r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Oct 31 '19

Hi, we're not /r/homeworkhelp

229 Upvotes

If you want homework help, go to /r/HomeworkHelp.

This includes searching for paper topics, asking anyone to read over or edit your work, or questions which generally appear to be in the direction of helping on exams, papers, etc. Obviously, that is at the discretion of moderators.

If you see something that breaks this rule (or others), please hit report!

We're happy to continue other discussions here—


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Mar 03 '23

The End of the English Major

187 Upvotes

Did anyone else read that New Yorker article? What did you think? I found these lines to be unfortunately rather accurate:

“Some scholars observe that, in classrooms today, the initial gesture of criticism can seem to carry more prestige than the long pursuit of understanding. One literature professor and critic at Harvard—not old or white or male—noticed that it had become more publicly rewarding for students to critique something as “problematic” than to grapple with what the problems might be; they seemed to have found that merely naming concerns had more value, in today’s cultural marketplace, than curiosity about what underlay them. This clay-pigeon approach to inquiry struck her as a devaluation of all that criticism—and art—can do.”

The End of the English Major


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jun 20 '25

Why does death of the author seem to be falling out of favor?

166 Upvotes

When I was in high school (I graduated in 2015 for reference, so this wasn't too long ago), I remember my lit teacher telling us not to let an author's opinions on their work carry more authority than our own, and that as long as you can find evidence in the work, your interpretation is just as valid as the author's.

I've always approached media from this perspective, but I've noticed recently that a lot of people I talk about media with or even just that I see talking about media online seem to really dislike the idea of death of the author. I see so many people cite the author (or director, producer, writer, etc,) as an authority on what a piece of media means. Is death of the author an unpopular way of viewing media, and if so, why?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jul 24 '20

How much of F. Scott Fitzgerald's work was actually taken from / written by Zelda Fitzgerald?

157 Upvotes

I sometimes hear people talk mad shit on F. Scott Fitzgerald because he supposedly stole a lot of material from Zelda Fitzgerald and published it as his own. I've even heard some people (mind you, not full-fledged PhD-acquired academics, but at least some grad students) claim that all of Scott F's work was actually Zelda's. Is this true?

From what I could find by doing some light, sloppy research, apparently portions of This Side of Paradise are ripped from correspondences Zelda had with her friends (wikipedia's article on Zelda F.). It seems like most people are willing to admit that F. Scott at least plagiarized that much. However, I'm curious to know whether anyone here may have a good idea, from legit sources, as to how much F. Scott really plagiarized from Zelda.

Thank you, all


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Sep 14 '20

Is there any surviving ancient literature that is regarded as really bad?

155 Upvotes

Of course, anything surviving for hundreds or thousands of years is of historical interest and importance, but we tend to be guided to the works that are well regarded or influential. Are there ancient texts (or anything more than a few hundred years old) that are regarded by scholars to be badly written or humorously derivative?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Apr 15 '25

Must-Read Essays

142 Upvotes

I’m putting together a list of must-read essays for incoming PhD in English students (and current students, including me). I’m looking for recs on essays that are frequently cited, well-known, but ideally under-taught.

Obviously, this depends on one’s unique educational route, so what I consider under-taught might differ. For instance, in my experience, Sontag’s “Against Interpretation” and Barthes’ “Death of the Author” are not under-taught, as I’ve encountered them in multiple “intro” classes, for good reason.

Some examples of these landmark essays that might have somehow missed an incoming English grad student:

Hortense Spillers’ “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe”

Greenblatt’s new historicism essay (can’t remember the name rn)

“Can the Subaltern Speak?”

Sedgewick’s “You’re So Paranoid”

Just looking for some useful additions that might cover any blind spots one might have.

After I compile this—maybe with links— I will post a Google doc here if that’s permitted.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • May 13 '25

Is Reading a Privilege?

137 Upvotes

Recently, I came across a reel where an author expressed frustration about her book being pirated, calling it "really frustrating" and saying it should be banned. Most of the comments seemed to agree, and honestly, it made my heart drop.

I live in a third-world country, and in my area, libraries are becoming rarer and rarer. Buying books is also difficult, especially when popular authors like Colleen Hoover are dominating the market. It's hard to find other books, and the prices online are really high.

