r/COPYRIGHT • • 13h ago

Discussion Update from the Maine Movie Pirate: Game on.

0 Upvotes

You know, I’ve been posting here for almost two years since I got out of prison, and I've made a lot of good friends (just kidding—but I still love you guys: Trevi, DaNorder, and all you faithful downvoters).

Since my appeals are exhausted (mostly—there’s one more, but that is a story for another day), let's set the record straight: my case was never about guilt or innocence. It was about a broken system. I copied the movies; I never denied that. I did it because I believed—and still believe—it falls under the Fair Use of Orphan Works.

With my case, that legal question has finally been answered. In the First Circuit ONLY. Everywhere else in the country, it remains unsettled law.

So, game on. I’m picking the Prison Journal back up tomorrow, and I’ll keep pushing my message and calling out bad copyright law for as long as it takes—or until I die first. Please continue to debate and challenge me. Frankly, I love it.


r/COPYRIGHT • • 1d ago

Do small TikTok Shop sellers actually get licenses for anime merch?

0 Upvotes

I’m thinking about selling anime graphic tees and wall tapestries on TikTok Shop US, but I’m confused about how licensing works in practice.

Say I make my own version of a design featuring a recognizable character like Gojo or Luffy, without using the official logo. Can I sell it without a license, or do I still need permission because it’s an existing character? Does TikTok Shop actually ask for proof before letting you list it?

The other thing I’m wondering about is the shops already doing this. I’ve seen the same shop sell shirts from Dragon Ball, Chainsaw Man, and Black Clover, with some designs showing thousands of sales. Are those shops usually getting separate licenses, buying from licensed suppliers, or are some just selling without permission? Is there any reliable way for a buyer to tell?

If you’ve actually sold this kind of merch on TikTok Shop US, I’d be interested to hear how you sourced it and what paperwork, if any, the platform asked you for. I’m trying to figure this out before I pay for a print run.


r/COPYRIGHT • • 2d ago

Discussion what do u think about this?(2)

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/COPYRIGHT • • 2d ago

Discussion YouTube Copyright Land of Happiness

2 Upvotes

A very tongue in cheek analysis of YouTube's copyright process.

She found a couple of "rules" that I was not aware of.

The TL;DR version: some Creators hide borderline stuff in Patreon, I guess it's paywall and lack of a search index make it difficult to scan by both manual and automated processes. Personally I think Patreon is a shady business model, people should make new and original content instead.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-VbNr9Qg92Y


r/COPYRIGHT • • 2d ago

Cross stitch Album covers

0 Upvotes

Hello!!

Would greatly appreciate any and all advice on this!

I've been thinking about making and selling cross stitch needle point artworks of my favourite album covers/costum requests (maybe even selling pdf patterns although I think this might be more difficult CR wise), combining two of my biggest passions. Since the embroidery part means converting the medium I thought maybe this might be possible without needing to ask for permission?

And if it turns out I do need permission, how would I go about this?

Also does anybody know of a website/database of album covers that are considered public domain so I'd be free to sell art based on it?

Thanks so much in advance <3


r/COPYRIGHT • • 2d ago

Question Received an "Image License Enquiry" email from Press Association asking me to pay £6,016.25

3 Upvotes

I run a blog where I had used some copyright images around 7 years ago and now I have received this email from PA asking me to pay the said amount. I have removed the images but the amount they are asking me is too much. I have adsense on my blog and it barely makes $100 a month. What should I do in this case? Also I have been a digital nomad for the last decade, so the country where I started the blog is not where I am residing currently. If I just take down the images and not pay the amount, how would they come after me?


r/COPYRIGHT • • 2d ago

Question How can I find out if a comic book is still in copyright?

0 Upvotes

I'm looking at a US comic from 1947 which I believe is now in the public domain. How can I make sure?


r/COPYRIGHT • • 3d ago

The End of Software Copyright. Posted: 11 Nov 2026 Mark A. Lemley. Stanford Law School. Date Written: October 29, 2026.

Thumbnail papers.ssrn.com
41 Upvotes

Abstract

The vast majority of coders and software companies today use AI-generated code or employ programmers who do; surveys suggest that nearly 90% of coders are using AI tools like Claude Code or Codex to write their software.

That code is uncopyrightable regardless of how it is made. There are three possibilities: 

First, the AI tool may replicate someone else’s proprietary code from its training data set. And if portions of their code are infringing, the law denies the user copyright protection even for the parts that are original that are intermingled with the infringing code.

Second, the AI tool may replicate open source code from its training data set. The viral nature of most open source licenses means that the user who incorporates that code, even unwittingly, has agreed to open their code in turn to copying by others.

Third, the AI tool may generate its own code. But AI-generated code is uncopyrightable.

