r/AskAChristian • u/CogitoErgoBruh • 11d ago
LGB I'm tired of Christians calling homosexuality immoral without actually explaining what's immoral about it.
I'm tired of hearing that two people loving each other is somehow an offense against God, only to get a handful of Bible verses thrown at me whenever I ask what makes it wrong
And I'm not going to pretend the Bible contains no condemnations of same-sex acts. Leviticus 18:22 condemns sex between men, and Leviticus 20:13 goes as far as prescribing death. So let's start there. Was that punishment morally justified? If your answer is no then you're probablalready willing to recognize that a biblical moral prescription can be wrong
Romans 1:26–27 describes same-sex acts as unnatural, and 1 Corinthians 6:9 contains Greek terminology whose precise scope scholars continue to debate. But even if I grant that Paul condemned all same-sex sexual relationships, so what? Paul believing something was immoral doesn't tell me why it was immoral. Ancient authors were perfectly capable of inheriting the prejudices and assumptions of their societies.
And before someone brings up Adam and Eve, agn yes, I'm aware Genesis describes a man and a woman. How does describing one kind of relationship establish that every other kind is inherently immoral? I hear this horsehit argument all the time.
Then there's the procreation argument. If sex is only morally acceptable when it can produce children, are infertile heterosexual couples doing something immoral by marrying and being intimate? What about elderly couples? If those relationships are perfectly acceptable, you've already admitted that reproduction isn't the sole justification for intimacy.
"It's unnatural" isn't better at ALL Nature isn't a moral authority. Plenty of natural things cause suffering, and plenty of things humans do to improve their lives aren't natural. What matters ethically is whether something causes harm, violates consent, involves exploitation, or otherwise wrongs somebody.
So tell me what is inherently immoral about two consenting adults of the same sex building a loving, faithful relationship. Who is being wronged? I'm genuinley curious? What moral principle is being violated? And can you actually defend that principle without first assuming that your interpretation of scripture must be correct?
I'm also exhausted by the insistence that condemning gay relationships is somehow an expression of love. Telling someone that a healthy, loving relationship makes them morally defective, or that they must remain celibate to be acceptable to God, is an enormous demand. You don't get to dismiss its consequences simply because your intentions are religious.
I'm not saying every Christian is cruel. Plenty reject these condemnations themselves. But using religious authority to shame, exclude, or mistreat gay people is cruel, and calling it biblical doesn't make that cruelty disappear.
If your entire argument ultimately comes down to "God says it's wrong," then at least acknowledge that's where your reasoning ends. Don't pretend you've independently demonstrated that homosexuality is harmful or immoral.
If your going to respond, pls do so with proper moral justification and not some random bible verse.
* AND do NOT try to bring up incest 🙄