r/AskAChristian • • 3m ago

I consider myself to be agnostic. If someone who's Christian prays for me to turn to a Christian, will god listen and respond?

1 Upvotes

I'm agnostic because it's just hard for me to believe there's an actual god out there. I need to see him at least once. Some people say god responds to their prayers. How do you know 100% that was god?


r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

Christian life Yelled at God?

1 Upvotes

I yelled at God. I have a beautiful life but I can’t shake the ex that overnight ditched me to party in NYC then a few months later found an Ivy League girlfriend. He calls still. Either way, I have a beautiful and full life but I get mad at God that I feel lost, feel like a loser, and can’t find another love )it’s been a year). I mostly get sarcastic like “oh hey should I do coke in east village after being horrible to the people I love? Maybe then I’ll get rewarded with everything ever wanted?” It’s gross. I have such a full life but here I am just mad at Him for the last puzzle piece while people are literally suffering and dying?

I feel so gross.

How do I handle this? I’m a new Christian as of this last year when I’ve been shown signs by God that everything is as He is planning it. I’m just disappointed in myself for yelling at Him.


r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

Jesus Did Jesus live a perfect life? And if not did he die for his own sins as well?

0 Upvotes

I’m curious to know if Jesus led a perfect life and if not did he die for his own sins as well?


r/AskAChristian • • 2h ago

Church how much should i donate to the Church that just helped save my life? also would a Pastor accept a personal gift or should I put any money towards a gift to him towards the donation?

2 Upvotes

hi everyone, i (22F) recently moved out of a bad domestic situation after having 3 hospitalizations since June, both for physical and mental health separately. the most recent stay was 65 days and i just got out on the 4th, and then realized i could not stay at that home anymore or i would have to return to inpatient care. a couple days ago i visited a Church-ran thriftstore that was having a 50¢ for everything day, so i was getting lots of things for my new bathroom, kitchen, living room as i’m currently staying with family but am now moving four hours away Sunday (tomorrow).

while shopping, a man came up to me and asked if there was anything else i needed. he introduced himself as the Pastor of the Church and then told me he had another building that may contain things i’d be interested in. he offered me a china cabinet, night stand, TV, loveseat, floor lamp, and much more. i started getting nervous because i don’t really have that kind of money currently, so i asked for a price estimate. he proceeded to say, “ you can just have it!”, and added that any amount of cash donation would be appreciated, but not required. when i went to go pickup the items, he had added more things to the pile as well.

i am visiting the area for Christmas and if i have the funds, i would like to make a donation to the Church. also, i intend on making the Pastor a handmade card but i was wondering if there’s any type of gift i could possibly get him otherwise. i did used to attend Church weekly for about a decade, but actually due to my domestic situation i previously mentioned i had to stop. if he would just appreciate a donation, that’s fine! i’m just wondering what is an appropriate amount, i don’t want to give too little and am not really sure how much is normal to donate to Churches.

also, i have been doing lots of couponing for my apartment and sometimes in the past i’d get products that i never got around to using. standardly do Churches take donations of unopened food and hygiene supplies? thank you!

just in case anyone is worried, just know: i will NOT donate above my means!


r/AskAChristian • • 2h ago

God's will My faith easily waivers idk what to do

1 Upvotes

Every time someone debates God i have nothing to say, no ability to stick up for Him. It’s like i shut down, I feel like I betray him all the time. Like someone will say the bible is misogynistic and ill fail at disputing it because even adding context it still sounds it. I don’t know how to dispute “God knew the future and still created satan“. I get free will but at the same time I don’t at all like I can be eternally tortured if i lack faith so that isn’t rly free will? And why couldn’t God just not created satan?

I was raised Christian but actually started seeking him three ish years ago. I feel like ive been blindly following like i love God ive seen the things he’s done for me in my life but I can’t help but think of all the children getting tortured do they go to heaven? I don’t think it would be fair especially if they didn’t know of Jesus, it briefly mentions that in ezra but God is like don’t worry about the seeds that haven’t been watered.

I have ocd so I already spiral frequently and spiralling about hell genuinely makes me not want to live anymore it’s so mind eating i feel guilt for questioning God

Please could someone help?


r/AskAChristian • • 4h ago

Money matters What are your opinions on Christians who play the lottery every now and then?

3 Upvotes

I’ve heard different opinions on this matter some people say it’s not wrong to do as long as you don’t make it an obsession. Some say it’s completely wrong and people shouldn’t do it. What are your thoughts on this topic?


r/AskAChristian • • 7h ago

Art / Imagery Is this kinda art i made Blasphemous?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Kinda of my more extreme kind of art to what i have posted on r/christianity. So wonderd why the line is?

