r/Composition • • Nov 12 '22

Fragments/Sketch

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Composition • • Aug 18 '26

Music First Composition!

2 Upvotes

This is my first composition, a trumpet solo named The Ballad of the Meadow. Any constructive criticism, comments or compliments would be very appreciated. This is my own piece, however i used a Postal 2 referencing pseudonym for privacy. Thanks, Reddit!


r/Composition • • Dec 19 '22

Was it hectic for you to keep track of all the books and sheet books to learn music theory?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Composition • • Jun 15 '19

The Five Stages of Musical Composition

Thumbnail
medium.com
0 Upvotes

r/Composition • • Mar 05 '26

Music I composed a fugue

0 Upvotes

Enjoy! :)


r/Composition • • Nov 15 '25

Discussion Do people with a high musical IQ come up with melodies with no theoretical knowledge at all?

4 Upvotes

I started to learn the piano, and a bit of composition, music theory and stuff a month ago, but I sometimes hear that some people can just come up with melodies that actually make sense with no theory knowledge at all, and that’s kinda making me feel like I’m not built for this cause I could not come up with an original melody for my life if I had to.

I did a quick test in a website for musical IQ, and I scored 113 (I don’t know the legitimacy of it but anyways), I’m always humming songs in my head, and I can spot wrong notes and stuff like that rather easily, but I can’t think about new melodies on my own…

Does this have to do with the fact that I never studied music nor played any instrument before? Or should one be able to think about original melodies and such if they do have a higher musical IQ?


r/Composition • • Aug 16 '26

Music Peice I'm working on:

6 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ci8aU4ObwYg

This is a reupload of a post where I forgot to include the video 😆

Please!!! I'm open-eared when it comes to criticism!


r/Composition • • Jan 10 '26

Music Is this bad jazz?

5 Upvotes

I wrote this. Is it bad or a terrible composition? How can I improve it? It’s an instrumental piece meant to be sung over. I feel like it’s good, catchy but awful


r/Composition • • Mar 21 '22

Music Mi first attempt at some kind of piano concerto. what do you think?

0 Upvotes

r/Composition • • Apr 29 '20

Discussion Criticism issues I have had since the very beginning. How can I get over this huge bump?

0 Upvotes

I have received some very harsh criticism before. Not on this forum but other places. Whether it is my stories, or my music, the very harsh critics do the same thing, analyze my work in detail, and then tear it to shreds by telling me of every single mistake, EVERY SINGLE ONE! When that happens, I absolutely feel the need to justify myself by replying back:

Well, I had it this way because of X Y Z things. So what if it is technically a mistake? You could say Beethoven technically made a lot of mistakes in his symphonies and it would change nothing, absolutely nothing about how Beethoven is perceived. The critic on the other hand, it would be perceived as a Big Fat Liar.

For every mistake they analyzed, I had a justification for why it was the way it was. Then they would reply back tearing my own reply to shreds like they did the original work and then I was like:

NO Way am I going to reply back to them. They are being so harsh it's making me as angry as a cornered up cat. And I don't want to start an Internet War, no matter the anger. I'll just move on to something else. They don't deserve commenting on me if they are going to be so harsh about it. I mean, you are talking Lion vs Housecat here. it's totally unfair because I did the hard work of producing that work and what did I get? Nothing but anger right back at me.

So you can see why my comments back on my pieces are mostly on the "mistakes" people find and not on thanking them for looking, even as I have encountered more and more constructive critics than the very harsh ones I encountered before. After having had those very harsh critic encounters, or metaphorically speaking, Lion vs Housecat(where I am the Housecat and the very harsh critic is the Lion), I'm sensitive to criticism. This has left me with a huge bump in the road that I can’t get past. Even if I move on to something else, the criticism bump moves with me. I need to flatten this bump somehow. But how am I going to do it?

I am generally open minded. If I wanted an 8 bar transition but it turned out to be 14 bars of transition material, I’m fine with that. But I’m always worried that there will be that 1 critic that is the lion, harsher than anybody else and tearing my beloved composition to shreds. And worse, what if I run into a group of those harsh critics or, to go with the cat metaphor, a pride of lions and I am this itsy bitsy, sensitive housecat to them?

It feels like there is no hope, even as I become a better, more expressive composer and blossom into my own style.


r/Composition • • Aug 27 '26

Music they said i wasn't ready for music school...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

i submitted this in my composition portfolio... they rejected me and said my music was outdated...


r/Composition • • Apr 09 '22

Meta God it feels good to have my (legally prescribed) ADHD meds again so I can focus! I forgot how amazing hexagonal piano keyboards are why the fuck don't we have them yet!?!?!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Composition • • Jun 26 '23

Discussion Morse code music

Post image
1 Upvotes

A friend and I are writing music and I’m taking over the composition part and he’s taking over the lyrics. We want a song based off Morse code and want to use the acronym FOMO (we’re writing pop punk music) as the main riff rhythm. It got very confusing quickly using those letters, picture above is what I came up with but I would love suggestions to make it better


r/Composition • • Jul 26 '26

Music Made this on flat. Got 7 views and 0 plays in 1 day before I unpublished it. Please tell me if it was really that bad.

4 Upvotes

https://flat.io/score/6a6464b66a5d2b08656f293a-the-space-journey-for-brass-ensemble?sharingKey=7462306e6f3b8489ea635b7eed39d079cc3ae3aa390f91a6696914ed50fef7293481d72cdbd23ddd8846a0cb51e8fdd2164e64b078dcc0ca4ab6698ef248fbed

As u can see it's a brass ensemble kinda stuff. it's about a space odyssey. idk guys maybe im out of my depth here. after all i dont really play brass except a bit of french horn.

