r/AskDND • • Feb 22 '26

Answered Huh... Has anyone seen a dice like this?

Post image
925 Upvotes

For context, I am a DM for a friend group, and I bought them dice. I did not notice when I bought it, but it seems to be out of line? Honestly, should I go buy a new D4 for him or should I let him figure it out himself???


r/AskDND • • Oct 08 '25

Answered Is it just me, or does this look fishy

Post image
807 Upvotes

I'm a first-time DM, and this is one of my players' character sheets. I'm pretty sure that this is his second time playing, and this feels too good for level 3.

Edit: Talk to him, he did, in fact, roll a lot, but this was not out of malice, just a bit of a new player being dumb.


r/AskDND • • Aug 21 '26

Does anyone have any interesting ways that they use doublegangers or changlings aside from just using them for spy stuff?

Thumbnail
gallery
501 Upvotes

Like for example I’m wanting to have a character that is a doubleganger that is more horror themed like a skinwalker or something.

Edit: i got a lot more responses then i thought i would.


r/AskDND • • Sep 15 '26

A new question on Fireball

270 Upvotes

Image you weren't on a flat table top, but rather in a 3D world. You are a wizard and you want o cast fireball but the terrain is uneven.

My question: How would you expect this to work, and how do we keep it fair and not turn it into an auto-targeting mortar? (as fun as that would be!)

For reference: From DnDBeyond

A bright streak flashes from your pointing finger to a point you choose within range and then blossoms with a low roar into an explosion of flame. Each creature in a 20-foot-radius sphere centered on that point must make a Dexterity saving throw. A target takes 8d6 fire damage on a failed save, or half as much damage on a successful one.

The fire spreads around corners. It ignites flammable objects in the area that aren't being worn or carried.

At Higher Levels. When you cast this spell using a spell slot of 4th level or higher, the damage increases by 1d6 for each slot level above 3rd.

* - (a tiny ball of bat guano and sulfur)


r/AskDND • • Apr 16 '26

A player of mine wants to try this, but I can't come up with a ruling. How would you rule it?

Post image
248 Upvotes

r/AskDND • • Oct 26 '25

How to respond when players "Attack the Guards"?

144 Upvotes

Finished the first session of my campaign yesterday. To clarify there not actual guards so it's not like they will be arrested, think more magic hermit. The players as stated above attacked an entity that's supposed to be powerful, was neutral to them (but a little standoffish), and even gave them an item they wanted to collect. they launched their (rather sudden) attack and I ended the session there. I am unsure to proceed.

on one hand I don't want to impede their choices and say "no you can't do that".

on the other hand, it's the first session and I rather they not die to a fight they absolutely couldn't win (they haven't even fully grasped the games rules).

on the other other hand, I don't want to encourage this behavior by making this fight even possible.

on the (I'm running out of hands) I'm willing to explore the consequences of this choice violently.

If you were in similar situation, what did you go with?

EDIT: For those that come back to this post for an update. We tried to run a session but one the players ran late, this pissed off the player that initiated the attack and swiftly left the game. The others agreed to roll back to before the attack and likely do something else.


r/AskDND • • Aug 03 '26

Would you guys run the 2014 or 2024 rules for a dnd game

Thumbnail
gallery
142 Upvotes

I'm looking to try and finish up one of the campaign ideas that I am trying to write, or at least get it to a point where I'm comfortable running it and I'm starting to wonder which version of 5E I should use when it's playable. I have heard good and bad things about each and don't know which would be the 'ideal' version to run for one my campaign ideas. I'm aware I can probably mix and match certain aspects of each but I wanna try to stick as close as I can to the intended rules to not accidentally confuse myself or potential players


r/AskDND • • Oct 30 '25

Wizard is using Silvery Barbs. How cooked am I?

135 Upvotes

Amateur DM here who has never had a player who used Silvery Barbs before at their table. It's an infamous spell frequently banned at most tables. I looked at the description, and it doesn't seem too bad. Is it easily abused, though? DMs and players, what are you experiences with this spell?