For you guys?


r/AskAChristian • • 8h ago

Miracles Former Christian turned Deist reconsidering

4 Upvotes

Maybe this is the wrong tag, I wished there was one for “divine intervention”

I recently had an unbelievable experience happen to me, and it’s made me reconsider deism and is pushing me back towards the Christian faith, as I believe God heard my prayers and many others’ prayers and intervened in my life and brought me peace.

The story starts in Cambodia, where I start on a work trip. I get horrible food poisoning in Cambodia, and have to fly to Vietnam for another meeting the following day. I still felt horrible in Vietnam but started to get better. Took a nap at my hotel to hopefully sleep off the remaining food poisoning, only to wake up in excruciating pain — I was having a kidney stone. And not one that can pass naturally. With my visa expiring the following day, I rejected the hospital’s advice and checked myself out and booked a flight to Hong Kong where I could enter without a visa in hopes to get surgery there.

I’m struggling in the hotel, and one of the kind workers who brought food to my room noticed my distress and reported it to the front desk. A team of staff members came to my room urging me to return to the hospital (I was in really bad shape; I couldn’t get out of bed and was nearly hyperventilating and almost fainted from the pain). I reluctantly agreed, knowing that I was going to end up overstaying my visa in a communist country (this is something you should avoid if you can….).

Turns out, I had developed a severe kidney infection from the blockage that could’ve turned septic had I not gone to the hospital when I did. There’s my first sign of divine intervention — the girl who brought me food reporting me to staff and having the staff essentially force me to the hospital. This could’ve saved my kidney or my life.

The following morning, after the pain meds wore off, I was back in immense, indescribable pain. I prayed to God for the first time in probably 16 years, asking for relief, and apologizing for doubting Him for so many years. As my prayer finished, my pain subsided for quite some time — and it shouldn’t have, as the stone was still lodged in my ureter and not moving whatsoever.

After having a stent put in and having 1 week of antibiotics to prepare my body for a laser lithotripsy, I had a successful surgery and was discharged from the hospital the following day. I’m now 10 days over my visa, and have to deal with Vietnam’s immigration department to be allowed to leave the country. This is where I really feel like the divine intervention started to happen.

My family and most of my friends are Christian; I probably had close to 100+ people back home praying for my recovery and visa situation so I could get back to my wife who is chronically ill back at home taking care of our 18 month old baby. I happened to have found a lawyer on ChatGPT who was helping me figure out how to exit the country legally. As it turns out, following the proper channels would have likely taken another 2-4 weeks for Immigration to issue me an exit Visa; a length of time I couldn’t stomach considering I’d already been away for more than 16 days at this point. I won’t give all of the details of how my lawyer managed it, but essentially he found connections within immigration and customs police at the airport that allowed me to use back channels to circumvent the entire immigration process and give me a “pass” through customs that I shouldn’t have been able to get. The intervention part is that this born and raised Vietnamese lawyer told me, unsolicited, in the car on the way to the airport that he was a born again Christian, converted from ancestor worship. A Christian missionary from Kansas City had taken interest in him 10 years ago at an English club and over a 2 year period of time of speaking with this missionary, this lawyer turned to Christ and the Christian faith. He said he had been praying for my recovery ever since meeting me and had been praying for my case with immigration. He was praying over me in the car and in the airport, and while he was praying, more good news would continue to come and eventually I got cleared to leave the country.

Another small miracle; after getting through customs, I would’ve missed my flight out due to the security line and after begging an airport security officer to let me use the airline staff security line, he said yes after telling me no 3 times. I made my flight by about 5 minutes, and had I missed it, all of the back channel work that was done to get me out of the country would have been moot as it was an exception for that day and that flight only.

There’s too many coincidences for this to feel like anything other than divine intervention and an answer to prayer.

My question now is, now what? I have denied God’s intervention or compassion or care for individuals for 16+ years and now I’m rethinking everything. Who do I talk to about this? Who can help me figure out my beliefs? I just don’t know what to do next or how to process this any further.

Thanks for reading.


r/AskAChristian • • 9h ago

God Separation from God and 2 other things I've been noodling on

1 Upvotes

I have 3 things that I guess aren't questions but more topics/ideas and I'd like to hear what you all think about them. The first one is the one I think about the most, the first two I guess you could say are related to religion while the 3rd is more spiritual but still applicable.

  1. How can anything be separate from God?

  2. I don't think most people actually believe hell is real

  3. I can't figure out how to not view a relationship with God as transactional

1. How can anything be separate from God?

I think about this not based on anything from an ancient historical/religious book, just what I can reason about "the universe" from my own faculties (hopefully you won't just hit me with the classic plot hole cover of something like "God's ways are beyond understanding").