In none of those cases is software copyrightable. The end of software copyright is nigh. Indeed, it may be here already. That doesn’t mean the end of the software industry, and probably not even the end of proprietary software. The industry may muddle through, and it may persuade Congress to change the law. But whatever future comes, the law of copyright and the software industry it underlies will never be the same. 


r/COPYRIGHT • • 2d ago

Question Why has this channel not been copyrighted, and how can I stay safe?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

CraftTasticMedia is a YouTube channel that posts animations that include popular video game characters like Baldi, Piggy, Sonic, etc. and their vids has not been taken down. In video descriptions, it has this: "EDSA Exception Warning. This content is a Satire animation of popular games and characters made while parodying the popular game Minecraft. It falls within the EDSA exception outlined by YouTube for its Artistic nature. It is completely safe to view for all ages to be enjoyed by everyone." and "DISCLAIMER: This is a parody or spoof. All characters are property of its actual owners. We claim no rights to the characters in this parody series and hope you enjoy."

What is this channel not doing to keep the videos safe from being taken down or sued? I want to do something similar


r/COPYRIGHT • • 4d ago

Pokémon Fan Complains After Spending Thousands on AI Game Tools, Only For Anthropic to Finally Begin Crackdown

Thumbnail
ign.com
24 Upvotes

The great dumbening era that AI promised is well and truly upon us


r/COPYRIGHT • • 3d ago

Trademark advice

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

I’m looking to get a trademark for a software I’m developing.

However 2 people own the trademark, one is a platform that is niche and the other took it as a broad topic but when you go on their website they are in one specific industry.

My question is if I file for a trademark that is niche to my industry would it get denied because this person was to generic?

Fake example (both real trademarks are filed under class 042, mine would be the same):

Sell soft : providing a fake software for selling items

Sell soft: fake software offering a catalogue of cakes to be sold for vendors

Sell soft (mine): sell software for vendors to sell cars

Mine is niche not generic but holds the same name as the already trademarked names, would I not get the trademark or get infringed?


r/COPYRIGHT • • 3d ago

Why can this youtuber in this video https://youtu.be/hjh38gfXRlE?si=gq8lTjv7sgPp8yE3 use the song Wind at 19:07 seconds even though he has no copyright. I also want to mention that this is not the original version of the song he uses in the video https://youtu.be/oNDvzs8Ruxc?si=aZsbnNlN-0Oi5r_k

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/COPYRIGHT • • 3d ago

Question what do u think about this?

0 Upvotes

Could I legally release a song commercially if I recreate a free-tier Suno track entirely from scratch?

I have a question about Suno's free-tier licensing and commercial release.
I recently generated a track using Suno's free plan, and I absolutely love it. Unfortunately, I understand that songs generated under the free plan are generally restricted to non-commercial use.
So I came up with a possible workaround, and I'd love to hear your thoughts, especially from musicians, producers, and people familiar with copyright law.
Here's my idea:
I memorize the entire Suno-generated track.
I open my DAW and recreate everything from scratch.
I personally record every instrument and all vocals.
I write completely new lyrics (100% original).
I make some changes to the drum patterns, basslines, and other musical elements.
I handle all the mixing and mastering myself.
I release the resulting recording commercially.
In other words, I would never use the original Suno audio file, stems, or generated vocals in the final release. Everything would be recorded and produced by me.
However, the composition would still be inspired by the original Suno track, and some musical elements might remain recognizable.
My questions are:
Would this still violate Suno's free-tier Terms of Service?
Could this potentially constitute copyright infringement or an unauthorized derivative work?
Does independently re-recording everything make any meaningful legal difference?
Would memorizing a generated song and recreating it from memory change anything legally?
Has anyone dealt with a similar situation or received clarification from Suno?
I'm not looking for ways to evade copyright detection. I genuinely want to understand whether there's a legitimate way to turn a song I love into a commercially releasable recording without violating anyone's rights.
I'd appreciate perspectives from people around the world, particularly those with experience in music production, copyright law, or AI-generated music.
Thanks!


r/COPYRIGHT • • 4d ago

Question Book summary video series split into parts?

2 Upvotes

One of the TV Shows I cover on my channel also has several canon books, so I thought it'd be a good idea to do (monetised) summary videos going over and briefly discussing everything that happens in them, splitting them into parts and doing maybe a few chapters per vid. (Because multiple smaller vids are easier to promote and get out than one huge one)

99% certain this is completely fine, as while Copyright covers a lot of ridiculous corners...you can't copyright someone just...talking about what happens in your content (right?), but it's always better to ask, you know?


r/COPYRIGHT • • 4d ago

TikTok keeps rejecting our AI-made short drama for “missing core rights materials”. What document actually proves ownership?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

We’re a small team publishing a vertical short drama series on TikTok’s short drama program. Every episode keeps getting rejected, and support only replies “core materials are required” with a link to their rules page, which we had already read.

The situation:

  • We made the series ourselves using AI tools (script, visuals, voices). There is no outside production company and no licensed IP.

  • TikTok’s guidelines list two types of “core materials” to prove you own the rights:

    1. A production or co-production agreement naming the rights holder and the title

    2. A copyright registration certificate listing the work as an audiovisual work, with the signing entity as the copyright owner

  • We submitted a rights declaration (based on their template), but it was still rejected.

Our questions:

  1. When there is no production company, what document can actually prove ownership? Is a self-signed rights declaration from our own company enough?

