I’ve been in a steady campaign for about six months. Recently, a friend of a friend joined. He’s completely new to D&D, and while I usually love teaching new players, he has a very "video game" approach—utilitarian, cold, and strangely hostile toward my character. I’m a long-term DM myself, so I try to be patient, but I’m reaching my breaking point.
The Red Flags started early:
The "Sleeper Agent" Child: We found a child who might have been a mind-controlled machine (the BBEG’s MO). The party wanted a non-lethal solution. This player was adamant about killing the child. When I expressed that child-killing was a "red flag" theme for me and I didn't want it at the table, he got annoyed and shut down for the rest of the night because he didn't get his way.
Sabotaging Mercy: Later, we encountered a mind-controlled NPC we were trying to save. She wasn't even attacking him, but he went out of his way to target her during a teleportation sequence. It felt like he was intentionally trying to ruin our "heroic" moment because it didn't fit his "optimal" combat style.
The Breaking Point (The Squirrel Incident): Last session, we found a mysterious teleportation circle. Another player suggested sending my character’s squirrel familiar through to "test" it. My character is deeply attached to him, so I roleplayed the squirrel being "offended" and "mad" about the suggestion.
I described the squirrel fluffing up his fur and scurrying up the new player’s leg to "scold" him. It was a 2-second flavor moment meant to show the familiar has personality—no damage, just a "hey, don't use me as a guinea pig" vibe.
The Escalation: The player snapped. He used Mage Hand to snatch the squirrel out of the air, held it "hostage," and threatened to throw it into the teleportation circle if I didn't give him an apology. The table went quiet; it felt incredibly aggressive.
When I called him out, his defense was that he hadn't even been the one to suggest sending the squirrel through in the first place, so my character’s reaction was "unprovoked." While true that he didn't make the suggestion, his response—physically seizing my familiar and threatening to kill it over a flavor interaction—felt like a massive, personal overreaction.
He keeps using "character motivations" to justify acting against the group or being hostile toward me. I’m starting to dread sessions because of the constant conflict.
Am I overreacting, or is this player a "horror story" in the making?
Edit - A couple of points have occurred repeatedly and I will give some clarification:
- The new player doubled down on sending the squirrel through the portal, and in a much less nice way. I phrased that wrong in the initial post.
I also see that this was unnescessary, but I didn't ever think it would escalate like this. It was meant as a funny interaction.
- "The familiar doesn't have a personality". Alright, in your games it doesn't. But in ours, my familar does. It's still a role-playing game - and the text of the spell doesn't even say it can't have a personality. If not, how could it act on its own in combat? Things like summoned skeletons need a bonus action to be commanded to do anything.
- We did not know if the child was mind-controlled. He wanted to shoot it on sight. And even after I rolled some checks, it was much more likely it WASN'T mind controlled. He just didn't like that we had to send two of our 8 guards we brought along with it to keep it safe or to prevent it from harming anyone.
- I wrote this text myself, but let AI rewrite it, because I sometimes feel that my texts are confusing when I write a longer thread like this. English isn't my first language, sorry.
- The new player is a friend of one of the other players. The DM is friends with me. Overall, most of us don't know each other that well.
- There was no session 0 because I joined at about 2/3rd of the campaign, and the newest player only a couple of sessions ago.