r/zensangha • • Mar 15 '25

Submitted Thread Zen Masters versus Downvote Brigading liars and cowards

0 Upvotes

Downvote brigading

When people downvote and can't explain why, or downvote targeting particular users or topics, it is always coming from a place of bigotry and ignorance.

Recently a religious troll tried to justify their conduct becasue their conscience was hurting them. The failures of their justification explain just why Zen is so dominent in the history of public debate, and why rZen is so feared and hated by meditaiton worshippers and newagers.

Zen is not faith-based: Zen Masters give citations

Huangbo, when arguing about Zen's supremacy over Buddhism, gave justifications based on texts. Here's a great example: https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/comments/1j4icr8/the_wanling_record_of_master_huang_po_part_267/

What we see here is Huangbo citing the text AS EVIDENCE.

Newage bigots can't do that.

Downvote Brigaders give claims and bias

Keep in mind this is from a redditor who doesn't contribute content, but instead spreads bigoted cult propaganda, blocks people who expose his logical trainwrekks and outright fraud, and says there "isn't much to say" about koans.

I downvoted your OP and according to Reddit rules I'm explaining why.

  • At no point will he cite any text as evidence

  • At no point will there be any logic to his claims.

First of all you're isolating Buddhists and speaking falsely about them -- Buddhists are equipped to think about koans. I've heard many dharma talks where koans were discussed in detail. Their understanding of these cases is accurate.

  • Buddhists do not think about koans. 1900's Buddhist writing proves this. Start with ANY REFERENCE TO THE MU KOAN.

    • or Pruning the Bodhi Tree

  • Buddhists lynched the 2nd Zen patriarch. Does that start the conversation off on the right foot?

  • There are no examples anywhere of Buddhists "understanding" koans, or even reading them. No evidence offered.

Second. You pit your 10 years of experience against 2500 years of Buddhist thought and contemplation on not only Zen, but the whole spectrum of Buddhist scholarship.

  • No evidence offered. No evidence is ever offered anywhere by newagers.

  • This lack of evidence is part of the fraud that newagers are a group with ideas. They aren't a group. They don't have ideas.

In truth, I needed to downvote you four times, but Reddit only allows one per user. Sorry.

  • Downvoting four times would be just as much a violation of the reddiquette as all the downvote brigading this user engages in. No recognition of the rules.

  • There is no "truth". There is no evidence. The newager cites NO TEXTS BY ANYONE ABOUT ANYTHING

  • Claims of truth are all newage ever offers. Anybody could prove me wrong, but nobody even tries.

Why newagers are upset but still have conciences?

The interesting thing here is that we know that bigotry and ignorance hurts. These people who downvote brigade are suffering. They do not like that they downvote brigade, but they aren't in control of themselves and their emotions are tormenting them. That's why this justification is unusual: they are dislike themselves so much they can't face their own lack of justification.

When they try? It's all about you can't quote those books.

Keep in mind that this redditor can't define "Buddhism' either. But rZen has, and nobody disagrees: www.reddit.com/r/zen/wiki/buddhism


r/zensangha • • Mar 05 '21

Submitted Thread Consent and fraud and Dogen and sex predatoring

0 Upvotes

From NYT Opinion column:

Imagine the following hypothetical situation: Frank and Ellen meet at a night course and end up getting drinks together after class several times. The drinks start to feel like dates, so Ellen asks Frank if he is married, making it clear that adultery is a deal-breaker for her. Frank is married, but he lies and says he is single. The two go to bed. Is Frank guilty of rape?

To most people, even those who consider Frank a dishonorable creep, the answer is clearly no. The law agrees: In most American jurisdictions, Frank is not liable for any tort or crime, let alone something as serious as sexual assault.

But why? This question has been a source of contention among legal experts for decades, ever since the law professor Susan Estrich argued that the law of rape should prohibit fraud to procure sex, just as the law of theft prohibits fraud to secure money. Ellen did not consent to have sex with a married man, the argument goes, so the sex she had with Frank was not consensual.

To many feminist legal scholars, the law’s failure to regard sexual fraud as a crime — when fraud elsewhere, such as fraud in business transactions, is taken to invalidate legal consent — shows that we are still beholden to an antiquated notion that rape is primarily a crime of force committed against a chaste, protesting victim, rather than primarily a violation of the right to control access to one’s body on one’s own terms.

