r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 1h ago

How can a signifier be determinate or particular if the symbolic order is differential?

2 Upvotes

Hopefully the question is obvious:
It makes no sense to say that the word "man", for example, gains its identity through its relation to words like "woman", "father", and "boy", because this would not distinguish the word from "woman" which is related to "man", "mother", and "girl". Both sets of words are functionally identical if they're equally determined by differential relations; there would be nothing to distinguish one word from another because what all words have in common is a set of differential relations.

Let's say the word "man" is "positioned" in some way that it enjoys a certain relationship to "father", a certain relationship to "woman", etc. This just pushes the problem into what we mean by "positioned". Now we have a set of particular or determinate positions or relations, and we still have the question of where this particularity or determinateness is introduced. In fact, I think there's a tendency to use words like "position" and "relation" without clearly explaining how these "positions" are to be distinguished from the signifiers that occupy them, as if there were a bunch of empty slots for words to slide into.

Nor do I think it addresses the question to say "meaning is always deferred and never guaranteed". For it might be true that we can never adequately account for a word, but my problem isn't even about adequacy or pinning something down. It's about the basic fact that each word is clearly not identical with every other word, which differential relations are incapable of accounting for in any way whatsoever. Basically, the problem becomes "what is the description of differential relations accounting for or doing?" why do we use this word "differential"? what question is it answering? what is it doing for us?

Finally, I don't think it makes sense to say in some vague pop-Lacanian way (this is how i often see it presented, although i don't think this is necessarily an indictment of the Lacanian clinic as a practice) that "more radically than saussure, we can prioritize the signifier and sliding of meaning without fixing it to signifieds" AND ALSO SAY "this takes place in a given set of kinship relations or cultural institutions or whathaveyou", because this latter group of words (kinship relations, cultural institutions, history, whatever else you want to insert here) is just smuggling back in the same "signifieds" or "objective references" or "world of objects" you just said a second ago are not how we're going to understand signifiers.

I've been in analysis for nearly 3 years and I'm still completely perplexed by the basic concept of a "signifier", which should be the simplest term in Lacanian theory and the basis for everything else. So I'm effectively at level 0 after three years. So...?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 16h ago

Ambiguous ages in texts

4 Upvotes

I've read quite a few experimental texts where the protagonist's gender is unclear and thus a topic of discussion amongst readers (e.g. Jeanette Winterson's Written on the Body, Woolf's Orlando,...).

I'm interested in ageing studies and temporarilies, and just had a thought that there must be a book where the age of a character is undefined — they could be a child, could be an adult, could be an old person, maybe they have dementia, who knows?

Does anyone know a text that plays with the concept of age in that way?

Otherwise someone pleaaase write one, I'm sure it'd be very interesting!


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 1d ago

What are some pieces of clothing that give insight into a characters inner world?

2 Upvotes

The only ones that come to mind are the hunting cap in A Confederacy of Dunces and A Catcher in the Rye. What are some other great depictions of clothing used to show the inner world of characters in literature--preferably ones chosen by the character and not enforced upon the character through society.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 2d ago

How to analyze a book?

9 Upvotes

I’m starting to read and I love it, but I don’t exactly know how to analyze books, I’ve spent my whole life watching movies, and although I love cinema, I don’t even know how to analyze cinema that well either

How to analyze a book completely and write a quality analysis about it?

I created a book club and would like to aggregate authentically instead of just reading other ready-made reviews


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 2d ago

Please recommend me a short story featuring colonial Discourse and Postcolonialism

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 2d ago

The Bed Trick in modern adaptations…problematic??

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 4d ago

Launching point after a decades’ long hiatus

2 Upvotes

I have an English degree and have spent my career practicing law. I want to return to serious literary study independently. Will you recommend a published close reading of a short story or poem that makes the critic’s reasoning visible, so I can read the original alongside the analysis and learn how to do it myself?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 4d ago

The Harlem Renaissance and Marxism

4 Upvotes

Hello all,

I am brainstorming in writing my masters thesis about the Harlem renaissance analyzed through the Marxist lense. Still don’t have the specifics figured out. I was hoping some reading recommendations could be given. I know during this time, a lot of black Americans were influenced by the USSR and were finding comfort in becoming communist. So there’s a lot to work with here concerning radical writings. Im hoping to talk about how the productive forces influenced the proletarian culture / ideas. As of now I’m thinking of using the following texts:

Native son
Invisible man
Their eyes were watching god

And some Langston poetry.

Again, I’m still in the brainstorming stage so any thoughts would be great :D


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 4d ago

Question about a statement of Beckett's on literary form

31 Upvotes

I'm a ridiculous Beckett fan. Have read every one of his works, in English, that is.

Anyway, I just came across an interview that he did with the NYT, in '56. At one point he is asked about the works of Kafka. He says the following:

"You notice how Kafka's form is classic, it goes on like a steamroller-almost serene. It seems to be threatened the whole time-but the consternation is in the form. In my work there is consternation behind the form, not in the form."

