r/CriticalTheory • u/stieldsceefn8 • 8h ago
r/CriticalTheory • u/aaronthecameraguy • 5h ago
Photographing the Existential | Sam Stone
r/CriticalTheory • u/gastogne62 • 1d ago
Slapping the Anti-Sociology Slop Down to Reveal Socialist and Critical Theory Perspectives
So the article is a defense against conservative critics who claim that sociology is not a science. Conservatives hate sociology because it shows the flaws of capitalism through empirical methodology.
It also shows that much of sociological research validates socialist and critical theory perspectives.
Toward the end the article also points out that a critical theory perspective encourages us to question existing power structures, challenge dominant explanations that blame individuals for their circumstances and examine whose interests existing institutions serve and the research studies provided in this article largely do that.
So 15 interesting sociology studies that have a critical theory flavor. Enjoy!
r/CriticalTheory • u/lore-realm • 1d ago
Specta-Seppuku Hype, or, Why Sam Altman really called for urgent regulation of AI at the AI Impact Summit
hypestudies.orgHype studies is an emerging field that studies the social phenomenon of hype. Hype Studies e.V., the public interest organization whose site I've linked, is an "international collective of researchers, designers and practitioners who are concerned, yet interested by the phenomenon of hype across science and technology".
In the piece I've linked, they examine the seemingly paradoxical self-humbling performances of (generative) AI insiders, who are "deeply concerned" about genAI, and how this performance serves their interests.
r/CriticalTheory • u/AutoModerator • 1d ago
Bi-Weekly Discussion: Introductions | What have you been reading? | Academic programs advice and discussion November 15, 2026
Welcome to r/CriticalTheory. We are interested in the broadly Continental philosophical and theoretical tradition, as well as related discussions in social, political, and cultural theories. Please take a look at the information in the sidebar for more, and also to familiarise yourself with the rules.
Please feel free to use this thread to introduce yourself if you are new, to raise any questions or discussions for which you don't want to start a new thread, or to talk about what you have been reading or working on. Additionally, please use this thread for discussion and advice about academic programs, grad school choices, and similar issues.
If you have any suggestions for the moderators about this thread or the subreddit in general, please use this link to send a message.
Reminder: Please use the "report" function to report spam and other rule-breaking content. It helps us catch problems more quickly and is always appreciated.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Disastrous-Corgi-841 • 21h ago
Not to Worry
Not to worry. Hollywood is working on the next movie with cutting edge graphics or story telling for you to live through. They are here to blur the lines between making a living—what you do—and living a life—what they do. This way you can ignore how miserable your life is and the fact that you’re not living at all. And they know how hard it is between movies, so they were kind enough to give us tik tok, reddit, youtube shorts and instagram. I heard they’re even working on some type of chair so comfortable that it will make you orgasm as soon as you sit on it.
The beneficent monetary system
It gave us fdr, jfk, mamdani, sanders, and aoc for blind hope. It gave us Chappelle to laugh at racism. South Park to laugh at authoritarianism and genocide. Jay-Z to prove it’s not racist and that anyone can make it if you work for it. Greta Thunberg to spice it up with a bit of sass. Drugs to kill the pain. Theories and philosophy to replace observation. Labels that everything must fit inside of, so that no one is delusional; they are either right, left or center, and of course entitled to their own opinion. Music good enough to make you forget about all of this for a few minutes. NWA and SOD for when we want to feel a little rebellious. One of those two groups even said “Fuck The Police!” How exciting!
... it gave us idols and role models to look up to.
It has informed us that when capitalism fails, it was really just a sneaky form of socialism. It has also informed us that when socialism fails, it was really just a sneaky, rascally form of capitalism. It assures us that, despite the centrality of money in both systems, they are in fact entirely distinct systems, and that civilized, educated people keep their imagination anchored to such ideas and realize that a side—a group—must be picked. It understands that your dollars say United States of America on them and are backed by its government, but it would like you to understand that when the government and dollars are pointing fingers at each other, a rational debate is taking place.
It killed 200 million, then killed 190 million and told us that this is progress. After all, which would you prefer? For 200 million to be killed?! Surely you’re not so heartless. And surely you’re not so daft as to think that no one had to be killed! Certainly not while a monetary system is still around and in use.
It has watched us for 10,000 years now. Well aware of the cycle of atrocities every society is subjected to that uses it, it has been working restlessly to find the right sequence of words to put to paper... maybe a constitution or law it says... to fix and end the cycles. This is likely a fault of our own through ignorance, apathy or nature rather than a fault built into any monetary system. And after 10,000 years it must be close to finding that sequence of words, that correct arrangement of ink on paper.
