to atheists...

0 Upvotes

Sure, we have some silly beliefs as religious people, but to call our beliefs religious is being hypocritical in so many ways. So many atheists, not only on reddit, mind you, laugh at the way Christians openly state their faith. Now, while I think everyone is liable to their own opinion, a simple comment stating that "yeah, religions are dumb" or something along those lines is not only detrimental to your own image, but a statement founded on nothing. I could just as easily say that atheists are dumb for believing in something as silly as a huge coincidence like the big bang. But I don't do that. Why? Because spouting your beliefs to anger or try to sway people is the kind of in your face promotion that nobody likes. Christians dislike atheists doing it as much as atheists dislike Christians doing it.

The pure and undeniable fact is that not a single living person knows what truly happens after death, so to assume that any belief is dumb is ignorant as well as presumptuous. Not only this, but doing so insinuates that you are more intelligent than all religious men preceding you, which includes some of the world's smartest men.

"In the words of A.A. Milne 'Get out of my chair dillhole'"


r/DebateAChristian • • Nov 11 '12

The invention of Christianity.

1 Upvotes

The Jews in Jesus' time were expecting a military messiah to save them all from the Romans. Instead they got the utter destruction of their holy city and Temple (which destroyed the sacrifice system). They were also banished from their holy city indefinitely.

This is why the end of the sacrifice system was conveniently justified by the "once and for all" sacrifice of Jesus. This is why it is only in the NT that we see the concept of the "New Jerusalem".

Imagine the country in which you live and grew up invaded and occupied. You strongly believe this country of yours possesses a culture, religion and political system far superior to that of the occupier. Numerous unsuccessful rebellions have occurred against the occupier. Some of these rebellions were led by men who claimed they were sent by God to save your country. The religious hopes and the political hopes of your nation become hopelessly entangled. The occupier has defeated rebellion after rebellion. You and your countrymen are hopelessly enslaved by this foreign ruler. There must be some way to snatch victory from the jaws of defeat. If there can be no victory in this world then there must be some way to describe (or spin) a defeat as a victory. Imagine how bitter you would feel if your country were taken over by a foreign army with no regard for your history, culture or religion. Imagine how joyous and vindicated you would feel if someone could convince you that the country's liberator, it's savior, would return at any time and defeat the occupiers. Imagine how the Jews felt. Their religion and their god had been completely discredited by the Romans. But the prime directive of a religion is to preserve itself at all costs. We see it all the time with the constant apologetic games played by Christians.

So the Jewish apologists in the years immediately after the events of AD 70 had to find a way to salvage Judaism. They did this, first of all, by declaring that, when the Romans destroyed the city and the Temple, the Jews were being punished by God. It's been the standard ploy of prophets for centuries. They then simply had to find a reason for incurring God's wrath. There has never been a shortage of reasons. But the specific reason in the 1st and 2nd century was the execution (by Jews) of the High Priest in the heart of the city. This is stated by the historian Josephus as the reason God punished the Jews through the Roman army. And the High Priest cited by Josephus was not Jesus of Nazareth. The NT book of Hebrews declares that this High Priest was Jesus Christ.

Jesus of Nazareth is kind of like a Jewish Captain America figure meant to represent the "good old days" before the city got destroyed and the Jews dispersed. Little did the Jewish creators of this Hellenistic messiah character know that their invention would become so popular among the Gentiles (after all the Jews were to blame for everything) that the Gentiles would hijack the new sect and accuse the Jews of being Judaizers of their own religion. The rest is history.


r/DebateAChristian • • Feb 20 '14

If Jesus appeared to you and commanded you to become homosexual and practice homosexuality, would you obey?

0 Upvotes

r/DebateAChristian • • Oct 10 '24

BDSM is safer for women than a complementarian marriage

1 Upvotes

Before I start, I want to clarify that this is not a PSA for BDSM nor an encouragement to try it. Do not take part in any sexual activity you are not fully enthusiastic about nor give in to your partner’s pressure to do things you don’t want to do. This is strictly about comparing something conservative Christians would likely see as depraved or abusive and comparing it to how a complementarian marriage functions.

BDSM is bondage, domination, sadism, and masochism. For the purposes of this argument I will focus on heterosexual monogamous female submissive BDSM, though obviously there can be homosexual, multi-partner, and male submissive BDSM. Basically it’s sex that most people would likely call “freaky” and/or “rough”.

Complementarianism, sometimes called biblical patriarchy though some draw a distinction between the two, is a marriage structure in which men are considered heads of household and with that comes authority their wife is expected to submit to. This will often be demonstrated by the husband having the deciding vote in a marital disagreement. There are responsibilities the man is supposed to follow, but if he doesn’t the wife has little recourse against it, see below, so it ultimately only means as much as the husband decides it does, which can include “not at all”.

BDSM is safer than a complementarian marriage for many reasons, but first among them is that BDSM has a safe word. For the uninitiated, a safe word is a word that the submissive person in the relationship or during that particular sex act says to end whatever activity the person wants to end. For example, the submissive and dominant person will agree that when the submissive says “hamburger” everything stops. Whether the act is extreme or vanilla, the safe word represents the withdrawal of consent and the dominant person stops and any sort untying or whatever that needs to be done to restore the submissive to a feeling of safety is done by the dominant person. This is because in BDSM both people are supposed to enjoy what is happening and if they’re not, then something is going wrong and it needs to end.

