r/CriticalTheory • u/HypocritesA • Sep 18 '23
Why aren't TERFs permanently banned from this subreddit?
There needs to be a no tolerance policy pertaining to this issue.
r/CriticalTheory • u/HypocritesA • Sep 18 '23
There needs to be a no tolerance policy pertaining to this issue.
r/CriticalTheory • u/playboy • Mar 20 '26
r/CriticalTheory • u/Kaelum_Nexis • Jun 18 '25
I'm exploring how Zionism operates not just as a nationalist movement but also as a settler-colonial project layered with Holocaust trauma.
So I wonder how do we understand the moral exceptionalism embedded in Zionism logic while still acknowledging the history of persecution that shaped it??
Would love to hear perspectives or recommended readings.
Thanks!!
r/CriticalTheory • u/leftzoloft • Mar 13 '24
This is coming someone who isn’t super educated on the subject but generally believes in the Palestinian right to self determination.
It seems to me that the left is super intent on describing the current conflict and loss of life a “genocide.” I think this is an interesting and worrying discursive phenomenon.
Coming from a critical theory background, I’m pretty familiar with discourses of settler colonialism and ethnic conflict. One could certainly describe the ongoing violence in this area using a decolonial framework.
But this insistence on saying “genocide” or “apartheid” seems less rooted in actually caring for Palestinian lives and more about young people wanting everything to be described in the most dramatic language possible. Not that this situation isn’t horrible—it’s just that I don’t think genocide or apartheid is a good word. People seem to think that “genocide” just means “killing a lot of people” when in reality describes a deliberate intent to wipe out a group.
We can argue whether Israel has this intent. You can certainly use statements from Israeli leaders to show their utter dehumanization of Palestinians. But statements are not equivalent to genocidal intent.
What I think is happening is that it seems in a post-WWII neoliberal era, “intent” and “genocide” have a certain legitimacy to them. I honestly think that in the WEST and its sphere of orbit (such as israel) an event similar to the Holocaust will likely never happen again, assuming the neoliberal order is still strong. I’m not saying that fascism could never rise but I’m saying that as long as the US and Europe holds a hegemony over the world system, mass scale intentional genocide is highly unlikely. I think this isn’t necessarily because we’re “evolved” or better, but that the Holocaust holds this grip on our cultural memory as “the worst thing”. It is used to justify current structural and neocolonial violence because the western empires can justify their current violence by saying “oh, well, this isn’t genocide! We arent being Nazis! So it’s fine!” Like, as long as intent isn’t a factor, then the west can extract as much as it wants.
The left is just as susceptible to this. Instead of showing how “intent” isn’t necessarily relevant to the level of actual existing violence, they want to prove intent, thereby legitimizing the current social order. It’s meeting the current social order on its own terms. Because “settler colonialism” and “structural violence” isn’t codified into international law or neoliberal regimes. But that’s what exploitation and imperial hegemony looks like. And it can be just as bad as genocide—maybe even worse in cases where the fact of its “not a genocide”ness can be used to ignore or excuse horrible actions.
So I think arguing that something is Genocide is just…. A bad strategy. I understand that people want to leverage the legitimacy of that term. But what they’re really doing is maintaining the current order and blocking anything from actually happening.
This is not a denial of the violence. This is not downplaying the violence. This is a desperate plea for a different framework of western Palestinian activism that might result in actual lives being saved.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Ask_me_who_ligma_is • Oct 14 '25
I’m interested about the act of engaging in politics, and how it has become not only a spectacle for the citizen, but it seems like it even is for the participant? Trump’s cronies being obsessive about the look of soldiers, the military parades, the aesthetics of power, I suppose, is very odd when you consider what exactly they’ve accomplished so far. All of it horrible and immoral of course, but it seems like they do not care that they are being throttled by the courts as long as they have another visual display to move onto.
Would Fredric Jameson’s work speak to this? What are your thoughts as to why they care more about the aesthetics of power than actually wielding it?
r/CriticalTheory • u/NoWave3 • May 06 '21
r/CriticalTheory • u/[deleted] • Sep 27 '23
Hello, I would consider myself a conservative. Broadly speaking(as it relates to my below question) what I mean by that is that I think "Society" as it exists and has existed ought to be conserved and we should be very cautious about making any radical changes and to the extent that we do change it should be slow and meticulous to ensure we(humanity) are on good footing when as we progress into the future. The main reason for this being that I see "Society" as a very very thin very very fragile fabric that is barely held together to keep the world as relatively comfortable for everyone as it is and keeps us away from chaos.
