r/AskLiteraryStudies • • May 28 '26

Why do almost all literature lectures spend an insane amount of time just retelling the plot?

2 Upvotes

TGC (The Great Courses) is particularly guilty of this. I recently listened to their lecture on Euripides's Alcestis, and it took the lecturer nearly 20 minutes out of a 30-minute runtime just to recount the plot.
Most of the university lectures I've seen have this problem too.

I think it is a horrible practice.

First of all, this only appeals to people who are not serious about learning and haven't read the literature in question. And those people wouldn't get much from a lecture on it anyway: you can't learn math without solving math problems, and you can't learn literature without reading (or at least listening to) the works themselves.
It is even a bit malicious: just by being a highly credentialed person who gives such a lecture—a lecture that assumes an audience of people who haven't read the book—they make people feel like they are getting a quality education while putting in zero effort. It wastes a genuine impulse to learn by channeling it the wrong way, the lazy way.

Second, isn't it a complete waste of the expert's time? If a professor has, say, an hour to spend with an audience, wouldn't it be better for everyone if they utilized their expertise instead of retelling the stories, which literally anyone who has read them can do? Why take time from their research for this? It's like forcing Nvidia engineers to mop the floor for half of their shift.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Sep 29 '18

Do you think anglophone literature is overrated in general?

0 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • May 17 '18

What is the point of publishing a work of literature if the author's intended meaning is not regarded as the true meaning of the work, and reader interpreted "meanings" that are contrary to the intended meaning are treated as equally right?

0 Upvotes

I love writing, it's my passion and the center of my life. I write for myself, not only because I enjoy the act of authoring, but because I'm extremely dissatisfied contemporary literature, and have long had a difficult time finding fiction in English from the last few decades that I enjoyed reading, that was not only topically interesting but spoke to my values and engaged my ideas, so I decided to write literature (as of today, 14 short stories, 3 dramas and so-far the first third of a novel, all in verse) that I wanted to read. I gave a professor of mine 1 of my dramas and 4 of my short stories to read, and he suggested that I submit some of my work to a publisher.

Part of me wants to, but another part of me is considering the question what is the point of publishing my work? (aside from the money that I could make). Ideally, my reason for publishing would be that I have something to say/a message to convey and I want to share it, but I wonder if literature is the appropriate medium for making a statement, since it seems that so many people think that the author's intent is irrelevant, and that it's valid to interpret the work to be saying something other than that. In all of my work I try I convey a message, but if my intended message is meaningless then what's the point of conveying a message at all? A perfect example of this is how Fahrenheit 451 is widely interpreted to be about and opposed to censorship, Ray Bradbury has repeatedly said that it isn't that, and that he was trying to convey his anti-television sentiment. For me, that means that meaning of the book is that, end of story, and that for anyone to say that it isn't is akin to someone telling me about landscape architecture or their new pair of ice skates and me replying that I've interpreted what they've said to be about tea being better than coffee, and saying that I'm no less correct than they are because their intent is meaningless — it seems that their saying anything at all was pointless.

That's not say that what a work means for a reader, in the sense of feelings or inspiration they get from the text isn't an entirely personal and interpretive thing. It's that, in my view the work has a fixed meaning, it means whatever the author intended it to mean, and it's only the personal meaning that a reader derives from a text that is subject to interpretation.

If I do decide to send my work to a publisher, and if they choose to publish my work, I'd like to add a preface to each explaining what the piece means. If not, and other people who didn't write the piece feel empowered to attach a meaning to my work that wasn't my meaning, what's the point?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • May 31 '26

Why is "The Death of the Author" still taken seriously?

57 Upvotes

As someone trained in the Hispanic literary tradition, I've always been surprised by how often Roland Barthes' "The Death of the Author" is still invoked in online literary discussions, sometimes almost as if it were an established fact rather than a controversial theoretical position.

