r/AskALiberal • • Feb 20 '22

Do you believe Canada's actions against peaceful protestors is a dangerous precedent?

72 Upvotes

I ask because it how blown my mind how one side of the aisle is remaining quiet on this issue.

Regardless of how you feel about vaccine mandates, we are currently watching a western democracy break up and punish peaceful protestors.

Trudeau has claimed that the protestors are hurting the Canadian economy, but doesn't that just mean that their protest is effective? Should governments be allowed to break up protests whose only crime is being effective?

It seems that liberals are largely ignoring the dangerous precedent of the government saying "Hey, your protests against the government are too effective. We are going to break it up, de-bank you, and dissuade you from speaking out against the government ever again."


r/AskALiberal • • Oct 01 '25

Can people stop saying doomer BS like “There won’t be elections in 2026/2028”?

7 Upvotes

I see this take a lot on Reddit, with people even spreading the disinformation that elections can be cancelled during a war. I actually saw a guy say that 2028 isn’t going to happen but 2026 was “debatable”. And I'm sorry but this is 100% disinformation: states run elections, not the federal government, so it's impossible to cancel them. Also, war has never cancelled elections (see: the Civil War and WWII).

So, genuinely, can we (as in anti-Trump redditors) stop spreading this bullshit all over the website? Not trying to soapbox but I’m worried about how the spreading of this take could lower voter turnout, as if people become convinced elections can be rigged or cancelled, they won’t vote come 2026 and 2028 and instead play GTA 6, lowering voter turnout, and we all know how low voter turnout went in 2024.


r/AskALiberal • • Mar 14 '25

Do pro Palestine progressives really not know what “From the River to the Sea” means?

3 Upvotes

I was on r/stickers and I was seeing at first what looked like some awesome pro LGBT stickers but the second picture had 2 stickers I raised my eyebrow with.

One was a “Gays for Palestine” sticker which… as a trans person I REALLY don’t get since it’s like a “Chickens for KFC” sticker. But that is a whole separate can of worms.

The main one I am pointing out was one that used the phrase “From the River to Sea” as a “Free Palestine” message. In the comments a bunch of people were saying they oppose genocide and such but I gotta wonder… do these people not understand what that phrase means… it is literally a rallying cry for the destruction of Israel… like a cry that says “Israel does not deserve to exist.” And I have seen this phrase time and time and time again in pro Palestine protests and rallies. I gotta wonder, do western progressives just… not know or do actually know and don’t care/actually support the message?


r/AskALiberal • • Apr 13 '21

What can be done about Tucker Carlson?

18 Upvotes

I know this is exactly what he wants, but at some point, someone who actively peddles in racist ideology needs to be silenced before they encourage more violence or get more fascists elected to office.

I’m talking about his latest foray into white supremacist talking points. This time, he tweaked “white replacement theory” for “voter replacement theory” and ranted about that for a while. Next day, he’s back on doubling down. He insists that it’s not racist to accuse the democrats of importing minorities to vote in order to dilute and replace his (a white man’s) vote. It’s just politics.

It’s not politics. It’s racist. It’s the same language that predated the Nazi regime, and I’m not just saying that because of the internet Nazi thing, I’m saying it because it’s actually the kind of things that Nazis said when they were trying to gain power. What can we do to stop this kind of rhetoric before it causes more death and harm to minority communities in this country?


r/AskALiberal • • Sep 12 '25

Why are liberals willing to sacrifice the party’s relationship with Black people to show sympathy to a White supremacist?

0 Upvotes

Black people are the most loyal group to the democrats.

Our numbers are needed in a few key cities and states.

Why are liberals bending over backwards to express sympathy to the point of crying over the death of a man who denies the humanity of Black people and other minorities.

This man spent his life working to make the lives of Black people and other minorities worse. He woke up everyday working to convert young people into that mission so hate can survive long after he is gone.

How do liberals think Black people and other minorities feel looking at them expressing sadness. Calling the rhetoric he spewed as differences in opinion? Calling him a good guy? Saying that they want the same American as him?


r/AskALiberal • • Oct 04 '24

I'm pretty socially liberal, but I can't stand "political correctness," "safe spaces," etc. Anyone else?

8 Upvotes

Like I said, I'm pretty socially liberal.

Climate change? It's basic science. It's baffling how people can deny it.

Abortion? The same people that want to ban abortion worship a child-murdering God.

LGBTQ? I had a gay uncle, so that was a no-brainer.

Despite this, I just can't jump on the whole "woke" band-wagon. And I hate using that word, because it makes me sound like an alt-right neckbeard, but I can't think of another word.

Remaking movies to make the protagonist a person of color doesn't accomplish anything except for virtue signaling. Hiding in a safe space can't protect you from reality forever, and when you eventually step out of that safe space, you're going to fall flat on your face. Inventing new words, like "Latinx," to be more inclusive, ultimately ends up being disrespectful to the original speakers, even if the intentions were harmless.

One of my favorite movies is "Blazing Saddles." It is VERY politically incorrect, but it has a strong anti-racist message. It essentially uses racism to make fun of racism, which I believe is a much more effective method then censorship. Unfortunately, most people completely miss the point, and that movie would have never been made today (which is sad, because imo we need it now more than ever.)

Another example I think of is "Family Guy." "Family Guy" is also very politically incorrect, frequently making use of racial and ethnic stereotypes and making fun of taboo topics like rpe and pdpohilia. But "Family Guy" also contains strong liberal messages. I have no problem watching it, but does anyone else feel conflicted?

TL;DR: I lean left on many social issues (abortion, climate change, LGBTQ, etc.) but I just can't jump on the PC bandwagon. Obviously I'm against actual bigotry, but I find "offensive humor" funny. And I can think of some media (i.e. "Blazing Saddles," "Family Guy," "South Park," etc.) that use this "shock value" to get their point across. Freedom of speech is freedom of speech, including the freedom to offend. Does anyone else feel this way?


r/AskALiberal • • Nov 16 '23

Has your perspective on the radical left changed?

2 Upvotes

I'm a centrist, I support Blue-Dog Dems and I hate the radical right but I admit that lately the radical left, Bernie-Bros, and Rashida Tlaib-type progressives scare me just like the MAGAs. Has your perspective on the radical left changed? In my opinion the super radical pro Islamist Progressives are the biggest threat to America AFTER the MAGA. The more radical Trump's cult is, the more the radical progressive left will become more and more delusional and this will lead America to the abyss.


r/AskALiberal • • May 07 '24

Do liberals actually understand the pro-life viewpoint? Do you want to?

1 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I'm pro-choice, but I've oscillated back and forth over my life on this topic, as I don't think it's as black and white as many make it out to be.

This has gotten me super curious, because every time I see abortion discussed on liberal social media sites, I feel like it's framed as if pro-lifers "hate women" or "want to control women" or some other variant of that. They sometimes reference it as religious based, or "God telling them to control women" or something ofr the sort.

This has me wondering, are these just bad faith arguments, or do liberald truly not understand the pro-life argument at all? Have you ever sat down and tried to see this particular topic from the opposing point of view, or is it too abhorant to even consider?

Thank you!

Edit:

Some people have asked me to explain the pro-life viewpoint, and again, it's not super complicated. It's just this: Abortion is killing a baby (or what will become a baby without any additional intervention). Kind of like killing a tree sapling. You didn't kill a tree, but you killed what would eventually be a tree.

As someone who has many religious and conservative friends, when I hear this topic discussed it's *never* been about control of women, most pro-lifers understand that it's a *massive* inconvience for the woman being denied an abortion, but view that inconvience as a neccesary evil to save a life.

I also understand that the fact that *many* pro-lifers are also pro-death penalty and pro-guns makes this argument seem tenuous, and I understand that.


r/AskALiberal • • Mar 17 '24

Do leftists acknowledge that Palestine has actively promoted terrorism against Israel?

8 Upvotes

Now before you guys smash your keyboards, I'm not posting in bad faith, and I'm not a secret rightist. I consider myself solidly within liberal thoughts and consider myself relatively left of center. I'm a registered Democrat and voted for Biden in the primary this year.

But it drives me insane to see leftists who actively are staunchly anti-Israel due to settlements and them bombing civilians. It is immoral for them to occupy Palestinian land, and it is true that they are bombing civilians. But do you really think that occupying territories should merit being terrorized, raping, killing and burning intentionally civilians? And do you not acknowledge that when Israel is bombing these civilians and civilian areas (hospitals and such), that they are bombing those places because that is where Hamas stores their weapons and that they are calling ahead to try to get all the civilians out? Because it seems like (specifically fringe) leftists actively ignore those points.