I have 5 fingers fingers, but they're all part of 1 hand. I have 2 hands, but they're part of one body. I'm an individual and have siblings but we are one family. There are multiple planets but together they are a solar system.

Basically, if you have 2+ things, something higher up the chain/hierarchy exists. And if you have separation from God, then you have 2 (you could argue more than 2) categories: God and Not God. But that implies both of those are a part of something bigger. And that to me just doesn't make sense. God has to be The Ultimate. I can't say my finger is greater than my hand which has 5 fingers.

So it seems to me either people have too small of a definition of God, or true separation (different than illusory separation) is impossible and then sin etc. doesn't really make sense and then the religion falls apart as I see it.

2. I don't think most people actually believe hell is real

Tons of people call themselves Christians and say they believe that unsaved people will spend eternity in hell, separated from God. Some form of suffering, the details probably depend on the congregation/methodist/baptist/etc.

Then these people get home from work, and watch TV for a few hours, while countless people around the world die every day, unsaved.

Thus the conclusion is either that these people are truly despicable people, or they don't REALLY believe in hell. I don't think most people are truly despicable, so I think they don't really believe it. Looking back at my nearly entire absence of a desire to minister during my time in church, I imagine it's the case for most people.

Now of course you can say "well we're all broken, we're all wretched" yeah okay, but from my point of view an average joe that screws up and inadvertently hurts people (as we all do) is very different than an average joe that does that but also thinks billions of people are going to suffer forever and just sits around watching tv.

3. I can't figure out how to not view a relationship with God as transactional

I'll preface by saying I feel like either I'm missing something, or, even though people use it all the time, relationship isn't the right word, because I wouldn't point at a brick wall and tell you I have a relationship with it, and talking to God feels like talking to a brick wall. Or if you said you wanted a relationship with me so I gave you a book about what my life was like 2000 years ago and told you that has everything you need to know.

Anyways, despite trying I just can't seem to come up with any reason to pray or even think about God regularly other than because I feel like it might benefit my life in some way, which isn't really pure hearted. And I think, oh I wish I was pure hearted and did just want to worship God all the time, but when I really dig down it's only because I think if that was the case I would be happier and my life would be better.

Maybe it just reflects how I view life and relationships in general. Earlier on a walk I was thinking, well I can't seem to love God without it being transactional, and a transactional-focused marriage probably doesn't work very well, so maybe I'll never be able to have a successful relationship until I learn how to properly love God. And I'm right back to it: ok I have to love God so that I can have a successful relationship.

Perhaps I'd feel different if there was some actual two way communication... but like I said, if you heard from a ton of people that I want to have a relationship with you, but then I just inaudibly whispered to you and gave you a book that doesn't relate to the specifics of your life at all... Well I'll stop rambling. Is this mostly how you all feel too or do I just need to figure it out?


r/AskAChristian • • 9h ago

Dating What are your thoughts on dating a non Christian?

1 Upvotes

Even tho they're supportive and never against Christianity.


r/AskAChristian • • 10h ago

Sin Is this gossip

0 Upvotes

I was talking to a woman with which there’s a mutual interest. Yesterday, a coworker she had made what I thought was a rude remark. Today, I asked her “what did so and so say to you? “We’re not friends, we’re coworkers?” And she had affirmed what I asked. She then mentioned, “He told me I have a big ego, and it makes me rude” and I very jokingly said that I can see it. Was I gossiping in asking what he had said? Should I just avoid talking about people entirely? I’m a new christian. Gossiping is something I cant seem to understand the definition of. I don’t openly talk bad about people, but asking and talking about their actions like this situation here. Is that still gossip?


r/AskAChristian • • 13h ago

Leaving a marriage

4 Upvotes

I’ve been married for seven years to a disabled man, and we have a toddler together. I have been the sole financial provider for our family, and I take care of our child approximately 90% of the time. He is not bedridden and can move around the house, but his involvement in parenting is very limited.
I have reached a point where I want to leave the marriage. To be completely honest, I don’t think I love him anymore. I stopped expecting financial support a long time ago, but I also receive very little emotional or mental support. He struggles with severe depression and anger issues but refuses to see a doctor or psychiatrist. He often cooks only for himself, disregards my needs, and there is a lot of shouting and fighting.
The situation has started affecting my health. Last month, I ended up in the ER because of a panic attack. When I came home, he didn’t ask how I was or even acknowledge what had happened. The other day, he called me an “attention whore” simply because I opened the windows to let some fresh air in, accusing me of wanting the neighbours to see me.
I’m exhausted from carrying the responsibilities of this marriage and family for so long. The situation is even more complicated because we are immigrants in a foreign country without family support. His residency visa is sponsored through me, and if we divorce, he may lose his basis for staying in the country and could have to leave. He has nowhere to go. He has no friends (doesnt get out of the house ), has a difficult relationship with his mother, and doesn’t want to return to his home country.

