r/AskALiberal • • 6h ago

I'm for the Second Amendment BUT... walk me through the thought process of this. Can you actually square being 'pro 2a' yet wanting to ban things like 'assault weapons'?

0 Upvotes

I hear this constantly and every argument so far has been contrary to the purpose of the second amendment which is violence against the tyrannical, small or big scale does not matter.

"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

"Drafting and Ratification: The amendment was part of the Bill of Rights, ratified in 1791, balancing the need for national defense through citizen militias with concerns about government overreach."


r/AskALiberal • • 9h ago

What is the chance the National popular vote will win a lawsuit?

10 Upvotes

One of the big stories coming out of the election has been all the talk about Dems new trifectas and how they will join the Popular vote compact. Dems in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin have already stated their intentions. No doubt, Republicans and groups like Heritage Foundation and Federalist Society are preparing to lawyer up and pushing judges to strike this down. Does anyone think this will survive legal standing? What incentive would there be for conservatives to back this, given how much they benefit from the electoral college?


r/AskALiberal • • 9h ago

If a 3% wealth tax on billionaires is deemed constitutional, would that mean that a 10% or even a 20% wealth tax on billionaires and/or a 10% wealth tax on millionaires would also be constitutional and something that could be, at least theoretically, implemented in practice?

2 Upvotes

Thoughts? Concerns?


r/AskALiberal • • 12h ago

Do you view Assyrian and Kurdish nationalism, as well as Lebanese Phoenicianism, as legitimate expressions of indigenous identity and cultural self-determination?

2 Upvotes

So I'm assuming most people here aren't really familiar with who the Assyrians are, but to provide a short summary, they're an ethnoreligious group indigenous to northern Mesopotamia who traditionally practice Syriac Christianity. They use Classical Syriac, a form of Aramaic, as their liturgical language, while some communities continue to speak modern Neo-Aramaic dialects in their everyday lives.

Modern Assyrians generally identify themselves as descendants of the ancient Assyrians, whose civilization once dominated much of Mesopotamia and the surrounding regions. Although their language, religion, and culture have changed quite a bit over the last 2,000 years, they have maintained a distinct ethnocultural identity despite the gradual Arabization and Islamization of much of the Middle East following the Arab conquests of the seventh century. Today, Assyrians continue to live in Iraq, Syria, Turkey, and Iran, although many also live in diaspora communities in Detroit, Chicago, San Diego, Sydney, and Melbourne.

Among the Assyrians, there is a faction that believes their people should have their own independent nation-state within their ancestral homeland, particularly in northern Mesopotamia. While some Assyrians favor autonomy within existing countries, those advocating for independence want a sovereign Assyrian state within their historical homeland, which spans parts of northern Iraq (particularly the Nineveh Plains), northeastern Syria (Al-Hasakah), southeastern Turkey (Tur Abdin and Hakkari), and northwestern Iran (around Urmia).

With the Kurds, I'm assuming most people here are probably more familiar with them. They're an Iranian ethnolinguistic group whose traditional homeland, commonly referred to as Kurdistan, stretches across southeastern Turkey, northern Iraq, northeastern Syria, and northwestern Iran. Unlike the Assyrians, most Kurds are Sunni Muslims (not including the Yazidis). Kurdish nationalism has existed for some time, particularly since the collapse of the Ottoman Empire after World War I. Some Kurdish nationalists advocate for the establishment of an independent Kurdistan, while others prefer autonomy within their respective countries. In Iraq, the Kurds already have an autonomous region with their own government and parliament, and in 2017, they even held an independence referendum in which the overwhelming majority voted in favor of independence. However, the referendum never resulted in the establishment of an independent Kurdish state.

The Kurds of Syria, under the al-Sharaa administration, have also faced some recent developments. During the Syrian Civil War, Kurdish-led forces established a de facto autonomous administration in northeastern Syria. However, following clashes with the Syrian government in January 2026, the SDF agreed to integrate its military and governing institutions into the Syrian state. By August 2026, the SDF had formally dissolved as an independent military organization. Although the al-Sharaa administration has recognized Kurdish cultural and linguistic rights, there are still disagreements over how much autonomy Kurdish communities should have and whether their rights will be permanently protected under Syria's future constitution.

