I am a Perma-DM. The group I play with, we've been playing things on-and-off for years. In the last 3 or so, I've been the only DM because people make commitments to run things and never do, then bitch about not having anything to play so our games go on and off with weeks or months in-between.
From there I can say this: Most of the time the party is consistent and good. They are as follows (Names changed)
T - Literally the only player who appreciates the fact I run games. Steady. Never late or Unprepared
A - Has horrible time keeping. Only gotten worse since he got a GF. Like. A-LOT worse and not in the 'we, his friends, are jealous way'. This comes up later.
First it started with a small Fallout: Vaults and Deathclaws game. This one I offered to run b/c I actually know the system. Teach T, A, and I how to play. It goes really well. Game takes place in St. Louis, it's a whole thing. We all have a bunch of fun. Take a small break for college finals for A, come back and it goes well. Mostly. A has a GF.
Happy for him. It's his first one (He's in his 20's. Is my best friend). Except we notice a problem. He's always on the phone with her. Fellow GM's I'm not talking like... for ten-twenty minutes. I'm talking hours on end. So we hear him baby-talking her for hours. Trying to get his attention and having to repeat things over and over. Then he was slow as molasses on his 'turns.'
When the party would get to the hub area, a beached cruiser dubbed 'Fortuna' everyone would get down time to spend their hard earned dollars, repair stuff, craft stuff, drink, you name it.
A would spend forever trying to barter. I mean like.. He bartered for an hour trying to knock THREE DOLLARS OF THE ASKING PRICE OF AMMO
Not because of like... trying to use his words (I grant bonuses for speaking. Don't let my players get away with just saying: I roll Charisma)
But because he was on the phone, not paying attention, failed his first barter roll, and then was digging through his pockets to find something worth that much.
Then he tried to take out a loan to cover it. A loan from the shady raider underboss who used his debtees as drug mules. This was not hidden knowledge. He had the money. Several hundred dollars worth. He was just refusing to use it.
Later on the Ship and it's Market square get hit by tactical nukes. An NPC, Karla, was there. She'd been the confidant, quest giver, guide, and at one point: Lawyer for the party.
She lost her kid. All A had to say was: Aw that sucks.
I- No, We were floored. There had been emotional investment from EVERYONE in the party. EVERYONE. And he just didn't care. We found out why soon after.
In retaliation, the party is sent to knock out a forward operating base of a rival faction. Combat takes two sessions because A got up when his GF gave a surprise visit. He was gone for two hours and came back AND WAS BACK ON THE PHONE WITH HER. Combat ends on session two. Party goes on to loot. Finds a fancy item. An automatic laser rifle. To note: The party had barely gone past low-level slugthrowers. A takes it along with ammo, some expensive grenades, a fine piece of body armor, and some other various goods. Three-way split with the party. Easy peasy.
Except it's not. He tells me afterward that it was his last session, and that he wanted to drop out to spend more time with his GF. They spent six days a week together in the evenings. Sunday night was our game night.
He took the literal best loot from the rest of the party and withdrew from the game with promises to return.
We have a house rule of no retconning. We've had it for years. Literal years over a dozen games. Not once did we ever talk ignoring it just one time. (For the record, we're all stubborn and believe if you break a rule once, it just opens up a whole new avenue.)
He did eventually join back, but it was much the same. Except this time it was so bad, his phone calls were so disruptive it put the entire game on permanent hiatus because everyone's drive was killed when there was a serious moment involving a slave girl, her kid, a serial <redacted> and a self-termination to end the pain. His response to it all: "Huh. What kind of pistol does he have?"
We learned why she would always call though even though it was the one day a week we had scheduled for three-four hours in the evening. She "wanted to see how his game was going." Except it was never that. And she made a point to make surprise visits during session and we wouldn't hear from him for hours. I've given the most egregious examples but this is something that's been going on for months outside the game and during the game.
The worst part is A talking about running a rogue trader game. His time when he wants to run it? November or December. I should be free by then. This was not a joke. It was deadpan serious.
I have to add this in to be fair. He is not normally like this. There's a reason our group stayed together for years. Even with the serial <redacted> and Karla burying her kid, he is completely invested in his character. He just gets on the phone and clicks out. Hell, we've caught him muting his mic during some of the discord games. Vehemently denying he's talking to her while we can hear her over the mic in the background. Not just with tabletops either.
I just don't know what to do peeps. We've been friends for years. Hell, we got drunk together for the first time. We graduated together. But this is actively killing drives to play things. He joins games when they're open (not just mine) and then he has zero investment.
What do I do here? I feel bad because he is/was my best friend. Now I don't even want to be in the same room as him most of the time. I don't want him anywhere near the games I join or the ones I host.