Whenever I mention separation, he tells me to go ahead but says he will fight me. Sometimes I’m so exhausted that I almost stop caring about what happens to him. Other times, I worry constantly about what will happen to him if I leave. I feel caught between wanting to save myself and feeling responsible for someone who may have nobody else to turn to.
I’m a hopeful person, and I pray regularly. I keep praying for an answer or some direction, but perhaps I’m simply too exhausted to recognise it or find the strength to move forward.
From a Christian perspective, what should I do? Is it wrong to leave a marriage when I no longer love my husband and feel that staying is damaging my health? How much responsibility do I have for what happens to him if I leave?
I would genuinely appreciate biblical advice and prayers.


r/AskAChristian • • 15h ago

How to handle spiritual attack and pray against it

1 Upvotes

I’m a Christian raised Pentecostal, and lately I’ve been going through one of the most difficult seasons of my life. Over the past 2 months, I’ve been dealing with unexpected health issues that have really taken a toll on me physically, mentally, and emotionally. I cannot work for now. I was supposed to be moving next month and now I can’t move either.

What has also been weighing on me is that it seems like unfortunate things have been happening to people around me, too. Some of my friends have been getting really sick, and other people close to me have been going through difficult situations. It just feels like there’s been so much happening all at once, not only in my life but in the lives of people I care about. We are all very young as well. Maybe God just wants us to slow down?

Something else I want to mention is that for the past couple of months, I’ve been praying and asking God to help me hear His voice. I’ve felt somewhat disconnected from Him spiritually questioning if he’s real, and I’ve been trying to strengthen my relationship with Him and understand what He may be trying to teach me during this season. About a month after feeling this is when my health got crazy.

Then, recently, a video about witchcraft and spiritual attacks randomly appeared on my TikTok. I wasn’t searching for anything related to witchcraft, so seeing that video, especially with everything that’s been happening lately, honestly rattled me a little.

I started thinking about all the unfortunate circumstances, the illnesses, and the spiritual disconnection I’ve been experiencing. It made me wonder about spiritual warfare and what the Bible actually says about it. Especially witch attacks. Because there’s someone I am no longer friends with and no matter how much I block her for some odd reason her username keeps popping up on my social media. And I don’t know if she was a witch or anything. I just know she didn’t believe in God.

I want to be clear that I’m not claiming someone has performed witchcraft against me or that these events are necessarily connected. I also understand that illness and unfortunate circumstances can happen for reasons that have nothing to do with spiritual attacks. But the video brought up questions that I hadn’t really considered before.

Has anyone experienced a season where everything seemed to be going wrong at once, including things happening to people around you?

How did you distinguish between a difficult season of life and what you believed might be spiritual warfare?

And most importantly, what scriptures, prayers, or biblical practices helped you feel protected, strengthen your faith, and reconnect with God? Thank you my friends in Christ.


r/AskAChristian • • 17h ago

God's will Did god force existence onto me, use niv if you need to use the bible.

0 Upvotes

Ignore the niv part, I didn't write the top properly,I use niv personally so I prefer niv but doesn't matter,I know alot of people asked this before but I can't get the answer from reading so I want to ask and reply to the replies personally


r/AskAChristian • • 17h ago

Old Testament Why trust ancient Jewish scribes to preserve the words of the prophets, when the OT itself accuses them repeatedly of paganism, lying and opposing the prophets?!

0 Upvotes
  • Chronicles & Kings are full to the brim with stories about how the People deviated, the priests went astray, the kings shunned the prophets, the prophets cursed the people, etc. It's not a good picture of continuous line of preservation of the words of God. How many versions were lost, discovered, lost again in one kingdom, supposedly popped up in another kingdom, shred to pieces in an invasion, in an exile?

  • And what about the holy men themselves? The OT accuses Solomon of deviation, of accommodating idolatry! I don't believe it for a second, but you do.. then you go and take Ecclesiastes as divine inspiration! The book reeks of depression, of materialism (almost denying the afterlife!). It's infamously the preferred book of the heretics. Which Solomon wrote it? The aged one? The one who you accuse of being crazy, plaything for pagan wives?!