It’s a powerful argument. Still, to many people, even those concerned about accountability for sexual misconduct, the notion that Frank has committed sexual assault remains deeply counterintuitive. How are we to reconcile these competing considerations?

I recently conducted a series of psychological studies that shed light on this debate. My research suggests that the reason people think Frank is not guilty of rape has less to do with their treating rape differently from other offenses and more to do with how they understand consent. Many people, it turns out, believe that an individual can give consent even though she was lied to by the person seeking her consent.

I asked hundreds of research participants to evaluate hypothetical situations in which a person is tricked into agreeing to something he would otherwise refuse. In one situation, a patient agrees to a medical procedure as a result of a doctor’s false representations. In another, a civilian allows police officers into his home because they lie about what they are searching for. In another, a research participant agrees to enroll in a study after the researcher lies about its purpose.

Surprisingly, I found that most people say that the victims in all these cases have “consented.” I also found that most people agree with the moral and legal implications of that view: For instance, they say that a doctor who performs a surgery after obtaining consent by lying deserves less punishment for medical battery than a doctor who simply performs the surgery without asking permission.

These findings fly in the face of the standard scholarly understanding of consent, which is that it is an expression of an individual’s autonomous will — controlling one’s life as one would like. Interestingly, my participants agreed with this standard legal understanding when presented with situations in which coercion or threats were used to achieve the same ends, such as when someone agreed to sex as a result of blackmail. It was only when the situations involved deception that respondents thought the victim’s “yes” counted as consent.

So it seems that the reason many people have a strong intuition that Frank didn’t rape Ellen is that they think it’s fair to say she consented, not because they think rape must involve physical force.

Of course, my empirical discovery does not resolve the question of whether our laws should criminalize sex-by-deception. It merely shows that if you have conflicted feelings about the case of Frank and Ellen, it may be because you think that his deception does not fully invalidate her consent. Whether lawmakers ought to disregard that intuition and insist on treating such cases as nonconsensual remains an open question. There might be good reasons, after all, for the law to discipline us against following our gut instincts.

So the two relevant questions are:

  1. What role does consent play in joining a religion or cult? Is it fraud if the cult misrepresents itself?

  2. When we talk about Dogen's sex predators, and whether they had consent especially given that they told people they were Zen Masters, are we talking about amir or violation of a religious vow or are we talking about rape?

.

When we bring these questions back to the teachings of Zen Masters, I'm reminded of Foyan's comments on the nature of Zen Masters being true friends.


r/zensangha • • Mar 04 '15

Submitted Thread Huangbo: No member of our sect

0 Upvotes

Blofeld's:

If you take [what Buddha taught] for truth, you are no member of our sect; and what bearing can it have on your original substance?


r/zensangha • • Aug 11 '24

Submitted Thread Meta Not nice: Racism, Misogyny, and Religious Bigotry

0 Upvotes

Subtley Bigoted

I was surfing r/Buddhism lately for examples of people identifying as Buddhist who didn't know what "Buddhism" was.

Then today I got into an argument about how "feeling uncomfortable" is a modern passive aggressive bullying technique most of the time. I came across this:

Years ago spent time in /r/(a particular variant of buddhism Im not going to name because Reddit drama isnt good for anyone). It was a great sub but there was an account that was really loud and abrasive. It got to the point where this one account was constantly at the centre of all sorts of arguments and many antagonisms had been generated by it within the community. It was abrasive, abrupt, rude, and unapologetically antagonistic. In most subs this type of presence would be removed by a mod team. It was really bad actually, in terms of the level of disruption it created and how pervasively it frustrated the sub's members and sewed discord.

On the one had, we have general agreement in the social contract that racism, misogyny, and religious bigotry are NOT OKAY.

On the other hand, we have a steady stream of political figures saying "That woman is not nice", which is shorthand for the social-contract-violating misogyny and racism that dare not speak it's name.

TOLERATING INTOLERANCE

This idea that "discord is bad" and "abrasive" is bad and "loud" is bad are all used to marginalize minorities.

Zen culture is huge on Intolerance for Tolerance, whereas Western Mystical Pseudo-Buddhism is all about intolerance for individuality.