Part of my perspective comes from being familiar with the work of Spanish literary theorist Jesús G. Maestro. Outside the Spanish-speaking world he is not particularly well known, but one of his recurring arguments is that theories such as Barthes' "Death of the Author" or Foucault's concept of the "author function" ultimately underestimate the role of real historical individuals in the production of literature.

I should say that I don't necessarily agree with Maestro on everything. In fact, one reason I find his critique interesting is that many of the problems he identifies seem fairly obvious to me.

The "Death of the Author" appears somewhat plausible when discussing average writers whose works largely reflect the assumptions and values of their time. But what happens when we look at extraordinary figures such as Miguel de Cervantes?

Cervantes was not simply a passive expression of early modern Spanish society. He challenged assumptions that were dominant in his own age and opened intellectual possibilities that later generations would continue to develop. It is impossible to reduce him to a mere "function" of historical or social forces.

This is particularly interesting when we consider intellectual history beyond literature. We know that Baruch Spinoza owned and read works by Cervantes. Whatever one makes of the precise nature of that influence, it is at least clear that Cervantes was part of the intellectual environment that Spinoza engaged with.

And Spinoza himself is not a marginal figure. His philosophy is widely regarded as one of the foundational pillars of modern thought: naturalism, secular rationalism, and many of the assumptions that underpin the modern intellectual world can be traced, in significant ways, back to Spinoza’s system.

If Spinoza is one of the key figures in the emergence of modernity, and Spinoza is reading Cervantes, then it becomes harder to maintain a strict version of the "Death of the Author," where authors are reduced to mere functions of social structures.

What surprises me is that this criticism does not seem particularly difficult to formulate. From my perspective, it almost feels self-evident that some authors cannot be adequately explained as simple products of their social context.

So I'm curious about the Anglophone perspective. Is Barthes' essay still regarded as a convincing theoretical position within literary studies? Are there contemporary English-language critics who have substantially challenged or moved beyond it? Or has the debate largely shifted elsewhere?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Nov 11 '23

The feminine version of The Odyssey

0 Upvotes

"The Odyssey" is the archetypical masculine narrative in western society - to this day, even - given the proeminence of the "hero's journey" in pop culture. Not that the hero's journey applies exclusively to men (obviously not), but that its foundation is often masculine, both in its presentation, and the fact that it features traditionally male endeavors like wars, etc.I wonder which book/narrative/myth is the same, but for femininity, if that makes sense. Because the Odyssey seems very influential historically: it influenced not only the Aeneid, the Lusiads, Moby Dick etc, but Renaissance culture and the European exploration age. Odysseus seems always to pop up as a inspiration for the European male colonizer, and men more broadly. I simply don't know about a text/narrative that does the same for women, historically. What major narrative has shaped our view of what women "should be like", and things like that, that has been extremely influential, like the Odyssey?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Sep 24 '15

I'm looking for literary criticism of JK Rowling's Harry Potter

0 Upvotes

Or interviews where she goes into depth about the ideas behind the books. e.g. Why did she choose the name Xenophilius?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jun 01 '22

I’m wanting write a paper on gothic literature. But no clue on how or where to start? I’m not into Dracula or vampire stuff. More like supernatural or horror. What do I do?

0 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Oct 19 '23

Why do we humanize villains?

0 Upvotes

Not that I’m complaining, in fact if done right villain origins can be fascinating! Joker (2019) being my favorite. But I was always curious why modern movies like Joker or books like the new Hunger Games prequel (which is quite good btw) humanize antagonists. How did that start?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jul 10 '25

Why do I relate more to male authors than to female authors, despite their sexism, though I see myself as a feminist?