For some reason I can't understand what he's saying in its totality. I think I understand what he means when he speaks of his own form. And I think I understand what he means by Kafka's form being "serene". But this seems to me to be contradicted by his saying that consternation is "in the form" in Kafka. If the consternation was contained within the form, then wouldn't the form not be serene? Perhaps I merely have an inexact notion of what Beckett means when he says "in the form" and "behind the form".

Could anybody clarify what Beckett meant here? Or point to some piece of scholarship which might also clear things up and exand on what Beckett is talking about here? Thank you.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 6d ago

Earth/ground metaphors

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 6d ago

Is it even considered my analysis?

17 Upvotes

So if I'm reading a book and want to analyze it, but I see many videos on the internet that might influence how I interpret the book and how I analyze it, is the analysis considered mine in that case or did I just collect what other people think and use it?

And how do you analyze a book anyway? What should I look at and pay attention to?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 7d ago

Quote definition from Oxford English Dictionary?

1 Upvotes

For a term paper, I'd like to discuss the common definition of a term I'm writing about, before delving into the historical and cultural usage of it as well as its connotations. Would it be sufficient to quote from the Oxford English dictionary or are there other sources you would recommend?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 7d ago

Have Palestinian writers or philosophers explored the nature of evil through their experiences and testimonies?

24 Upvotes

I’ve recently been reading Goethe’s Faust, particularly his portrayal of Mephistopheles and the philosophical exploration of evil and human nature. This has led me to wonder whether Palestinian writers, philosophers, poets, or intellectuals, particularly those who have experienced or witnessed the genocide in Gaza, have written about the nature of evil through their own experiences, historical understanding, and political observations.

I’m interested in how their encounters with such violence might inform their understanding of evil. how it manifests in human beings, how it is justified, how it becomes normalized, and what it reveals about morality, human nature, and the societies in which it takes place.

Are there Palestinian writers whose work explores these questions, whether directly or indirectly? I would appreciate recommendations in either Arabic or English, including works that haven’t received much international attention.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 7d ago

Void/Uncrossable expression literature

12 Upvotes

I have spent the last several years moving through authors that touch upon a certain kind of looking at the void in language, about the impossibility of expression. I've got a dozen authors in the rearview mirror, people like Kafka, Lispector, Beckett, Pizarnik, Pessoa. People that in some way or another talk about the void either that is felt personal, or that they find when they want to go further in language than is probably possible. I've painstakingly dragged myself through a lot of Blanchot. I'm working on beginning to study Mallarme, and I've expanded outward to people like Rothko, Munch. And I've been trying to tie some sort of thread into mountaineering.

The thrust of the interest and what I'd love to hear any thoughts, advice, or recommendations about, is a seeming stage within artistic expression when certain artists reach a relationship with their medium that could be described as, continuing to work only in preparation for the impossible task. Blanchot talks about the book to come, Mallarme talks about "The book", mountain climbers talk about the mountain within. There is a seeming progression where an artistic relationship begins with external achievements, the desire for acceptance by the art or community in some way, where the achievements are still rewarding, and then after that there is a living relationship where each next challenge is viewed more and more as tools and explorations that add to their ability to express themselves or open up new possibilities, and then at some certain point, these artists become oriented towards something far beyond, where the reward is an intangible impossible, book that expresses everything that can be expressed, or that delivers beauty from a Mount Olympus to the hands of the artist.

I've studied the works of Ernest Becker, Joseph Campbell, Eugene Gendlin, and an unpleasant amount of trauma psych writers, trying to sort of see where that orientation comes from or what it signals or means, what it does to the artists who become absorbed in a near totalizing way with that portion of their life or aims. Anything that you might have to offer up that I should look towards would be helpful, thank you so much.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 7d ago

Some of your favourite scholars working on the Victorian era?

7 Upvotes

Looking to read more broadly and constructively at the start of my PhD. I would love to hear any recommendations for your favourite scholars working broadly in the Victorian period.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 8d ago

Bridging the gap between Greek and Roman Literature: 320 BC - 240 BC

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 8d ago

when, how and why did dialogue tags migrate from before to after or inside the dialogue?

3 Upvotes

in "old literature" like canterbury tales and the king james bible dialogue tags come before the dialogue the character is saying

>and the LORD said let there be light

but these days the dialogue tag comes after

>He should have been a great philosopher, said Mrs. Ramsay

in conventional speech usually dialogue tags come before the dialogue, so it seems less artificial, is the reason for the change to immitate the way scripts are read? usually you don't "read" (read as in mentally speak, you use the "Character :" as punctuation) the tags in scripts, so the sentence's focus (first phrase) is on the dialogue, and this is the same for tag-final-style. but the focus doesn't matter as dialogue tag position usually doesn't vary within the text. is it just to be more immediate?

are there any works written during when this change took place? did anyone comment about it at the time? do other cultures have different conventions for writing dialogue?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 8d ago

BA English Literature: Dissertation advice

4 Upvotes

I am back to square one with my dissertation - I have no chosen texts, no chosen theory/ research angle, no chosen thesis etc. I am truly struggling to pinpoint anything to be interested in and am finding it all super daunting. I am back to square one mainly because the concepts suggested by my old supervisor and my new supervisor (changeover due to staff leaving) felt/feel forced. Every time I have tried to talk about what it is I wanted to write about it has been moulded into what the lecturer wants me to talk about.