  2. Does a copyright registration make sense for an AI-generated work, given the US Copyright Office’s position on AI authorship? Is there a country or registry where this is realistic for a non-Chinese company?

  3. Has anyone here gotten an AI or self-produced drama approved on TikTok or a similar platform (ReelShort, DramaBox…)? What exactly did you submit?

We’re not trying to cut corners. If something is wrong, we’ll fix or remove it. We just need to know what is actually expected.

Thanks a lot for any help!


r/COPYRIGHT • • 5d ago

Question Character copyright

2 Upvotes

Hi I uh looked around and I saw about some people asking this question but I wanted to ask a further couple ones.

I have a series or two that I'm working on and have been for a while! The script is around like 400 pages long idk if that's useful to know and I would like to make videos relating to my series yk to build up an audience.

I guess I'm just worried that people might steal my characters. But I saw some people mention that it's hard to copyright characters. I do have like what I could say is a character bible of sorts. Like with his initial designs and a whole lot of backstory and his personality and how it affects his decisions and his character you know the whole thing.

Is that enough for a character bible/to be copyrighted? And before I do upload videos, should I try get him copyrighted? Or do I try and get the series as a whole? Am I just over thinking things?

Sorry if this is long winded I just want to get things right :D


r/COPYRIGHT • • 4d ago

How to use a bunch of clips from someone else's channel without getting a copyright strike?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/COPYRIGHT • • 5d ago

how do you know when someone has decided NOT to sue you for copyright infringement after threatening that they would?

2 Upvotes

Is this nightmare over? That's what I'm trying to find out.

Many months ago, I got the infamous letter from Higbee & Associates. I read all their threats carefully, and then researched, found and followed advice I found on Reddit about them, like this one. I took the offending photos down (there were two) and didn't respond to these people/this person until I got an email with an attached letter from them that renewed all the threats, but also said if I am a non-commercial entity (I'm a non-commercial entity - totally!!) , to let them know, "as you are probably receiving this letter in error." And then it said "we define commercial entities as any individual or entity that derives or attempts to derive revenue through selling advertising, promoting or selling goods or services, or soliciting donations." They said if they didn't hear back in response to the letter in 14 days, that they would consider that to mean I didn't have a license and that I didn't want to "settle this matter out of court" (by paying them several thousand dollars).

My blog isn't a business. It's just goofy personal observations. The only people I give the address to are family and friends (but yeah, sure, I guess someone could find it). It has maybe one reader a week (prolly a bot). My friends and even my family don't even read it - and it's a personal blog I thought I was writing for them! So I wrote them all this to this person/these people.

That was a month ago. The 14-day deadline is long over. I've heard nothing in more than two months.

Is this over? When do I know this is over?


r/COPYRIGHT • • 5d ago

Question regarding commissioning art using designs from an IP you are not associated with in anyway

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/COPYRIGHT • • 5d ago

Question Is a prom invite copyrighted?

0 Upvotes

A group doing a fundraiser for a non-profit wants to use an online image of a prom invite as their promo image. How can we determine copyright and keep ethics clear?


r/COPYRIGHT • • 5d ago

Who is responsible when Ai breaks the law?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/COPYRIGHT • • 6d ago

International comity does not apply to baseline copyright authorship/ownership.

0 Upvotes

Let me get this out there for anyone who might face the same situation as myself.

Comity is essentially a treaty violation when invoked against the issue of initial authorship/ownership of copyright. This is because of the Berne Convention Article 5(2) No formalities rule. The no formalities rule is entirely practical because there is no temporal gap between fixation of a work in to a tangible media and the point of attachment of copyright to the author. Thus, no place for comity (a future foreign ruling) to fit into that automatic protection criteria.

The enjoyment and the exercise of these rights shall not be subject to any formality; such enjoyment and such exercise shall be independent of the existence of protection in the country of origin of the work. Consequently, apart from the provisions of this Convention, the extent of protection, as well as the means of redress afforded to the author to protect his rights, shall be governed exclusively by the laws of the country where protection is claimed.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/treaties/berne/5.html


r/COPYRIGHT • • 6d ago

AI Account Rips Off Animated Short To Promote Filmmaking Classes

Thumbnail
cartoonbrew.com
0 Upvotes

AI Account Rips Off Award-Winning 2008 Short ‘El Empleo’ To Promote $49-A-Month ‘Filmmaking’ Classes (EXCLUSIVE)

By Jamie Lang


r/COPYRIGHT • • 6d ago

Question Copyright Advice for Youtube

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm sure I'm like the 90th person to talk about this. But I want to start a youtube channel where for each video have a segment for a song of the day where I play a snippet of a song (ranging from million dollar bands/artists to indie less then 10k streams songs) and then let it continue for a little awhile much quieter while I discuss the song before my actual stuff begins. What should I know or what to avoid when doing something like this. Anything helps please and thank you!
If anybody cares it'll be me playing a game I enjoy and while I wait for the queue to wrap up I'll talk about the song and after while I play the game just shoot the shit talk about whatever is current.