9 Upvotes

I am a big reader of mid century American literature. I really enjoy JD Salinger and Phillip Roth. Though, something that I realize, especially about Roth, is the fact that women are used as nothing but props in his most famous novels, for example one of my favourite books, Portnoys Complaint. Salinger has a similar issue, in that all the women he writes are largely the same ascetic thin archetype. I feel comfortable reading these stories despite the frequent sexualization and reduction of women, and even feel more uncomfortable when I read lit about women and sex, since I feel like many times sex "interested" women in literary fiction are shown as totally detached and traumatized. I relate more to the male authors in general, and it makes me feel weird since I'd call myself a feminist but feel so detached from female sensibilities especially in literature.

I read a lot of female authors, along with many, and more often that not I feel more understood by men that by women. Which, makes me fear: Am I a "Pick-Me"? Does anyone else experience this?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • May 26 '22

Did Harold Bloom read everything? Or the most of anyone?

7 Upvotes

Who are the people most familiar with literature?

Harold Bloom was praised to me as that guy. From his books I see huge familiarity, a collection to strive for, but still a selected and common collection.

The mythological everythingness mystified or profounded me more than any literary anecdote or tale I've heard. But was it just a tale?

The tale sounds like other literary people's retreat to mass reading, but where are the details to expand these monastic tales?

I want to understand the gap between going into the jungle or shed, and emerging 2-10 years later as an electrified critic or critic/writer.

ps. watching his affected manners in interviews begs my idea if reading and humbling increase together after becoming a master, or how masters alternate between interesting ideas and snobby exaggeration.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Feb 21 '24

AI-Powered Poem Analysis? Actually helpful?

0 Upvotes

As I read more and more difficult text, I increasingly have been using large language models as a way to double check my understanding. I'll copy and paste a section of Milton into an ai model and ask for a simple explanation to make sure I am following. I understand hesitations around it. However, this doesn't take away from its ability as a reading co-pilot.

A very actionable way to use it are things like "Period Word Look-Ups" to find context around weird words or just a general poem analyzer to sorta get a college freshman level close reading of a poem and see what details I may be overlooking. Again, not a way to replace reading, but a way to augment it.

I suppose there are many polarized opinions on this.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Mar 17 '26

Modern Shakespeare?

0 Upvotes

I'm a big fan of Shakespeare and I was wonder what his style of book is called. I know he wrote plays and poems, but is there a word for long book-like plays? If so does anyone else write in that format?

The closest I can think of is epic poetry/narrative (which is not that close imo) and I tend to favor books in those genres (reading, writing, and analyzing wise). I'm curious as to if there is a whole format/genre that draws from Shakespeare or perhaps an unknown progenitor of his style.

Edit: I think Blank Verse and Closet Drama were what I was looking for. Thank you all.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Feb 02 '15

Has anyone rebutted Chinua Achebe's "Images of Africa"?

0 Upvotes

I love Heart of Darkness and don't care much for Chinua Achebe's fiction, so in the spirit of fanboyism I am obligated to consider Achebe's critique of Conrad, "Images of Africa", to be nothing more than the spitballing of a jealous imitator. Problem is his points are astute. Has anyone written at length on Achebe's criticisms of Darkness? If so, would you be willing to share?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Dec 05 '23

Why did modernism fail? Is it no longer considered a viable position to claim that modernism was "right" to rebel the way it did, or that certain forms of literature are obsolete?

1 Upvotes

For example, what is the point in the 21st century of pretending something is real when it isn't? Or of telling a story with a relatively conventional narrative structure and characters you are supposed to empathize with? Why does literature (and art in general, maybe especially film) still rely on kind of facile ego-identifications and all this BS that belongs to the imaginary register?

It just seems like it is now considered "passé" to think art should be interesting. I'm not saying we should have government boards deciding what is good enough or anything. But why is there even still room for this stuff culturally speaking? Is it just a kind of opium of the masses? Couldn't modernism be the LSD of the masses? It feels like a movement backwards.

Blanchot talked about a "question of literature". Is there a point in any literature that closes itself off from this question? Or that doesn't in some way play with form and try to do something? What's the point supposed to be? Why can't everything just be avant-garde and awesome? This seems to be what the surrealists wanted.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • May 01 '23

Primer on How to Read with a Transgender Literary Lens?

