r/AcademicBiblical • u/ArrantPariah • Oct 22 '22
r/AcademicBiblical • u/No_Boss_7693 • Jun 09 '24
Question Is the story of Adam and Eve misogynistic?
I’ve read that the story of Adam and Eve was a misogynistic tale where women(Eve) was blamed for the existence of all evil similar to Pandora how true is this claim
r/AcademicBiblical • u/GuitarGuy7177 • Mar 06 '25
Question I don’t see why Tacitus has any value in proving a historical Jesus
I’m not saying he doesn’t, I’m just new to this.
It seems like in academia, Jesus is widely believed to have been real and existed.
A big part of this is the fact that we have a Roman source from a respect historian less than a 100 years after his death. I’ve seen many claim that this adds a lot of probability to his existence.
Here’s my problem -
He either got the info from Josephus or an independent source through his own investigations.
If he got it from Josephus, then Tacitus is just regurgitating info from a source that is likely at least a partial forgery. It’s not like Tacitus met Jesus himself. Even if we strip away the interpolations, it doesn’t help much. If a modern day historian said he heard from someone that they saw ghost , that doesn’t mean ghosts are real. It just means someone is claiming to have seen a ghost. Just because Tacitus lives around Christians and is hearing claims about a teacher who was executed by the Roman’s doesn’t make it more legitimate just because Tacitus is the one repeating it.
So Tacitus is worst case regurgitating a questionable source OR he has independent info but that still doesn’t mean that what he’s saying is true.
I do know that Tacitus was thorough and did preface rumors or anything he thought might be preposterous. He doesn’t give this preface to his Jesus record. But once again, that might be what he heard but that doesn’t make it true. I can give an account of what Mormons believe without actually believing it. As a historian describing those events, why would he give a preface to that by saying “it’s a rumor” or “this is preposterous.” He’s simply describing it as it is.
All that I’m saying could be said about Josephus too, which just makes Tacitus’s information even less likely to be valuable.
I hope this makes sense
r/AcademicBiblical • u/thelastdragonb • Aug 28 '26
Is there any scholary consensus if the Gospels that are canon were written by Romans in an attempt to coax a Jewish population into following a passive Messiah instead of a Messiah that would liberate them from Roman oppression?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/UnhappyComplaint4030 • Sep 27 '25
Question Is the idea that Jesus was a fictional creation arising from the Bar Kokbha revolts plausible?
So I recently decided to do a change my view thread titled "A historic Jesus existed" and put forth some reasons. You can have a read of the dumpster fire here. Most of the replies was moving goalposts back to the miracle Jesus or saying variations of 'Paul is lying".
One user brought up a theory I had never heard before, and it was that Jesus was a fictional creation as an "anti-war figure" from the a Bar Kokbha revolts. My immediate pushback was that this occurred nearly 100 years later, but I don't know much about the revolts.
My question is - is it plausible and do any scholars take this theory seriously?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/scifishortstory • Mar 29 '23
Has anyone here seen the Biblical Series by Jordan Peterson? What are your thoughts on it?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/Exotic-Storm1373 • Apr 12 '25
Question Does the Bible use gender-inclusive language?
There seems to be a fair amount of debate in Christian circles over English translations of the Bible using gender-inclusive language. But is gender-inclusive language present in the Bible? Is it accurate that some translations (e.g, the NRSVue, CEB, etc.) use this where necessary? Thanks.
r/AcademicBiblical • u/Manchesterist • Nov 14 '23
Question Did Jesus had aposthia?
In Galatians 4:4, Paul states that Jesus was "born of a woman, born under the law".
Correct me if I´m wrong, but doesn´t being "under the law" of Moses and become Jewish requires a male to be circumcised?
If Jesus was born "under the law", can´t we infer that is saying Jesus was born "circumcised" (with aposthia)?
If so, how much could this fact - if true - be valuable as a Messiah claimant?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/Human_shield12 • Apr 05 '26
Were early Christians aware that their god originated from the Canaanite pantheon ?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/lost-in-earth • Dec 18 '23
Question Let's settle this once and for all: Would shepherds in Palestine be out in winter during the time of Jesus?