It's closely linked to the political movement demands a return to traditional roles, traditional values, and traditional intolerances.

Communities that try to stifle dissent are also going to target minorities... it may not be your minority this time... but eventually it will be.

Zen is not Buddhism, not Christianity, and not Nice

The 1,000 year historical record is really really REALLY clear about this... but just saying it triggers "traditional" biases.

That's how banning books becomes burning books.

That's how 20th Century Buddhist academia went from anti-historical to religious apologetics... and that's why Critical Buddhists turned on them.


r/zensangha • • Oct 24 '22

Submitted Thread The Zen Basics: What the "self taught" get wrong (repost)

5 Upvotes

Zen Basics

Affirming:

  1. The Four Statements of Zen

  2. The 5 Lay Precepts

  3. Zen Masters wrote books of instruction

Denying

  1. Zen is not Buddhism, Buddhism is not really a thing, sutras written by rival factions

  2. Zen Masters don't like meditation, historians agree Dogen invented Zazen

  3. Zen has about 1000 years of historical records from China alone, Buddhism has nothing that old as a primary source.

Self Taught Fail

  1. Zen is not an altered state, so all the LSD and meditation people are on the wrong track.

  2. Alan Watts and other sex predators (like all the 70's Zazen "masters") aren't teachers, or even reliable researchers.

  3. You can't "get it" by reading a few koans... because the context of koans is Zen instruction.

.

Welcome! ewk comment: I was trying to think of how to concisely sum up all the confusions that people who think they are "self taught" have fallen into in this forum, on social media generally, and throughout Western "Buddhism".

Go ahead. Test me. What did I miss?

Edit:

6.7k views as of this edit... and for all the complaining, no quotes or citations to prove me wrong!

Time to self teach some book learnin'!

edit 2

We're starting to flatten out at 8k-ish views. I was hoping that someone would be able to point out a fact or an argument that I had overlooked... Instead it was a lot of really confused people telling me how I was wrong because they said so.

edit 3

https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/comments/y8jis2/the_zen_basics_what_the_self_taught_get_wrong/

at 8.9k views and 334 comments, this post was taken down four days after it was posted to r/zen for being "too off topic". I'm not sure why or how. This post summarizes the primary disputes Buddhists (even those who think they are Zen) have with the historical record discussed continually in the forum, specifically in terms of the Affirming and denying.


r/zensangha • • Mar 30 '15

Submitted Thread Any comments?

0 Upvotes

r/zensangha • • Mar 21 '15

Submitted Thread Huangbo redefines Buddhism

0 Upvotes

Blofeld:

Bodhidharma merely pointed to the original Mind and substance of us all as being in fact the Buddha. He offered no false means of self-perfecting oneself; he belonged to no school of gradual attainment.

His doctrine admits of no such attributes as light and dark. Since it 1is not light, lo there is no light; since it is not dark, lo there is no dark! Hence it follows that there is no Darkness, nor End of Darkness.

Whosoever enters the gateway of our sect must deal with everything solely by means of the intellect. This sort of perception is known as the Dharma; as the Dharma is perceived, we speak of Buddha; while perceiving that in fact there are no Dharma and no Buddha is called entering the Sangha,who are otherwise known as 'monks dwelling above all activity'; and the whole sequence may be called the Triratna or Three Jewels in one Substance.^1

^1:Huang Po is juggling with the most sacred of Buddhist terms, perhaps causing some of his hearers to stiffen with disapproval, but clearly in the hope of shocking them into a deeper understanding of truth. The terse humour with which he cloaks his underlying sincerity is lost in the translation.


r/zensangha • • Mar 24 '15

Submitted Thread Huangbo: Discuss it as you may

0 Upvotes

Blofeld:

Discuss it as you may, how can you even hope to approach the truth through words? Nor can it be perceived either subjectively or objectively. So full understanding can come to you only through an inexpressible mystery.

The approach to it is called the Gateway of the Stillness Beyond all Activity. If you wish to understand, know that a sudden comprehension comes when the mind has been purged of all the clutter of conceptual and discriminatory thought-activity.

note: Another Gate! How generous!


r/zensangha • • Oct 06 '24

Submitted Thread You can't study Zen if you want to be a moron

1 Upvotes

Earlier today in response to a post, a two week old account said in response to a comment by another user calling BS on his claims that

"An authoritarian cites an authority (a Zen Master, for example) as basis for his claim. A scientist cites an observation as basis for his claim."