When I first came to dissertation writing my basis of ideas/ interests were:

- moral and religious contentions/ shame

- female rage/ anger

- mental illness in literature (basically just any expression of the pysche)

- the female experience as a whole (interest in motherhood/ the body/ mental health/ self expression etc)

For context, in case it helps anyone with recommendations or advice, texts I've loved in the past were:

- Beloved, Toni Morrison

- The Yellow Wallpaper, Charlotte Perkins Gilman

- The Picture of Dorian Gray, Oscar Wilde

I feel like it seems like I have loads of ideas to spin off of but I just feel really truly stuck.
I had really hoped that I could get some advice on forming dissertation ideas, even if its just books that really inspired people or sort of "lit that creative fire" for lack of better description.

So any help at all would be really appreciated, whether it's general dissertation advice, specific recommendations, ideas for how to turn my interests into enough to write 10,000 words on etc.

Thanks in advance :)


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 8d ago

Hello!

4 Upvotes

I would love to deep dive into the very best examples of literary memoir, fictionalized memoir, autobiographical fiction, and similar. What works of this flavor would you recommend?

My own reading tends toward very dry non-fiction or Margaret Atwood, Barbara Kingsolver, contemporary poetry, so I’m not terribly familiar with memoir. Would love any suggestions!

Thanks!


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 9d ago

POV/Narratorial Consciousness in Philip Roth's "American Pastoral"

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 9d ago

How to deal with not being able to think beyond the surface level without being provided with secondary sources?

55 Upvotes

Yes, I am aware that this question has been asked countless times but I assume not always by a final year literature undergrad who is aspiring to be an academic. I know not everyone is supposed to be a genius, or an academic. But I have spent my entire life thinking I want to spend the rest of it dedicated to the study of literature. And even though the world hates the humanities and most academics simply make each other's lives harder, I love the things literature academics do. If I could even be a mediocre academic, that would be enough and with the major I have and in the country I live in, my career options are limited anyhow. Yet I simply cannot think deeply about the books I read without someone (a professor, a peer, or an article) formulating potential deeper thematic, social, symbolic connections or any other hermeneutic/philosophical/political/intertextual etc. readings. When things are set forth in front of me, I can think critically and bring together theoretical readings, but on my own I feel so stupid. When I am reading or watching something, I am mostly immersed in the story itself to be a critical reader unless it's so obvious that even someone who is checking Instagram at the same time can notice. I don't think I can't think theoretically or abstractly. I love philosophy and I love literary theory. I am just terrible at actually starting a reading without other people going deep beneath the surface first. I apologise if this sounds like a rant or something I should tell a therapist, or if the answer is simply "listen, just try your best, not everyone is supposed to be a superstar", but I am writing this embarrassing post in case someone shows up with a method that might be helpful to me. Thank you.

Edit: I don't want to sound corny but I really appreciate you caring enough to share your comments and advises.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 9d ago

Advice on Bachelor’s Thesis

2 Upvotes

Hello, i will be writing my bachelor’s thesis this year and I could not decide which literary text I will work on. I am an American studies major and the main text has to be an American work as well. I am specifically interested in psychological theories (psychoanalysis to be exact) applied in literature like Freud’s or Lacan’s. Modernist works thus will do best but the ones we covered in class cannot be chosen naturally, and i need some ideas as to what i can choose.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 10d ago

Looking for books or papers about the low perception of literature written by women (or to women)

6 Upvotes

I'm writing my undergrad thesis on fanfiction and I'm looking for scholarly sources about the low brow perception on women's literature!

Additionaly (but not the point), something on the construction of gender that is not Butler


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 11d ago

I’m struggling to understand what this passage from “The Beast in the Jungle” is even trying to say?

4 Upvotes

“She took his gaiety from him—since it had to pass with them for gaiety—as she took everything else; but she certainly so far justified by her unerring touch his finer sense of the degree to which he had ended by convincing her.”

I had to google it and the A.I overview didn’t help me at all because it just broke down the parts that already made sense to me.

My interpretation (which was similar to what the A.I overview said too) of the part of the passage that says “She took his gaiety from him—since it had to pass with them for gaiety—as she took everything else; but she certainly so far justified by her unerring touch” is something like:

“She [placed under her own possession] his [cheerful mood], [or, at least the particular mood of his with which they had come to the unspoken agreement to choose to view as a “form” of cheerfulness]; [in the same manner in which she had already placed everything else of his, under her own possession]. [But this action was justified (from his point of view) by the very fact that she had done so perfectly, and without error.]”

But what I don’t understand (and what the A.I overview didn’t even make an attempt at making sense of) was the part that I was actually struggling to understand:

“his finer sense of the degree to which he had ended by convincing her”

What on earth is this part of this passage even trying to say??? It just really reads to me like… borderline-gibberish???


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • 12d ago

Thoughts on different translations of In Search of Lost Time?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes