r/Composition • u/Big_League7004 • Sep 16 '26
Discussion Classical Composing Machine
I have been studying classical composition for sometime now and am honestly wondering if the classical composers possessed information regarding composing that is now lost to history. I took a small set of pieces specific to a small set of dances and created an arithmetic composition machine. It can compose in a limited style to some of the greats - but is not perfect yet. With that said I would like to share it and recieve honest constructive feedback. The machine is located at Music Builder .
2
u/Boneroni1980 Sep 16 '26
There's literally a century of literature/text books/academic inquiries written about the great composers.
how they learned, what their techniques were, what they said about composition.
Try reading that stuff. I don't think anything has been "lost" as you say, and I fully fail to understand how a "machine" could help "recover" any of that if it were the case.
I mean, you do you, but that's my take.
2
u/Big_League7004 Sep 16 '26
You are correct. The resources and literature are rich and deep. I am especially facinated in the way that some of these composers were able to take less than 200 distinct measures and with it create over a quadrillion amazing sounding pieces. It still boggles my mind!
1
u/Boneroni1980 Sep 16 '26
not sure what you mean by "less that 200 distinct measures". Is that part of what the machine does? parses out "distinct" measures?
Cause that's not really composition.
2
u/Big_League7004 Sep 16 '26
In the 1700's, the idea was to create 16 bars with 11 interchageable measures each. A person roles dice for each bar and chooses which measure to use for that bar out of the 11 possible choices. 11 measures times 16 bars is about 176 measures - from which over a quadrillian different pieces could be created. It was made for those who had interest in composing but not necessarily the skill to do so. The machine itself drifts from the historic dice games by attempting to uncover part of the math that was used to actually create an original dice game. To my understanding, there are less than 50 known dice gmes to have survived - and less than 10 that have been made since the mid 1800's. Wikipedia has an article about this called Musikalisches Würfelspiel
1
u/Boneroni1980 Sep 16 '26
Again, that's not really composition. Chance combinations (dice, RNG, etc.) can certainly inspire pieces and passages, but the dice deciding the whole piece is not composition.
1
u/Big_League7004 Sep 16 '26
I would agree with you. Composition suggests a deep understanding of principles and theory - dice do not. The real question becomes : is it possible to create a system that follows principles and rules good enough to produce beautiful sounding music. When I listen to any combination of Mozarts dice game I feel that it is possible. This begs the next question: How did he make such an amazing system - and is it possible to create new ones today for different genres of music, and if so has anyone ever succeeded in recent history?
2
u/RichMusic81 Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26
Chance combinations (dice, RNG, etc.) can certainly inspire pieces and passages, but the dice deciding the whole piece is not composition.
With very little exception, all of my work and every element within my work is written via chance procedures.
Are you telling me that I'm not a composer?
1
u/Boneroni1980 Sep 18 '26
That depends. Are all of the chance created elements arranged into the linear flow by chance procedures, or do you take those chance created elements and arrange them?
2
u/RichMusic81 Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26
I don't "arrange" anything that chance produces. If I'm using chance, I have to accept it even if I don't love the result, otherwise it isn't really chance to me.
The whole point my using chance is to remove my personal preferences, tastes and dislikes from the music as much as I can (à la Cage).
If I start organising what chance produces, then it defeats the purpose.
P.S. As to "linear flow", some of my scores are open to the point where the performers can make decisions about where to place things (notes, page order, etc.)
1
u/Boneroni1980 Sep 18 '26
I'm not saying you are not a composer, but I don't believe that is composition. I understand the point of using chance to try and inspire new ideas (remove personal preferences) but I don't believe that pieces that are fully chance are your compositions.
FWIW, I'm not saying that those pieces can't be good or enjoyable. I think we humans find beauty in patterns and symetry/asymetry, and chance music can provide that, I just don't think that is a composition. It's chance music, composed by chance.
It's like if you provided all the ingredients for your friends to make a meal, and then you claimed that you cooked that meal (ugh, maybe not the best metaphor....)
2
u/RichMusic81 Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26
I don't believe that is composition.
Saying that it isn't composition assumes composition has one single legitimate procedure, but that's never been true of how composition has actually worked, historically or in practice.
