r/AskGameMasters • • Jun 22 '26

Your players will adopt the throwaway barkeep and ignore your villain. I finally stopped treating it as a bug.

887 Upvotes

Spent a week building a villain once. Motivation, secret backstory, a whole web of lieutenants, the works. The players met him for ten minutes, decided he was "kinda sus," and moved on. Then they met a barkeep I invented on the spot to describe a room, asked his name (uh... Garrett), and proceeded to spend three sessions helping Garrett with his cabbage shipment problem like it was the central plot of the campaign.

For a long time I treated that as the players going off the rails. Took me way too long to flip it: that wasn't them ignoring my game, that was them telling me in the clearest possible terms what they actually wanted to engage with. A week of villain prep bought me ten minutes. One improvised cabbage guy bought me three sessions of real investment. The players were handing me free data and I kept arguing with it.

So now I prep differently. I deliberately leave NPCs half-built, just a want and a voice, and I wait to see which one the table grabs onto. Whoever they adopt gets promoted. That barkeep gets wired into the plot after the fact, because the players already care about him, so any stakes I hang on him land ten times harder than the villain they never bonded with. Their attention is the realest prep signal you'll ever get, and it's free. You just have to be willing to throw out the thing you were proud of.

The villain, by the way, eventually came back as Garrett's shady cabbage supplier. Best arc I ever ran.

Anyway, I'm curious what the rest of you have learned the hard way. What's a technique or realization that genuinely changed how you run games, especially the kind nobody really talks about? I'll trade you a half-built barkeep for it.


r/AskGameMasters • • Jun 16 '20

A 'flavor adventure' I came up with out of the blue. My party liked it so much I thought i'd share with the community. Feel free to steal it

373 Upvotes

The party hears bickering in the distance. Players with appropriate language feats would recognize this as kobolds.

Two kobolds argue as they carry an egg the size of the watermelon. They call each other names and insult each other. They're very invested in this debate.

When they spot a PC they gesture them over. If the PC can understand them they ask them to weigh in on their debate:


"Listen. My brother stupid. He say this is owl egg. Clearly not. Egg is too big"

"No MY brother stupid. This is clearly owl egg. Got spots on it like owl egg."

"Quiet stupid. Too big for owl egg! This definitely bear egg."

"BEAR DONT LAY EGG STUPID"


If the PC sides with one of them then the kobold who is 'right' will gloat and taunt the kobold who was 'wrong' and the one who is 'wrong' will sulk as they continue walking

mama owlbear attacks in 1D4 turns

Edit: wew /r/AskGameMasters all time top post. Glad y'all enjoyed it!!


r/AskGameMasters • • Jan 12 '24

Mage hand as counterspell?

313 Upvotes

I have a player who is wanting to use mage hand as a counter spell. They saw a tiktok video where the person asked if they could put their mage hand in someone's mouth to prevent them from using verbal components to a spell. My initial thought is no as counterspell is an instantaneous thing and a reaction, where as mage hand would be an action to cast, also if it were already out it would have to be moved to the caster's mouth which I imagine would take too long to prevent a 6 second casting of a spell.

Thoughts?

Edit: Sorry y'all I forgot to mention the system. Yes this is for 5e


r/AskGameMasters • • 21d ago

One player always "Double checks" his failed results. What should I do?

297 Upvotes

Im playing DND with a couple of friends. And there is one player in the group, who every time they roll low, they always try to double check to avoid the failed result. For example, they rolled a 7 on a survival check the other day to tie a rope to a tree that they were going to hang on, and imediately afterwords when "I want to check the knot" and "I want to tug on the knot firmly before I go down to make sure it can secure me" and things like that. If I then reveal to their character that it wouldn't have held them, they retie it until it does, but if they fail to check and then fall down anyways they complain that they checked. And they only really check if they know out of character the roll went poorly. If they had rolled a 22 on that same check, for example, they would not bother with checking.

Should I do something about this? This feels... Wrong, but I dont know how to better approach the situation. Please help!


r/AskGameMasters • • Jul 04 '22

What is your best quality of life GM thing?

