r/zensangha • • Oct 13 '18

Submitted Thread ewk podcast on Case 48 of Wumen's Gateless Barrier

19 Upvotes

https://anchor.fm/ewkatreddit/episodes/Gateless-Barrier-of-Zen-Case-48-e2d39c

Let me know if the notes I based the podcast on would be useful. I could put them here or wherever.

I wasn't drinking tea during much of the recording and I had to re-record it five times, so buyer beware.

While the podcast might not be coherent, the portrait of Case 48 turned out pretty good, really. Research really does pay off.


r/zensangha • • Aug 21 '21

Submitted Thread Death of Thomas Cleary

14 Upvotes

The great translator, Thomas Cleary, died earlier this year.

Thomas Cleary (1949—2021) was one of the twentieth century’s greatest translators of Asian classics. He was extremely prolific, translating and authoring countless works. Shambhala Publications has published over sixty. His books have sold millions of copies and his translations have in turn been translated into over twenty languages worldwide. His first published project, in collaboration with his brother J.C. Cleary, was the classic Blue Cliff Record, that great collection of koans.

Buddhism was a large part of his translations, with over thirty works spanning the traditions of Chan, Zen, and Soen while also including Tiantai, Indian Tantra, Theravada, and Hua-yen, and Bushido. Arguably his magnum opus is the 1,600+ page Flower Ornament Scripture, a masterpiece of translation from one of the most influential works of Mahayana literature...

Robert Thurman said of him,

“There is no doubt in my mind that Thomas Cleary is the greatest translator of Buddhist texts from Chinese or Japanese into English of our generation, and that he will be so known by grateful Buddhist practitioners and scholars in future centuries. Single-handedly he has gone a long way toward building the beginnings of a Buddhist canon in English.”

Shambhala is editing another book of Thomas’s that will be published in 2022: Dahui’s Treasury of the Eye of True Teaching.


r/zensangha • • Mar 23 '20

Submitted Thread Why I Should Not Call Out a Narcissist

13 Upvotes

TLDW: They will never change. The only effective defense is to withdraw the supply of attention.

Really digging her videos these days. - Dr. Ramani

Be well, folks, inside and out.


r/zensangha • • Nov 16 '14

Welcome to /r/ZenSangha - FAQ Inside

13 Upvotes

TL;DR;

/r/ZenSangha is a space for constructive discussion and exchange. It's an invitation-only community where its members address topics related to self-examination by using some literary works as pointers. Those desiring to join are encouraged to first spend some time in the threads labeled [ Periodical Open Thread ]. After we get to know you a bit through your participation, you'll get an invitation.

 

Please note that comments done in threads not labeled as open to non-members will be automatically deleted. You might see them when looking at your comment history but for everyone else they're removed.

 

On the use of /r/ZenSangha

We at /r/ZenSangha think that it would be an interesting endeavour to try and build a cohesive community whose interests revolve around self-examination and sincere discussion. Loosely speaking, to proceed by asking rather than affirming. All while making a friend or two in the process.

 

On what /r/ZenSangha could be

  • A space for open and sincere discussion.

  • A space devoted to self-examination.

  • A space where the records of the patriarchs guide but not limit the discourse.

 

On the Members

  • /r/ZenSangha is and will likely stay a restricted sub. We have learned much from /r/Zen and thus its members are welcome to read or crosspost whatever gets written.

  • Members wanting to participate in /r/ZenSangha are encouraged to first contribute in the threads labeled [Periodical Open Thread] After some of the members at /r/ZenSangha get to know you a bit an agree to let you in, you'll surely get an invite. Please note that comments done in threads not labeled as open to non-members will be automatically deleted. You might see them when visiting with your account but for everyone else they're effectively removed.

  • Members have a voice and they are responsible for using it for the keeping /r/ZenSangha an open, honest and constructive space. It is expected from members to cast their votes no matter what with full attention and sense of purpose.

  • /r/ZenSangha is what its members want it to be. Hence, suggestions and feedback from the community regarding this space are always welcome. There will be periodical threads labeled [/r/ZenSangha Affairs Thread]. The purpose of this thread is for members to suggest and discuss potential changes which could countribute to the betterment of /r/ZenSangha. Members are encouraged to think carefully before posting in the [/r/ZenSangha Affairs Thread ], since everything posted there will be considered carefully and discussed by the mods.

 

On the Content

  • Regarding content and due to the community being invitation-only, the content and scope of the discussions that take place are up to its members.

