r/AskGameMasters • • Feb 19 '24

Do you use AI in your games/prep? Why or why not?

11 Upvotes

and how do you incorporate it?


r/AskGameMasters • • Jun 17 '23

Games for women??

1 Upvotes

Hi there. I'm 40 f. I'm not a gamer so I have limited idea. because of health reasons I'm stuck in bed and need bed rest so I'm gonna play a lot. Previously I have played life is strange and I enjoyed it a lot. What other games are there these days? I don't wanna play Sims and I don't like war games.


r/AskGameMasters • • Dec 14 '23

Avatar:The Last Airbender-inspired Homebrew compatible with 5e

0 Upvotes

I am creating an Avatar: The Last Airbender-themed D&D 5e homebrew guide with five custom classes with each element and a chi-blocker class, totaling over 500 abilities once all the levels are fleshed out.

It's formatted under Google Slides, and the slides hold a link to Quizlet for each element's bending abilities (spells). Races and classes were combined for a more streamlined experience.

I know the TTRPG exists - this is a homemade alternative for those who may enjoy D&D mechanics more or more freedom with their roleplay (some of the abilities are... dark).

This is something I'm doing for fun that plenty of people have expressed interest in; please don't discredit the hard work that has gone into it. If it's not for you, don't play it! It's free - not a product I'm selling.

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1w2cBhQqfSx4Dpj9F4sb7KZR2EheaF7guLAkgbiIv1To/edit?usp=sharing

All homebrew content is mine and may not be used for monetization purposes by any third party or other.


r/AskGameMasters • • Apr 01 '23

Why Does Reddit Claim 5e Is "Anti-DM" Or "Has No DM Support"?

30 Upvotes

I hear this echoed non-stop on DnD subs, which makes no sense to me. You have the rules, and you have the adventures, and you make the rulings. I would much rather have what we have now than another game with hundreds of source books and some dickhead player making a stink about my ruling on something because they found a rule for it in book #1324252 that I've never seen or heard of (looking at you Pathfinder 1e and 3.5).

What is so DM unfriendly about this game? Sure, there are balance issues, but that isn't a good argument because every game has balance issues.

EDIT: My question was posed with the tunnel vision of the DnD family. A better way to pose it is, "Why is 5e said to have terrible DM support compared to similar systems?"


r/AskGameMasters • • Dec 11 '22

Use Open AI for random tables

0 Upvotes

Open AI ChatGPT can generate random NPC’s, items, spells, monsters, etc. It’s super useful for creating lists. Check it out


r/AskGameMasters • • Jan 10 '17

Dealing with "retarded" characters.

0 Upvotes

Title is slightly bait and switchy, but as we talking about trolls and goblins being overly pc doesnt seem super important.

We have all been there. Someone on the team ends up playing the either mentally or socially deficient character. In the olden days with 3d6 for stats int/cha was always dumped for fighty types. Now we have many more systems with many different types and ways to build characters.

How do you guys deal with a char that is "well below average" in a particular area?

Do you adress when a person strongly disrupts their mechanics with roleplay? For example most of us are socially "ok" or mentally average. Which makes it difficult for us to play down to the stats on the sheet. How do you adress that?

For example I do alot with shadowrun where the average atteibute is 3 (of a 1-6 scale for the majority). Its always seems to crop up the shootybangbang types will drop their logic to 1.

With Shadowrun being a very plan oriented game, it would make sense that if they use the "retarded" persons plan it should go wrong. That character doesnt have the mental cognition to easily and formally articulate in depth plans.

Now slightky below average, say 2 instead of 3. Could have alot of different reasons. Maybe they didnt have proper schooling, they arent "dumber" just not as learned. Or maybe they are a trust fund baby and never had to apply themselves. Or maybe just a ganger who knows all he needs to know to survive the streets.


r/AskGameMasters • • Jan 04 '26

How do i include Vecna into my D&D Campaign?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,
I'm here to ask a simple question. How do i add Vecna into a campaign? The character became quite popular among my players after Stranger Things and i was wondering if there is a way to add him. I don't know much about his lore, beside the basic stuff that I've manage to read online.
I would like some ideas, suggestion or advice, really anything that can help me :3
I know there is a campaign around him "Eve of Ruin" but from what i've read online it seem to be a bit bad (mostly about the fact that Vecna is present only at the end of the campaign and it's lore heavy).