227 Upvotes

What is the best quality of life thing you have got or made for your GM life?

For me, as most of my sessions are virtual and all my materials are digital, a transportable screen has been a godsend. The ability to have all my windows open at once is such a delight and with in person games I can lay the screen flat on the table and have a battle map while still having my info on my labtop.


r/AskGameMasters • • Nov 20 '21

My sincerest apologies...

213 Upvotes

To all GMs/DMs out there,

My D&D 5e party just informed me that I was the best DM on the planet. My apologies to other DMs out there who may have believed themselves the best, but this has been officially confirmed by my party.

Better luck next year.


r/AskGameMasters • • Dec 27 '19

What little known resource would you like to share to fellow GMs?

209 Upvotes

I've found that many Game Masters have found some interesting helpful resources for running games. What ones do you find super useful and suspect others here might benefit for learning about them?

Here are a few of mine:

Chaotic Shiny Generators:

http://chaoticshiny.com/crowdgen.php

Soldier Nicknames:

http://www.ufopaedia.org/index.php/Nicknames_(EU2012)

101 NPC Personalities:

http://marnok.com/content/_adventure/101npcs.php

Encounter Generator:

https://www.roleplayingtips.com/city-encounter-generator/

Autoroll Generators:

http://autorolltables.github.io/#

The Link Says it All... (Works for NPCs too)

http://www.whothefuckismydndcharacter.com


r/AskGameMasters • • Apr 20 '22

What have you seen another game master do that totally blew you away?

205 Upvotes

I recently had the pleasure of helping my brother figure out how to do ambient noise on discord. I thought it was for scene setting and immersion building.

Nope.

He figured out how to use diagetic background sounds for a navigation puzzle, and needed a way to rig it together for online play. With a digital mixing board.

On the surface, the puzzle was simple. Blackbirds are left. Cardinals are right. Ravens mean straight ahead. And to truly test us, he incorporated panning in the last step of the puzzle, to confirm the logic if "the birds on the right mean 'go left', while the birds on the left say 'go right'."

I am the more experienced DM of the two of us... but he is very much the better Puzzler.


r/AskGameMasters • • Jan 01 '24

One of my players (my girlfriend) keeps complaining in my d&d campaign.

190 Upvotes

I run a dnd campaign based on dungeons of drakkenheim.

It’s going great and almost everyone is having fun, but my girlfriend keeps complaining about how I’m not being “nice”, she says this whenever she or anyone in the party rolls poorly, she does this whenever I tell her she can’t do something absurd and I’m any other case where she is displeased.

On top of this, when she doesn’t get what she wants she starts acting all annoyed and she just doesn’t bother interacting with the game, she has also told me I should give her special benefits (I.e advantage on all rolls) cause she is my girlfriend. As well she plays Minecraft in the background, and this has led to her being unfocused and often talking about Minecraft mid game. (We play online, as the others don’t live in the local area)

I feel like this brings the mood down in my campaign, and she doesn’t seem to be having any fun.

What do i do?


r/AskGameMasters • • Jan 23 '20

Somebody Who Knows You (The Flip Side of "I Know A Guy")

186 Upvotes

Most of us have heard of the "I Know A Guy" Strategy by now. short version is that it's when a player can pipe up and claim their character knows an NPC who can help, adding them to the roster and giving the party someone to turn to if they're stuck.

I decided to turn that on its head. Somebody Who Knows You (A DM Tool For Moving The Plot Along) is when you insert NPCs who are useful, but who often come with strings attached, to provide aid should the party need it. The key is that these NPCs know (or at least know of) the party in some way.

For instance, they might need an invite to the duke's ball. There's somebody in town who passes the word along, because they recognized Light-Fingered Fawkes the party rogue, and they make them an offer. The contact can get them on the list, but Fawkes needs to swipe some incriminating documents while they're in the manor. Maybe the party needs a guide to get to a certain part of the woods, and someone who's a big fan of theirs shows up to offer. They know where to go, sure, but they're also not a professional adventurer, so there's a bit of a double-edged sword there.