This is an example of someone not knowing the meaning of the words they try to use and coming into this forum to open their mouth about something that is outside their intellectual wheelhouse in general with a sub-standard set of intellectual tools at their disposal.

They would fail any high school "five paragraph" essay that required the student to describe authoritarian societies in the 20th century.

This is not something unique to /r/Zen, but a phenomena that has been catapulted in the main stream over the past few decades in the United States. People who don't know jack in general giving what are euphemistically called "hot takes" on specific subject they have no expertise in like the state of the economy, American history, the prevalence of racial discrimination, nutrition, fitness, and youth culture.

When someone comes to /r/Zen, a subreddit centered around a marginalized and historically misrepresented culture that addressed high-level philosophical and religious concerns through public argument, debate, and, literary engagement across centuries and starts proffering their "hot takes" that are really just uneducated BS, we know they're part of the same streak of American morons platforming other morons.

It doesn't matter whether it's Fox News, the GOP, Twitter, or Zazen Dogenism platforming the bigotry--if it's anti-fact, anti-literacy, anti-rational conversation, it isn't Zen.


r/zensangha • • Sep 02 '24

Submitted Thread rZen subreddit dhrama: Zen Masters vs lying religious trolls

1 Upvotes

Why are we here?

The mod team has been signaling an increasingly passive approach to moderation with regard to some kinds of content:

  1. Bogus religious claims that aren't linked AT ALL to the quotes by Zen Masters... after they removed posts that had no quotes, quotes are now used as "cover".

  2. Posts that are seemingly on topic, followed by bigoted religious claims in the comments that the mods don't have time to review... or don't care to review.

  3. Outright disinformation and propaganda that is not supported by any facts or arguments from the same accounts, over and over, and these accounts denigrate Zen, rZen, any arguments they don't like but can't respond to... accounts that can't AMA w/o getting banned.

How do we know somebody is lying?

Because they admit to it in other forums

Because they can't ama about what they really think without getting banned for hate speech and bigotry.

Because they can't ride a high school book report about their claims... And it's obvious in most cases they haven't read the book.

Because they use the block function to avoid questions about books they claim they've read.

What: Koans are historical records

Buddhists and Christians and new agers (particularly unaffiliated western mystics) can't create records from public conversation and depend on myths and supernatural fables for their authority.

Zen Masters do not. Zen Masters use historical facts to create challenging conversation about what it means to be in the "Zen" group... and this completely excludes Christians, Buddhists, new agers, and Western mystics who look foolish when they try and fail to AMA.

Koans are a kind of bragging that Zen has history... koans are an open challenge to who claims to understand what... koans are an ongoing reminder that *if you can't AMA, you aren't connected to Zen IN ANYWAMA.

https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/wiki/famous_cases#wiki_dongshan.27s_capable_of_conversation

One time the [founder of Caodong and Soto Zen, Master Dongshan] said, "If you would experience that which transcends even the Buddha, you must first be capable of a bit of conversation."

Why it matters: Buddhists hate history, just like Christians

Buddhists and Christians depend on myths for the "truths" of their faith. Zen Masters just point out what real people said when asked real questions.

The Buddhist narrative in the West throughout the 1900's was that koans were "Zen fanfiction". This narrative disintegrated in various stages, including:

  1. Mazu "invented" koans... debunked by earlier koans, koan-like nature of Zen Master Buddha answering questions in sutras.

  2. Koans weren't meant to be understood as history... debunked when it Japanese Hakuin religious branch (claimed to be Rinzai) was found out to have been lying all along about everything, including (a) secret koan "answer manual" circulated since Hakuin (b) translations of koans proved Zen Masters explained meanings, did not create riddles

  3. Mu just meant no, and this was important in Zen because it was a "no to Buddhism".

Who is lying? Why no AMA?

This week the big liar about koans was /u/express-potential-11... who can't AMA publicly, uses reddit "block" to insulate himself from textual debate, who has a history of religious beliefs on the fringe and religious bigotry against Zen... repeatedly claims that Zen koans aren't historical records.