In a complementarian marriage the man is empowered to make decisions that his wife doesn’t agree with and the wife is supposed to submit anyway. There is no safe word that restores the wife to an equal partner. If they’re arguing over moving, a career change, the monthly budget, or where to send the kids to preschool and the husband has made up his mind, the wife can’t say “spiders” and the husband loses his advantage over her. The wife isn’t empowered in any way within the relationship to pump the breaks in a situation where she feels uncomfortable. She can only hope her husband listens, but she can’t make him stop. Therefor BDSM takes her wishes and the enjoyment of her life more seriously than a complementarian marriage.

While I think the above is enough, let’s also look at the environment the two groups live in. BDSM can exist independently of every other aspect of their life, both in the sense that you can have no involvement with others who practice BDSM and you can also have an egalitarian relationship outside of the bedroom. A complementarian relationship is 24/7 and the couple will exist in a church that practices and promotes complementarianism, any sort of guidance they receive on marriage will be provided based on the idea the man should lead, and any counseling they seek within the church will be weighted in the man’s favor and the male dominated relationship will be reinforced in all aspects of their life. A woman in a complementarian community will have less support when facing an impasse on top of being raised in a church that pushes this type of relationship. BDSM arises out of curiosity and consent, not out of community pressure, and you can stop at any time. Once again it’s shown to put a greater emphasis on consent and choice compared to complementarianism.

When things go wrong: while BDSM has no binding, pun intended, documents or literature, the church does. Divorce is prohibited and reconciliation expected/required even if the husband becomes abusive. If the man makes a decision the wife would rather jump off a bridge than follow and her words can not convince him to change, she must follow anyway. If he physically or sexually abused her she may separate for a time but then she is expected to go back, and often she is not the arbiter of his repentance but the church, that promotes a male dominated relationship to begin with, will often be the one to determine it. All of this amounts to what is called “coerced consent”, which means consent that is not freely given. Sort of like if someone put a gun to your head you couldn’t be said to have truly chosen to give them your wallet or purse, threatening someone with eternal hellfire in conjunction with childhood indoctrination, is not really giving someone a free choice to create the life or relationship they want for themselves.

As a concrete example of the harm that can come from this type of community: John MacArthur, an incredibly popular conservative pastor, demanded a woman take back her abusive spouse, she refused and took out a restraining order so they sent church staff to her house to attempt to convince her to drop it. When this did not work, he publicly excommunicated her. When the man went to jail for molesting his children he never apologized and still retains a large audience among evangelicals.

https://www.christianitytoday.com/2023/02/grace-community-church-elder-biblical-counseling-abuse/

In a BDSM relationship if a dominant does not respect their submissive’s boundaries they can end the relationship or marriage and nothing can stop them. No one forces them to work things out with someone who mistreats them. No one expects them to give in to things that they don’t agree with. Even while submissive in BDSM she retains choice, consent, and agency. As she decides when and if to use the safe word. Meanwhile at least functionally in a complementarian marriage the wife is entirely reliant on her husband’s goodwill and entirely vulnerable to him when he lacks it and even when he makes choices that he ultimately thinks are for the best but she vehemently disagrees with.

All of this is to say a BDSM relationship is a safer place for women than a complementarian relationship.


r/DebateAChristian • • Nov 16 '22

Jesus was a compassionate, super-intelligent gay man

0 Upvotes

In Elton John's famous opinion

https://parade.com/40380/dotsonrader/elton-john-web-exclusive/

I think Jesus was a compassionate, super-intelligent gay man who understood human problems. On the cross, he forgave the people who crucified him. Jesus wanted us to be loving and forgiving. I don’t know what makes people so cruel. Try being a gay woman in the Middle East — you’re as good as dead.

Some Christians reacted violently

https://www.catholicleague.org/elton-john-calls-jesus-gay-2/

Still, if one considers the question prayerfully, and without prejudice, Jesus Christ's homosexuality seems quite likely.

For a Jew in ancient Galilee, not marrying before the advanced age of 30 would have been extremely unusual. Per the Jewish Encyclopedia:

http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/10435-marriage-laws

It is thus considered the duty of every Israelite to marry as early in life as possible. Eighteen years is the age set by the Rabbis; and any one remaining unmarried after his twentieth year is said to be cursed by God Himself. Some urge that children should marry as soon as they reach the age of puberty, i.e., the fourteenth year...A man who, without any reason, refused to marry after he had passed his twentieth year was frequently compelled to do so by the court. To be occupied with the study of the Torah was regarded as a plausible reason for delaying marriage; but only in very rare instances was a man permitted to remain in celibacy all his life...

Jesus' disciples were all men. Per Mark 14, at the time of his arrest:

there followed him a certain young man, having a linen cloth cast about his naked body; and the young men laid hold on him. And he left the linen cloth, and fled from them naked.

