r/COPYRIGHT • • Aug 22 '25

Discussion Why do you think people are so naturally inclined to defend excessively long copyrights?

1 Upvotes

I've always found it absurd that copyright can last as long as it does. When I think about all of the stuff that should rightfully be in the public domain, it is especially frustrating because it's literally theft. Previous generations had a wealth of material in the public domain to draw from. Disney itself made it's mark through animating public domain stories.

And while we still have that same old public domain material, it feels incredibly unfair that my generation (and others) have been deprived of their own new public domain material. If we go by the original copyright term of 14 years plus another 14-year extension, then basically anything made before 1997 would be public domain today.

However, it's baffling to me that this doesn't seem to bother people in general and many actually will defend it. Like they don't want stuff to be in the public domain. They hoot and cheer when there's a 50th anniversary theatrical re-release in theaters. "Finally! I grew up loving this movie and I can now watch it on the big screen!" But tell them it could have been free or affordable in theaters their entire adult life if we had sensible copyright terms, and they freak the fuck out.

What do you think is going on here? Why the affinity for corporate owned media and a seeming fear/aversion to stuff simply being public domain? Is it because we have not had anything new in the public domain, so we just can't comprehend how good it could be? (Like "public domain" to people today means really old shit they're forced to read/watch in school?) It feels like it should be a no-brainer, so I want to figure out what the hang up is.

Edit: The comments here prove my point. People have such ignorant and emotional reactions to the idea that copyright terms should be sensible. From what I can gather is that moment you say "Copyright should only last 30 years at most" all people here is "There should be no copyright for anything at all ever!" because the majority of the comments that aren't just plain nonsense seem to be arguing for copyright existing rather than arguing it should last 100+ years.


r/COPYRIGHT • • Oct 15 '26

I created a software to track AI training on specific websites to create more direct evidence of infringement.

0 Upvotes

In the vein of what many of us here already know, AI systems are infringing on copyright and de-incentivizing humans to create content. They claim liability laws will keep them in check. I say we prove it.

I created a software that plants markers on websites that sign up for it that can then be used to trace to models. There is a statistical validation method for proving these markers came from the specific websites they came from and tracks that evidence. It also tracks violations like ignoring robots.txt and other minor annoyances that are illegal.

I'm trying find publishers (any website that wants to join) to pilot and validate the experiment, and if it works, expand and start partnering with firms. It shouldn't be only publishers with millions to spend on lawsuits that get to try to fight these.

My dream is to have this on the entire internet so we can prove to a legal standard what we already know - that AI is just ripping off the entire internet, and these companies owe human creators money for the value they create.
If you have any interest in checking it out, you can email me at [email protected].

Cheers


r/COPYRIGHT • • Oct 19 '25

Question Is it illegal to print discontinued playing cards for personal use?

0 Upvotes

By this, I mean I want to print out some discontinued LEGO NINJAGO cards (that go WITH a discontinued LEGO NINJAGO game - alongside other elements) that have a trademark logo on their reverse side. I would be using my family's printer and I would be copying images of these cards onto a plain document (Word or the like) before printing onto plain paper. I would then do the same for images of the reverse sides, and then glue one front and one reverse onto each other manually before using them to play the game with by myself or with friends and family.

Basically, I am too tight to buy the cards on eBay (people sell the real ones at what I think are high prices for paper with printed images and text on them) and want to print my own for personal use, with no intent to sell them. Would I be breaking any laws? I don't want to become a criminal as a teenager (or ever, for that matter).

EDIT: On the company's fair play page, they state that the trademark in question is not to be copied, depicted, or used in any way without prior consent from the LEGO Group.


r/COPYRIGHT • • Apr 08 '26

AI Gen advocates still to this day try to claim that AI Gen doesn't require copyrighted works.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

AI Gen advocates still to this day try to claim that AI Gen doesn't require copyrighted works - and yet some of the same group of AI Gen advocates are on reddit - AND they are using my own copyrighted character to be antagonistic toward me!

Without following link (And I don't particularly endorse the sub it links to) : - Some AI Gen Advocates attempted to be disparaging toward me due to my comments and actions on AI Advocacy sub-reddits (it's a silly activity of mine to engage sometimes). They found some of my copyrighted work and created disparaging AI Generated imagery from it.