  • Clearly the Torah isn't the exact copy of Moses, since it describes his burial! Lots of cooks had their hands in that pot.

  • What version did Jesus use? The LXX or the Hebrew? Who was keeping it at the time.. the corrupt priests of the temple who hated him?! Those "trustworthy" guys you entrust with your eternal fate??

  • Do you really trust the sect that kept the Dead Sea scrolls? In fact, you don't! How do I know? Because the same bundle of manuscripts had heretical writings, and weird versions of the OT, and apocryphal beliefs. Clearly their canon wasn't the same as yours, and you'd call them heretics now.


r/AskAChristian • • 17h ago

A priest was killed by a falling crucifix while preaching — how do you hold God's goodness when tragedy strikes the faithful mid-ministry?

0 Upvotes

Last month in Guayaquil, Ecuador, a parish priest was celebrating Mass, preaching — of all things — about death and time, when a large crucifix came loose above the altar and fell on him. He died in front of his congregation, on a livestream.

I have not been able to put this story down. He was not doing anything wrong. He was doing the most faithful thing a man can do, in God's house, with God's people watching.

Christians, how do you think about this? When suffering falls on the faithful in the very act of serving God — not as persecution, not as consequence, just a falling object in a fallen world — what do you do with the "why"? What has actually helped you hold God's goodness and His sovereignty together, without cheap answers?


r/AskAChristian • • 19h ago

How do I stop anxious thoughts?

1 Upvotes

Early in the morning when I lay down in my bed I start to overthink and imagine horrible scenarios happening I know God’s got me and has a great plan for my future but I still overthink “what if this happens?” “What if that happens in the future” I say to myself “God’s got me” and move on but anxious thoughts keep popping up in my head every time I start to feel safe with God


r/AskAChristian • • 22h ago

Do you think Agnostic Christian is a reasonable position to hold?

0 Upvotes

Christian agnosticism (also called “agnostic Christianity”) is a view that mixes Christian beliefs with uncertainty, generally affirming belief in God or a higher power and the significance of Jesus while rejecting biblical infallibility and being unsure whether Christianity is the one true religion.

Or is it the Best Position to hold, since certainty is hard to justify, also the different conclusions Christians reach from the evidence, it seems that dogmatism is overstated.


r/AskAChristian • • 23h ago

Christian life What's the end goal for Christianity?

2 Upvotes

Say that every person on earth is a believer and follower of God under the one religion Christianity. They also are all taught and understand the world of God. What does it look like? How is the world effected socially, economically, politically, environmentally? What's the next steps if we all reached the same enlightenment?


r/AskAChristian • • 1d ago

How do you justify verses like Psalm 137:9?

2 Upvotes

One summer when I was 14 I decided to read the entire Bible. It took years, but Psalm 137:9 was the beginning of the end for my faith in Christianity. How do you justify this and other OT passages of divinely ordained genocide?


r/AskAChristian • • 1d ago

How "different" are sects of Christianity from each other?

1 Upvotes

Hello. I am a non christian. I want to know what is the difference factor between let's say a gnostic, a Protestant, a catholic and a jehova's witness and maybe mormonism? Which things do they agree on and which things do they differ? Which was the "original"? I only know these "terms" but don't know how they differ.


r/AskAChristian • • 1d ago

Why does your god require worship?

0 Upvotes

What is the purpose of worship? How does it help you? How does it help god?


r/AskAChristian • • 1d ago

How can you support god

0 Upvotes

How can you support god when he gives stage 4 cancer to those that doesn’t deserve it. What kind of just and loving god would do that. Why would god inflict so much pain misery suffering and disparity.


r/AskAChristian • • 1d ago

Sin If I am a christian, should I stop dancing?

4 Upvotes

Dancing has always been my joy. Especcially latin american dances like merengue or cumbia. When I hear the music, I can't help it. I have to move and it makes me happy, especially when I am with my sisters dancing or with other people. It is also a good fun excersice. But I know a lot of people view dancing as a sin. Especialy latin american evangelicals view these types of dances as a huge sin. What are your thoughts? And if it is wrong, should I act like I don't like dancing or something and become bitter when I hear the music?


r/AskAChristian • • 1d ago

Jewish Laws Who Decides Which Old Testament Laws Christians Must Still Follow?

1 Upvotes

If Jesus said he came not to abolish the Law but to fulfill it (Matthew 5:17–19), which Old Testament commandments are Christians still obligated to follow today?

And more importantly, who has the authority to decide which laws remain binding and which ones no longer apply?

Is it Jesus, the apostles, the Church, or individual interpretation?

I'm genuinely interested in understanding the biblical basis for this distinction.