Finally, we have Phoenicianism, which emerged primarily among the Lebanese Maronites (named after Saint Maron). Lebanese Maronites who support Phoenicianism generally believe that the Arabization of Lebanon gradually erased much of their pre-Arab Canaanite/Levantine culture, as they view Arab culture as originally foreign to the Levant.

These Lebanese Christians also utilized Phoenicianism to distinguish themselves from the rise of Pan-Arabism, which had greater support among many of their Lebanese Sunni, Druze, and Shia counterparts. For these Christian nationalists, Lebanon was a distinct nation with its own history and identity, rather than another part of the broader Arab world. Phoenicianism became especially prominent during the Lebanese Civil War, as the Phalangists believed that maintaining a separate Lebanese identity was necessary to preserve Lebanon's independence and the safety of its Christian communities.

Furthermore, some proponents went so far as to reject the idea that Lebanese Arabic was actually Arabic, arguing instead that it was a separate language descended from ancient Phoenician. However, unlike Assyrian and Kurdish nationalists who advocate for their own independent states, Phoenicianists generally aren't seeking to establish a new country; instead, they want the modern-day state of Lebanon to return to its Cannaite/Levantine roots and abandon Arab culture entirely.

With all that said, I'm curious what you guys think about these three movements, especially since they all have different ideas about what nationalism should look like. Do you see them as legitimate expressions of indigenous identity, or do you think they can become problematic when other ethnic groups also call these places home?


r/AskALiberal • • 13h ago

After 9/11 my liberal professors instilled in us that constitutional rights can NEVER be suspended or curtailed because of a national emergency. I assumed this was was a deeply held liberal value. So what happened between then and Covid?

0 Upvotes

Rights in question in the case of Covid were assembly and religion as people were being arrested for protesting the lockdowns and churches were ordered to close.


r/AskALiberal • • 16h ago

Do you believe the FAA and Duffy?

22 Upvotes

Duffy was on Meet the Press and basically said, "give us money or this will happen again and lives will be at risk." I couldn't believe he said it. I've very skeptical this was a "router" issue. Blaming it on L3Harris, I'm not buying it.


r/AskALiberal • • 21h ago

Is everyone morally required to be open about their opinions on divisive topics?

1 Upvotes

Recently people have been wanting Metallica to get canceled because Janes Hetfield called out people who share political opinions on stage, most likely calling out Macklemore. The people who are vocal about this are basically saying "you must be openly political about global/social issues, otherwise you are a bad person." For me, I don't think pushing people to be neutral about a literal genocide is good, but I also don't think a full blown cancellation is a good idea. James seems like a great guy.

What are your thoughts? Is the cancellation justified?


r/AskALiberal • • 21h ago

Would you agree that there’s an urgent need for the legislatures of Wisconsin and Minnesota to start implementing independent redistricting committees?

8 Upvotes

I think Wisconsin is the clearest case of this. WI Republicans have shown that they are more than willing to gerrymander the maps to a very ridiculous level, especially when they have the governorship. Wisconsin is not a state that Democrats are going to win a majority in every election in, especially at the state governmental level, but we can make it so that we have a fair shot when we exit power.

I think referring a state level redistricting proposition to Wisconsinites as a ballot initiative is in the top 5 of state level critical legislative priorities.

A congressional level redistricting committee is much more debatable, because there’s no real scenario where Wisconsin Dems don’t win a fair state legislature election but still also retain the US House. I’m open to either option here.

Minnesota matters because it consistently nets a one to two seat majority in each legislative chamber while electing Democrat governors, but it’s one you’d want to shore up in case a Republican wins one day.


r/AskALiberal • • 22h ago

Is there a work of fiction that built a world that particularly resonated with you as how the world should be according to your politics/ideals?

2 Upvotes

If so, how plausible do you think it would be to get there?


r/AskALiberal • • 23h ago

150 million people would move to the United States if the US had open borders. What do you think?

0 Upvotes

This is proven by a Gallup poll. The same poll also says 45 million would move to the United Kingdom, 42 million to Canada, 32 million to France, 26 million to Australia, another 26 million to Germany, 25 million to Spain, 18 million to Italy, 9 million to Switzerland, 6 million to Sweden, and like a few million to the Republic of Ireland, Portugal, Austria, Belgium, Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, Finland, Greece and New Zealand.