2 Upvotes

I am interested in learning how to read non-trans* texts with an eye for trans* issues.

I know that there are many popularly taught techniques on how to read literature with an eye to queer, feminist, post-colonial, anti-racist, indigenous, and Marxist lenses, just to name a few. There are important texts written for each of these lenses on how to read with an eye for what is important to each field. However, I am wondering if anyone here is familiar with a 'how to read' primer or literary technique to read for trans* issues or gender non-conformity more broadly in primary texts.

Have you happened upon any? Have you taken a literature course with important articles about how to read 'canonical' texts through trans* lens?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Feb 28 '23

Is there a list of books that could sufficiently replace a bachelor's degree in literature? I understand that college gives you the experience of speaking to others - but I wonder if there is a list of books that could sufficiently be degree equivalent?

0 Upvotes

Is there a list of books that could sufficiently replace a bachelor's degree in some subjects such as literature? I understand that college gives you the experience of speaking to others - but I wonder if there is a list of books that could sufficiently be degree equivalent?

Which books would qualify as 50-100 books for a literature degree?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Oct 03 '22

I'm considering writing a paper on Queer representation in Postcolonial South Asian literature. If you know any texts that fall under this category, please drop down the names

1 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Nov 23 '22

All the sources for my Literature Review are from Mid-tier Journals. What do I do?

1 Upvotes

I am doing my thesis on a collection of short stories that was critically acclaimed and won a few prizes but hasn't been researched extensively in the academic world. I found about 10 or 13 research papers after a month of looking in google scholar, JSTOR, and basically any other resource my library had to offer. However, most of the papers come from mid or low-tier journals that aren't very well known. Most of the papers were also written by either graduate students or professors in Pakistan. Probably because the book I'm using was written by a Pakistani American author. The research I found wasn't bad per se but they definitely weren't of the same quality as what you would get from more well-known journals or better sources. Should I acknowledge in my lit review that I am aware that these papers were from low or mid-tier journals or would that be disrespectful to the researchers whos work I'm reviewing? I wanted to know the best way of addressing this situation respectfully. Would greatly appreciate some advice on the matter.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jan 23 '23

Would it be possible for humans to detect better-than-human literary skill?

1 Upvotes

Hello, everyone. Odd question for you, if you don"t mind: Do you think it would be possible for human experts to detect compositions written with superhuman levels of skill or sophistication?

I may be stepping into a minefield that I'm unaware of here -- my background is not in literary studies, and I don't know how contentious the idea of literary skill or quality of work is. I guess my initial attempt to define it would be analogical: experts can usually detect a difference in sophistication between (e.g.) a dystopian story composed by an eight year old, and one composed by a bestselling novelist whose work is taught in literature classes, like Atwood or Orwell.

Moving that analogy a step further: If there was something (or someone) capable of producing literature in a particular genre with greater-than-human skill, would it be possible for human experts to spot the difference? If so, what methods do you think would be most promising in finding superhumanly good literary composition? Would the answer differ significantly by genre?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jun 28 '24

destroy the image of Victor Hugo for me

17 Upvotes

basically, lately l've done some really shallow research for my exams and found out he was pro-women's rights. plus I've actually never heard any bad things about him before. so, I’ve already started idealising him subconsciously. however, as far as l'm concerned, every famous author ever had either been a narcissist or had heavy diseases due to a questionable lifestyle lol. my question is: do you know about anything that shows him in a bad light? I came here to ask for information from people who are more informed than me. thank you in advance! :)


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jun 22 '17

Almost 30 and still don't understand how anyone enjoys literature (fiction).

5 Upvotes

All my life I've been surrounded by people who love reading fiction books -- friends, teachers, family, coworkers. They will begin to tell me about a book, or give me a recommendation of a book, which typically leads to my confession: I've never read a fiction book that I enjoyed.