EDIT NOTE: not looking to add him in my current campaign but i would like to build one around him or with him as the big bad at the end 😅


r/AskGameMasters • • Feb 10 '23

Help me design a 5e statblock for a laser shooting crystal elf daddy

1 Upvotes

So my DnD party is going to face the father of one of the PC's, a real nasty piece of work. Here's the concept:

  • Uses magitech crystals to shoot lasers and do other shenanigans

  • Is particularly good at manipulating light and creating illusions

  • Has a forcefield that both repels magic as well as provides a barrier with a damage threshold

  • Has maybe 1-2 legendary actions

Any advice would be great, even just some suggestions / links to already existing monsters that could be tweaked and reskinned would be a great help, thank you!


r/AskGameMasters • • Sep 20 '26

Hours of prep thrown out before we could even start. Just regular DM stuff

0 Upvotes

I don't know if i am the @$$ in this or if I'm just venting but i feel like i just need to get this out of my system before i go back to the drawing board.

I am the Dm for my wife, a friend from work and a few strangers I found online. I've gone through enough of the typical Dm horror stories to earn my stripes. I've had toxic players, constantly late or missing games without warning, power gamers that completely throw off the balance, and new players that need extra patience to learn how the game works. All that is fine, I worked out the issues with the good players and kicked the bad apples. now the party has a good equilibrium and we meet every other week without issue. Things were good, I prep ahead of time to reduce crunch and for the most part the story progressed without to much of a hitch. a little constructive criticism here or there is always appreciated but this time it just tore everything down.

We are starting the next chapter in our adventure. The party voted to give the Barbarian's questline the spotlight as they try to find her kidnapped child. the problem is that I gave the party the opportunity to try out new characters and they all took it. now i need a way to introduce the Barbarian to this new group of adventurers. It was just meant to be a small side quest to hunt monsters in a desert with some added challenge from a constructed limitation on rests thanks to a water scarcity. I hadn't even worked out all the kinks yet because I didn't have enough time to prep before our next session. I warned them i didn't have enough content prepped for our session tomorrow so it will be mostly about introducing all the new characters and the environment. I start opening up about what to expect from the game and they kept digging and over thinking and poking holes in everything.

They asked why they couldn't bring all the water they would need to survive. I try to explain that their characters could never carry that much water and the client that hired them has all the water you could want. He is strictly rationing it and will extort allot of gold out of you if you require more. they ask why they would have run out of water and not him. i start to drop hints at the reward for the quest by saying he never seems to run out of water. one guy quickly deduces what it could be the decanter of endless water. I don't mind that since it was so obvious but when he was asking to roll to try to determine how that was possible outside of game i told him to wait until tomorrow for everyone to get together. then he posted the description of the item when no one else was online and spoiled the surprise. They ask why their character would work for this guy and i tell them they have been scammed. he acted nice to get them into the job, then lead them out into the desert with plenty of water and is now basically holding them hostage with the promise of a reward when the job is done. if they try to leave they would die without his water. typical $#!+ job with a $#!+ boss that you totally wont get to enthusiastically kill when he betrays them. Nope. they are having none of it. Their characters are way to smart to every get deceived into being sucked into a bad job. Its not what their characters would do. Fine.