  • As stated above, this subreddit aims at providing a space for discussion and exchange of ideas regarding self-examination and whatever is deemed to be related to Zen by the members. We keep the principles upon which this space has been created in mind, so that discussion and inquiry don't always devolve into /r/Funny.

  • Moreover, there will always be a place for funny images, jokes, videos and whatnot. The place for those is the [Periodical Open Thread]

  • From birds and rivers to clouds and mountains, what can be called Zen? Why insist in defining what it is? Discussion of both traditional and contemporary works is encouraged, always keeping in mind that if you want to learn to bake you'd go to the master baker if you could.

 

On Moderation Policies

  • The duty of the mods is solely to protect the sub from damage, what can be considered damage is of course a complex topic. We trust the common sense of our members and hence mods are likely to have not much to do. However, posting content such as pornography or personal information are examples of situations where mods will without hesitation interveene.

  • Mods aren't mediators between parties. Members of /r/ZenSangha ought to be mature and capable enough in order to tolerate dissent and constructive inquiry. We would like to mention it once again, this sub is about constructive inquiry, not preaching. You agree with something? good. Disagree with something? good. Neither? good. Mu? good.

  • Members are as much encouraged to share their views as others are encouraged to sincerely question them. As with any discussion, a self-righteous or pedantic attitude is detrimental. Because of this members are expected to be both open and critical. Open to stating their views, open to changing them and open to challenging those of other members.

 

On Our Wiki

  • We believe Wiki pages to be an incredible tool for preserving information. * Because of this, we encourage the members at /r/ZenSangha to contribute to our Wiki, it can be found here.

  • It is meant to keep record of particularly interesting discussions which take place in the community or any kind of content which our members or readers could find useful.

  • Feel free to add past or future conversations, sources, art or whatever strikes you as particularly insightful.

  • The Wiki ought to be an organized materialization of /r/ZenSangha according to the principles upon which the members have agreed to run the sub on.

  • If you feel like you need help with formating, organization, structure and so on, please ask the community or the mods, we'll be glad to help.

 

The following three points have been throughly discussed but we would like to rather encourage dialogue instead of simply policing it away. The provisional idea is simply dialogue, dialogue, dialogue. Want to join? meet us in the open threads. A member wants to help the community by being a mod? Let's get a submission going and discuss how you want to contribute to this space. Some members believe someone's behavior is detrimental to the community? Discuss. The community hasn't grown to the point of requiring clear policies regarding percentage of moderators versus members, or how voting is to be used or even if it should to used. Thus, dialogue, dialogue, dialogue.

 

On How Non-Members Are Made Members

Dialogue.

 

On How Members Are Made Mods

Dialogue. In order to keep the discussion going in an orderly manner, we encourage the community to nominate moderators in the periodical [/r/ZenSangha Affairs Thread]. There's no particular reason for this besides keeping discussion related to the operation of /r/ZenSangha in a central place where the mods and the community can go and discuss.

 

On How Members Are Demoted to Non-Members

Dialogue. This is also a topic which we believe would be best discussed in the periodical [/r/ZenSangha Affairs Thread]. We don't expect the need of discussions regarding demoting members to be that common but the possibility is left open.

 

On How And Why This Sub Started Operating

  • The creation of /r/ZenSangha can be traced to a conversation between two members at /r/Zen which took place as result of an event. The event discussed was a temporary ban a particular user got. Said member was temporarly banned because of persistently asking another person to explain views stated in a post.

  • Said user protested, his protest can be found here.

  • Said departure statement sparked a controversy, more information can be found here and here.

  • An exchange took place where ideas and perspectives were shared, more here and here.

  • /u/ewk and /u/ShowMeTheMoons kept discussing about what an alternate space for talking about Zen would look like.

  • /r/ZenSangha is the result. It doesn't exist in order to replace, criticize or judge moderators or members at /r/Zen.

  • This is a space created for the community by the community.

  • It's like a basketball game in the neighborhood, one game many posible rules. Some of us would rather play by some other rules


r/zensangha • • Mar 18 '21

Submitted Thread The Mind Seal

10 Upvotes

The term "mind-seal"(心印) is derived from the Chinese tradition of an emperor or high authority using a red-inked stamp, or seal, to authenticate important documents.

That's the standard interpretation of what the term 'seal' was derived from.

Here's a different one:

印(yin) has served as a translation of the Sanskrit term 'mudrā', which [refers to] (https://tricycle.org/magazine/mudra/) a series of ritual hand gestures that serve to communicate the particular religious orientation of the sect in iconography as well as a ritual that aims to 'seal' the teachings within the practitioner.