Hamas and the Palestinian nation have actively promoted Israel not having a right to exist. And all of these issues Israel has and is doing is a result of Hamas' terrorism and radical Islam's actions.

Israel certainly has problems with their country. They have a far-right government, their people are kind of shitty, Netanyahu is a problem of his own and they are occupying land that isn't theirs. But they are a liberal democracy and encompass very important values to western civilization. They don't have as repulsive and disgusting a nature as Palestine, which includes them not just wanting to kill & torture innocent people and wipe an entire nation. And they certainly aren't teaching children as young as 6 that Israel shouldn't have a right to exist.

Anyways, enough of my preaching. Just hope that there still isn't this gap of knowledge that is necessary.


r/AskALiberal • • 4d ago

Just learned Nancy Pelosi was one of the 11 Democrats who didn't show up for the vote to impeach Hegseth. Your thoughts on her and the others?

0 Upvotes

Now that she's retiring, this seems like a final "fuck you, I got mine"

edit: if we had just 8 more votes Hegseth's impeachment proceedings would be underway

edit2: Massie announced the impeachment vote on Monday, and the vote was held on Tuesday. You can't blame DC traffic for this, or anything else short of a medical emergency. Those 11 Democrats had enough time to get there for the vote.


r/AskALiberal • • Dec 04 '22

Why is it so important to have men in drag reading books to children?

1 Upvotes

I don’t understand why this became such a big thing, recently… I guess there are a number of questions. First, is there such a drought of literate adults that schools and libraries have to resort to drag queens to get stories read to kids? Why is the drag component so important? If it’s just about reading to kids, why not dress normally? Why can’t the teacher or librarian do it? It obviously ruffles a lot of feathers, so why continue to push the issue? It’s so weird that it sounds like a mad lib generated situation


r/AskALiberal • • May 06 '24

Can I still call myself a leftist if I think the "man vs. bear" thing crossed a line?

4 Upvotes

Even if it was a joke. Same with the questions about what women would do in the twilight zone-type scenarios where men disappeared for a day.

I don't like incels at all, I agree that "no" always needs to be taken for an answer when it comes to intimacy, "boys will be boys" is bs, and that victim blaming is disgusting. And I definitely don't blame women for not wanting to be hit on, though catcalling should be responded to with simple metaphorical finger-wagging from society, not by screaming at the disrespectful people and treating them as evil violent monsters or getting police involved.

As much as i like to believe i'm a feminist, I cannot get behind this idea that we have to honor the feelings of women and parents who act like the whole world is a minefield due to the existence of Y chromosomes. They are entitled to their opinions and can take whatever precautions they want, but in no way can we allow for a mandate that men "appear nonthreatening" to women and children. And for those who say misandry is merely something that hurts feelings, no it isn't. A lot of racism involves the trope about men of color being hypermasculine and a threat to white women. So is a lot of hateful TERF ideology.

I feel for all the black men who walk on eggshells around white women lest their actions be misinterpreted and their life becomes at stake following the police call. Or the trans women who are afraid to use the women's room. Or the gay men who abandon their dreams of being teachers because of parents with a "Defcon 1" attitude.

Even if Zootopia was meant to be about race, i think the theme holds just as much water about gender.

If you think i'm trying to sympathize with incels and MRAs who want to have special privileges for being male, I don't even have any interest in sex myself. Zero. Zilch. I am on the ace spectrum. The only dog i have in the fight, besides being male, is that I am on the ASD and resent many social norms about gender, including ones about "appearing nonthreatening."


r/AskALiberal • • Aug 14 '25

Why do liberals bodyshame?

0 Upvotes

By bodyshaming I mean saying things like ”small dick energy”, ”big pickup trucks to compensate for their small penis”. Not saying all leftist do this, but this is generally accepted within liberal circles, even though leftists are always vitrue siglaling about racism, yet they still partake in bodyshaming. They know that penis size is genetical and political opinion has no effect on it. They are not really even insulting rebublicans, but are only insulting people who have small penises which includes liberals.