Edit: people are talking about Legendary Resistance. To be clear, we’re playing LMoP and starting at level one. Would it still have much of an impact?


r/AskDND • • Dec 16 '25

Tragic vs non-tragic backstories

Post image
133 Upvotes

As a DM, do you enjoy tragic backstories more than non-tragic ones, or vice versa? From your perspective, are tragic backstories easier or harder to work with, and how does a character’s past influence the way you integrate them into the campaign and makes backstory engaging to work with for you? I've had only 2 or 3 non-tragic backstories to work with so far, the rest usually tragic or semi-tragic. Why is it so popular and widespread trope?


r/AskDND • • Jan 25 '26

Answered What is this die?

Post image
131 Upvotes

Anyone know what this die is for? I put together a set of dice from the bulk bin at a game shop. All the d6 dice they had were like this.


r/AskDND • • Jan 29 '26

How to deal with a player with +11 persuasion at level 5

117 Upvotes

The question is pretty much exactly what the title says. I want my party to have some fun outside of combat messing around and throwing social challenges at them like most games do, but as a new DM I'm having a hard time trying to come up with social encounters that won't be blown straight through because of a bard in my party that had a ridiculous charisma stat and took jack of all trades.

Does anybody have some advice for reworking these kinds of encounters? Maybe some suggestions for social encounters that don't just rely on the party just convincing one guy of something?

Let me know if this is too vague and you have any specific questions on the story or anything else.

Edit: Just to clarify, this isn't a game breaking issue and I'm not trying to make his character pointless. I want to find new ways to make his character useful and also give other players a time to shine in these situations so that they feel more memorable and engaging for my players.


r/AskDND • • Sep 09 '26

My Paladin just signed a contract without reading it.

114 Upvotes

So I am a DM for my 5 friends and in our last session the party saw a posting in the tavern to hire a bard to travel as basically a professional hype man. He would introduce them as they enter rooms and would create songs of their exploits for a low cost of 50 gold per week. My party jumped on this and immediately started negotiating with him. They came to an agreement and the bard provided a contract that the party Paladin just grabbed and signed immediately. So now I'm wondering what funny clauses or twisted subsections could be hidden inside. Open to all suggestions.


r/AskDND • • Oct 23 '25

How do I tell me best friend he's an awful DM/Player?

107 Upvotes

I think I need to start out by expressing my level of commitment to this friend. He is a genuinely good friend and someone I don't want to lose from my life. In the past five years this person has taken time every single weekend (including taking off work or adjusting with his family) to be their and hangout, watch movies, play games, etc. If it came down to the absolute of him or the game, I would take him.

However, when we got into D&D a few months ago we were excited to share the hobby with our friend group and honestly I'm already nostalgic of the weeks of prep leading up to our first sessions as the excitement and anticipation was so genuine for all of us.

Then we played D&D.

I don't consider myself an expert in this area by any means, but from my extensive time learning the game, watching others play, reading books about how to role play better, etc. I think I have at least a core idea of how these games should flow. And it feels like every right thing to do he does wrong.

When he's on the player side he make uncooperative characters. We're in a life or death situation and his character is goofing off or refusing to assist. It got so bad that in a spontaneous PvP moment the party almost killed him (not our proudest moment.) To be clear all of this is 100% in game. Out of game he's being super nice and friendly and genuinely engaging with everyone. He just likes trouble making characters in stories. The DM (a close friend to both of us) has tried talking to him, and a little has gotten through but not nearly enough. He kind of just excuses himself by being new/bad at roleplay and says he's trying to improve, which I believe, but just not in the right ways.

Eventually he asked to DM a short adventure he made so we agreed. It should have been a red flag when he didn't ask us to make our characters, and instead the day we showed up we were assigned John Doe's with no back story and thrown into a plot none of us knew anything about. He also ran a massively changed homebrew system we had never used before so we were fiddling trying to figure everything out. But that didn't matter much as he also just went rulings crazy and half the time just eyeballed hits or god-moded "yeah that kills him, or suddenly these creatures all disappear". The story he wrote was also painfully generic and confusing. It was one of the worst D&D experiences I ever had.

