r/AskLiteraryStudies • u/Blarki • May 28 '26
Why do almost all literature lectures spend an insane amount of time just retelling the plot?
TGC (The Great Courses) is particularly guilty of this. I recently listened to their lecture on Euripides's Alcestis, and it took the lecturer nearly 20 minutes out of a 30-minute runtime just to recount the plot.
Most of the university lectures I've seen have this problem too.
I think it is a horrible practice.
First of all, this only appeals to people who are not serious about learning and haven't read the literature in question. And those people wouldn't get much from a lecture on it anyway: you can't learn math without solving math problems, and you can't learn literature without reading (or at least listening to) the works themselves.
It is even a bit malicious: just by being a highly credentialed person who gives such a lecture—a lecture that assumes an audience of people who haven't read the book—they make people feel like they are getting a quality education while putting in zero effort. It wastes a genuine impulse to learn by channeling it the wrong way, the lazy way.
Second, isn't it a complete waste of the expert's time? If a professor has, say, an hour to spend with an audience, wouldn't it be better for everyone if they utilized their expertise instead of retelling the stories, which literally anyone who has read them can do? Why take time from their research for this? It's like forcing Nvidia engineers to mop the floor for half of their shift.