  1. He can't address the percentage that are historical vs mythical

  2. He can't address whether the recorders of these koans thought they were writing fiction or recording history

  3. He can't address whether the Masters who referred to these koans thought of them as history or myth

How do we know it's a troll lie and not a mistake?

express_potential can't publicly discuss his faith, his doctrinal beliefs, or even his history on social media. He won't answer questions about his education or religious affiliations.

He can't provide arguments for his claims.

express_potential hides his religious beliefs from people so he can lie about Zen without his hypocrisy dominating the conversation.

Zen Masters say koans are history

The most famous example in rZen of the debate about how Zen Masters treat koans is:

According to tradition, Master Chih died in the year 514, while Bodhidharma came to Liang in 520; since there is a seven year discrepancy, why is it said that the two met? This must be a mistake in the tradition. As to what is recorded in tradition, I will not discuss this matter now. All that's important is to understand the gist of the matter.

This is in THE FIRST CASE OF BCR. Yuanwu clearly knows there is a debate and clearly understands that koans ARE SEEN AS HISTORICAL, which is WHY DATES AND NAMES MATTER. He's arguing that in this Case, that's not what he wants to discuss. This isn't the only example, and the Zen use of specific people's names and places and times is all about record keeping, all about historical facts.

Regardless of accuracy, then, koans are seen as history, weighed as history, used as historical records. Where Christians and Buddhists want supernatural myth stories, Zen Masters want real life flesh and blood historical records to measure themselves (and all of us) against.


r/zensangha • • Oct 21 '22

Submitted Thread The neuroscience of dialogue

2 Upvotes

Many times, we miss an opportunity to talk to another person because we have fallen into a pit of prejudice; a conversation will never work if you don’t give it a chance,” explains Sigman, who recently published The Power of Words, a great treatise in defense of dialogue based on scientific evidence.

The Zen tradition is completely recording dialog. Dialogues were recorded and Zen Masters instruct by engaging with those dialogues.

Let’s say you and I go to see the same movie and we each have a different story about what we have seen, which can completely change our emotions. For you, it caused a lot of anguish, but for me it was a comedy. And then if we get together to talk about it, seeing your point of view nourishes me and gives me a perspective that I didn’t have before.

It's not just that people don't understand what they read sometimes and don't understand what they experience and don't understand what they think... It's that without someone to talk to they may not be able to doubt what they've taken as true.

We’ve understood that one can cultivate a good life, but it is not yet widely accepted that having a space for good conversation is an essential tool for health care, not just a good life. Loneliness is toxic.

We've all met confused and angry and scared people on social media and we know that they have one thing for sure in common: they can't engage in dialogue.

In my recent post that ran almost 400 comments almost everyone entirely failed engaged in dialogue. People were coming to thread and say you're sick/delusional/fake, but they couldn't have a dialogue about why they believed that and what else they believed let alone the possibility anyone might see anything else any other.

If we stop saying these people simply wrong, a sign from that suffering from a toxic loneliness that comes from an inability to have a dialogue... I think we're getting closer to what's going on.

There's a lot of shame involved too of course because they are ashamed of their beliefs and experiences... That just feeds the isolation and toxic loneliness.

Zen insisting on dialogue is just another example of there quiet genius.

https://english.elpais.com/science-tech/2022-10-20/neuroscientist-mariano-sigman-loneliness-is-toxic-having-someone-to-talk-to-is-tremendously-important-for-our-health.html


r/zensangha • • Aug 01 '24

Submitted Thread rZen needs to do more for new people

2 Upvotes

I'm trying to talk the mods into having a sticky post that will help people new to this forum understand:

  • the massive amount of textual study and the dedication to historical the authentic Zen that we have here,

  • why Western academic Buddhism is criticized both in the East and in this forum

  • why we say that no master ever taught the eight-fold path or Zazen or solving koans, which are nothing more than historical records

  • how there is no graduate program in Zen anywhere in the world and this influences what Buddhist academics can say about Zen in peer review

Here's an explanation I offered recently about modern Buddhist academia in the west:

Christian colleges and Buddhist colleges

If you get information from a church, or scholars from Buddhist religious schools, then you should be as skeptical of their work as you would be of Christian academics "proving" the resurrection. When ANYONE says "universally" or "everybody thinks", and there's no historical records in there? Basically, it's like you think Baptists are the only Christian narrative.