Ps. I know someone is going to ask this so I answer it here: The reason I pressing the left instead of the right is because. 1. This sub is called ask ”askliberals” 2. Because debating conservatives doesnt serve any purpose for me because I know they are not going to learn. 3. Liberals vitrue signal, despite the fact that some of them arent kind at all.


r/AskALiberal • • Aug 11 '24

Where is the criticism for Kamala Harris not doing interviews?

0 Upvotes

Everything she has done to this point has been scripted and on a teleprompter. I just watched JD Vance take questions from Dana Bash on CNN.

One of his criticisms of the Harris campaign is that she isn't doing anything off script. Dana responded by saying CNN has been trying to get an interview.

This isn't meant to be a pro vance post, I simply think it's a fundamental duty of a presidential candidate to answer questions that a lot of Americans have, specifically as it relates to policy. And if there's a growing perception that said candidate is dodging those questions, the media should hold them accountable outside of opinion editorials.


r/AskALiberal • • Sep 05 '26

Can someone please explain to me the appeal of the DSA, socialism, and the far left?

0 Upvotes

I genuinely dont get it. They attack Democrats the same, if not more, as Republicans. They tend towards authoritarianism to accomplish their goals, and they are unable to tolerate criticism without resorting to personal attacks or somehow blaming Zionists.

What am I missing?


r/AskALiberal • • Jun 25 '26

Am I Wrong For Being Concerned About Democratic Socialism ?

0 Upvotes

As somebody who is an American, I do admit I have some concerns when I hear the word Democratic Socialism. For me when I think of Socialism, I think of losing private property, the USSR/China/Cuba/etc., placing more faith in the government only for them to not do right by the people. This isn't helped for me when MAGA Republicans call everything left-leaning in the world 'Socialism' or God forbid, 'Communism.'. At a point, it does get difficult to discern what qualifies as Democratic Socialism and what doesn't. I am hoping to have these concerns put to rest with what you guys think of Democratic Socialism, what it means to you, and if it really isn't all that bad.


r/AskALiberal • • Aug 23 '26

Why is it SO bad that Hakeem Jeffries met with Jared Kushner?

1 Upvotes

Context: ((NYTimes gift article))[https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/23/us/politics/jeffries-kushner-private-meeting.html]

According to the Times, Rep. Jeffries met with Jared Kushner to talk about where they can work together on topics like housing, cost of living, and immigration. The article makes the argument that this is Trump conceding that he's going to get his ass handed to him in the midterms.

The leftists on twitter have been predictably apoplectic.

A few choice leftists on the outrage here:

"This is just pathetic stuff from the House Dem leader" - Mehdi Hasan

"Why anyone thinks he [Jeffries] can be an effective leader in 2026 is beyond me" - Wajaht Ali

"It was Jeffries showing his ass to the [I] lobby" - Cenk Uygur

among many others I can bring up.

The response to this and when Mamdani went to the White House to meet with Trump has been nothing short of baffling from the same people. The argument for that was that Mamdani can extract things from the President to get things done for his constituents. Jeffries is doing the exact same as the White House is preparing for a complete wipeout in a few months.

So, why the difference? What's the problem with the House working with Trump to get good things done if they can manage that?


r/AskALiberal • • Jul 15 '22

As a black man, why does the left typically stick up for black people when black people are essentially against the cause?

23 Upvotes

The majority of black people are socially conservative, and the majority of black culture presupposes that deviancy IS liberation.  In all actuality, and I'm not trying to come across as some "uncle tom", but the fact of the matter is that the black "community" is extremely racist, sexist, homophobic, and religious. We also embrace the grotesque, such as the pro-crime nature of thug and hip-hop culture. I observe this on a daily basis: many black individuals, especially black men, embrace these stereotypes.

Hell, even when I see people trying to defend black people, it's usually black people THEMSELVES who call them out, as if black people don't even want you on their side.


r/AskALiberal • • Aug 11 '26

Thoughts on the banning of pre op transgender women from "women only" spaces?

0 Upvotes

So this question kinda came up after seeing this over on my home city sub:

https://komonews.com/news/local/women-only-spa-takes-fight-over-transgender-access-to-supreme-court-olympus-spa-lynnwood-tacoma-pierce-county-transgender-woman-identity-korean-body-scrubs

So this case is going all the way up to the Supreme Court now. And as a Trans Woman myself I am conflicted on this. Like on one hand I understand the desire to want to go to a spa and enjoy yourself and the pain of being told "no you are not allowed." But on the other hand, I can understand the desire of Cis women not wanting to be around naked male anatomy while naked themselves. And I can understand the discomfort of the proprietors being uncomfortable working with a person who has male anatomy. Oh and this spa is a "traditional Korean spa" so nudity is a thing there.