So:

Zen Master Buddha's mudra is mind, and 'sealed' by mind.


Neat.


r/zensangha • • May 08 '20

Submitted Thread People who have "lost their religion" show residues of their religious past in their thoughts and behaviours, study claims

10 Upvotes

https://digest.bps.org.uk/2020/05/07/people-who-have-lost-their-religion-show-residues-of-religious-past-in-their-thoughts-and-behaviours-study-claims/

Link to the actual study to skip the blah blah article

 

grrl: What's at play here? Ego? Neediness? What would a zen master say? I'm gonna splash around in Joshu for a bit to see if anything sparkles to me.


r/zensangha • • Apr 29 '20

Submitted Thread D.T. Suzuki Translation of Case 1 BCR

10 Upvotes

[Can be viewed here.] (https://imgur.com/a/rJFXKl6)

Unlike some bozos, Suzuki actually translates the entire case.

Some excerpts of note to contrast with Cleary's in the '>>' section:

Bodhidharma lost no time in baptizing the Emperor in foul water. When you can go through ablution of this kind safely, you are said to have had an intimate interview with [Bodhi]Dharma.

He immediately doused the Emperor with dirty water. If you can penetrate this statement, "There is no merit," you can meet Bodhidharma personally

How can one abstain growing briars and brambles?

How could he avoid the growth of a thicket of brambles?*

The refreshing breeze is sweeping all around

What limit is there to the pure wind circling the earth?


r/zensangha • • Nov 26 '19

Submitted Thread Zen

10 Upvotes

Yangshan said "If you want to exchange something we can make a deal. If you don't want to exchange anything we can't."

Some years ago I wandered into r-zen and tried to use a mish mash of perennialist tree huggery and pass it off as Zen. I'm not sure entirely what motivated me to do that. I think, maybe, trying to assure myself and others that I had my spiritual ducks in a row was self-soothing. But the ol' book report standard checked my integrity. Are you really gonna say you know something about Zen when you can't name 5 Zen Masters? So a little later, I picked up my first little Zen text, Hsin Hsin Ming. Sengcan wasn't talking about any of the stuff I was talking about.

Little later, I got hooked by some phrases I'd heard. "What do they teach where you come from is the claw and fang of the Zen sect" -- I got introduced to the dialogues of Guishan and Yangshan. Later, I skimmed Mazu, and Joshu, and then Mumon reaaaaally made me realize no, I do not know what in the hell this is about, and I felt like I could never sneak one past Zen Masters after that. Which is weird, because one, I realized I am trying to prove something, and two, there's some thought that exists in me which wants to show affinity with some old Chinese sect. What's with that?

Stopped skimming Mazu and picked up Sun Face Buddha. Somehow, without being able to explain it, my thoughts became less serious to me. So did my story. So did everyone else's story. In fact, everyone living stories, it feels so dead. I acknowledge the irony in my blabbering here. Without really understanding why, likewise, I've stopped being as hard on myself about being a human being. I spent a lot of time in life monitoring my speech and walking on eggshells and judging other folks' sins. I used to put myself in all kinds of mental pain when I'd convince myself I'd missed the mark... there was even a period of time when it was hard for my wife to deal with me, because I wanted her to change.

I got a new laptop -- the old one was on the fritz. I got Huangbo and Green's Joshu in physical, and plan to get back into studying a bit. I credit Zen for the changes in my life which have helped to reveal ordinary life to me. I don't look to learn something in words that will improve me... that isn't it... but without understanding, and literally without a way to explain it, somehow becoming more acquainted with Zen has helped to take my head out of the clouds. I'm not well educated, but I can say I got a bit more honest... I can name a few masters and I'm in on the joke of having collected up a bunch of papers fit for wiping off my pus boils with...

I hope it is okay to say these words here. Thanks for bearing with me over the last few years, during the pleas for "look at me I am special" and "I am a mod I'm gonna fix everything" and "what this place needs is some good ol' fashioned compassion" and whatever else. Thanks for kicking the legs out from under the soap box and making me face up to the fact that I didn't know wtf I was talking about.

I am wishy washy and a bit selfish with my time. Sorry for venting whatever this is.


r/zensangha • • Jan 05 '19

Submitted Thread Intellectual humility - How to admit when you're wrong

10 Upvotes

As technology makes it easier to lie and spread false information incredibly quickly, we need intellectually humble, curious people.

