r/AskAChristian • • 11d ago

LGB I'm tired of Christians calling homosexuality immoral without actually explaining what's immoral about it.

1 Upvotes

I'm tired of hearing that two people loving each other is somehow an offense against God, only to get a handful of Bible verses thrown at me whenever I ask what makes it wrong

And I'm not going to pretend the Bible contains no condemnations of same-sex acts. Leviticus 18:22 condemns sex between men, and Leviticus 20:13 goes as far as prescribing death. So let's start there. Was that punishment morally justified? If your answer is no then you're probablalready willing to recognize that a biblical moral prescription can be wrong

Romans 1:26–27 describes same-sex acts as unnatural, and 1 Corinthians 6:9 contains Greek terminology whose precise scope scholars continue to debate. But even if I grant that Paul condemned all same-sex sexual relationships, so what? Paul believing something was immoral doesn't tell me why it was immoral. Ancient authors were perfectly capable of inheriting the prejudices and assumptions of their societies.

And before someone brings up Adam and Eve, agn yes, I'm aware Genesis describes a man and a woman. How does describing one kind of relationship establish that every other kind is inherently immoral? I hear this horsehit argument all the time.

Then there's the procreation argument. If sex is only morally acceptable when it can produce children, are infertile heterosexual couples doing something immoral by marrying and being intimate? What about elderly couples? If those relationships are perfectly acceptable, you've already admitted that reproduction isn't the sole justification for intimacy.

"It's unnatural" isn't better at ALL Nature isn't a moral authority. Plenty of natural things cause suffering, and plenty of things humans do to improve their lives aren't natural. What matters ethically is whether something causes harm, violates consent, involves exploitation, or otherwise wrongs somebody.

So tell me what is inherently immoral about two consenting adults of the same sex building a loving, faithful relationship. Who is being wronged? I'm genuinley curious? What moral principle is being violated? And can you actually defend that principle without first assuming that your interpretation of scripture must be correct?

I'm also exhausted by the insistence that condemning gay relationships is somehow an expression of love. Telling someone that a healthy, loving relationship makes them morally defective, or that they must remain celibate to be acceptable to God, is an enormous demand. You don't get to dismiss its consequences simply because your intentions are religious.

I'm not saying every Christian is cruel. Plenty reject these condemnations themselves. But using religious authority to shame, exclude, or mistreat gay people is cruel, and calling it biblical doesn't make that cruelty disappear.

If your entire argument ultimately comes down to "God says it's wrong," then at least acknowledge that's where your reasoning ends. Don't pretend you've independently demonstrated that homosexuality is harmful or immoral.

If your going to respond, pls do so with proper moral justification and not some random bible verse.

* AND do NOT try to bring up incest 🙄


r/AskAChristian • • Oct 03 '26

Recent events I’m seeing a lot of right wing (Christian) men on X and other social media not taking the side of Cornell rape victim Jane Doe. How did we get here? NSFW

0 Upvotes

It is quite alarming. Some kind of hive mind virus is affecting young Christian men.


r/AskAChristian • • May 19 '26

why would God make David’s wife get raped because of his sins?

0 Upvotes

why would a glorious loving God have a woman raped because of her husband sins not just raped but raped in public that’s like saying God is gonna have your spouse get raped in public because of your sins. Good faith only please

2 Samuel 12:11

Dan Barker OBLITERATES Christian Apologist In EPIC "Faith Is Not Evidence" Takedown YouTube video sparked this question where he says God sent David’s wives to be raped because of his sins


r/AskAChristian • • Aug 30 '26

Evolution The sheer scale of science denial I've seen on this subreddit is concerning... Why does science denial re: evolution seem common here?

0 Upvotes

The usual "gotchas" such as "evolution is just a theory" and other nonsense, I've seen a number of times.

This was a talking point I was refuting... Sixteen years ago ... I would have been fourteen or so at the time... Like there comes a point where this stuff isn't even funny anymore. It's just depressing.


r/AskAChristian • • Jun 24 '26

If Genesis I clearly states that God made male and female in his image, why can we not call god “she”?

0 Upvotes

This should be interesting.

Once again, I am just trying to take the temperature of contemporary Christianity to see if any arguments have changed in the last forty years. I’ll give my answer as an edit and, probably, in the comments below.

As expected, it’s an answer that is simple, obvious, and guaranteed to drive modern Pharisees and Sadducees to distraction. ;)

Feel free to be creative in your responses. Snakehandlers, agnostics and bush Christians, this is your moment to shine!

Edit after 12 hours: a couple of people gave the same answer I uphold. God is both male and female, but prefers to use he/him pronouns.


r/AskAChristian • • Jun 15 '25

Evolution Why do so many christians reject evolution?

