r/AskDND • • Jul 01 '26

Why is goblin’s AC so high ?

1 Upvotes

Goblin’s AC is 15, which means that my level one players have at best 50% chance to hit ( they can have +5 to hit so they have to roll a 10 or more ) which means that they miss half of the Time.
I find this a bit to difficult.

On top of that I find this a bit weird that goblin have the same AC as fore exemple ice giants and even strong creatures like wyvern or howlbear have only 13 AC. I don’t understand why.

The fact is that my players are more concerned with the plot and the fun roleplayplay than the fighting optimisation, so I am thinking about giving my goblins only 10 AC and play with the environnement to give them an davantage at first, then if the players are smart enough they can find a way to revers the situation and ez win rather than having to roll again and again until they finally hit.

Waiting for your wise knowledge!


r/AskDND • • Oct 19 '25

What should I do when my dm put my ball away from me

1 Upvotes

I play by goblin. It was just an ordinary fight with another goblins. But when I was killed goblins took me and started to draw some pentagram with my blood. Then instead of me it was another goblin, I missed. When my friend killed this goblins I appeared but only with one ball. How should I react. And what should I say to this stupid dm(Sorry for my bad English, I’m from Russia)


r/AskDND • • Aug 17 '26

Follow up uncomfortable question

Post image
1 Upvotes

I saw this post and found all the comments very positive and inclusive. I agree with the vast majority of them. However, I have a follow up question.

Would it be racist for this guy to attempt an accent while playing?

I'm asking because I've definitely done a variety of accents while playing and DMing games, but they've all come from majority white cultures. British, Irish, French, German, Slavic, etc. These cultures obviously don't share the same history as the ones being discussed in this thread, but the question still stands. Also just for clarity I'm asking if it's racist for him to attempt an accent from a culture that would closely resemble that of the character he's portraying.


r/AskDND • • Nov 09 '25

Isn't Hex kinda dogshit in 2024?

2 Upvotes

It's an extra 1d6 per hit, but it doesn't scale and you are wasting a spell slot every time you want to put it on someone. At higher levels and with how little spells slots you have as a warlock, why wouldn't you simple spend that on eldritch smite? That's like 5d8. Even with devouring blade, Hex i's like 3d6 max. Eldritch Smite is just infinitely better, am I missing something? Also you don't have the older Hex improvements you had before, like Chilling Hex.


r/AskDND • • Oct 17 '25

Is there anything like my 'idea' that exists in dnd?

Post image
0 Upvotes

So i was picturing like multiple spheres(i took the refrence pic of Pinterest it was the easiest to get) that have Koliken runes all over it(too much setail uik sorry,excuse my hyperphantasia) eitherway, that has a magical core(or magic wielder(sage,magician, scorcerer, whatever) in the middle from wich the projectiles(that could be anything) shoot at an enemy.

Maybe better to imagine in a fight against a god, or a big ass dragon and from the middle of the spheres massive swear or arrows or smth shood and attack.

Anyway, does smth like this exist? If yes, whats it called?


r/AskDND • • Oct 06 '26

Which D&D class do each of the Avengers fit into?

0 Upvotes

I'm talking about the Avengers team from the first movie, so basically Iron Man, Hulk, Thor, Captain America, Hawkeye and Black Widow.

My thoughts are Artificer for Iron Man, Barbarian for Hulk, Paladin for Thor, Ranger for Hawkeye, Rogue for Black Widow and possibly Fighter for Cap. What do you guys think?


r/AskDND • • Mar 08 '26

Am I missing something, or does the 5.5e Moon Druid have better damage output than any marital class?

3 Upvotes

I was super excited for the Moon Druid changes because, in my experience, Moon druids were cartoonishly tanky. Always able to create massive amounts of hp with Wildshapes to the point where they really didn't need to fear dropping to zero. And I'm happy to say I believe that issue is gone now... But it's replaced by an absolutely cracked damage output that embarrasses paladins, fighters, and barbarians.

In my current campaign of two years, my players are lvl 15 and one is a Moon Druid. As part of a mini arc, I worked with the player to have his druid kidnapped and now he's playing a psi knight fighter he used to play (updated to 5.5e) to help the party get him back. It's all been fun but the Druid PC has echoed what I thought was the case: he can't do nearly as much damage as he was with the Druid.

