I’m planning on getting vertical retaining I-Beams that is. One wall has dead man anchors (bolts on plates attached to rods which attach to buried concrete piece 10 feet away from house). I thought this was a foolproof solution (based on what the pre purchase structural engineer said) with no downsides until the second quote pointed something out.
—————————————-——————————————
First quote:
Had a guy come out from the highest rated foundation repair company on Google. He seemed a little out of his realm, but just struck me as someone at the company’s son. He didn’t explain much, but his quote says:
“Break concrete at each support location exposing foundation footer.
-secure bottom/lower end of steel I beam using high strength concrete.
-secure top/upper end of steel I beams to sill plate and framing members using treated
lumber and structural fasteners”.
This is good because I’ve heard that sometimes they bolt into the existing basement floor without any other pour, and that just doesn’t seem like a secure way of doing it to me.
Price is $6000 for the two walls that I noticed bowing, besides the one with anchors (that I thought was an okay system).
Second quote:
My boss recommended these guys but they only have 4.0 stars on Google.
The guy went downstairs and I pointed out the anchor system, to which he immediately said “oh that’s weird, they usually put the plates higher, where the wall is actually bowing”. I looked at it and he’s right. The anchors are on the lower third of wall whereas the bowing is most significant right in the center (pictured). He then pointed out that the west wall (pictured with a wood shelf for reference) also has bowing. He remarked “I can’t believe a bank would finance this” which honestly kind of scared me. I then asked if, when they install, they pour a footing, to which he said “no we just bolt to the basement floor” (yikes imo).
He then wrote me two quotes, one for the three walls without anchors at $7000, one with all four walls (including the anchor wall) for $9500.
—————————————-——————————————
I’m considering calling the first company and having them do all four walls for what I’d assume would be $12k (just doubling their quote). The second guy did explain better but I’m not sure if I trust a basement floor to counter the force of hydrostatic pressure.
Is this the right move? Should I get more quotes? Any advice?