1 Upvotes

If we were to compare the theory of gravity to theory of evolution both are overwhelmingly supported in their fields, but in terms of direct, measurable, repeatable experiments, gravity may edge out. In terms of diversity of evidence and explanatory scope, evolution may have the broader base.

Neither is "weak"; they are among the strongest scientific theories we have — foundational to modern science.

Not here to debate evolution just curious as to why so many christians reject evolution when it has more evidence for it than any claim in the bible?


r/AskAChristian • • Oct 02 '26

How do you explain this to non-believers?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve been seeing this and posts similar to it popping up on my feed for weeks now on different social media apps (I guess that’s what being non-MAGA gets you) and yes, I know, it’s an oversimplification of biblical salvation but ngl, if my 15 year old self saw this post, I would agree with it (I got saved at 16).

Edit: To add, I remember seeing some comments on a post like this that basically says, “If God created the rules that prompted Him to do all of this, wouldn’t it be better if He just did it differently so He didn’t have to suffer from ‘Himself’”


r/AskAChristian • • Aug 18 '26

LGB My wife thinks I’m homophobic

1 Upvotes

I was scrolling on instagram and I came across this preacher talking to a member of the lgb community about how homosexuality is a sin but that didn’t mean he hated her or thought she was disgusting and the. My wife interjected about how thinking it was a sin is homophobic because and I quote her words here “why is the choices I make or that others make to live happily in life a sin she basically just doesn’t understand why it’s a sin.

For the readers of this just to know she’s not a believer of Christ

Then I explained to her that it’s a sin because it in the bible more the one time saying it is that’s when she calls me homophobic I interjected and said no u can love the sinner but hate the sin But then she just goes into circles saying im homophobic asking me why it’s a sin . And truthfully I don’t know why it’s a sin I just know it is because I’ve read the hole bible so I know its true and in there. Long story short how would you respond to so this

My wife is bi sexual which makes her biased


r/AskAChristian • • Dec 10 '25 Heartwarming

How do I hold God accountable for the harms he has caused me?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I'm wondering how I go about getting any kind of reparative action from God. We generally understand that people who have harmed you owe you something, and I'm wondering what Christians would say is my recourse for the things God has done to harm me.

I was born with an extremely deadly heart defect and was only saved by very modern medicine in the 80s. I will most likely die in the next few years as the ventricles connecting my heart to my body disintegrate and my heart becomes too overworked. This is an inevitability that I've lived with my whole life.

I would like to know how to hold God accountable for this and I'd like to be given some sort of reparation, either in the form of better health or, I don't know, something else. It's difficult to even know what God could give me since he's never done a single thing to even let me know he exists.

But if he does exist he definitely owes me something because he's already tried to kill me and failed multiple times. Are there any mechanisms in Christianity that allow for accountability of God?


r/AskAChristian • • Jun 27 '25

LGBT How do I tell someone LGBTQ is a sinful lifestyle without coming off as judgmental?

0 Upvotes

I have a lot of friends that are a part of/support LGBTQ, but I personally don't agree with that.

Romans 1:26-27

"26 Because of this, God gave them over to shameful lusts. Even their women exchanged natural sexual relations for unnatural ones. 27 In the same way the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed with lust for one another. Men committed shameful acts with other men, and received in themselves the due penalty for their error."

However, sometimes telling someone that LGBTQ is a sin can come off as hateful/judgmental because of the whole idea that "love is love" (which I also don't agree with; I believe God is love).

But, you can be attracted to a person of the same gender without sinning (that's called temptation), but I don't think people should be making that their identity/acting upon it in a sinful way (having a romantic/sexual relationship with the same gender).

Because this is a highly touchy subject, I'm bound to get some hate, but I really just want answers on how to approach it.

(Please note that I am not letting someone's identity affect how I act around them and I am not condemning or judging anyone for I am also a sinner in need of a savior just like anyone else).

Thanks to anyone who understands.


r/AskAChristian • • 7d ago

Can we be feminist & still believe in God's design for humanity?

Post image
0 Upvotes

It's best to promote the well-being of women and men by God's will.


r/AskAChristian • • Aug 08 '25

LGBT What if gay, transgendered and others were put on earth by God as a test of mankind’s compassion?

1 Upvotes

From what I’ve observed many Christians (though not all) demonize those who don’t fit the mold. What if this is a test by God that so many are failing?

As an aside, wow! So many choices for a flair! I’ve never seen so many. ☺️ I couldn’t pick just one.

EDIT: How does one add flair after the fact? I got a bot notice on adding a flair.

