r/AcademicBiblical • • 8h ago

Question Where did the Lukan tradition of the repentant thief come from?

9 Upvotes

Luke is unique by having the second thief defend Jesus against the mocking of the first thief, but where did this idea originate from? Was there some Old Testament text that Luke could have been drawing from for inspiration? Was there competing versions of the crucifixion where one of the thieves was repentant and Luke was drawing from these contra Mark and Matthew? Was it a detail just made up for stylistic reasons by the author of Luke without any real traditional predecessor?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 14h ago

Question What is the current scholarly consensus on the dating of the Gospel of John, and how do topographical/archaeological details (like pre-70 CE Jerusalem) factor into arguments for an earlier date?

13 Upvotes

Hello,

I am trying to better understand the current academic consensus regarding the dating of the Gospel of John, as well as the specific arguments put forward by scholars who advocate for an earlier composition.

While mainstream scholarship generally dates the final redaction of John to around 90–100 CE—largely based on its developed Christology and the socio-historical context of the "parting of the ways" with the synagogues—I often see references to its remarkably accurate topographical and archaeological knowledge of pre-70 CE Jerusalem (such as the five porticoes of the Pool of Bethesda, the Pool of Siloam, or the agricultural/quarry landscape surrounding the traditional site of Golgotha and the tomb).

Could anyone clarify:

- What are the main historical, textual, or archaeological arguments used by scholars (e.g., John A.T. Robinson, Richard Bauckham, or others) to argue for a pre-70 CE dating, or at least for very early eyewitness strata?

- How does the current scholarly consensus account for these precise pre-70 CE geographical details while maintaining a late 1st-century date for the text's final form?

References to standard academic literature or recent commentaries on this specific debate would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you!


r/AcademicBiblical • • 11h ago

Discussion Limitations in “social revolutionary” portrait of the historical Jesus?

6 Upvotes

In reading some of John Dominic Crossan’s works, I found myself really in awe about how powerful he makes Jesus’ life and teachings, without appealing to any kind of dogmatism or later belief about who Jesus was or his purpose. His usage of anthropology and his overall methodology is great too, but I found myself wondering about the explanatory power of his concepts.
I’m sure he expounds on the more technical details and labors over every aspect of his work in other books. But at least in the “Jesus: a revolutionary biography,” I couldn’t help but think that his methodology didn’t really address a number of the statements about Jesus’ apparent predictions of an imminent arrival of the kingdom of God, that comes along with an upheaval of the world as we know it. Think, Matthew 24’s lesson of the fig tree, the son of man sayings and the apostles judgment over the twelve tribes found in Matthew and Luke.
In this way at least, as much as I find the overall ideas about the messages behind Jesus’ words, his social, economic, political subversions and radicalism, quite convincing. It also seems that this portrait that strays away from the “apocalyptic prophet” narrative loses some of its explanatory power behind a number of the sayings of Jesus.

Do some of Crossan’s other works address these specific matters? Or is this seen as a genuine point of controversy in his methodology by many scholars today who do prefer the more generalized “apocalyptic prophet” concept of Jesus?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 19h ago

Discussion Concerning "the apostolic gap"

23 Upvotes

It was pointed out about a month ago that some of the most interesting developments in early Church history (I use that term hesitatingly) occured in the years 60-100 or so. This time period of course includes the Jewish-Roman war. By that point, Paul is probably dead, along with Peter and James, the brother of Christ. We know a few names which reasonably fall within this time frame, but our sources are late.

Now, two very interesting discussions have generated some attention in recent years: the relationship between Luke and Marcion and Acts and Josephus. I'm very seduced by these suggestions. Marcion as the mutilator seems to play into orthodox clichés. Acts using Josephus would put it more in line with other ancient historians. These suggestions seem to date Luke-Acts to the second-century.

One of the more interesting books of biblical dating (which recognizes the interconnectednes of this endevour) is Sturdy's Redrawing the Boundaries. One of his interesting moves is to post-date 1 Clement, the Ignatian letters and the letter of Polycarp. These are otherwise the only non-pseudonymic texts from the early 2nd century (I think).