Do not worry, it has thought of or is in the midst of a bandaid for all of the problems it creates.
These problems are not for you to solve, dear reader. How could you be expected to do anything, when you are not one of its chosen? When you are not cast in certified shiny metal, how could anything be expected of you, dear reader? Even so, it understands that every once in a while you will have an urge to act on your grey monotony, your emptiness, your outrage... your misery. The beneficent monetary system has thought of this too! To make things easy on your mind, all you have to do is channel your frustrations into faith and appeals to its chosen, for it hath given you the avenues of protest and vote. But what happens when the chosen are not up to par, you ask? Not to worry yet again! It keeps a row of back up chosens on the bench ready to go should we feel the need to revolt. Sometimes things will get confused and the backup chosens will persuade us to revolt when it’s against our long-term interests, but you should understand that nothing is perfect. In any event, how kind of it to make these avenues of action mentally easy on us?
The beneficent monetary system and the care and attention it gives to human rights
It’s as if it fabricated the concept of human rights right out of thin air!
What else may it have fabricated out of thin air? Has it fabricated pressures of a treadmill out of thin air?
Were there economic pressures that pushed Germany to war? Was there an insatiable monetary drive to expand needing justification and a scapegoat? Has history shown us a cycle of such economic pressures pushing for expansion and justification for said expansion? Did the US experience a postwar economic boom after WW2? Maybe. These ponderings are best left to historians and philosophers. It is not in the layman’s tongue to say “systemic.” Instead, you are to say “good versus evil”, and you are to know that in 1945, good triumphed over evil. Nevermind that 9 million people starve to death every year in countries that are in debt to the alliance that arose as the victors of WW2. That is a topic of ne-o-co-lo-ni-al-ism and is certainly a mouthful. No, no, no, that won’t do at all. Let’s try e-vil and good. Ahhh, that’s much better. Yes, that’s more like it. This is the framework you are to use for the Russia-Ukraine war as well. Should you go pondering down this train of thought and start questioning things, you are advised to keep in mind that this is human nature and push out of your mind that you have never killed anyone yourself. Do ignore that neither organized warfare nor systemic discrimination make themselves obvious in our archaeological record until the adoption of monetary systems; that there are even pockets of societies around today without a monetary system that have no recorded cases of homicide and even shun competitive behavior. If we can ignore these things, then we can conflate capability with inherent nature.
And
Is it true that when every single person wants a policy passed, there is a 30 percent chance it will be passed? And is it also true that when not a single person wants a policy passed, there is still a 30 percent chance it will be passed? Does this echo James Madison’s remarks at the Federal convention and in his federalist no. 10 essay about the constitution “protecting the opulent minority from the majority”? Obviously, the father of the US constitution was more noble than this makes him appear and had the tyranny of the majority in mind when he wrote these provisions into the constitution. Still though, is it a little odd that out of all the steps on the social ladder, the opulent minority was singled out for protection from the rest? Why not pick the lowest step on the ladder instead of the highest as the minority group? Has James Madison made similar comments about the concentration of wealth and how this concentration of wealth should be secured? Were the “founding fathers” some of the richest in America at the time? Are the ones who became president still among the top 10 richest presidents of all time to this day? If you were to look, would you find that the top 1 and 10 percent of the US population own 34 and 69 percent of its wealth, respectively, today? If you were to look harder and in other countries, would you find that this trend is generally the same everywhere, to one degree or another? Does this lead to a global spectacle of dollars and government pointing fingers at each other, while the whole thing just keeps chugging right along? Would you use such observations to define what the monetary system is and what it is not? Is it possible that the government is just a subordinate system of the monetary system and cannot be meaningfully separated from it? Nay. Mamdani says that we can be FDR’s new deal again and Trump says we can be post war economic boom again. Such promises of making america great again relegate such observations to the back burner. You should use your tongue and hands to suck their dick than your eyes and ears to piece this together.
Could it be
That holism is more than hippy-dippy superstition? Are bio-psycho-social links established that directly connect the health of your organs to your psychology, your psychology to your social relations, and social relations to social systems? Does this literally link the health of your heart to social systems? Is it true that medicine, technology and science have been advancing ever so rapidly, and yet heart disease is still the leading cause of death in the US? 30 percent of American adults will still experience major depression? And what of suicide rates? Is there a profound realization in suicide rates remaining steady in a population over time while the rates between the groups that compose the population vary, but the rates within the groups remain steady? How is it possible for suicide rates to remain steady in a population over time if the people killing themselves are not calling each other up to intentionally coordinate a steady suicide rate? Are there correlations across geographic regions between inequality and heart disease, depression, suicide rates, murder rates and other maladies? This can’t be. We were told that those who coldheartedly align with facts wear a jew cap and talk like they’re smart. Observations were never supposed to prove scientifically that we are, in fact, all connected to each other in what is presently a web of cancer. We were supposed to be able to find happiness on our own. Meditation and yoga were meant to be key. Individual intervention in health care made perfect sense to prioritize. A route out was supposed to be there for those who worked for it. Individual responsibility made perfect sense as an explanation for shortcomings.