At level 15, here's the Moon Druid damage die breakdown while wildshaped:

3d10+5 bite attack, with 2d8 from Improved Elemental Fury (once per turn), 2d10 from Lunar form (once per turn), and 2d6 from Fount of Moonlight. Then a 3d8+5 tail attack with 2d6 from Fount of Moonlight.

Average: 81 Maximum: 124

With three attacks as a level 15 fighter, he can't keep that level of damage even expending his class resources like psi dice. For fun, I tried working out how much a paladin of the same level could smite with:

Let's say 1d12+5 base from a greataxe, 1d8 from Radiant Strikes, burn a 4th level spell slot for an extra 5d8 radiant from a Divine Smite. Then a second attack for 1d12+5 and the 1d8 from Radiant Strikes. And let's say Divine Favor was up and so 1d4 for each hit.

Average: 65 Maximum: 98

So in this scenario, the half-caster paladin burning one of their two 4th level spell slots (plus a first level for Divine Favor) doesn't match the full caster druid concentrating on a 4th level Fount of Moonlight as a giant lizard. And I feel it's worth mentioning, at level 15 the Druid has access to 8th level spells so a 4th level slot isn't a big deal even if he loses concentration.

For the most part, I really like the changes made to Moon Druid and think it is an improvement. And I know damage gets crazy at higher levels but like... Should a Moon Druid really be the epitome of damage output?

If anything, I just wish martials could even compare. If my player is feeling it after a couple sessions, I'm curious if anyone else has. Specifically he's mentioned that Druids expend very few resources to be at their peak output, whereas his fighter has to cherish each and every psi die to do less damage than said Druid.

Maybe I'm missing an important buff or spell for martials that could help them keep up but I'm at a loss. Any outside opinion would be appreciated. Thanks!

Edit: should mention, the wildshape stat block is Giant Crocodile (CR 5) which a level 15 Moon Druid is allowed to shift into (CR = Druid Level ÷ 3). Also, Fount of Moon is an action to cast but beyond the Bonus Action to wildshape, the rest is passive.


r/AskDND • • Sep 29 '26

My friend is crashing out about AI image in our DnD campaign

0 Upvotes

I DM a home game, mostly just me and my friends. Lately I've been using PixAI to make character portraits and some manga-style pages of stuff that happened in our sessions. I also made some trading cards of our characters, just for us, not selling anything. Sometimes I use ChatGPT to help write scene descriptions too. One of my friends got pretty upset about it and thinks I shouldn't be using AI art at all.

Not trying to start a fight, just curious:

Has anyone else run into this with their group? How did you handle it?

For stuff that's purely for fun between friends, is it reasonable to ask everyone not to use it? Or should the group just go with whatever makes one person uncomfortable?"


r/AskDND • • Aug 29 '26

Built a mobile app for character creation and in-game full tracking! Looking for people to break it.

0 Upvotes

Hey! My name is Rammy, and I have been working on an app for the past few months for playing DnD with my friends; to create and track everything from levelups, to spell preparation, weapon damage toggles and even inventory and consumable items.

I am currently looking for testers; and don't worry, its completely free to sign up and test the app to your own leisure. I want people to try it at their own tables and attempt to break it or otherwise give any kind of feedback: From the looks, to the feel, to the information completeness; everything matters.

Some details about it:

*It is free to test. I do plan to release it for free, with a lifetime-premium for the option of leveling up characters.

*Its made for 2014 rules and all books related to it.

*When testing, there will be a paywall on levelup - This does not mean you get charged. Its just to test that the payment procedure works.

*Absolutely no data is collected from the app. No sign ups, no nothing. Though, granted, I will have your emails and your feedback.

If you are interested in what this app has to offer and would like to test your wacky characters on it, please sign up to be a tester in this form:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSf-BVTL1hqtvltZL28ZD7JAv3oMB6UUo0h4PsDeLNzlXaui9g/viewform?usp=header

Thank you, and happy dungeon crawling!


r/AskDND • • Aug 23 '26

Need Advice Handling a Player Who Constantly Derails My Story (Autism Included)

0 Upvotes

I’ve been DMing for almost two years now. My group plays once a month, and I put a lot of work into our campaign — reading, prepping, planning, building story beats, designing NPCs, all of it. D&D is how I express myself creatively. It’s my art. After each session, I want to feel accomplished and fulfilled, like the story I worked hard on actually landed.