Now I see various Critical thinkers/activists giving lectures and all they seem to do is to critique and tear down what exists without ever furnishing a working model of something better. I suppose this is the point in and of itself given it's called CRITICAL theory but the people who are super into this stuff seem to act with a certain impetus as if their views are actionable in the real world and that they can actually obtain some desired outcome in reality. This is never spoken about though, again it's just the aura they have when speaking while doing their critiques.
To further solidify this I can give a recent example that kind of brought this all to a head for me and caused me to seek out a subreddit that may be able to answer my question. I was watching several lectures from famed author Dr. Robin DiAngelo, these lectures took place across a timespan of several years and they were all essentially the same canned speech, it doesn't seem like she has made much progress on the topic she is just throwing around the same old anecdotes about white people who are afflicted with white fragility and how white people in general are horribly and irredeemably racists, big time.
So now the part where you fine folks come in. Could you please direct me to some material where she actually rolls her sleeves up and presents an actionable plan on what we're to do about this dilemma we're in? It's like okay lady, I buy into your philosophy 110%, now what? What do we actually DO about this besides just flogging ourselves for the rest of our lives? OR if there is no material to this effect from Robin, I'll take it from any other learned person in the Critical Race circles who is well respected. And then lastly if this material does not exist, either from Robin or anyone else could you please give me your 2 cents on what the worth is of these "Critical" disciplines if they are not actionable in the real world. Thanks in advance for any help or input you can contribute.
P.S. If you do actually have material I GREATLY prefer it in video/audio format(like an excerpt from an audio-book or a lecture that was filmed or a University course that was filmed and put online, stuff like that). I prefer this medium as 1. I'm lazy and don't want to read and 2. I usually like to listen to the arguments while playing video games, it's kinda like meditative for me and lets me think about what's being said. If material does exist and is only in text that's fine too I'll take that if it's the only thing available.
r/CriticalTheory • u/CorneredSponge • Dec 31 '23
Among the only prominent philosophers to support this idea was Karl Popper, who argued that closed, authoritarian societies were often sustained by dogmatic myth, in parallel with Plato's advocacy for a grand myth or noble lie to unite people in the Republic, with both Plato's utopia and contemporary authoritarians suppressing critical thinking to an extent. And in a direct line to fascist movements, we can see this mythicism perpetuated through grand tales of blood and soil, racial and ethnocultural superiority, etc.
Aside from this, fascism seems to support a general class collaboration and the economic model of corporatism, which seems to fit in with Plato's myth of the metals, itself echoing the fascist idea of individual obligations to the state rather than individual rights. The two are utopian, idealistic, hierarchical, etc. Fascism and Plato also hold eugenics in common. Of course, Plato professes opposition to Athenian democracy and Fascists are about as illiberal as one can get.
The only aspect of fascism Plato does not directly align with is expansionism; while Plato advocates for peace, he is wholly in favour of militarism as a posture and method for preventing war, though he may implicitly be glorifying war by doing so. Even to that end, Plato, either through or in dialogue with Socrates, does praise the Homeric epics, principally the Illiad, which was supportive of militarism and obedience. As such, while there is no evidence of Plato being an expansionist, we can say that Plato was not explicitly anti-war. I found this textbook to be of particular interest on the topic (use libgen if you don't have access), which concludes that Plato was never under the illusion his ideal society could end war and supported war given the correct circumstances; Plato's opposition to war was also likely informed by its redefinition from codified conflict between city-states to the civil strife following the Peloponnesian war
Thus, leaving aside one aspect of one part of fascist doctrine, Plato maintains ideas in line with contemporary fascist ideas, and should be labelled a proto-fascist.
This brings me to my question since I see many on different subreddits brushing off the idea that Plato is or had ideas pertaining to proto-fascism, but not necessarily discussing why.
r/CriticalTheory • u/[deleted] • Sep 22 '24
I worry how the Puritan and settler-colonial roots of white masculinity might contribute to the suicide crisis of white boys, and their recruitment into bizarre, fascist cults. I understand white masculinity as a political religion invented by Anglo-Saxon Protestants to justify the ongoing conquest of North America. Given white masculinity's roots as a kind of biological Calvinism and a belief in predetermined blessing by biology, I worry that white masculinity is fundamentally eugenicist. At any rate, I am convinced that the Protestant work ethic and Puritan self-hatred have strongly shaped white masculinity today. So I am very interested in finding whiteness studies work discussing white masculinity's cultural hollowness, suicidal bleakness and its roots in Puritanism.