And yes, Zen is more historical than Buddhism. Buddhists just have a Bible that's a collection of myths and the myths go together less than the books of the Bible and that's problematic.

Zen Masters have actual historical records of real people. No comparison at all.

You don't have to believe zen Masters over church people but you do have to come into this forum with an attitude that history is about fact and not about myth.

Yes, Western Buddhist academia is fringe

And yes, it is weird that you can't find any papers by people with degrees in Zen. But there's Big important reasons for this.

  1. There is no graduate program anywhere in the world in Zen study. The Japanese don't have a Zen tradition and after world war II, they spread their own Buddhist vision to the world which was religious exoticism excited to hear it.

  2. Japanese Buddhists also created religious school graduate programs in their religion and almost all of the western Buddhist academics right now are students of those graduates or graduates of those programs. www.reddit.com/r/zen/wiki/fraudulent_texts

  3. People who get degrees in Buddhism or in Chinese are not qualified to translate zen texts. Just like people who have degrees in Christianity or Spanish couldn't translate philosophy, texts or medical texts I didn't know anything about.

  4. Mystical Buddhist academics in the west have come under fire from more serious philosophically trained 8FP Buddhists such as those from the secular Buddhist or critical Buddhist traditions. The criticisms of Western Buddhism entirely undermine the scholarship that you're likely to find by googling.

  • Dogen not a. Zen master or representative of the Zen tradition

  • zazen invented in Japan. No connection to Soto Zen.

  • Meditation not a central Buddhist practice, not mentioned in the eightfold path, not intrinsic to Buddhism.

Yeah I think it's big news. That's why I talk about it all the time.

This forum was the first anywhere:

  1. THE first where a translation of Rujing was ever attempted,

  2. The first place to start dialogues about the four statements of Zen being more Central to Zen than the 8-fold path, which no zen master ever taught

  3. the first place to have a translation of Mingben's Illusory Man,

  4. Sthe first place on the internet to bring the academic consensus about Bielefeldt's debunking of zazan into online discourse.

Zen scholarship is in its infancy

It's basically like 1800s paleontology.

That's how wild West it is. If you keep in mind that it hasn't been a hundred years since world war II, hasn't been 100 years since Japan was almost wiped from the face of the Earth, hasn't been 100 years since Chinese civilization was totally destroyed and all its scholars disappeared from history...

Yeah. None of this should be that surprising to you.


r/zensangha • • Feb 02 '15

Submitted Thread Huangbo: Mind is not really mind.

1 Upvotes

http://www.reddit.com/r/zensangha/wiki/bc1-5

Q: Just now you said that the beginningless past and the present are the same. What do you mean by that?

A: It is just because of your SEEKING that you makea difference between them.

If you were to stop seeking, how could there be anydifference between them?

Q: If they are not different, why did you employ separate terms for them?

A: If you hadn't mentioned ordinary and Enlightened, who would have bothered to say such things? Just as those categories have no real existence, so Mind is not really 'mind'. And, as both Mind and those categories are really illusions, wherever can you hope to find anything?

note: Mind is not really mind! Well, then, what is it?


r/zensangha • • Oct 07 '15

Submitted Thread Explain the Joke - ( a long pause)

0 Upvotes

I won't type the whole thing out, the three people who contribute here I know already have the book and so can look at the case.

Case 3: The invitation of the Patriarch to eastern India.

...The Liang Court took Bodhidharma to be Avalokitesvara, in-india they considered his teacher Prajnatara to be Mahasthamaprapta--only Amitabha Buddha hasn't come down here to earth so far.

(a long pause)

'Fenggan talks too much'

I feel like I missed something here, especially considering the long pause. Who is Fenggan and why is he introduced suddenly? Also, it's a quote, so who is actually talking? It made me laugh, but only because of the abrupt change of pace in the writing.

