r/CriticalTheory • • Dec 15 '24

Judith Butler, philosopher: ‘If you sacrifice a minority like trans people, you are operating within a fascist logic’

Thumbnail
english.elpais.com
2.9k Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Jan 22 '25

Can we ban x links?

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Feb 06 '25

Trump is unleashing sadism upon the world. But we cannot get overwhelmed | Judith Butler

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
1.5k Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Sep 13 '25

UC Berkeley shares 160 names with Trump administration in ‘McCarthy era’ move: Prominent professor Judith Butler among students and faculty investigated for ‘alleged antisemitic incidents’

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
1.4k Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • May 19 '25 This

Why do modern liberal protests feel symbolic instead of strategic?

1.4k Upvotes

I’ve been sitting with this question for a while: why does so much modern liberal resistance, especially what I am seeing in the U.S., feel powerful emotionally but powerless materially?

I don’t mean to say people aren’t trying or don’t care. It’s clear there’s passion. But the tactics often seem more focused on expression than on pressure. We march, post, vote, and donate, but it feels like the far right and facisim have been gaining ground for decades. The worst actors stay in power. Climate change accelerates. Foreign policy becomes more brutal.

Meanwhile, the resistance seems locked into a loop of:

  • Raising awareness,

  • Making moral appeals,

  • Avoiding escalation (even nonviolent confrontation),

  • Then resigning until the next news cycle.

It’s strange, because many of the movements liberals admire like Civil Rights, LGBTQ+ rights, labor, ACT UP, used disruption. Not just speeches, but sit-ins, boycotts, occupations, even riots. Today, similar tactics are often condemned even within liberal spaces.

Is it just that the context has changed? Is there a fear of losing legitimacy? Or has resistance become more about feeling right than getting results?

I have theories but I'm genuinely curious to hear what others think. Is this a misread? Are there modern liberal movements that have used real leverage to win? Or are we stuck in a cycle of symbolic resistance?


r/CriticalTheory • • Dec 19 '25

What do you think about the line “if you study history, you’ll end up a socialist. If you study anthropology, you’ll end up an anarchist?”

1.1k Upvotes

I don’t know where I came across it, but i remember reading it somewhere.

my initial thought is that studying history inherently teaches you patterns of inequality, class conflict, and imperialism. it gives you a good understanding of “who wins and who loses” and could probably make people a lot more sympathetic to collective solutions or redistributive ideas.

studying anthropology shows that people have been living in endless variations of social arrangements without centralized states, authority, or formal hierarchies. i think anthropology and anarchism investigates power and tension in the way socialists or Marxist schools of thought investigate economics


r/CriticalTheory • • Jan 11 '26 Heartwarming

Is anyone looking at MAGA through the lens of drag?

1.1k Upvotes

It strikes me that many, if not all, MAGA leaders are doing drag performances constantly. Trump does drag as a physically strong virile man, attempting to obscure the whiny old weak man he really is. Kristi Noem puts on Federal Agent drag and goes on TV and does grown up drag like the way where a child will impersonate an adult and exaggerate the authoritarianism of adults. ("You better eat all your vegetables or no screen time for you, little lady!")

Then there's the garish makeup that Trump, Noem, and others wear that is reminiscent of a campy drag that isn't trying to be taken seriously, or reminiscent of a child who gets to put on makeup for the first time and overdoes it.

The plastic surgery, the Maralago Face, is young person drag.

It just strikes me that, unbeknownst to them, they are doing many drag performances and are actually doing something that the best drag performances do, which is to not attempt versimilitude, not try to convince everyone you are AFAB or an actual responsible adult running the government, but to do it in a way that isn't convincing and thus undermines the essentials that we assign to these identity categories.

This isn't a defense of MAGA or an attempt to find silver linings like, "Well, they are doing the Lord's work by undermining government authority with their drag performance!" but to highlight the irony of people who made hay off of drag queen storytime having press conferences that are just drag queen storytime with more A/V equipment and more fabulation.


r/CriticalTheory • • Oct 09 '26

Public execution as spectacle

1.1k Upvotes

I don't know where else to post this but I wish everyone in the US could grab a copy of Foucault's Discipline and Punish right now. Because the administration's plan to live stream a firing squad should be seen, and I think would be seen by Foucault, as the act of an authority regime that has lost legitimacy. I think it is an atavistic expression of State violence and an admission that modern social conditioning or "discipline" is failing.