I post this here for it's relation to copyright issue and AI Gen because it's an interesting development. (Whether such disparagement is justified isn't the point of this post.)


r/COPYRIGHT • • 9d ago

Question I copied some code from an open source Github project that was under GPLV3 License with credit and He says i am a thief, am I in the wrong here?

0 Upvotes

I was working on a tool for a very old game and another person so happened to work on the same thing so i asked him if he wanted to merge but he said he wanted to work on it independently. This was his reply "My tool is open source under GPL-3.0, so you're welcome to use any of my code or findings under that license. Thanks again, and all the best with your project!"

I took that as permission and used his code (Although i hadn't bothered adding any license on my own repo cuz i thought having it public would be enough, i admit that was a fault from my part). That's why i continued developing my tool and only used his tool as a cross reference to check anytime i was stuck and needed help and also copied some parts of his tool to improve mine as well. At most about 5% of my code was from him: some functions, a set of help texts, and four add-on scripts. I also made sure to add him in my credits in my ReadMe with a link to his repo too just in case.

Now he is accusing me of going against the license and stealing his code when GPLv3 clearly allows usage and modification of code. I did immediately make the project GPLv3 added a NOTICE listing every file with his code and apologized but he has continued accusing me of theft and has blocked me and banned me from his server

Was I in the wrong, and is there anything else I should do to make it right?


r/COPYRIGHT • • May 16 '25

Seeking support for a petition to in support of the US Copyright Office.

0 Upvotes

Hello from a writer/creator who was encouraged by the recent WIPO Day on Capitol, which actually left me hopeful that the US Copyright Office had a spine. It's worth a watch: (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yd-TcGiEOQw).

If you are willing to sign a petition, here is one I'd suggest. I monitor the UK and EU battles as well.

https://www.change.org/p/stand-up-for-creative-rights-in-the-age-of-ai-support-the-us-copyright-office/dashboard?source_location=user_profile_started

We are living through precarious times for those who want a creative livelihood that is secure.

Copyright matters.

DD


r/COPYRIGHT • • Sep 25 '25

YT is allowing someone to steal my video!

0 Upvotes

Someone stole one of my videos and yt is giving me the run around with bullshit. Denying my claim, saying in order to remove MY video from someone's channel I have to upload a copyright certificate despite my upload was 2 months before it was stolen, I've given them screenshots of my process that also has timestamps, I recently became monetized and that video is what pushed me to the finish line, hell even my channel logo is displayed on the stolen video! How is YouTube allowing this?! They are protecting the thieves more than the creators!


r/COPYRIGHT • • Aug 25 '25

Question Current state of copyright protection for AI-generated works

0 Upvotes

Which of the following best describes the current state of copyright protection for AI-generated works in the United States as of 2025?

A) AI-generated works are automatically granted copyright protection if the AI was trained on licensed data.

B) AI-generated works are not eligible for copyright protection because they lack human authorship.

C) AI-generated works can be copyrighted if a human provides significant creative input in the process.

D) AI-generated works are protected under a special "AI copyright" category distinct from human-authored works.


r/COPYRIGHT • • Oct 24 '25

Is it legal to make a grocery price comparison site?

0 Upvotes

I'm considering making a website that scrapes the names, photos, and prices from grocery stores' websites to compare prices.

Would this be legal in the US, even if a site's TOS says that you cannot do this?

Thanks in advance for any advice!


r/COPYRIGHT • • Mar 27 '23

AI and the Law: What You Need To Know The AI Topic Nobody Is Talking About (Paul DelSignore)

0 Upvotes

"Here’s What You Need To Know

If you are generating content using AI tools, you don’t own any of it.

That’s right. The beautiful images you generate with Midjourney are not protected. I can take your images, print them on a t-shirt or book cover and sell them without any ramifications.

If you are a company that is using AI for written documents, articles, or news items, they can be copied and re-used somewhere else. If you are using AI to generate fashion and interior design, advertising, or marketing campaigns, music or sound effects, 3D models, magazine covers, billboards, or educational content, none of that is protected under copyright laws.