An incriminating verse if there ever was one. In the "Secret Gospel of Mark"

http://gnosis.org/library/secm.htm

...the youth, looking upon him, loved him and began to beseech him that he might be with him...And after six days Jesus told him what to do and in the evening the youth comes to him, wearing a linen cloth over his naked body. And he remained with him that night, for Jesus taught him the mystery of the kingdom of God.

Moreover, in the Gospel of Thomas:

https://www.marquette.edu/maqom/Gospel%20of%20Thomas%20Lambdin.pdf

His disciples said, "When will you become revealed to us and when shall we see you?"

Jesus said, "When you disrobe without being ashamed and take up your garments and place them under your feet like little children and tread on them, then will you see the son of the living one, and you will not be afraid"

Sure seems suspicious. And, it was with a kiss that Judas betrayed Jesus:

And immediately, while he yet spake, cometh Judas, one of the twelve, and with him a great multitude with swords and staves, from the chief priests and the scribes and the elders. And he that betrayed him had given them a token, saying, "Whomsoever I shall kiss, that same is he; take him, and lead him away safely." And as soon as he was come, he goeth straightway to him, and saith, "Master, master"; and kissed him.

There is no record, in the Bible, of Jesus ever playing kissy-face with a girl. For that, you have to go to the Gospel of Philip:

http://gnosis.org/naghamm/gop.html

There were three who always walked with the Lord: Mary, his mother, and her sister, and Magdalene, the one who was called his companion. His sister and his mother and his companion were each a Mary...and the companion of the [...] Mary Magdalene. [...] loved her more than all the disciples, and used to kiss her often on her mouth. The rest of the disciples [...]. They said to him "Why do you love her more than all of us?"

The Gospel of John speaks of a disciple for whom Jesus had special affection, John 14:

Now there was leaning on Jesus' bosom one of his disciples, whom Jesus loved.

Jesus was liberal about a lot of things. We can eat pork. We don't have to take the Sabbath so seriously. Per Mark 2

The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath:

But, when it come to marriage, Christians have it rough. For the Jews, Deuteronomy 24:

When a man hath taken a wife, and married her, and it come to pass that she find no favour in his eyes, because he hath found some uncleanness in her: then let him write her a bill of divorcement, and give it in her hand, and send her out of his house. And when she is departed out of his house, she may go and be another man's wife.

Per Proverbs 21:

Better to live on the corner of a roof than to share a house with a nagging wife.

This is where the situation for Christians is considerably more arduous. Matthew 5:

It hath been said, Whosoever shall put away his wife, let him give her a writing of divorcement. But I say unto you, That whosoever shall put away his wife, saving for the cause of fornication, causeth her to commit adultery, and whosoever shall marry her that is divorced committeth adultery.

Unless she commits fornication, you're stuck with her, no matter what. In Matthew 19,

His disciples say unto him, "If the case of the man be so with his wife, it is not good to marry."

You see a certain anti-marriage bent here. Then, Jesus goes on about eunuchs:

For there are some eunuchs, which were so born from their mother's womb: and there are some eunuchs, which were made eunuchs of men: and there be eunuchs, which have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven's sake. He that is able to receive it, let him receive it.

Jesus is most likely referencing the Galli

https://www.britannica.com/topic/Galli-ancient-priests

Galli, singular Gallus, priests, often temple attendants or wandering mendicants, of the ancient Asiatic deity, the Great Mother of the Gods, known as Cybele, or Agdistis, in Greek and Latin literature. The Galli were eunuchs attired in female garb, with long hair fragrant with ointment. Together with priestesses, they celebrated the Great Mother’s rites with wild music and dancing until their frenzied excitement found its culmination in self-scourging, self-laceration, or exhaustion. Self-emasculation by candidates for the priesthood sometimes accompanied this delirium of worship. The name Galli may be Phrygian, from the two streams called Gallus, both tributaries of the Sangarius (now Sakarya) River, the waters of which were said to inspire religious frenzy.

King Herod had some eunuchs

https://penelope.uchicago.edu/josephus/ant-16.html

There were certain eunuchs, which the King had; and on account of their beauty was very fond of them: and the care of bringing him drink was intrusted to one of them; of bringing him his supper to another; and of putting him to bed to the third.

The Emperor Nero married an eunuch:

https://www.gutenberg.org/files/6400/6400-h/6400-h.htm

He gelded the boy Sporus, and endeavoured to transform him into a woman. He even went so far as to marry him, with all the usual formalities of a marriage settlement, the rose-coloured nuptial veil, and a numerous company at the wedding. When the ceremony was over, he had him conducted like a bride to his own house, and treated him as his wife.

Still, some eunuchs, in ancient times, performed heterosexual acts for the ladies, as Martial points out in a famous epigram

http://www.tertullian.org/fathers/martial_epigrams_book06.htm

Do you ask, Pannicus, why your wife Caelia has about her only priests of Cybele? Caelia loves the flowers of marriage, but fears the fruits.

Finally, in Mark 7, Jesus says

whatsoever thing from without entereth into the man, it cannot defile him;

Note the word: whatsoever. No exceptions. This would presumably include another man's ejaculant.

While some eunuchs may have engaged in heterosexual acts, and while one non-canonical source has Jesus Christ kissing Mary Magdalene, the evidence overall suggests that Elton John was right, and that Jesus was a nice gay man.


r/DebateAChristian • • Apr 18 '25

If the laws of Logic exist, God exists

0 Upvotes

I'm curious to hear potential objections to the following argument:

  • P0: The laws of logic exist.