EDIT #2: I figured it out but there is no flair that fits. So I picked the next best one.


r/AskAChristian • • Oct 02 '26

LGBT Why will some Christians not attend an LGBT+ wedding

1 Upvotes

(Edit: please don't use this as an opportunity to be horrible - I get that it's a sin etc. That's not what I'm asking about)

(Edit 2: thank you for the people who genuinely tried to help me see the other perspective. I'm out now - this is become a pile on and I no longer wish to defend my humanity from strangers on the internet)

My (35f) partner and I (36f) are getting married in April. She was raised in a high-Anglican, evangelical household, left the church at 19 and came out at 22.

She has spent her entire adult life putting her own needs and wants aside to make her Christian family feel loved and supported through all of their trials and tribulations. She was a bridesmaid for both her younger sisters, and delights in their little kids. She will do anything for them.

Her younger sister called less that 2 days after we got engaged to pre-emptively declined to be a bridesmaid and that he daughter would be a flowergirl, but her husband and her would come if we wanted...

The other sister got her (pastor) husband to call and say thanks but we won't be coming either.

Her dad is all for it, and her mum will come but doesn't want a roll.

They've been talking behind our backs about it since Christmas. My partner has called lifeline on several occasions because she is so heartbroken. She feels like their love is completely conditional - which I'm starting to agree with.

I just don't understand how coming to a secular party (in essence), where we sign a contract (again in essence) and say nice things about each other can be the thing that sends them to Christian hell. We aren't trying to claim our marriage is religious in any way.

I'm just so sad for my partner - even one of her best friends is now making it seem like she might not come.

The sim would not be theirs, surely. Couldn't they just view it as supporting their loving, kind, good sister? Attending a gay wedding is explicitly not mentioned in the bible - it's just a choice, or am I wrong.

Genuinely asking to understand


r/AskAChristian • • Apr 14 '26

LGB I need help i'm queer and 14

0 Upvotes

I'm 14F, and I'm a lesbian. I can't stand the thought of ever having kids with a man or being with a man. I'm Christian, I still love God, and is it true he will sentence me to hell for loving who I want to love? I wholeheartedly believe that I will NEVER be happy with a man. I haven't even told my parents yet because I believe that they're gonna throw me out. (They are constantly homophobic) pls i just need help and advice quickly. I don't want to run away, but the idea isn't looking too bad rn. If it's true that I'm gonna go to hell, I'm probably not gonna tell them anyway and run away so I don't curse my family.


r/AskAChristian • • Aug 02 '25

LGB Is it ok to be Gay and Love Jesus? Some people in R/christianity don’t think so but God is perfect and knows all my actions so he wouldn’t make me Gay unless it was OK?

1 Upvotes

r/AskAChristian • • May 27 '24

Science Why do you so many of you distrust science and scientists' research?

0 Upvotes

We see the products of science, we are using it right now all the research and how meticulous scientists are, how harsh they are when it comes to what can even become a theory yet so many of you dismiss their endeavors why? I constantly hear people on this subreddit say evolution is wrong etc, yet no one has ever debunked it in a manner that made sense. You all are easy to accept science that doesn't conflict with your religion but as soon as it foes you push back even though you have seen and benefited from scientific breakthroughs more than your religious beliefs .

You prayers, nor god improved birth rates, or the myriad of health accomplishments, yet why do you distrust the science but believe in your god?


r/AskAChristian • • Oct 18 '24

If man was created first, why do all embryos start off as female?

0 Upvotes

I’m just curious on what the Christian explanation on this would be. Considering for the first 6-7 weeks, the embryo is phenotypically female.

Edit: maybe I didn’t narrow down my point a bit, but my point is, considering how in conditions such as Turner’s syndrome where if there is there is only 1 X chromosome, it would only produce a female. It’s supports that the ‘base’ of all humans is from the X chromosome. I’m curious to see if anyone seems to find it confusing that bible describes a woman being created using the ‘base’ of a man, yet the biology shows men being created from the ‘base’ of the female.


r/AskAChristian • • Aug 27 '26

LGB Why do SOME Christian’s care so much about homosexuality.

0 Upvotes

I see so many Christians going out of their way to only attack the LGBTQ community. I get many people believe it’s a sin but why just people who are already an oppressed group over something that does not effects you at all. They are just happy people who are living life why do so many Christians find that disgusting.


r/AskAChristian • • Nov 03 '25

Why does Christianity single out gays so much? After all, it's said in the Bible that premarital sex is a sin as well, but every Christian does it and there's no hate or disdain levied against heterosexual sinners. How come?

2 Upvotes

r/AskAChristian • • Jul 02 '26

Why are atheists allowed here?

0 Upvotes

I feel like all they do is disrespect God and make everything worse.


r/AskAChristian • • Feb 16 '26

God's will Why didn't god stop Epstein?

4 Upvotes

Pretty simple- why? Why not just prevent it from the beginning? These kids had no one to bat for them. Why would god just watch it unfold for years in vivid detail without ever stepping in? His ways are so mysterious


r/AskAChristian • • Jan 08 '26

OP has misconceptions Do you think Christians today need to be reminded Jesus was a rebel to the Roman government?