I don't believe that pieces that are fully chance are your compositions
So whose are they? If it weren't for me, they wouldn't exist.
Composition for me is a process, regardless of what that process actually consists of, that results in a piece of music.
It's like if you provided all the ingredients for your friends to make a meal, and then you claimed that you cooked that meal
They're not making the meal: I am. Using that metaphor, it's closer to me using chance to choose the ingredients.
2
u/davethecomposer Sep 18 '26
but I don't believe that is composition. I understand the point of using chance to try and inspire new ideas (remove personal preferences) but I don't believe that pieces that are fully chance are your compositions.
This is an interesting topic. Like /u/RichMusic81, I also compose using chance. What's interesting is that looking at Cage (whom we both greatly admire and are influenced by), Rich and me we all compose with chance in very different ways. And this might be the key to help you understand what's going on.
One of the important realizations we've had over the past 60-70 years (and earlier but a different philosophical framework for this started about 70 years ago) is that being "good" art or "bad" art or "beautiful" are not qualities that inhere works of art. In other words, art cannot be objectively good or bad.
The evidence is all around us. If beauty were an objective quality then, by definition, it would be universal. Obviously it's not. Not only do people react differently to works (especially on the levels of different cultures), but we as individuals change throughout our lives.
One consequence of this that I find particularly interesting is that it doesn't matter what notes I use in a piece of music. It is not more beautiful or not regardless of the actual notes. Since the notes do not affect whether the piece is objectively beautiful then does it really matter what notes I (or other composers) use? Aesthetically, no.
That doesn't mean that composers can't choose notes for reasons that are meaningful for them. This can be copying Bach or combining Stravinsky and Beyonce or using chance.
For me (and Rich and Cage), one idea that influences what I do is that I want to create music free from my likes, dislikes and memories. Another way I express this is that I want music that transcends all human culture and is not bound by the likes, dislikes, and memories of humanity.
This is impossible but one way to at least take a step outside my likes, etc, is to use chance processes. What's interesting is that once you've finished experimenting with naive ways of doing so, you start to think and explore the concept more deeply and come up with approaches that are a better reflection of you.
For example, Cage generated his chance music by asking questions of the I Ching. It was part oracle and part random numbers. I don't know exactly how Rich works but I do see in his work a Feldman influence along with Medieval Chant with long notes and lots of space. I use software I create that allows the user to choose a dedication which becomes the seed for the pseudo random number generator (if that doesn't make sense, don't worry about it just suffice to say it's very different than what the others do). The user chooses a meaningful dedication and this determines all the underlying data (which looks entirely random even though it is strictly deterministic).
The specific notes that get generated do not matter to me at all. What matters is the process I created to generate the notes. And that's the key. The notes used do not determine beauty. Neither does the process. But every composer chooses a process that they find beautiful. It's just that some of us choose processes that are chance-based.
You can see it as a different kind of creative process than choosing specific notes but it's still art whose goal is to create an aural aesthetic experience.
It's like if you provided all the ingredients for your friends to make a meal, and then you claimed that you cooked that meal (ugh, maybe not the best metaphor....)
Not a great metaphor. Composers work at the level of creating a recipe that others (performers) follow. Whether that recipe is generated through chance or consciously by the chef doesn't change the fact that the cooks still generate food that can then be eaten. Likewise we composers create music that can then be performed and/or listened to.
1
u/712DarkHorse Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26
One thing I wonder if composers did was create a time line along an x axis. Along a y axis place staves of various sizes on separate sheets of paper proportional to the amount of time the part takes up as well as according to their starting and ending time.
It would look like a multi track on the grid of a DAW.
The cutting up of the phrases and parts idea is like what you're saying. Instead of using a machine or randomized method they might have just simply separated different types of phrases and parts on paper, maybe with some journaling, to form a catalog of their techniques and ideas for new music.
1
u/Big_League7004 Sep 17 '26
That is a clever idea because that way the phrases do not feel random. It also allows reuse in an efficient way. This would create a mechanical process that could be done without a computer!