  • P1: The laws of logic are universal.

  • P2: The laws of logic are concepts.

  • Conclusion: There exists a universal mind.

The laws of logic exist (P0), and are true everywhere in the universe regardless of whether humans exist (P1), e.g., the law of non-contradiction held before humans existed on planet earth.

The laws of logic are conceptual in nature (P2). They are not physical entities, nor are they properties of the physical universe, but are rather prescriptive laws describing how we ought to reason. They are not descriptive, as they do not describe how we do reason (many people reason quite incorrectly), but rather they are rules for how we ought to reason if we want to think rationally - and these rules are true independent of the opinion of any human.

Concepts are, by definition, the product of a mind. Since the laws of logic are universal concepts, if they exist, there must be a universal mind, independent of any human mind that exists. Therefore, if the laws of logic exist, God exists.


r/DebateAChristian • • Feb 28 '26

According to biblical moral standards, Epstein did nothing wrong in the eyes of Jehovah

4 Upvotes

According to biblical moral standards, Epstein did nothing wrong in the eyes of Jehovah. Bold claim, I know, but I can provide evidence. Let's break it down point by point.

Argument #1 - Women are considered to be the property of their husbands or fathers

Exodus 21:7-8

If a man sells his daughter as a servant, she is not to go free as male servants do. If she does not please the master who has selected her for himself, he must let her be redeemed. He has no right to sell her to foreigners, because he has broken faith with her.

A father can sell his daughter into slavery. Female slaves are not given the right to freedom after six years of servitude (as described in verses 2-4). A master is allowed to use his female slaves for his own sexual pleasure.

Genesis 19:6-8

Lot went outside to meet them and shut the door behind him 7 and said, "No, my friends. Don’t do this wicked thing. Look, I have two daughters who have never slept with a man. Let me bring them out to you, and you can do what you like with them. But don’t do anything to these men, for they have come under the protection of my roof."

Lot offers his daughters to be raped by Sodomites in place of the three angels visiting him. A very similar story is found in the book of Judges;

Judges 19:23-30

The owner of the house went outside and said to them, "No, my friends, don’t be so vile. Since this man is my guest, don’t do this outrageous thing. Look, here is my virgin daughter, and his concubine. I will bring them out to you now, and you can use them and do to them whatever you wish. But as for this man, don’t do such an outrageous thing."

But the men would not listen to him. So the man took his concubine and sent her outside to them, and they raped her and abused her throughout the night, and at dawn they let her go. At daybreak the woman went back to the house where her master was staying, fell down at the door and lay there until daylight.

When her master got up in the morning and opened the door of the house and stepped out to continue on his way, there lay his concubine, fallen in the doorway of the house, with her hands on the threshold. He said to her, "Get up; let’s go." But there was no answer. Then the man put her on his donkey and set out for home.

When he reached home, he took a knife and cut up his concubine, limb by limb, into twelve parts and sent them into all the areas of Israel. Everyone who saw it was saying to one another, "Such a thing has never been seen or done, not since the day the Israelites came up out of Egypt. Just imagine! We must do something! So speak up!"

Note that neither this nor the next chapter (which describes a war against the tribe of Benjamin as a result of this disgusting act of sexual violence) condemn the concubine's master, who himself send her to be raped by Benjamites, therefore being co-responsible for the rape. These two cases clearly show, that according to the Bible, it is acceptable for a woman's "owner" (her father or husband) to have her sexually abused if he allows so!

It is also worth pointing out, that the Benjamites remaining after this war, are given virgin daughters of the people exterminated at Jabesh Gilead as wives. They are also told to kidnap and force into marriage young women from Shilo; kidnapped during a festival in the worship of Yahweh! (Judges 21)
Why are these acts of rape (yes, rape, because those girls were to be forcibly married to the Benjamites, so they could grow back in numer following their near extinction) on a mass-scale considered acceptable?

1 Peter 3:5-6

For this is the way the holy women of the past who put their hope in God used to adorn themselves. They submitted themselves to their own husbands, like Sarah, who obeyed Abraham and called him her lord. You are her daughters if you do what is right and do not give way to fear.

Argument #2 - Torah's treatment of rape and rape victims

Deuteronomy 22:23-24

If a man happens to meet in a town a virgin pledged to be married and he sleeps with her, you shall take both of them to the gate of that town and stone them to death—the young woman because she was in a town and did not scream for help, and the man because he violated another man’s wife. You must purge the evil from among you.

If a rape victim does not scream for help, she is considered to be guilty as well. But what if the rapist threatens her to stay quiet?

Deuteronomy 22:28-29

If a man happens to meet a virgin who is not pledged to be married and rapes her and they are discovered, he shall pay her father fifty shekels of silver. He must marry the young woman, for he has violated her. He can never divorce her as long as he lives.

Rape of a virgin who is not pledged to be married is considered to be a crime against her father. Rape victim is forced to marry her oppressor for life, presumably leading to life-long sexual abuse.