What's going on here?


r/zensangha • • Oct 04 '15

Submitted Thread BOS: Bodhidharm's "Emptiness" - Wansong commentary

0 Upvotes

be careful not to go too fast and wither under the sun. And when you get there, don't stay in the South--there they only like fabricated merit and don't see the inner reality of buddhahood, so even if you go there, you shouldn't stay too long.

And after all it turned out that he did travel to Lian(in the South), cross over into Wei (in the North), and remained unmoving for nine years.

Did anyone else see the North and the south references to be the gut (emotional) and his moving to north to be of mind? I don't know what Liang in chinese means, but moving to Wei would be moving to "become." So moving from emotional where they don’t' see the inner reality of buddhahood to the north where they do.

Or perhaps I saw a ghost?


r/zensangha • • Feb 10 '16

Submitted Thread I know what Zen is

0 Upvotes

r/zensangha • • Sep 28 '15

Open Thread [Sep 28 - Periodical Open Thread] Members and Non-Members' are Welcome to Post Anything Here! From philosophy and history to music and movies nothing is misplaced here, feel free to share your thoughts.

0 Upvotes

Hey there, welcome to /r/ZenSangha!

  • The patriarchs were as much wise as silly, anyone dare to disagree?

  • Feel free to post your content, suggestions and questions.

  • From philosophy to art nothing is misplaced here, feel free to share your thoughts and generate discussion on anything you desire to.

  • If you want to know more about this subreddit and what it is about have a look at our FAQ.

  • Hang around a bit, talk to us a bit and then ask us to let you in.

  • This thread is like when you invite someone to drink some tea, we put the tea you put the topic!


r/zensangha • • Oct 01 '15

Submitted Thread Wansong - B.O.S. is a russian doll.

0 Upvotes

Wansong.

I am surprised at the trouble I'm having getting through this material. Eyes glaze over continually. I'm surprised at the way it's written, especially considering Wansong came later (historically) than Foyan did and both books are translated by the same guy. Yet Foyan is (in my opinion) substantially more to the point and an enjoyable read.

Is it that Foyan is talking to an audience and was captured by someone, and that Wansong is writing about the cases himself?

What are your thoughts on the text? Would you rate it favourably amongst the books you've read? Is it a book you keep coming back to?

What about the book did you enjoy? What about it did you not enjoy?

How did you hack your way through the text? Brute force?

Am I being a whiny runt? (What? I said runt)

Did I post something about this before? i'm old and senile


r/zensangha • • Sep 25 '15

Open Thread [Sep 25 - Periodical Open Thread] Members and Non-Members' are Welcome to Post Anything Here! From philosophy and history to music and movies nothing is misplaced here, feel free to share your thoughts.

0 Upvotes

Hey there, welcome to /r/ZenSangha!

  • The patriarchs were as much wise as silly, anyone dare to disagree?

  • Feel free to post your content, suggestions and questions.

  • From philosophy to art nothing is misplaced here, feel free to share your thoughts and generate discussion on anything you desire to.

  • If you want to know more about this subreddit and what it is about have a look at our FAQ.

  • Hang around a bit, talk to us a bit and then ask us to let you in.

  • This thread is like when you invite someone to drink some tea, we put the tea you put the topic!


r/zensangha • • Sep 22 '15

Open Thread [Sep 22 - Periodical Open Thread] Members and Non-Members' are Welcome to Post Anything Here! From philosophy and history to music and movies nothing is misplaced here, feel free to share your thoughts.

0 Upvotes

Hey there, welcome to /r/ZenSangha!

  • The patriarchs were as much wise as silly, anyone dare to disagree?

  • Feel free to post your content, suggestions and questions.

  • From philosophy to art nothing is misplaced here, feel free to share your thoughts and generate discussion on anything you desire to.

  • If you want to know more about this subreddit and what it is about have a look at our FAQ.

  • Hang around a bit, talk to us a bit and then ask us to let you in.

  • This thread is like when you invite someone to drink some tea, we put the tea you put the topic!


r/zensangha • • Dec 27 '14

Underlined Huangbo: How?

0 Upvotes

Blofeld's Huang Po:

You do not see that the fundamental doctrine of the Dharma is that there are no dharmas, yet that this doctrine of no-dharma is itself a dharma; and now that the No-dharma doctrine has been transmitted, how can the doctrine of the dharma be a dharma?