And so on, and so forth.

I've been messing with it, figured I'd share for other DMs to try out at their tables!


r/AskGameMasters • • May 14 '20

New rule : Bloggers, Self Promotion & Other Advertising no longer allowed

178 Upvotes

After the poll I have decided to no longer allow Blog posts, self promotion and other advertising.

If you still see any of these posts you can report them and they will be removed.
The poster will receive a warning and be banned if it happens again after that.


r/AskGameMasters • • Apr 24 '20

Reward Your Low-Level Players with Magical Goblin Items

170 Upvotes

Low-level play in D&D can be a bit of a slog. The most iconic content is still to come, and you don't have most of your special abilities yet. I started wondering how I could make low-level play more interesting while mostly maintaining the balance of the game.

I decided to create magical items for goblins.

Everyone fights goblins sooner or later in their D&D career, so I might as well make them more interesting and rewarding. I made a rusty sword, a wobbly command stick, an adrenaline potion, and a cauldron of booze so heinous that just thinking about it turns my stomach. They're weird, they're fun, and like all things goblin, they're pretty grungy.

www.spelltheory.online/goblin-items


r/AskGameMasters • • May 20 '21

Is there a better feeling than staying up chatting with your players until 5 AM, only to leave them going mad with paranoia about upcoming plots that may or may not exist, all while figuring out how to knit their emerging backstories into each other?

163 Upvotes

My god I love my players.


r/AskGameMasters • • Jun 27 '22

I hate one of my players.

161 Upvotes

I am a Perma-DM. The group I play with, we've been playing things on-and-off for years. In the last 3 or so, I've been the only DM because people make commitments to run things and never do, then bitch about not having anything to play so our games go on and off with weeks or months in-between.

From there I can say this: Most of the time the party is consistent and good. They are as follows (Names changed)
T - Literally the only player who appreciates the fact I run games. Steady. Never late or Unprepared
A - Has horrible time keeping. Only gotten worse since he got a GF. Like. A-LOT worse and not in the 'we, his friends, are jealous way'. This comes up later.

First it started with a small Fallout: Vaults and Deathclaws game. This one I offered to run b/c I actually know the system. Teach T, A, and I how to play. It goes really well. Game takes place in St. Louis, it's a whole thing. We all have a bunch of fun. Take a small break for college finals for A, come back and it goes well. Mostly. A has a GF.

Happy for him. It's his first one (He's in his 20's. Is my best friend). Except we notice a problem. He's always on the phone with her. Fellow GM's I'm not talking like... for ten-twenty minutes. I'm talking hours on end. So we hear him baby-talking her for hours. Trying to get his attention and having to repeat things over and over. Then he was slow as molasses on his 'turns.'

When the party would get to the hub area, a beached cruiser dubbed 'Fortuna' everyone would get down time to spend their hard earned dollars, repair stuff, craft stuff, drink, you name it.
A would spend forever trying to barter. I mean like.. He bartered for an hour trying to knock THREE DOLLARS OF THE ASKING PRICE OF AMMO
Not because of like... trying to use his words (I grant bonuses for speaking. Don't let my players get away with just saying: I roll Charisma)
But because he was on the phone, not paying attention, failed his first barter roll, and then was digging through his pockets to find something worth that much.
Then he tried to take out a loan to cover it. A loan from the shady raider underboss who used his debtees as drug mules. This was not hidden knowledge. He had the money. Several hundred dollars worth. He was just refusing to use it.
Later on the Ship and it's Market square get hit by tactical nukes. An NPC, Karla, was there. She'd been the confidant, quest giver, guide, and at one point: Lawyer for the party.
She lost her kid. All A had to say was: Aw that sucks.
I- No, We were floored. There had been emotional investment from EVERYONE in the party. EVERYONE. And he just didn't care. We found out why soon after.

