I was super excited for the Moon Druid changes because, in my experience, Moon druids were cartoonishly tanky. Always able to create massive amounts of hp with Wildshapes to the point where they really didn't need to fear dropping to zero. And I'm happy to say I believe that issue is gone now... But it's replaced by an absolutely cracked damage output that embarrasses paladins, fighters, and barbarians.
In my current campaign of two years, my players are lvl 15 and one is a Moon Druid. As part of a mini arc, I worked with the player to have his druid kidnapped and now he's playing a psi knight fighter he used to play (updated to 5.5e) to help the party get him back. It's all been fun but the Druid PC has echoed what I thought was the case: he can't do nearly as much damage as he was with the Druid.
At level 15, here's the Moon Druid damage die breakdown while wildshaped:
3d10+5 bite attack, with 2d8 from Improved Elemental Fury (once per turn), 2d10 from Lunar form (once per turn), and 2d6 from Fount of Moonlight. Then a 3d8+5 tail attack with 2d6 from Fount of Moonlight.
Average: 81 Maximum: 124
With three attacks as a level 15 fighter, he can't keep that level of damage even expending his class resources like psi dice. For fun, I tried working out how much a paladin of the same level could smite with:
Let's say 1d12+5 base from a greataxe, 1d8 from Radiant Strikes, burn a 4th level spell slot for an extra 5d8 radiant from a Divine Smite. Then a second attack for 1d12+5 and the 1d8 from Radiant Strikes. And let's say Divine Favor was up and so 1d4 for each hit.
Average: 65 Maximum: 98
So in this scenario, the half-caster paladin burning one of their two 4th level spell slots (plus a first level for Divine Favor) doesn't match the full caster druid concentrating on a 4th level Fount of Moonlight as a giant lizard. And I feel it's worth mentioning, at level 15 the Druid has access to 8th level spells so a 4th level slot isn't a big deal even if he loses concentration.
For the most part, I really like the changes made to Moon Druid and think it is an improvement. And I know damage gets crazy at higher levels but like... Should a Moon Druid really be the epitome of damage output?
If anything, I just wish martials could even compare. If my player is feeling it after a couple sessions, I'm curious if anyone else has. Specifically he's mentioned that Druids expend very few resources to be at their peak output, whereas his fighter has to cherish each and every psi die to do less damage than said Druid.
Maybe I'm missing an important buff or spell for martials that could help them keep up but I'm at a loss. Any outside opinion would be appreciated. Thanks!
Edit: should mention, the wildshape stat block is Giant Crocodile (CR 5) which a level 15 Moon Druid is allowed to shift into (CR = Druid Level ÷ 3). Also, Fount of Moon is an action to cast but beyond the Bonus Action to wildshape, the rest is passive.