Argument #3 - Men who visit prostitutes in the Old Testament

Genesis 38:15-16, 24

When Judah saw her [Tamar], he thought she was a prostitute, for she had covered her face. Not realizing that she was his daughter-in-law, he went over to her by the roadside and said, "Come now, let me sleep with you." [...] About three months later Judah was told, "Your daughter-in-law Tamar is guilty of prostitution, and as a result she is now pregnant." Judah said, "Bring her out and have her burned to death!"

Note that Judah himself is not condemned for hiring a prostitute. Ironically, the very next chapter is about Judah's brother Joseph not engaging in fornication.

Judges 16:1-3

One day Samson went to Gaza, where he saw a prostitute. He went in to spend the night with her. The people of Gaza were told, "Samson is here!" So they surrounded the place and lay in wait for him all night at the city gate. They made no move during the night, saying, "At dawn we’ll kill him." But Samson lay there only until the middle of the night. Then he got up and took hold of the doors of the city gate, together with the two posts, and tore them loose, bar and all. He lifted them to his shoulders and carried them to the top of the hill that faces Hebron.

Samson's strength comes from Yahweh. Even through he slept with a prostitute, he is still able to rip out the doors of the city gate, indicating that Yahweh still favours him, despite his misconduct.

Conclusion

Passages quoted above show that according to the Bible:

  • women are property that can be sold as a slave or shared with sexual predators,

  • rape is a crime primarly against the woman's "owner", rather than the woman herself,

  • it is acceptable for a man, a servant of Yahweh, to use the services of a prostitute.

Jeffrey Epstein and his co-conspirators trafficked hundreds of underage girls and young women to be sexually abused by the rich and the powerful. We are rightfully disgusted (or at least should be) by those reprehensible acts of sexual violence against, yet we're supposed to believe the god of the Bible (especially the Old Testament), whose law and ethical standards were presented here, is a perfectly good and just god deserving of our praise?


r/DebateAChristian • • Jun 13 '24

Murdering children is one of the noblest things you can do as a Christian

8 Upvotes

If we assume that innocent children go to heaven if they die, then killing innocent children means sending them to heaven. You remove any possibility that they could do enough wrong to separate themselves from God before death and guarantee their eternal happiness.

You might respond that God would command you not to do this, so it is wrong. However, this only makes it all the nobler. Not only do you have to struggle emotionally with killing children at the time, but you also sacrifice your own afterlife.

As such, under Christianity, murdering as many children as possible maximises their happiness at the price of your own eternal condemnation, and therefore is about as noble as any action can get.


r/DebateAChristian • • Nov 09 '25

There is no reason to believe that the Jesus of the gospels was a historical figure

4 Upvotes

There is no reason to believe that the Jesus of the gospels was a historical figure

The claim in favor of a historical Jesus gives diminishing returns depending on how close to the gospels you are trying to get.

Was there someone named Yeshua in first century Palestine? Yes, there were many Yeshuas. It was a common name.

Did the Romans execute preachers, insurgents, messiah claimants and zealots? Yes, the Romans encountered many resistance groups and enjoyed crucifying the participants.

Was anyone named Yeshua executed by the Romans? Probably. The Romans executed tens of thousands of Jews during the occupation, and it would be reasonable to expect that a few of them were named Yeshua.

Does that lend any credibility to the gospel stories? Absolutely not.

Is there a contemporary record of someone roaming around Palestine turning water into wine, raising the dead, walking on water, being resurrected and inspiring a world-changing movement? Of course not. Paul admitted to having never met the man, and the anonymous gospels were written several decades later.

Are there any independent sources that verify the existence of Jesus? None whatsoever. The Roman historians often cited by apologists were not contemporary sources, and wrote mainly about the Paulian movement, without corroborating the existence of its figurehead.

Should we expect contemporary historical sources considering the state of literature at the time? These were not cavemen. Historians existed, as did other writers and bureaucrats. It is notable that no one wrote anything about the extraordinary events narrated in the gospels.

Why do most biblical scholars agree that there was a historical Jesus? Over the course of history, most of the people who have studied the bible presuppose its authenticity, and apologists have published scores of books over two millennia promoting that narrative.

In conclusion, we have no evidence in favor of a historical Jesus other than apologist propaganda, and while it is entirely possible that the gospels were inspired by a real person. It is also possible that the stories come from an amalgamation of several different characters, an exaggeration of certain events, or a complete fabrication. There is no concrete evidence either way


r/DebateAChristian • • Oct 17 '25

Christians should be vegan.

1 Upvotes

There are many examples of why.

From the basis that the religion is based on compassion, love, kindnesses and beauty it is wrong to intentionally and unnecessarily create suffering for the animals and the planet by eating them.

There's a commandment saying not to kill, this gets ignored or reasoned though illogically.

There are so many reasons from the garden of eden to the everyday interactions of Jesus.

There also have been historical saints who have been vegan such as St David as it's how to align with the beliefs.

There have also been documentaries on this such as Christspiracy.

I would be interested in hearing about this from a Christian perspective and pray for positive change.