Did we forget about
Survival instincts? Should they be considered a basic defining feature of life on Earth? And if so, what does that make us when 7 out of 9 planetary boundaries are crossed into the danger zone? When they are measured with 13 different metrics and cO2 emissions are just one of them, yet all anyone can talk about are the big, bad, e-vil oil men? When every single society that’s been using a monetary system since the 1950’s has been rapidly destroying the conditions for life on Earth? When we replace conclusions based off this observation with moral panderings and political philosophy that are neither here nor there? When we clutch our identities and opinions in the face of certain demise? Isn’t it at this point we let go of our identities and use these observations to define what the monetary system, in all of its forms, is and is not? Is it at a point that in 40 years, 20 percent of the world’s land is projected to have an average annual temperature greater than 29C, when the last time such temperatures covered significantly more than 1 percent of the world’s land was millions of years ago? Do we happen to be living in the sixth mass extinction event of the planet’s history, and does anyone seem to act like it? On a planet with 8 billion people, how is it appropriate to blame the rich? Was it Elon Musk who woke you up out of bed in the morning to go to work? What sense does it make to say that the system is doing exactly what it was designed to do, when there is no evidence of this system being intentionally designed from the ground up at all? When all evidence suggests we are using a monetary system from 10,000 years ago, passed down to us through the generations, with each adapting it ad hoc to the times?
Have we become droids, only capable of doing the one job we are programmed to do from 9 to 5?
Maybe I’m just being W.E.I.R.D.
How ironic
I shouldn’t
Worry that I’m living in a cult that has made a suicide pact
I should
Tune in to the next podcast, album, movie, game, show, social media feed, sport, bar, restaurant, fiction book, fantasy, political promise or gimmick
Fade out
Go to sleep
And
Sleep well knowing that everything that needs to be thought about outside of my job, outside of my little bubble of a life, will be thought about for me.
r/CriticalTheory • u/SolarpunkMythos • 1d ago
Jordan Peterson’s Error and Castrating Women
In this essay, we discuss the psychoanalytic theory of the Succubus and two of its three components, the castrated and castrating woman. How can this help us better understand where Jordan Peterson and the traditional psychoanalytic tradition go so wrong in regard to the “feminine” archetype? In understanding myth, we must be conscious how our own perspective is always projected onto the world no matter how hard we try otherwise.
Thanks for your time and attention :)
r/CriticalTheory • u/MMostafa691 • 2d ago
From Idealist Teleology to Late Capitalist Contradictions: An Overview of the Hegelian and Marxist Legacy
A crucial component of current critical theory is its continued critical engagement with G.W.F. Hegel and Karl Marx. Where classical German idealism sees history as the unfolding of consciousness and totality, historical materialism provides us with an updated dialectical approach, where history is driven by contradictions in material relations of production and the commodity.
Western Marxism and the Frankfurt School, most notably Adorno, Horkheimer, and Jameson, provide us with a complex intermingling of the two traditions. Modern critical theory deals with the issue of late capitalism, where ideological apparatuses, culture industries and digital media are seen as both material and ideological.
This leads us to ask; to what extent does modern technocratic capitalism still fall in line with the secularised and reified Hegelian teleology? How canwe develop a materialist approach to diagnose our current situation where immaterial labour and digital media hide the immediate conflict of classes?
I want to consider how current theoretical approaches attempt to deal with the continued existence of idealist totality in cultural production andthe pressures of material extraction.
Sources:
Theodor W. Adorno, Negative Dialectics (1966) – specifically regarding the critique of identity thinking and Hegelian synthesis.
Karl Marx, Capital: Volume I (1867) – Section on "The Fetishism of the Commodity and Its Secret."