Now everything is scrapped. they are mondain adventurers being paid to kill monsters but there is a famous monster hunter over there that has a special job that they could help with if they choose to. No managing water rations to survive. no sneaking around a piece of $#!+ boss or plotting to betray him. Only one of the players commented on how hours of my prep work was wasted in seconds.

this doesn't feel good. my session is tomorrow night and all i have ready is that barbarian gets lost in the desert. she gets hit by a sand storm and miraculously finds shelter from the wind in the valley of some cliffs but the place is occupied by another group of adventurers. they can lead her to her destination once their job is done. one of the adventurers is a bigshot that is being snooty and letting everyone else do all the work while he gets ready to do the real job.

i know my original idea wasn't conventional but i thought it would be an interesting fun game to play


r/AskGameMasters • • Jan 09 '17

Potentially triggering RP

2 Upvotes

I'm about to DM my first ever game and I'm working on an email to address letting the table be a safe space for players even as it's a deadly, traumatic space for their characters. My draft follows and I would love feedback before I send it out (or suggestions for more appropriate subreddits to ask in). One thing I would especially like feedback on is the frequent use of "you" - does it imply that I don't put myself in the same boat?

In accordance with my previous exhortation that the gaming table be a safe place, and my enthusiastic embrace of the notion that the most important rule of RP is "If you're having fun you're doing it right," I'm putting out a request for consent. I'm actually really excited about this because it's about everyone being invested in everyone else having fun. Knowing that - between the PCs and NPCs - our game world includes sexuality, violence, violence against animals, violence against children, domestic violence, sexual violence, racism, sexism, heterosexism, cissexism and other possible triggers, I'm going to ask for each of us to affirmatively consent to playing in this world. In doing so I will make the stipulation that I intend to explore potentially triggering issues inasmuch as I think they serve the interest of the narrative, and to the extent that I feel capable of treating them with appropriate sensitivity. I'm going to use the FRIES acronym: Consent is Freely given: feel no pressure to consent. If you don't consent, you'll be no less welcomed at the table. Consent is Revocable: consenting now doesn't allow anyone later to say "you already consented so you have to bear with us during this scene." You should be able to discover your boundaries dynamically and know that the rest of us are here to support that discovery. Consent is Informed: I'm doing my best now to point out the kinds of potentially triggering issues that might come up, but I'll also try without spoiling any surprises to lead up to potentially triggering scenes and activities in a way that gives everyone an opportunity to check in. Please try to do the same with your character and narration. Consent is Enthusiastic: if you feel like you're just going along with an uncomfortable scene or discussion to be polite with the other players, then the rest of us are doing it wrong. It's not consent if you're doing it only for the sake of the other people at the table while you have a rough time. Consent is Specific: this ties back to 'I' - you should know what you're in for and be genuinely on board for that. What should you do if you realize that you're not up for what's going on at the table? I think every situation needs room to for its own response. Let the rest of us know you need a break, and based on the situation, we'll work together to find a way to go forward. The upswing of all this is that we should all be able to expect that everyone else at the table is as invested in you having a great time as you are.


r/AskGameMasters • • Apr 01 '25

How to make a nat 20 "fail"

0 Upvotes

Hey guys !
I'm writing a campaign and i created an extremely powerful character, and my players shouldn't attack him, they aren't a menace to him at ALL.

He'll be presented as something like : "You feel a dark, oppressing, violent aura behind you, you feel how dangerous it is, what do you do ?"

If one says "i attack him" and roll a nat 20, his attack should be successful if i follow the classic rules of RPG's, but how can I turn his successful attack into a "miss" ?

I thought about something like : "Your attack hit, but deals absolutely no damages to his body.." or something like that, i'm new to game mastering, help me please !!!

Thanks ! :)

EDIT : "I can't thanks you all for all your answers and your tips at DMing, it's my first time as a DM and I needed all this, thanks a lot to y'all guys ! :D


r/AskGameMasters • • Dec 16 '22

My players were bored of combat on my game, so I made some stuff up to spice up

0 Upvotes

Hey, I’m a newish dm to dnd, and me and my 4 friend’s all play dnd at school everyday, so we’re running lost mine pre adventure, and they just looked bored when combat came around. So I made the mistake of making up an encounter where they fight a glautios cube and an azer because of an spell by a wizard goblin in the crawmaw cave.


r/AskGameMasters • • Apr 22 '22

Is this manipulative metagaming?

