r/Composition • • Aug 06 '26

Music Feedback Please

It would be lovely to hear some feedbakc on this little piano piece of mine. It somwhere falls in to contemprorary music stilistically.

IMPORTANT:

Some notes are played way to fast in the midi so they may seem hardly playable, i do NOT want such high tempo in real preformance.

5 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

9

u/MewsikMaker Aug 06 '26

It has no structure. No melody or recapitulation.

If it’s a study in Dadaism, then being a study defeats the purpose of the Dadaism. If it’s Dadaist, then it defeats the purpose of being a study.

Right now, it’s arbitrary noises and repetitions. If you want to make a statement with music, this likely isn’t the method. Unless you’re commenting on the irony of making an effort to create nothing, which is my own interpretation and not yours.

I’d start with a structure. A melody. Simple A B A.

-2

u/Particular-Desk7574 Aug 06 '26

I completely agree. The piece is not coherent nor structured. It is simply loose expression. This is what i wanted to create here, a study of nothingness. If this does inherently provide it with meaning from your perspective makes prefect sense, but i maybe have not clearly written what this piece is. This piece can be called Dadaist or not intepretation wise, but i want it to simply carry this one aspect of Dadaism. Dadaism in the end is a deeply complex.

3

u/MewsikMaker Aug 07 '26

Um, well. Then you nailed it. Genius.

6

u/anikom15 Aug 06 '26

Sorry I don’t want to play or listen to anything with an erotic tempo.

4

u/OpportunityReal2767 Aug 06 '26

I don't mind erotic tempos, personally, but they have to be with color.

3

u/eddjc Aug 06 '26

Hey -

From where I’m sitting, it doesn’t feel like this piece has much of a drive behind it. What I would want to know is - what do you love about it? What makes you want to write it this way? To me, and it might be just the midi realisation, it feels like just some notes placed one after the other to “sound” a little contemporary (whatever that means). Sorry if that’s me being totally unfair - feel free to ignore me.

Similarly the structure doesn’t seem to lead naturally from one thing to another - it feels a bit arbitrary.

When it comes to “étude” - what are you studying in this piece? What makes it a study? Is that because it’s inspired by another piece?

Finally - there are a very few pianists that can play repeated chords that fast or even approaching it, but it’s not something that I think they’d want to approach in its current form - I’m certain there are better ways of writing that material for piano.

Either way - don’t be dispirited. Feel free to passionately disabuse me of my view and tell me why you personally think it is brilliant.

2

u/Particular-Desk7574 Aug 06 '26

 Last month i went to an art exhibition in Zurich about Dadaism. One of the features of Dadaism is that it does not portray anything, just like this piece. There is no deeper meaning or coherence, there doesnt need to be.

4

u/eddjc Aug 06 '26

Ok, so why are you looking for feedback? Dadaism is a rejection of bourgeois notions of value in art. I’m not really interested in whether you’re trying to portray something - I want to know why you wrote it this way. Dadaist work is ultimately self defining (and arguably self defeatist). To you there doesn’t need to be any meaning (whatever that means) or coherence, so why should we care? Your question is “what do you think? Actually I don’t care”.

It doesn’t convey that to me though - it just feels like notes on a page, sorry. Consider Duchamp - why did he choose a urinal? It wasn’t because of a vacuum of meaning. Where’s your urinal?

2

u/Particular-Desk7574 Aug 06 '26

Thanks for all this great feedback, i think its important to meintion something about this piece. Last month i went to an art exhibition in Zurich about Dadaism. One of the features of Dadaism is that it does not portray anything, just like this piece. There is no deeper meaning or coherence, there doesnt need to be.

1

u/Tough_Mousse5419 Aug 06 '26

An étude is a musical composition created for the purpose of practice or technical study.

By calling it an etude you are already endowning it with a meaning.

1

u/Particular-Desk7574 Aug 06 '26

With this i meant artistic meaning. In the end this is still a study, the study of nothing.

2

u/bruikenjin Aug 06 '26

Well theres clearly something there, what is it

2

u/ImprovementSlight947 Aug 06 '26

Would you share a detailed analysis of your piece and some comments about it? For example what the player should learn through it etc. Thank you in advance!

1

u/Particular-Desk7574 Aug 06 '26

The piece does not have any coherency, it is mostly loose ideas and expressions. There is no deep or artistic meaning for it. It is a cry, a moan or maybe a scream, but nothing more. How do you feel about it?

1

u/ImprovementSlight947 Aug 06 '26

I find its like an excerpt from a scratchbook and therefore find it interesting because it gives insights into your ideas!

6

u/SwedishPianist Aug 06 '26

So I looked through some comments, to make sure I somewhat understood what you were after.

First it's the title. An etude is an exercise. It cannot be an exercise in artistic expression, while you also claim that it's a piece about nothingness.

Second, you say you were inspired by dadaism. Dadaism is a sort of "anti art", which makes the whole purpose of writing music for it, in hindsight, a bit odd. Also, dadaism isn't incoherent and formless, but rather nonsensical and silly.