But I have one player who keeps unintentionally ruining the flow of the game, and I’m struggling with how to handle it without hurting him. He has autism, so some of this is impulse‑control and social‑timing stuff, not malice. I don’t want to kick him out. I just want the game to be fun for everyone, including me.

Here are the issues:

• Whenever I introduce an NPC, he interrupts immediately — usually to flirt with them — before I can even finish describing who they are or why they matter.
• If I try to continue the scene, he cuts me off again to keep flirting or doing something chaotic, even when it’s a serious story moment.
• He argues rules constantly. Example: they were climbing down a cliff on a rope, someone fell, and I called for an Acrobatics check to swing the rope and a Strength check to catch the falling player. He insisted it should be Strength to swing the rope and argued about it mid‑scene, killing the momentum.
• He feels the need to fill every silence and constantly “do something,” which slows the pacing and derails important beats.
• He interrupts narration so often that I can’t get story details out without losing the vibe.

Here’s the thing: he’s actually great at NPC voices and roleplay when he’s given a controlled moment. When he runs an NPC, it’s honestly one of my favorite parts of the session. He brings characters to life in a way nobody else does, and I genuinely appreciate that. I don’t want to lose him. I just need boundaries so the story can breathe.

I snapped at him last session because the constant interruptions and rule arguments wore me down, and I feel bad about it. I want to fix this in a way that respects him, respects the group, and respects the work I put into the game.

Has anyone dealt with something similar?
How do you set boundaries with a player who isn’t trying to be disruptive but is disrupting the game?
Any tips for communicating this clearly and kindly, especially with autism in the mix?

EDIT: I have spoken to him yet this just happened two days ago in giving him time relax before i talk to him this post is mainly how do i talk to him like i said i dont want him to leave but yeah if it doesn’t get better then he will but id like to help and fix it then give up on someone who wants to play this is a great game and want to share it with my friends


r/AskDND • • Aug 15 '26

Answered Kinda uncomfortable question

Post image
42 Upvotes

Ok so I’ve been wondering this for a very long time, I’m a big fan of Darkest Dungeon, and my favorite character in that game is The Occultist, or Alhazred. I’ve always wanted to make a DND character based off him, but I don’t know if it would he perceived as racist or not, considering I’m not Arabic. This is something I’ve really been wrestling with recently, is it weird to even ask this? I have no idea so I’m just putting it out there.


r/AskDND • • Jan 08 '26

Does anyone play D&D alone?

0 Upvotes

Well I was wondering if anyone here play D&D alone and if so how they do it. If they use Ai or one of those modules meant for solo play. And if so if anyone could either recommend an Ai that can be a decent DM or a Good Module to play.

Don't get me wrong, I play with people once a week, but it's also awesome being able to just grab your phone and immerse yourself in your character.


r/AskDND • • Oct 17 '26

Is it possible to make a punk paladin?

2 Upvotes

I wanted to create a Paladin who has sworn an oath to a deity of freedom—or something along those lines—where her highest priority is personal liberty, the freedom of others, and so on. However, after looking through the existing Paladin oaths, none of them seem to fit; many focus on adherence to law or submission to authority—which, while not necessarily in direct conflict with my character’s values, doesn’t really align with them either. So, I’m curious: is there an oath that might be a good fit?

I’m not currently playing—I’m a DM—so there isn’t really anyone for me to negotiate with regarding a custom solution, like creating a new oath or modifying an existing one; this is more of a theoretical question.


r/AskDND • • Dec 03 '25

Answered I somehow have a +16 on all charisma checks now?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Im playing a level 10 halfling gild artisan college of creation bard and, as the rules say, I get 2 expertise, which i beleive doubles proficiency for ability checks for the abilities of 2 skills, and I have chosen 2 charisma skills. Im not sure if I'm allowed to do this, or if I just calculated it wrong.


r/AskDND • • Jul 30 '26

I need inspiration for a character in a campaign starting tonight

1 Upvotes

I need inspiration for a character in a campaign starting tonight the character is a rouge and we are playing a pirate campaign


r/AskDND • • Mar 01 '26

Thoughts on unoptimized characters?