I guess I'm looking for whiteness studies work like The Wages of Whiteness but more focused on the cultural hollowness of white masculinity than the economic consequences. I think I probably need to read The Invention of the White Race. I've read a bit on fascism and gender such as Klaus Theweleit's Male Fantasies but I haven't read feminist work tying the cultural side of white masculinity to specific Anglo-Saxon Protestant beliefs. I also think I really need to read up on decolonialism in general.
I started down this line of thought reading through Max Weber's The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. It really clicked to me that a lot of the condition of post-modernity is not just a consequence of capitalism and the information age but also evolved from specific historical constructions such as Puritanism. Largely white masculinity is hegemonic over post-modernity, and I wonder how much of the post-modern condition is explainable by reference to the Puritan roots of white masculinity.
This is a tangent, but there's also the aspect that white masculinity is globally hegemonic, and women and people of color can (over)perform white masculinity. I would be extremely interested in reading about indigenous white-masculinities, Black white-masculinities and female white-masculinities.
Edit: I really should have mentioned but I'm thinking of this all in the context of the "alt-right", websites like Reddit and 4chan and weird stuff like Gamergate. So I'm specifically talking about the bleakness of white male culture and white male leisure such as social media, open source software, true crime fandom, the kink scene, traditional gaming scene, anime fandom, gaming fandom, the porn (anti)-fandom, bodybuilding, wellness, religion and (con)spirituality. It's a little perverse but I would consider it important to also expand leisure to include political fandom, religion and digital self-harm communities like pro-ana or self-injury as well.
r/CriticalTheory • u/[deleted] • Oct 14 '23
I know it's a very retrded thing to ask for me but I have been thinking alot after my discourse and other people I follow on their pro sex work stance that personally are conflicting my views. What is exactly wrong with sex work? I mean sure the sex work industry doesn't function around with choice of many of the people in it, but that's just the claim the politically progressive people state. Have we ever had a theory on sex work by a sex worker itself? (That is not some bougie class women who WAS a sex worker) don't you think abolishment of sex work is gonna harm sex workers more? Like, let's say we abolish sex working, who's gonna provide the livelihood to those sex workers?
Even so if someone is doing sex work by their will, what is exactly wrong with it? How is sex work degrading and degradation of a body and sexual intimacy; camille paglia had said that she's on pro sex working stance, what's wrong exactly with people selling their body (as people say) for sex, being sexual objects, etc.
Our display for criticism for sex working always show that sex workers are being abused and forced to the condition for their work; while this hold degree of truth it's obviously not the case of all, by that we are just implying hierarchy as well that no one indulge in sex work by their own, and anyone who does is ofcourse weaker. I think the stance of abolishment of sex work harms sex workers more (by criminilsing it, etc etc) and the fact that if we really to make a society free of choices, what is exactly wrong with sex work?
r/CriticalTheory • u/SpaceSire • Dec 01 '23
I really have a hard time with it and to build my arguments for why it makes me uncomfortable.
I get this feeling that queer spaces want to draft me to become a Marxist, judge me for being too conforming and blending in as an ordinary guy (I am trans, but after HRT it can't be seen) and scowls at me when I say gender isn't social/performative. I think saying that it is performative is very invalidating to my lived experience as I was still trans/genderdivergent before I had socially and medically transitioned. Reading Gender Trouble and Testo Junky was really disturbing and upsetting to me.
Now I have also been exposed to critical pedagogy. Similarly, this was very unsettling to me and not have I liked a learning environment to be. I felt like I was forced to adopt a mob mentality and relinquish my own self. I don't want to be a generation that overthrows the former generation. I don’t want forced solidarity feelings with my peers and having to conform to peer norms rather than to teacher norms. And peer pressure is much more distressing than disagreeing with an authority figure. I don’t like student-centered learning or person-centered therapy. Whether it is in an learning environment or at a therapy session it makes me feel disturbed and angry.
I feel so upset at the current queer movement, and it really makes me feel scared and alienated. I have this feeling that the theory and pedagogy was designed to create a collective mindset with a mob mentality that revolts. I am scared of the current political situation. I don’t want to transform society through power inversion as a mob.
Help I started to go somewhat into a rabbit hole of alt-right content, but I can’t find more compassionate sources that explain to me why I feel so unsettled by the critical/queer theory/pedagogy movement.