Study


r/zensangha • • Oct 31 '22

Submitted Thread r/Zen isn't fooling anybody

9 Upvotes

First, an article from the NYT:

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/25/opinion/american-historical-association-controversy.html

I'll quote the beginning, but r/zensangha gets to be more reading intensive by virtue of it's... ahem... patronage:

Last week, the historian James Sweet found himself in the middle of one of the confusing messes that pop up from time to time in the highest reaches of academia. As the president of the American Historical Association, Sweet writes a monthly address to his colleagues. His September entry, published on Aug. 17, was titled, “Is History History? Identity Politics and Teleologies of the Present.” What followed was a seemingly harmless missive about “presentism,” a phenomenon wherein historians allow the political, identity-based demands of the current day to dictate the focus of their scholarship and inquiry. Paraphrasing one of his predecessors, Sweet asked if students who enter the field with a fixed, identity-first point of view might be better suited to sociology, political science or ethnic studies.

Later in his address, Sweet writes, “If history is only those stories from the past that confirm current political positions, all manner of political hacks can claim historical expertise,” and claims that “too many Americans have become accustomed to the idea of history as an evidentiary grab bag to articulate their political positions.” As an example, he writes about taking a tour of the Elmina Castle in Ghana, a stop in the Atlantic slave trade. Sweet claims that his tour guide at Elmina both overstated the relevance of the site to African Americans (according to Sweet, “less than one percent of the Africans passing through Elmina arrived in North America”) while falsely downplaying the role that Ghanaians played in the slave trade. These elisions, Sweet believes, come from a desire to make history conform to our modern political understandings of race and inequality.

Sweet’s address was met with considerable criticism, and in some cases backlash, from fellow historians, many of whom felt that he was demeaning the work of minority scholars by broadly questioning whether work driven by “identity politics” belonged in the historical tradition. Sweet quickly apologized.

I agree with Sweet on the fundamentals of what he said, but I also understand why minority scholars felt like the integrity of their work was being questioned. An uncharitable reader might accuse him of singling out scholars who write about identity (read: mostly nonwhite scholars) and making unfounded insinuations about the motivations behind their work. This would be more forgivable if Sweet were not the president of the American Historical Association, a position that presumably gives him some influence over where the discipline is headed. There have been times in my own career when someone high up in an institution assumes that because I am not white, my work must be driven by identity politics. It’s an enraging experience.

The question this raises for us as students of Zen is to what degree "identifying with Chinese Masters" is an "identity" that colors our perspectives.

Certainly when I argued that Dogen was a fraud it seemed to be "identity driven". Then when internationally famous Buddhist scholars admitted the same thing, even before I said it, it didn't seem to be identity driven.

Therein lies the problem, and it can be reversed with an easy perversity:

Dogenism has been trying to reshape history along the lines of identity since Dogen wrote FukanZazenGi, wherein he lied repeatedly about his new religion and tried to cast it as having the identity of Chinese Zen.

Similarly, from Ikkyu to the /r/zen/wiki/sexpredators, Dogenists have been trying to identity history to justify their faith by denying the harm and psychological imbalance associated with violation of the lay precepts by religious leaders.

And what does this mean for Zen scholarship? Is it possible that people who weren't enlightened participated in dharma transmissions? Have historical facts been "identity'd" into a more pleasing picture for Zen students?

The answer is absolutely yes. Zen Masters themselves have asked this question repeatedly, most notably about Bodhidharma's supposed dialogue with the Emperor.

And that's what it means to be a grown up, right there... you are willing to be suspicious of your own perspective.

That's what we never get from religious people, that suspicion.

That's why it's Trust in Mind, not trust in lineage.


r/zensangha • • May 14 '20

Submitted Thread [Article] "Caught Up in the Cult Wars: Confessions of a New Religious Movement Researcher" Susan J. Palmer (2001)

9 Upvotes

Happened upon this in my online travels, and since the wrrd "cult" has been tossed about in other arenas, it seemed topical to share.

 

Each new religion I encounter evokes in me a sense of awe not unlike what my art historian mother feels when she beholds Greek ruins, German cathedrals, or Renaissance paintings. I see heretical religions as “totems” or testaments—not necessarily of Ultimate Truth, but rather of the creative power of the collective human imagination. Their prophets I approach cautiously, and with respect, as artists of the most radically experimental sort: unpredictable conceptual artists at best, semi-opaque con artists at worst.

[...]

When asked to define a cult, I explain that it is a baby religion. Personally, I find cults (and babies) attractive. Babies can be heartbreakingly adorable or intensely annoying, depending on the beholder’s perspective—but also on the baby’s mood and stage of development. So infant religions are not quite toilet-trained, like MOVE, a cult that annoyed neighbours by throwing garbage on the street; toddler NRMs, like the Rajneesh, run around naked in the park and knock over tea trays; and teenage missionary movements, like The Family, mooch off their parent society, refuse to get a job, and flaunt their pimply sexuality.