1 Upvotes

A question as old as time. Should you optimize your character? Or let them be busted as heck?

One of my favorite characters that I’m playing right now is a bard, who has basically no buff or healing spells. I personally love her so much, it’s a big part of her personality to ‘not care’ about people (the table does enjoy this, and it’s a running joke that she’s unoptimized). This hasn’t hindered our progress in the slightest and has made it more fun for me to find ways to be a support class with out many classic ‘support’ mechanics.

Anyone have similar thoughts or experiences? Or know how to play into this even more?


r/AskDND • • Aug 02 '26

I was thinking on ways to punish my warlock player if ever they decide to not obey their patron ( ofc, they don't know that that this is the punishment I'm planning if they ever decide to disobey their patron ) and I would like some thoughts, is it good or could it use some tweaking?

0 Upvotes

So.. one of my player's a warlock and I was thinking what if instead of them instantly getting their powers taken away from them ( if they disobey their patron/contract with said patron ) it's insteadg radual ( like say around 3-5ish sessions give or take ) and their character's health slowly deteriorates.. and they eventually start vomiting, looking pale, and they grow weaker by the day until the patron themselves give a warning to the warlock that they will be coming to collect their soul for not obeying their contract/deal, at which point the party urges this player character to seek the help of divine/holy people and they would have to venture alone to resolve this. What do ya'll think?


r/AskDND • • Feb 04 '26

Answered Am I allowed to re arrange my stats?

2 Upvotes

I haven’t been playing DnD very long but after losing my level 2 sorcerer to an unfortunate incident involving an arch demon and a Tarasque I started working on a fighter and kind of submitted the character sheet to my dm before looking at what subclasses there are. Now I think I want to go eldritch knight but rolled aweful on my wis and int is there a way to fix that or will it matter in the long run ?

Thanks everyone who replied and I did spend some time to talk to my DM and after reading some of the comments I decided probably not a big deal if I don’t change my stats I just have to keep it in mind when picking spells

Also about the antics with the legendary monsters I don’t look at it as bad DMing mind you I am a new player but my opinion is that it was supposed to be ment as a look into the future as a reward for some great rolls by the Rogue and my character getting eaten by the Tarasque was a result or my character tripping over his own robe knocking over a box that lead to a mouse trap scale dominoes that end with the lock to the Tarasque cage being opened then continues to get worse when I stumbled get on my horse when we started running giving the monster enough time to catch up.


r/AskDND • • Apr 07 '26

Answered First proper character and I would like assistance please.

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hello, I am fairly new to DND. I have done a campaign before, but I had a lot of help with all the gimmicks and character creation. Anyway, I wanted to create my own character for a new campaign with a different group. I wanted a samurai subclass based on Jin Sakai from Ghost of Tsushima, but I didn't know how to do it (didn't use DND beyond because it does not have the samurai subclass or so I've heard), so I had help from AI and I did some of my own research. I just want to know if I did everything correctly and if this character is too over/under powered. Also, I don't know how to do equipment/inventory. If anyone is willing to assist, I would appreciate it. Thanks!

Edit: I didn't realize the top got cut off of the screenshot, but she is a multi-class level 5 fighter and a level 3 rouge.


r/AskDND • • Mar 21 '26

What characters in one piece would you say would be the most challenging or the most interesting to stat build around?

0 Upvotes

r/AskDND • • Sep 12 '26

Am i in the wrong?

0 Upvotes

Okay so a little context. I am the dm of a dnd campaign with friends we all know each other from highschool and even primary school for some (we just graduated hs).About 4 or 5 sessions deep my players stop by in a city. They were on an story relevant escort quest and the plot would have them stop there for rest and fun times yk the whole ordeal.