If it somehow is good really, I would like to kindly ask you guys to let me know the best ways for this score to gain publicity. This will be of great help. Thank you.


r/Composition • • Feb 06 '26

Discussion I built a piano composition tool and I’d love people to try it totally free

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I built a web app for piano enthusiasts that helps you turn an idea into a playable piano draft really quickly, without getting stuck writing everything note by note.

You can see clean sheet music, hear playback right away, and watch the notes on an on-screen keyboard in real time while the piece plays.

It’s meant to feel simple and intuitive, so you can focus on the musical idea instead of wrestling with software.

I’m looking for a few early testers who’d like to try it out and share honest feedback. Would anyone here be interested?


r/Composition • • Aug 06 '26

Music Feedback Please

5 Upvotes

It would be lovely to hear some feedbakc on this little piano piece of mine. It somwhere falls in to contemprorary music stilistically.

IMPORTANT:

Some notes are played way to fast in the midi so they may seem hardly playable, i do NOT want such high tempo in real preformance.


r/Composition • • Sep 16 '26

Discussion Classical Composing Machine

0 Upvotes

I have been studying classical composition for sometime now and am honestly wondering if the classical composers possessed information regarding composing that is now lost to history. I took a small set of pieces specific to a small set of dances and created an arithmetic composition machine. It can compose in a limited style to some of the greats - but is not perfect yet. With that said I would like to share it and recieve honest constructive feedback. The machine is located at Music Builder .


r/Composition • • Mar 07 '20

Music I’m new to composing stuff, this is what i’m working on

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Composition • • Jan 16 '24

Discussion AI generated pics for cover art question

0 Upvotes

Hello,This post is mostly aimed at any artists within the subreddit but I wanted to get a general opinion from everyone on using AI generated pictures to use as cover art for my music. I know its important to support the art community through commission work but I'm only planning on using it for my portfolio/social media posts and not for sales.

Just seeing what's socially acceptable as well as avoiding conflict in the artsy community. Thanks...


r/Composition • • Dec 06 '21

Beginning composer with questions

0 Upvotes

Hi y'all,

I've been self-teaching music during the pandemic, mainly for soprano and alto recorder. I've been using various YouTube channels for this (Adam Neely, Sarah Jeffrey with Team Recorder, Malinda, 12Tone, Sideways). A lot of this stuff goes over my head, but something in one of Adam Neely's videos struck me, he said that music is one of only a few disciplines where students aren't expected to make things from the beginning. In an english class, you write, in an art class, you draw or paint or sculpt, but music treats composition as something else entirely, and that does indeed strike me as strange.

With that in mind, I want to start doing some composing. I've been mostly practicing songs in the Irish and Scottish folk traditions, and there's some pretty distinct formulas they use. I've been doing a bit of improvisation, but I'm not entirely sure how to go about writing things down and making them into compositions. How do y'all start? Is it a matter of recording yourself and writing things down? Is there a composition equivalent to drawing a sketch before doing a painting?

It's probably worth saying that I'm very slow at reading music. I can do it, and I'm trying to get better, but I'm *very* slow. I've been learning partly by ear, and since I have good relative pitch, it's much easier for me to learn that way. How do you develop the skills to determine if you have things notated at the correct length (a quarter note or an eight note, etc.)?

And I guess, if there's anything you wish you knew when you started, I'm asking for wisdom.

Thanks, and happy writing.


r/Composition • • Jan 17 '21

My 5th vlog is out now. This time everything goes wrong...

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Composition • • Aug 26 '20

Discussion The future for composers lies in audio drama

0 Upvotes

I first heard the term "audio drama" when I bumped into Storytel while looking for music startups to reach out to. Also referred to as podcast drama, fiction podcasts, or radio drama, this idea combines storytelling, audio, music, sound effects, and character lines at the same time — something like a movie without the visuals or an audiobook with diverse sound accompanying the plot.

Read the whole article here: https://mycomposium.com/audio-drama-future


r/Composition • • Nov 19 '17

The other day I made a video testing the sounds of Basic MIDI and note performer. This time I tested the sounds of Sibelius vs the sounds of Noteperformer. Take a look if you are interested in upgrading you MIDI sounds!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Composition • • Sep 17 '26

Music Can someone tell me how this would be written in sheet music?

0 Upvotes

Sorry if this is the wrong sub for this but I'm having trouble recreating this on playback apps. You can disregard the different dynamics I'd like to know the dictation of the tempo


r/Composition • • Oct 22 '25

Discussion Is composing your own music that much harder than other art forms? If so, why?

2 Upvotes

It seems so common that people that wants to do music always falls back to doing covers. I think it is rare to hear anyone make their own music, at least in my circles. It could have something to do that I follow YouTubers.

Just to compare, when I get into forums of game developers they all make their own games. They don't make covers of other games. When I see people trying to make movies they almost never makes covers of other movies. People seem to want to be creative and make their own things.

If I look away from the argument that I could be in some filter bubble I have some theories why this is. Either it is just fact a lot harder to compose music or it is question about capture people's ears. I know for a fact I just want to listen to popular songs when I search for music, (you name it, Toto's Africa or any top 10 Beatles song), I have no interest in listen to some random song. Music is about feelings and recognition, we do not want anything new. Your average dad rock band don't want to write something, they want to just play the songs the like and their audience feels the same.

Another argument is that covers of songs are new songs in the same way as new game is a clone of another game but I do not think the argument holds up really.

Just to leave with an example, there is this guy called James Rolfe that made a lot of original movies, albeit being very mediocre movies, but they were original. He went of creating a band called Rex Viper and they been around for 5 years a not a single original song, not even a mediocre one. Then the guy from Game Grumps also has a band called Ninja Sex Party, yes they have original songs, but the majority are covers.

Am I in a filter bubble or is there some resistance in making music you don't see in other art forms? If so, why?