 

Source: Longreads


r/zensangha • • Dec 17 '19

Submitted Thread Zen Genealogy : A call to arms!

9 Upvotes

I'm wondering if anyone wants to help me on a project putting together a 'family tree' of the zen lineage.

The goal, while fairly straightforward, will require a lot of effort and time to get done but to be brief it is to construct a more robust “family tree” of the zen lineage that is reliably sourced, can be built upon in the future, and contains citations to where they make an appearance in the texts.

Google Docs will be used for gathering the info from the texts, and I'll be compiling it all in a genealogical software program.

Anyways, if interested PM me or comment on this webzone.


r/zensangha • • Mar 28 '18

Submitted Thread Just a suggestion, mixing it up a little...

9 Upvotes

What would we think of getting spouses/significant others to AMA about "living with Zen students"? We could come up with questions, post them on our own accounts to avoid trolling splash damage, and keep it all in here where the trolling wouldn't be the focus.

I've been thinking about what it means to practice Zen "IRL" and conversations we don't get to have in r/Zen...


r/zensangha • • Oct 14 '20

Submitted Thread Another Zen Master, Another Sea Crossed

8 Upvotes

Zhuxian Fanxian (1292-1348)

Bio: From China, dharma heir of Gulin Qingmao, Linji branch; spent last twenty years in Japan causing trouble. No known Dharma heirs, no written texts besides untranslated calligraphy scrolls.

Excerpts from Japanese 'compilations' text Zoku Zokyu, translated by J.C. Cleary.

At a small gathering at the end of the summer retreat Zhuxian said:

Tomorrow morning concludes our retreat. At tonight's small gathering what shall we talk about? The Buddhist scriptures? Bodhi and nirvana? True Thusness and liberation? Everything that the generations of the world's great leaders have already spoken of in every possibly way?

These are all scraps of food left over from countless sacrifices, a cud that's been spit up countless times. Only starving dogs would taste it. Humans would hold their noses--how could they eat it?

We say that these are 'not the words of the time,' that they are irrelevant, that they are various kinds of poison.

If you have full certainty, then you can slay buddhas and patriarchs as you meet them twenty-four hours a day, and when you meet yourself, you slay yourself. Only after that is everything up to you.

Dahui said, 'Everywhere else they talk snail Zen, convoluted and twisted. Here at my place it's oyster Zen--as soon as he opens his mouth, you see his guts.'

I am not this way. I have no snail Zen, and no oyster Zen either. Within a hundred and twenty days of drinking the water, you will know the source for yourself.


A few things that immediately stand out about what this guy blabs on and on about:

  1. Central elements of Buddhist faith and praxis, namely, sutras-as-wisdom-transmitters, bodhi & nirvana and thusness & liberation as guideposts--all dismissed irrelevant to seeing your true nature; poison for for the unenlightened.

  2. Buddhas & Patriarchs do not occupy a sacred position. The ability to slay Buddhas & Patriarchs is the mark of the Zen lineage and a family tradition.

  3. Inter-generational quoting of Zen Masters comes up--literacy in the gossip isn't branded as a sin; overturning what another Zen Master said is a lion roaring.


r/zensangha • • Apr 14 '18

Submitted Thread The Economist takes on "Buddhism"

8 Upvotes

At its liberal edge, the boundaries of the religion, as practised in America, can be very fuzzy. For example, most Buddhists would agree that their faith’s core axioms include five moral precepts: don’t harm living things, don’t take what is not given, don’t engage in sexual misconduct, lie or consume intoxicants. But not all the Americans who call themselves Buddhist really know about these precepts, let alone practise them.

Then there is the fact that American culture, including corporate culture, has cherry-picked aspects of Buddhist life, such as the practice of mindfulness. Big corporations may employ full-time coaches on meditation which draw on Buddhist techniques. But that does not make the users of these practices into followers of Buddhism.

In Mr Mitchell’s view, issues of politics and social justice are becoming a focal point for the large and disconnected Buddhist scene, prompting followers to cohere and connect more often. “There is definitely a sense of, what I should do as a Buddhist about this or that issue,” he says. There have been Buddhist initiatives in favour of the environment and against racism. Last year, a dozen or so prominent American Buddhist leaders signed a statement protesting over the effect on the vulnerable of the current administration’s policies; scores of others added their names. The authors explained that although Buddhism can take many different forms, “our commitment is to ease the suffering of all living things…” Whatever the merits of learning to meditate in a Seattle studio, that is not where the religion will stop.