They went shopping, identity items,the barbarian beat the champion of the arena and thus became the new one.. they cheated. They always do lol. Anywhos while the 5 man party was split in two groups one of 3 one of 2 the lather went into the slums of the city looking for weapons. The shadow sorcerer being a slumy background went to the item/weapon shop he knew existed. Arrived at the destination they come to newer renovated building it is still an item shop it is simply disguised as a fancy mob ranned bar. Entering the shop a single npc stands at the counter fancy dressed he understands threw the dialogues that they are interested in purchasing weapons he then reveals the password to see the list of hidden contraband. Its vaguely named things such as : thing that hurts 100g :thing that really hurts 300g :thing that really fucking hurts 600g. Yeah… safe to say i didnt had the item list made up for this lol. They buy for 400g worth of items and get told to open the second door to the right. Opening the door stand a single silver coffer id say about a cubic feet big standing there. The door closes behind them. They open the chest and insides lays a magical dagger. After not finding the other item they storm down the room to confront the npc. As they lash out on him he tells them that they had to close then reopen the coffer to make the item appear which is a locally known gimmick that they obviously wouldn’t know about he also tells them that they have to come back in 48 hours to retrieve it. They afterwards try to break in the building to no avail due to a magical force field blocking the windows. After a successful arcana check dc17 they understood it was an entity’s domain and they could not enter it without its permission.

Alright thats where it gets crunchy. The mob boss is a reasonably high level warlock that has a deal with his patron to make him summon magic items in trade for a cut of the rewards of the sale like 60%. He has the the item shop as a kind of side hustle i thought it was a pretty cool concept. The contracts he made with his patron are a bit ambiguous because it has to reach certain conditions to make the magic items appear as in it can only appear one at a time in a silver coffers in a locked chamber and only a willing creature he made sure of it for business purposes. Anywhos the monk player feeling robbed and deceived gathers the party back and convinces them to go beat up the barman npc to get his honor refurbished in vengeance (his words) and get his money back.

After doing so they get absolutely no much further because the barman can genuinely do nothing about it its completely out of his control. After this the session ends a bit later as they prepare to leave the city to pursue the quest (he never tried to convince the quest npc to wait a little longer so he can get his item) in all of this… we went thru 20% of my preparation advanced the quest 0% in a 4h30 session. Which i dont really mind city episodes are always like this lol but the monk player was so frustrated about it the whole session about it saying things like he will burn the building down (the bar) even tho he got a really cool magical item that he split the price down the half with the sorc.

I like no i love to hear feedback from my players so after the session we had a kindof argument him saying that he had no counter play from getting scammed and that he couldn’t possibly know thus making it unfair and that unfair wasn’t fun and it made the game frustrating. I didn’t really know what to say back to him honestly i personally didn’t really see the big issue i just felt like it was a realistic outcome of events. And i even made attempts to make him understand the situation like saying :okay so you open the chest tell me exactly what you do with it : so you just open it like that and nothing else : as you leave the room are you sure you closing the door?. He even acknowledged it but refused it saying it would be meta gaming. Fair i do agree with that but like cmonnn mann im trying my best😭.

That was it for me id like to hear from you guys :)

(Sorry guys for the original post it was realllyyyyyy roughly written i added some paragraphs and tried to clean it up a bit)


r/AskDND • • Jul 09 '26

Is a Nat-20 always good?

0 Upvotes

WIP!!! (And this is also for my first campaign and homebrew, so I am still trying to even just under how to do the DM)

I was thinking, does nat twenty always have to be good, while thinking about some possible thing that would happen in my campaign I thought about a special (optional) boss, to make a long story short, it is a being beyond humans comprehension

And I was thinking that when the party meets them I should make them throw a perception check, the lower they get the less their character actually sees of this being, so like, a one sees a "normal" person, a five probably something uncanny, and so on until the possible twenty could actually receive damage and a (temporary) blindness because they saw too much.

How does this idea sound? And what are other moments where a nat twenty could be the worst outcome?

Edit: I should specify, the entity isn't hostile from the start, so it wouldn't be the start of the encounter and the player will have easy access to healing.