Cheers.


r/DebateAChristian • • Jun 20 '25

"X Does Not Make Sense" Is Not a Rational Argument

0 Upvotes

There are many posts which could be summarized as "X Does Not Make Sense." These posts can be well supported but they are never rational arguments. The primary reason for this is that it never deals with the problem of hard heartedness. Hard heartedness is a concept, like cognitive dissonence or bad faith, where the user is lying to themself. The position of this argument is not that skeptics are hard hearted. Rather it is for the argument "X Does Not Make Sense" to be made the user must prove they are not hard hearted. This cannot be rationally proven and so "X Does Not Make Sense" cannot be a rational argument.

"X Does Not Make Sense" is structured basically like this: "X contradicts what I know; what I know is well supported and I am not hard hearted. People who believe X can be as well studied as me but they are wrong because they are hard hearted." Rarely is this overtly stated but it is necessary for the argument and therefore is implied. It is a fact that whatever subject of scholarship the OP might use to support their rejection of X there is someone with equal (if not superior) knowledge on the subject who does believe X. If the knowledge of the subject is the defense in rejecting X then there must be something wrong with the people who have the knowledge but accept X. That is hard heartedness.

However we cannot prove hard heartedness in other people. We can see it in ourselves and imagine it in others. Even if we are certain the user is hard hearted there is no way to prove it. Thus the argument "X Does Not Make Sense" cannot be proved by reason.


r/DebateAChristian • • Apr 02 '14

April Fools

0 Upvotes

So clearly this was an April Fools joke.

Although I've had quite a bit of you convinced and poor /u/Zyracksis' reply was buried, I think it went well. Better than what /r/pics did, anyway.

To those that truly thought I converted - I'm sorry for the prank though I appreciate the comments and everyone was upvoted. In case you're wondering - two Christians didn't think this was a bad idea so this isn't some "atheist gotcha" nonsense. I'm not one for pranks but I thought this being my first April Fools on the sub and one as a mod, I thought why not?

For those of you who thought you were the only ones to catch onto the date - congratulations but I don't know why you thought you were the only ones. I had to delete all your comments but I just went back and approved most of them. There were a lot of you.

As far as the sub in general - I've seen content posted by quite a few people I haven't seen before so it made an impact. I'd say it was an overall success and definitely my most talked-about post. It was very interesting how everyone wanted to ask me questions, it's like I got engaged.

For those of you with hurt feelings, I truly apologize and I definitely didn't mean it. I will say that debates are typically for the benefit of those watching the debate, not the people actually debating. I personally do learn from debates and I did learn quite a few things being here so I hope you take that away at least. Also, I actually DO own a Bible though I haven't read it. I began reading it and found problems on the first page that don't make any sense to me but that's another topic...


r/DebateAChristian • • Mar 30 '12

Seriously, if there is no evidence, why do you believe?

0 Upvotes

There is no evidence, so why can't you admit that there is unlikely to be a god.


r/DebateAChristian • • Jun 29 '23

Islam scriptures are enormously more authentic than Christian scriptures, so why not consider becoming Muslim?

2 Upvotes

Christians, explain why your Bible has a publishing company. The Qur'an starts with "Bismillah". We have no middleman.

Allah sent us the unchangeable, perfectly preserved Qur'an, and yet you still insist the Bible is somehow more reliable? Nobody can even agree on what the Bible is. The Bible doesn't even come from the time of Jesus. Luke, Matthew, etc are literally unknown individuals who were assigned these arbitrary names by later Bible scholars! Luke starts his gospel by saying he "investigated" into these stories, but via which sources? Again, 100% unknown!! This would be literally unacceptable transmission of knowledge in Islam. Even a WEAK hadith cannot have such a break in the chain of narration, let alone the Qur'an's perfect preservation.

The Bible itself doesn't even use the word "Bible", while the Qur'an often refers to itself and tells us to use the Qur'an. The Bible doesn't even say to use the Bible as part of your religion! Furthermore, the Bible doesn't even contain the word "Christian"! The Qur'an, on the other hand, is very clear in its use of "Islam" and "Muslim". Why is this? Jesus didn't even use the word Christian, yet Muhammad (saws) consistently used the word Muslim. He called people clearly to Islam!

And how could the Prophet Muhammad saws have copied the Bible when he was illiterate and living in a remote, backwards desert village where there were no Bibles, let alone Bibles in Arabic which didn't even exist ANYWHERE in the world at the time.

If you sincerely care about the truth, then you need to seriously consider Islam. How can you accept every other Prophet of God except the one individual who has been more thoroughly documented and narrated from than any other single person in human history, down to the side of his body he slept on and the way he ate his food?


r/DebateAChristian • • Oct 21 '13

[Meta] For the love of God, can the non-Christians on this subreddit stop poisoning the well?

0 Upvotes

I understand that some of you fedorians feel an undying need to comment on everything. But for fuck's sake can you please stop commenting on threads that ask questions of Christians before any Christians have commented on them?

Example: How do you know Christianity is the one true faith?

Random genius: Lol Christianity is true because le Bible says so. Le Bible is full of contradictions lol DAE contradictions?!?!

This is called a Poisoning The Well Fallacy. Poisoning The Well "is a rhetorical device where adverse information about a target is pre-emptively presented to an audience, with the intention of discrediting or ridiculing everything that the target person is about to say."