If you are creating AI-generated videos, (like what Netflix just did for background animations in an anime), you don’t own the IP for those videos or animations."

https://medium.com/the-generator/ai-and-the-law-what-you-need-to-know-bfebb51b7d53


r/COPYRIGHT • • Apr 18 '25

can I draw a character from a book or would that get me copyrighted?

0 Upvotes

I was thinking of drawing a couple from a book, but i was worried i would be arrested for copyright. can I draw them without facing legal trouble?


r/COPYRIGHT • • Sep 13 '25

Discussion Sony Entertainment Japan Destroyed my channel

0 Upvotes

Do I need to send legal notice to youtube?

I got false strike by Sony Japan Entertainment and now my channel is basically dead because of shadowban.

Youtube won’t let me counterclaim no matter how detailed I am about it now They also blocked me from sending more counterclaim.

Sony accused me of uploading their movie on my channel but It’s basically a game that based on an anime published by Sega and Sega state in their post that it is safe for streaming.

Used to have 10-50K views now It barely touch 1K

Ps. it’s commentary gameplay with copyright music cut off


r/COPYRIGHT • • Nov 19 '24

Discussion AI 'Opt-out' is a "big Lie". It's an invention of AI Gen advocates to conflate Text and Data Mining with Machine Learning to get copyright exceptions that are not available to machines.

0 Upvotes

AI Training or Machine Learning is 'self-learning by a MACHINE'. A "self learning machine" can't avail itself of ANY copyright exceptions to allow it to use copyrighted material in order to replace human authorship.

That's why a judge is OK with researchers doing Text and Data Miming (LAION Case). Researchers are human so the law applies. But AI Training is self-learning by a machine and shouldn't be conflated with human activities. The Machine itself is infringing copyright in Machine Learning. Not any human.

AI Training is what a Machine does (Machine learning). "Copyright law doesn't apply to machines" so that is why they shouldn't have a copyright exception.

That's the real argument we should be putting forwards.

A Machine can't use "fair use" as an affirmative defense in any court. It's just infringing copyright in order to replace human authorship. A Machine doesn't have any rights nor any copyright exceptions. It's a machine!

"the AI Act recognizes the relevance of TDM to AI training, but in no way does it indicate that TDM is synonymous with AI training or that everything in-between TDM and AI training is covered by Articles 3 or 4 of the DSM Directive." (Eleonora Rosati)

https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/european-journal-of-risk-regulation/article/infringing-ai-liability-for-aigenerated-outputs-under-international-eu-and-uk-copyright-law/C568C6B717E9CFC45FB52E58E54B6BEC


r/COPYRIGHT • • Apr 18 '25

Is using AI (image to image) to make copyrighted images transform into a different visual style (like making cartoons look like real life) and animating them with AI video, copyright infringement, or fair use? (Example included)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Something about this, is SO COOL to me. Instead of the usual uncanny valley effect AI usually has, there is something very satisfying about seeing cartoon characters ACCURATELY basically cloned into real life.

I’m even willing to accept copyright claims, giving all revenue to the original copyright holder, on those specific videos.

However my initial reason for using AI video was to make more original content, which has turned out to be harder than I thought, even with AI (part of the problem is it taking too much control away from you, but for THIS character restyle specifically, it’s PERFECT, and that’s kind of what makes it seem even more risky copyright-wise).

I’d love to take it a step further and animate not just 5-10 seconds, but longer videos, and clone the actual voices, but I’m near positive that would DEFINITELY get me STRIKES AND CHANNEL TERMINATED, MAYBE EVEN SUED IN REAL LIFE.

But just doing THIS, something that actually excites me, could bring in HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS, EVEN MILLIONS (just look at the channel that posted the video I included as an example) OF VIEWS, so that could pull in views for non-copyrighted monetizable videos too.

Problem is STRIKES (worse than claims) actually hurt your ENTIRE CHANNEL, and if your goal is monetization, a real human reviews your channel when you reach the required hours and subscribers to apply for it, and if they see a lot of copyrighted materials, they’ll deny you.

On one hand I feel like “I have access to these tools that can generate ANYTHING, I have NO REASON to rely on copyrighted IP.” But I actually have passion for the shows and games I want to visually transform, and it’s also good way to get views in to show your other videos.