But when it was over it pained me to see how enthusiastic he was and he was talking about the next session how he'd try to have better music (another painful point for me), more interesting encounters, etc. This guy is trying his hardest and its breaking me apart.

So it comes down to this: One of my closest friends is making D&D an excruciatingly painful experience that I do not want to play, but I'm also really worried about crushing his fun. I know that if I were to confront him our friendship would probably survive, but it goes beyond that for me, I don't want to take away his enjoyment. I want him to be happy as much as I want to be and I really keep wondering if I'm just being an asshole by not sucking it up and giving him a few hours every now and then to let him play however he wants, when he's always been willing to give me all the time in the world to do things I enjoyed. Any advice would be helpful.


r/AskDND • • Sep 30 '26

New to DnD… does this look right?

Post image
104 Upvotes

I’m a brand new player to the game and I have my session 0 today. I want to make sure my character sheet looks right, anything stand out as wrong or need to be changed?

Edit: Thank you so much to everyone who helped!! I took your advice and changed my CON stat and instead dumped my strength, I also changed some of the weaponry mistakes and incorrect numbers. If anyone has any advice for my first session let me know! I can’t wait to start playing :)


r/AskDND • • Nov 28 '25

What to put here?

Post image
98 Upvotes

what do i put here i do know what hit point are just don’t know where to put them please help.


r/AskDND • • Jul 07 '26

My DM stopped doing combat and blames me for it.

97 Upvotes

Hey y'all first time posting, but in the campaign my group is currently doing we were in a prison type area where most of the party weren't able to fight at their full potential except for my character (pugilist build). We're all level 4 and for the one or two combats we've had while everyone else was barely scraping by, my character was doing great, but now for the past good few sessions we have only had role-playing sessions hard focusing on two of our party members. Another player in the group informed me that the DM doesn't want to do combat because my character can fight while the others are barley doing anything, even now that we're out of that prison area and not limited story wise. I feel like its unfair to basically give my character the cold shoulder and take away combats just because my character is better at combat at this point in the campaign. Lemme know what y'all think.

Edit/Update: Me and my DM talked it out, I was indeed basically getting benched for the past few sessions after the combat in the prison, he did admit that the party hadn't seen much outside of role-playing because of my character. He didn't give me a solid answer on when my character will at least get to be more involved in any way going forward. He did say that next combat whenever it happens he won't be nerfing the other party members in the same way, hopefully this means that we'll just get to see all of our characters do what they were meant to in combat. If things don't improve me and another player may walk away from the playgroup due to other similar issues that have happened in the previous campaign with certain pcs being nerfed into being no fun for anyone.

TLDR Me and the DM talked, he did blame me for no combat when he built the encounter to counter most of the party, hopefully things get better, if not me and some other players may leave the playgroup


r/AskDND • • Jun 20 '26

Am I wrong to feel upset that my character was killed?

89 Upvotes

For several months, I (22f) played as a druid elf with my family/friends' D&D campaign. Unfortunately, my work schedule became more busy and I had to step down from playing regularly. So we roleplayed that my character decided to stay in a druid city to study for a while.

A few months later, I was informed that my character was brought back and played by the DM as an NPC for a quest. In this quest, my character was killed in battle. A party member said they were given the option of not letting her die, but his character didn't know her, so they let it happen. (his character was added prior to my departure, but he was playing a different one while I was there)

I'm wondering. Do I have a right to be upset by this? I was quite attached to my character and no one had asked if I was okay with her being brought back as an NPC, with the possibility of her being killed.

Is this just how D&D works? Am I just making a big deal out of nothing?

Edit to add some information: Been getting these questions.

  1. It was undecided as to whether or not I'd be coming back to the table at any point. I didn't say "I'm never coming back" but I didn't set a return date either.