I understand that some of you may actually explode if you don't preach to the godless choir, but it's really goddamn annoying and I'd appreciate it if you'd stop.


r/DebateAChristian • • Feb 21 '22

After deleted from r/debateanatheist, I am reposting here: Paul Copan has stated "the New Atheists aren’t willing to own up to atrocities committed in the name of atheism by Stalin, Pol Pot, or Mao Zedong, yet they expect Christians to own up to all barbarous acts performed in Jesus’s name."

3 Upvotes

The post was originally buzzing on r/DebateAnAtheist, however after "a high volume of reports," it was automatically removed, despite violating no rules. Therefore, I am redirecting it to here. Original post:

Rattling off the supposed atrocities of Christianity is fair game for Atheists. New Atheists like Hitchens popularized this style of argumentation in books like "god is not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything." Dawkins and others have reasoned the same way, with Dawkins explicitly coming up with his own fallacious reasoning as to why his double standard is acceptable.

There's no real reason why Atheists expect Christians to own up to the events of, say, slavery, (even though there was also the Christian abolitionist movement) while they blatantly disregard the actions of Stalin and Lenin's USSR, other than the fact that the errors of Atheistic communism has a far higher death toll within just the past 100 years than all of every religion combined.

We (Christians) are often told to take the blame of Hitler (despite there being significant evidence of Hitler not being a Christian), yet an Atheist has no share of the blame with Mao.

Despite what the Atheist may argue to defend his double standard, the historical evidence is to the contrary. To use the USSR as an example, Soviets saw Russian Orthodoxy to be in opposition to the implementation of Marxism. The Soviets desired the communist party to replace religion, and the two were incompatible since they needed the Russian people to rely on the State. This was much harder to achieve if people relied on God.

With the implementation of the NEP, Lenin recognized this. Dimitry Pospielovsky in A History of Soviet Atheism in Theory, and Practice, and the Believer analyzes the effect of Soviet Atheism and how it influenced the Party's actions.

Anti-religious campaigns were commonly performed by the Soviets, lasting until USSR dissolved in the 90's. The congressional meetings up in the 80's were still regularly discussing the need to suppress religion.

Hundreds (or more) journals, books, etc, have been written on the Atheism of the Soviet Union and how it effected the policies taken. Yet, with the clear influence of Atheism on the USSR, Atheism itself is expected by Atheists to have no blame. Christianity, however, is expected to bear the blame of every atrocity ever committed by a supposed Christian.

What's even more significant is that, usually, the crimes committed by Christians that Atheists rattle off about are almost always in violation of the teachings of Christianity itself, whereas the actions of Stalin are not in violation of Atheism as Atheism has no rules to violate.

This double standard, fallacious, dishonest, and historically false narrative peddled by Atheist serves one primary purpose: The crimes of Atheism of just the past 100 years are exceedingly worse than that of every religion combined. If this is admitted to, the "Atheism is morally superior" narrative collapses, and with it, the Atheist worldview and the ideal Atheist society. The commonly parroted argument of "religion being evil" collapses with it as well.

Atheists strive for an Atheistic utopian civilization. It is commonly believed by these people that an Atheistic civilization will be vastly superior to a religious one. The problem is that this version of society has been attempted over a dozen times, and each time it has been a complete and cruel catastrophe.

If we applied the scientific method to the sociology of attempted Atheistic societies--observation, measurement, and experiment--it has failed every single time. There is multiple examples of Atheist societies, yet not one has been anything other than cruel and evil. If this is admitted to, the Atheistic worldview, ethics, philosophy, and meaning collapses. Therefore this double standard must be peddled by New Atheists in order for Atheism to have any chance at claiming victory.


r/DebateAChristian • • Jun 20 '25

Gods like Yahweh may be real — but they’re definitely not what you think

1 Upvotes

Look, I'm not here to tell you gods don't exist. What I'm saying is a little deeper: Neil Freer's Breaking the Godspell nails something most theologians would rather avoid entirely - maybe these 'gods' are real, but they're not the all-powerful, all-knowing, morally perfect beings we've been sold. They're just really powerful beings with serious character flaws. Once you see it this way, Yahweh's whole act falls apart. All that omniscience, omnipotence, and moral perfection? Pure omni-nonsense. The Bible doesn't show us some transcendent creator of everything - it shows us a cosmic con artist whose track record would be hilarious if billions of people weren't still buying the con.

So let's dive into the evidence and see what we're really dealing with here.

Yahweh's Greatest Hits (and by hits, I mean epic fails)

  1. The "All-Knowing" God who somehow doesn’t know things?

    1. "Adam, where are you?" (Genesis 3:9)

    2. "I will go down and see if Sodom is as bad as the outcry suggests". (Genesis 18:21)

    3. Tests Abraham’s loyalty (Genesis 22) because apparently, an omniscient being needs to verify things.

Reality Check: if your boss constantly asked you for updates on things he should already know, you’d question his competence. But when Yahweh does it, it’s "mysterious"?

  1. The "All-Powerful" God who keeps losing?

    1. Couldn’t defeat iron chariots (Judges 1:19)

    2. Struggled against the Egyptian magicians  (Exodus 7-8) 

    3. Let Satan wreck Job’s life on a bet (Job 1-2)

Reality Check: if a "God" can’t handle primitive technology or needs to prove himself in petty cosmic bets, he’s not omnipotent - he’s a second-rate trickster.