Note: Well?


r/zensangha • • Dec 08 '14

Underlined Huangbo: No loathing

2 Upvotes

From Blofeld's:

The Buddha said of the sands [of the Ganges]: 'If all the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas with Indra and all the gods walk across them, the sands do not rejoice; and, if oxen, sheep, reptiles and insects tread upon them, the sands are not angered. For jewels and perfumes they have no longing, and for the stinking filth of manure and urine they have no loathing."

note: Huangbo is talking about seeking for something objective outside "your own minds." He says such seekers have turned their backs on the Way.

It isn't that Huangbo isn't vicious and nasty to Buddhists. When he is, how can anybody say that he loathes them?


r/zensangha • • May 18 '15

Submitted Thread Academia in a clown circus? Dates don't match.

2 Upvotes

Let's dive in. Maybe somebody can explain to me what doesn't make sense.

  1. Here's Ferguson's lineage chart, rife with errors. It puts Puji as an heir of the Northern School's Shenxiu (hereafter Shen Hsiu).

  2. The Will to Orthodoxy: A Critical Genealogy of Northern Chan Buddhism, By Bernard Faure, repeats Ferguson's dates for Puji, and then says this:

But Faru had just died (811), and Puji then decided to go to his "successor," Shenxiu , who was living near the Yuquansi. The disciple was 29 and the master 83.

3. So, Puji was 29 in 811? and Shenxiu was 83? Which would mean that this Shenxiu was born in 727, not the same year as Northern School Shen Hsiu who was born in 706 according to Ferguson.

4. But how could Northern School Shen Hsiu be born in 706? He studied alongside Huineng (638-713) and vied for the robe of robe of Hongren (5th Patriarch) who died in 675?

5. Thus I conclude that there is a second Shenxiu, from Shenhui's line and that Puji is unrelated to the Northern School. Huuineng->Shenhui->Faru->Shenxiu->Puji->Dingzhou.

6. Which changes this conversation's context, rendering in traditional rather than political: https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/comments/36bkp9/blue_cliff_record_find_the_punchline/


r/zensangha • • Oct 17 '22

Submitted Thread Mental health risks from violating the Lay Precepts?

2 Upvotes

There is mounting evidence that two commonly violated precepts are linked to mental health problems.

  1. Slaughterhouse work and mental illness

The role of a slaughterhouse worker (SHW) involves the authorized killing of living beings, yet there is limited understanding of the consequences this behavior has on their well-being. The purpose of this systematic review is to collate and evaluate the current literature on the psychological impact of slaughterhouse employment. Fourteen studies met the specific a priori inclusion criteria. The findings from this review were demarcated by the focus of studies: (1) the prevalence of mental health disorders, (2) the types of coping mechanisms used, and (3) the link between slaughterhouse employment and crime perpetration. It was found that SHWs have a higher prevalence rate of mental health issues, in particular depression and anxiety, in addition to violence-supportive attitudes... Finally, there is some evidence that slaughterhouse work is associated with increased crime levels. The research reviewed has shown a link between slaughterhouse work and antisocial behavior generally and sexual offending specifically. There was no support for such an association with violent crimes, however. Based on existing research, we suggest future directions for research (i.e., applying more methodological rigor) but highlight key findings for practitioners and policymakers that warrant attention.

2. Alcohol in any quantity harms normal brain function

According to a recent rodent study, even tiny amounts of alcohol may cause epigenomic and transcriptomic changes in brain circuitry in a region that is essential for the development of addiction. The pathways that are involved in setting the brain up for addiction, according to researchers at the University of Illinois at Chicago, are also linked to the highs that come with drinking, such as euphoria and anxiolysis, a state of relaxed but awake sedation.

In general these kinds of studies point to the need for further research. What does "privileged meat consumption" really cost society, when the real absolute costs of meat packing are calculated? What other changes, besides epigenomic changes promotion addiction and reduction in brain function, is alchohol causing?


r/zensangha • • Jun 06 '16

Submitted Thread Imzy experiment

2 Upvotes

I have five invitations if anyone wants one. I think it's intended to be basically a version of reddit requiring less moderation. Who knows. I put the usual posts about Zen and meditaiton and Buddhism up. It's in beta now, so I'm guessing it will be even quieter there than it is here.