When I was studying critical theory 30 years ago I could not imagine the future that we have found ourselves in. I think this planned spectacle is the clearest sign that real social change is underway. Far from being overdetermined, the authority of the State is crumbling.

Am I overreacting? Is anyone else getting this vibe?


r/CriticalTheory • • Feb 28 '25 Helpful This

Wellness capitalism is so dangerous

Thumbnail
theoffcut.substack.com
1.0k Upvotes

Wellness capitalism is just another way for corporations to control you and exploit your labour. Plus it's pretty dangerous now that health is so tied to corporations, and they have all this sensitive data about you. Severance does a good job at portraying to the masses the issues with 'perks', it's more important than ever to organise, unionise and stand in solidarity.


r/CriticalTheory • • Nov 05 '19

Martin Scorsese criticizes commodification of modern Marvel movies 'Scorsese boils the films down to assembly-line narratives that are “market-researched, audience-tested, vetted, modified, revetted, and remodified until they're ready for consumption"...

Thumbnail
variety.com
953 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Mar 18 '24

Cultural obsession with pedophilia and rape

914 Upvotes

It seems like everyday, somebody—not even necessarily an actual celebrity, but even some irrelevant YouTube content creator like this Vaush guy—is getting accused of pedophilia. But also pretty much every celebrity, every politician, random people you disagree with on the internet, people you think look kind of weird or whose behavior does not adequately reflect your own interpretation of social norms, etc. One of the more chilling to me was the construction in some antisemites' heads of a whole child sex ring operating out of the Chabad-Lubavitch headquarters in crown heights.

This last case I think tied together a lot of the sexual morality and conspiracy thinking into a pretty neat package basically replicating old blood libel canards. But besides Jews, gays have also historically been associated in the public imagination with pedophilia. Historically, some gays have also categorized themselves as "pederasts" at one point before the modern understanding of homosexuality developed, presumably because it was a similar enough category which was found close to hand. But in France, reactionaries would "casser du pédé", go fag bashing, and the word "pédé" clearly identifies the fag as a child predator.

What's maybe even more concerning is how quickly ideas about due process go out the window when it comes to this. People brazenly assert that we should kill pedophiles, with or without a trial. Accusations are taken as proof, and the presumption of innocence is all but forgotten. The more general discourse around rape ("believe all survivors", etc.) contributes to this too. But there's a kind of resurgence of this obsession with sexual morality, policing people's sexual behavior, using the court of public opinion to avoid due process ("cancelling", aka lynch mobs), and whatnot. And the Crown Heights 770 example really makes me wonder where this could go in the future. The obsession with pedophilia also seems to reflect some kind of a morality around childhood innocence which is supposed to be protected but which is apparently always under threat (maybe because it never existed in the first place).

So has anybody recently discussed this? I mean not just discussed vague ideas about sexual morality or identity groups being smeared with pedophilia accusations, but the more recent wave of all this stuff coming largely from the left and counterculture, the weird obsession people seem to have on the internet with proving their interlocutor is a closet pedo. Wtf is with all of this?


r/CriticalTheory • • Jun 02 '20

Not strictly critical theory, but relevant writings nevertheless. Link in the comments

Post image
815 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Feb 23 '25

Trump is Not a Populist: The American Era of Post-Populism

Thumbnail
rafaelholmberg.substack.com
762 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Apr 06 '24

University Revokes Philosopher’s Visiting Professorship over Signing of “Philosophy for Palestine” Letter

Thumbnail
dailynous.com
672 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Dec 11 '25

Chris Hansen (To Catch a Predator / Takedowns) is the real predator

639 Upvotes

I watched the Predators (2025) documentary, and the segment on Chris Hansen’s “Takedown” has been bugging me so much. They ran a sting in Marquette, up in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, very conservative rural area, where the crew lured an 18-year-old gay kid into thinking he was meeting a 15-year-old boy.