I think 70 to 80 percent of these potential migrants would be solid unpersuadable Democratic voters, and 95 to 99 percent of Muslim immigrants. My opinion, I may be wrong. I don't think black descendants of immigrants have the same politics as those who are the descendants of African slaves brought to the United States.

What do you think?

EDIT 1 (AT THE REQUEST OF A MODERATOR): https://news.gallup.com/poll/153992/150-million-adults-worldwide-migrate.aspx

EDIT 2: What I meant by "95 to 99 percent of Muslim immigrants" is that this would be the percentage of Muslim votes that would go Democratic, not that 95 to 99 percent of all these 150 million would be Muslim.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Opinion on France's proposed 5.5 cent per gigabyte tax on internet traffic?

10 Upvotes

The whole tax is that internet content providers would have to pay 5.5 cents per gigabyte of data delivered to French users. It is important to mention that the tax is capped at 2% of the company's total revenue or 15% of the company's total revenue generated in France, whichever is lowest.

It has generated quite a bit of opposition that the company behind VLC media player alleged that they'd have to pay over €1 mln on taxes.

The people who proposed the tax claim that it would bring in €10 bln in revenue for the French treasury.

It still is pretty far from becoming law since it only got adopted as an ammendment to the 2027 budget by like a single vote and it will be voted on again it can still always be removed from the budget.

So is such a tax a good idea or a bad idea in your minds?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

What do you think of these Covered CA promo videos?

0 Upvotes

Covered CA is the health insurance marketplace run by the state of California. Do you have any comments or concerns about their promo videos? See https://www.youtube.com/@CoveredCA/videos .

I'm not going to give my take but I draw your attention to "For the Love of Californians :90" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iovSOy5QaIo). See any issues with their depictions of my fellow residents?

Then there's their latest set (the videos at https://postimg.cc/LqBWmd8V except for the upper left). The languages are Tagalog, Vietnamese, Hindi, Chinese, and Korean. They all use the same images.

There's also "Déjanos ayudarte a encontrar el plan de salud que más te convenga" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eiqIbzPVkzs). See anything there?

And, there's "Backyard :30" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxHUBwVxvqs).

Maybe this video of CoveredCA employees (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v50pruvjDmQ) and https://www.linkedin.com/posts/sandrofusco_coveredca-leadership-healthcare-activity-6986866524431015936-Lrg5 might be informative.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

What is the best solution to deal with Iran?

1 Upvotes

Trump and Hegseth has pretty much done irreversible damage and I don't see how a deal can be made without Iran prioritizing getting nukes in the future. Which means there probably will be a nuclear war in the ME sometime in the future (near or far).

Looking back, it looks like Obama/Kerry's nuclear deal was probably the best and least violent way to contain Iran's nuclear ambitions.

This is a quagmire with very serious consequences. Damned if you do and damned if you don't.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

What do you think is the likelihood of a catastrophic AI incident happening soon?

6 Upvotes

There’s really no shortage of doomer, prepper type info circulating these days, especially with all the AI hacks occurring (black October, the crypto hacks, UK freezers etc)

What do you think is the likelihood of a really catastrophic AI hacks that takes down our electric grid or water or something?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Will the Democratic party follow a similar trajectory to the Labour party in the UK on trans issues?

7 Upvotes

Hello, I am a trans woman who is obviously from America. Over the past few years, we've witnessed the Labour party entirely abandon trans people and concede to far right anti trans talking points, essentially leaving the UK with no major political party that will actually defend the rights and dignity of trans Brits. In this most recent election, many democratic politicians have conceded to far right talking points on trans people or even actively ran on attacking our rights (like the senator elect from iowa, I forget his name). Several anti trans ballot props also succeeded even in very blue states. Given that this strategy was implemented during an election where Democrats saw incredible electoral gains, this makes me immensely afraid that, come 2028, the democratic party may entirely abandon trans people like the labour party or even make attacks against trans rights part of the democratic party platform. Is this a reasonable fear for me to have? What do other people think about this topic?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Why is Jensen Huang not viewed as a victim?