  2. I am a new player. This character was my first ever D&D character I had created, and the first campaign I ever took part in.


r/AskDND • • Feb 26 '26

New player is bringing "Video Game" hostility to our table and just held my familiar hostage. Am I overreacting?

89 Upvotes

I’ve been in a steady campaign for about six months. Recently, a friend of a friend joined. He’s completely new to D&D, and while I usually love teaching new players, he has a very "video game" approach—utilitarian, cold, and strangely hostile toward my character. I’m a long-term DM myself, so I try to be patient, but I’m reaching my breaking point.

The Red Flags started early:

  • The "Sleeper Agent" Child: We found a child who might have been a mind-controlled machine (the BBEG’s MO). The party wanted a non-lethal solution. This player was adamant about killing the child. When I expressed that child-killing was a "red flag" theme for me and I didn't want it at the table, he got annoyed and shut down for the rest of the night because he didn't get his way.

  • Sabotaging Mercy: Later, we encountered a mind-controlled NPC we were trying to save. She wasn't even attacking him, but he went out of his way to target her during a teleportation sequence. It felt like he was intentionally trying to ruin our "heroic" moment because it didn't fit his "optimal" combat style.

The Breaking Point (The Squirrel Incident): Last session, we found a mysterious teleportation circle. Another player suggested sending my character’s squirrel familiar through to "test" it. My character is deeply attached to him, so I roleplayed the squirrel being "offended" and "mad" about the suggestion.

I described the squirrel fluffing up his fur and scurrying up the new player’s leg to "scold" him. It was a 2-second flavor moment meant to show the familiar has personality—no damage, just a "hey, don't use me as a guinea pig" vibe.

The Escalation: The player snapped. He used Mage Hand to snatch the squirrel out of the air, held it "hostage," and threatened to throw it into the teleportation circle if I didn't give him an apology. The table went quiet; it felt incredibly aggressive.

When I called him out, his defense was that he hadn't even been the one to suggest sending the squirrel through in the first place, so my character’s reaction was "unprovoked." While true that he didn't make the suggestion, his response—physically seizing my familiar and threatening to kill it over a flavor interaction—felt like a massive, personal overreaction.

He keeps using "character motivations" to justify acting against the group or being hostile toward me. I’m starting to dread sessions because of the constant conflict.

Am I overreacting, or is this player a "horror story" in the making?

Edit - A couple of points have occurred repeatedly and I will give some clarification:

- The new player doubled down on sending the squirrel through the portal, and in a much less nice way. I phrased that wrong in the initial post.
I also see that this was unnescessary, but I didn't ever think it would escalate like this. It was meant as a funny interaction.

- "The familiar doesn't have a personality". Alright, in your games it doesn't. But in ours, my familar does. It's still a role-playing game - and the text of the spell doesn't even say it can't have a personality. If not, how could it act on its own in combat? Things like summoned skeletons need a bonus action to be commanded to do anything.

- We did not know if the child was mind-controlled. He wanted to shoot it on sight. And even after I rolled some checks, it was much more likely it WASN'T mind controlled. He just didn't like that we had to send two of our 8 guards we brought along with it to keep it safe or to prevent it from harming anyone.

- I wrote this text myself, but let AI rewrite it, because I sometimes feel that my texts are confusing when I write a longer thread like this. English isn't my first language, sorry.

- The new player is a friend of one of the other players. The DM is friends with me. Overall, most of us don't know each other that well.

- There was no session 0 because I joined at about 2/3rd of the campaign, and the newest player only a couple of sessions ago.


r/AskDND • • Oct 13 '26

Kid's/simplified character sheet

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

Hii, I'm trying to cook up an easy character sheet for the kiddos and found this template online. Unfortunately the link to their google drive to download doesn't work anymore - so I thought I'd try to recreate a high res version of it. Trouble is, as a beginner I'm really not certain what some of the pixelated text says. Could someone offer some insight into what these might be saying? Whole image and labeled unknowns. Thanks!!


r/AskDND • • Oct 03 '26

New to dnd

Post image
79 Upvotes

I’m wanting to get into dnd, and tried to find a paladin model I liked, but couldn’t. Then I remembered that I had some old space marine minis at home, and had an idea to kitbash one. So my question is, would I be able to use a kitbashed space marine as a stand in for a paladin model?


r/AskDND • • May 27 '26

Am I being an a-hole DM?

