r/COPYRIGHT • • 11d ago

Question I copied some code from an open source Github project that was under GPLV3 License with credit and He says i am a thief, am I in the wrong here?

I was working on a tool for a very old game and another person so happened to work on the same thing so i asked him if he wanted to merge but he said he wanted to work on it independently. This was his reply "My tool is open source under GPL-3.0, so you're welcome to use any of my code or findings under that license. Thanks again, and all the best with your project!"

I took that as permission and used his code (Although i hadn't bothered adding any license on my own repo cuz i thought having it public would be enough, i admit that was a fault from my part). That's why i continued developing my tool and only used his tool as a cross reference to check anytime i was stuck and needed help and also copied some parts of his tool to improve mine as well. At most about 5% of my code was from him: some functions, a set of help texts, and four add-on scripts. I also made sure to add him in my credits in my ReadMe with a link to his repo too just in case.

Now he is accusing me of going against the license and stealing his code when GPLv3 clearly allows usage and modification of code. I did immediately make the project GPLv3 added a NOTICE listing every file with his code and apologized but he has continued accusing me of theft and has blocked me and banned me from his server

Was I in the wrong, and is there anything else I should do to make it right?

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

14

u/ozyx7 11d ago edited 11d ago

I took that as permission and used his code (Although i hadn't bothered adding any license on my own repo cuz i thought having it public would be enough, i admit that was a fault from my part).

That was wrong. The GPL explicitly states that derived works must be licensed under the GPL. He even explicitly told you that you could use his work under that license. It was wrong to not use GPLv3 for your derived work.

At most about 5% of my code was from him: some functions, a set of help texts, and four add-on scripts. I also made sure to add him in my credits in my ReadMe with a link to his repo too just in case.

Irrelevant.

Was I in the wrong, and is there anything else I should do to make it right?

You were in the wrong. From his perspective, you tried to take his work and use it without the proper license, and you changed it only when he caught you and called you out on it. You've already corrected the license problem, so there's nothing more you need to do, but you've probably burned that bridge unless you can manage to convince him that it was an unintentional oversight from ignorance. But that probably won't be easy to do after he's blocked you.

-2

u/Unique_Response366 11d ago

Yeah it was a complete oversight from me as this was my first "Big" project on github too. I always assumed that having any project there would mean anyone can take it if i havent licensed it. Thats why when i looked over what GPLv3 does, it mentioned that i needed to have my project open source with credit so i thought i was in the green since i ticked both.

5

u/Party-Cartographer11 11d ago

It's the opposite.  If you don't declare a license you retain all rights.  So you had taken his code and published under your exclusive copyright.

4

u/CBrinson 11d ago

This is a super easy mistake to make as a developer and most people develop in a private repo anyway before publishing with a license. Since the OP did add the GPLv3 at first notification it should be viewed simply as an oversight and not malicious. I wouldn't try to make nice with someone who behaved this way. Be glad they blocked you and continue forward.

People who really steal GPL code don't leave it in a public repo for others to see and take. They hoard the stolen code and hide it inside compiled binaries. I have seen real GPL abusers and this ain't it.

1

u/reybrujo 11d ago

Ignorance is not an excuse. The repository has the whole history and the commits that have been without an explicit GPL3 license could be considered "stolen". Maybe it's too harsh a word but again, are more vibecoders appear this will be more of an issue.

2

u/CBrinson 11d ago edited 11d ago

They don't need an excuse. There are no damages and no harm. There is no real recourse. They don't even need to apologize.

Like if I steal GPL code and use it to make money you can sue me for the money, but there is no harm. This is a non-issue. It's just hurt feelings.

Edit: good old reply and block to make them seem right, but they don't want me to respond because they know they aren't.

3

u/One-Lifeguard-1108 11d ago

And why even hurt feelings? The OP said that no more than 5% of their code came from this other user. That's hardly anything, and barely even noticeable. If you ask me, it's the other user who's being a dick.

-2

u/Party-Cartographer11 11d ago

In what world is the amount of other (janky?) code you have considered when you steal someone else's property?

2

u/CBrinson 11d ago

This is so overboard it is back around to comical.

GPL is all about requiring you to let other people when your source code. The core and spirit of the license essentially books down to anyone can use it as long as they share. OP was following the exact spriit of the license. It is the person mad their code was used by someone else that needs a refresher on the GPL.