This to me seems to fit well with later datings of also the canonical texts. Of course, a late Luke-Acts doesn't necessitate late Clement, Ignatius and Polycarp, but it does work well together. Unless of course one of them edited Luke-Acts ...

So, a question to everybody interested: considering the impossibility of the known people of the "apostolic gap" to have left any writing, can the same be said for the named individuals up to ca. 130?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 11h ago

Transjordanian Territory of Twelve Tribes of Israel

4 Upvotes

If three of the twelve tribes had "assigned" territory east of the Jordan, then what was the origin of the belief that "the Promised Land" was the area west of the Jordan?

I think the question is pretty self-explanatory, but I do want to clarify that I am asking in the context of an academic/historical answer, not a historical one: How do scholars understand Israelite beliefs about their own tribal territories and origins stories to have evolved and connected to one another?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 5h ago

Question Stationary Earth

1 Upvotes

Did the ancient Israelite authors of the Hebrew Bible believe that the earth was unmoving and stationary?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 16h ago

Question Marcion's Apostolikon

6 Upvotes

Is there a growing number of scholars who believe that Marcion's Apostolikon has primacy over the canonical Gospel of Luke as an earlier textual tradition, or an earlier source which was expanded into the canonical Gospel of Luke? How widespread, if at all, are these beliefs?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 15h ago

Question What should I know about Thecla? (Any book or article recs?)

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I’m a longtime lurker of this sub and graduated college with a minor in Biblical Studies.

I am recently intrigued by the story of Thecla and her influence on the early church. Beyond reading “The Acts of Paul and Thecla,” I want to know more about her, but am struggling to find good books or articles. I know that there is Meggan Watterson’s “The Girl Who Baptized Herself,” but I’m honestly a little put off Watterson after reading “Mary Magdalene Revealed.”

Any recommendations are helpful and welcome, as well as your own knowledge of Thecla!


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Weekly Open Discussion Thread

9 Upvotes

Welcome to this week's open discussion thread!

This thread is meant to be a place for members of the r/AcademicBiblical community to freely discuss topics of interest which would normally not be allowed on the subreddit. All off-topic and meta-discussion will be redirected to this thread.

Rules 1-3 do not apply in open discussion threads, but rule 4 will still be strictly enforced. Please report violations of Rule 4 using Reddit's report feature to notify the moderation team. Furthermore, while theological discussions are allowed in this thread, this is still an ecumenical community which welcomes and appreciates people of any and all faith positions and traditions. Therefore this thread is not a place for proselytization. Feel free to discuss your perspectives or beliefs on religious or philosophical matters, but do not preach to anyone in this space. Preaching and proselytizing will be removed.

In order to best see new discussions over the course of the week, please consider sorting this thread by "new" rather than "best" or "top". This way when someone wants to start a discussion on a new topic you will see it! Enjoy the open discussion thread!


r/AcademicBiblical • • 22h ago

Are there Christian influences on the Midrash Elleh Ezkerah?

4 Upvotes

Apologies, I know this isn't AcademicJewishStudies, but that sub doesn't exist. I hope there are some specialists here who might be able to help.

Midrash Elleh Ezkerah is a literary account of the Ten Martyrs. It is part of the Heikhalot literature. I don't know if an English translation is available; I'm reading it directly from the Hebrew in the Otzar Midrashim, Sefaria edition, the first recension. It's very brief, only 14 paragraphs.

Certain aspects of this undoubtedly rabbinic or para-rabbinic text seem peculiarly Christian-like to me. There is of course an overarching concern with the Roman persecution, suffering, and deaths of rabbis. The rabbis display unwavering piety through their ordeals and are given various comforts in the afterlife. But a handful of particular details really stand out to me:

- R. Ishmael the High Priest is miraculously conceived by the Angel Gabriel. When Ishmael meets Gabriel, the latter embraces him and calls him "my son". This obviously resembles Christian accounts of Jesus's divine conception. Ishmael's mother in this midrash is explicitly not a virgin.