Honestly this case reminds me of that case with Jessica Yaniv in Canada where she sued a bunch of spas for refusing to give her a Brazilian wax because they didnt want to or were uncomfortable with waxing male genitalia.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/transgender-woman-human-rights-waxing-1.5330807

In that case Yaniv had lost, but that was 7 years ago and in Canada.

So what are your thoughts on things like this and how would you thread this needle if siding with the Spa, knowing this ruling can be used by the right to discriminate in other ways?


r/AskALiberal • • May 26 '26

for my fellow liberals - are you ever frustrated by the inclusion of leftists in our spaces?

4 Upvotes

it seems quite often that leftists (communists, socialists etc.) get lumped into the broader "liberal" movement and communities.

liberals, does this frustrate you?


r/AskALiberal • • Oct 31 '24

Why Are So Many Democrats Leaving the Left? - Ana Kasparian?

12 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/dpcmEuwvsxY?si=iPwdEJVYUWNu0G1a

Ana seems to be having a very manufactured meltdown against the left to justify her jump into a right wing grifter. There are those that are “leaving the left” over culture war reasons but it’s overblown.


r/AskALiberal • • 4d ago

Why do you think the average progressive seems so unaware of how much leftward movement America has made over the last 5 decades?

0 Upvotes

I'm no fan of Schumer or Jeffries, but in all the conversation about them likely remaining in power, I keep seeing some of the common progressive lines. Mockingly saying how the liberal view is that "Better things aren't possible" and that "the Democrats keep moving right"

Where exactly does this mentality come from?

Socially alone, Democrats have moved extremely left in basically every way over the last 20 years (and are unrecognizable from how they were 50 years ago)

And even economically, while we've never fully recovered from just how much damage Reagan did, Dems have still been slowly moving things back in the left direction.

So what is it? Propaganda? A misunderstanding of the FDR era? The idea that cost-of-living and inflation are things that would just be solved by "moving left"?


r/AskALiberal • • 16d ago

Is the online far left becoming as conspiratorial as the online far right?

2 Upvotes

Wanna start this thread by saying I’m not intending to throw shit or start a fight, I’m sharing my opinion and I’m curious how other people feel.

For example, a post on the politics subreddit about Trump and Vance cancelling upcoming rallies was met with top comments “This is weird. Something is afoot, what are they up to?”, with the top responses including: Trump is gonna start a civil war to cancel elections, Trump is preparing to deploy the Army against registered Democrats, and Trump is going to execute a false flag bombing to stay in power, all highly upvoted among many other similar predictions - instead of the much more likely explanation, which is just that their rallies aren’t helping so they stopped. They also frequently assert Trump stole the 2024 election, with no evidence, just as the right did in 2020. In another thread, I was downvoted and ridiculed for suggesting that they can’t convince the 1 million infantry in the Army to fire on their own neighbors and family members.

Compare this to conspiracies of the far right: Biden is gonna deploy the military to lock down the country, Biden used COVID to steal the election, Hillary Clinton is a baby eating Satanist, etc. They’re more extreme and dangerous, not denying that, but they’re just as baseless and ridiculous IMO.

I’m not saying that it’s as bad as the right, or that they’re as crazy as the right, but there’s definitely been a shift I’ve noticed over the last 2 years, getting even worse the last month or so.

What’s causing this and what can be done about it? A few years ago the left was making fun of the right for having the same flavor of conspiracies they have now. Is this a real thing anyone else has seen or am I way off base here?

edit: reworded a sentence to be more clear


r/AskALiberal • • Apr 09 '25

Do you think Trump is going to declare martial law on April 20th?

1 Upvotes

I see so many rumors that he may invoke martial law on Hitler’s birthday. Do you think there’s any merit to these rumors? Normally I would dismiss rumors, but with how unhinged Trump is I’m afraid that it is not outside the realm of possibility. It would also go along with Project 2025 to get rid of political dissent and get rid of Americans who protest Trump.