I’m not sure what my limits are here.

I could create a separate YouTube channel on a separate Google account just to be safer, but if I can upload them on my main channel it could help me grow and get more original content viewed and pushed out.

Also is showing the original copyrighted image (for visual comparison) particularly a problem? Are the AI “real life” versions a problem since they still obviously represent the recognizable copyrighted IP?


r/COPYRIGHT • • 2d ago

Question Received an "Image License Enquiry" email from Press Association asking me to pay £6,016.25

3 Upvotes

I run a blog where I had used some copyright images around 7 years ago and now I have received this email from PA asking me to pay the said amount. I have removed the images but the amount they are asking me is too much. I have adsense on my blog and it barely makes $100 a month. What should I do in this case? Also I have been a digital nomad for the last decade, so the country where I started the blog is not where I am residing currently. If I just take down the images and not pay the amount, how would they come after me?


r/COPYRIGHT • • Mar 03 '26

Question +170 years old drawings requiring a license to use for profit?

1 Upvotes

I've been searching through the database of a museum's art in order to acquire copyright-free visual content for an indie game I'm developing.

While the museum allows personal use and monetary use in small amounts, it requires you to license any content you want to use in monetary projects.

For example:

https://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O703989/macau-street-scene-with-the-drawing-george-chinnery/

If you click on the image, a small teal 'License image' button will appear. Clicking on it tells you you need to email them to license the work.

I don't understand how art that has long since fallen into the public domain would require a license?


r/COPYRIGHT • • May 13 '25

Copyright News The Copyright Office Issues A Largely Disappointing Report On AI Training, And Once Again A Major Fair Use Analysis Inexplicably Ignores The First Amendment

Thumbnail
techdirt.com
0 Upvotes

r/COPYRIGHT • • Apr 24 '26

The real problem with AI in education isn't cheating - it's systematic IP theft being normalized

10 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this education post that's making rounds, particularly the point about AI being "plagiaristic content synthesis" that's designed to sabotage learning for working-class kids while the wealthy still get real education.

But there's a deeper issue here that everyone's missing. When we hand students these AI tools and tell them it's okay to use content that was scraped without permission from millions of creators, we're not just undermining their education - we're teaching them that intellectual property doesn't matter. These models were trained on copyrighted books, articles, code, and creative works without compensation or often even attribution to the original creators.

The irony is brutal. Students who use AI to write papers risk getting expelled for plagiarism, but the AI companies who built these tools by essentially plagiarizing the entire internet face no consequences. We're creating a generation that thinks this is normal - that taking someone's work without permission is just how technology works.

And yes, this absolutely hits working-class students hardest. Wealthy families can afford to send their kids to schools that emphasize original thinking and proper attribution. Meanwhile, cash-strapped public schools are pushing AI tools as efficiency solutions, not realizing they're normalizing copyright infringement as an acceptable shortcut.

Has anyone else noticed how the same institutions that will fail a student for citing Wikipedia are now celebrating AI tools that can't even tell you whose work they're synthesizing?


r/COPYRIGHT • • Nov 30 '24

Discussion The real killer of AI Gens is USC17§103(a)

0 Upvotes

The real killer of AI Gens is USC17§103(a)

...protection for a work employing preexisting material in which copyright subsists does not extend to any part of the work in which such material has been used unlawfully.

I think many copyright experts know this but are avoiding the issue.

The other killer issue is the fact AI Gens are just Vending Machines.

There is no copyright in the whole process. This is logical too as you can't stop people asking the same question and getting similar answers from an AI Generator regardless of whether it's text, image or a translation of text or even a search engine result. There is just no way to monopolize such things and claim "exclusive rights".

The results are also based on copyrighted works used without authorisation which is still true even if "fair use" applies. The maker of a derivative works just can't gain protection without a "written exclusive license signed by all parties". Fair use isn't a substitute for a "written exclusive license signed by all parties".

I think AI Gens will just die when the above issues are really brought to light which is inevitable.