If you know anything about rural queer life, the whole thing feels grotesque. This wasn’t a seasoned predator searching for minors. This was a lonely teenager in one of the most isolated, conservative pockets of the state, where openly gay youth are nearly nonexistent. It’s entirely possible the decoy was the first “gay boy” this kid ever thought he could meet.

And Hansen’s team crafted the perfect decoy. They didn’t make him 13 or 14 — ages that would have sent any normal teen running. They made him 15, just under the age of consent, just plausible enough for a lonely and inexperienced kid not to recoil. They didn’t set bait so much as construct a psychological and legal kill zone: the exact circumstances most likely to entrap an isolated teen who wasn’t seeking out minors at all.

When you strip away the television narration, the moral direction reverses. The teenager wasn’t hunting anyone. Hansen and his team were hunting him. They entered a rural community, identified the most vulnerable queer youth they could find, and exploited his loneliness for content. If predation is defined by power imbalance and exploiting someone’s vulnerability for your own purposes, then Hansen is the one who fits that definition here, not the kid whose life they ambushed and broadcast.

The power imbalance is staggering. An 18-year-old with no peers and no community on one side. A middle-aged media celebrity with a production crew, police cooperation, legal safety nets, and total narrative control on the other. Hansen walked in knowing every consequence of what was about to unfold. The kid walked in hoping, probably for the first time, to meet someone like him.

There was always something off about the people who ended up on To Catch a Predator. Not just socially awkward, many seemed outright cognitively delayed or developmentally impaired. Some were on the autism spectrum. Some appeared to have intellectual disabilities. Some clearly did not grasp the implications of what they were saying or doing.

And these were exactly the people Perverted-Justice’s tactics were engineered to capture.

PJ’s decoys often initiated flirtation, steered conversations toward sexual topics, mimicked the vulnerability of lonely teens, asked leading questions, implied affection or romantic feelings, and created an emotional dynamic where the target felt needed, wanted, or validated.

A cognitively typical adult would reject this for obvious reasons. A cognitively impaired adult often cannot.

These individuals don’t understand innuendo. They don’t detect manipulation.
They take statements literally. They mirror the decoy’s energy. They comply to avoid conflict. They try to please the person they think they’re bonding with.

Many had no criminal intent whatsoever. They were simply inexperienced, lonely, gullible, and socially delayed.

But those aren’t obstacles in a sting — those are targets.

PJ didn’t catch predators. They caught the manipulable, the naive, the disabled, the confused — people whose vulnerabilities made them easy to bait, easy to disorient, and easy to shame on camera.

And once Hansen confronted them with lights, microphones, accusatory binders, and faux-authoritative interrogation tactics, these individuals did what cognitively vulnerable people almost always do under stress: they panicked, shut down, complied, babbled, and incriminated themselves without understanding what was happening.

Of course there were real predators on there too, but it's pretty obvious to me that stopping child sexual exploitation is not the point of the exercise.

The bitter irony is that rural, conservative areas absolutely do have older men — in their 30s, 40s, 50s — who prey on queer teenage boys. And those men operate with near impunity, because queer teens in such places have no community, no peers, no trusted adults, no sex education, no sense of bodily autonomy, and often no parental support at all.

A fifteen-year-old boy who has never met another out person, who doesn’t know a single thing about sex besides fear and shame, and who already thinks his identity is a sin is the perfect target for a manipulative older man. These kids know what’s happening is wrong but they also know they can’t tell anyone. Because telling anyone requires outing themselves, and the consequences of that can include violence, homelessness, or complete family rejection.

The entire predator-sting ecosystem pretends to be about child safety, but it avoids every actual factor that leaves kids vulnerable. It gives viewers the thrill of moral clarity while ignoring every systemic condition predators exploit.

If we cared about kids, we’d start with the basics: making sure every child is fed, housed, clothed, and cared for. Children who are hungry, unsupported, or unstable are the ones predators identify and move toward.

We’d support families. Stable, present, emotionally available caregivers are among the strongest deterrents to predation. But family supports are always the first thing on the chopping block when the GOP wants to "balance the budget" (cut social safety nets)

We’d teach kids about sex, boundaries, and consent in honest, shame-free language. A child who understands their body, knows what grooming looks like and who trusts that adults will believe them and not punish them is far better protected than a child raised in silence and fear. But the states that shout the loudest about “protecting kids” often ban the very education that would keep kids safe.