I still live with my parents, and the money I use to buy books comes from my lunch money — money I save by not buying lunch at school and making my own. Before anyone calls me entitled, I’ve told my parents I don’t buy lunch, and if they want to stop giving me lunch money, that’s their choice.

If what the author says were to happen, reading would become even more of a luxury for me than it already is. I can only buy one book a year, and the rest of the money goes towards presents or donations.

I know I might be coming from a biased perspective, but I can’t help but wonder: should reading be considered a luxury?

Edit for clarification: I’m not the one pirating book—I honestly wouldn’t even know how to. My concern is more about how local bookshops might be getting their stock from unethical sources. I just wanted to share what access to books looks like where I live. Hope that clears things up!


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jun 13 '14

What is modernism, post-modernism, and modernity?

136 Upvotes

And what are some examples? I hear these terms used a lot and feel like I have a frail understanding.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Oct 02 '25

Which authors are currently “in” in literary studies? Who’s out?

130 Upvotes

Which prose authors feel in fashion in literary studies right now, and which ones seem to have slipped out of favor? I’m not asking about bestseller lists or broader culture, but within English/Literary Arts departments: who’s showing up on syllabi, being written about and appraised up in new ways, and who isn’t appearing as often anymore?

I’m interested in this across any period — nineteenth-century novelists, modernists, contemporary fiction, earlier traditions, whatever. Which names are getting more attention than they used to, and which feel less central than they were a decade or two ago?

I know this will vary depending on the flavor of your school, but I’d love to hear about the larger patterns and shifts you’ve noticed. Curious what you’re seeing in your own departments and fields.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Nov 14 '20

Why does 19th Century Russian literature have such a high reputation in the English-speaking world?

126 Upvotes

Most English-language readers have heard the names Pushkin, Chekhov, Dostoyevsky, and Tolstoy, at least in passing. Meanwhile, I can’t think of a single 19th century author from Italy, Greece, Spain, Poland, etc - let alone one that has been universally praised. Maybe I’m just an uneducated moron, but I genuinely do think that Russian authors from that era get more attention.

Are Russian authors really just that great? Or is there some other reason that these names have become known for being great authors in the English-speaking world?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Mar 20 '20

does anyone know of online English Literature courses I can take for free?

125 Upvotes

Sometimes I really wished I majored in English. I love to read and want to learn to analyze literature and poetry. Any suggestions appreciated! Thanks!

EDIT: Thank you guys for all the suggestions!


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jan 21 '21

Half shitpost, half genuine question about Shelley's 'Frankenstein'

118 Upvotes

I would like to discuss this with a literary group of people, but I'm not quite comfortable with my English class yet so I've turned to Reddit instead.

I'm rereading Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and recently came across a tumblr post in three parts, which goes as follows:

"Dr Frankenstein is a gay man whose internalized homophobia destroyed his life and his relationship and no i will not be taking any questions / If Victor Frankenstein just let himself get completely railed by his good friend Henry and let himself explore the beauty of another man's body instead of letting his repressed feelings form into an obsession over creating the perfect male body with a working penis he could have avoided all that mess / Fellas, is it gay to want to create human life without the confines of compulsory heterosexuality and also to fixate on creating the perfect male body but also make him 8 feet tall" (tumblr user oak23)

Reading this at first made me go "haha, whatever." But then I remembered this section, spoken by Frankenstein himself:

"As the minuteness of the parts formed a great hinderance to my speed, I resolved, contrary to my first intention, to make the being of a gigantic stature; that is to say, about eight feet in height, and proportionally [my emphasis added] large." (from page 33 in my Norton copy of Frankenstein)

Since the Creature desires a wife––not just any companion but a female companion––we can reasonably assume that its sexual organs function as normal. My question is, how long did Victor Frankenstein spend finding a penis that was proportional to an 8 foot tall man? Why the heck? What does proportional even mean when you're 8 feet tall? Would size have mattered to a female creature? What do you think of oak23's theory about Victor?