  1. The "Moral" God who acts like a tyrant?

    1. Orders genocide (1 Samuel 15:3) 

    2. Kills babies in plagues  (Exodus 12:29) 

    3. Demands absolute loyalty while delivering inconsistent justice (Luke 14:26)

Reality Check: if a human dictator did these things, we’d call him a monster, right? But slap "divine" on it, and suddenly it’s "holy"?

Let's talk about what this actually is..

Let’s stop pretending. Yahweh’s worship isn’t based on moral admiration, it’s based on the fear of consequences. Meaning it’s not voluntary devotion; it’s compliance under threat. This doesn’t feel like faith, but a cosmic protection racket. Bow or burn isn’t exactly a moral framework.. or is it? It’s more like coercion disguised as love.  The Bible spells it out: Yahweh’s "love" is conditional on total submission. Fail to obey?

This is terror masquerading as holiness. And believers don’t just accept it, they defend it, because their survival instinct has been hijacked by doctrine.

Think I’m exaggerating? Try applying Yahweh’s behavior to any human leader:

  • A king who tests loyalty by demanding a father sacrifice his child (Genesis 22:2).

  • A warlord who punishes disbelief with infinite torture (Revelation 21:8).

  • A ruler who butchers children to intimidate his enemies(Exodus 12:29).

One would surely call that evil. But throw 'holy' on it, and suddenly, crimes become commandments. I don’t know if it’s just me, but this looks suspiciously like Stockholm Syndrome sanctified. Believers aren’t admiring Yahweh’s virtue. They’re rationalizing his abuse because the alternative - admitting this God is a monster - is too terrifying to face.

And the proof is in the gymnastics:

  • "He’s just testing us!" → Translation: "He only hurts me because he cares".

  • "We can’t understand his ways!" → Translation: "I’ve stopped expecting basic decency".

  • "His love is perfect!" → Translation: "I’ve confused threats with affection".

This isn’t just faith at all; it’s devotion under threat of punishment. The more Yahweh’s actions contradict "love", the harder believers cling, because their entire worldview collapses if they admit the truth: they’ve been worshipping power, not actual goodness.

So here’s the question no theologian can answer: If Yahweh weren’t considered the all powerful "God" of the whole cosmos, would you call him moral, or simply the most successful tyrant in history?

I know how this goes. Someone will scramble to defend him. So let’s make this simple: prove me wrong.

And before anyone retreats to "but Jesus!"..consider this:

  1. Jesus threatens eternal torture → "Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire" (Matthew 25:41).

  2. Jesus endorses Yahweh's brutality → Calls Psalm 110 (where Yahweh commands genocide) "inspired"  (Matthew 22:43).

  3. Jesus Claims to BE Yahweh → "Before Abraham was, I AM"  (John 8:58), echoing Exodus 3:14.

Therefore, either:

  • Yahweh/Jesus is consistently monstrous, or

  • The Bible's "perfect" God is not the creator-of-all-existence at all.

Pick one.

After all, the Bible's core message never changes:

  • Old Testament: worship or drown/burn/be slaughtered.

  • New Testament: worship or burn forever.

This is spiritual extortion masquerading as divinity..

Alright, here's my challenge:

Find one clear, unambiguous example in Scripture where Yahweh or Jesus demonstrates:

✅ True Omniscience: No ignorance(Mark 13:32).
✅ True Omnipotence: No failures  (Mark 6:5).
✅ True Morality: No cruelty  (Revelation 14:11). The example must:

  • Be unambiguously good (no offsetting cruelties elsewhere).

  • Show consistent morality (not one-off acts).

  • Not rely on disputed/added texts (e.g., John 8:1-11).

If you cite Jesus forgiving the adulteress, remember:

  1. The story was added centuries later.

  2. Even if ‘true’, it’s negated by him threatening eternal torture for lesser sins.

  3. True morality doesn’t require exceptions to prove goodness.

Rules:
❌ No appeals to "mystery" (that’s waving a white flag).
❌ No redefining words ("all-knowing" doesn’t mean "occasionally surprised").
❌ No quoting the Bible to prove the Bible (circular logic is for toddlers).
❌ No redefining "love" to include eternal torture.
❌ No claiming God "changes" (Malachi 3:6).

If this standard seems unfair, propose a better one.

Here's what it all comes down to:

Yahweh’s resume includes acts that would condemn any human ruler. Yet believers are asked to call this deity the ‘divine’ creator of all life. What I’ve proven beyond any doubt is the simple fact that Yahweh is:

  • Not omniscient: He asks questions and needs "tests".

  • Not omnipotent: Iron chariots stump him and magicians match him.

  • Not moral: He commands infant slaughter, but calls it "love".

So.. the naked reality is: when power defines morality, worship becomes a negotiation with fear.

Time for a reality check:

This isn’t about denying or dismissing the existence of the supernatural or the beyond human awareness as ‘myth’ like atheists (I’m not one) would usually do. It’s about rejecting the con.

So after examining Yahweh’s record, the question remains: is this worship motivated by truth, or by the sheer weight of that authority?