In retaliation, the party is sent to knock out a forward operating base of a rival faction. Combat takes two sessions because A got up when his GF gave a surprise visit. He was gone for two hours and came back AND WAS BACK ON THE PHONE WITH HER. Combat ends on session two. Party goes on to loot. Finds a fancy item. An automatic laser rifle. To note: The party had barely gone past low-level slugthrowers. A takes it along with ammo, some expensive grenades, a fine piece of body armor, and some other various goods. Three-way split with the party. Easy peasy.
Except it's not. He tells me afterward that it was his last session, and that he wanted to drop out to spend more time with his GF. They spent six days a week together in the evenings. Sunday night was our game night.
He took the literal best loot from the rest of the party and withdrew from the game with promises to return.

We have a house rule of no retconning. We've had it for years. Literal years over a dozen games. Not once did we ever talk ignoring it just one time. (For the record, we're all stubborn and believe if you break a rule once, it just opens up a whole new avenue.)
He did eventually join back, but it was much the same. Except this time it was so bad, his phone calls were so disruptive it put the entire game on permanent hiatus because everyone's drive was killed when there was a serious moment involving a slave girl, her kid, a serial <redacted> and a self-termination to end the pain. His response to it all: "Huh. What kind of pistol does he have?"

We learned why she would always call though even though it was the one day a week we had scheduled for three-four hours in the evening. She "wanted to see how his game was going." Except it was never that. And she made a point to make surprise visits during session and we wouldn't hear from him for hours. I've given the most egregious examples but this is something that's been going on for months outside the game and during the game.

The worst part is A talking about running a rogue trader game. His time when he wants to run it? November or December. I should be free by then. This was not a joke. It was deadpan serious.

I have to add this in to be fair. He is not normally like this. There's a reason our group stayed together for years. Even with the serial <redacted> and Karla burying her kid, he is completely invested in his character. He just gets on the phone and clicks out. Hell, we've caught him muting his mic during some of the discord games. Vehemently denying he's talking to her while we can hear her over the mic in the background. Not just with tabletops either.
I just don't know what to do peeps. We've been friends for years. Hell, we got drunk together for the first time. We graduated together. But this is actively killing drives to play things. He joins games when they're open (not just mine) and then he has zero investment.
What do I do here? I feel bad because he is/was my best friend. Now I don't even want to be in the same room as him most of the time. I don't want him anywhere near the games I join or the ones I host.


r/AskGameMasters • • Jun 22 '20

How do I tell my gm that his campaing is boring?

156 Upvotes

My best friend is now taking my role as gm and running his own game but every encouter so far has been with his homebrew monsters and it's getting very boring every fight is the same we fight an extremely op creature and then some npc saves us or we fight for what seems like an eternity just so the creature could say " oh I'm done playing" and go use a broken unbalanced hability that we have to waste every resource we have to stop. And every time I try to use dispel magic,detec magic or identify it's always either tecnology or some kind of creature that cannot be detected.

Update: I sat down and talked to him told him I was greatfull and tought of somethings that would make his game even better and I have him some ideias of villans that are treathning because of things other than overpowerd magical stuff and some other stuff and he conceded on the points I raised ou session after that was very pelasent with more well balanced enemys some light hearted banter and some john wick referenced npc's, so thank you guys for the advices and encouregment


r/AskGameMasters • • Apr 24 '22

About to Run a game with a Trans/Non-Binary Person, how do I make the game inclusive to them?

155 Upvotes

Hi folks. So I am a long time DM, but as the title says, I am about to run a game with a person who is Trans/Non-binary. I'm afraid I am not sure which it is, and I get the impression it is rude to ask. I haven't had much experience with people who identify as such, so I am ignorant of correct etiquette and manners.

I believe my games should be as inclusive of everyone at my table and their beliefs (provided they are not obnoxious or offensive to others at the table)/gender/orientation/race.

What should I keep in mind? What should I definitely do? What should I completely avoid? Is there any general advice on the topic you have?


r/AskGameMasters • • Mar 18 '22

What GM advice did you think was good, but realized was terrible later on?