Please mind that I don’t have a background in humanities. I am just unsettled. Maybe this isn’t the right place to go to, but at least you might help me understand.
r/CriticalTheory • u/JerseyFlight • Apr 12 '24
In his new book “Christian Atheism,” Zizek writes: “The question is: humanism presents itself as universal, all-encompassing, but this universality is already grounded in an exclusion. It is not just that humanism imposes a Western standard of being-human which reduces subaltern Others to a lower level of humanity; Humanism is based on the exclusion of a large group of humans… as non-Human…” p.27
Why Zizek feels the need to engage in this distortion of Humanism is… perhaps, because he wants to insinuate a contrast of superiority for Christianity?
Here Zizek is thinking of Humanism as being synonymous with Christian fundamentalism as well as Westernism. This is a problem. None of this is reflected in any of the Humanist Manifestos. More importantly, it’s not even presupposed by them. To interpret Humanism thus is to erect a straw man of Humanism.
What then is Humanism?
In short, it’s the axiom of the value of humans as central, of human life and dignity as central. This doesn’t mean that Humanism lacks an ecology, quite the opposite. Because Humanism is axiomatic, and proceeds by means of reason and evidence, it can be said to be foundational to progress/ because it’s not a superstitious system, its approach to the world is open and reflective, it doesn’t dogmatize, but is a continual process of open learning.
“Humanism is an ethical process through which we all can move, above and beyond the divisive particulars, heroic personalities, dogmatic creeds, and ritual customs of past religions or their mere negation.” Manifesto II
Zizek gives no citations to back up his negative and limited characterization of Humanism. He simply asserts that it’s a system of “exclusion,” when in fact, it’s just the opposite!
The religions of the world have failed, so much so that Zizek is now offering a negative version of Christianity/ why not the positive one? (In contrast, Humanism is not something that needs to be inverted!)
So far from “reducing” people, Humanism embraces the hope of a world united. “We urge recognition of the common humanity of all people.” Ibid. It is an approach whose time has come.
The historical religions of the world aren’t epistemologically or ontologically broad enough to cope with the increase of social complexity, but Humanism is, because its foundation is universal. Zizek wants to claim that this universalism contains an exclusion. Fair enough. What then is that exclusion? It’s not Humans as he wants us to believe! (He got it wrong because he doesn’t understand Humanism, or purposely tried to distort it): it’s the exclusion of the non-universal. This alone makes Humanism exceptional among the religions of the world.
I suspect that Zizek is threatened by Humanism because, even as an Atheist, he’s still too much of a Christian!
r/CriticalTheory • u/chickenbabies • May 29 '24
What are works that tackle the proposition That many societal issues such as sexism and racism stem from the conscious or subconscious normalcy of having children?
The argument could be in the sense that it leads people to to be easier to radicalize, to sustain bad world views, and to harm others. For example brcause they assume they are responsible for their lineage.
I want to explore this concept further
r/CriticalTheory • u/[deleted] • May 16 '24
Edit: I was temporarily banned from this subreddit for being "antagonistic." I'll let you judge how antagonistic I am in relation to others. Pay attention also to what comments get to stay up after the ones that allegedly go "to far" get removed 🙄
I'm curious about a dynamic where "affluent white male" radicals are not able to appeal to a status as "marginal" under currently dominant social paradigms, and thus are in a position to be more critical of such paradigms.
Obviously, plenty of "affluent white males" are taken in by nationalist or other regressive narratives, but it also seems that "affluent white males" can be in a position to see that not being "marginalized" isn't all that non-"affluent white males" seem to make it out to be.
Do you know of anyone who treats of this dynamic? I'm basically interested in how attempts at "critical" interventions often reproduce reductionist and binary social paradigms, often seemingly because of the subjective agreeability of these views to some subsection of non-"affluent white males."
I figure this is hostile territory for this question, but I thought I'd raise it anyway since it's on my mind.
Again, the idea is basically that "affluent white males" don't have the privilege to blame some stereotype of society for their alienation, e.g. patriarchy, class discrimination, white supremacy, in a simple way. They are often told that the world is "set up for them" even as that is obviously not true to those who eshew standard paradigms of valuation.
So, this drives such people into more avant-garde directions, since much social theory is explicitly or implicitly not for them in its treatment of people "like them."