And we would finally take LGBT youth seriously. Queer teens, especially in conservative or rural areas, aren’t vulnerable because they’re queer. They’re vulnerable because they’re isolated. Because they’re forced into secrecy, denied community and understanding. Predators exploit all of it.

None of this work is flashy. It doesn’t make captivating television. It doesn’t create villains or cathartic “gotcha” moments. But it is the only approach that consistently reduces harm.

Meanwhile, sting operations give the public a comforting lie; that danger comes from strangers online, and that justice looks like public humiliation. It shifts attention away from the predators in homes, churches, schools, sports programs, and care facilities. And it lets society indulge in righteous fury without confronting the difficult truth: the real protection of children requires resources (yes money! including your taxes, if you care about protecting innocents), education, empathy, and the dismantling of shame.

This is why the Marquette sting feels so morally backwards. Hansen didn’t expose a predator, he preyed on a vulnerable queer teen for a story. The real work of protecting children is slow, quiet and complicated. As long as we have the 'predator-catching industrial complex' devouring clicks and eyeballs, it will suck most of the oxygen out of conversations that address the most serious risk factors for predation (kids who are not fed, clothed, housed, protected, loved, educated and believed)


r/CriticalTheory • • Dec 31 '20

Foucault’s Oeuvre in 4 trialectics

Post image
608 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Sep 20 '25

The dawn of the post-literate society

Thumbnail
jmarriott.substack.com
595 Upvotes

While I find this essay goes a bit into alarmism in places, I do appreciate how it communicates the importance of long-form reading in the intellectual and social advancement of civilization. I appreciate the idea that the written word is a cognitive prosthesis that can enhance our intellectual capabilities beyond what was capable during the era of oral traditions. Screens have demonstrated the same potential, but the flood of highly addictive screen-content junk-food seems so much more destructive than the pulp novels of the past. Thoughts?


r/CriticalTheory • • Sep 11 '20

Critical theory's great achievement - Lululemon's resist capitalism workshop.

Post image
591 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • Oct 27 '25

Is the "success" of the Louvre heist an example of how much of security is merely a panopticon?

530 Upvotes

One of the most intriguing elements of the recent Louvre heist is the sheer simplicity. In case you aren't aware, the robbers merely parked a truck near the museum, used a ladder to reach the window, cut through it with a chainsaw and then stole the jewels.

This made me think about how maybe the Louvre's security is more or less a panopticon. The whole idea that the Louvre is one of the most prestigious and reputable museums forces criminals to self-police and not dare to attempt a heist due to the complex and unbreakable security systems that it would probably have. Of course I don't think that the Louvre management sat down and decided to not invest anything into security and instead rely on a panopticon, but it just seems like the heist exposed how seemingly illusory their security is.


r/CriticalTheory • • Mar 18 '25

The Problem of Jordan Peterson: How to Beat a Dead Horse Correctly

Thumbnail
rafaelholmberg.substack.com
525 Upvotes

As nonsensical as most of his ideas are, Jordan Peterson is definitely a problem. Although he has been criticised in the past, academics and philosophers seem reluctant to treat his discussions of poststructuralism, Marxism, Heidegger, Kant, or anything else seriously enough to respond to him. This is, however, a risky response. Rather than criticising certain misogynistic or transphobic sentiments of Peterson, I try in this article to begin a more serious and systematic ‘correction’ of his profound lack of understanding of any of the topics he discusses. In other words, I try to show that despite his status as an intellectual, he rarely has any clue of what he is talking about. It may seem like overkill, but given his extensive influence I think this is more necessary than ever.

This might be something that some of you will find interesting, and if you do enjoy it, please consider subscribing to my newsletter, Antagonisms of the Everyday: https://rafaelholmberg.substack.com/


r/CriticalTheory • • Jan 31 '24

How has the left "abandoned men"?

525 Upvotes

Hello. I am 17M and a leftist. I see a lot of discussion about how recent waves of reactionary agitation are ignited by an "abandonment" of men by leftists, and that it is our responsibility (as leftists) to change our theory and agitprop to prevent this.