Ignoring the fact that this story likely didn't happen, many people point to the presence of shepherds with their sheep in Luke 2 as proving that Luke didn't think Jesus was born in winter.
The argument is that the shepherds would not be out with their flock during the winter.
This is an often repeated "fact."
So is there any truth to this or not?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/ICanEatABee • Aug 04 '24
What explains the very many miracles of Jesus written about by the apostles?
Why did the apostles write about and believe in so many miracles he supposedly performed? I mean these were very dedicated people. They almost all willingly went to their deaths and in turn died very brutally. It's shown repeatedly that the apostles questioned whether or not Jesus Christ was actually the son of god or not. He calls them people of little faith on multiple occasions. But eventually they all accept that he really was who he said he was. Every single one of the 13 Including Judas supposedly believed in Jesus Christ as the son of god in the end, citing his many miracles as the proof of this being true.
So what gives? Logically speaking, if these people really believed in Christ as the son of god it wouldn't make sense for them to lie about miracles he supposedly performed. That would be equal to very great blasphemy if they contorted the story so much that it didn't even resemble what really happened in actuality and just gave him magic powers all of a sudden.
And Paul believed that after Jesus had died he would not only raise himself from the dead but very many others as well. Yet Paul himself admits that this never happened but kept his faith either way. So then it seems like if they were just making things up about Jesuses magical powers he would have included Jesus raising people from the dead after his crucifixion.
Were the stories corrupted somehow or is the appearance of Jesus's miracles still unexplained?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/jeron_gwendolen • Sep 19 '24
What was God's motivation for mixing up languages and keeping people from becoming too powerful/united?
People often interpret it as God's response to people's arrogance or threat to overthrow him. It's funny, because nothing in the chapter seems to support this view. All it says that one day people got together and, looking to make a name for themselves (to keep together), built a city and a tower to stand out. God said that lest they become too powerful and nothing is no longer possible for them , let us confuse their languages and scatter them across the earth. Why did God want people to "fill the earth" at expense of their unity? Does it have anything to do with making way for Israel as a nation to be set aside?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/DisillusionedDame • Oct 20 '24
Discussion English Bible Confusion, deliberate..?
Looking through different English Bible translations, this verse sticks out.
Knowing basic English, we know that little g, god, is a noun. Whereas the big G, God, a proper pronoun/name. According to the Bible, there is one god; God.
I find this a bit troublesome. There are many English translations is which language is changed in order to help people better understand the text.
2 Corinthians 4:4 seems to suggest that Jesus is an embodiment of the god of this world, the devil.
Indeed, I seem to keep finding little passages that mention Jesus with the same terms used to describe the “antichrist” in popular culture.
What’s going on here? Is there some deception as prophecy would suggest? Deeper and more cryptic meaning? is English just insufficient when it comes to describing certain ideas? Or should I just stick to the study notes and leave actual scripture to someone more qualified?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/HonkHonkMTHRFKR • Apr 28 '26
Christians practice symbolic cannibalism. Do we have any earlier Jewish sects that also practiced symbolic cannibalism?
I really am curious if symbolic cannibalism that Christians practice today where they pretend to drink the blood of Jesus and eat his flesh can be found in any earlier traditions or possibly religions where they might have borrowed it from.
Is this a new thing or is this something borrowed?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/kamilgregor • Nov 15 '23
Video/Podcast I'm currently binging this radical criticism podcast
r/AcademicBiblical • u/AceThaGreat123 • Apr 09 '25
What’s the academic consensus on if Mary remained a virgin after the birth of Christ ?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/[deleted] • Mar 16 '24
Question Is the strong hate of idols of the Old Testament can be considered proto-atheist psychology ?
When I see verse like Jeremaiah 2:11, or 1 Kings 18:27, it seems you can replace idols by "religion", and it seems, pretty modern.
r/AcademicBiblical • u/SnooSprouts4254 • Feb 07 '24
Is Richard Carrier becoming more respected as a Biblical scholar?