0 Upvotes

I'm not referring to his affairs with coworkers (including direct report). I'm specifically referring to his relationship with the Chinese spy, which has potential serious national security and economic consequences.

Alice Huang, if she is a Chinese spy, obviously is manipulating Jensen Huang. They planted her at Megaspeed (the Singaporean company that bought Nvidia chips) in part to develop a relationship with Jensen, through manipulation, psychological operations, etc.

Lets bring it home to make it clear how Jensen is the victim here. We've all had or know of women who have been manipulated by their boyfriends and husbands. I say women because typically it's the men who are the "operatives" and the women the victim, although it goes the other way as well, just less common. Boyfriends and husbands manipulate women, gaslighting them, lying to them, etc. They use women to support them financially, sexually, etc. 5 minutes on social media and you can see so many stories of women being mentally manipulated by men, working full them jobs to support their lazy boyfriends, etc.

We view these women as victims of male manipulation and "abuse" (not legal abuse). We don't tell these women, "you should have known better". Jensen Huang, in some sense, is like these women. Victim of a coordinated manipulation campaign by the Chinese, fronted by Alice Huang. But obviously she had much assistance.

Does it bother you that Jensen is not being seen as a man who was a mark and is a victim here?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Is there any energy among Liberals and people further left to get the Epstien files released?

0 Upvotes

I know there is debate about exactly how much oversight to carry out once the Democrats take power. People further left are calling for impeachment of Trump and investigations into everyone involved in this administrations crimes and corruption, but then there are people who worry about squandering the Democratic party's momentum and believe Democrats need to get something done or at least get caught trying.

I am wondering why I'm not seeing more discussion from the left about the Epstien files.

That seems to be popular and could lead to impeachment of Trump.

Is there any energy to apply more pressure on Epstien? If there isn't, why do you think that is?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Do you think the MAGA popular movement is now dead? If you do, what does its base do now? If you don't, what are the next steps to address them?

18 Upvotes

For all the negatives of Trump, one thing that always seem to hang with him is a seemingly unshakeable base of support. Even now he still maintains a ~30% approval rating as a lame-duck president who ushered in a historic blue wave. That's not really surprising and I don't ever expect him to go below 30%. To be clear, this is a president who has tried extremely hard to appear like a fascist (not even touching on if and where he was successful) while being an obvious financial and sex criminal.

What can or should be done about this base? It seems like regardless of what happens with Democrats in the next few years, having roughly a third of the adult population be pretty openly amenable and supportive of fascism is an issue. Another version of Trump, presumably younger and more competent, seems somewhat inevitable if not.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Is it plausible that the lack of attention to Europe’s age of consent laws is related to racism? And why do you think it gets so much less attention than older adults dating 18/19 year olds?

0 Upvotes

I find it odd that Europe is seen as this bastion of moral superiority when they have age of consents ranging from 14 to 16. I also find it odd that it gets so little attention compared to, say, the multitude of cases where people date 18 or 19 year olds here in the US.

People make all sorts of justifications for it such as the fact many of these nation have a “superior position” exemption that raises the age to 18, but the age of consent by default is still low.

If anything, it’s jarring to see how Muslims are accused of pedophilia sympathizing when Europe has essentially enshrined pedophilia sympathizing.

Why do you think this doesn’t get much attention?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Is there an argument that Scott Colom, Adam Hamilton, and Annie Andrews will likely be the most powerful people in the Senate given they all have seats they are much more likely than not to lose in 2032?

8 Upvotes

These three Senators all won their seats in huge upsets and will have to defend their seats in 2032, which, especially if we have a Democrat president, is in the highly difficult to impossible category.

I think this makes them the three most powerful Senators. They know they have 6 years and they can vote their conscience instead of focusing on an improbable re-election.

You could add Talarico and Peltola here but their re electability difficulties are far less certain imo.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

What are some arguments against a Wealth Tax?

3 Upvotes

First off, I am not an economist, so I'm viewing the problem from a very basic perspective. Based on these facts, I support a wealth tax.

  • Our current debt is 40 trillion

  • The stock market is worth around $ 78 trillion.

  • The top 10 percent wealthiest households own around 88% of the stock market.