I will simply say: I do not even remotely understand this sentiment. I have heard of the "incel" phenomenon before, of course, but I do not see it as a wholly 21st century, or even wholly male, issue. As I understand it, incels are people who are detached from society and find great difficulty in forming human connections and achieving ambitions. Many of them suffer from depression, and I would not be surprised if there was a significant comorbidity with issues such as agoraphobia and autism.

I do not understand how this justifies reactionary thought, nor how the left has "failed" these individuals. The left has for many years advocated for the abolition of consumerism and regularly critique the commodification and stratification of human relationships. I do not understand what we are meant to do beyond that. Are we meant to be more tolerant of misogynistic rhetoric? Personally become wingmen to every shut in?

Furthermore, I fail to see how society at large has "failed" me as a male specifically. People complain about a lack of positive male role models for my current generation. This is absurd! When I was a child, I looked up to men such as TheOdd1sOut, Markiplier, Jacksepticeye, MatPat, VSauce, and many others. For fictional characters, Dipper Pines, Peter Parker, Miles Morales, Hary Potter, etc. I don't see how this generation differs from previous ones in terms of likable and heroic male leads. If anything, it has never been easier to find content and creators related to your interests.

I often feel socially rejected due to having ASD. I never feel the urge to blame it on random women, or to suddenly believe that owning lamborginis will make me feel fulfilled. Make no mistake, I understand how this state of perceived rejection leads to incel ideology. I do not understand why this is blamed on the left. The right tells me I am pathetic and mentally malformed, destined for a life of solitude and misery, and my only hope for happiness is to imitate the same cruelty that lead to my suffering to begin with. The left tells me that I am in fact united and share a common interest with most every human on the planet, that a better future is possible, that my alienation is not wholly inherent.

I also notice a significant discrepancy in the way incels are talked about vs other reactionary positions. No one is arguing that the left has "failed white people" or straights, or the able bodied and minded, or any other group which suffers solely due to class and not a specific marginalizing factor.

Please explain why this is.


r/CriticalTheory • • Apr 30 '25

Are we witnessing the controlled demolition of liberal democracy — and if so, who benefits from its collapse?

522 Upvotes

Recent developments in U.S. governance — including an executive order directing the military to support law enforcement and a Supreme Court ruling effectively granting the president broad immunity — have me wondering whether we’re watching the managed dismantling of a political system under the illusion of continuity.

This isn’t just about one administration. It’s the slow decay of institutional trust, the erosion of checks and balances, and the normalization of “emergency” powers that never seem to sunset. What’s most unsettling is how procedural it all feels — like the mechanisms of democracy are being used to hollow themselves out from the inside.

As someone who has served and believes in civic duty, I struggle with a core question:

Who actually stands to gain when executive power expands, the military gets domestic authority, and civil liberties are reframed as conditional?

Is this:

  • A state reacting to late-stage economic and social instability?

  • A transition toward a post-liberal framework masked by legalism?

  • Or just a desperate power structure trying to preserve itself by consuming its own foundations?

We often talk about authoritarianism like it's a sudden shift. But this feels slower — more like institutional self-cannibalization, where compliance is secured not through force but by exhausting the public’s ability to resist.

I’m not here to push a partisan agenda. I’m just trying to understand the theory and historical precedent behind what happens when a liberal democracy begins using its own laws to outmaneuver its values.


r/CriticalTheory • • Feb 02 '26

How many here read theory as a hobby/self-education rather than for school?

518 Upvotes

I understand there are quite a few people here who are earning degrees or are in grad programs. Here in the States though, college is expensive. You can only really study anything pertaining to the humanities if you’re not concerned about job prospects. So I was just wondering if anybody here has taken the route of entirely self-educating themselves through books.


r/CriticalTheory • • May 06 '25

Stoicism Has Been Bastardized

Thumbnail
medium.com
492 Upvotes

I believe stoicism can be a transformative philosophy for young men looking for direction. But over the last few years, I have seen the largest conversations about stoicism exist in the toxic misogynist spaces online. As a response to this, I wrote this long form essay not only to expose grifters and their hypocrisy but also to be informative for people that might not have previously been exposed to stoicism. In the piece, I use comparative techniques to critique the some of the more corrosive elements of modern stoicism online. I believe it is fitting for this community.