"The truth is incontrovertible. Malice may attack it, ignorance may deride it, but in the end, there it is." Winston Churchill.


r/COPYRIGHT • • Sep 01 '25

Your Favorite Franchise Has Been Ruined By Bad Copyright Law

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
2 Upvotes

r/COPYRIGHT • • Aug 15 '24

Artists Score Major Win in Copyright Case Against AI Art Generators The court declined to dismiss copyright infringement claims against the AI companies. The order could implicate other firms that used Stable Diffusion, the AI model at issue in the case. (Winston Cho. The Hollywood Reporter)

3 Upvotes

"Siding with artists, Orrick concluded that they sufficiently alleged that Stable Diffusion is built off of copyrighted material and that the “way the product operates necessarily invokes copies or protected elements of those works.” In a finding that could spell trouble for AI companies that used the model, he said that Stability and Runway could’ve promoted copyright infringement and that Stable Diffusion was “created to facilitate that infringement by design.”"
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/business-news/artists-score-major-win-copyright-case-against-ai-art-generators-1235973601/


r/COPYRIGHT • • 26d ago

Discussion Re: AI generative copyright and the "fruit from the poison tree" legal maxim that means even edited or "selection and arrangement" (thin copyright) fails due to § 103(a) and Anderson v Stallone standard. Each AI gen user would have to make an "offensive" fair use defense to get to § 103(b).

0 Upvotes

(a) The subject matter of copyright as specified by section 102 includes compilations and derivative works, but protection for a work employing preexisting material in which copyright subsists does not extend to any part of the work in which such material has been used unlawfully.

17 U.S. Code § 103 - Subject matter of copyright: Compilations and derivative works


r/COPYRIGHT • • May 30 '25

Google's Veo3 AI Video Generator's copyright problems makes it worthless to professionals.

22 Upvotes

I own joint copyright to the film Iron Sky and as an independent professional artist you may think I'd be well placed to use AI Video Generators to make further derivatives of my own work - WRONG!

It's now well known AI Gen systems need training data which includes copyrighted works. However, to hide the copyright infringement, especially in the Outputs, the system is designed to avoid "over fitting" (exact replication of training images) and produce "transformative works". However, what if I want a replication of my existing copyrighted works? The 3D models used in the previous film?

If I asked Google's Veo3 AI Video Generator to generate an Iron Sky space craft flying over New York then what I would get would be a "transformative" version that avoids copyright infringement. That is to say if it produced an accurate version of my previous work then that would be copyright infringement because I haven't assigned rights even to the Iron Sky Producers let alone Google to use for a commercial AI system.

This means that the fact the system attempts to avoid making previously copyrighted works, then it is actually useless to me as I would want it to create my previously copyrighted works.

This problem exists for more renowned film makers. Lets say George Lucas wanted to use Google's Veo3 AI Video Generator. Again to avoid copyright infringement, the system would actually try to avoid replicating works such as the Millennium Falcon because such outputs would be copyright infringement and could be created by others as well as George Lucas. None of which have any licensing value either because AI Gens can't produce copyrighted works.

The way around this would be for Google to actually acquire the whole Star Wars franchise but that franchise is valued at billions of dollars which not even Google could afford especially as the resulting output Star Wars Derivative Sequel would also still be an "author-less derivative" and devoid of copyright itself!

Nick Clegg recently said that forcing AI companies to ask for the permission of copyright holders before using their content would destroy the AI industry overnight. But what exactly does that mean if ultimately AI Gen systems are impractical and worthless.

There doesn't appear to be any viable AI Generation industry for the future if the systems can't actually make sequels of existing films which have established billion dollar copyrighted works to build upon and to make derivatives of. On the one hand it would be obvious copyright infringement and also the resulting work couldn't be protected by copyright. On the other hand, to buy the rights to such works to avoid infringement would cost billions and still the outputs have no licensing value.

It's all worthless.


r/COPYRIGHT • • Apr 26 '26

Discussion I don’t see why corporations should be able to have copyright longer than 15 years.

10 Upvotes

Most media doesn’t make a notable profit after fifteen years and if it does it probably made the studio or publisher a a lot of money.

Having a movie studio be able to make a profit for fifteen years seems fair.

Also if someone makes a sequel to a movie after five years then it gets its own fifteen years.

That’s corporations I think that human people creator owned work should be life plus 30 years.

I do see a problem where smaller studios might not be able to turn a profit