Hello! I've always had the impression that Richard Carrier was not highly respected as a Biblical scholar (despite his education), particularly due to his fringe views regarding the existence of Jesus. However, I've recently seen very positive references to him from scholars like Derek from MythVision and Robyn Faith Walsh. Are his ideas now closer to the mainstream?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/[deleted] • Jun 27 '25
Discussion Mary Magdalene a disciple?
I believe Mary of Bethany (Martha's sister) is Mary Magdalene. There are so many connections throughout history and art. We can see plainly the propaganda and lies surrounding the church, and our day is in age who's to say there wasn't grand agendas. We already know one keeping women out of responsibility is in the church. But is that what Jesus truly taught? They're the gnostic gospels that depict her in a different sense, there are some that say she was prostitute...in the gospels, it does clarify that she had seven demons cast from her. Mary of bethany saw Jesus do great things like raise her brother from the dead... then all of a sudden some random woman named Mary is the first at his grave? Who's to say after the anointing? Jesus didn't just change her name? Magdal does mean Tower in hebrew. Just as he did Peter?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/AdAshamed4591 • Oct 08 '24
Can anyone tell me if the book of Q is real and the actual sayings of Jesus or just a fake?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/Fuck_Off_Libshit • Oct 28 '24
Question Has any biblical scholar ever presented a serious argument that Jesus was homosexual?
Just curious. What are the best scholarly arguments for Jesus being gay? So far, I've heard non-scholars argue that Jesus was gay based on the "Secret Gospel of Mark."
r/AcademicBiblical • u/LAkshat124 • Nov 24 '20
Bias in the responses
It seems to me that a lot of the posts and responses on this subreddit are just apologetics. I know that the field of Biblical Studies is dominated by Christians but the responses on here are basically attempts to substantiate the most "Orthodox" understanding of Christianity rather than engaging in scholarship.
r/AcademicBiblical • u/UnexpectedLizard • May 05 '24
What are the arguments in favor of the existence of Jesus?
Richard Dawkins argues that Jesus likely wasn't a historical figure. He based his argument on:
Similarities with the cult of John Frum - a man who also likely never existed.
We have no writing of Jesus
We have no physical description of Jesus
The only writings from his contemporaries are decades later, contradictory with each other, and filled with descriptions of miracles.
And yet most scholars treat Jesus as a historical figure. What are their arguments?
r/AcademicBiblical • u/onlinesunshine • Sep 30 '24
Queer books, film, or TV that allude to the Book of Ruth?
I'm doing my MA in Religions and Cultures, and my research is on lesbian reappropriations of the Book of Ruth in 20th century (thus far) literature. So, I'm looking to add to my list of media to look at that alludes to Ruth in a queer context! My current literature list is as follows:
Oranges are Not the Only Fruit, Jeannette Winterson
Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistlestop Cafe, Fannie Flagg
Patience and Sarah, Isabel Miller
The Well of Loneliness, Radclyffe Hall
I'm not as interested in film and TV, but am open to any additions to this list also!
Wynonna Earp
Teenage Bounty Hunters
Saving Hope
Fried Green Tomatoes
r/AcademicBiblical • u/pardongbat • Mar 25 '23
Did the biblical Jesus come from Dionysus?
Recently I heard someone say that
"It is correct that Christianity’s Jesus was directly derived from Dionysus in terms of precedence. This conclusion was reached based on the latest research standards in the field of comparative religion since the 2010s.
Research on the “dying and resurrecting god” motif has been ongoing for over half a century. Reflecting the research that has continued since Joseph Campbell, naturally Campbell’s research has also been continuously revised and supplemented for over half a century to become a “modern theory,” and based on research from at least the 2010s, including revised editions, from the perspective of comparative religion in the context of comparative language and culture, rather than a perspective that presupposes the denial of neutrality such as theology or biblical criticism, the origin of Jesus in the Bible is Dionysus. Since at least the 2900s B.C., the universal golden rule of humanity has been communicated through a set of symbols, conveying a common theme with a common symbol, a context that persists both before and after Jesus."
Is this correct?