0 Upvotes

Having studied a bit more about Jesus I am realizing a number of the problems with the modern Christian is racism and not standing up to real oppression, I think the black Christians in particular has so many points that there is a huge problem in the US that modern Christianity does need to focus and be more woke. Now the fact that we use the word woke as a derogatory term that in itself is racist because the whole origin of that word use to mean being aware of racial injustice, and even today they are still going on. With anti-DEI statements when DEI mostly helps white women, we turned into this idea that we give black people an easier chance when that's not really the case so even Kirk I hope he's qualified is in itself racist.

Jesus absolutely was a rebellion of his time, and helped marginalized communities. So it's a big wonder why the modern day Christian doesn't see the real problems, the problem isn't secularism you can still practice Christianity in a secular country as Rome was not even a Christian area so you don't need to focus on political control that leads to nationalism and pride.

But even the issue with the modern state of Israel and how even the Bible condemns a modern state of Israel, we have Christians today that don't even know but even in Genesis there are conditions given to Abraham.

I do think modern Christianity in the US in particular is awful, and we need to understand that we don't truly follow the Bible. If we did we would be more vocal about police brutality, but instead we get the police do nothing wrong it's just one police officer. As someone who was a victim of sexual grooming by someone who is currently the Sheriff I can say without a doubt, police stick up for each other and make up things to help their own.

The problem is Christians are blind and prideful about their own government I feel.

Is this truly the problem here? Why don't Christians follow Christ and rebel when something actually does happen?


r/AskAChristian • • Sep 29 '26

LGB How were you able to fully accept that homosexuality is a sin?

0 Upvotes

I find myself constantly going back and forth with this issue. Constantly reminded of when Elijah asked the people when will they finally make up their minds and follow God after seeing Him spark fire to wet wood. I am same sex attracted and if being gay is a sin, then what does that mean for my life? How am I supposed to never fall in love or open myself up to a future that so many are freely given because they are heterosexual. Please don’t talk about how not every heterosexual person gets to marry because even if they don’t marry they are not told to never desire it. What made you be fully convinced that homosexuality is a sin if you once believed it wasn’t and how do you face the constant fear that you might be severely wrong for thinking it is a sin?


r/AskAChristian • • Jul 15 '25

Trinity Where’s the Feminine in the Trinity?

0 Upvotes

I want to ask something uncomfortable about the Christian Trinity.

In Christian doctrine, God is three persons—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit—locked in a relationship called perichoresis: a total, eternal, intimate interpenetration. It’s often described as a dance. But it’s a dance between three male figures. There is no feminine, no womb, no mother, nothing like the creative feminine force you see in other cultures.

God creates everything alone, ex nihilo, just by speaking. There’s no consort, no partner, no trace of the feminine in the act of creation.
Compare this to tantra or Hinduism: the divine always needs the union of masculine and feminine. Shiva is powerless without Shakti, the creative feminine energy, the source and womb of everything. Creation is born from their union, sometimes symbolized as sexual, sometimes as cosmic dance. The point is, both masculine and feminine are essential.

Even in ancient Israel, there was Asherah, a mother goddess, sometimes seen as Yahweh’s partner, the one who gave life and fertility. But she was erased, her symbols destroyed, her name wiped out from the official story.

In Christianity, it goes even further. Mary, who could have been a symbol of the sacred feminine, is reduced to a passive tool, especially in Protestantism.

Now here’s the real contradiction:
Today, Christians insist the “family” must be a man and a woman. But in the core Christian myth, God creates everything without any woman, without any sexual union, just three men in perfect communion. If we followed that logic, the “divine model” for family would be a brotherhood, not a marriage.

Let’s be honest: the Trinity is a story of absolute, intimate interpenetration between three male figures. In any other context, for a Latin or anyone with symbolic sensitivity, that sounds at least a little bit homoerotic. Yet the feminine is excluded, not only from creation, but from the deepest spiritual mystery of Christianity.

So my questions are:

  • Why was the feminine erased from the heart of Christian creation and spirituality?

  • Why demand a “natural family” of man and woman, when even God doesn’t need a woman to create or to have communion?

  • What kind of spirituality are we building when the feminine is not just missing, but actively erased?

If other cultures see creation as the union of opposites, what does it mean that Christianity built its whole story on the exclusion of the feminine?

No taboos, pleace.


r/AskAChristian • • Dec 20 '24

God Why does god give cancer to children?

0 Upvotes

I know it’s a very common question, but I’ve never gotten a satisfactory answer on why this happens. Just wondering :). I’ll very grateful if anyone could provide a good answer. Thanks!