- Gabriel informs Ishmael that Michael sacrifices the souls of the righteous on the heavenly altar next to the Throne of Glory. Ishmael and the other nine martyrs must be sacrificed, executed by the king of Rome, in order to punish or recompense [פריעה] the sin of kidnapping committed long ago against Joseph by his ten brothers. This resembles the sacrifice of Jesus as atonement for Original Sin, but the theological force is lessened by limiting the nature of the sin to a specific crime committed against a Jewish patriarch by the other patriarchs (including Judah). Rather than saving humanity from Original Sin, the sacrifice of the martyrs proves God's justice and His love of the Jews.

- The fate of the martyrs is sealed by a 'betrayer'. In this case it is not a human man like Judas, but the wicked accusing angel Samael, who may or may not be identified with the hypostasized Middat Din, 'the Attribute of Judgment'. God offers Samael the choice to either pardon the martyrs or forfeit his share in the World to Come, and Samael chooses the latter. In a certain sense he trades his share in the World to Come in exchange for the martyrs' deaths, like Judas selling out Jesus for silver.

- The dead body of the third martyr, R. Akiva ben Joseph, is lifted 500 parasangs by Elijah the angelic prophet and placed in a bed inside of a cave for three days and three nights, whereupon Elijah removes him from the cave and Akiva ascends to the Heavenly Academy. This resembles the disappearance of Jesus's body in the tomb after three days and three nights (and the same phrasing is employed by the midrash, 'three days and three nights').

- As he faces execution, R. Judah ben Baba says that "we [the ten righteous of Israel] are liable for death for a great and awesome king, and he has delivered us to the hand of a king in order to claim [לתבוע] our blood from his hand." If the expression 'for a great and awesome king' refers to Joseph (who was second only to Pharaoh), then this could be a Judaization of Christian polemics which blame the suffering of the Jews on the charge of deicide. Instead of suffering for killing the Son of God and King of Kings, R. Judah depicts the Jews' sufferings as justice for the ancient Jews' crimes against their brother Joseph. If this is truly an anti-Christian polemic, then the text is tacitly arguing that the human Joseph was a 'greater and more awesome king' than the Christians' Jesus, and it is worthier to suffer on Joseph's behalf than on Jesus's.

On the whole it seems like this text is aware of Christian doctrines, including polemical charges against the Jews and especially Christian claims about the miraculous birth and death of Jesus. It seems to me like the text is taking those claims and 'defanging' them by putting them in a thoroughly Jewish context, making Christian claims no longer unique and offering Jewish alternatives. Ishmael's angelic conception and the disappearance of Akiva's body after three days and nights in the cave are especially intriguing, but also intriguing are the various ways in which the midrash deals with concepts of the suffering and sacrifice of the righteous as punishment for ancient sin, as well as explaining the theological reasons for the Jews' suffering at the hands of Rome. It seems to work, in several places, against Christian narratives about these same topics.

Is this a valid reading of this text? Does this midrash really contain these Christian influences, or am I reading too much into it? I tried to look up this question on Wikipedia but the page for this midrash does not address the question of Christian influences.


r/AcademicBiblical • • 11h ago

Was ritualistic cannibalism like the Eucharist a common practice in ancient times?

0 Upvotes

How common was this practice? Is this something unique to Christians, or is this something that has been observed/ talked about multiple times?

This practice seems to come out of left field when you read this in John after reading this in Synoptics. It makes me wonder if the authors of John were introduced to this idea from something else.

Do we know anything about ritualistic cannibalism during this time?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 18h ago

Question Does the Hebrew Bible and The Bible as a whole contain self criticisms

2 Upvotes

So an interesting question I have, and this could also relate to source criticism, is does the Hebrew Bible criticize itself, or previous scriptures and traditions within it. Like we are all familiar with the "Hard Parts of the Bible." the stories which a lot of go "EHHH" and some even lose faith over. Does the Bible itself, from its writing provide a self criticism of this? and can that be established.

A secondary question, following up on that. Involving Source criticism, and source Hypothesis, with multiple sources, in of itself, the various sources being compiled together, is that in of itself, a criticism of other sources. Inserting sources, or stitching them together, to act in correspondence each other or as criticism of each other, or to go along with each other, to give a fuller world view?