152 Upvotes

What GM advice did you think was good, but realized was terrible later on?


r/AskGameMasters • • Jul 11 '22

off my chest: Please don't make me roll when there are no consequences (D&D 5e)

149 Upvotes

Let me first state that I'm going to vent a little, so please don't take this as purely critique. I was annoyed in the moment, and I'm still annoyed when I think about it. If that bothers you, I apologize in advance.

So Jim GM gives us a scenario where the party finds a pretty prize, but of course its going to take some work to extricate it. The treasure is a golden bell bolted to a heavy wooden timber at the top of a belfry. There are two obvious solutions: take it down with tools that we don't have or just leave it there. Eventually, Bob has the idea to use his tools at hand - his axe and brute strength to simply attack the timber. We all decide that this is about our only shot to get it loose and get back on our way back to town, without a serious diversion.

Bob comes up with a solid plan - climb up the exterior wall, to the belfry, chop some foot holds for himself, then tie off. From there it is, as logic would dictate, just a matter of time for him to get through the timber. I'd estimate about the time it takes to chop down a mature tree to be a couple of hours. If this was my game, I'd let him roll an Athletics check to get up to the belfry, a Dex save to represent a foot or hand slipping, and then give him a single level of exhaustion if he succeeded on the save or two if he failed to represent the bumps and bruises. Then after those 2-3 hours were up, the bell would crash down spectacularly, the group would load it up into the cart, and we'd be on our merry way.

Now, this is where Jim GM decides that he wants Bob to roll for each single attack until he breaks the timber, his weapon, or falls off the roof enough times to get tired of it. That might be necessary if we were trying to cut through a wall to escape some danger - but we were alone, in a safe area, without any pressing agenda.

This is the lowest stakes roll I could envision. We aren't talking about one roll, we are talking 25-30 rolls by one player for both attacks on the timber and saves to catch himself from falling. Eventually the handaxe breaks, but not before the rope snaps after fall 4 or 5. Mind you, none of this damage would ever be enough to kill a 3rd level fighter, we can Mend the axe, we can Mend the rope. I can not stress how safe and secure we were at this point. Everyone was fully rested, fully healed, with all 3 of us watching/supervising this process. No enemies, no danger, no unfolding plot against us. Zero. Danger.

With nothing but time on our side, and a physical task that while somewhat challenging, presents no real difficulty to our group: I slowly turn from amazement to aggravation that I was sitting through this ordeal. Instead of being excited to find this massive windfall and happily carting it back to town to sell it, the group gets to watch Jim and Bob roll for 20+ minutes and neither seemed to catch on how absolutely monotonous this is. This is where the bitching part comes in: Jim, Bob, and Joe all seemed to have fun doing this. Bob and Jim were laughing, Joe was cracking jokes. I'm just left to grin like an idiot and play along. They genuinely seemed to enjoy it and it makes me feel like I'm was just being grumpy, and maybe I am? But I can't possibly see the narrative importance of how much damage our fighter took to chop down a timber, how many falls he took, and how many times we had to mend his tools.

Jim GM and I have a big difference in opinion on the importance of details vs the big picture. Obviously, he is a detail guy. I'm much more concerned with the big picture. So, already we have two opposite perspectives. That's not enough to make me leave the table or try to change him, but I just want to know if other players would feel as aggravated as I did. There is no chance that I'd ever be able to bring this up at the table or with other friends, since it would eventually get back to Jim. So I've turned to my fellow GMs & players to ask you if you'd feel the same way as I do.

And if you see this somehow Jim, I still love you, but don't make me roll unless failure is a possibility.


r/AskGameMasters • • Oct 25 '20

My GM used a "spell" loosely once thinking it wouldn't come up again and now that it has he needs real rules for it

144 Upvotes

It's basically an oath that a spellcaster can force you into if you shake his hand, you feel a burning sensation in your arm and now whatever you agreed to has to be done.

He wants to know if anyone knows about some homebrew spell similar to it because he's not sure about the punishment for not doing what was promised. He's not sure if it should just kill you, or apply exhaustion the more time you take, etc.


r/AskGameMasters • • Apr 17 '22

My players are taking a dead hero's body home to be buried. I want to use that as a hook but every idea feels like it'd turn into Weekend at Bernie's.