Is this a stupid train of thought? Yes. But I would love to see some discussion.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Apr 09 '23

People with PhDs in literary studies, what do you think are the best works of English literature published after 2005?

117 Upvotes

Whenever I look for the best literature, almost everything is from the 20th century. I know I’m being a bit picky when I say “after 2005” because I could just say 21st century. I was originally going to put “after 2010”, but I’ve decided on the compromise of 2005.

I asked this question in r/suggestmeabook, and I was recommended Donna Tart and Louise Erdrich. I feel people in this subreddit with PhDs might have a lot more knowledge to give out on this topic.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Dec 27 '25

Recommendation of Literature professors on YouTube or Spotify?

116 Upvotes

I've always been a reader and, after seeing how my boyfriend approaches his own interests, I've wanted to dive deeper in literature and would love a podcast or lessons taught by good professors. I'm very interested in Russian literature but not only. I've tried searching for that on YouTube but the class I watched wasn't what I was expecting at all. I'd love someone passionate and that brings actually relevant and interesting topics. Do you have any recommendations?

Not sure this is the correct sub. I apologize if it's not.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Apr 23 '20

(? user interest) Willing to do mini lessons in undergraduate/graduate areas of lit theory? :)

107 Upvotes

HI :)

I am a PhD student in lit theory — my specialist areas are poststructuralism, mad studies, discourse analysis & history of literary theory (approx. 1850-present).

I do a lot of extra teaching with my own students just because I genuinely love what I do. And I can see that you guys love lit, too! I would love to give mini lessons or host discussions on topics I’m qualified in, or be given the chance to spark your interest in other areas of lit theory you may not have approached yet. Would you be interested in joining me for this? I have so many resources I can share with you, tips and writing help and et cetera.

Let’s talk, okay? 💕

BIG EDIT: i took out a huge chunk of this post after getting creepy messages from redditors who used this info and other subs i’ve posted in to identify who i am and where i live, etc. it really freaked me out, so i’m taking down a lot of the background detail. i will definitely make some mini lessons in the coming weeks for you, but please don’t send me weird messages about trying to track me down. i look forward to sharing my resources with you!

UPDATE: I created a Google Classroom free-access course module that I will post and update over the summer. You only need a g-mail account to access it, and you are under no obligation to ever post, comment, or otherwise engage. (Though I certainly encourage you to!) Go to classroom.google.com and input the following room code: xd6refj See you there! :)


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • May 19 '19

In "I Have No Mouth, And I Must Scream", why did AM decide to increase the size of Benny's genitals?

105 Upvotes

I've always thought this was a really weird and unnecessary detail. The book says:

Benny had been a brilliant theorist, a college professor; now he was little more than a semi-human, semi-simian. He had been handsome, the machine had ruined that. He had been lucid, the machine had driven him mad. He had been gay, and the machine had given him an organ fit for a horse.

So the context is that AM (The machine) is trying to reverse everyones positive characteristics, so how does giving him a large dick change him to heterosexual? What does it add? I understand the story is meant to be unnatural and uncomfortable, which it does very well, but this detail feels rather pointless.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Jun 19 '20

Why is Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness considered a racist work?

104 Upvotes

I must admit it's been about 3 years since I read this short novella, so my memory is a little bit rusty. What I do remember is that the theme I took away most strongly was a condemnation of the savagery of European imperialism, especially that of the Belgians in the Congo. The european workers of the company are depicted as exploitative, taking advantage of the native population to fulfil their quotas. Kurts especially believes in the supremacy of the White race, using his unique position as an alien outsider to form an almost godlike reverence from the tribe he takes control of and uses to commit his atrocities. However, I don't feel like the book presents Kurts as justified. His actions are depicted as deplorable and horrific, even he is haunted by the savagery that has been carried out under his orders, hence "The horror, the horror". The main character Marlow is presented as a character that would be typical of his time, a raised imperialist with indoctinated views of racial supremacy. But that is the character of Marlow, and the novella doesn't seem to sympathise with his views.