77 Upvotes

So, for the last 4-5 sessions I've been basically begging to my friends stop using AI to make/update their sheets, and to start reading the PHB. They just joke about it but when battle starts, they don't even know if they must use their Dex or str mod to do damage. They're getting into lvl 6.

So I'm planning to make them fight "shadow clones" of themselves next session, and I won't pull any punches and I will use every trick that THEY can use.

Am I an asshole DM?

Edit:
Alright, I've read everything you guys said.
First I'd like to thank you all. 1st time Dming is a LOT. You need to create a world (At least I did), a Mythology, Gods and demigods etc. (I read a LOT of fantasy and Tolkien is my bible, so I'm not complaining about it). Besides that you have to immerse your players into it since they don't have a clue about the end goal or what they are doing at the start of a campaing... AND you have to balance combat, puzzles, and the randomness that comes with a TTRPG.
Second, I'll use both the talking and the teaching to solve this problem.
A SPECIAL shoutout to u/Idiot_Savant_13 that gave the beads idea, wich I'll turn into a narrative hook for a later encounter that I had no idea how to do.
Besides that, yesterday I've reached them to talk about some points (AI especially) and that I'm not trying to be an asshole or a rule-lawyer, I'm just trying to make them read the PHB to learn how to actually play their own characters.
ALSO, I'll focus more on doing puzzles or investigations for a bit, while throwing a few easy encounters to see if they're getting the hang what to do in combat.

TY ALL


r/AskDND • • May 28 '26

Does this puzzle work and make sense?

Post image
76 Upvotes

I’m running a homebrew maze of sorts and wanted to include an optional little corner puzzle. Rules are as follows: the room ahead has multiple magical barriers in between some of the spaces that deal random 1d4 elemental damage when a creature attempts to walk through them (or something else negative, like a smaller reward). The number in each space tells you how many barriers are adjacent to that space, examples in green. In the corner space with the star is a completely optional reward, a treasure chest trimmed in gold. Can you figure out the correct path through? Once you enter the room, the entrance behind you closes, so you can’t return the way you came. I’m fairly confident there is only one unique, correct path through, but I don’t know if that comes from knowing the solution beforehand. I may give the players all of the numbers right away, or they are revealed when entering an adjacent space. Regardless, it could just be brute forced.

Thank you for testing!


r/AskDND • • Jun 15 '26

Thoughts on miniatures?

Thumbnail
gallery
67 Upvotes

I want to get into making figures for table top gaming and enjoy working in the DnD aesthetic. I've played around and got a few early prototypes together and keen for thoughts and feedback. I haven't played DnD, but from what I've read 'Large' monsters should fit on 50mm bases, and Medium and below on 25mm bases, but some other things I was curious about;

When using miniatures, should they always have bases? And if so, should the figures be glued into the bases permanently? If you were after miniature, would you expect it to come with a base?

I build these myself and print them in colour - any feedback welcome!


r/AskDND • • Oct 07 '24

Answered Is there any way for a level 1 druid to do 20 necrotic damage on turn 1?

63 Upvotes

Got a discord friend who's a first time DM who's just started running a game. There's a guy in the group who's being kinda sketchy with his character. He's playing a druid with the custom lineage. I wasn't able to join the game that day but my brother, who's in the game, told me he did 20 points of necrotic damage and it wasn't a critical hit. Just a reminder, we are ALL level 1. We have no idea what he is but he can turn invisible, specifically he says "i cast invisibility". I've told my brother to bring it up with the DM.

I feel like this is something that's gonna cause trouble down the line if not addressed soon.