141 Upvotes

[RAF / MAX AVERT YOUR EYES]

What it says on the tin. The last adventure ended with an NPC valiantly giving his life to resurrect a fallen player. His last request was to be taken home (a weeklong trip) to be buried.

I want to spin the journey into an adventure of its own, but I'm having trouble coming up with good hooks / inciting events. I'd love to hear some ideas, anything to help kickstart the creative juices.


ADDED CONTEXT: I probably should've kept this in the OP, but I'd edited for brevity.

The NPC was an old traveler (a former knight) who tasked the players with helping him retrieve an heirloom. In the process one of the PCs died and the NPC used the heirloom (a relic, it turned out) to give his life to resurrect the player. Before dying, he asked that he be buried in his homeland. The players are now escorting the body home.


r/AskGameMasters • • Feb 27 '20

Is it unfair to tempt my predominantly good alignment group with better rewards from choosing the bad option in moral quandaries?

138 Upvotes

I’m relatively new to DMing, so I’m not sure the effect this will have. Basically my PCs are going to be deciding between a usurping General (evil option) and the legitimate king and regent. Is it unfair to give the PCs better rewards (items and gold) if they choose the evil option? My thinking is that the larger rewards will provide temptation and force the players to choose between their characters’ greed and actual moral sense. If they choose the good option, some of the rewards offered in the evil option are still available (through finding them in the usurping general’s house). Will making them make this decision cause problems?


r/AskGameMasters • • Sep 06 '22

Tips for planning a one-shot?

136 Upvotes

So I'm planning to run a 5e one-shot for a group of friends who have never played D&D before (but are all interested in it) in the hope of getting them hooked so I can have a new regular group to play with. (Last one fell apart for IRL reasons, as groups do)

I've run a homebrew campaign before, but never homebrewed a one-shot and am quite interested in trying that. So, what are your top tips for writing a one-shot? I imagine it's quite different to a campaign since the story needs to come to a neat conclusion in one session and the pacing etc seems trickier to nail.

Alternatively, what are your favourite (newbie-friendly, so low level) pre-written one-shots? I find the planning and worldbuilding to be the most fun part of DMing, but I wouldn't be opposed to adapting an existing adventure if it gives me a better chance of having a tighter story that's engaging for the players, since after all the goal is to make them want to continue playing D&D.


r/AskGameMasters • • Mar 16 '20

I left my group on a cliff hanger about a sarcophagus pulsing with yellow light. It’s going to be have loot that’s good for a new level one party, but I want to sneak the Macguffin of the campaign in under the radar, its supposed to have the power to raise dead gods. What should it be disguised as?

130 Upvotes

r/AskGameMasters • • Jun 20 '22

Should I just terminate my game?

129 Upvotes

My group (all around the age of 30) meets once a month because of how busy 2 of the players can be. However, we haven’t had a session for the past 3-4 months because of something coming up at the last second for these 2 players (like today). They’re good friends, they’re interested, they enjoy and play the game when we finally do meet. I don’t want to drop the game. I don’t want to tell them I’m dropping the game because of them.

I’m tired of being let down, though. The session prep, cleaning house, going over game mechanics, getting food and drinks ready, only to get a text from one or two of them saying something came up, sometimes within an hour of playtime.

I’m intending to give my group one more chance to meet next month, but I don’t think I have much patience left. The group knows there’s a level of commitment to be expected. Maybe it’s time for everyone to face reality?

UPDATE: Thank you everyone for the thoughtful responses. I’ve decided that I’m going to do one-shots for the time being, and whoever joins can play and have a good time. Most of my group agrees that one-shots might be a better option at this time (and then we’ll just pick up the story/campaign later). This should be easier on everyone. I’ve even offered to have these sessions occur more than once a month. Basically if they’re available, we can set up a game day. I’m excited to get this flexible, free-form schedule going!