If we can't agree on what "easing suffering" entails though?


r/zensangha • • Oct 20 '17

Submitted Thread The pre-Zen history of Buddhism in China

8 Upvotes

When Buddhism entered China, it came as something foreign that provided relief from the Chinese cultural crisis that prevailed during the decline and collapse of the Han dyanasty. To some degree this new Buddhist world was made accessible by being interpreted as a form of Taoism practiced in India. In this interpreation, Buddhism was seen as augmenting the Taoist pantheon and proving new spiritual technology (rituals, texts, meditations, and various paraphernalia) along with specially trained technicians (priests). Buddha and Lao-tzu were worshipped together and were seen as forms of each other, and strange Sanskrit words and Indian ideas were translated by Taoist terms which were considered to match the Buddhist meanings. This activity has been labeled ko-i (matching the meanings), although it seems that this specific phrase originally referred to a more limited practice.

The fact that Buddhism was foreign, on the other hand, was also one of its attractions: its ideas and practices were different enough from those of Chinese society to represent a distinct alternative. By internalizing the new religion through meditaiton, on e could find a new refuge within oneself; and by joining the sangha, one could separate oneself from the woes and sufferings attendant with family obligations and participation in Chinese society. Under the leadership of new literati monks from the fourht centruy on, Buddhism formed a monastic community separate from Chinese society. This refuge attracted a growing following by providing "another world to live in" as an escape from the external crisis in Chinese society.

  • Buddhist Hermeneutics, David W. Chappell, Hermeneutical Phases in Chinese Buddhism.


r/zensangha • • Sep 13 '20

Submitted Thread From the introduction of case 86 - Book of Serenity

7 Upvotes

Even with a head of bronze, a forehead of iron, the eyes of a god, the pupils of a dragon, the beak of an eagle, the jowls of a fish, the heart of a bear, and the guts of leopard, under the diamond sword planning isn't admitted -- you can't manage a single strategem. Why is it so?

UExis: Go meditate.


r/zensangha • • Mar 01 '20

[Mar 01 - Periodical /r/ZenSangha Affairs Thread] - Discussion Regarding the Operation of /r/ZenSangha

7 Upvotes

Hi Folks!

  • /r/ZenSangha belongs to all of us. Post your thoughtful suggestions regarding the sub and how you think it can be improved.

  • Every single suggestion will be considered seriously by the mods so please be reasonable and suggest always with a sense of purpose. The majority of the mods have lots of interesting books to read and meditation pillows to use.

  • Suggestions will be implemented once agreement among the mods is reached. In order to learn how the mods reached agreement please have a look at the FAQ here.

  • New mods can be nominated here and members wanting to contribute by becoming moderators are also encouraged to express their interest in doing so in this thread.

  • This thread is to be the only thread heavy on "politics" at /r/ZenSangha and as mentioned above every suggestion will be considered carefully by the community, please use it diligently.


r/zensangha • • Mar 31 '19

[Mar 31 - Periodical /r/ZenSangha Affairs Thread] - Discussion Regarding the Operation of /r/ZenSangha

7 Upvotes

Hi Folks!

  • /r/ZenSangha belongs to all of us. Post your thoughtful suggestions regarding the sub and how you think it can be improved.

  • Every single suggestion will be considered seriously by the mods so please be reasonable and suggest always with a sense of purpose. The majority of the mods have lots of interesting books to read and meditation pillows to use.

  • Suggestions will be implemented once agreement among the mods is reached. In order to learn how the mods reached agreement please have a look at the FAQ here.

  • New mods can be nominated here and members wanting to contribute by becoming moderators are also encouraged to express their interest in doing so in this thread.

  • This thread is to be the only thread heavy on "politics" at /r/ZenSangha and as mentioned above every suggestion will be considered carefully by the community, please use it diligently.


r/zensangha • • May 11 '16

Submitted Thread Zhaozhou 12

7 Upvotes

The master [ZhaoZhou/Joshu] addressed the assembly saying, “This fact is clear and obvious. Even a person of limitless power cannot go beyond it. When I went to Kuei-shan’s (Isan’s)’ place a monk asked him, ‘What is the mind that the Patriarch brought from the west?’ Kuei-shan said, ‘Bring me my chair.’ If he would be a master of our sect, he must begin to teach men by means of the fact of his own nature.”

A monk then asked, “What is the mind that the Patriarch brought from the west?”

The master said, “Oak tree in the front garden.”