Whereas it can be much harder for anyone in a "marginalized category" to see the limitations of a social theory which seems to speak to the entirety of their experience by claiming to speak to one part.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Strict-Price1557 • Jan 04 '25
Recently I’ve been attempting to read Marx’s capital. As a student of economics it feels a right of passage to read such a text. Chapter 1 was, testing. My issues and challenges lie in the labour theory of value. I had taken a class in Economic philosophy where my professor told me the LTV had been debunked. But this professor was a weird Cato Institute core kind of individual so I took it cautiously.
Despite not really taking their opinion on board, I was still broadly convincing by the marginalist revolution. The idea that value is subjective and largely a function of the scarcity of a product just inherently makes a lot of sense. It sort of offers a pretty good explanation for the water diamond fallacy i.e water is more useful but diamonds are scarcer hence the higher exchange value for diamonds.
Beyond this the LTV just doesn’t realy make sense. Like in the text Marx gives examples of making coats with Linen and the labour being the value, but here’s a case imagine I had two separate coats and one was made of cashmere (very scare) where as the other was just made of linen (less scarce), clearly the former will be more expensive in exchange value because the cashmere is scarce and hard to get a hold of thus driving up prices, also, it just looks a bit nicer. LTV immediately debunked. This feels too easy, hence why I think I’m probably off.
Anyway, I’m pretty sure I have failed at reading the book and I’m probably missing aspects of the theory. I genuinely have really enjoyed the book though and found other aspects of it very interesting. I don’t think the rhetoric that the LTV is wrong thus we throw out the book is particularly helpful. Labour is alsov ery clearly an enormous part of the production process and the idea of commodity fetish where commodities are essentially just amalgamations of human labour is an unsettling idea. Marx has definitely got me thinking but I’m caught up on the LTV. Anyone good at this shit want to explain where I’m off.
r/CriticalTheory • u/leftzoloft • Mar 21 '24
Just to caveat everything: I am trans, I've had top surgery, and I support people's right to freely pursue this. But, From a critical perspective, I don't have an answer when I'm confronted with a common anti-trans talking point.
This "talking point" is often used as a dog whistle against trans people: "Why should we let trans people with gender dysphoria attain surgical intervention if we don't let people with Body Integrity Disorder chop their limbs off?"
And while I don't think it's asked in good faith 99% of the time, I don't see a genuine response to this IF you are using a critical theory lens (the one used in most queer theory).
The best argument I can think of against this is one that reinforces hegemonic medical discourses: That gender dysphoria and BIID are (possibly neurological) mental illnesses and that gender dysphoria responds to surgical intervention while BIID doesn't. But that seems a flimsly excuse especially when much of critical theory/post-structuralist theory on which queer theory is based will contest the idea that the medical institution has the right to decide the legitimate knowledge/subject life path of an individual. And What if there were edge cases where people who have "BIID" do genuinely respond to amputations?
Why is it wrong to desire to be disabled? Shouldn't the burden be on society to change to accomodate disability and destigmatize it? If we believe in the liberation of the subject, then why wouldn't we support people who want to chop off their own legs? If we want to combate ableism, Is there any good reason why one should discourage an individual from desiring that which society labels "disabled"?
r/CriticalTheory • u/BreakThings99 • Feb 16 '24
I'm using this definition, due to the nature of the insititution. I believe it's mainstream enough:
What strikes me is the scare quotes around 'deficits'. Why is it wrong to say someone has 'deficits'?
Neoliberalism and capitalism is a morality based on productivity. Only those who work hard are morally righteous. It is immortal not to work hard, not to 'hustle'. The stigma around disabled people and the mentally ill is that they're not 'trying hard enough'. It's assigning moral value to labour. We can assign moral values to many things, such as being good at music or physical strength. I'm sure - but can't confirm right now - that in some cultures physical strength is seen as a moral obligation.
In short, only in a neoliberal morality, 'deficit' is something to be ashamed of. Only in a neoliberal world, saying you have a 'deficit' means you're lesser, not worthy of compassion or of having a place in society.
I don't subscribe to that. I'm a humanist. I believe humans by their mere existence have value. Therefore, I see nothing wrong with saying we the disabled have 'deficits'. We still have value. Our struggles with reality - and autism is an inherent disability (research has yet to prove autism doesn't cause immense harm, plus my first-hand experience and of others is evidence enough. Autism killed one of my friends).
Yet only the neoliberals need to claim that autistics are 'different' in order to justify accommodating them, because that means they can still be productive enough for the neoliberal machine.
I also think the justification of inclusion is completely wrong here. Compassion and accommodations are justified morally because of someone's deficits and weaknesses. There's no reason to accommodate people who are 'just different'. Having a dark skin is a totally different mode of being than not being able to walk.