It's really depressing and frustrating. I've read plenty of books for school. I've read a few of my own choosing. A few that others have recommended. I've even tried to read the books of some of my favorite movies, like Fight Club.

From what I seem to gather, there are typically two "reasons" given for reading books. One, for entertainment, and two, for the themes/interpretations.

For the first reason, it is something I am obviously lacking. There is nothing I find enjoyable about reading a story. I would much rather see or hear it. This is not really a "reading" problem, because I actually love reading nonfiction books. There's so much to learn out there. Reading a story that never actually happened seems just like such a waste of time -- I might as well read the sparknotes.

Speaking of sparknotes, that brings me to reason 2, the interpretations of the story. I see absolutely no reason why someone would read the whole book if they wanted to understand the themes (unless of course there are no summaries, cliff notes, or other analysis already available). In all my years of education I have been asked to read many books, and have usually exclusively read some type of summary, or just talked about the book with someone who had read it. This always got me an A on my papers/essays and even allowed me to participate in class discussion.

Believe it or not...I actually do find value in reason 2, even if I only read the sparknotes. I like hearing about unique ideas regarding the human condition being told in a story (that's why I like movies too). But, I simply cannot wrap my head around why anyone wants to read the entire text to get these themes.

Among the many reasons I find fiction books boring is the pointlessly long descriptions of things which have no impact on the story/message.

One of the few types of fictional stories I sometimes found enjoyable were fables/fairytales. These stories are typically very lacking in description aside from the key points to the story. You get the moral of the story in about 5 pages, rather than 300.

Anyway, that's about it. Sorry if this post is pointless. I'm just very frustrated and sick of getting weird looks when I tell people I just can't connect to fiction books. Trying to find some way to understand more about myself and also society.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Apr 30 '23

what is the code to crack amazing academic writings in my essays

0 Upvotes

due to some unfathomable reason, my university conducts annual exams and monthly class tests where we are supposed to write a literary essay on a text. Very typical literature stuff I believe. But recently I have noticed that my marks have sort of gone down despite the millions of essays I read under that text, or the literary criticism I engage in. My friends who have only vaguely read the text or engaged in some literary criticisms are scoring higher marks than me so it's not like an entirely class universal experience.

I feel like it is something to do with how I am unable to answer what the question wants from me. My finals are coming up and I am scared that no matter how hard I work I'll never crack the code. Some advice on how to navigate and work on my essays, including understanding the question, would be very helpful.

EDIT: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR SUCH VALUABLE RESPONSES LIKE I AM SO SHOCKED AND IT MAKES SO HAPPY THAT I ENCOUNTERED SUCH HELPFUL AND KIND STRANGERS ON THE INTERNET. LIKE?? I HOPE YOU ALL HAVE A VERY VERY GOOD DAY, SIRS AND MADAMES AND NON-BINARY FOLKS. THANK YOU AGAINNN I AM IMMENSELY GRATEFUL.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Oct 06 '20

Incel Theory?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I am wondering whether anyone has ever written on incels in literature or incel ideology in literature. I am also interested in potentially incel authors


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jul 20 '26

Joining DU Department of English for M.A. English soon – What should I read before classes begin?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'll be joining the Department of English, University of Delhi for my M.A. in English very soon, and I want to make the most of the time before classes start.

I'd love to know from current students, seniors, or alumni:

What books or texts do you wish you had read before starting the course?

Are there any literary theory or criticism books I should be familiar with?

Which novels, plays, poems, or authors are essential?

Any academic skills (critical writing, research, MLA, etc.) that I should brush up on?

Are there any YouTube channels, lectures, or other resources you'd recommend?

I'm not looking to complete the entire syllabus beforehand—just want to build a solid foundation so the transition into the course is smoother.

Any advice, reading lists, or general tips about the Department of English would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance! 😊


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Dec 02 '22

What are some easy non-fictional american literature characters i can try to cosplay or something

0 Upvotes