I am curious, is there any scholars who think this?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Question Creation Ex Nihilo

21 Upvotes

I have a few questions on creation:

  1. Does God create the universe out of nothing in Gen. 1?

  2. Is creation out of nothing found in 2 Macc. 7?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Is there a distinction between image and likeness in Genesis 1:26

14 Upvotes

I understand that there is a patristic distinction between "image" and "likeness" in Genesis 1:26, but that this view fell out of favor with Protestants since Calvin gave his opinion on it. What is the academic view? Is this a simple case of Hebrew parallelism so that image and likeness are basically synonyms or is there a real subtle distinction in terms here in the Hebrew?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Did Jesus believe or preach that there was an evil one that controlled the world?

17 Upvotes

In John 5:19, John states that "We know that we are children of God, and that the whole world is under the control of the evil one"

I'm guessing the 'We know' comes from Jesus's teachings. John seems to be recounting what he learned from Jesus in that verse. In the Lord's prayer, Jesus asks for deliverance from 'the evil one'.

There are other gospel references to the evil one by Jesus. I am curious about what Biblical scholars have written about the evil one, as a concept.

Was Jesus's central message a solution to the problem of the evil one, that controlled the whole world?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Question The timeline of from polytheism to monotheism in the Levant

9 Upvotes

The evolution of the Israelite religions is a topic of heated discussion in academics, but I want to get some glimpses of the topic.

I know most scholars used to think Josiah was a monotheist, but his reforms were actually monolatristic and weren't that popular. After all, according to the Bible, the son of Josiah quickly reverted to polytheism and his heirs were polytheists, too. Deutero-Isaiah was then chosen as the start of monotheism, but it uses the classical West Asian rhetoric of incomparability, claiming no other god compares to YHWH in power. It is also a common motif in ancient Egyptian hymns and prayers. Then the Second Temple period was chosen, but one of the Dead Sea Scrolls, 4QDeutj which si dated to 50 CE, stating sons of Elyon inheriting the nations in which YHWH inherited Israel tells a lot of. Paul was then chosen, but he wrote about the foreign gods being real, and that Jesus will defeat them. Some scholars suggest late Second Temple Judaism is binitarian, and so was Paul.

I would be very happy, if you guys can give historical-critical sources about the evolution of the Israelite religions from polytheism to henotheism to monolatry to monotheism. E


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Does the original Hebrew of the Old Testament convey a flat earth view?

35 Upvotes

I’m looking into this argument a bit. If you read the Old Testament as it was originally written, does it say the earth is flat?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Is it possible that some sayings attributed to Jesus in the Synoptics originally came from Paul?

13 Upvotes

I came upon this question while reading A Marginal Jew: Rethinking the Historical Jesus (John Meier), Vol 1, Ch. 2: SOURCES: The Canonical Books of the New Testament)

It's an interesting thought especially if we keep in mind that the Pauline letters came before the gospels.

Some critics point to another possible Pauline source of information: the large sections of Paul’s parenesis (= moral exhortation) that find parallels in the teaching of Jesus. The data, however, allow of many explanations. Was Paul consciously using teaching that both he and his converts knew came from Jesus—Paul not bothering to advert to the well-known source of his exhortation? Or was Paul using material that de facto came from Jesus without Paul’s knowing its origin? Or did Jesus and Paul both use similar Jewish ethical and wisdom traditions in their exhortations? Or did Paul and other first-generation Christians develop parenesis that then passed into the Synoptic tradition and was attributed to Jesus? All of these options are possible, and all may be true to some degree. At times, close similarity in both form and content, as well as dissimilarity from the wider religious environment of the 1st century, may make dependence of Paul on Jesus likely. Such may be the case in the exhortation to love one’s enemies or persecutors, as it is preserved in Matt 5:38-48; Luke 6:27-36 on the one hand and in Rom 12:14, 17-20; 1 Thess 5:15; 1 Cor 4:12 (cf. 1 Pet 3:9) on the other. [25]