Some would say that lack of ramps and a racist crowd are both barriers for someone who wants to participate. I think this forgets the temporal feature. A person who cannot walk, cannot walk. It doesn't matter what society he lives in. A dark-skinned person is only the Other in a racist society - and racism is not an inherent feature of society.
In short, I'm surprised this sort of discourse around disabilities isn't louder in leftist / CT circles. I actually expected that, with the rejection of neoliberal ideology, we'd also reject the shame around having 'deficits'
*I'm disabled myself. So remember I am speaking from inside. If I say we're excluded, that means we're excluded. I cannot be wrong about ableism just as a woman cannot be wrong about misogyny. Nothing About Us Without Us.
r/CriticalTheory • u/ladleisafunnyword • Sep 21 '25
Maybe I'm just stupid and dense but Judith Butler's arguments on gender almost feel like they're pushing in the opposite way Butler is moving. To me claiming that everybody is nothing and there fore their identity is based on actions they take just works to reinforce conservative ideologies and invalidate non gender conforming individuals. I think my issue is that they're trying to remove society from a purely societal topic. Yeah if you remove societal definitions no one would self identify as anything but in a world like that gender also ceases as a concept because the removal of society from a purely societal concept = 0? (if that makes sense) like yeah im sure that is the case somewhere but its not the case in our reality, so making those arguments kinda feels harmful to the very community they're appart of? idk pls let me know thoughts :P
r/CriticalTheory • u/saveyourtissues • Mar 04 '25
r/CriticalTheory • u/ssiavooshm • 2d ago
I've been reading some classic feminist theory and a lot of the time they emphasise body and reproductive abilities as an important qualifier of gender. There never seems to be a good explanation of where transgender and nonbinary people fit into this narrative. I'm especially curious to see how the gender one "feels" like or thinks is "closer to who they are within" relates to feminist and queer theory. I am trans and feminist myself, by the way, I'm just very new to queer theory. I would love it if you could give me theory book recommendations, especially if you can rec me some easier, more beginner-friendly ones.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Imaginary_pencil • Nov 24 '22
It seems now that most Universities are Post Modern or shilling to China depending the nature of the course. What happened to Critical Theory and Marxism?
When I was young all I heard was the university’s where full of Marx. I literally am at one with 150,000 students and I have seen none of it despite being a Philosophy Major
r/CriticalTheory • u/saveyourtissues • Sep 09 '20
r/CriticalTheory • u/landcucumber76 • May 18 '25
This paper critiques diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) for its focus on access to elite institutions. This focus serves the class interests of the diverse professional-managerial class while neglecting the material needs of most blacks. In doing so, DEI reinforces an integrationist vision of the civil rights movement, hypocritically presenting itself as aligned with the movement’s radical social democratic vision.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Fantastic-Fennel-532 • Jul 13 '26
Artwork: ‘Girl in a Green Cap’ by Laura Wheeler Waring, 1930
I've been thinking about the relationship between recognition and love in Claude McKay's The Harlem Dancer and Lorrie Moore's A Gate at the Stairs. Both texts suggest that what appears to be recognition can be another form of possession, or objectification. The observer believes they understand the marginalised subject while continuing to project pity or political meaning onto them. It reminded me of discussions around 'the gaze' and the politics of representation.
I'd love to hear your thoughts on these texts, questions and ideas, particularly from the perspectives of affect theory, critical race theory or postcolonial theory.
-How do we read the speaker's claim that the dancer's 'self was not in that strange place'? Is this a gesture toward radical interiority, or does it repeat the colonial gesture of denying the subject's suffering due to her material conditions?
-Moore's novel seems to suggest that Sufism provides Tassie with a vocabulary for the 'absence of the Beloved.' Does this religious framework offer a way out of the problem of recognition, or does it relocate the performance of love to another register?
-How might we think about love under conditions of what Saidiya Hartman calls 'the afterlife of slavery'? Is 'true love' possible or is it always already compromised?
-The texts seem to converge on the impossibility of being 'truly seen.' Is this a universal condition, or is it specifically produced by racialised and gendered systems of power?
Link to the poem: https://poets.org/poem/harlem-dancer
I also developed these ideas into an essay comparing The Harlem Dancer and A Gate at the Stairs if anyone is interested: https://open.substack.com/pub/adiakesserwany/p/when-recognition-becomes-a-facade?r=4sesf9&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web