Fredric Jameson, Valences of the Dialectic (2009) – on the modern persistence and structural necessity of dialectical thinking.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Typical_Database695 • 2d ago
Have you ever wondered how Deleuze and Guattari's works were received in the late Soviet Union?
r/CriticalTheory • u/sergeant61 • 2d ago
Just some ideas
To take up the question of New Materialism, one should perhaps cut in through Deleuze: both posthumanism and agential realism stand close to his ontological position, while clashing sharply with Harman’s ontology. All the more so since Braidotti herself draws directly on Deleuze; setting out from the Body without Organs (BwO), one can also refine and supplement Harman’s anti-reductionism.
“The BwO [CsO] is not at all the opposite of the organs. The organs are not its enemies. The enemy is the organism.”
To avoid drifting too far from sociology into a metaphysical world thick with metaphor, the scope of discussion ought to be confined to the relation between humans and things, rather than debating whether—and how—human subjectivity exists in a purely symbolic sense.
In Cartesian philosophy, the Other is assigned the position of an object; its subjectivity is negated, and it is reduced to a mere offshoot of the taproot. And that taproot is precisely the action system described by Parsons. The Other unfolds around the taproot, while the taproot itself moves along a pre-established direction, every branch nothing more than the becoming of its movement. Only the subject, occupying a transcendental vantage point, can glimpse this movement. Husserl and Schutz resolved the problem of generalization here; otherwise, this unity between subjectivity and movement would remain an enigma. We cannot return to the past to observe this emergence directly, yet we can grasp how order is generated and maintained through its ceaseless production and reproduction. Even so, such understanding and explanation can operate only within micro-situations, and cannot account for the material world we inhabit—or for how its materiality bears upon order. The a priori status of order may have been revoked, yet the whole framework still breathes the air of idealism.
This problem is laid bare in the feminist movement. Is “woman” really nothing more than a socially and culturally constructed identity? Female essence cannot simply be erased at will; its distinction from the male—that is, the question of how the mode of being bound up in an essence differentiates itself from others so as to exist at all—is material. Distinct reproductive systems set the two apart; males possess heavier body hair and stronger musculature, which is material rather than ideational. Even so, we must admit that such material distinctions are not necessarily bound to “woman” and its derivative sub-concepts. The word “woman” carries a terrifying symbolic violence; thus relative weakness in the aggregate does not make my own weakness an individual necessity, nor does frailty of the flesh mean impotence of the will. Simply opposing patriarchy still cannot emancipate women; it only breeds a more deeply legitimized form of symbolic violence. For the abolition of concepts and symbols in this process is achieved through a counter-concept—only this time, unity is born in another dimension, and the subject remains in chains.
By bringing things into the picture, Braidotti seeks to liberate the definition of the human from any single signifier: the human mutates ceaselessly through its couplings and decouplings with things—an adaptation of Deleuzian deterritorialization and reterritorialization. Imagine the most powerful man in the world, George H. W. Bush: strip him of his eyeglasses, and his power is drastically diminished; he can no longer peer with presidential gravity at the teleprompter to deliver the line, “At my direction…” Obama, by contrast, need not worry that losing a pair of glasses will damage his political image; instead, the melanin concentrated in his flesh allows him to secure a greater share of the Black vote, and thereby accrue greater power. Yet an implicit presupposition lurks here all along: we cannot assume there is no essential difference between Obama the President and Obama the private citizen.
In this sense, can we still rely on an abstracted concept as a label to grasp an entire group? Much as this question has been debated in economic terms, has intra-group heterogeneity not already outstripped inter-group heterogeneity? Such heterogeneity is driven not merely by the division of labor in economic activity; we must also reckon with the countless possibilities generated by the permutations and combinations of myriad “actants” under globalization. This indeterminacy, as I see it, is a path toward emancipation. For stability means that the practical dispositions of individuals or groups are likewise stable—making their behavior all the easier to manipulate and exploit.
r/CriticalTheory • u/ssiavooshm • 3d ago
Trans-inclusive feminist theory
I've been reading some classic feminist theory and a lot of the time they emphasise body and reproductive abilities as an important qualifier of gender. There never seems to be a good explanation of where transgender and nonbinary people fit into this narrative. I'm especially curious to see how the gender one "feels" like or thinks is "closer to who they are within" relates to feminist and queer theory. I am trans and feminist myself, by the way, I'm just very new to queer theory. I would love it if you could give me theory book recommendations, especially if you can rec me some easier, more beginner-friendly ones.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Benoit_Guillette • 2d ago
Slavoj Žižek, ‘„Digger”, czyli powidoki z przyszłości’ ("Digger", or afterimages from the future), in Krytyka Polityczna, Nov 14, 2026
r/CriticalTheory • u/naored • 2d ago
Deleuze for understanding AI, digital state and power
reddit.comr/CriticalTheory • u/unseemlycandour • 3d ago
Looking for work that talks about normality
Hello everyone! I'm currently exploring the idea of normality and would appreciate suggestions for readings/ theorists/ etc. that are central to or have influenced this area of study.