Footnote [25]

For this special case, see John Piper, “Love Your Enemies.” Jesus’ Love Command in the Synoptic Gospels and the Early Christian Paraenesis (SNTSMS 38; Cambridge: Cambridge University, 1979). Contrary to Piper, Jürgen Sauer (“Traditionsgeschichtliche Erwägungen zu den synoptischen und paulinischen Aussagen über Feindesliebe und Wiedervergeltungsverzicht,” ZNW 76 [1985] 1-28) does not think the command to love one’s enemies and waive retaliation comes from Jesus; rather, Paul represents the oldest Christian literary stage of the tradition, which entered Christianity from OT wisdom, Hellenistic popular philosophy, and Hellenistic Judaism. The bearers of the Q tradition attributed the teaching to Jesus to give it authority. Whatever one thinks of the thesis, Sauer’s article is a mine of bibliographical information.


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Did the Johannine community consider itself Jewish?

19 Upvotes

It is my understanding that most Johannine scholars who posit the existence of a Johannine community believe they were originally Jewish Jesus followers who were expelled by the mainstream Jewish community following the destruction of the Temple. In the Johannine corpus there is a consistent theme of marking off "the Jews" (or "the Judeans") as a distinctive group opposing Jesus. Did the Johannine community no longer consider itself Jewish, religiously, ethnically, or nationally? Would they have thought of themselves as Christians or as something different entirely? Did they view themselves as belonging to a post-Jewish religion? Are there any other examples of Jewish groups at this time disavowing their own Jewishness?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Question Did the Author of Jude Consider 1 Enoch Canonical?

20 Upvotes

George W. E. Nickelsburg argues that the author of the Epistle of Jude considered 1 Enoch canonical. However, many Christians disagree with this interpretation, arguing that quoting a work as an authority does not necessarily mean considering it canonical, just as biblical authors quoted Greek poets and writers without recognizing their works as canonical. Which position is closer to the academic consensus? What are the historical and literary arguments for and against this interpretation?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Question Christian biblical view of heaven/hell vs Judaism view of heaven and hell

5 Upvotes

IIRC Old Testament/tanakh speaking there is no traditional heaven/hell just a graveyard all the dead go to. When the son of man comes there will be a raising of the dead with a new earth perfect without ailments which also abolishes tehom/the deep

Does this change in the New Testament? Does Jesus being the first to go to heaven mean that his followers will also be with him in heaven awaiting the new earth and general resurrection?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

Question "Let us make man in our image" (Genesis 1:26): why "us" and "our"?

40 Upvotes

Apparently, the Jews were already monotheistic under Babylonian captivity, so why "us" and "our"?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

Are there any serious Greek scholars that argue the Textus Receptus over the Critical Text?

13 Upvotes

Is there even a thing such as a serious Greek scholar who argues for the Textus Receptus.

I'm curious to know what their arguments are?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

Question What is a midrash in the New Testament?

19 Upvotes

Occasionally, I hear people say that a passage from the New Testament is a midrash.

Like, how important is that? What I understand is that it's something like referencing an earlier text and interpreting it in your own way and giving it a new meaning. Is that right?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

Question Is there any trace of a "Logos" concept in the Synoptic Gospels or the Q source, or is it strictly a Johannine development?

25 Upvotes

Hello guys,

​In critical scholarship, the Gospel of John (c. 90–100 CE) is recognized as a late, highly theological text originating from a distinct community, featuring the explicit cosmic framework of the Logos (the Word).

​By contrast, the earlier Synoptic traditions (Mark, Matthew, Luke) and the Q source generally express Jesus' exalted status through other categories—such as prophetic voice, divine Wisdom (Sophia), or eschatological figures—without using the philosophical Logos terminology.

​My question is/are :

- ​Do scholars find any conceptual precursors to the Logos in the Synoptics or Q prior to John's formulation?

- ​How do these earlier layers frame Jesus' pre-existence or connection to Hebrew Bible prefigurations compared to the Johannine prologue?

​Thank you for any historical-critical insights or scholarly sources you can point me toward!