I have 3 things that I guess aren't questions but more topics/ideas and I'd like to hear what you all think about them. The first one is the one I think about the most, the first two I guess you could say are related to religion while the 3rd is more spiritual but still applicable.
How can anything be separate from God?
I don't think most people actually believe hell is real
I can't figure out how to not view a relationship with God as transactional
1. How can anything be separate from God?
I think about this not based on anything from an ancient historical/religious book, just what I can reason about "the universe" from my own faculties (hopefully you won't just hit me with the classic plot hole cover of something like "God's ways are beyond understanding").
I have 5 fingers fingers, but they're all part of 1 hand. I have 2 hands, but they're part of one body. I'm an individual and have siblings but we are one family. There are multiple planets but together they are a solar system.
Basically, if you have 2+ things, something higher up the chain/hierarchy exists. And if you have separation from God, then you have 2 (you could argue more than 2) categories: God and Not God. But that implies both of those are a part of something bigger. And that to me just doesn't make sense. God has to be The Ultimate. I can't say my finger is greater than my hand which has 5 fingers.
So it seems to me either people have too small of a definition of God, or true separation (different than illusory separation) is impossible and then sin etc. doesn't really make sense and then the religion falls apart as I see it.
2. I don't think most people actually believe hell is real
Tons of people call themselves Christians and say they believe that unsaved people will spend eternity in hell, separated from God. Some form of suffering, the details probably depend on the congregation/methodist/baptist/etc.
Then these people get home from work, and watch TV for a few hours, while countless people around the world die every day, unsaved.
Thus the conclusion is either that these people are truly despicable people, or they don't REALLY believe in hell. I don't think most people are truly despicable, so I think they don't really believe it. Looking back at my nearly entire absence of a desire to minister during my time in church, I imagine it's the case for most people.
Now of course you can say "well we're all broken, we're all wretched" yeah okay, but from my point of view an average joe that screws up and inadvertently hurts people (as we all do) is very different than an average joe that does that but also thinks billions of people are going to suffer forever and just sits around watching tv.
3. I can't figure out how to not view a relationship with God as transactional
I'll preface by saying I feel like either I'm missing something, or, even though people use it all the time, relationship isn't the right word, because I wouldn't point at a brick wall and tell you I have a relationship with it, and talking to God feels like talking to a brick wall. Or if you said you wanted a relationship with me so I gave you a book about what my life was like 2000 years ago and told you that has everything you need to know.
Anyways, despite trying I just can't seem to come up with any reason to pray or even think about God regularly other than because I feel like it might benefit my life in some way, which isn't really pure hearted. And I think, oh I wish I was pure hearted and did just want to worship God all the time, but when I really dig down it's only because I think if that was the case I would be happier and my life would be better.
Maybe it just reflects how I view life and relationships in general. Earlier on a walk I was thinking, well I can't seem to love God without it being transactional, and a transactional-focused marriage probably doesn't work very well, so maybe I'll never be able to have a successful relationship until I learn how to properly love God. And I'm right back to it: ok I have to love God so that I can have a successful relationship.
Perhaps I'd feel different if there was some actual two way communication... but like I said, if you heard from a ton of people that I want to have a relationship with you, but then I just inaudibly whispered to you and gave you a book that doesn't relate to the specifics of your life at all... Well I'll stop rambling. Is this mostly how you all feel too or do I just need to figure it out?