2

u/One-Lifeguard-1108 11d ago

This one. Especially when the OP was given permission for its use by the the other user before the other user turned around and accused OP of being a thief. Generally, once you've been given permission, it's not theft. And, yes, amount does matter, certainly when it's 5% or less.

0

u/Party-Cartographer11 11d ago

They were given permission to use it under GPL.  They didn't use it under GPL. Amount of stolen code versus the size of your code base does not matter one bit . What are you talking about?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/bubushkinator 11d ago edited 8d ago

There is real recourse - statutory damages can reach up to $150,000 per infringed work

This is copyright infringement and has heavy penalties in the US

Some examples:

  1. Artifex Software v. Hancom, Inc. (2017)

  2. Entr'Ouvert v. Orange S.A. (France, 2024)

  3. Software Freedom Conservancy (SFC) v. Vizio (Ongoing)

  4. Free Software Foundation v. Cisco Systems (2008)

3

u/tokillawootingbird 11d ago

Show me an example. Can't? Thought so.

The law doesn't work that way.

Not encouraging it or anything but no one is being fined $150k for an oversight that caused no financial damage.

0

u/Party-Cartographer11 11d ago

Profit is not a consideration in Intellectual Property rights.  Authors get to chose how their work is used.  Full stop.

1

u/CBrinson 11d ago

All civil lawsuits are about gain and enrichment. How else would they decide damages?

But there is no real issue here. You are trying to tie this back to ai and keep mentioning vibe coding but it's not the issue. You are just trying to derail the conversation.

1

u/StoneCypher 11d ago

just replace his code, what are you even making a thing about

2

u/tomxp411 11d ago

Your error was in not immediately applying GPL3 before publishing your project. But you corrected it, so that should have been the end of it.

That said - if this guy got this worked up over it, that’s his problem and not yours. There are plenty of high-strung people in the software industry, and you just found one of them.

I’ve dealt with a few, myself, and sometimes the arguments are legendary and the causes truly stupid.

1

u/Unique_Response366 11d ago edited 11d ago

Yeah haha that was completely on me, but still i also thought that his reaction was unnaturally hostile considering how i did make sure to properly credit him everywhere. I also checked the license and it says that as long as i correct it under 30 days after being informed i should be fine, of which i corrected instantly. I feel a little disheartened by how harsh he was haha and not even giving me a chance to appeal when a simple headsup wouldve sufficed

6

u/throwaway275275275 11d ago

He told you you could use the code "under that license", meaning you have to comply with that license, so you should check what that requires. The main thing will be to make the rest of your code GPL, that's the requirement of the license

4

u/frankster 11d ago

You distributed his code to people without it being under gpl3 licence. This is obviously a licence violation . Of course you are in the wrong.

Respect the licence next time.

3

u/itsdan159 11d ago

GPL3 is a 'copyleft' license such that your project should have been under the same license from the start, but if you've made an effort to fix things are are now acting in good faith I certainly wouldn't worry about the ethical implications. Learn from the mistake and move on, and likely that person has a particular view of you and won't want to work with you.

2

u/taisui 11d ago

 is there anything else I should do to make it right?

You attach the GPLV3 license to your code, easy.

1

u/FarmboyJustice 11d ago

OP already did that. They are asking if there's anything ELSE they can do.

1

u/taisui 11d ago

It's a mistake that's been corrected, move on with life

1

u/FarmboyJustice 11d ago

Sorry, I simply pointed out that you didn't even read the OP before commenting.

1

u/taisui 11d ago edited 11d ago

"Either ignore him and let it go or if you really care, get a lawyer to send a cease-and-desist notice to him."

I AM SO SORRY FOR NOT READING

1

u/FarmboyJustice 11d ago

As well you should be. Responding to things without reading them is a sign of a lazy intellect. You should do better.

2

u/FarmboyJustice 11d ago

You corrected the mistake as soon as you were notified of it, and you apologized. Publicly apologizing and explaining that you simply did not understand your responsibility at first is all you can do and all you should do.

Being banned/blocked is because you pissed him off by breaking the rules. If he won't accept your apology then he's just being emotional.

However, if he continues to accuse you of violating the license after you have already corrected the problem, then he's a jackass. State your case, explain that you already corrected the issue, and if he continues to make such claims after you have already corrected the problem, then he's just trying to harm your reputation.

Either ignore him and let it go or if you really care, get a lawyer to send a cease-and-desist notice to him.