Edit edit: I'm changing it so that the effects are the same but the other way around, net twenty is fine, nat one gets the debuff, but keep giving me your opinions on it

Edit edit edit: I heard, and to make things clearer I'll explain the character that I have in mind (so you can judge that too), this character is the god of chaos (loosely based on Azathoth), they aren't hostile by any means (so much so that in there battle I plan on finding a way to make it clear that for him the battle is just for entrainment and doesn't plan to kill), the reason why I'd make the throw it's because being god of chaos (and one of the two primordial beings) he's mostly outside human competition, and the party would arrive in a moment where she doesn't except it so they would be in a "compatible form", with a chance to hurt the player that see menage to get a good with (with all the beyond completion and stuff), but then they would be hostile, so it's not like I am debuffing before a fight (and if they are in a bad state I could always have the entity heal them in their own way). This is just to make the player understand that it's a being that if he wanted (which they don't) could probably over power the Main antagonist

Last small detail, the entire campaign revolves around going against gods, so it's not a jump from human Main antagonists to horror beyond their competition. Hope that clarified something that might have been left lacking. Still, give me your honest opinion.


r/AskDND • • Jan 03 '26

Start off I’m a bit of a jerk

2 Upvotes

So my coworker started a homebrew game. We a small group so just a dm and 3 players. I’m an old time player but was not familiar with the new editions. His pitch was the world is new with no gods and we were going to be eventually the new gods..

We have a ranger who won’t cast spells, sorc/war he became second level first game. Me cleric. We are not a cohesive party at all.

First game we stuck in a cave with no memories other than we died numerous times ground hog day mechanics. Ugh war sells soul to trapped deamon. He Gains a level. No equipment no money we get out and to town. I a cleric of the god of order. Find out he’s an asshole that will destroy and murder to keep order.

So I’m getting frustrated. Nothing drops any loot or money. All his creatures are home brew so we lost on how to fight half of them. Cursed items l, scenarios on train tracks with abilites that would take wishes to achieve just to have the effect he wants. I get tricked into taken a cursed time to track dead souls and claim them. Ohh I was torturing them. 5e clerics suck. I hate the concentration mechanic. We can’t go anywhere without getting exhausted. No food.

We have a scenario with invulnerable plot npc#5 who picks apart every decision we made making us the bad guys. Party sends undead ogre through town killing innocent. I retire character tell him I want to go to tavern never leave and drink my self to a stupor. 1 year into this game no loot level 5 10 gp to our names. Plot… keeps hinting at it we still haven’t left the starter town.

Ok new char, tell them I come to town because of a vision of me surrounded by dead bodies me in tears blood soaked hands. Dm calls me a dirt hobo I am now the joke party so I lean into and start telling ridiculous stories about my former fried Eric, his 2 brothers Eric and the sister I have a crush on. Now level 7 one magic item. 1 1/2 year into game still really don’t understand what’s goin on.

I ask to run an adventure. My character leaves for side quest. It has my back story they meet Eric and Eric jr. he tells them my crush died in a bandit raid 30 years ago (I’m a wood elf) Eric is old and tell the story that we got back at the end of the raid and I went wild and wiped out a bunch of bandits and one of the towns people saw me surrounded by dead bodies. Runs off into the mountains. My character name was not my name but the name of my younger brother who died in a bandit raid. So my character who tells stupid stories is broken. My gm runs ends and he picks up with me being sent to take out bandits with a new magical helm. Cursed

I take out the bandits with strange this happening missed swing basically illusions thought the gm was playing on my trauma. Nope the bandits were a normal town and I killed reg people and Eric jr.

I told the gm he’s sadistic and my character walks into the woods and I will be rolling another character….

One my feats is lucky. I told a stupid story of how a gremlin no one else can see appears and plays tricks on me but I usually just kill it. He ran with it and now it has the ability to shape reality and make me see and have realistic fights with illusions. So after I realize I killed Eric jr it appears and starts taunting me. Ugh a simple joke story gm has been trying to make this character life miserable.

So eric sr paid the characters to track me down. Ohh I’m cursed now and can’t die…. My plan is they find me on a rock over looking the river. My hood is up and I’m rocking. I don’t respond to greetings. When they touch me I will turn around blood from my eyes and ears have soaked my tunic. My eyes and ears have been gouged out. I say “I don’t hear or see the gremlin anymor” I point to my head and smile “I’m smart…. “ And start to cackle.

Im frustrated, i know ima jerk. But…

I need this time with my friends but I won’t sacrifice (dignity?) inner peace?

Suggestions?


r/AskDND • • Mar 03 '26

The Bard Class

2 Upvotes

Hey, I've been watching Videos about the Bard D&D class and gotta say it sounds interesting. Thing is that some people say it's good, some say it's bad so I wanted to know what the general consensus is, is it good? Is it bad? Also, what do you think is the best subclass for it?