Overall the book came across to me as a strong anti-imperial piece, so I was actually very suprised to see that the book has been condemned by some to be a racist work, which had me asking whether I'd read the correct book. The points I do understand are that the African characters are not given a voice... but the novel is presented through the lens of a white imperialist, so it's natural that the character wouldn't have investment in understanding the natives or communicating with them. The novel uses the actions and speech of white characters to demonstrate Imperialism's inherent barbarism. In some senses the African population could represent any oppressed ethnic group, including Conrad's native Ukraine.

Like I say, it's been years since I read the novella so if I'm forgetting something please correct me, it just shocks me that I never got the implication that Conrad harboured racist views, and in many way the text lead me to believe the opposite.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Sep 18 '21

Holding "non-standard" political views in a comp lit PhD program

103 Upvotes

I'm at a crossroads right now. I'll be applying to comp lit PhDs this cycle, but I'm concerned that I'll feel alienated in a department that I have observed — at least from an undergraduate vantage-point — to be something of a monoculture. It seemed more or less obligatory at my university that everyone defer to the same postmodern understanding of personal identity (race, gender, sexuality) and the same critiques of power. Now, I'm no right-winger, and I'd in fact consider myself healthily to the left of your average academic as far as substantive economic policy goes, but I'm deeply skeptical of the culture-war politics generated by Ivory Tower critical theory. I find today's jargon-heavy strain of identity politics to be counter-productive, and believe instead in the importance of forming broad coalitions around working-class issues. I also find left-wing attacks on free speech — discourse as "violence," anyone? — to be altogether horrifying.

I'm worried that I may find my thinking and speech constrained in a comparative literature department, even though my literary interests are comparative and cross-linguistic. Are my fears off-base? Also, could anyone suggest particular comp lit departments (i.e., universities) that they've felt do have space for dissent and debate on these issues?


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • May 01 '21

How to learn literature without getting a degree?

103 Upvotes

I already graduated college, but I want to learn more about literary studies and critique. I don't mean just reading literature but how to argue a point, how to analyze a text, how to write a critical piece at a scholarly, graduate level, and so on. Basically the skills that you build through a degree at a good school in English, literature, etc.

I lack the money and time to go back for courses. With that in mind, what's the best way to do this on my own even if it's an imperfect approach?

Edit: I love to read and plan to read. I did not mean to imply that I did not want to read. I just wanted to emphasize that I wanted to do more than just read.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Mar 29 '20

Why did Ernest Hemingway say you have to learn French to understand short stories?

102 Upvotes

I was reading a Paris Review article on Ernest Hemingway called The Art of the Short Story, and he said "So I do what the French call constater. Look that up. That is what you have to learn to do, and you ought to learn French anyway if you are going to understand short stories".

I'm curious about what he meant by that (I understand if it might be hyperbole).


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Apr 14 '25

Who is a Literary Theorist you look up to?

100 Upvotes

It’s Giorgio Agamben for me. I wrote my M.A thesis on the little Anarchist Grandfather and got published with TheAnarchistLibrary.

Reading Homo Sacer Omnibus as a community college drop out reworked and rewired my brain like taking a hit of DMT. My trajectory changed after that point. Bless.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Oct 04 '20

Who has gained the reputation of Shakespeare in their own language, like Cervantes in Spanish?

98 Upvotes

r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Aug 23 '20

What do you think of Sylvia Plath?

97 Upvotes

Honest opinions. I am writing my PhD dissertation on her life and works, and I’m finding that many literary scholars think her work is “juvenile,” while others primarily write about her death. I am just curious as to what this sub thinks.


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Aug 22 '24

What’s one of the best books of literary criticism that you’ve read?

91 Upvotes

I’ll start: The Antinomies of Realism by Fredric Jameson


r/AskLiteraryStudies • • Aug 20 '26

Which popular authors have written really good essays?

88 Upvotes

Some of my favorite essays have come from authors I really respect and admire. Why A.I. Isn't Going to Make Art by Ted Chiang (Sci-Fi writer known for 'The Story of Your Life' which was adapted into 'Arrival' (2016)) was an instant classic for me, and it's one of my go-to examples of well constructed essays on current events. I also really enjoyed The Anthropocene Reviewed by John Green, and Tolkien and LeGuin have also written plenty of essays that I've appreciated, but I have no idea where to go to find people sharing or discussing them.