The monk said, “Don’t instruct by means of objectivity.”

The master said, “I don’t instruct by means of objectivity.”

The monk again asked, “What is the mind that the Patriarch brought from the west?”

The master said, “Oak tree in the front garden.”

This came up over at /r/Zen. What do we make of it? Why don't people study Zen in the Zen forum?


r/zensangha • • Feb 08 '15

Submitted Thread "Zen" and Zen, some of my thoughts lately.

7 Upvotes

So recently, I've taken a break from reading any Zen or studying any Zen or being concerned with Zen at all, especially /r/zen. I feel that the community there is a bit toxic and adversarial and oftentimes cheaply circle-jerky. The purpose of /r/zenjerk was to collect some of the most low quality posts and to provide a space where we could laugh at ourselves. I have high hopes for this place being what will amount to a more friendly and less toxic version of /r/zen, while not being against critical thought. I feel much better about contributing here than I would there mostly because of a few problem users who are frankly just meanies.

Anyway, on my Zen break, it became apparent to me that after studying this material for a long while that it can become really easy for things to run together, since so much of the Zen material is similar and also contradictory. Consuming lots of it can make it all grey out, which was happening to me. Plus I changed jobs and bought a house, so it was a good time to take a break.

A lot of Zen material has this aspect where you have a master seemingly trying to "trick" students, or more clearly, to get a student to expose his belief; where he or she is stuck. This exchange is a good one:

Monk; What about it when I am not taken in by anything?
Joshu: Things are, of course, as they should be?
Monk: Such is my true nature isn't it?
Joshu: Taken in, already taken in.

Taken in by what? "True Nature".

I would say that "Zen" or trying to "be Zen" or trying to figure out the "right view" or trying to nail down exactly what viewpoint "is Zen", is not only an exercise in frustration, but is a huge barrier.

When you just rest freely with the unattached mind, there is a clarity and a freedom. The birds are always talking about it. They just returned to Alabama in fact. You are always reality, your true nature, but being in a state of perpetually trying to nail down the sky isn't exactly conducive to experiencing that freedom purely. This is exatly how the monk was taken in, not by his true nature, but by concern for his "True Nature" and "How to See It" to the point of blinding himself from experiencing it consciously. It's always there, but we are not always expressly conscious of it. It has seemed to me recently that /r/zen has been bogged down my too much "Zen" at the expense of Zen.

So lately, I haven't been concerned with studying Zen as much as I have been just studying reality and myself being alive. It's been wonderful. Now with this refreshment, I can return to the material with a new eye, and I'll be posting my stuff up here. I'm light as a feather!


r/zensangha • • Apr 22 '26

Submitted Thread New Theory on Zen's Decline in China

6 Upvotes

What I thought up until a few years ago.

Zen had pretty much disappeared in China around 1450 as a result of the devastation on the commune system brought on by Mongol invasion, confiscations, killings, subsequent religious control by empowered Tibetan Buddhists and then millennial rebellion by the ascendant Ming dynasty.

Cleary's "Zen Under the Gun" is the last work of note from the lineage in China.

What I thought from a few years ago up until about a day ago.

There was a Zen lineage in China that lasted until about 1700. Exemplified by Yinyuan Longqi, aka, the guy who moved to Japan mid-way through his career and hosted the hitherto unseen practice of formal public interviews. The records are there. They don't look like the recorded sayings genre of texts but they're full of Zen references and Zen instruction.

The Zen lineage faded away in China sometime around the Ming-Qing transition (~1685 end date).

Current Theory

It was the Taiping Rebellion (1850's) that inaugurated a century of societal collapse, devastation, and erasure of traditional culture in China on a massive scale.

That's where the conversation in China ends. Not necessarily because there weren't any Masters, but the Zen record keeping traditions were already on life support and didn't survive the stresses of the period.

What is Needed

A list of alleged Masters between 1700 and 1850 that have their records digitized and which can be validated.


r/zensangha • • Feb 11 '26

Submitted Thread Case 51 BoS: Is it Zen Talking or Mundane Talking?

6 Upvotes

What's at Stake? What's the Tension?

Zen is a tradition of public interview where students and masters alike test each other's understanding. As generation upon generation of Zen Masters expounded the Zen dharma, they used different turns of phrase and probing the questions which while on the surface looked the same as non-Zen turns of phrase e.g., "Where do you come from?", they weren't designed the elicit small-talk.

Nevertheless, Zen Masters remark upon this aspect of their tradition and celebrate it when a Master's response works on both the mundane/literal level and the Zen-testing enlightenment-manifesting levels.