1 Upvotes

So I'm of the opinion that not all meta-gaming is bad (big long Matt Colville video linked which is basically identical to my position).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1IyWfaMmhrM&t

Recently, I saw a thing that did a plot twist I want to steal, BUT I'd have to meta-game to sell it well. I want to tell my players that I'm tired of running our long-running campaign, and we'll have one final session. In that session, the players will think all their adventures happened in their minds and they're actually in an asylum (and because it's the last session, could conceivably be true). The twist is that the asylum is an illusion by a greater villain (which hopefully they figure out), and they return to the status quo (and we can continue with future sessions in the same campaign).

Is that manipulative in a bad way to tell players I'm capping our session off in order to sell a plot twist?

Edit: you guys are right, it's not worth selling a plot twist to be an utter dick to my friends. For the two people who are downvoting, I'm asking for input on a proposed thing, not offering up a suggestion for everyone here to try.


r/AskGameMasters • • Mar 12 '23

should DMs tell their players..

0 Upvotes

Following the title... Do you think DMs should inform an established party of a new player?

This question remains whether it be session 1 or 20...


r/AskGameMasters • • Oct 06 '24

I want to let the player go and I don't know whether or not I am justified

0 Upvotes

*Long text below*

Hi. My name is Jacob, I am 24 yrs atm, and I have been GM since high school. I've run plenty of campaigns and one-shots in many different systems. I've played with various people, of different backgrounds. I have a master's degree in Psychology, and I try to be a pretty accepting, supportive, stand-up guy, I am always friendly to newbies, and do my best to explain the rules and stuff to them, I see no race, no gender, etc.

Currently, I am running Pirates of the Carribean-esque campaign in the Shadow of the Demon Lord system. I've run it for a group of 3 people. After 7 sessions, one of my players had to resign due to scheduling problems. Because we love this campaign very much, and we do not want it to end, I've decided that we have to recruit new people, so I wrote a post on Facebook, to search for new people (I had to recruit from strangers because most of my friends don't have time to roleplay regularly atm).

From around 10 candidates, I have chosen 2 guys. To keep the anonymity, let's call them Jason and Mark.

I met them at a local game pub for a beer and some character-making. Now, I've spent only around 2,5 hours with them, but I've managed to get to know them a little.

Jason is the coolest guy around. He was also a SoTDL DM, so he knows the mechanics behind the game. He is pretty laid back, polite, and witty, and he seems to be living a happy life with his new fiance.

Mark is...strange. And that's the problem. Because honestly, he didn't do anything wrong, or at least anything majorly wrong. But his vibe is off.

So 1st problem is that Mark didn't fully accept how I wanted to run this meeting. When I was explaining the campaign's plot so far and telling what my players had gone through so far, he made cringe jokes and started rolling traits of his character. Jason, for example, listened, asked a few questions, and only then started rolling, and gave me the results, I read the results from the tables for him. He did ask me if he could reroll anything if he did not like the outcome. Unlike Mark who did whatever he wanted, Jason ran things through me. I tried to ask him if he could wait, that maybe it would be funnier if we could go through the whole process together, but he brushed me off saying that he's almost done anyway or something like that. I tried to be nice because we were just getting to know each other, so I let it slide.

The second problem was with his character's backstory. It was very original and tbh I liked it, but it was also very complicated. Since guys are joining an already-created world, I asked if they could at least partially connect to the plot threads of my players. I tried to direct his idea a few times and simplify it, but he has a few plot-threads that for some reason he doesn't want to let go and which do not fit the assumptions of a pirate campaign.