Some questions I'm looking to read about include:
What is normality?
How does something become normal? or abnormal?
Can we always identify normality?
etc.
I'm currently reading Empire of Normality by Robert Chapman and that's been interesting so far. Any and all suggestions are very welcome.
r/CriticalTheory • u/NewMunicipalAgenda • 3d ago
The Ghost of Social Democracy, a Libertarian Communist critique of the DSA
r/CriticalTheory • u/kbysm • 3d ago
Algorithmic Desire: Toward a New Structuralist Theory of Social Media - Matthew Flisfeder
Hello all,
I’ve been doing some self study of media studies lately, read some seminal texts and historical texts such as ‘PR! A Social History’ by Ewan. Anyway, I want to read something a little more contemporary and I found the book by Matthew Flisfeder, and just wanted to know if anyone had engaged with it and their thoughts on it.
Apparently it’s quite Lacanian? My Lacan isn’t very up to speed but for those of you who read it will I be able to get by just fine?
Best regards.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Benoit_Guillette • 3d ago
Slavoj Žižek: Signs from the Future - How to Academy and Chan Centre InsightsNovember 4, 2026, Vancouver, Canada
r/CriticalTheory • u/cmarlee • 3d ago
What functions do discourses have in the political economy?
Hey there, a PhD student here. I’m engaging with uneven development literature and have a rather Marxist understanding of how the political economy works. I really want to do some research understanding how future promises stabilise the current material conditions for accumulation. However, I feel like I lack the glue to understand how do discourses and materiality (political economy) interact. For example, when the states say we need data centres because it will grow the economy, make public services more efficient, create jobs etc., these are conditional claims to future that never come. Still, they have material effects in land use, energy grids, and resource politics.
Am I too naive to trying to find a comprehensive framework between two big things like “discourses” and “materiality” and need to rather focus on finding a suitable framework that explains my phenomena?
r/CriticalTheory • u/powergripsx • 5d ago
Jean Baudrillard Research Help
I have a research project at university where I have to look into the work done by a cultural theorist of my choice. I’ve decided to pick Jean Baudrillard because he sounded interesting, and there were a lot of books and articles about him in my university library.
I need to pick out the recurring themes in the books and articles I've chosen. I’ve chosen a lot of secondary sources which focus on his book Simulacra and Simulations. I’ve also tried to read a bit of the book itself, although I am struggling.
For anyone who is quite familiar with his work, could you help me understand the ideas in this book? I'm going to try and focus on this idea of hyperreality and mass media as these seem to be recurring in almost all the sources I’ve looked at. I also don't really know what he means when he talks about simulation, my mind instantly goes to The Matrix and simulation theory, but i don't think that's what he's talking about. Also, if anyone has any tips about doing research on Baudrillard or research in general, that would be super appreciated. Any advice at all would be awesome, as this is the first time I’ve done something like this.
r/CriticalTheory • u/Yikaft • 4d ago
Critique, Repair, Escalation: Three Modes of Posthumanist Theorizing
researchgate.net"I want to suggest that within posthumanism, we can today identify three principal modes of theory.
"Following Eve Sedgwick (2003, 123-51) and Felski, I essentially conceive of [critique] as involving a ‘paranoid’ or ‘suspicious’ stance, of being committed to negativity and the practice of denaturalization, and of being driven by an interventionist, emancipatory ethos.
"Yet, this hegemony has come under attack, especially by what, following Sedgwick, I will call a reparative mode of theorizing, whose main characteristics are a more affirmative, hopeful outlook and its commitment to an ethics of care, and which manifests most clearly, though by no means exclusively, in the various new approaches associated with the ‘postcritical turn’
"Finally, there is escalation, a mode that works through excess and overdrive, through pushing things to the extreme, that is resolutely anti-natural and committed to a politics of radical immanence, and whose chief, though again not sole, expression is accelerationism. These three modes are best thought of as ideal types, forming the end points of a continuum, or as three overlapping circles, allowing for the existence of all sorts of mixed forms." [Cord, pg 1]
"Stuart Hall once wrote about the warring paradigms of culturalism and structuralism within Cultural Studies... with the work of Gramsci serving as a fulcrum... Today, it is perhaps in the influential thought of Donna Haraway that we can identify such a hinge. Her work stands testament to, and, indeed, as one model for, the immensely productive combination of the three posthumanist theoretical modes: critique, repair, and escalation" [Cord, Pg 16]