r/AskLiteraryStudies • u/ecstatic-tyson-4338 • 1h ago
How can a signifier be determinate or particular if the symbolic order is differential?
Hopefully the question is obvious:
It makes no sense to say that the word "man", for example, gains its identity through its relation to words like "woman", "father", and "boy", because this would not distinguish the word from "woman" which is related to "man", "mother", and "girl". Both sets of words are functionally identical if they're equally determined by differential relations; there would be nothing to distinguish one word from another because what all words have in common is a set of differential relations.
Let's say the word "man" is "positioned" in some way that it enjoys a certain relationship to "father", a certain relationship to "woman", etc. This just pushes the problem into what we mean by "positioned". Now we have a set of particular or determinate positions or relations, and we still have the question of where this particularity or determinateness is introduced. In fact, I think there's a tendency to use words like "position" and "relation" without clearly explaining how these "positions" are to be distinguished from the signifiers that occupy them, as if there were a bunch of empty slots for words to slide into.
Nor do I think it addresses the question to say "meaning is always deferred and never guaranteed". For it might be true that we can never adequately account for a word, but my problem isn't even about adequacy or pinning something down. It's about the basic fact that each word is clearly not identical with every other word, which differential relations are incapable of accounting for in any way whatsoever. Basically, the problem becomes "what is the description of differential relations accounting for or doing?" why do we use this word "differential"? what question is it answering? what is it doing for us?
Finally, I don't think it makes sense to say in some vague pop-Lacanian way (this is how i often see it presented, although i don't think this is necessarily an indictment of the Lacanian clinic as a practice) that "more radically than saussure, we can prioritize the signifier and sliding of meaning without fixing it to signifieds" AND ALSO SAY "this takes place in a given set of kinship relations or cultural institutions or whathaveyou", because this latter group of words (kinship relations, cultural institutions, history, whatever else you want to insert here) is just smuggling back in the same "signifieds" or "objective references" or "world of objects" you just said a second ago are not how we're going to understand signifiers.
I've been in analysis for nearly 3 years and I'm still completely perplexed by the basic concept of a "signifier", which should be the simplest term in Lacanian theory and the basis for everything else. So I'm effectively at level 0 after three years. So...?