And honestly, the third, the main reason why I'm writing this post. After creating the character, we all thanked each other and of course, we parted ways. Mark offered to take me to the bus stop. Since it was a bit awkward, I wanted to break the ice. I asked him what he does for a living. In response, I got a 5-minute rant about how he's been unemployed for a while, that he probably will be for a while, and that the world is unfair because he has a master's degree in management and sees how many corporations don't support the passion of their employees and lead them to burnout. I even suggested that if he was having financial problems, I could try to get him into the call center where  I am working, but he said he didn't want to be a salesman. It got sad, so I wanted to change the subject. I asked him why he decided to play a female character, because it rarely happens in my experience. He answered very briefly that he liked it that way. I asked him if he liked MMOs too, whether he just liked bikini-styled armors and so on. Mark went on another rant for a few minutes again, about how gender is a social concept, that he has male and female traits, and that he is simply himself. Everything would have been fine if it wasn't for the fact that he talked about it very awkwardly, he got confused, stuttered and generally seemed as if he wanted and didn't want to talk about it at the same time. Kinda as if he was looking for some validation and at the same time felt that I was pressuring him (even though I hadn't spoken for 3 minutes). It got so weird that I had to point out that I had no problem with it and that I support the LGBTQ+ community.

I normally support freedom of expression and self-actualization. Let Mark just be himself, if that's how he feels best. But at this stage, although I didn't say it, I just wanted to ask "Who asked?" I felt like I was being answered questions that I didn't ask and that it was a bit of an oversharing. I felt like I was being analyzed, and tested in some strange way? And Mark just exudes an aura of life dissatisfaction.

I don't know if I'll enjoy playing with him. I don't know if my players will like him. That's why I want to ask? Should I give him a chance, or if i feel this way, should I let him go now? And how do I do it without hurting his feelings??


r/AskGameMasters • • Aug 23 '22

Trapezius problem

0 Upvotes

Lately I’ve been hurting a lot in the trapezius area, I think playing too much video games caused that problem. I’m trying to cut on video games and if possible is there a right position to play games with keyboard and mouse? I also think wrong position cause it too. So any position suggestions?


r/AskGameMasters • • Feb 01 '22

GM ideas request for a 1940s Harry Potter/Narnia crossover campaign with Nazi enemies

2 Upvotes

I'm planning a campaign for a Harry Potter RPG. The PCs are teenage British wizards who in 1940 will find themselves transported to the world of Narnia during the Witch's long winter. They will find that the world has already been invaded by a large group of Nazis who are trying to exploit the world for their purposes. I'd like to figure out how the Nazis got there and what they are trying to do, which the PCs must then stop.

Ideas for how the Nazis got there 1. A Navy light cruiser was taken by a magic storm in the Bermuda triangle. They can't get back that way and no reinforcements can arrive. In this scenario, they can sail up and down the coast in Narnia. 2. A Nazi spy acquired the wood of Digory's magic tree and they used it to build a big portal. With this idea, they could in theory bring in unlimited people unless I had its magic "burn out".

Would the White Witch ally with them or oppose them? What are they trying to do? Perhaps they have heard that people from England have come through and they would like to use Narnia to invade? Perhaps they want to use the time skips to built more equipment? So many possibilities... what do you guys think would be cool?


r/AskGameMasters • • Sep 25 '25

Autism/Asperger’s syndrome in play?

0 Upvotes

I’ve got high functioning autism, now my question is this:how do you fine people build/play as such a person?


r/AskGameMasters • • Jun 01 '20

Is Using a TTRPG as a Social Experiment a Terrible Idea?

0 Upvotes

I intend to reflect our current political climate in America to fuel our next few sessions, having a rebellion lash out against the totalitarian govt. of a country in my home brew world. I feel it would be very interesting to see where my players would decide to align themselves as well as what they feel is appropriate to do in the name of justice (or perhaps finding a niche of power in the upheaval of the establishment if they decide to go that route.)

This rebellion is going to be caused by the BBEG framing the govt. for using an ancient artifact to spread a plague to the country’s citizens.