  • The bottom 90 percent hold around 12%, mainly composed of 401ks and IRAs

  • Stocks are unrealized, so they are not taxed until realized.

  • Stocks can be used as collateral for private loans.

  • 401k, high-yield savings, pension, etc all pay taxes. 401 (k) s can't be used for private loans.

So when I first discovered these things. I immediately saw this as a blatantly rigged system. Why are all the financial avenues the bottom 90 percent use taxed, while the system the top 10 percent use is untaxed? Now I understand that the bottom 90 percent can trade stocks; however, in reality the average American doesn't have the money to take advantage of the stock market like the top 10 percent.

Now I am aware of certain issues, mainly regarding retirees whose 401(k)s and other retirement accounts could be affected by a wealth tax; however, I don't think that supersedes the need for a wealth tax. When I discovered these facts, I couldn't wrap my head around why people would be against taxing the wealthy. The main arguments I hear on this sub and others like r/askaconservative are basically calling it "theft", " "it will kill growth and innovation", " The wealthy pay more in tax" or " The government want use the money correctly".

What else am I missing?

Edit: I got educated here on the post. Although I said I'd be for a wealth tax what I am actually describing is more of a progressive tax on capital gains that is aimed to target the wealthy and close off loopholes

This is my idea and the numbers aren't to important:

Your stock portfolio on Jan 1st has to be filed as a " Yearly Portfolio Value (YPV)" you hold that price until Jan 1st of next year. Say your YPV for 2026 was $10,000 and on Jan 1st of 2027 You're YPV is now 30,000 that 20,000 all taxable. Being that you're under a certain dollar amount say it would be like 1%. Then if you get a YPV jump of like 100k you pay 2%. If your YPV start at 30,000 Jan 1st 2026 then drops to 10,000 in 2027, you pay no taxes on you YPV.

I think this would be a good way to ensure money doesn't stay hoarded in the stock market and stops the while "Borrow until you Die" strat that many of the top 10 percent use. Also, i think it also gives incentive to stay in the market since you're not beimg punished for losing on your investment.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

What should the left do about the porn industry? Ban it, leave it the way it is, or just stricter regulations?

0 Upvotes

This is a pretty divisive topic, because i've seen people advocating for different things. Some say it's harmful to women, others believe everyone has the right to do whatever they want with their lives. I really don't have an opinion, but i think it'd be interesting to propose some solid policies for our political representatives here in the US and other countries.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

Should businesses be allowed to blankety ban minors?

11 Upvotes

My local McDonald's banned under 18s from entering the establishment after school hours (2-6 PM) unless accompanied by an adult. I get that they had problems with rowdy teens, but this policy blanketly applies to all minors regardless of how they behave.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

How come liberals in the US seem less concerned about immigrations' effect on wages, housing availability, and workers' rights than the liberals in Canada, Europe, Australia, New Zealand, etc.?

0 Upvotes

The liberal parties in Canada, UK, Australia, New Zealand, etc. often express concerns about immigrants being exploited for cheap labor with worse conditions. They also argue that mass immigration can compress wages, rise housing costs, inflation, overcrowding/overpopulation, and straining public services such as healthcare, education, social benefits, etc. In other words, they use left-wing and economic arguments against immigration

It seems Democrats in the US don't bring up these concerns nearly as much as the center-left parties in the rest of the world.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

Why do Democrats seem willing to come rightward on social issues, but not on economics?

0 Upvotes

A big narrative from the mid-terms is the fact that a lot of moderate Democrats won, but a lot of these moderates are just people who are pro-welfare and pro-border control, but this is the worst of both worlds imo.

Why do we never see any who are the other way around? The Democrats seem to refuse to budge on the economic policies they've had for the past decade. They will back off on immigration, but they won't back off welfare, they won't back off universal healthcare, they won't back off wealth taxes. Moderate Democrats now are at least as economically progressive as Obama, if not more, and Obama was already more economically progressive than the Clinton Democrats that held the office for his party before him.

If there were Democrats who were highly pro-market, but also pro-immigration and most other standard Democrat social issues, I'd probably support them over most modern Republicans. But those people don't seem prominent in the Democrat party, if they even exist.