1
u/Frosty-Win8543 Sep 17 '26
I’d suggest removing urself fully from the equation and letting the bot do it
2
u/Big_League7004 Sep 17 '26
I actually had the same thought. It is fun to go through the process, but if a machine were to actually be able to compose on its own, why not let it do so? Saves time.
0
u/Boneroni1980 Sep 18 '26
Saves time for what? The process of composition is one of the rewards! If you are just trying to generate output, you're not an artist.
2
u/Big_League7004 Sep 18 '26
Two different mindsets. One only cares about the destination, the other appreciates the Journey. Imagine only watching the end of a movie to see what the out come is. On the other hand, industry seems to care more about mass production with the thought that if the quality is high enough who cares how the work got done.
0
u/Boneroni1980 Sep 18 '26
Exactly. If you are just trying to generate output and meld to industry mass production standards, you're not an artist.
2
u/Big_League7004 Sep 18 '26
Here is an experiment. The following link opens a pdf which contains a modern dice game after the order of Ricci (an Italian organist and composer from the 1700's). A lot of thought, study, and time went into its creation. The question is: Is this art? If so, why? If not, why not? https://artizandata.blob.core.windows.net/data/Ludovico%20Sartori%20-%20Jeux%20Harmoniques.pdf
1
u/Boneroni1980 Sep 18 '26
I think the creation of the game and the game itself is art.
The definition of "composer" one who writes.
If a user uses a chance system to create music, and there is no creative influence exerted in the use of that system, there is output but the user did not employ creativity.
Maybe this is just about semantics now. I don't know.
I will say though, that after thinking more about this, I do view those who design chance systems the be composing, and that arranging chance created pitches/measures/passages is indeed composition.
1
u/Big_League7004 Sep 18 '26
To take this a step further (if you are willing to bear with me). The classical composers who wrote dice games must have had a sound understanding of how to do so. The users (those who rolled the dice) did not. Now here is the point: the music that the users created only sounded as good as the creator made them sound. However, if the creator was indeed a master artist he could create a dice game that allowed its users to assemble something worth listening to. Now the step further. If Mozart were alive today and had a good understanding of programming, what type of musical system could he have created? How much of his inspiration could he have encoded into some sort of automation - or in all honesty, is that still beyond the reaches of automation itself (which I would argue it is)?
1
u/imamajorscale Sep 16 '26
aint no way OP isn’t AI
1
u/Big_League7004 Sep 16 '26
I am flattered - honestly! No piece is generated by ai and the machine does not use ai. Instead it is based off of a facination that I got from studying Ricci's dice game which translated as Arithmetic Harmony. This is where I started to wonder if there were not some ideas related to composing that got lost in time. Again thanks for your flattery.
1
u/imamajorscale Sep 16 '26
I’m not talking about the post I’m talking about the one who made the post
1
u/Big_League7004 Sep 16 '26
I am not an ai. I am a human. I made the post. But you bring up a facinating thought. Have you ever watched shows like the Zetta project? Its a cartoon I really liked about a robot that looked and acted like a human. By the end you would think it actually had feelings. I am a computer programmer by trade and have been for the last thirty years and have some strong opinions of what an ai can achieve and what it cannot. My own bias is that ai will never be alive or have real feelings - ever. That said, I do think it is possible for software and hardware (including ai) to advance to the point where it would be honestly difficult to distinguish between itself and an actual human. Lately I have been watching the Netflix series Sparks of Tommorrow with my wife and children. Its a fictional anime about bringing in the age of electrity. It makes me think that mystical and common are the same thing - just viewed from different perspectives.
1
u/imamajorscale Sep 16 '26
It’s a pointless discussion, we’ll never be able to verify the inner state of anyone (or thing) else but our own.
2
11
u/Maestro_Music_800 Sep 16 '26
I’m confused, what is the purpose of this machine? What did you intend its use to be?
Understanding classical composers and the way they processed music, creative ideas, theory, etc is best understood when actually studying their scores. A score is the meticulously crafted culmination of everything the composer was thinking.
This machine seems to produce very poorly created motives copied from classical composers, and regurgitate them in a non intuitive way that makes it arguably more difficult to understand their thought process.