I’m very interested to hear y’alls’ thoughts. I know this is a touchy subject so please be civil if you decide to respond and I will do the same when I reply. Love you guys <3


r/AskGameMasters • • Apr 26 '18

Need help for a NPC revealing that this is all a game to the PC's

0 Upvotes

So I'm going to be DMing 5e of D&D a multi-game story where I'm getting the players heavily attached to their characters. Where their characters are going to have to solve why they keep dying and they keep resetting to the same day with some things changed (NPCs missing/gone, high level monsters appearing, some characters evil/good etc).

At the very end they will figure out that the NPC that they will know (Call her M for now as I'm still working on names) just wants to be more than a side character, just wanted to be more than the bar wench or the evil villain, just tossed aside and forgotten or just used for the benefit of the PCs. All she wants is to be a PC, no longer an NPC.

So the PCs have a choice: Either rip up their character sheets and accept that this is just a game, or fight a boss they can not win and just die.

But how can I make sure the PCs are aware that they are in a game at this point? I'm not sure what classes the players are going to be playing, and I'm unsure how to make sure by the very end they are fully aware that they are aware that they are essentially puppets being controlled by players.


r/AskGameMasters • • Jan 15 '16

How do you deal with sexism/bigotry at your table?

0 Upvotes

Do you let it continue if it seems no one is offended? Do you step in right away?


r/AskGameMasters • • Sep 30 '22

HD Tally Marks Instead of HP

0 Upvotes

I’ve gotten in the habit of just using a monster’s hit dice instead of hit points as a measure of how many hits it can take before it goes down (using tally marks to keep track). So, for example, if a 1 hd goblin gets hit once, it goes down. If a 23 hd dragon gets hit 23 times, it goes down.

This has greatly reduced calculations and still approximates what occurs during a battle, for the most part.

Thoughts?


r/AskGameMasters • • Mar 13 '17

How to work with a critical Fail and get XP for it

0 Upvotes

r/AskGameMasters • • May 02 '18

PC who rolled very low stats

0 Upvotes

Hello, I am new to DMing and looking for some advice with a 5e campaign I started.

In this party, I gave the pcs an option to either take the default spread of stats, or to roll. Most of my players chose to roll. However the problem comes with 2 players in particular. One rolled extremely high (lowest stat is a 12), and one rolled very low (highest stat is a 12, everything else is less than 10). And with that, he seems very disinterested in the combat side of things, he just casts bless and goes afk until someone needs healing. The player who rolled high is not much of an issue himself, but the contrast between the 2 characters is glaring.

I want to come up with a solution for him to become more invested in his character, currently I came up with 3 options. Which with my limited experience DMing, I don't know if any of these solutions are even any good.

  1. let him re roll his stats. This seems like a simple solution, but i feel my other players might think this might be unfair. And I don't really want to be a dm who retcons stuff or waves my hand and says magic happened.

  2. Kill him off and let him roll a new character. Currently we are still early in the campaign, and he is not really invested in the character. He did a random gen and has not cereated any backstory yet.

  3. Give/let him find a magic item that may level the playing field a bit.

My current thought is maybe some sort of cursed hulk ring (he is a gnome, I figured it would be a cool idea). Once per day, he can essentially turn into the hulk, where I'm thinking of setting his str and const to maybe 18, Dex to 12 or so, and wis, int and charisma to 6. In this phase, he starts to rage, using the barbarians rage rules. He also becomes large, gains barbarians unarmoured defence, and gets 2 unarmed strikes, dealing 1d6+rage (scaling to d8,10,12 with level) . However for every round of combat he is in, he gets -1 temp hp, effectively reducing his max hp when he returns to gnome form until a long rest. He can deactivate it the same way rage is deactivated.

Does this seem balanced at all? This might not be the best sub to ask for homebrew advice. What other magic items might make a good fit? I originally thought maybe the ring of grammarian , but it feels like it would be broken and impossible to keep balanced. Mostly bc I can't even imagine a fraction of the possibilities it could have.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated, and what you would do; if anything, in this situation. ty