21st Century, Who Cares? How Relevant?

We don't have a tradition of public Zen testing anywhere in offline spaces. We don't have a way of spotting at a glance in the West (and, frankly, much of the East) who observes the lay precepts, much less is a professional student of someone in the lineage of Zen Master Bodhidharma.

This seemingly resolves the tension in the case by virtue of the fact that the safe bet for anyone asking you a question in the wild is that they're looking for an answer that fits in with one mundane-oriented subculture or another...

...but in reality it doesn't.

Zen Masters demonstrate a willingness to context-shift a conversation from one space to another immediately, without warning, and on their own initiative.

There's a certain kind of skill involved...but more importantly there's enlightenment.


r/zensangha • • Dec 09 '25

Submitted Thread Zhaozhou's Instruction on Sengcan: Quote it Correctly

6 Upvotes

Trying something less intensive for my current project. Retranslating the Third Patriarch's Trust in Mind instructional poem with the goal of annotating the text with times Zen Masters reference sections of it elsewhere.

This is important because the fact that Zen Masters quote each other all the time, often without attribution, was largely ignored by 20th century translators. By putting that instruction in situ with Sengcan's text, the diversity of instruction that Zen Masters delivered can be properly showcased.

The text is also an incredibly personal one for myself. It's one of the first texts I've read and one I regularly have returned to and notice different parts of.

It also has a lot of translations of varying quality which many people over the years have compared the merits of.

信心銘 | Inscription on Trusting in Mind

至道無難 唯嫌揀擇  

The Ultimate Principle is not difficult, just be heedful of pickiness.

但莫憎愛    洞然明白

Merely avoid aversion and attachment, and all is perfectly clear.

BCR Case 59 | ChatGPT

舉。僧問趙州。至道無難。唯嫌揀擇纔有語言是揀擇和尚如何為人

州云。何不引盡這語

僧云。某甲只念到這裏

州云。只這至道無難唯嫌揀擇。

A monk asked Zhaozhou: “ ‘The Supreme Way is not difficult; it only detests choosing and rejecting. As soon as there are words, it is choosing and rejecting.’” The monk asked: “How, then, does the venerable guide people?”

Zhaozhou said: “Why not carry these words through to the end?”

The monk said: “I have only recited up to this point.”

Zhaozhou said: “Just this — ‘The Supreme Way is not difficult; it only detests choosing and rejecting.’”

Cleary's translation has Zhaozhou's question as "Why not quote it in full?" while I haven't gotten that either of the times I fed this section of the text through ChatGPT.

The confusion of the monk is still a common one throughout the Zen records. Namely, the fact that Zen enlightenment is not found in words, yet Zen Masters choose words to express their enlightenment throughout the record.

Zhaozhou seems to be challenging the monk to test the limit of Sengcan's teaching; while the monk's reply reveals that he still is engaging with the text on an academic rather than personal level.

How relevant is Sengcan's instruction to people?

Are people who get emotionally invested in worldviews and opinions really clouding their vision of reality?

Why does this seem so challenging for most people to internalize? What's the trade-off?


r/zensangha • • Oct 30 '25

Submitted Thread Is Woodchopping and Water Carrying Layperson specific work?

6 Upvotes

On the most recent podcast episode, ewk made the argument that Layman Pang's famous verse only makes sense if his "chopping wood and carrying water" is layperson specific work done in service of the professional monk Zen community.

My counter-argument is threefold.

  1. I haven't seen any evidence of any primary or secondary text remarking that it is layperson specific work.

  2. Various references to professional monks doing or talking about woodcutting. Yunmen #274, Dongshan #59, Measuring Tap #2. The last one is a big deal since Linquan uses previous generations of Zen Masters woodchopping and hauling water to make a point the idleness of his generation in Zen communes.

  3. The argument Layman Pang is making is standard Zen argument. He does this in couplets throughout his poem. It gets more obvious if we add question marks or colons. Other translations probably do it a little more elegantly.

Here's Pang's verse

One day Shitou asked, ‘How is it going with the daily-life practice since last seeing the old monk?’ ‘Although questioned about daily-life practice there is no way to open the mouth,’ replied the Layman, but submitted a gatha:

Daily-life practice is not separate

It is just my being in natural harmony
[What is] Neither grasping nor rejecting[?]

Nowhere open or closed

Who assigns ranks of vermillion and purple?

One speck of dust sunders great mountains.

[What is] Spiritual penetration and wonderful functioning?

Fetching water and carrying wood.

Shitou approved it, saying, ‘A son in white silk or in black silk?’*