To then add "erotic" in the beginning doesn't add anything...

I get the "lose ideas", but they have really nothing to do with one another, and then I'm not sure it could really be considered a composition, except in a veeeey broad sense.

Did you work on it, and really try to puzzle it together, or was it something you put together in an hour or two?

2

u/LongjumpingBook3331 Aug 07 '26 edited Aug 07 '26

Thanks to the endless new music courses, I can actually give feedback to something like this lol.

I'll actually differ from others in this thread and say the main issue here isn't the lack of drive or purpose behind this piece. Nor does it matter much (beyond a philosophical discussion) that this, as an etude of Dadaism, is a contradiction. Art doesn't always have to have an answer, sometimes it is the act of exploration or questioning itself that is the purpose.

The practical issue I find is this: if you gave someone who'd never read the score this piece, I doubt they would be able to hear even an ounce of the emotions and detail you wrote.

This is a very common thing with modern compositions. We write so much on the score that doesn't translate musically. Eyes away from the score, what about this piece reads nothingness? Is it the repetition? But repetition can also read as frustration, as resignation, and so on. What about the sound is restless? It's a perfectly fine, resonant chord. Fiery? Nothing about that part has any sense of urgency.

The piece itself already is not "nothing". You have emotions you are trying to communicate. That's probably a good starting point to improve this.

Music composition is how you arrange all of these elements so they communicate what you intend it to. Or at least get as close to it as possible

2

u/Mr_Jake70 Aug 07 '26

Not going to add to the musical/stylistic advice that you’ve received. But please don’t use Opus numbers. These are generally given by a publisher or archivist. It is rarely used by contemporary composers, and smacks of being a bit ostentatious. A simple date is more than enough.

2

u/mascotbeaver104 Aug 10 '26

Not to be rude, but to reframe your comments, you basically just slapped some notes in a notation software because you were bored and too lazy to figure out how to actually put together a piece of music, and now are just seeing if it's possible to pitch that in such a way that people will percieve it as meaningful art?

2

u/NDCIves Aug 10 '26

Contemporary Music isn't a style. This is objectively contemporary music because it was written by you, recently. You keep saying it's Dada but the idea of posting it for feedback and the fact that we are 100+ years past the dada movement suggests that what you really want is to use that label to shield yourself from criticism, but welcome any praise you might receive.

All that said, I think you are actually genuinely interested in composing and if so, the feedback I would give would be to take one of these ideas, maybe 2, and really explore them with two single constraints: You may not use the copy or transpose functions.

2

u/JazzGunk Aug 12 '26

Has a long ways to go. I have to ask, how much time did you put into composing this?
I saw a lot of this kind of writing (and justification for this kind of writing) at university, studying composition. A lot of the students who churned out stuff like this either dropped their degree or went on to work in manufacturing.

2

u/Historical-Estate-40 Aug 06 '26

Well, idk. It's hard to understand what's going on, some parts then some other parts that doesn't give no understanding what are you listening too. Even if you take individual part, inside it has many repetitions and.. Basically instead of billion theory words, listener doesn't understand what is this, what's going on, where it is going, why some parts like this then others like that. Some parts, well you said something about MIDI thing, then why didn't you adjust notation? Some parts seems hardly/impossible to play🤔

1

u/boxlinebox Aug 06 '26

If the question is "would I ever want to play this, listen to this, or analyze this", the answer is no. I think others have clearly expressed the issues with the piece not only musically, but also conceptually.

1

u/PoorSadAlcoholic Aug 06 '26

If you cleaned up/tightened the engraving, made it “look” a little more convincing, it might be passable for what it is. But as it stands, the score doesn’t communicate the idea. Though one should assume that music speaks for itself, in instances such as these, where the concept exists in the in-between space of expression and academia, the concept would be better served by better scoring.

1

u/Cautious-Vanilla-205 Aug 07 '26

Костя что за кал ты сотворил

1

u/samosa_skin_enjoyer Aug 10 '26

Throw in some blast beats and some distortion and it can work as a black metal piece.

1

u/Time_Law_9446 Aug 10 '26

im a little late to the party but umm whats happening in this piece it feels like if u took random pieces of paper in the shredder and tried to remake a picture except the shredders are across the globe

first off you could use a key that incorporates all of these key accidentals.

there is no melody and nothing rememberable.

another thing is that its just nothing its bs on a app.

1

u/VisualPhase3281 Aug 11 '26

This gave me anxiety 🥶 and panic attack

1

u/CatMinous Aug 11 '26

Sorry, man, it’s crap. There are some small parts that, if worked out in a better way, might lead to something nice.
As it is…

1

u/synth_alice Aug 13 '26

I came across this post just today, so apologies if it's already "old".

Don't want to repeat what other comments have already mentioned, but I did want to mention that I feel there are a couple interesting ideas in your piece that you could salvage, and perhaps eventually develop into something, like the use of a mode of limited transposition at the beginning, or some of the textures. Maybe go over the piece with a big marker to cross out the uninteresting bits, and keep the uncrossed bits in your notebook.