So I'm assuming most people here aren't really familiar with who the Assyrians are, but to provide a short summary, they're an ethnoreligious group indigenous to northern Mesopotamia who traditionally practice Syriac Christianity. They use Classical Syriac, a form of Aramaic, as their liturgical language, while some communities continue to speak modern Neo-Aramaic dialects in their everyday lives.
Modern Assyrians generally identify themselves as descendants of the ancient Assyrians, whose civilization once dominated much of Mesopotamia and the surrounding regions. Although their language, religion, and culture have changed quite a bit over the last 2,000 years, they have maintained a distinct ethnocultural identity despite the gradual Arabization and Islamization of much of the Middle East following the Arab conquests of the seventh century. Today, Assyrians continue to live in Iraq, Syria, Turkey, and Iran, although many also live in diaspora communities in Detroit, Chicago, San Diego, Sydney, and Melbourne.
Among the Assyrians, there is a faction that believes their people should have their own independent nation-state within their ancestral homeland, particularly in northern Mesopotamia. While some Assyrians favor autonomy within existing countries, those advocating for independence want a sovereign Assyrian state within their historical homeland, which spans parts of northern Iraq (particularly the Nineveh Plains), northeastern Syria (Al-Hasakah), southeastern Turkey (Tur Abdin and Hakkari), and northwestern Iran (around Urmia).
With the Kurds, I'm assuming most people here are probably more familiar with them. They're an Iranian ethnolinguistic group whose traditional homeland, commonly referred to as Kurdistan, stretches across southeastern Turkey, northern Iraq, northeastern Syria, and northwestern Iran. Unlike the Assyrians, most Kurds are Sunni Muslims (not including the Yazidis). Kurdish nationalism has existed for some time, particularly since the collapse of the Ottoman Empire after World War I. Some Kurdish nationalists advocate for the establishment of an independent Kurdistan, while others prefer autonomy within their respective countries. In Iraq, the Kurds already have an autonomous region with their own government and parliament, and in 2017, they even held an independence referendum in which the overwhelming majority voted in favor of independence. However, the referendum never resulted in the establishment of an independent Kurdish state.
The Kurds of Syria, under the al-Sharaa administration, have also faced some recent developments. During the Syrian Civil War, Kurdish-led forces established a de facto autonomous administration in northeastern Syria. However, following clashes with the Syrian government in January 2026, the SDF agreed to integrate its military and governing institutions into the Syrian state. By August 2026, the SDF had formally dissolved as an independent military organization. Although the al-Sharaa administration has recognized Kurdish cultural and linguistic rights, there are still disagreements over how much autonomy Kurdish communities should have and whether their rights will be permanently protected under Syria's future constitution.
Finally, we have Phoenicianism, which emerged primarily among the Lebanese Maronites (named after Saint Maron). Lebanese Maronites who support Phoenicianism generally believe that the Arabization of Lebanon gradually erased much of their pre-Arab Canaanite/Levantine culture, as they view Arab culture as originally foreign to the Levant.
These Lebanese Christians also utilized Phoenicianism to distinguish themselves from the rise of Pan-Arabism, which had greater support among many of their Lebanese Sunni, Druze, and Shia counterparts. For these Christian nationalists, Lebanon was a distinct nation with its own history and identity, rather than another part of the broader Arab world. Phoenicianism became especially prominent during the Lebanese Civil War, as the Phalangists believed that maintaining a separate Lebanese identity was necessary to preserve Lebanon's independence and the safety of its Christian communities.
Furthermore, some proponents went so far as to reject the idea that Lebanese Arabic was actually Arabic, arguing instead that it was a separate language descended from ancient Phoenician. However, unlike Assyrian and Kurdish nationalists who advocate for their own independent states, Phoenicianists generally aren't seeking to establish a new country; instead, they want the modern-day state of Lebanon to return to its Cannaite/Levantine roots and abandon Arab culture entirely.
With all that said, I'm curious what you guys think about these three movements, especially since they all have different ideas about what nationalism should look like. Do you see them as legitimate expressions of indigenous identity, or do you think they can become problematic when other ethnic groups also call these places home?